Strategi Peningkatan Pelayanan Dinas Kebersihan dan Pertamanan dalam Pengelolaan Sampah Perumahan (Kajian di Kabupaten Bogor)

!

" !

# $ %&&

.

/((0 01 ' 2 " 0 2 ! 3 4

" ! ( "

/ " ! 56 6 7 868 0'4 9(' ' (/ 0 0

"" " ! "

2 ! " 2 !

" 5 & 2 !

2 " ( " # : " "

2 " # . ! 2

" 2 ! 2 " ( "

" " 2 2

" : ; 2 " 2

" 2 " ! 7 !

( 0 ! " ' *.,< <7< %%&# = # ) " " " ) > 2 ! " !

! " 2 #,?

@ "" 2 " &? @ !

2 " " % @ !

" ?#*@ ! " ! 2 " 9!! " 2 " " 2

! ! " ; 2 " ! # 2

" 2 "

! ! " " ! (. " #

" " 5 & 0 : " (.

# 9 ! < # . 2 ! "

" # , "

5 # 2 2 " # (. " #

,

/((0 01 '

6 6 7 868 0'4 9(' '

(/ 0 0

#

# )

2 0

A A #* < < %%A.%%

< .

#

2 #

5 & 7 2

/ B

3 # 7

# . 7 "

#

' 2 %&%#

" 2 2 # "

# A

/ " # ?%

.% 3 "

.% ( "

/ " #

# # 6

) (B - ( 7

! 7

B ' *.,< <7< %%& 7

" !

"

)

) 5 &

" ! B 3 C

" #,?@ )

# #

" &?@

*

?#*@ #

#

. )

"

%#,*% 7 %#..*

2

%#&?- #

9 .( %#& +

.( %#%-,

( "

/ B 3 5 &

D .( D .

!

/ / B 3

..

&?* &. &?*

( *E + . *%% %%%#%%

/ %%-#

/ &? ??

( && E * %%% %%%#%% 3

( C7 .&@#

/ B 3

*& / &E

( && *.E -%% %%%

.( 5

.( / "

/ B 3

"

# # 8

!

.(D <

.( .(

.( 7 D " .( /

.(

' 7 D

?

#

/ 7# !

! #

!

'

# !

+

F )

3

0

#

%&&

)

3

/

A/

! "

# ! $ %

E

7 !

&%

C 5

' 5

'( 5 ) * %+,&-*

0 6 7 # 7 0 9 ( # 7

" 7

0 1 # 7 9" ! 0 ' # 7

&&

B

G

G

7 !

" 7 0

" 0 6 7 #

7 0 9 ( # 7

/"

7 7 0

/" #

0 # # A

"

!

&

+ &-+?

0 $ )

/ 2 C / # %%%

'

%%. ! / / B

( 6 ) %%*

/ B 3 # %%+

( 6 ) 3 %%E#

A

7 " 0

&.

$ ( 96 = 2

$ ( 4 7 ( =2

$ ( 6 7 0( ' =2

0 9' )/6/ '

& & 6 & & 7 . & . *

00 0'C / ' /

& + &. & &* &+ . % , % * , . * , ? * E

000 79 8 9 C0 '

. & -. 6 B .% . . 7 .& . , 7 . . * 7 . . * & 7 ! . . * 7 0 7 .. . * 7 ( ) ..

0H 8' 0 0 /7/7 B06 1 )

, & 4 /

.-, 4 / ,%

, . ,& , , / 6 ) ,E

, * 8 ( ,E

H ) 06 ' 97 ) '

* & ) *. * & & ' *.

* & **

*-&, * . ? * . . ?, * . , ?? * . * ?? * , ' ! ?+ * * +%

* ? 7 <

< 6 + * ? & / ( +. * ? ( +. * ? . ( +, * ? , 0 7 +, * ? * 0 ! 7 +?

* ? ? ++

* ? + <

++ * ? E ( ++ * ? - +E

* + 7 +E

H0 ( 940 ' 9( '3 '4 ' (84( 7

? & ! E& ? E

? & E* ? 7 EE ? . "

-H00 9 07 /6 ' ' ( '

+ & -+ + -E

--&*

& C &+

C &

. # # 7 8 .&

, <

.

* .?

? 8 ,+

+ ,+

E C ,E

- ! C #

)

,-&% ! C #

7 *%

&& ! C #

< 2 A 2 ! *&

& !

*-&. < / B 3 ?&

&, C B 3 ?E

&* C # H H

7

B ' *.,< <7< %%&

?-&? 7 &%%@

8 / B 3 +

&+ $ / +.

&E $ +.

&- $ C +,

% ' 0 C +*

& 0 A +?

) 3

&?

. / 9 " 4

EE

, / 9 " 4

7 -%

* / 4 3

-&

? 7 .& @

&+

& 8 &,

.%

. 8 ,.

, 4 ( 3

E,

* 4 !

E*

? 4 ! 6 <

8 E?

+ 4 ! 6 8 9 E?

E 4 ! 6 ! E+

- 4 !

7 EE

&% 4 ! 6 .(

E-&& 4 ! 6

( -%

& 4 ! ) 7 7

-&E

& 7 ) 7 "

3 &%*

7 7 A7 (

4 7 ( A 4 &&&

&

&-! " # $ % &

2

A

#

#

2

"

" 2 7 %%*

"

! #

#

2 #

#

# " #

7

%

7 A

# # A

8 "

A

#

"

"

2 ! '

"

" 2 !

)

#

2

" #

" ! ! !

0

*E@

.%@ # -@ # @ A &@

# %%& ) 2 0

A A #*

%%A.%% < . # %%- 7 6

) C03 %%. # A E%%

&--* -&% %%%

#

&

< # < # <

#

" )

7 4 * +

" " +% @

%&*# 7

/ ' &< ( <7< %%? '

' A / "

2

A

A

! $#' '( ( )

2

"

#

" #

A

0

C

" , ,++ -?

2 I E -** 7.< #

?? *E @

# &*@# 0 &* @

< # # #

# < # /# #

( " C

7 ( C7 %%EA %&.

"

,#&+@

,%@ C " *. @ B

"

! "

#

/ B 3

* & + % ) ,$ %( ,$ - + ( $.$#(+) / $#" .', "$ 0&0# / ,$ &$ 0 ( , ) ,$#' ) 1 %)'('( - /+ + - ) +.+ 0 &2

"

#

#

#

/

#

.

A

J & + % ) #' '( ("# "$&+ ,$ + &% " 3 %', ,$ - ( , ) ,$#' ) /+ + - ) +.+ 0 & .', "$ 0&0#24

!5 '6'

5

& 7 2

/ B 3

7

. 7 "

*

! , )

) &-E. # ! A

A

! C

"

#

A " #

"

#

" " :

# #

! # %%,

" / A ' .

%%-# : %%-# # <

"

!

# "

! !

9 ! !

3

?

! 7 &--+

! ,

" !

!

!

!

! #

# # A

7 &--+ #

"

( #

#

A ! #

2

7 # &-E+

2 #

C

#

#

& / A ' &E

%%E A

<

' % %%E

( < #

# #

+

/ %% !

!

2

"

.

7 : &--% #

# #

#

! %%. !

! #

#

A

A #

# #

! # !

#

# A

7 %%% # !

# 5

& C

#

"

#

!

