ORAL ASSESSMENTS AT ENGLISH EDUCATION DEPARTMENT OF UNIVERSITAS MUHAMMADIYAH YOGYAKARTA

(1)

E4Iutdhhn[yhdldl:0|rd

Yogyakarta

ABSTRACT

IEED uMYlro

m4!E

nldst'!p6k

ns ob{r rh6

c*q.6

oE5 ro

dtrrt

bdh

o/!o

qe5 oid drcdvo os4 rolai nrheorctcs

,s

rhe ddo {qe .orhded

G

q

ideprh

eryAab5nEEDUMyrud. svhohorthGd

hs4oiddroJlodoosollheoorcs

ltu(lorchrD-rhdllEDorPo spqeEdlhdrheo

.l Ed Gedbo<|, mprcwd rude 5

0@4aJ ruJe

r'f

r (oiriJeie, qn

".ldro"b

m!r{..

r-eolo@ro,.rhep,'!po soErcreo!drEr

i(esell.qlounss

dE

oo*,

J$dE

006

INTRODUCIIOI{

Ai.Nssnncnr pla,:

N i'nporNnnc

nr

du.rin,r.

Nirb,

Bro.thm

(loll.

|

4r8)ddn.

D

_Nscnnrrntas

th.tl.rcs

_{ri,r oL,unring}_nn

rntrrn

_rlur

is

s.l

n,

mih

d..hidrs

ur

srrtlors, ntrrirul t rnJ

rrt,lrxN

inl

.nn.r

tir,nl

n.kf'.li

t|c I

r.!cs

.I

rc.r.h nt!

turlltrnrn,:n

R.sn.rr fr,\ (

nr6',nx.!n

{Lio r nuJctrt

rrlrnrfhor

rs it

r

ns.,l,N x

r!rh.!tr,

rrtn,,tu rL.

noJuts

onrrhcnron

xhlluml(btundrg.

Tlr.trlli

rhr

issn,crr,

jtrJo

r

,Ld\"fi

n'

tlt

LNlyl.dse rn.l sli lls

rlrll

ltN! lun,.Ll.

tr

rln! tr.11,

tdJr.(

.an

dalL'

. r1r. rudcn6'

rr.srr$

iri l.inrnrs, obs.nt

rl[

$trtldrj

r.rd.nn.

$uigrl)s

r

ltikncs.s.

! N

tritct

r.Lnrqrnutils.,l

",t1."J",-"1,,

of

Universitas

Muhammadiyah

(2)

m..trd

Bynsnre NsNmrn6,

t.r.h!$

nn

rl$

.heck ii teachnrs .blednrs

hrt

Lccn mci

Tlcrcinrc, nr

xsNm.ni

_|r.viJ.s

lmlly

n

Itrtunraiior rhrr.an b.

trs.!lisibaili

nr

ofrlrt urors

rlt.s

oaxssm.nr,

oril

isscsmcnt k t.qu.n.lyus.J

h

Frslisli

lr,!ulg.

rlsscs Acro{lnr! to

Btr

y,

n*,nlll,

D.(

n

\

otur

ds,)r

,, o/r.,

i,i<r

qd

r

L0/<

Id

n,r[

L'.l)ilnr ro _rruJr<

&!ili

1&r _lfintr$

lr

{?r,dhsn(Lft

'l(urrn?nr o/d 1oiln

ii,krr

wlL

6 6[in!

cnl

(a(n'l!

qr4nor

.l,

n

.il,!.1!r,,ioms fu

LpL!,tu'{ii(

4

ntrtri

Jii'Lsu

,l/rnii(

q

,nths dlbd

eie li!in$,

-

ill{in!

rlDd

ri,u

rrn6

_{[60)

Tn

\,.

l

Ns.$

'.ntas!tool

bftank

sricrd

sFrknr!

rbility.r

bt

d.m

in virnn r

ixms.In

dii.r,

.cl

isNm.ni rnrouig.:

$udcrF

r. hc..nli.l.nr

ril r(

ur.rirL nrctrr$\

{nlr|.n

tua.h.rs.

HrxNr,

()

_{$r1,!11, xnJ}

Vr{qxal

_{1011)

nrt

thron,l

N\*n.!r

nn.ridrs

i!

i

nrcN

n)

J.\rl!in

{

Jcrtr' onl

6nmuni.it,.r

sk,Lh

Thdcl

.

$un.rN Lr.,r

l.nLlii

rionr oral

rsNnrch

o

dun,mnr{.anJ

imF^r

th.tr

kn.\'l

gcDd

uJr$a'Lddr

oI thor ..NnnunctioD sllLls.

Endrh Edn.xri.n

lrc|rnn.nt

ol

UnnrrirN

li(rhmDuJ,|,lr

nlg)1,ksra (EDD UI,IY) 1\r

!)

airE,$irl.i,l

rs.lsmdrs

mth!

fRcss oa

i({hiir!

trnd llinnrr: Th.

o

l is$str,.Ds

s'Jr

ri

Jk'lLcs\ fr.s.nr^t

\

rnl

{dli Jis(!

ti!r\

rn.licn xt thn

dcfrtnror.rn

trlins

nmr

cliLr.

of

ih s

_{llcfr Nra.nnrn.c A|)lri roni}

i'i

ro.lrnl

rltuG,{ni

rs rl.\.1!,r.nrq oDnntr,i-.rnon rlnL, .i,,1

acsnr.ri

xllr

_rr.srns

i.m.

nrn

.ms nr irs

nrd.mrnttnm

B(rnsrnu-d.nts,rc dn)s! trl$ rre,lirc.nl

iil..t.d

lir

tlr

nnpl.nen

nnr

oio

assesm.nt, it is im|op

hnt

t.

s.. ihcir _rcNrc.nnor drcaL(anbgcs anl

Lli$J!N{$.i.

1

)s.s.\.nr

nr

nrxr

r

ne..lsrry

inraourdt!

b

ur'lLe t]ror

(i

fulonn Ncll

n

rhe

Nsesmdr.rb.

tild

ThL

$

yxi'n: nr

NNilrc tk

$udcrs'Nnns

oi

lie\

o.

oriL6s.rm.nr

uriL\lout

i'r EEI)UMY iir t.nns oi

6

al!an?$s uLl Jisxd\antagcs.

ORAL AS5ES5IIEI{T

()r,'l _i.n:rn,on,

il!,1n"*r

_i"

oi'1.'nnn.i.

tn,r or tun, is

oro.In,r

cxdns

rl

tar!h'llt

(nnh.d

rnh

nrJcrN' sf.xhnr! s[nL. t hh,

r

r!1c6tu tl,r

i$.sn\rtol$u\l.,ir

l.min!

