ŝ
3(1*$58+&$5$%(/$-$5'$1/,1*.81*$1
.(/8$5*$7(5+$'$3+$6,/%(/$-$56,6:$
0$7$3(/$-$5$1(.2120,.(/$6;',60$
1(*(5,781-81*$1.$%83$7(1%/25$
7$+81$-$5$1
6.5,36,
8QWXN0HPSHUROHK*HODU6DUMDQD3HQGLGLNDQ 3DGD8QLYHUVLWDV1HJHUL6HPDUDQJ
2OHK 6LWL=XODLNDK 1,0
-8586$13(1',',.$1(.2120, )$.8/7$6(.2120,
ŝŝ
3(56(78-8$13(0%,0%,1*
6NULSVLLQLWHODKGLVHWXMXLROHKSHPELPELQJXQWXNGLDMXNDQNHVLGDQJSDQLWLD
XMLDQVNULSVLSDGD
+DUL 5DEX
7DQJJDO 2NWREHU
ŝŝŝ
3(1*(6$+$1.(/8/86$1
6NULSVL LQL WHODK GLSHUWDKDQNDQ GL GHSDQ 6LGDQJ 3DQLWLD 8MLDQ 6NULSVL
)DNXOWDV(NRQRPL8QLYHUVLWDV1HJHUL6HPDUDQJSDGD
+DUL 5DEX
7DQJJDO 2NWREHU
3HQJXML, 3HQJXML,, 3HQJXML,,,
3URI'U-RNR:LGRGR03G'U.DUGR\R03G'UD+DUQDQLN06L
ŝǀ
3(51<$7$$1
'HQJDQLQLVD\DPHQ\DWDNDQEDKZD\DQJWHUWXOLVGLGDODPVNULSVLLQLEHQDU
EHQDU KDVLO NDU\D VD\D VHQGLUL EXNDQ MLSODNDQ GDUL NDU\D WXOLV RUDQJ ODLQ EDLN
VHEDJLDQ DWDX VHOXUXKQ\D 3HQGDSDW DWDX WHPXDQ RUDQJ ODLQ GDODP VNULSVL LQL
GLNXWLS DWDX GLUXMXN EHUGDVDUNDQ NRGH HWLN LOPLDK $SDELOD GLNHPXGLDQ KDUL
WHUEXNWL VNULSVL LQL DGDODK KDVLO MLSODNDQ GDUL NDU\D WXOLV RUDQJ ODLQ PDND VD\D
EHUVHGLDPHQHULPDVDQNVLVHVXDLGHQJDQNHWHQWXDQ\DQJEHUODNX
6HPDUDQJ2NWREHU
6LWL=XODLNDK
ǀ
02772'$13(56(0%$+$1
0RWWR
,OPXSHQJHWDKXDQWDQSDDJDPDDGDODKSLQFDQJ(LQVWHLQ
.HEHUKDVLODQ DGDODK NHPDPSXDQ XQWXN PHOHZDWL GDQ PHQJDWDVL GDUL VXDWX
NHJDJDODQEHULNXWQ\DWDQSDKDUXVNHKLODQJDQVHPDQJDW:LVWRQ&KXFLO
3HUVHPEDKDQ
2UDQJ WXDNX WHUFLQWD \DQJ VHODOX
PHPEHULNDQ FLQWD GXNXQJDQ
VHUWDGR¶DGLVHWLDSODQJNDKNX
$OPDPDWHUNX 8QLYHUVLWDV 1HJHUL
ǀŝ 35$.$7$
3XMLV\XNXUSHQXOLVSDQMDWNDQNHKDGLUDW$OODK6:7\DQJWHODKPHPEHULNDQ
NHNXDWDQ ODKLU GDQ EDWLQ VHKLQJJD SHQXOLV PHPLOLNL NHPDPSXDQ XQWXN
PHQ\HOHVDLNDQ SHQXOLVDQ VNULSVL GHQJDQ MXGXO ³3HQJDUXK &DUD %HODMDU GDQ
/LQJNXQJDQ .HOXDUJD WHUKDGDS +DVLO %HODMDU 6LVZD 0DWD 3HODMDUDQ (NRQRPL
.HODV;GL60$1HJHUL7XQMXQJDQ.DEXSDWHQ%ORUD7DKXQ$MDUDQ´
GDODPUDQJNDPHQ\HOHVDLNDQ6WUDWDXQWXNPHPSHUROHKJHODU6DUMDQD3HQGLGLNDQ
SDGD)DNXOWDV(NRQRPL8QLYHUVLWDV1HJHUL6HPDUDQJ
3HQXOLV PHQ\DGDUL EDKZD SHQ\XVXQDQ VNULSVL LQL WLGDN OHSDV GDUL EDQWXDQ
GDQ GRURQJDQ GDUL EHUEDJDL SLKDN 2OHK NDUHQD LWX GHQJDQ NHUHQGDKDQ KDWL
SHQXOLVPHQJXFDSNDQWHULPDNDVLKNHSDGD
3URI 'U )DWKXU 5RNKPDQ 0+XP VHODNX 5HNWRU 8QLYHUVLWDV 1HJHUL
6HPDUDQJ \DQJ WHODK PHPEHULNDQ NHVHPSDWDQ SDGD SHQXOLV XQWXN
PHQ\HOHVDLNDQVWXGLGL3URJUDP6WXGL3HQGLGLNDQ.RSHUDVL
'U :DK\RQR 00 VHODNX 'HNDQ )DNXOWDV (NRQRPL \DQJ WHODK
PHPEHULNDQLMLQGDQNHVHPSDWDQXQWXNPHQJDGDNDQSHQHOLWLDQ
'U $GH 5XVWLDQD 06L VHODNX .HWXD -XUXVDQ 3HQGLGLNDQ (NRQRPL
8QLYHUVLWDV1HJHUL6HPDUDQJ\DQJWHODKPHPEHULNDQEDQWXDQGDODPSURVHV
LMLQSHQHOLWLDQ
'UD +DUQDQLN 06L VHODNX 'RVHQ 3HPELPELQJ \DQJ WHODK EDQ\DN
PHPEDQWXPHQJDUDKNDQGDQPHPELPELQJSHQXOLVVHKLQJJDSHQXOLVGDSDW