# #

E

# # # #

A 2

.

# # "

! # # # # # #

7 &-E+ !

# 5

& #

A #

. #

, 0 #

*

3 &--&

5

& ( #

#

. 0 #

, # # #

* #

? C

A #

: # "

-&

2 # #

7 ! #

# # # # A

. 0 # # A

, " !

#

* ! #

# #

? ! #

+ 0 # #

# # #

E

7 ) &-E. # ! !

" 5

& # A # # #

# # A #

A

A # A

# # #

A # # A

A

7 &-E+

# 5

& ! 4 A

.%

A !

#

#

# "

. "

! # "

# # #

A

, # "

A # A # #

A

* #

" ! #

C B %% #

5

& # 5

A

# #

A

#

# # " #

# A

" #

#

A # A

# #

.&

. #

# #

, $ #

# # # # !

! $ &$ 0 , )

/ A ' &E %%E#

# #

D

D < !

5

# # < ! D

D

" <

D

# #

D <

<

"

"

#

.

& B ! # #

D

B D

. B

/

# # ! #

# ! # #

/ # %%

!

4 &

. # ! %$ $% +% ,$# (+0 $ &$ 0 $#( , )

2 G K K

G 2 '

0 / !

..

3 8 # '0 ' &-A

.-,?,A&--, 7 3

# ' 0 '0 ' A%,A

&--.A%. ! "

0 # 7 B '

*.,< <7< %%& 7

5

! ! $7 / )

2

2

#

#

"

#

<

# 5

& # # #

D

# # # #

D

. " .

/ # %%

#

"

# #

.,

A #

!

7 / #

#

5

5 A #* < < %#,A%#*

< <

< " 5 &#*A < < &#. K

&#, < <

7 3 # &--&

A 5

& "

L 6 #% < <

L +* @ K E% @

L % @ A * @

L 6 # * < <

L ?* @ K +* @

L * @ A .* @

# # <

" / #

%% 2 5

& C D

D

. $

, 3

* 2

.*

.$ ! $ +( $7 / )

' C

B

/

B

& &% A ,% & A. 0 2

,% & A. 7

. &

. & % A. A.

, ,% ,A? A. A

* & %%% E% A. A

? *%% ,% A.

+ .%A,% A.

5 /# &--%

/ "

<

'

#

! " $ A!

- # &--. 5

& C

6

.

, 7

! ! $ &' ,'

"

.?

# A A

5

& 0 2 6 # " A

<

2

5

! A M *@

"

"

C M %#. .<

0 2 6 # " A

5

6

" "

! ! A N *@

! 8

. 6 # " A

# 5

!

" A

.+

! /

, 6 # " A

#

5

"

" 6

! ! N *@ #

# " # ! M * @

" # "

6 <

! 8

" A

5

& ( &A, <

& # .

# 5

&

& D

#

# . & D

. . D

, D

* " D

?

#

.E

C

! !5 $ + / )

/ # %% 8

<

)

<

!

< ! 5

!

" <

!

! 0 %%

# ! 00 ?%A %%

"

! 000 &%A %

?A&% . &K&% .

.-/

#

-. - #

-C 5

.$ ! $ +( # %"$#+("+% " $ & &%'"

C 3 E . &% . & . -- 8 - 8O7

- 3 "

- / *

- K . <

- ? 7.

E . &% .

-- 8O7 !

-- 7 #

A. <

- / * K +

- 3 - * . + . E . - 7 - " - 8O7 - 7

- 3 "

-- / *

- ,A* <

-3 "

-5 / # %%

5 & 2 # 5 D A D " D # #

! 0 00

,%

! D

!

D

. ! 000 #

& " &#

5

D

D

" D

D

" #

5

D

D

" D

" #

#

. " .#

<

D

,& " , " # # D # D " $ # # # $ $ . 7 # !

# 2 #

0 # %%

" ! 2

#

" )

" 7 ! # ! " #&--. %%%

" &? # &

,

! !9 $ .' & %)+#

"

A 5

& 5

2 # #

# " " #

.

D

, 2 " " D

* ! !

0 / # 5

&

"

3

"

5

L 2 # D

L " D

L " D

L D

L 9

7 /

,.

7

. 7 /

"

# "

/

A

, ( , "

2

!5 ' +" ( $ -

! #

A # #

A

"

# ! !

7 6 2 " &--,

9 %%- !

#

,,

# # #

# ! ! # )

6 2 " &--,

#

7 4 " 2 &--?

! " " 5

# # #

&--+ "

< < < #

" #

< <

!8 $ - '. +%

8 #

J 7 G

# #

" "

2 ) 7 &--*

! 2 #

#

7 6 %%% #

,*

6

0 #

# ! &--- !

! # # #

A

8

" !

A #

/ A ' *

%%-A

# <

!

7 %%E

"

#

" !

# !

# %%E '

,?

# #

# A

!9 6+ $#/ )' '

7 %%E J

7 7 0 1

4 " 3 )

5

& # !

"

4 "

7

7

4

,+

5! $# &% $ +%+#

7 2

"

A

!

! #

!

"

H

#

# #

" A

#

,#&+ @

+.? 7. 2 " I. %?*7.

) # &--. A. # 2

, ,++ -?

,E

4 5

. # ! $# &% $ +%+# 6+

5! 0% (+ / %"' 6+

/ 0 B 3

" B 3

2

"

.

' 2 %&% # # 7 8

.

"

3 _!

)

3

,-.$ 5! '6' 1 " 1 $"0/$ / '",'" $ $ +"+

7 8

C

7 2 ( C7

# 6 C

!

<

' *.,< <7< %%&

!

7 ( ?%

( 0 7 ! 7 " ( ? # # 6 ) (B ) "

5!5 $"0/$ $ &' ,' "

*%

5!8 $"0/$ $ $ "' ,$

7

" / " ! #

?%

# .%

3 " .%

( "

5!9 $"0/$ +(+( "

5!9! $"0/$ +(+( $(%#+,"+:

" !

!

# " # A

7 # %%, / "

,

.$ 8! $# "'# ; $.+6 % - & +&' % $. & + " / # $ &'%'# $ -

0 $# "'# ; $.+6 % " / # - & /+"$" ,%

& 7

B '

*.,< <7< %%& 7

& &%%

< &%%

@

&%% < *%AE% @

. &%%% &

& 7.

, & &% %%%

/ ' A& A&--&A%.

3

&

%%% E

*&

5!9! $"0/$ +(+( /$%( $#($,(+ (- # % "

" !

#

" !

' A A

?

#

5

A P C

C

/ A A

5

' A P ' C

C

/ A A

A /

A

/ #

*%A&%%# 2

*%# 5 ' Q *%

2 *% K +*

+?A&%%

5!9!5 $"0/$

"

) #

*

" A

) "

A ( "

<

00 000 #

000 0H " #

000 6 )

(B - (

.( (

7 ) 6 &-+%

) 5 &

D "

!

D . "

)

# &--

7 $ %%- #

" # 5

&

" # "

)

A # A

*.

A " A

! A

2 "

# &-- # !

# A

!

! # " A

D

/

# A

!

.

#

" "

' &% @#

A )

5

7 ! "

"

"

A

7 "

&-- # !

#

" "

*,

! "

"

#

#

"

! 9

/ ! !

A

! 7 # # &

-! ' #

! !