Jor

inrlalol:Nlenworll!U.ughir,

:010)

Snni-Lr\:

hli(:0ll)

sgcis thai

..il

assesmcft is

rslJ to dftnnnrc

{uicns'

rrLal

rcsrns. sLcn

rss$si!r!

{n\[r$' r,'d.lI

ol

lr.

1(!]!r,rLill\,

anJ

,hliri$

arfnsqu.ndi

*ullcnG

'n

$l.c

?blt ror.nrb,n! d]er lnoNltJr. ann _F.JL.rnm oI m,dsi tln

r

dris

(ill

mrLt

u

snJons'

b.it.r

Jd'!hn, (1001) c.rtnrNir.\

tlur.riL

rs.:n

ment Lrr meilul

b nrcrm

nuJcr.'Lnorn

.dsc

Iinrlr!no..,l.ughiD

(1001) Ns.' F

nrf

,hu. itu

6u i.g.rs.llufln!

6

h

iR:!.Ll

ii) !n,l

r\i\inqr,l.,

Irolvl.l$

niJ

nrJr.

iinnix!, rdn!m

nnvi,,s .irJ

,'Frii.tnrs,

nn.rpfr:.nrl

n

np$.rt,

rnJ

N6.nrlr

triliur.5 ln

the.ft.q!i,!

oikno!ltLlge

uJ

u.let'

.i.n

nrg,.r,n

rs..smut ;ll,N:

icr.h$

n,

rhc.t

.hur

if.lc's'

nrJU

$nJi|s

.I

n$r, ..n.cFh.

t,r

ridG .r n.l

fi'(hhr

tr

nJ.nlln! ilir

_1,r.,is

.i,,nitf'rrir!

llth! k$.n$

1lthc.iftloq

or

rol'lnn

!,1'i,,s

r\l

iftJlirdD\,

o 1isrsNrt

(3)

.tl

d

n, kn.*ldse, l.ut rlso

,,bsri.

rnclr $ud.nF to

apf\nr

LDov leJle

b

al

sire.

'ih. ncxr.rtqoi

ftulxiscl 1\ldLshin (1001)

is

iLn.rler.nrl

..mfftnic.

I n

rhis.m!.rx

pcntii! or

d

NferaLle s*ilL, nr.ludi.g

..nnnui-.xri.n ind ifuervi$ shls in nrc.onr!!i oI

F)r(sior,lsituxti.ns

xE

itrble aor

mea{trc-$er$ dNugl

.riL rs.s\mcnt. Th. L$citeqor!

\persln

ariLrmwlicl

r.oltun

!l

mcdro

Lc

urd

to mcxsuft _te6onrlqurLiri$ su.h

r

ilctnes:, rcx.tun n,

*ft$,

a{|$611i41 stltl xwmncss xnJ srtnonidcn... Bft.J on rh.

.

.s.riG ot onl rssLncnr, ii .rn b.

(n.l"J!i

.lw

Jtrri'rs t]). rim. oanrc Nsc$'nent, sudents NL* 1[

rn[

n, Ll.nmN rtu

illoitl].lour

u(.!orics .r lcrmnrg. Th.rc 6tu,

taJrcr

w,ll l)e

,nL-

maLy4

tl.

i(nrrln

ind s.rhrcscr oI calh

r

Llcnt to nnrnN th. qtrnhl

.l

flLldnr

ADVANTAGE5 AND DIsADVAIITAGES OF ORAL A55E55MEI{T5

As:

*xl r. nr.Aurc

ud.n6 rl,,litir., ort,l

rsxsu.fr

hx r(ant.,s.s

r

dFid!

nrlcs Brig$, Woor lriJJ, M.trtrr

rnl

Slr*t.n

(1001r)

$rr

ih{

onLrscsnrn

ur

nr.icknuJcntr

nnni\aril

n,lu

trs,\ehi.h

I

ntrn,1qtl

nr.iusc

r,

enr()n,li!tun.( Thl: \i(a( Ls ilso

surNtr..l

lf

w,Llhmi rn,l Willirn,i

(l0ll)

*l!

i,s::c$ nixr

nntri\ari

ii dr.

mosinrp.(,ni

fr.iortlrt

rrells ru,i'n

b

nnttrxt [rnnng.

In

dN.ii,

wltn

onlNt.n","L

i\.irt,.d

our

n,

msuc$uJcnc',

,hli$

ii i:

holi.l

iLtc

ntr\lIh

!(

nn)Liutu.lr'

flJ|ndr

rlLl,sudt tu

|rq.m

n,rir

r{*rrnb

Tlid!ti),r,

n

rin

br

i,i,l

nri.r,t.Nf.!nc

tr.,

r,

irnn1i rn.ldtr

The ncxt

rJv

tilr

L:

rha

l cqurllq Dl

ildcnt

l.idn!

dD

6t,m!ft\.d.l({,s|i't

(1010)

exnhft

6tsu,l.r$

bft}.&^LNd

rhq rm to

&nl

r l,lxnL,n rront

oltlk lxrm$s

or tdor

F(r5

.\

r Es,lt,

rud.nswill6e

Fre

|Ircd pnor

o

the

ii5c$n,$t

Th$NiU

ru.n.c

rr,n,iliryb

sl,cik noR antl

m.r.lns(1..r

.!tsld!.r.hur

rLss's

in.drr

to arhicn rhc rcq

irc rliliq

n)sNiL ntll. Sntrlcnc

vill

ur.dtirlc

or Ns.r\nr n t ,x.t. rirls rDd horv

drcl _{trill r.rroi,n}i'r nr. iscsnr.nt. As r .cnrlr su,len$' kno"[.]sr

r\J

sIi11s,.sl.c.nlh,n

..nnnlrnnr.r (,nnntr)i.ri(r

\kill, vnL _scr nnt)nnd.lr

is

lLne wirh

Hrrl,,n

(

(l0ll)

drronLr\e$mcnt.ande'.1(,f

"i,lr.nnrui

rain t sliills olnuJdts. l'i

lnJ

i,,

(;cn.,

J(,ln$tn, mJ &Nsu (lree)nnJ

n)

.ril

lrtN

r.

is ore oaforarn,LNxls ro Ns.ss unJ*nrnJ-msrtu] eNonng.

uiiicn'[nJii'rs.

An.dierrr)rr.i

D nnnG fi.m Punvrntu

(l0lr) -hirh rll,u:

!""..r1l).

r(anti!.\

or oril

NiNnNt

Ftr{, ontLNr$n,cni is.trn,od

ou i)y

i

Llnrd nnm.non drit allols t.rrLrcN to

N$rrrJ$ri

kn.NL.ds. ind

urJr$

tnirr:.

Srnf

,

ir$trJ.tr:J.r.ihari.Lr!nl.r

sr

nrs ornic

qtr.{nir, drdci,.hd.an.hr)!c

dr

qrcsnf ,

i)

rlr,,

rrJcn,s.rn

uidNaml

n

Thtrd,

r.r.hr.