ǀŝŝ
3URI 'U -RNR :LGRGR 03G VHODNX 'RVHQ 3HQJXML \DQJ WHODK
PHPEHULNDQELPELQJDQVHUWDDUDKDQGDODPPHQ\HPSXUQDNDQVNULSVLLQL
'U .DUGR\R 03G VHODNX 'RVHQ 3HQJXML \DQJ WHODK PHPEHULNDQ
ELPELQJDQSHWXQMXNGDQVDUDQ\DQJVDQJDWEHUPDQIDDWVHODPDSHQ\XVXQDQ
VNULSVLLQL
%DSDN,EX GRVHQ GDQ VHOXUXK VWDII )DNXOWDV (NRQRPL 8QLYHUVLWDV 1HJHUL
6HPDUDQJ \DQJ WHODK PHPEHULNDQ EHNDO LOPX \DQJ WDN WHUQLODL KDUJDQ\D
VHODPDSHQXOLVPHQHPSXKSHQGLGLNDQGL8QLYHUVLWDV
'UV %DPEDQJ -XOLDQWR 03G VHODNX .HSDOD 60$ 1HJHUL 7XQMXQJDQ
.DEXSDWHQ %ORUD EHVHUWD VWDII \DQJ WHODK PHPEHULNDQ LMLQ GDQ EDQWXDQ
NHSDGDSHQXOLVXQWXNPHODNXNDQSHQHOLWLDQ
'UD 1XUODHOD $ VHODNX JXUX 0DWD 3HODMDUDQ (NRQRPL \DQJ WHODK
PHPELPELQJVHODPDSHQHOLWLDQEHUODQJVXQJ
6LVZDVLVZL 60$ 1HJHUL 7XQMXQJDQ .DEXSDWHQ %ORUD \DQJ WHODK
PHPEHULNDQEDQWXDQGDODPSHODNVDQDDQSHQHOLWLDQ
2UDQJWXDNXWHUFLQWD\DQJWHODKPHPEHULNDQSHUKDWLDQGR¶DVHUWDVHPDQJDW
6HPXD SLKDN \DQJ WLGDN GDSDW SHQXOLV VHEXWNDQ VDWX SHU VDWX \DQJ WHODK
PHPEDQWXGDODPSHQ\HOHVDLDQVNULSVLLQL
6HPRJD $OODK 6:7 PHOLPSDKNDQ VHJDOD UDKPDW GDQ NDUXQLD1\D DWDV
NHEDLNDQ\DQJWHODKGLEHULNDQ$NKLUQ\DEHVDUKDUDSDQSHQXOLVVHPRJDVNULSVLLQL
GDSDWEHUPDQIDDWEDJLSHPEDFDGDQSHUNHPEDQJDQSHQGLGLNDQVHODQMXWQ\D
6HPDUDQJ2NWREHU
ǀŝŝŝ 6$5,
=XODLNDK 6LWL ³3HQJDUXK &DUD %HODMDU GDQ /LQJNXQJDQ .HOXDUJD WHUKDGDS+DVLO%HODMDU6LVZD0DWD3HODMDUDQ(NRQRPL.HODV;GL60$1HJHUL
7XQMXQJDQ .DEXSDWHQ %ORUD 7DKXQ $MDUDQ ´ 6NLSVL 3HQGLGLNDQ
(NRQRPL.RSHUDVL8QLYHUVLWDV1HJHUL6HPDUDQJ3HPELPELQJ'UD+DUQDQLN 06L
.DWD.XQFL+DVLO%HODMDU&DUD%HODMDUGDQ/LQJNXQJDQ.HOXDUJD
)DNWRUIDNWRU \DQJ PHPSHQJDUXKL KDVLO EHODMDU VLVZD GLDQWDUDQ\D FDUD EHODMDUGDQOLQJNXQJDQNHOXDUJD+DVLOREVHUYDVLDZDOKDVLOEHODMDUVLVZDNHODV; ,36PDVLK UHQGDK\DQJGLEXNWLNDQGHQJDQKDVLOQLODLXODQJDQKDULDQVLVZD\DQJ VHEDJLDQ EHVDU EHOXP PHPHQXKL .ULWHULD .HWXQWDVDQ 0DNVLPXP 3HQHOLWLDQ LQL GLODNXNDQ XQWXN PHQJHWDKXL DGDNDK SHQJDUXK FDUD EHODMDU GDQ OLQJNXQJDQ NHOXDUJD WHUKDGDS KDVLO EHODMDU VLVZD PDWD SHODMDUDQ HNRQRPL NHODV ; GL 60$ 1HJHUL7XQMXQJDQ.DEXSDWHQ%ORUD7DKXQ$MDUDQ
3RSXODVLSHQHOLWLDQLQLDGDODKVHOXUXKVLVZDNHODV;,36\DQJEHUMXPODK VLVZD -XPODK VDPSHO GDODP SHQHOLWLDQ LQL GLWHQWXNDQ GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ UXPXV 6ORYLQ VHEDQ\DN VLVZD 7HNQLN SHQJDPELODQ VDPSHO PHQJJXQDNDQ
SURSRUVLRQDOUDQGRPVDPSOLQJ3HQHOLWLDQLQLWHUGLULGDULGXDYDULDEHOEHEDV\DLWX FDUD EHODMDU GDQ OLQJNXQJDQ NHOXDUJD VHUWD YDULDEHO WHULNDW \DLWX KDVLO EHODMDU 0HWRGHDQDOLVLVGDWDPHQJJXQDNDQDQDOLVLVGHVNULSWLIGDQUHJUHVLEHUJDQGD