*

.$ 9! % $ + + $#. /+ & $#, ( &

0 !

&

!

. 9

* 9

+

-#,#?#E ' A

A 5 &--.

' A !

**

!#

7 7 0 2

7 #

"

2 )

#

D

P &< &

$ 7 0 2 5

3& 3 3

3& & & 3 &< & &

&

3 &< & &< &

3&# 3 # # 3

!

= '

" 3 3

7 7 4

A 2

$ # %%- 7

A A A

A

( A

*?

" # &-- (

A 5

P

P

P A &< K

-(

$ # A

( A

!

/

#

"

' A

#

M M3# " M3

92

" " 3(

" &% %#&% &%

*+

<

8! . # ' .', "$ 0&0#

2 C 6 -E E.E#.%, ) #

" ! ? &-R A ? ,+R 6 &%? &R A &%+

&%.R " !#

# < / #

3 #

3 # 6 2

A

! 2 #

#

/ A

/ ?

# 3 # 3 " # 3 # 3 #

3 3 A

A !

#

! #

-, ,-?# E ) ?. A

!

!

" !# , E < #

,&& # &+ # .?.- (B# &, ,%. ( "

,% " C " ,%

*E

" 6 "

6 # " " 3 #

" 3 " 3 # "

" "

" 3 # #

%%?# B #

3 " C

# #

# "

%%.# %%,#

" 3 #

, E <

8! . # ' $,$ /'/'% .', "$ 0&0#

%%+ " , *& E.E

&%#. @ C

< C

#

# "

3 +, &&&

# " %* *?E # " 3 % -?,

# " 4 * +E% # " 3 & - *?*

" 3 &+% & . #

" #

3 # # 3 "

# A

&,#&E <) # "

.#%? <) #

+E#?% <) " 3

*-A "

C

& % , -,, #

#

A A ,A* <

/ "

# A.

8!5 $# &% " $# ) $ &$ 0 $ - , )

B

' && %%E

# 3

6 /

7 %%+

# # # # #

#

& # . #

, # E * /

5

D

?%

& D

/ D

. D

" 6 # 5

& 6 D

D

6 # 5

& D

D

( # 5

& ( D

( D

! # 5

& D

D

/

C !

" 8

?&

. # 5! "#'%"'# #& +( (+ + ( $.$#(+) / $#"

$ 5

&

# #

! # 5

#

D

# # D

/

0 '4 '0 0 60'4 /'4 '

0 '4 9 9( 0) ' 60'4 /'4 '

0 '4 (9 6 79

0 '4 9( 7 ' ' '

97 7 '

9 0 '0 0 0( 607 )

9 0 96 1 ' ' 9 9( 0) '

9 0 9'49' 60 ' (9 6 79

9 0 9'49686 ' 9( 7 ' '

9 0 '0 0 0( 9( 0)

9 0 9'49686 ' 7 )

9 0 9' '

(9 6 79

9 0 9'49686 '

97 7 '

9687 8

C '

?

# #

D

!

!

! 5

D

# D

D

D

D

# 2

!

5

D

/ D

7 A

. 6

! 5

D

!

6 5

?.

7 A

6

, 6

#

! S 5

D

!

6 +

5

D

7 A

6

* (

! 5

D

!

( 5

D

7 A

(

?

! S 5

?,

!

5

D

7 A

+ /

/

6

/

* /

# / 0 B 3 # / 00 B C # / 000

B 3 # / 0H B 6 / H B / 0

B 3 " 3 # 3 # #

# 4

/ #

#

/ ! 5

/ D

# 0 6 0 6 #

D

"

# 0 6 0 6 # D

# ! #

D

D

?*

D

C <

? 5

.$ =! $"'& ( ,$# (+0 $#( , ) .', "$ 0&0#

0 # + ' ) 0# & ; )'

9 = > ? @

& ,& ,, ,? *% ??

&?, &+? &+? %% ?,

5 # %&%

+ 5

.$ >! # $ /'%' & $ - $#( , )

# + / <

%%* %%? %%+ %%E

%%-& - .- , ,, ,+ ?.

. - . .

. # &A. 7. ?* +& +. E* -%

, ! & 7. & & &, &E &E

* % ' & & & & &

? & & & & &

+ # C %#? ) & & & A A

E B # %#* ) & & & A A

- ( # - ) & & & & A

&% 4 # % ) & & & & &

&& ' ,% ) A A A A A

??

.$ ?! " ' ) $ /'/'% / + .' , ) .', "$ 0&0#

0 # + 9 = > ? @

& C . +%% %+ , &* ,.? , *& E.E , .,% E.E , ,++ -?

C

7.<

! "

,

7.<

!# # !"

5

8!8 0 /+(+ ' + &%' & +/',

?

# 3 # 3 " # 3 # 3 #

3 3 A

A !

#

!

'

' 7 6 76

8 # 38 # # $ # T # ! $ " #

3 3 ) 7

? " 5 3 # 3 # 4 #

# 3 3

76

8!9 .-$% $"#+.'(+ $ - $#( , ) / $.$#(+)

' % %%E (

<

<

<

# # 2 # #

?+

# 5

# D

# D

" < D

D

# #

< 2 A 2 !

# 5

( D

( D

" 0 # # D

# # < D

< 2 A 2 !

!

A

<

-.$ @! "#'%"'# / $( # - #+: ' "'% $ +( $ - $ & .+ 1 $ & &%'" / $ .' & , ) #+

0 ' ( &' #+: $"#+.'(+ ,;.'

& & 7 < +% 7 % %%%#%%

+& 7 < &%* 7 * %%%#%%

. &%? 7 < %% 7 + *%%#%%

, %& 7 < .%% 7 .% %%%#%%

* M.%& 7 ,% %%%#%%

?E

.$ ! "#'%"'# / $( # - #+: ' "'% $ +( $ - $ & .+ 1 $ & &%'" / $ .' & , ) + &&'

0 "$&0#+ ' ( &'

# % <0 ' $ , )

5

; #+

#+: ,; '

& ( ' N & & < +% +& < %%

%& < .%% M .%% A A A A A A A A A A , %%%#%% ? %%%#%% &* %%%#%% &+ %%%#%% % %%%#%% ( 6

& < .* .? < ,* ,? < +%

A A A A A A , %%%#%% ? %%%#%% + %%%#%% 7

& < .* .? < ,* ,? < +% +& < &%* &%? < %% M %& A A A A A A A A A A A A + *%%#%% &% %%%#%% & *%%#%% &* %%%#%% &+ *%%#%% % %%%#%% " 7 & < .*

.? < ,* ,? < +% +& < &%* &%? < %%

%& < .%% M .%& A A A A A A A A A A A A A A &% %%%#%% & *%%#%% &+ *%%#%% % %%%#%% + %%%#%% .% %%%#%% . *%%#%%

0 # ( #

) 7 A A A A A A < &* M &* < % M % < * M * < .% M.% < .* M.* A A A A A A

& * %%%#%% &*% %%%#%% &+* %%%#%% %% %%%#%% * %%%#%% .*% %%%#%%

3 # #

( <( 7 A A A A A A N %#*& %#*& < %#+* M %#+*

% %%%#%% .% %%%#%% *% %%%#%%

?-.$ ! "#'%"'# / $( # - #+: ' "'% $ +( $ - $ & .+ 1 $ & &%'" / $ .' & , ) ' "'% $&+ "

$# ; $B$ "A$B$ " + - - & .$#(+: " + (+/$ "+

0 # % <0 ' $ #+: ,

& < &* < . 7.< M . 7. < ? 7.<

&*% %%%#%% %% %%%#%% M &* < % < . 7.<

M . 7. < ? 7.<

&+* %%%#%% *% %%%#%%

. M % < * < . 7.<

M . 7. < ? 7.<

%% %%%#%% .%% %%%#%%

, M * < .% < 7.<

M . 7. < ? 7.<

* %%%#%% .*% %%%#%%

* M .% < .* < 7.<

M . 7. < ? 7.<

*% %%%#%% ,%% %%%#%%

? M .* < 7.<

M . 7. < ? 7.<

+* %%%#%% ,*% %%%#%%

5 ' % %%E

!