.aD a.k

nrll.rr:

r,)..llNrc

JdNiG

iL.urnlcir

usror $

rh. rurl).rsLl!

kno\' ! Li.l,

rM .l

nr

mlt

niL

d,r

il,r suJ.trrs

uml{$

u

n. n, { unJd, r,nd kLl. l_(r,

(h,

rlt

sr..smot

ir,,1'rr.|\ii.tu

nr.'nR

nu-Jrnr.' und.FnnJrn!,

nll1

i,,{rlr!

rlnl,., n,

tu

rnn

n,d.or:ron

slr LLr

.n

r

fmirnrr

rLbr..r.

l:rnh,,':\csrn.rrdrLLLtrs..fun,

(4)

mBnr,

uch(s

.N

a!'

*n'$

rhe

otriir[: nit

rh.

trrlcnbhNt$hdr tr'nrs rM

ri:'smcnr

Fn llv. rft.r

orfld'rg

rlk

rsclnnc

'

nudrts

kr"* dtn...rG,

rnl

snnrltrn"usll

rcrJu'

.in

rlll

|hr

rrcr dr'

rnd'n6

n"J

tu

nntrNt'

'l _lkR_r.rc,_.ral

A:$:mdt r!lt"'\

I JctiilcJ

rn'l

('

,oR cnnr.

i

\r

r q r'{L

'

LtrJ

rr

!'tr;'

,.tr.tr.,

r

l.^B,drtre.''

"r'ch''

LU

il

]'n

rn.lProLl.msdu rgrht asi'slnrnr

In &lJition ro irs iJvrtascs V'slc'(1004)

iircs

irnt ric

.nl

NG$lnr

tu'f

uNe som'

ru.lots t,

rccl trn.l.r Frcsur' Lr!'xus'

fi

!

rr'

ni,n.d

l.

tltink qui.hlv Tho) rhonld

l"

rlrlcn)

oeNi?!

tlrtr

idc$ nr

i

sl$ii

t'no'l

oI time 1 h'

icoirng

rrv

e(

torsc

*\or

drc'c sruJon$

lut

I

1,,*

Ld.l.l..niidot

in

t['ir

sFxkings!'ll'

l'.rson,n tuits,

$r.!

is

r"iil

Nitrv

ro'l sh'tnes maysignin.inr\ c.nrib0tc n) rh!

{tGs

ol

{fdd{s

n1

o

l trsrsrn'nt

lroN'

rh'r'

vho hNr r|cs. l..Nmilnics

*rrlJ

rrdrcr do drc

isNrn.ri

nr

.lifler(t

wrls,

'

e

nr

*rifus'

Iir

i.llino!

tu

is,

Vrs!'r

(loo+) rlso sh'*s nnt

'.h..

Joins.in

N-$o

,

i'nc icl'lrrr

tcnn

o

.l

$

dr.Lnon:

too

'ru'[\

l)cfd'

$dcnE

nLlU

r!\ss

th.

qn6iiof\

tin

exi'\'['

s'nrr

&a.h{.

!n{

a!n.

$trdrf

x

l'n'u

_errdcl'urusr

ihey txlc x liine

l(fistnrnNtlddhe

risls

isigncJ.

()ft.r, s)mc(rdr!$

nn' u

tu\knts

rlrt

l).rfonn

.nl

rscsmut

inn

!i!t

$dr

Lst bui

f.t

ler$, nr r'rn'r

'fnt

JLAlu"

rrg.r, oiil

N$rn.nr

Lr rim'

olullns

$d

,' i(

rhillorqF

md

q'(l'tgli'\1010;Al'

;m,i

s.

Ydr,

loloi rurs.rto,

lolli

uivis

&

Krun*LLirlt,loot)

f

i(

[r"

1vill

lur

illr

]rcri.i,n

o

l

is.snno{ r' ih'

:r

'ts'

rnY orc. $hL.h

will

ke x Ld

oitti'nins tnN'

c.F..ullf

nr.[$Arith

l]4 nurb"r

str-.!.n$

T.r.h(

r

$.uld

il{'

t''

rbl'

&' _'u$"nn:c

rh.

d

cnhns bnr.dirtclv

mitiLl!

lff

'Nh

{,r!cntr

lll

as

t'

oNtre x

<'nno

nn'en'!

r.rni.nt

b.6inr

r!

i'(trtr i!'tl

'fknolvllJge

rid

rlnlitf

oi$t

duncns durirrg

dt

rnnr

"tl'

TliN rud) u!.1 r

(lulnx

t n"*'lt

Jdil:n

l(,dn!nr

L5n!lltli]

l) llr

trrcm

rh

.,1

rrl,i.Artr. \lJ" '| ''Lrt'L"lI"l{

$oLlii\s oi rlrl

tnrtrl f[d]'m'non

Si

EEI )

UMY

nnJds

(tr.

scl'(d nrh

tl)crrn'i

.,.is

Lrr"..t"n tb!n

'riilrLiliq

rndNnlnrgNs

;,Nlirnrtu

rn tr,is

$n.\

Ih'r

hi'l

lctnlll,n

rr

s.nr.n.nr 5.,

rlN

lixd

dN'lcn"d i

v

'q

.Ioi'l

i:srnndns.

P\'ul'qN {'( rn'ln'

iJdr.ss

ir!

lirtl.itrns''im's

nr

"!l'(

J*t'

wdelnh

trt

,rLc.'s*6t

!

:lrrtuJ

"N$nrg

'r

,-.n.,"!.lq

n

"

Th n'^'" "'(

,,"a*..t,*-.u'

LJlrl L

Ln

'i

l(ir

r.

trLf.

'F.

n.r'n'L'l

'nl'lturtrmi{r

,r,

*]\L,nr

t

unnrrr

'r

'?r

' ! 'i'r

ri.".

"-"

;"n'd.'l"i"g

x

'"i""

"'"'1'

r"

innN

rL..lih.

tl)' r'nrl6

'itl'

n,"itiin*1iLrlJin.l('dntulhcolren'r\i)l

rJ

scitri!!

niinq

(in|rsirnt

rni'$\

ro

nrl(t

onr"fdt

r!{J'{tr,Ji"nl!

nf'J'x

ilto

r

tuxror

in:s.r1N.rt.r

ljLcirL':!g

r'nr

'!rh..ds((i.\{.11,

l01l)'

FINDII{GS

(5)

The

fr

i.iNnh

$rcd

ihrt the onl rs:GNncnt

m.tivrd

tlfh

b

nnlnnr nrcnspeikr!

i*illi

Lr.rxl

Aseinnent

Fn

iral

rn .n|U11urLt)

i,

tulk m,to in dNsu!n!Enslnh.