+DVLOSHQHOLWLDQGHQJDQDQDOLVLVGHVNULSWLIPHQXQMXNNDQEDKZDYDULDEHOFDUD EHODMDUWHUPDVXNGDODPNULWHULDEDLNGDQYDULDEHOOLQJNXQJDQNHOXDUJDWHUPDVXN GDODP NULWHULD EDLN 6HPHQWDUD KDVLO SHQHOLWLDQ GHQJDQ DQDOLVLV UHJUHVL PHQXQMXNNDQ DGD SHQJDUXK VHFDUD EHUVDPDVDPD DQWDUD FDUD EHODMDU GDQ OLQJNXQJDQ NHOXDUJD WHUKDGDS KDVLO EHODMDU VLVZD FDUD EHODMDU EHUSHQJDUXK WHUKDGDSKDVLOEHODMDUVLVZDVHUWDOLQJNXQJDQNHOXDUJDEHUSHQJDUXKWHUKDGDSKDVLO EHODMDU
ŝdž $%675$&7
=XODLNDK6LWL³7KH,QIOXHQFHRI+RZWR/HDUQDQG)DPLO\(QYLURQPHQW RQ7KHLU/HDUQLQJ2XWFRPHRI(FRQRPLFVLQWKH&DVHRIWKH7HQWK*UDGHURI60$
1HJHUL 7XQMXQJDQ %ORUD 5HJHQF\ LQ WKH DFDGHPLF \HDU RI ´ )LQDO
3URMHFW&RRSHUDWLYH(FRQRPLFV(GXFDWLRQ6HPDUDQJ6WDWH8QLYHUVLW\$GYLVRU 'UD+DUQDQLN06L
.H\ZRUGV/HDUQLQJ2XWFRPH+RZWR/HDUQDQG)DPLO\(QYLURQPHQW
7KHUH DUH VRPH IDFWRUV LQIOXHQFLQJ VWXGHQWV¶ OHDUQLQJ RXWFRPH VXFK DV
WKHLUKRZWROHDUQDQGIDPLO\HQYLURQPHQW%DVHGRQWKHLQLWLDOREVHUYDWLRQLWZDV NQRZQWKDWWKHOHDUQLQJRXWFRPHVRIWKHWHQWKJUDGHURI,36EHORQJHGWRSRRU,W ZDV SURYHG E\ WKHLU WHVW UHVXOWV ZKLFK PRVW RI WKHP KDG QRW UHDFKHG WKH PLQLPXPOHDUQLQJPDVWHU\\HW7KLVVWXG\ZDVFRQGXFWHGWRILQG RXWWKHLQIOXHQFH RIKRZWROHDUQDQGIDPLO\HQYLURQPHQWRQWKHLUOHDUQLQJRXWFRPHVLQWKHFDVHRI WKH WHQWK JUDGHU RI 60$ 1HJHUL 7XQMXQJDQ %ORUD LQ WKH DFDGHPLF \HDU RI
7KHSRSXODWLRQRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVDOORIWKHWHQWKJUDGHURI,36FODVVZKLFK DPRXQWV WR VWXGHQWV 7KH QXPEHUV RI VDPSOH XVHG LQ WKLV VWXG\ ZHUH VWXGHQWV GHWHUPLQHG XVLQJ WKH 6ORYLQ IRUPXOD DQG WDNHQ XVLQJ SURSRUVLRQDO UDQGRPVDPSOLQJ7KLVVWXG\KDGWZRLQGHSHQGHQWYDULDEOHVZKLFKZHUHKRZWR OHDUQ DQG IDPLO\ HQYLURQPHQW DQG RQH GHSHQGHQW YDULDEOH ZKLFK ZDV OHDUQLQJ RXWFRPH7KHPHWKRGRIDQDO\]LQJGDWDLQFOXGHGGHVFULSWLYHDQDO\VLVDQGPXOWLSOH UHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLV
7KHUHVXOWRIGHVFULSWLYHDQDO\VLVVKRZHGWKDWWKHYDULDEOHRIKRZWROHDUQ EHORQJHG WR JRRG FDWHJRU\ DV ZHOO DV WKH YDULDEOH RI WKHLU IDPLO\ HQYLURQPHQW 7KHQ WKH UHVXOW RI UHJUHVVLRQ DQDO\VLV VKRZHG WKDW WKHUH ZDV D VLPXOWDQHRXV LQIOXHQFH RI KRZ WR OHDUQ DQG IDPLO\ HQYLURQPHQW RQ WKHLU OHDQLQJ RXWFRPHV ZKLOHSDUWLDOO\WKHLQIOXHQFHRIVWXGHQWVKRZWROHDUQDQGWKHLQIOXHQFHRIWKHLU IDPLO\HQYLURQPHQW
,WFDQEHFRQFOXGHGWKDWWKHUHZDVDSRVLWLYHLQIOXHQFHERWKSDUWLDOO\DQG
VLPXOWDQHRXVO\ RI VWXGHQW¶V KRZ WR OHDUQ DQG WKHLU IDPLO\ HQYLURQPHQW RI WKHLU
dž '$)7$5,6,
+$/$0$1-8'8/ L 3(56(78-8$13(0%,0%,1* LL 3(1*(6$+$1.(/8/86$1 LLL 3(51<$7$$1 LY '$)7$5/$03,5$1 [YLL %$%,3(1'$+8/8$1
/DWDU%HODNDQJ0DVDODK 5XPXVDQ0DVDODK 7XMXDQ3HQHOLWLDQ 0DQIDDW3HQHOLWLDQ
%$%,,/$1'$6$17(25,
džŝ
3HQHJUWLDQ/LQJNXQJDQ.HOXDUJD ,QGLNDWRU/LQJNXQJDQ.HOXDUJD 3HQJDUXK&DUD%HODMDUWHUKDGDS+DVLO%HODMDU6LVZD 3HQJDUXK/LQJNXQJDQ.HOXDUJDWHUKDGDS+DVLO%HODMDU6LVZD 3HQHOLWLDQ7HUGDKXOX .HUDQJND%HUILNLU +LSRWHVLV
%$%,,,0(72'(3(1(/,7,$1
džŝŝ
8ML3DUVLDO8MLW 8ML.RHILVLHQ'HWHUPLQDVL*DQGDଶ
.RHILVLHQ'HWHUPLQDVL3DUVLDOU
%$%,9+$6,/3(1(/,7,$1'$13(0%$+$6$1