< ( .% %%%#%% <7.#

!

+&

<

9! $# &% " '%' / $# "'#

9! ! $.+6 % (+0 $ &$ 0 , )

E) & / A/ ' ( 0

&-,*

/ A/

)

"

7 ' .E %%+

/ # 2

< #

' ,& %%+ 8 #

/

#

.E %%+ ,& %%+

7 %%%

7 * + 7 4

7 4

" +%@

%&* 7 4

0 7 /

' &< ( <7< %%? '

' A ' A

+

#

" %&% 5 "

# "

% @# " "

?% @ # "

# "

/

# / " #

" # "

) "

#

" ,# &+ @

" / 4

5

& / A/ ' &E %%E D

7 ( ' ., %%?

/ # /

/ D

. '0 ' &-A ,*,A %% 3

D

, '0 7A.?A&--&A%. 7 3

/ A ' &E %%E

5

D D < "

+.

# # < !

9! ! $.+6 % $ &$ 0 , ) /+ .', "$ 0&0#

( " C 7 ( C7

%%EA %&.

5

7 A. ( C7 7 0 !

"

7 . "

! 5 7

"

#

.A( . P D

. P D . P D

( B

6 #

( " %%.A

%%E 7 *#

A #

4 " 3

+,

( '

"

( %%.A %%E

( C7 %%EA %&.

" %&. .&

@ .& @

?-@

!

5

& ' E %%? / D

' && %%E D

. ' &- %%E ( " (

B D

, ' % %%E (

<

* ' ?, %%E 8

/ /

? ' ,%

%%-' ?, %%E 8 /

/

<

+*

#

) A C R

A

' E %%?#

#

)

" #

( " ( B

' &- %%E

( "

5

& B 4 " 3 # 4

" # 3 "

3

B 3 4 "

( "

. B ' "

" C

/ A

+?

" A

6

#

!

!

7

!

"

'

#

/ A/

' &E %%E / A/

9! (,$% $ .+

-"

2 #

# #

++

(

%%- ( , * ,,% *E*#%%

( &? %& E%. ??%#%% #

# #

9!5 $% +( ,$# (+0 9!5! + .' ( , )

! "

# #

# # " # A &

.$ ! 0 ,0(+(+ :+(+% ( , ) /+ .', "$ 0&0#

0 ,0(+(+ " C # "

+ #,- @ +#-+ @

#?* @

< *#,% @

< &#,+ @

*#?+ @

6 &#.+ @

4 < " &#*% @

6 A # # &#,E @

0 " D

?%#% @ &%#*- @

' & + # " <

5 # %%E

#

7 / &--, #

#

5

& 5 A #* < < %#,A%#*

< <

< " 5 &#*A < < %#.A%#,

+E

%%-" , ,++ -?

,.. +%+ .? " ,% "

" 3

+, &&& # &?% # 4 E? &--3 &+* -E& "

"

. -%?

A < <

E -** 7.<

,.. +%+

, E?+

/ B 3 & %-E ?,+

&-+#. 7.<

" < / B 3

+-.$ 5! #0/'%(+; + .' ( , ) /+ + - ) +.+ 0 &

'8 < C

C

6

7 C < 7

7.<

& . , * ?

& . , * ? + E -&% && &

93 30 0'8'4

' ' 7 3 ( ) C 3 3 &? ,%, . %*, && *

& % & - E.? +? - -&? & &*.

% +& +% . & & .E% * + ,#%, .#?, #* ,#+& *# & ,#?-.# * #%+ #?, ,# * &+#&% .#,& , %?% ? .., , ,?* , ,?. * + + , +*% . %*& * E+& + ?+E &? *,? + , + .-E . #E& ,?#&& #*% , #%, *-#?+ ,,#** &-#E. ,#.& ,%#*, &,%#?, ,#+? ,#.& & . , * ? + E

-93 8C8'449 9 3 B C B ( ( %*, && ?*? %?E ,, ++? &* %E+ &+ ?%+ ., *E* . + %--*# * &#+. &#E& #+* .#*% #.* .#&* #,E ,#?E & +? & E* , &EE + ,E, E %,, ,& &,? & -%E . -, ,,#&& .#.& ,,#&, E-#** .%#&+ .*# & ?-#&-?,#,* ,,# % 3 & . , * ? + E -&%

93 4/'/'4 / (0

4 / ' 3 " B 3 / ' 3 --E ? -? ,, &?E &E &.-.. ,?-.& *.+ &, .--&* *?? .& -+* ,+ ?* .#%+ .#%-,#,% ?#+. ?#*? ?#+% ?#* *#E, E#? ,#+E + ,-& E *&% &% %.E ?-* * &%& , +%+ %E ??* . +%-- +%--?+%-- -?-,?#%% * #*-EE#., .?# E ?+#%+ ?.#%+ E#E% .&#&. ?.#-* -*#.% & . , * ? + E -&%

93 / ( C

3 3 ' 3 3 C 3 3

, , & + ?, - E. ? &+* && *, . &*, +?, - *,+ &* + &

& +%-&#*, # . .#&. &#E. .#.+ .#?* .#&? #&* &#.* ,#,% E+& . *+ . &,& . .+, . , * ? .,, + %, , ,,% && ?,* , -., E#E, &,#*. &-#?? & #.* .#%E ,?#.& ,*#*. &-#%-.&#,, ,.#, 9 & . , * ? + E

-93 30 9/(9/ 6

4 3

&, E%* && * & &- %-? && &E, &? ..& & &. &+ %%+ &E ++* & E..

#E # . #.-&#&* #*, #+? .#&& &#&* &#** * *% * &?? + --% - + * ? ,.% , , * * ,?E &? . ? E ?.

E%

.$ 5! 6'"

& . , * ?

$ & . , * ?

93 ' 7 '4

7 3 3 * ,, * ?,* ? *&& , *&-&, ,* &, &&-,#E, #.. .#,* #%& ,#&% .#,+ & %E. , . & EE+ ,E . ,+, , %?- &%#,&&# -&.#% -#%, E#,-E# ,

& %-E ?,+ %E# * &+#

-5 %%- )

9!5! $7 / )

# # # 5 7 C # # "

! # C

# #

#

!

7 &--. #

# #

" # #

< # "

/ # %%

A

B 3 5

E&

#

B

" # )

#

#

#

#

2 #

)

' #

#

)

E

.

<

#

<

' #

9!5!5 $ &' ,' / $ + / )

A &7.

7 " 5

& #

3

# #

/ 3 "

#

# A

#

3

E.