Or!

tindpDt

iaten rhar shc )nJ

l.r

lrrnJs mre molc

Nn!

lreJ

to leanr

ti

sDok.oiicnly

rdFrcn.nfi.

dut drey

d'ld

_scr_{soo.l srrdcs}

ir

rhc

sselv

$1

The.iher

(o

pdi.(iro$

rlso.onrnntul

tht

rh.

o

l xsesment

noiiv&J rltm

n.r only

i.

s!.rk bu(

ils.

nr lea,n

[ng[h

morc

OEr

a!6,na

pd iJ.l {lnd Jiil]r,a.t.

T[.

parti.il.

$

$rtuJ rhit dref

rt(Nd

?

(ln.n

fccdbr.L

irtln

llcir

rcr.hcn rtier rh$

$r,.rmc!l

.rxLs:csmentnr

Jii\

r

ihFm?dent'n

hr0f1.Tlvoofthe

pati.irrr

s imitieLl drat

nlq

g.rr\

nnmcJHft responr. Gort thc

tu.hcn

,1trring oml as{$mc.r.

One.r

r.

rrd.\\nt

rvc

cJ nut lccdback wrs

l.'.ai.irl

a.r $uden6

Tl)h..u1,11,.,

r.il.n,on

nr the

aseslnur

!&1.(Lrlyln

rrnlyi'r!rmr

so thrt nrq

.oulJ rc\tu nrcm

n,..n.lnJ.,

rhc _rirL.iptrnN

p.r.eNd rhar ricJl).c! r.rcrrcLl ro rctlection ilter tlrtynkl an i.s$.NcN, rnJ

sr

Lmn.trt

n, _snrn, the

iuJrnF

xs

it..ullnntrmrt

drstr

Or drsn< rfqtJniidt

JE&r(

d[nnr Thc

pr

ic,IYnts

Nru.J

tlkt

tl,.

"(l

r:rsnat.oLld

nnfnnt

rens|ellir]x:lill\

l)N

pr i.itN

frrnllt..n$lcrc,l.rxl

:.\-mon

ri

r !v,y ro _{fr?.iirc llicrknis,}

ah r

r ttrn, rould lmr,'o\t h.r sfcxti'rg

rlillr

iid

knosilJgc ol Enslisl lrnluxqc. All

prrt'.iFnb

ud

ih.trsF!rkr," rLili+ ntrt(\tL1Nhcn tlreir

tu).L.s oricn

gN uraLis.Nn!r.

Thc

t]ti.t

Fan$

tr.liclrl

rL\dr

o

Lrs.sn.ntlrr

_{su,J rnJ}

usch'l

b.o$e

drq rn,ntr,!oJ

iuJdts

t)

rr.il.

T[c nndcnLs mrc rc!N]rJ n,

ri'(L!

srcxknrq,

!) l).ir:1'.rlns

sL Lr nr.rca!.J

()tuId.sr.t,l..l,t,ln*l"nb

romn!trrdn."

,['11 Itrrhc

nncrviN,

r

p]tririplnbrnn

rhar,

I.. ,r

.r

nt

.rn

x$csmflt,

iltq

roul.l

.l*

nlor

rlcir

$rmuniitxr

slilLi,

durd

kno*l-!dge,

rkl

rc(lv.J.

t cit.r

undedr.ilii!

or

Lvlxt oiLer r.colilu srnl dunng .lx$ assesnnrntr' (rre

prn'iprn dthnrcn

Ht orrl

asesr".ri

hrltJcJ hcr lern how

o.lc'tl.r,

drtirkn.wled:c

rn,lmirJ{d

A,lJtk,ul\r

rNorh.r|xrtLcipxnt

$rel d-i

sllc !.trU

Jlnlor

h$

rlndn(

r

nJrhunli'r!,

whi.h

cu:.lhdn.tur

xtil,q* to

.\flain

rlr

mit.mLnr dn'oral r\s.s\mcnt.

Otul

djrs"*

i^.-_adl rlL

ieL i-fr^li

JoL.r. onc

oltlr!

l,sri.il,.,nE nnllth{r nic

!

l

$:\sm.nt

triired

h(

i.

Lc

tnhJrnt \\ntn

n.c sN ir.nsomcd

b..rliscsmnt,

h.r n{rons

llclins\hor

5t.eli1isi'r PUbtt \rar

Le.o'n6e lcs!.

sNilf$

rnod,cr

rrni.,p[t

aL:o

rstilcJ

nu,

.in

rslsnmn h(\rel

lioo*

ltr

Ltdias.r,un,

reri<lrtr ntrl.$

to

+!! illd

This n.err.h

ils,

nrrn,l

nrt

rh! orrl

N$in.nr

Jo.. nrth

!lAs..n

gNt drc ntrJrn6 n[)s kr

trlk

M,rtrrn.it,n$

Llrri'

nt.rxl

r:$r

m.nr..rU

l,! uscJ

tu:lwr nl.rs.r.PtrrnN,

c|c.irtl,,1trnr!

tlt

r,lsin(nr

l!1.r\NhLlc, onc

.t

rh.

rtnifrnsinl tht

tlrc onl

xsssn.ni

uNa.hru.n:.

tur

hcrluiuint

hid

r)rr.-\

n.iistr.F.r

ern,

r

\rrrsluttim. Ai'

orhlr

l*'it

i|\,nrrLd

ilrt

L{ rliliq

r o

l

is$in.fr

lNr grsr,

$n

t.nr

1).r ilLm.y shcn

!nre

olun,\

rnlhu

!o.l

s.o(-s

i't.rJ

ri.sincn6

Ihr

_II

tiri|ir.

xqrRd tl\,i rh. or

i:*rn,rff

mxJ.

fic

$n.nr:

xl,l!

r.

sl[re drcn

nLri.

llrtl.,

J

rh*nnr.rtr[

(6)

tD

h

Ji:nnh$n

b:$rh

Ihe

din

vxnn,sc" .a

tll

.tu1 xs..sNcnN Tl,c

rrti.lp

ts ttr.cntd ihii

dre aLlo.{i,n

.Inmc tudrc orxlr$essm.r(nx

limitn

rnn

drcy Llr

ncru6

whor hi'ing to _na,itin

li..t .l

6rn

r$.ncB rnJ

nti!

_{tccn. Th.}

{Ll.nts

.Lt,

n.sitnt

r.i'ti.fvnv\rrc

drcn rxtugori:cdi o the JMdvrtiscs

olil]c.qlNcsrut

n, ihis

OBI

llknivit

pro!Lltrl rtr'l/i.r.nr

tft

alloi

non S.hs

frti.inNs

*it dilltilk

nneliwn

lor thc orxl rsse$.\nh *x. so

lid. dn

th.f

r.uLJ not

uxtf

thBn iJtN

fturny

Moiciime

ill().,iion.:..o

insiotirtiri

nN,mLlJ!nt

rl]!m omoirunrcs r.