+DVLO3HQHOLWLDQ *DPEDUDQ8PXP2EMHN3HQHOLWLDQ +DVLO$QDOLVLV'HVNULSWLI
9DULDEHO&DUD%HODMDU;
9DULDEHO/LQJNXQJDQ.HOXDUJD;
9DULDEHO+DVLO%HODMDU< 8ML$VXPVL.ODVLN 8ML1RUPDOLWDV'DWD 8ML0XOWLNRORQLHULWDV 8ML+HWHURVNHGDVWLVLWDV $QDOLVLV5HJUHVL%HUJDQGD 3HQJXMLDQ+LSRWHVLV 3HQJXMLDQ+LSRWHVLVVHFDUD6LPXOWDQ8ML) 3HQJXMLDQ+LSRWHVLVVHFDUD3DUVLDO8MLW .RHILVLHQ'HWHUPLQDVL
.RHILVLHQ'HWHUPLQDVL5VHFDUD6LPXOWDQ .RHILVLHQ'HWHUPLQDVLଶVHFDUD3DUVLDO
3HPEDKDVDQ 3HPEDKDVDQ+DVLO$QDOLVLV'HVNULSWLI 3HPEDKDVDQ+DVLO5HJUHVL%HUJDQGD 3HQJDUXK&DUD%HODMDUWHUKDGDS+DVLO%HODMDU6LVZD 3HQJDUXK/LQJNXQJDQ.HOXDUJDWHUKDGDS+DVLO%HODMDU6LVZD 3HQJDUXK &DUD %HODMDU GDQ /LQJNXQJDQ .HOXDUJD WHUKDGDS +DVLO
%HODMDU 6LVZD
%$%93(18783
džŝŝŝ '$)7$53867$.$
džŝǀ
'$)7$5*$0%$5
*DPEDU +DODPDQ
6NHPD .HUDQJND %HUILNLU 3HQJDUXK &DUD %HODMDU GDQ /LQJNXQJDQ .HOXDUJDWHUKDGDS+DVLO%HODMDU6LVZD
*UDILN1RUPDO33ORW
džǀ
'$)7$57$%(/
7DEHO +DODPDQ
.HWXQWDVDQ %HODMDU 6LVZD .HODV ; ,36 60$ 1HJHUL 7XQMXQJDQ 7DKXQ$MDUDQ &DUD %HODMDU 6LVZD .HODV ; ,36 60$ 1HJHUL 7XQMXQJDQ 7DKXQ
$MDUDQ 3HNHUMDDQ2UDQJWXD6LVZD /LQJNXQJDQ .HOXDUJD 6LVZD .HODV ; ,36 60$ 1HJHUL 7XQMXQJDQ
7DKXQ$MDUDQ
3HQHOLWLDQ7HUGDKXOX
džǀŝ
+DVLO$QDOLVLV'HVNULSWLI9DULDEHO+DVLO%HODMDU
8ML1RUPDOLWDV
8ML0XOWLNRORQLHULWDV $QDOLVLV5HJUHVL%HUJDQGD
+DVLO8ML6LPXOWDQ
+DVLO8ML3DUVLDO
džǀŝŝ
'$)7$5/$03,5$1
/DPSLUDQ +DODPDQ
ϭ %$%
3(1'$+8/8$1
/DWDU%HODNDQJ
3HUNHPEDQJDQ]DPDQ\DQJVHPDNLQPRGHUQWHUXWDPDSDGDHUDJOREDOLVDVL
VHNDUDQJ LQL PHQXQWXW DGDQ\D VXPEHU GD\D PDQXVLD \DQJ PHPSXQ\DL NXDOLWDV
WLQJJL GLPDQD SHQLQJNDWDQ NXDOLWDV WHUVHEXW PHQJDUDK XQWXN PHQFDSDL WXMXDQ
SHPEDQJXQDQ\DQJOHELKEDLN3HQJHPEDQJDQVXPEHUGD\DWHUVHEXWGDSDWGLOLKDW
GDUL VHJL SHQGLGLNDQ \DQJ WHODK WHUNDQGXQJ GDODP WXMXDQ SHQGLGLNDQ
QDVLRQDO3HQGLGLNDQPHPSXQ\DLSHUDQ\DQJVDQJDWVWUDWHJLVGDODPPHQLQJNDWNDQ
NXDOLWDVVXPEHUGD\DPDQXVLDGDQXSD\DPHZXMXGNDQFLWDFLWDEDQJVD,QGRQHVLD
GDODPPHZXMXGNDQNHVHMDKWHUDDQXPXPGDQPHQFHUGDVNDQNHKLGXSDQEDQJVD
8QGDQJ8QGDQJ 1R WHQWDQJ 6LVWHP 3HQGLGLNDQ 1DVLRQDO
WHUFDQWXPEDKZDSHQJHUWLDQSHQGLGLNDQ \DLWXVHEDJDL EHULNXW
³3HQGLGLNDQ DGDODK XVDKD VDGDU GDQ WHUHQFDQD XQWXN PHZXMXGNDQ VXDVDQD EHODMDU GDQ SURVHV SHPEHODMDUDQ DJDU SHVHUWD GLGLN VHFDUD DNWLI PHQJHPEDQJNDQ SRWHQVL GLULQ\D VHKLQJJD PHPLOLNL NHNXDWDQ VSLULWXDO NHDJDPDDQ SHQJHQGDOLDQ GLUL NHSULEDGLDQ NHFHUGDVDQ DNKODN PXOLD VHUWD NHWHUDPSLODQ\DQJGLSHUOXNDQROHKGLULQ\DPDV\DUDNDWEDQJVDGDQQHJDUD´
%HUGDVDUNDQ3DVDO885,1RPHQ\HEXWNDQEDKZDSHQGLGLNDQ
QDVLRQDO PHPLOLNL IXQJVL VHEDJDL SHQJHPEDQJDQ NHPDPSXDQ GDQ PHPEHQWXN
ZDWDNVHUWDSHUDGDEDQEDQJVD \DQJEHUPDUWDEDWXQWXNPHQFHUGDVNDQNHKLGXSDQ
EDQJVDVHUWDXQWXNPHQJHPEDQJNDQSRWHQVL\DQJGLPLOLNLROHKSHVHUWDGLGLNDJDU