#

&A-7. #

4 )

! ' #

7 ) &--* #

A # #

#

"

#

# ! #

) #

!

3

B

( 2 "

A

"

E,

A

! #

/ B 3 . &

!

" #

,

" , )

#

C

&

9!5!9 $ , " $ .' & %)+#

4 " 3 4

&-E+

#

' ?*E&<, < <) < %%E

? %%E

E*

? %&&

6 4

- )

- )

&& ) #

% )

4

4

/ /

A A

"

( '

6 ' "

" ,% ) ' !

#

4 C # # B B '

?*E &< <' <)/ < %%- - C

%%-( #

" '

%%% E%% 7.< '

" %&

9!8 +(+( + $#6 $ &$ 0 , ) .$#/ ( #% " / # 0# "+:

" !

/ #

E?

2

" / B 3 #

B 3 .

& 2 + 7.

A &

" .* 3

4 " #

#

A .,+ 7.

&,

.$ 8! ' ) , ) $# &%'" $ /+ + - ) +.+ 0 &

C ( < H

7.

H

7.

H

7.

.. &#* + .,+ &+#

-5

#

/ B 3

#

7

B ' *.,< <7< %%& 7

E+

#

!

&*

.$ 9! ' ) $ /'/'%1 <0 ' $ , ) / $#%+# <0 ' $ $ - , ) .$#/ ( #% $"$ "' / $,'"'(

$ "$#+ $# '%+ / # ( # + - ) 0!

958; ; ;

' " C

C

H

7.

6

) C <) @

H 6 7.<

& 3 +, &&& *,E# * +*. ,E E% &- E-

&?% ,,,#. ++% E% E% &++ + E .**

. 4 E? &-- *+ #,% * ?.& *& E% E -*- ,*E

, &. & - ?,# ? ?E& ,- E% &%* +%. &&

* 3 &.. +?* ?+#*. %+% ?* E% &%+ %& &,

? 7

*% E. &%%#*+ % % * *% * &, *%

C & %-E ?,+ &-+# - % - * E?. E.. & + E

5 )

&* #

A " &%% <

7 B ' *.,< <7< %%&

*% @ E% @ /

" ! " #

3 # 4 # 3

E%@ # "

! 7

*% @

#

& + E 7.< " #

EE

#

& +?. 7.< /

B 3 .,+ 7.< #

,- 7.< .-? 7.<

& +?. 7.< #

B 3 .-?<& +?.Q &%% @ P ,? @

# " !

B 3 " ,?@

#

# #

.,+ 7.

.,+ Q &%%% < P &+. *%%

&+. *%%<& %-E ?,+ = &%% @ P &? @

B 3

9!9 +(+( $.'"') # / # ( # $ &$ 0 , )

7 B '

*.,< <7< %%& 7 #

&%%% & & 7.# &

&% %%% # ! .% %%%

5

& &%%% &

& %-E ?,+ &

%--*%

E-&% %%% & #

& %-E ?,+ &&% 9

3 . & #

" .% @

& + E 7.#

& + E<+<& * P &?* " % @

7 / &--& #

%%%

A E

*

&- + -

E+-&. #

" &* @

' -%%<*& < <) < %%- ) #

# C # 7 #

#

E *

( + E & %%% %%%#%% &?*

( & ? *%%#%%

&. ( .E E% %%% %%%#%%

&.

&?*

( *E + . *%% %%%#%% &?

/ %%-#

/

&? ?? (

-%

( &% ,,? -.E %%%#%%

.$ =! %$ #+0 $#%+# + - ' "'% $ $ ')+ D $.'"') # ,$# (+0 $ & &%'" , ) /+ + - ) +.+ 0 &

0 # + <0 ' $ + - , ' ) ,

5 E 8

5 8 9

& + 7. &. -% %%% %%%#%% .E E% %%% %%%#%%

&?* .? %%% %%%#%% ? ?E *%% %%%#%%

. 7 &?* ,% *%% %%%#%% * -,% %%% %%%#%%

, &?* Q & -*% %%%#%% & EE& %%% %%%#%%

* <C ??% Q & +*% %%%#%% * -,% %%% %%%#%%

0" , 9?!> 5!9 ! 1

5 ' -%%<*& < <) < %%- )

" &%% @

"

!

# !

#

"

9!= $#($,(+ (- # % " "$#) / , $ - $.$#(+) ; $#( , ) /+ + &%' & $#' )

/

-&

" .% 3

" # ?%

9!=! # %"$#+("+% '(+ #$(,0 /$

&+ 5

.$ >! +("#+.'(+ #$%'$ (+ (+

/ $

!

% < .% ? &% &%

6 .% A,% , ,% *%

6 ,% K *% &, . +.

6 *% &? + &%%

?% &%%

5 )

# .% ,%

,% @# ,% *%

*%

9!=! # %"$#+("+% $ /+/+% $(,0 /$

7

# &E

.$ ?! +("#+.'(+ #$%'$ (+ + &% " $ /+/+% $

!

7 && &E &E

7/< .& * +%

&% &+ E+

& ? &% -+

7 . &%%

?% &%%

5 )

!

6 * @#

.% @ 6 &E @ #

"

-9!=!5 # %"$#+("+% $%$#6 $(,0 /$

&-.$ @! +("#+.'(+ #$%'$ (+ $ +( $%$#6

$ !

' < '0 < 86(0 &E .% .%

, + .+

&& &E **

B & % +*

0 ( &* * &%%

?% &%%

5 )

&-#

' < '0< 86(0 .% @ * @

A

% @ &E @ C

" !

9!=!8 $ &'%'# /$%( $#($,(+ (- # % "

'

A A

? #

5

A P C P & P % &+

C ?

/ ( # A A

-.

.$ ! + + /$%( 7 .

' ' ( A ' ( A

' A

Q % &+

& .* .% & &+ % %

.% .% & %% % &+

. .. .% & &% %

&-, ?% .% %% % .,

* .% .% & %% % &+

? . .% & %+ % &E

' & *

5 ) # %&%

# & A / .*# .%# ..# ?%#.% . A

A .% ' A

' A

A

A % &+ ' & *

A

' & *

2 *%

? * 2 ? *

(

/ 3 # A A

-,

.$ ! /$%( # " A# " 6 7 .

' ' ( A ' ( A

' A

Q % &+

& , .% & ,% % ,

*, .% & E% % .&

. ,, .% & ,+ % *

, ?% .% %% % .,

* ?% .% %% % .,

? .. .% & %% %

&-' & ??

5) # %&%

/ , #

*,# ,,# ?%# ?% ..

A

A

.% ' A

' A

A A % &+ '

& ?? A

' 2

*% E. %

2 E.

3 "

A + #+?

9!=!9 :0# (+ $ &$ + ,$# "'# ,$#( , )

( !

* &? @

* E, @ /

-*

&

,% @

9!=!= # / # ( # ,$ - ,$#( , )

( -+ @

-" # . @ &

" / 3 E% @

" # % @ "

9!=!> $,' ( (- # % " "$#) / , ,$ - %$.$#(+) ;,$#( , )

( -% @

&% @ "

3 *. @ ,+ @

" + @

E @

9!=!? $"#+.'(+ ,$ - ,$#( , )

( ( . %%%#A<

/ 3

( *%%%#A< 7

< (

& 7 < .* 7

' % %%E (

< # (

, %%%#A< 3

& < .* 7 #

' % %%E ! ( + *%%#A

-?