.hb.riic

ihen NSIrN

Jd

nr!(

drc

r$thc^'

.tpu.r0s.

Gd.$s.mat -,,r.

n*1.,1/"r

*"" ".lhc

lan nn.l rguA on

dt

nrq.(i'!

"

oarl..r,l

Nscsm.ot biscd on rhr ter.cFhons

oInuJ.iti,

lc,

oLi.

rerons lurinsrLr rscsm.nt. \,ton Dxd;FDt5

s,

dur tl,!) idt nd!.us \drcr Ferformnrg oral xsrlsmrnt.

Of.

l,triririni

rl

mcd nerrous lx.rLsc Jn

,l norl,i(

.i.rsh

NrriLo.,

r'rL

xs

r.i,h'l{!

SL. s

r!

orl0icrl

anll

r

lirk(l

()

d,$.

r

ni

qocsuN

g(m I'y h.r tuxlltr.

Anotir.rni

i.il'nM,

phmn

dft.

rs sh.

rNvoy

tur!.ls

Lrn,!.

1

iscrnrcni, hrr

itcn.or

Jurins nn,

r:srs{Nn

DtSCUSstON

'h.

prri.ilr.N!

_{m.ntdroJ iL.tr}

f($rn,'

.i11.

llunusN

rn,l

Ji:rlvr

rr:.s.t orl'l

rsrsmcnr Thue

nur

5ix i(I] r.1

'q.s

.l

.i,l

r!:!sudrinrnn

in drn

rdnr.h.

llc

n^t

fi

,rx*a:tl,ardr.

"rlll

^s.sn\{r

fr{riicd

nuJrnts

b

st

(k.-lhr

iuJ.n6

hxrlbror

tx{i'

urJ

b\

tlt

!rcsur

oaonl

*k!$sr.

It $

\

.orsistenrqirl\ Blr'L xnd !u,lli.,n (1e98) _{!tren in}

B.sss d

il

(1008)

iht

_\rnl

rlit

o

l trs$sn cnr

l)r\

n.J , n

nnJ.rhnJnr!

ol luw

Ns.$n.n.

ifie. n,J

+'tr](nl

motinri.n. nr dris tuscrJr. the isesmonis

n,

lc

tl'.sud.n6

Lcro'nr

ui.riliti

tospeik

r itnNt

rrirsroli'rs

()m1..icncc

h

idJrion, nmN

ln nifrrilclr

rhar nrotivitn$ sas

lnrl).trN

b ltlF

thun

f

.ti.c _rr.iknrs

n

.lN

h

ontcr wortls, rh. orJ

iii.sm.nr

tln tudcn$hxll

b

lric. nxd.

nIm

r(dv lunl.r

rnd is

i

kn'lt,

tlqrv Jl.L.trr

l1rr

r

Tld.nnc,

trrhrF.mptu!

enLr>

N(.rlmotnlrkri

x, rL.ir$uJcnb nr dr.

l.rmi'ip _Do.cs

drtrill

io,t..r.

rl.

qtrxLiN oI

l.trn,nrg

{rgpes

bW

llHirs rn(l

\r'illirns

(l0ll)iit

nnn1tnnr

r

thc

nut

nnlonrtr

6cor

t,

imB"c lrmur:.

TLc scnDJ

6n.lnrers

rlut

nt

fcc.lbr.k

G"r1n1c

mr.h.^t.

dr. srncnG BNiiLly, tLc

r n$Nll'NL],l

r th.r rc.ond fiedLr.k trch

iirn

tu

)cl

ihcr nrq

|lr.rmed

xn

is:.s$ot

nr

nr..lAroonr

Rc!,Jltrgthn

rs.l'.h,

fod

ii,g tunl)rrt

Nr

r Lool Nq

n.,urh.r:

xlr.r prov n,s

o

1

xscsmrN

nn

icllii.L

u'ld

h!\,

th! $uLl.nrs iJcndlrthcn

mrill$.Iiom

.h.

t.Nrc.ti'1

olt|. rr.i.,tffi

nqxot

r.-ll

r[

Nhcr rlkr

r.rn*n]..I in

o

1N..s!

nun

Th.

L,.Jbrrl

tdr.l:[I)

UMYo$irr.J

.Ir

ictle.non

ofr|c

nrJrrr.

shdn

thrlI[!

nnr.(l ni!tri.s

r

dr!

.l,Iro",n

L_crJlurl

..oldtc.on,citr

inNt

nrr

dr

nuJ.nN

b

Lt

bst

, nr

o

la$$sncn'

TLr.turofu,

ih.ru.l.nts

*!ic.x0..t.J

ro he

trLl.t,

r.t.!nl1'tllctr

nrnL'klir.!.,

rhc*rt

s

trdrrn.'tur,

mJ

$

o.

ThN, !r this

nQr.l,,

n cnl)x.l u N .nc oI

(7)

.tk,,

L{N..n

r.rch.s

rd suJots r. rur.c.J

Thc nnrr linJi',c slNtr.J dDr

fir

o

l

is.s'

men.

nnrdrd

ihe

{uJcrs'

\rrl

rs

ilntrt} Snr.c oral

r!

$DrcM

wr

.ons

.reJ r

drct

i'il.n.ii[

Leoc.n rhe

Ex.luand

lhcsud.trs, nrc studcrt

"se

rquircd io 1,.

rrllfrcfrcd

so

$,t

dq.onld

rn$o

ihc quenk,.s ln

ri.

rsNsm.ns

quick\

&rrcdb, rl,e

Frt,.i

f

tr!

drc'

i.n.cd

tht

Jift.r

lnt.nsnnN re

qrnci

inm.JLxtc?ns*einsi d,us. this monenr

.oflLlMni

rhcm.o

Lnrror thrna..xk

q

ihli$.

Thu.nr..

Ly _sivnrqrn orln

isr\mcri,

tl1.

i.a.h$

llrd

)lriysntn tltir*ul.rNin

.pNrtuLty

io Fa.r i.c nrcn Enstishsl{xLiis

sh,lls rn.l simtlta"c"ud.r Ilr! nudcrts qot

rt

scssc,l

Jft.il!

nr

thc.hs.

Thc

Frti.il.anii

_l,.r.i.v.drlst tlr. .nn

si.ssmcnt inpro\tn rhcir

:Nr[irg

slilLs This

ir(lDg*rs

m Lnre with shrr

hnvrn.

(l0Il)

Lal

nut,l

n

whdr oul rsrssncnr \us

u!.J

r dne(

sscsm..t

ordr

$nd.nts' In,Nl..lg. :n.]

.onrprel,.nsi.r, l..iuse the

rsrsnnlt{):

.orJu.ted nr

dn.ritr.r,ft,ons.

lhr

nrJdr

nn'lJ

imrbn

rheir

[ilio

rnd

t(r r tu.r

Jrir.

r'ithT.nrc,

(1998)*1..4r.J

tlut oriL

NiNntnr

h.lNd

inpo!