PHQMDGL PDQXVLD \DQJ EHULPDQ GDQ EHUWDTZD NHSDGD 7XKDQ <DQJ 0DKD (VD
EHUDNKODNPXOLDEHULOPXFDNDSNUHDWLIPDQGLULGDQPHQMDGLZDUJDQHJDUD\DQJ
Ϯ
PHUXSDNDQ VXDWX XSD\D \DQJ WHUHQFDQD PHQJJXQDNDQ EHUEDJDL SURVHV GDQ
PHWRGH WHUWHQWX GHQJDQ WXMXDQ XQWXN PHQJHPEDQJNDQ SRWHQVL GLUL \DQJ DGD
VHKLQJJD WHUMDGL SHUXEDKDQ GDODP VHJL SHQJHWDKXDQ WLQJNDK ODNX GDQ
NHWHUDPSLODQ
'HQJDQ GHPLNLDQ SHQGLGLNDQ PHUXSDNDQ VDUDQD XWDPD GDODP XSD\D
PHQLQJNDWNDQNXDOLWDVVXPEHUGD\DPDQXVLD\DQJOHELKEDLNODJL2OHKVHEDELWX
WDQJJXQJMDZDEWHUKDGDSSHQGLGLNDQEXNDQKDQ\DGDULVDWXSLKDNVDMDPHODLQNDQ
VHPXDSLKDNKDUXVWXUXWDQGLOGLGDODPQ\D %HUNDLWDQGHQJDQKDOWHUVHEXWPDND
GLSHUOXNDQ VXDWX OHPEDJD GDODP XSD\D PHODNXNDQ SURVHV SHQGLGLNDQ VHKLQJJD
WXMXDQSHQGLGLNDQQDVLRQDODNDQWHUFDSDL6HNRODKPHUXSDNDQOHPEDJDSHQGLGLNDQ
IRUPDO \DQJ PHQ\HGLDNDQ EHUEDJDL PDFDP NHJLDWDQ SHPEHODMDUDQ DJDU VLVZD
PHQGDSDWNDQSHQJDODPDQGDODPSHQGLGLNDQVHNRODKPHPLOLNLSHUDQ\DQJVDQJDW
SHQWLQJGDODPPHQFHWDNJHQHUDVL\DQJEHUNXDOLWDVWLQJJL
6HWLDS SURVHV SHPEHODMDUDQ SDVWL PHPLOLNL WXMXDQ \DQJ VDPD \DLWX DJDU
VLVZD PHPSHUROHK KDVLO EHODMDU \DQJ PDNVLPDO GDQ PHPXDVNDQ 6ODPHWR
PHQGHILQLVLNDQEDKZD³EHODMDULDODKVXDWXSURVHVXVDKD\DQJGLODNXNDQ
VHVHRUDQJ XQWXN PHPSHUROHK VXDWX SHUXEDKDQ WLQJNDK ODNX \DQJ EDUX VHFDUD
NHVHOXUXKDQ VHEDJDL KDVLO SHQJDODPDQQ\D VHQGLUL GDODP LQWHUDNVL GHQJDQ
OLQJNXQJDQQ\D´3URVHVSHQGLGLNDQ\DQJGLODNXNDQ GLVHNRODKPHQFDNXSEHUEDJDL
KDOVDODKVDWXQ\D \DLWXNHJLDWDQEHODMDU.HJLDWDQEHODMDU \DQJGLODNXNDQVLVZD
GDSDW GLODNXNDQ GHQJDQ EHUEDJDL FDUD VHSHUWL PHPEDFD PHQJDPDWL
ϯ
PHQJDODPL SHUXEDKDQ SHQJHWDKXDQ VLNDS GDQ NHWHUDPSLODQ GLPDQD SHUXEDKDQ
NHPDPSXDQLWXODK\DQJVHODQMXWQ\D GLVHEXWVHEDJDLKDVLOEHODMDU
6XGMDQD PHQJXQJNDSNDQ EDKZD ³KDVLO EHODMDU DGDODK
NHPDPSXDQNHPDPSXDQ \DQJ GLPLOLNL VLVZD VHWHODK PHQHULPD SHQJDODPDQ
EHODMDUQ\D´+DVLOEHODMDUWDPSDNVHEDJDLWHUMDGLQ\DSHUXEDKDQWLQJNDKODNXSDGD
GLULVLVZD3HUXEDKDQWHUVHEXWGDSDWGLDUWLNDQVHWHODKWHUMDGLQ\DSHQLQJNDWDQGDQ
SHQJHPEDQJDQ\DQJOHELKEDLNGLEDQGLQJNDQGHQJDQVHEHOXPQ\D
6DODK VDWX WRORN XNXU \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ ROHK JXUX XQWXN PHQJHWDKXL
NHEHUKDVLODQ VLVZD GDODP EHODMDU \DLWX GLOLKDW GDUL KDVLO EHODMDU \DQJ GLSHUROHK
+DVLOEHODMDUPHUXSDNDQWRORNXNXU \DQJWHODKGLFDSDLVLVZDVHWHODKPHODNXNDQ
SURVHV EHODMDU .HJLDWDQ EHODMDU PHQJDMDU \DQJ GLODNXNDQ GL VHNRODK GDSDW
GLNHWDKXLWLQJNDWNHEHUKDVLODQEHODMDUQ\DGHQJDQFDUDGLDGDNDQSHQJXNXUDQDWDX
HYDOXDVL GDUL SHPEHODMDUDQ \DQJ GLVHEXW KDVLO EHODMDU (YDOXDVL GDSDW GLODNXNDQ
VHWHODK SURVHV SHPEHODMDUDQ VHOHVDL PDXSXQ VHEHOXP SHPEHODMDUDQ GLPXODL
GHQJDQFDUDEHUWDQ\DJXQDPHUHIUHVKLQJDWDQVLVZDWHQWDQJPDWHUL\DQJGLSHODMDUL
VHEHOXPQ\D6HRUDQJ JXUXGDSDWPHOLKDWKDVLOEHODMDU \DQJGLSHUROHKVLVZDGDQ