9!=!@ $ .$/ $7 / )

3

(

3 -% @

# &% @

9!> $# $#" (- # % " / $ &$ 0 , )

# B 3 / ! ! " 3

B ( * (B &, ' .

3 ( , ( & (

" .(

. . . .7 7 # 7 #

7 . "

# " . A # " # ! # " # %%+

" ( * ' .

#

%%E 2

C " " # , # . #

-+

.

& B

? %%% #

( ( *

&%. ? %%%

?&E %%%

?%%

$ ) & & %%% #

?%%

?%% %%%

E-- %%%

# #

/

< #

A #

/ ( .( ( , (B &

. B ( , #

"

#

" #

" .(

.( 5& 7

#

.(# . "

--<

=! $#' '( "$# "+: "# "$&+ / #0&#

/ !

)

, ( !

7

6 & A

, ,

) "

)

5&

# / # .

7 ) ! A! !

# <

/ A

2

7

#

) A

"

&%%

A

.$ ! "#'%"'# +# #%+ $ + &% " %', $ - , ) $#' ) /+ .', "$ 0&0#

$B$ $B$ $B$ 5 $B$ 8

'6' $.+6 % "# "$&+(

%"0# $ /'%' & &% ) "# "$&+(

3

!

"

#

#

# $

%

&

'(

# )

( (

=! ! +(+( #+0#+" ( $ &$ . & $.+6 %

#

A 6

( "

#

6 )

&%&

(B .(

( #

.( 7

) " "

A

A < A

) 6

)

6 .

#

" "

#

%#,*%# /

%# &* 7 %#..*

"

7

"

3 &#%% %#,*% < %# &* 7 %#..* < 8 %# ,? 8 9 %#&%, %#&?- %#%*-%#%,* %#%.E 0 %#&%? %#&&% 0 %#%. 0 < %#%+, < %#%?. %#%,+ .( %# +& ( %#%?, 9 %#& + %#%-, 0 ! ! %#%*& ! %#%.+ %#% + ! %#&%% # %#%? 6 B %# %.E %#%.-E ,

=! ! $ + &% " # $ -

#

< 8

%#*,E# 8 9

%# .%# ! %# 4 *

< 8

"

5 8 ) %%%

. # 9! # :+% #+0#+" ( (,$% - & +,$#"+ . &% , / $.+6 % $ + &% " # $ -

< 8 # A

%#?E+

%#&*+

%#&*? / A

< 4 ?

&%,

5 8 ) %%%

. # =! # :+% #+0#+" ( &% ) "# "$&+( , / (,$% $ . ) ; $#. +% # ,$# (+0

" #

8 9 #

%#*?*

%#,.* 4 + #

4 /

/

4

. # >! # :+% #+0#+" ( &% ) "# "$&+( , / (,$% ,"+ +( (+ %(+("+ &

!#

#

&%*

%#?

%#.+E 4 E )

"

5 8 ) %%%

. # ?! # :+% #+0#+" ( &% ) "# "$&+( , / (,$% $ -$/+ "$# "+:

"

#

A

< #

&%?

.$ 5! #'" $ $ - & +,#+0#+" (% $3 # 0. / $ + &% " # $ -

#'" $ $ $B$ 0.0"

#+0#+" (

& %#,*%

& < 8 . %# ,?

8 9 . %#&%,

. ! . %#&%%

& ,

%#&?-B # # , %#%?

. ,

%#%*-, , %#%,*

* ,

%#%.-? , % %.E

+ 6

B

, %#%.E

5

=! ! $ + &% " $# (- # % "

#

.(

%#E%-( %#&-& 4 -

! 7

.(

(

5 8 ) %%%

. # @! # :+% #+0#+" ( (,$% - & +,$#"+ . &% , / $.+6 % "# "$&+ $ + &% " $# (- # % "

.(

/ A

&%+

9

%#,?E # %#.,*

0 ! ! %#&E+ 4 &%

.(

9 #

! /

.(

A

.(

5 8 ) %%%

. # ! # :+% #+0#+" ( &% ) "# "$&+( , / (,$% $ $# , 5

( #

! (

%#*E B %#,&E 4

&& !

&%E

5 8 ) %%%

. # ! # :+% #+0#+" ( &% ) "# "$&+( , / (,$% $" " $ . - # $"#+.'(+

"

#

7

9 ,

"

.$ 8! #'" $ $ - & /+,#+0#+" (% ($3 # 0. / $ + &% " $# (- # % "!

/ 9 6 2

7 %#..*

& .( . %# +&

( . %#%?,

& 9 , %#& +

, %#%-,

. 0 ! ! , %#%*&

, ! ( , %#%.+

* B , %#% +

5

2 A

" 3

%#&?- # 9

.( %#& + %#

&%-.$ 9! #'" #+0#+" ( 0. #0&# $ + &% " %', $ - , ) $#' ) /+ .', "$ 0&0#

#'" &% ) "# "$&+(; #0&# 0.0" #+0#+" (

&

%#&?-9 .( %#& +

. %#%-,

, 0 %#%+,

* < %#%?.

? B # # %#%?

+

%#%*-E 0 ! ! %#%*&

- 8 %#%,+

&% %#%,*

&&

%#%.-& ! ( %#%.+

&. %#%.E

&, 6 / B %#%.E

&* 0 7 %#%.

&? B %#% +

' ) 1

5

/

( ) ' , "

! 4 !

&&%

5 8 ) %%%

. # ! # :+% (+ + "$(+( $ &&' % 0/'( + "$(+( +("#+.'(+

=!5 $# 3 & #0&#

) " 2

"

5

&

/ / B 3

.. &?*

7

&&&

( .E E% %%% %%%#%% / E *

( + E & %%% %%%#%%

&?* (

& ? *%% %%%#%%

&. &?*

( *E + . *%% %%%#%%

/ %%-#

/ &?

?? ( && E * %%% %%%#%%

!

7 2

" 2 ) )

! A! !

3

%&. ( C7

.& @# / B 3

.& @ *&

/ &E

( && *.E -%% %%%#%%

? ?- @

! #

&&

.$ =! %$ #+0 $#%+# + - ' "'% $ $ ')+ 5 D $.'"') # ,$# (+0 $ & &%'" , ) /+ + - ) +.+ 0 &

0 # + <0 ' $ + - , ' ) ,

5 E 8

5 8 9

& +7. _{&E -% %%% %%%#%% * % %%% %%%#%%}

*& .? %%% %%%#%% _{& E.? %%% %%%#%%}

. 7 *& ,% *%% %%%#%% _{%?* *%% %%%#%%}

, *& Q & -*% %%%#%% *E& ,%% %%%#%%

* <C %, Q & +*% %%%#%% & E.? %%% %%%#%%

0" , !95?!@ ! 1

5 ' -%%<*& < <) < %%- )

.( 5

9 .(

/ " / B

&&.

/

" .(

.(

" " # # # #

.(

7

.(

' 7 '

7

.(

" ! #

<

.( 2

<

.(

.(

) .(

.( /

#

/ " 7 #

&&,

#

. !

!

! #

!