*!Llcn^

rrn.,r*

rnn nr

d[

rlNs Ly cxmLtring w]rd

lu

dr.

r

\Lrnt ti,ilcd.r pNsd

dr

isseiu.nrJctr

mnrcn

br.u$ifu,i,n:LilL:

I'r tlns

uurJr,

i\.

xs$smenr

d'l\l

nnl)naa nic $uJcn.' !]rcrLinprb,ti$ belrns.

rh

rci.hd

rtrtJnrtm

r, tr,.1i!.

\r,knrs

in

the.hs

lnrlJiln

,nr.

ofuli$eirn.

i

!r..n

scJ

drtjrJtnri

n,1[

n

nn.nt

o

Jsrbp

tL.irt.r,mutrrur

!L,lL

Tl'.

a,ntrnr nnJrn wrs

tht

tL!,""1

N.s.

ncnr,lo!1,)$J

'hc

{

n.nF'..mm\

nlr nr

rllll\

r-(D'ntrnisthrnr

rl,r.L*s is

Lmnotrt

fi

r

jul.rc

nr .onrN

m.liaq6

(nri..nmuDr

..r,or

Lar.t)cns whr n

tudcnt

0{ tl'.nowr

.trh,

!,nritn

r[r\

dr.tudln$

or!].NrNJ

lrLLlcrlop

fictr.f

nur.r,oD

stills

AlnnLl-nu

o

ld,shn (1!9lt)N.ncJ in I

[xmm (.1,

(l0ll),

ih. iduntxle

oio

liscsmcntNto

nrc\rdf]rgi,,

m.ln

thi:.rr.1rrl,, drt

$uduti

htrd

tuerphif

tlt. hri$sNen

inrltko$n

undcnrn.Ji,r: 0tnt!

dtn.wn

RrRl., l.nling

,n.nr

r.

M nnptur{ncnr in th.ir

!,n hrt

i.ltdr

:l(nLs

thisnt.motr\rmn,

xnn'd lr_

HN)nu

dxl

(loll)

thr.

L rs.sim.nr wisn)

J.nlol

iJcnF

.m L

..mmhirnidl

'liLLls.

'n(

[,i]r

_nrJiLrg

$llllcl,It

_{dr. orLLr5s\+}

Nun

nt(ii.Ll

nre

$ud.fb'

\li:unnltn..

IhL: \'r5 tul,.xnr(irh drc

rt(n.nriii.d

Ly

lNlhnr

(l0() l) nDi oril

}:..i"$l

.m Lc u...1

n)

n$nm

prrsnl !u,ltrili

ntrh N

rl.iinos.

d.r

n)

$r.s,

,'lilrl)l1iq.

:cll-Nr.,.s,

iN1

rtr{.nhJur..

A..oni ns,o rL. tituhrq\.anrh

k$r.|,

nr.ofuIi:.r$

mt.

ldu Nrrr{

n,c

{

crri

scLt{!Dn!l.n.r

Ari

rrJli

rhenrncnrs

.'!fr1,h'd

t,

d.lL\ar

dttr

rlnarghF ind .pln.

r r

EnlLnlr

r

tlrL:

-!rlnn"t

l.J

b

ri

lml,.!r.l

En:li.lr

r|[ilr!shill r

nrc

{uJ.rh

Jr*lF

n,r.ri.r.1,.rh,n! nr Lnsl'n,

*iih.ur lcir

nnr

L!h rh.\

hatlt,

\,.rh,n,nrt,,rfrt1ir'

ln

rnd(.f

|[nJorrr

!N

.nc ot

fit

*nli!,ls

.t

rlt oi'l[{:snrcii

in drir

r.i*rh

lh!

L$

tir\!i't!\r rl

hc,nlxs.smmt

:rr

rs

r,,l..ili,rg

IL,. rrn.iPanrs snJ

iLt

d,.\ nnLlJ.lrm n,cir nlN': nLcn drq

J lo

l

scsnnii

$

nr..ls

TLt.{tJu$

(rLlJ

h.

nn,ir Nnn.cl \,hur drq

!onrntrniitcJYirh

,{lrr

l,crrlc Thi! aiinLiLrg

n,rrotuJ

(lcnr,

(8)

nrtur

is

r

a

,oq.rn'l

siy nJ

N.,!tr.

unn&

sr

nrg;nn.n.oui'sr;ti.rlthi,ilir!.

Brsd or rl,c nrllirgs ol th. restmh, thcrc

(rr.

sD JFrd*ntxs$ of 11,.

.

l

ir.sntnr

nr rhis

r.s.r

.Th.6nt, ihetinrcn\

tlrd.

1

rss$menswN

fir

.J

l.\sthin

cnouJt ln

thr

onlrss.s.

eft.

r. $udcnN L,kl

t, rNv.r

r]I qu$ii.N

PG

lrrl,r

mfl].r

sru{ urrl}

in )

nrn

iinr. NhL[ ihe

rudcnG {Jc(l lo.g.r

rimc

krtliil

6.nxc

rN(nrgihcquc$

rs

A.(

nrq n,

\{nLu

( 1004),

rodcri:lccldrr

prcsur! to Jri,rk _!tri.[1r

{l[n

mnx]:i,rq nrcir

lJ.r ni r shotr

p...d

ol ri'nc

Tli$iiN

m

rlt

or

a-*.ssm..t i'r dxs kRxrrLr Na! \,

irilnYi

tr

Jnnrj

tli$,

il nrrlc drc $ud.n$

i(l\liinLlr

bdonre rnasmcnh 11, niis

i.srr.h

drr

$uJors.ould norman

s

thc

i'n!:N

Lynrc

r:.h.r

l,cciosc tle hmc wiJ

u,

dr.it

n, thrt rhcJ, m,ld

r.t

..trr.niir.

or aor

-lhs

r.on.l linkl'nntrg.rs

nr..ril

rs$tr

NN:

mrJe tlr|

nuJrt

ir.l.cnoh,

dnN lNinr .on.cntrnon n,

Nnu

rhr

,tucin

i

!n!n

b .tNh.r

ThNnas ilnr nLnforicJ

Ir

l',trsrnn,

(l0ll)

rhat

nd*rurics

DnghtJLntrL, tlr. il,Lrnryolthe

u$.rNh(n

th!

qr.rxu

ra:

givu,

BNi

oD nr. aituliiq drclrartnirnnrs

u'ld

nor

r

s!.r

rl,. rtrrrions Lrc.ius! da,r

!,irlcJ

:nr..tL(r

|nl

n.tl,rt.nrsh

0tupin-ti.rs,

r,rh

N

roriL,ul s.ln1Jn(i,r,,

(hc

flrl.n$,'!r,LliliLi ntr.