GHQJDQEHJLWXJXUXDNDQPHQJHUWLWHUNDLWODQJNDKODQJNDKDSD \DQJVHODQMXWQ\D
DNDQGLEHULNDQNHSDGDVLVZD
%HUGDVDUNDQ XUDLDQ GLDWDV PDND KDVLO EHODMDU ELVD WHUMDGL MLND DGDQ\D
SHUXEDKDQ SDGD GLUL VHVHRUDQJ EDLN LWX GDUL VHJL SHQJHWDKXDQ VLNDS PDXSXQ
NHWHUDPSLODQ \DQJ PHQMDGLNDQ LQGLYLGX WHUVHEXW OHELK EDLN ODJL GLEDQGLQJNDQ
GHQJDQVHEHOXPQ\D3HUXEDKDQWHUVHEXWQDQWLQ\DDNDQPHQJDUDKNHSDGDWLQJNDW
ϰ
+DVLOEHODMDUGLSHQJDUXKLROHKEHEHUDSDIDNWRUVHSHUWL\DQJGLXQJNDSNDQ
ROHK'DO\RQREDKZDKDVLOEHODMDUGLSHQJDUXKLROHKIDNWRU\DLWXIDNWRULQWHUQDO
GDQIDNWRUHNVWHUQDO )DNWRULQWHUQDO DGDODKIDNWRU \DQJDGDGDODPGLULLQGLYLGX
\DQJ VHGDQJ EHODMDU DQWDUD ODLQ NHVHKDWDQ LQWHOLJHQVL GDQ EDNDW PLQDW GDQ
PRWLYDVL VHUWD FDUD EHODMDU VHGDQJNDQ IDNWRU HNVWHUQDO DGDODK IDNWRU \DQJ DGD
GLOXDU LQGLYLGX DQWDUD ODLQ OLQJNXQJDQ NHOXDUJD VHNRODK PDV\DUDNDW GDQ
OLQJNXQJDQVHNLWDU
60$1HJHUL7XQMXQJDQPHUXSDNDQVHNRODKPHQHQJDKDWDV\DQJEHUDGD
GL .DEXSDWHQ %ORUD \DQJ LQJLQ PHQFHWDN OXOXVDQ EHUNXDOLWDV WLQJJL VHNRODK LQL
PHPLOLNL GXD SHQMXUXVDQ DQWDUD ODLQ ,OPX 3HQJHWDKXDQ $ODP GDQ ,OPX
3HQJHWDKXDQ6RVLDO6HNRODKLQLMXJDPHPLOLNLWXMXDQXQWXNPHQFHWDNVLVZD\DQJ
EHUNDUDNWHU 8SD\D \DQJ GLODNXNDQ GDODP PHZXMXGNDQ KDO WHUVHEXW GLDQWDUDQ\D
GHQJDQ DGDQ\D UHODVL \DQJ EDLN DQWDUD VLVZD GHQJDQ VLVZD JXUX GHQJDQ VLVZD
RUDQJ WXD GHQJDQ JXUX RUDQJ WXD GHQJDQ VLVZD VHUWD PDV\DUDNDW \DQJ GDSDW
GLZXMXGNDQGDODPEHQWXNSHUKDWLDQWHUKDGDSKDOKDO\DQJEHUSHQJDUXKWHUKDGDS
KDVLOEHODMDUSHVHUWDGLGLNWHUVHEXW
%HUGDVDUNDQREVHUYDVL DZDOGL60$1HJHUL7XQMXQJDQNKXVXVQ\DNHODV
;,36GDODPPHPSHUROHKKDVLOEHODMDU EHOXPGDSDWGLNDWDNDQRSWLPDO GLEDQGLQJ
GHQJDQNHODVODLQQ\D+DOLQLGDSDWGLOLKDWGDULSHUROHKDQKDVLOEHODMDUVLVZD\DQJ
PHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZD WHUGDSDW VLVZD GLQ\DWDNDQ WXQWDV GDODP EHODMDU .ULWHULD
.HWXQWDVDQ 0LQLPDO \DQJ WHODK GLWHWDSNDQ ROHK VHNRODK \DLWX VHEHVDU XQWXN
ϱ
NHWXQWDVDQ EHODMDU VLVZD NHODV ; ,36 PDWD SHODMDUDQ HNRQRPL WDKXQ DMDUDQ
VHSHUWLSDGDWDEHO
7DEHO
.HWXQWDVDQ%HODMDU6LVZD.HODV;,3660$1HJHUL7XQMXQJDQ
6XPEHU 'DWD 1LODL 6LVZD .HODV ; ,36 60$ 1HJHUL 7XQMXQJDQ 7DKXQ $MDUDQ
0HQXUXW0XO\DVDVLVZDGLNDWDNDQWXQWDVGDODPEHODMDUDSDELOD
PDPSX PHQ\HOHVDLNDQ PHQJXDVDL NRPSHWHQVL DWDX PHQFDSDL WXMXDQ
SHPEHODMDUDQ VHNXUDQJNXUDQJQ\D GDUL MXPODK VLVZD \DQJ DGD GL NHODV
WHUVHEXW%HUGDVDUNDQWDEHOGLDWDVGDSDWGLOLKDWEDKZDWLQJNDWNHWXQWDVDQEHODMDU
HNRQRPL VLVZD NHODV ; ,36 EHOXP RSWLPDO 7RWDO NHVHOXUXKDQ \DQJ VXGDK
PHQFDSDL..0\DLWXVHEHVDUGHQJDQSHUVHQWDVHVHEHVDUGHQJDQUDWD
UDWDNHWXQWDVDQEHODMDUVHEHVDUVHKLQJJDGDSDWGLNDWDNDQFXNXS
6HSHUWL \DQJ GLMHODVNDQ GLDWDV EDKZD EDQ\DN IDNWRU \DQJ PHPSHQJDUXKL
NHEHUKDVLODQ VLVZD GDODP EHODMDU VHSHUWL \DQJ GLXQJNDSNDQ ROHK 'DO\RQR
EDKZD IDNWRU \DQJ PHQHQWXNDQ SHQFDSDLDQ KDVLO EHODMDU \DQJ EDLN