'

&&*

<

>! $(+ ,'

A #

5

& " ! B

3 C "

#,? @ )

#

#

" &?@ C

% @

?#* @

#

. )

%#&?- #

.( %#& +

.( %#%-,

# #

8 !

&&?

5 & D

.(D . ,

>! #

#

A 5

& &E / B 3

.& @

!

# !

'

#

!

. 7

" ! #

, 7 #

.(

2

* .(#

# ' 7

' 7

? !

&&+

: # &--% $ 2 7 B # C

/ &--% - - )

3 )4$ 4 567 8987 1 6 7 #

UUUUUUUU &--, *

-& ) 3 )4$ 567:6;875668 1 6 7 #

UUUUUUUU &--, - 2 - )

3)&)4$7 :7: 8575668 1 6 7 #

( 0 &-E+ % ) )

# C

# ( &--+ ) ) & )

& 1 & % V W " 0 #

3 &--.

-< (&

,# C # /

9 # %%- ) - )

* &$ = V W " 0 #

$ # %%- - & *

( , " 0 #

) # &-E. / ) # 1 0 #

C

) # 8 &--. > ) *

- 2 6 #

0 %%, ) * - < ) &

7 B /' 0 #

# ( # %%+ ) . )

- ) ) #

# ( C %%. * ! . $ /

# 1

&&E

7 %%, * 3 ) #

C

7 # # 4 &-E+ / 2

* ) # C

7 # %%E ) & %

* * ! 0 1 - + &

& % V W " 0 #

# %%? * & / 3

-( ! # C

%%E 4 - ?

. @&

%%- 4 A - 6

. = * (. =*,

& % - ? B 5:

%%- & % % 4

6 @95 @& @ @ 6 ) % !

= ) *

- &

%&% & %

- 6

# &-- / 2 0 # C

( 0 %%E > 7> 4 5? - ?

)

( 0 %%- > 7> 4 9 - 6

( 0 %%- > 7> 4 : - 6

2

# %%, 2 9 # C

# C %%E . / 3 - & !

$ # C

# C %%% & 2 4 7 / 2 #

1

%%- * ) & # C

&&-" # &--. $ ) 1 734 A)

0 9 # ' 1

# &--? * ! = # 1

&--+ % & ! * 2 C & / >

* & ! 4 2 # C

B # %% * * * )

& %

105

Lampiran 1. Model Kuesioner AHP yang Digunakan Untuk Mencapai Tujuan Peningkatan

Cakupan Pelayanan Sampah Perumahan

LATAR BELAKANG

PETUNJUK PENGISIAN

!

" #$ % # & '& "

9 8 7 5 4 3 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

√ √

√

( ) % *lebih penting

+

&!&,&-K U E S I O N E R

* *# * * ) % % * .* ) # ) ) & #

* ) # # ) #

' % ) % / 0 * 1 / 2 # . *

) # # * . 34 5 * * #* 4 & * *% *

* 6 * 7 44, % %

% % % # 0 8 2

" * ) # ) % ) * % * # # *

' % * ! 5 * # * # ) , . !4 . *

' % % * # # % ) # . ) % . !4 5

' * # * ) % * * % % * * *

) % % * * * ) % . * ) # * #

* ' % ) % %* # 2 #

% %%*

% *

% * %

. % 0√₂

) 9

# '

# "

* & # *

% ) % % %

% ) %

* sangat penting

# % %

% ) % * $

7 % % * ( ) % %

: % )

( ) % *sedikit lebih penting * sama penting )

* %

. % % # %

# ) % %

106

LEVEL PERTAMA: Tujuan

LEVEL KEDUA: Pilihan Alternatif Kebijakan

9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

LEVEL KETIGA A: Faktor Pendukung

6 * * * % ) 9 & * * # 9 89 ) %

% *# )

7* % % # # ; % * * ) % % & %

* ) & % * %

# < < 7 ( % ) 7 9 Pertanyaan:

7* % % # # ; % * * ) % % & %

* ) & % * %

7* * * % # # * * * % % . * )

# % # * * ' % =>

' # # 9 89 % * % % ) % % *# % &

9 % ) % * % % # & ) *$ 2 % ) ? 2

% % * 6 # ? 2 % )

% % * 6 # % ) % )

* * & % % ) # * &alternatif kebijakan ) %

=

Alternatif Kebijakan Bobot Alternatif Kebijakan

107

9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

LEVEL KEEMPAT A: Sub Faktor Pendukung

9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

7* % % # # ; % * * ) % % & %

* ) & % * %

# % * % * # 7 % * # ' 7 Optimalisasi TPA Eksisting % 7 * % % # # Peningkatan Sarana Pelayanan Peningkatan Sarana Pelayanan Pertanyaan:

* * & % Optimalisasi TPA Eksisting * 9 * * % ) %

* * % = Optimalisasi TPA Eksisting Bobot # % * % * Pertanyaan: # <

6 * % 9 * * %& * * % %

* 9 ) % % *# )

# <

Bobot

* * & % Peningkatan SaranaPelayanan 9 * * % ) %

* * % = # ' 7 # % * < 7 ( % < 7 ( % ) 7 9 ) 7 9 Penambahan /Perbaikan Sarana Pelayanan Sampah Bobot Penambahan /Perbaikan Sarana Pelayanan Sampah * * & % Penambahan/Perbaikan sarana pelayanan sampah & * 9 * * %

108

9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

LEVEL KETIGA B: Faktor Pendukung

9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

LEVEL KEEMPAT B: Sub Faktor Pendukung

9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Pertanyaan:

Bobot _Peningkatan

Kerjasama dengan dunia Usaha/Swasta * * & % Peningkatan Kerjasama dengan Dunia Usaha/Swasta & * 9 * * %

) % * * % =

7 @ ) #

0' & 7 % # 7 * 2

7 %

* * * ) #

* * & % % % Kerjasama dengan Pengembang * 9 * * %

) % = Kerjasama dengan industri Bobot : * % % Peningkatan Kerjasama dengan dunia Usaha/Swasta

6 * * * % ) 9 & * * % 9 89 ) %

% *# ) Pertanyaan:

* * & % Penyediaan TPA Alternatif9 * * % ) %

* * % =

Pertanyaan:

6 * % 9 * * %& * * % %

* 9 ) % % *# )

* * & % % % Kerjasama dengan Industri * 9 * * % ) %

* % =

Penyediaan TPA/TPS Alternatif

Bobot Penyediaan TPA/TPS

Alternatif Kerjasama dengan industri Kerjasama dengan Pengembang Bobot Kerjasama dengan Pengembang ) # %* * ) % % # # % * % * # : * % #

# 0 # %

' # * ' #

' 2

: * ) % %

109

LEVEL KETIGA C: Faktor Pendukung

9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

LEVEL KEEMPAT C: Sub Faktor Pendukung

9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Contact Person: Purristiyana04- -+-,!!+2

6 * % 9 * * %& * * % %

* 9 ) % % *# )

( * ' *

%

6 * * * % ) 9 & * * % 9 89 ) %

% *# )

* * & % Peningkatan Peran Masyarakat& 9 * * % ) % * *

% =

Pertanyaan:

Bobot

7* % % # # ; % * * ) % % & %

* ) & % * %

Pertanyaan:

* * & % Penerapan 3R& * 9 * * % ) % * *

% =

Peningkatan Peran Masyarakat

)