liss.sm.n6\e'lJ

hrlr _{r.nrc r,rtnncm..nr..}

dr$-oulJ

l*.Lyt.,.r

rh.

r:sNrnd*:

n.'lDnslv ln

t'(,

nr

qfrrl

tua.h.F.trn ,nurll)

li.h{

.l.nF

ri,.ri.e

:n

[,D! nr nr!

rL]sti

onron.

nlN

{,r,css.

l(t l,nr

(1010).lisilics

ntc.rqjori.. oloril

Ncsmrn.

ini.I(up.i,ts,

rl

nN. {r,c

lotr d

l.

drn r$ci..L, i.e.,

kro*lclscin.l

undcNihliIs,

rhblcnr arhnrq rnd

rmll.*i.r,

'nr.rpcuonrl

nnnpRrt,

rid

l)cron.,l

x.

til6'hs.Ihe

|eronrl

aifilJn..s

i,,.l

cd nr rhr oral

r-*.s$uts

r

dnsrts.Rhs.rc

rh,tn,t

.ril,sseiimd$ Ntrirfi.J

tln $uJents, iLn.

rn\td

nrc

nnJ!.tl

\cli:o.iiJ.n.e,

ptuvntud thc

$Jcrh

lcs

rimcsh$ J.iIq

d\t,

niJctlrt

nn.leri5 Lclr.rvou:, xnd

u

nr.l the

nu.l.tr:

io _sctirrJl,i.k.

Itn

$xs i'r

r.nnmn.t

$nh l,n,phnr (1001)'"h.

rt,.,l

nui pcmnal

t

hrl

ns

vr

onq, .

linnJ

ri

l.

us.d to mcanrc

!c^.nrlqurt,i

sulh

is dt.s,

r.idnr

ro $r.ss,

rdrflibili!.,

s.ltl]Lv.Rncs nal

"rlir t

Jcnr.. TLcr.fotu,

t).^.nrl

iftrit utrs .oul(l 1..

riJ r

rhc..nilitnr

olrl..lrss

Nl

Fern,i:

nulllluring

xsscssment

ts$

lrtubutes

..

lJ lic

r.snnt

Nd n.grtnt,

r.o(li,tg

nr rnderN'

rlunrtri$trs

ir

nrc oml rscssrtr(nr,

rklr

NroDin[nlr,

ncrtisn\s, r]J

so on.

Tli..tr

goryor

knNld$

nl

un.lc6hnd-,n:nLlrhJ

rhc

oi'lisrsm.nrsNr

m.rs

ro

,mpoa iltc *udcnb

rltrrlnigrl)il$&l

gm

.i:

nr srGtn,q J.rshi'r

(l0ol)rsu

n,r

!)

lhi

r$.snr.nr

ill.w:

Ior _Brbi'rp

fldrnt!

unLlrrnriJi'rn.i

ix$, (ni.qr,

_l..i'r.'dcstrnn

pucJ,rcrlii.rrd.rlrr

.;rnn,

1,rftr.

drou{h

R:r.r.r

Lr

rh:$.ar.h,

tir

FdJ.

Bn6 \rnl rhrt the

t

r.hr

trral

Jilti,cnrq

cr

noN fu

nHnr.

rh.

iuJons' hoNl.Jg!

Thn

tr)!nrfNtldliyP! !n. (l0lr)*hoitcd

tl,xr(ttrf{nN

rc

ndxluys

in'sio!

tu r\trY

plror

ir

r.$,

r'rh

)s rhr

numlu.lrtrdn.ns

inJ tlr.

l.\.1oadimrLlrl

h

fir

orxl arscnri.nh

in

rhi:({^r.l\

ih.

tu,.h.h}..s.rJ

rlI

$n-,1.16'nnlLq drorsh rL.

$rJ.nti

rr5l\$.:

(9)

und.6n

nrgel,.tr drq

qftrn, i[.,nxrrirl

The.iteg.ry rLoui

!Dtr[N

_inL]

rN.li.xrnr

in.lL,dtul dr! on,l *r.!sm.nrs ro

Ll.\.l.rr|c

iuLlcnc'

.lhnuri(rnr

\k,lls xs _thcA\cs!

n.n6

als.l,uold

ttr.{trd.n6 b

l]&,Jex

_tu

:|.rk

durils rh. _{a$.snons. A..orJnjs}_ro

t.(hin

(2001), _{in o,)t}

r$sne,*

orues

t

rLcF

(r _xsl_{fudcDs que(ionr}

ir

_lvhirh

rtre

.s*sm.nr

is

rot.nlr

L.uscn.n _howt.tlAe iiscl( [ut ]ls. fo.ns!J otr rl\e afpLi.arion

oIttr.

knowlcise n) rhc r.,l

:iiuin,r

Thcit6(, onl

is.rhrnrssLnLlJ

_hot

ro{s

_mcd)._on_$(Jch.J

kn.iloJsc, _bur_n,Nnllr_rL!,

{n(turs

_nna&

onJnr!lu

),j

rhro

irjs.snnrtrt, whenr., rhc

$rn.n6!nd$+

rl!.

nr.i,rLr si(n

by nrc

The _{or.g.ry oi.nL}

N.s.icnr

_it,out

nhp

r.bumlsk'llsnr.lurlcdth..ktrs.5sm.irr.

rl(vel.Ddrcs

_enn

romnnui.tio.

sl

_ls

aj.n.ri.orfr

}tirijlcjhiltr,

n.l

,rs

(omN,

iu.nr,n

nftriew:lii[\

n

n]e..nrNr ot ,rrot'6sio

ril

snux

jn: ir!

*elt ru

ftll

h

mr.Nrc_

'n.nr dnonlh.hrt

Na\\nrnr

Uounhi|, loor)

tue(Iin, .rrunrit!kn[

arc

Ni

r)..m_

Dnrni.xrc Dd

tntu'NritL.rl.s

_tn_dln

*

sur.h,

tlt.

_lN:c\sm.nK_nrv.t(n

JLk{

.omDnnnornnr

$

rlaidr.

_{$uncnN rfrcJ}_rh.tr

|.

n),l]crt in

drc.Lisu.ll.

coNcLUStot{

Ai tcaJrfh h,tr( ih.ll)n.rinnrq- kr

l..rJ. rh

m.n _{iutrrur .N!sim.i}_r

nutrl

_aor_n)or

ru.

d.n6,

ia,.l,enun

Lh!

tttr.h. r.n

rhr

(rl{

_irh

olrhr,'!(artrsN

r di:iv,*

tu!$ oi cx.h _n

|r

oi

]s$\mon\

l|

nrLns.r

rl{Nrrcs

inn rlisrJ\

uii!!