GLEDJLPHQMDGL\DLWXIDNWRULQWHUQDOGDQ IDNWRUHNVWHUQDO)DNWRULQWHUQDODGDODK
IDNWRU \DQJ DGD GDODP GLUL LQGLYLGX \DQJ VHGDQJ EHODMDU VHGDQJNDQ IDNWRU
HNVWHUQDO DGDODK IDNWRU \DQJ DGD GLOXDU LQGLYLGX )DNWRU LQWHUQDO DQWDUD ODLQ
NHVHKDWDQLQWHOLJHQVLGDQEDNDWPLQDWGDQPRWLYDVLVHUWDFDUD EHODMDUGDQIDNWRU
.HODV -XPODK
ϲ
HNVWHUQDO DQWDUD ODLQ OLQJNXQJDQ NHOXDUJD VHNRODK PDV\DUDNDW VHUWD OLQJNXQJDQ
VHNLWDU 6DODK VDWX IDNWRU \DQJ GDSDW PHPSHQJDUXKL KDVLO EHODMDU VLVZD DGDODK
IDNWRU LQWHUQDO \DLWX FDUD EHODMDU &DUD EHODMDU \DQJ GLODNXNDQ ROHK VLVZD GLVLQL
DQWDUDODLQPHPEXDWMDGZDOEHODMDUGDQSHODNVDQDDQQ\DVHFDUDWHUDWXUVLVZDDNDQ
PHPEDFDGDQPHPEXDWFDWDWDQEHUNDLWDQGHQJDQPDWHULEHODMDUPHQJXODQJEDKDQ
SHODMDUDQ PHQJHUMDNDQ WXJDV GDQ EHUNRQVHQWUDVL SHQXK GDODP SURVHV
SHPEHODMDUDQ 6HPDNLQ EDLN FDUD EHODMDU VLVZD PDND DNDQ GDSDW PHQLQJNDWNDQ
KDVLOEHODMDUVHEDOLNQ\DMLNDFDUDEHODMDUEXUXNPDNDKDVLOEHODMDUMXJDWLGDNDNDQ
RSWLPDO
%HODMDU PHPLOLNL NDWHJRUL \DQJ VDQJDW NRPSOHNV GDQ EHOXP GLNHWDKXL
VHJDODVHOXNEHOXNQ\D+DVLOEHODMDUVHQGLULGLSHQJDUXKLROHKEHUEDJDLIDNWRU+DO
LQL VHMDODQ GHQJDQ 6ODPHWR PHQHUDQJNDQ EDKZD ³EDQ\DN VLVZD GDQ
DWDXPDKDVLVZDJDJDODWDXWLGDNPHQGDSDWKDVLO\DQJEDLNGDODPEHODMDUQ\DLWX
GLNDUHQDNDQ PHUHND WLGDN PHQJHWDKXL EDJDLPDQD FDUD EHODMDU \DQJ HIHNWLI GDQ
PHUHND KDQ\D PHQFRED PHQJKDIDO SHODMDUDQ´ -DGL GHQJDQ GHPLNLDQ GDSDW
GLVLPSXONDQEDKZDVLVZD\DQJPHPSXQ\DLFDUDEHODMDU\DQJEDLNNHPXQJNLQDQ
DNDQ PHPSHUROHK KDVLO EHODMDU \DQJ EDLN $UWLQ\D VHPDNLQ EDLN FDUD EHODMDU
\DQJGLODNXNDQROHKVLVZDPDNDVHPDNLQWLQJJLSXODLQWHQVLWDVXVDKDGDQXSD\D
\DQJGLODNXNDQXQWXNPHPSHUROHKKDVLO\DQJPDNVLPDO
&DUDEHODMDUVLVZDGL60$1HJHUL7XQMXQJDQ KDUXVPHQGDSDWSHUKDWLDQ
NKXVXV NDUHQD NXDOLWDV EHODMDUQ\D VHFDUD NHVHOXUXKDQ VXGDK FXNXS EDLN QDPXQ
EHUWRODN EHODNDQJ GHQJDQ KDVLO EHODMDU \DQJ GLGDSDW GDSDW GLNDWHJRULNDQ EHOXP
ϳ
SHODMDUDQ HNRQRPL PHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZD WLGDN DGD WDUJHW QLODL NHODV \DQJ KDUXV
GLFDSDLDNDQWHWDSLVLVZDKDUXVELVDPHPHQXKL..0\DQJWHODKGLWHQWXNDQROHK
VHNRODK VHQGLUL 6HODLQ LWX SHQHOLWL MXJD WHODK PHODNXNDQ ZDZDQFDUD NHSDGD
VHEDJLDQ VLVZD NHODV ; NKXVXVQ\D ; ,36 \DQJ SDGD XPXPQ\D PHUHND VXGDK
PHPLOLNLNHPDXDQNHUDVXQWXNPHUDLKNHEHUKDVLODQEHODMDUGLVLQLELVDGLOLKDWGDUL
VHNRODK PHPEHULNDQ MDP WDPEDKDQ NHSDGD SHVHUWD GLGLN VHODPD MDP GLPXODL
GDUL SXNXO VDPSDL GHQJDQ SXNXO SHQJDGDDQ HNVWUDNXULNXOHU \DQJ
EHUNDLWDQODQJVXQJGHQJDQSHQGLGLNDQGDQODLQVHEDJDLQ\D0HUHNDPHQJHUMDNDQ
WXJDV\DQJGLEHULNDQ ROHKJXUXGDQPHPDQIDDWNDQZDNWX\DQJDGDXQWXNEHODMDU
DNDQWHWDSLQLODL\DQJGLSHUROHKEHOXPPDNVLPDOVHVXDLWDEHOGLEDZDKLQL
7DEHO
&DUD%HODMDU6LVZD .HODV;,3660$1HJHUL7XQMXQJDQ
1R ,QWHUYDO .ULWHULD )UHNXHQVL 5DWDUDWD
± 6%