* #

: 9 9

Peningkatan Peran Masyarakat

Terimakasih

: 9 9 ( *

Pertanyaan:

* * & % Ketaatan Pembayaran Retribusi Sampah& * 9 * * % ) %

* * % =

Penerapan 3 R

Bobot

Penerapan 3 R

* 9 * * ) ( * ' * % ' * %

: 9 9

Ketaatan Pembayaran Retribusi Sampah

110

111

Lampiran 2. Matriks Persepsi Masing-masing Responden dan Perhitungan Pendapat Gabungan Menggunakan Rata-rata Geometris

Level 1. Kebijakan Strategis

Matriks

Pilihan A1 A2 A3 Keterangan

A1 1 1 2 A1 = Peningkatan Sarana Pelayanan

A2 1/ 1 1 3 A2 = Peningkatan Kerjasama dengan Dunia usaha

A3 1/ 2 1/ 3 1 A3 = Peningkatan Peran Masyarakat

Responden 1 Responden 2 Responden 3

Pilihan A1 A2 A3 Pilihan A1 A2 A3 Pilihan A1 A2 A3

A1 1 0.25 3 A1 1 8 3 A1 1 0.5 0.2

A2 4 1 5 A2 0.13 1 0.17 A2 2 1 0.33

A3 0.33 0.20 1 A3 0.33 6 1 A3 5 3 1

Responden 4 Responden 5 Responden 6

Pilihan A1 A2 A3 Pilihan A1 A2 A3 Pilihan A1 A2 A3

A1 1 3 0.25 A1 1 6 4 A1 1 3 5

A2 0.33 1 0.17 A2 0.17 1 0.33 A2 0.33 1 3

A3 4 6 1 A3 0.25 3 1 A3 0.20 0.33 1

Rumus Rata-rata Geometris : dimana :

w = = Penilaian gabungan elemen w

= wi = Penilaian elemen w oleh responden ke-i

n = Banyaknya Responden (n = 6)

Perhitungan :

1 = 1.944dimana 1/ 1 = 0.514

2 = 1.442 1/ 2 = 0.693

3 = 0.599 1/ 3 = 1.669

Matriks dan Bobot Hasil

Pilihan A1 A2 A3 Bobot*

A1 1 1.944 1.442 0.450

A2 0.514 1 0.599 0.215

A3 0.693 1.669 1 0.335

Level 2: 1. Peningkatan Sarana Pelayanan

Matriks

Pilihan A1 B1 A1 B2 A1 B3 Keterangan :

A1 B1 1 1 2 A1 B1 = Penambahan/Perbaikan Sarana Operasional

A1B2 1/ 1 1 3 A1 B2 = Optimalisasi TPA Eksisting

A1 B3 1/ 2 1/ 3 1 A1 B3 = Penyediaan TPA Alternatif

n

wn wi

w

x

a

x

x

a

a

₁

....

6 6 5 4 3 2

1 w w w w w

w

x

a

x

a

x

a

x

a

x

a

a

6_{0.25x 8 x 0.5 x 6 x 2 x 3}

6_{5 x0.17x0.33x0.17x0.33x3}

112

Responden 1 Responden 2 Responden 3

Pilihan A1 B1 A1 B2 A1 B3 Pilihan A1 B1 A1 B2 A1 B3 Pilihan A1 B1 A1 B2 A1 B3

A₁ B₁ 1 0.20 3 A₁ B₁ 1 4 6 A₁ B₁ 1 6 3

A₁ B₂ 5 1 6 A₁ B₂ 0.25 1 4 A₁ B₂ 0.17 1 0.25

A1B3 0.33 0.17 1 A1B3 0.17 0.25 1 A1B3 0.33 4 1

Pilihan A1 B1 A1 B2 A1 B3 Pilihan A1 B1 A1 B2 A1 B3 Pilihan A1 B1 A1 B2 A1 B3

A1 B1 1 3.00 4 A1 B1 1 2 0.33 A1 B1 1 5 4

A₁ B₂ 0.33 1 2 A₁ B₂ 0.50 1 0.25 A₁ B₂ 0.20 1 0.33

A1B3 0.25 0.50 1 A1B3 3 4 1 A1B3 0.25 3 1

Perhitungan :

1 = 2.289 dimana 1/ 1 = 0.437

2 = 2.570 1/ 2 = 0.389

3 = 1 1/ 3 = 1

Matriks dan Bobot Hasil

Pilihan A1 B1 A1 B2 A1 B3 Bobot*

A1 B1 1 2.289 2.570

A1 B2 0.437 1 1.0

A1B3 0.389 1.0 1

Level 2: 2. Peningkatan Kerjasama dengan Dunia Usaha/Swasta

Matriks

Pilihan A2 B1 A2 B2 Keterangan :

A₂ B₁ 1 1 A2 B1 = Industri

A2 B2 1/ 1 1 A2 B2 = Pengembang

Responden 1 Responden 2 Responden 3

Pilihan A2 B1 A2 B2 Pilihan A2 B1 A2 B2 Pilihan A2 B1 A2 B2

A₂ B₁ 1 0.20 A₂ B₁ 1 5 A₂ B₁ 1 0.33

A2 B2 5 1 A2 B2 0.20 1 A2 B2 3 1

Responden 4 Responden 5 Responden 6

Pilihan A2 B1 A2 B2 Pilihan A2 B1 A2 B2 Pilihan A2 B1 A2 B2

A2 B1 1 3 A2 B1 1 4 A2 B1 1 0.20

A₂ B₂ 0.333 1 A₂ B₂ 0.250 1 A₂ B₂ 5 1

Perhitungan :

1 = 0.963 dimana 1/ 1 = 1.038

0.548

0.230

0.222 6

₀

.

2

x

4

x

6

x

3

x

2

x

5

6

3

x

6

x

3

x

4

x

₀

.

33

x

4

6

6

x

4

x

₀

.

25

x

1

x

₀

.

25

x

₀

.

33

113

Matriks dan bobot hasil

Pilihan A2 B1 A2 B2 Bobot*

A2 B1 1 0.963 0.491

A₂ B₂ 1.038 1 0.509

Level 2 : 3 Peningkatan Peran Masyarakat Matriks

Pilihan A₃ B₁ A₃ B₂ Keterangan :

A3B1 1 1 A3 B1 = Penerapan 3R

A3B2 1/ 1 1 A3 B2 = Ketaatan Pembayaran Retribusi Sampah

Responden 1 Responden 2 Responden 3

Pilihan A3 B1 A3 B2 Pilihan A3 B1 A3 B2 A3 B1 A3 B2

A₃B₁ 1 4 A₃ B₁ 1 5 1 4

A3B2 0.25 1 A3 B2 0.2 1 0.25 1

Responden 4 Responden 5 Responden 6

Pilihan A3 B1 A3 B2 Pilihan A3 B1 A3 B2 A3 B1 A3 B2

A3B1 1 3 A3 B1 1 4 1 6

A₃B₂ 0.33 1 A₃ B₂ 0.25 1 0.167 1

Perhitungan :

1 = 4.234 dimana 1/ 1 = 0.236

Matriks dan bobot hasil

Pilihan A₃ B₁ A₃ B₂ Bobot*

A3B1 1 4.234 0.800

A3B2 0.236 1 0.200

Level 3: 1.1 Penambahan/perbaikan sarana pelayanan

Matriks

Pilihan