\, rhr

or

asdnotr

mflcDtn(n

ii

EngL,st,

EJu{nnr

_Dcfmmcnr

.allnn!rsnr

MuL:Dn\i!tiy)tr y.strl<a

i

L,roushr

iLorrI\nji.rror$

_rnN

l{spc(j\s

Ii s.,r _1.rLr.i!crl_{du, .rxt}_Nesm.nr

.ller

s.nnlrlv{t:g.srostrd.rts,{,.h

_nnprcvir!

sndoils'..nnn ri.aii.Dskiltsud.o.nn.n..

nren _{fositnr D.ap.(iv.s}_oa_rLc

juJ.ts.ih

_t)c

ni!

prrsb

Lc

rnituiirrd

ulllercLoNJ

_i,)

imfl.D,cnriDs or xl N\6sm.tr r Th.Ri.tu,

ru.

den^un

hlr

nre

nixnnfD t,{cr]$

iron

_rc

imrlc'nenrrnnrol.tuI

_scsrnenr_McxnLvtrite, mo(

m.rrilr

![r]trlhc ]],nti. nr nrn,fn.

r

rimcrllo.ni,

_{rosr\rik rD,tthr}

r(qnNn,rr

_nrc

$!dcn$ ffh !lurij){ drr

s:Nm.

si:

rcr..iv.!l

!,

i.c

n.$h\t

iJcs 01 njc

ort

Ascsnr

$

r

FED

LlMy',th.r

d(r

Ji:fu(a,ri{r Jurtd

_L.

'nnn'nir.n

!,

n,r

tl,c nn,r6r:ts .h

ri,uih..rat

rsicsucnt.rtr

L.

inrnrfrlil

_i,,J

rNur.Ll

Th's, L,-nnrlemon.ih"o

l,,\sr*ji,r,ri

itt;

rxfc!r.d ihat di. _t,'

rFs.

!iurng,nl

rsns!

Drqr

r

rr|{.t N*jnuh

nr _fr)vrJcrt{. trc{

i.n,ti

fi

nrr

m..NhNrnf

, )r

flJrnt!

r6iljq

.rn

REFEREI{CEs

Al.Amn,l!,1 N, & Y.rlnr (tOlO)

I\r.n.t)L.r

FnqLirh _rNrn!_i._nilLi

jaatrl,Irn!.

_n)_trr

qorl,

\rh.rir!

rorr

_EutiJ[

tr\n(si

trr.hu(I(1).Ul1t7

Ll:n'

\,

M

ll,

T.[r'rL,

H

S,

th!N]1,8,

N

I)rl.{lu,A.(l0ll)

Thcnnlr(oi iNkqr,r.n

or,,L _|ira.nn;_f._\'

.i

_Enlti:h

R)rl

\hool$nn.nc.

_H_Lr_n

oito/Et(ib,,

lnig$,

M

\({\liLclJ,A

\jrfn,

_C.

S

(10)

d.Dri

Lciil,i'r!Miii.n

I

tl

Lamh!.

BNtor

rlci,nctrnJ Hci'n. PubLirl}

cr$.rll,J

W(1011)

El,(n,o,(ln'tu.J',

l[iin,s,.or,lrdr's,.nJa{ik.nsi,ontirdnlr

I']LnvrDto,

N

1]0ll).l.,u,ll,nrLln("n(tr'r

arul _a(dli.arn!

E!,rh

(4 _el

)

B.n.r,

P.N.n

arl(drif-$jdrr

(18cd).llxnduns

l'I

EJu.aftnr,ln..

Rcmili R.silrl.rr,a

t)x!\

ll1 I 1.,

&

Kim]thihkc,

l. (1005). 'l

hc

R,.hrd, l. (i. (:1008).

n..i

ina ln&trn,a d,n

fLx.c.Irlt.r,lNnninxd.nintorl,y\

rl,rdki(

Adn

rMo

.o

td

axmtnnq.

rs!\:i,c.r \l,!rlnr

MJal

lialrur, 27

(4),

(lNL,rids. Pr.$ Unnr, !\...

:194-197.

Tomei, J. (1998) Oril

!rutn.icnq

t!$

ir

rh.

L)dmu,

I

(Ed.). (1001) _oial_ld"!l,.s.

asdj,r

.

_Enslrh_{sFtrhrq sorcc}nr l lolhanlo

Unntr

,'

_{tu lo<iF}

r.rs!,*

nh

,L^n

n{

o '(hc,

nir.loh

ol HisLr EJn(Lon, Ho[td{]o

,n(&,sDs)

N.iih

(;n,lnrc Srtrr.:

ERI(j

U

irdnr

(),

16l-166.

{lu*,l,Jolton,

B, Sr lG5er,

t

(lr9r)

Tl)n,l'VillimiK(r,[iL'iviLlirms,(].11.(l0ll).Fnt

n!

or _rratr

li.i

i. unJcr!.

ur...'nputu

k.r

inlrdilrti

ntr nnr(,vnrs *uJcnt

h.tntr

srLrn.c A

lmrnr.nvi:i

J.r.l.f

n! r

iJ

nor

nAaurh in l

ldu

Ahrd.or lornal, l l ,

l-r\s.ssii,g.riti.irltii,!i,r!r|N.xrhLrlJun{ ll.

r H{,'{EJ(rn.n,5ll.5ll

\(/i\Ld, (1. (1C01). _DdlLl)ltr!_i&l

dlausn(

Hr$u,

M, CamfLrll, l:,

&

Wsh(!xl,

l

J?nr o&lrLIL

nnd,ii'gli

$, Staal (l0l l).

lhrl n^ur

Nnftcn

isi.smrnr

A

t$

E.lu.ltnnr

nl

l)$aloPm.rtsA$c.i,tul

ol$uJcnr

p.f.nnm..

rrd,rlniJs

A'A'

nor

d

E,dr,ltitr

u

H,q'ur Er,,nru( J7 (1), 115-r6

rrn

(?01L). _fir.

uu

Mtrdd:

liLNtl$

_d,rl

8d'.r.

oiDiJ,

Jor.s

rnllttrdfi

ilLH.h.l

l,n!hih,

G

(1001)

()tuli.sr5snr

rG!n'rl\t

l,.rn,ir

_rcrs|a.hvtTh.

lxfu,

a!

oroin

ssn,mt

, n p.:!n,mprlsoN Edu!.rion

jdrghr,

(l

(1010)

LJ!rt

gun!.

i..rilrs.s!

ment Ljn

i,rl,,

\r/ouunsoi!, l-11

N;l,nnrm

Y

&\rt,l(f\,ll

(r001)

Turlrnir

k{ln!,trn.o'nnntrn.rnm:liLli

/N'l

d,nor,,r'.

diJ

linral

!.i.i.A, trlll,1l-51

Nni.,A 1,&

Bnrllld,

S l\,1 (1011)

E/iu

rid

!,NNtr.tr,lnkrdr.

NN losef