SHPEHODMDUDQ EHUODQJVXQJ PHUHND MXJD GHQJDQ EDLN EHUNRQVHQWUDVL
PHPSHUKDWLNDQSHPEHODMDUDQ
6HODLQ FDUD EHODMDU WHUGDSDW IDNWRU HNVWHUQDO \DQJ MXJD PHPSHQJDUXKL
ϴ
GLODNXNDQROHKVLVZDVHQGLULWLGDNDNDQ SHUQDK OHSDVGDULSHQJDUXKOLQJNXQJDQ
6ODPHWR PHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZD ³EHODMDU LDODK VXDWX SURVHV XVDKD \DQJ
GLODNXNDQVHVHRUDQJXQWXNPHPSHUROHKVXDWXSHUXEDKDQWLQJNDKODNX\DQJEDUX
VHFDUDNHVHOXUXKDQVHEDJDLKDVLOSHQJDODPDQQ\DVHQGLULGDODPLQWHUDNVLGHQJDQ
OLQJNXQJDQQ\D´ 6HODQMXWQ\D 6ODPHWR MXJD PHQMHODVNDQ EDKZD VLVZD
\DQJ EHODMDU DNDQ PHQHULPD SHQJDUXK GDUL NHOXDUJD EHUXSD FDUD RUDQJ WXD
PHQGLGLN UHODVL DQWDU DQJJRWD NHOXDUJD VXDVDQD UXPDK WDQJJD GDQ NHDGDDQ
HNRQRPLNHOXDUJD
%HUGDVDUNDQREVHUYDVLDZDOGL60$1HJHUL7XQMXQJDQMXJDGLSHUROHK
GDWDSHNHUMDDQGDQOLQJNXQJDQNHOXDUJDVLVZDNHODV;,36VHEDJDLEHULNXW
7DEHO
3HNHUMDDQ2UDQJ 7XD6LVZD.HODV;,3660$1HJHUL7XQMXQJDQ
1R .HODV 316 3HWDQL 3HNHUMDDQ2UDQJ7XD%XUXK :LUDVZD -PO
VWD 6ZDVWD /DLQQ\D
;,36 'DWD GL DWDV GDSDW GLNHWDKXL EDKZD VHEDJLDQ EHVDU SHNHUMDDQ RUDQJ WXD
VLVZD NHODV ; ,36 GL 60$ 1HJHUL 7XQMXQJDQ DGDODK VHEDJDL SHWDQL \DLWX
VHEDQ\DN VLVZD DWDX VHEHVDU .RQGLVL LQL PHPEXNWLNDQ EDKZD
1R ,QWHUYDO .ULWHULD )UHNXHQVL 5DWDUDWD
ϵ
NHOXDUJD VDQJDW EHUSHQJDUXK GDODP PHQGLGLN DQDN +DO LQL DNDQ PHPEXDW
VHPDQJDWEDJLVLVZDXQWXNOHELKWHNXQODJLGDODPEHODMDUDJDUKDVLOEHODMDU\DQJ
GLFDSDLELVDPDNVLPDO6HODLQLWXEHUGDVDUNDQREVHUYDVLDZDO\DQJGLODNXNDQROHK
SHQHOLWL GDODP SHQ\HEDUDQ DQJNHW REVHUYDVL GLGDSDWNDQ EDKZD OLQJNXQJDQ
NHOXDUJD VLVZD GDODP NDWHJRUL FXNXS EDLN XQWXN PHQXQMDQJ WHUFDSDLQ\D KDVLO
EHODMDU VLVZD %HUGDVDUNDQ KDO WHUVHEXW PDND FDUD \DQJ GLODNXNDQ ROHK VHWLDS
RUDQJWXDGDODPPHPEHULNDQSHUKDWLDQDWDXSXQPHPELPELQJDQDNGLUXPDKDNDQ
VDQJDW EHUSHQJDUXK WHUKDGDS SHUEHGDDQ VHWLDS KDVLO EHODMDU \DQJ GLFDSDL GL
VHNRODK
%HUGDVDUNDQ XUDLDQ GL DWDV PDND SHQHOLWL WHUWDULN XQWXN PHQJDGDNDQ
SHQHOLWLDQGHQJDQMXGXO³3HQJDUXK &DUD %HODMDU GDQ /LQJNXQJDQ .HOXDUJD
WHUKDGDS +DVLO %HODMDU 6LVZD 0DWD 3HODMDUDQ (NRQRPL .HODV ; GL 60$
1HJHUL7XQMXQJDQ.DEXSDWHQ%ORUD7DKXQ$MDUDQ´
5XPXVDQ0DVDODK
%HUGDVDUNDQ ODWDU EHODNDQJ PDVDODK GL DWDV SHUPDVDODKDQ \DQJ GDSDW
GLLGHQWLILNDVLGDULSHQJDUXKFDUDEHODMDUGDQOLQJNXQJDQNHOXDUJDWHUKDGDSKDVLO
EHODMDU VLVZD PDWD SHODMDUDQ HNRQRPL NHODV ; GL 60$ 1HJHUL 7XQMXQJDQ
.DEXSDWHQ%ORUD7DKXQ$MDUDQDGDODK
$GDNDKSHQJDUXKFDUDEHODMDUWHUKDGDSKDVLOEHODMDUVLVZDSDGDPDWDSHODMDUDQ
HNRQRPL NHODV ; ,36 GL 60$ 1HJHUL 7XQMXQJDQ .DEXSDWHQ %ORUD WDKXQ
ϭϬ
$GDNDKSHQJDUXKOLQJNXQJDQNHOXDUJDWHUKDGDS KDVLOEHODMDUVLVZDSDGD PDWD
SHODMDUDQHNRQRPLNHODV;,36GL60$1HJHUL7XQMXQJDQ.DEXSDWHQ%ORUD
WDKXQDMDUDQ"
6HEHUDSDEHVDUSHQJDUXKFDUDEHODMDUGDQOLQJNXQJDQNHOXDUJDWHUKDGDSKDVLO
EHODMDU VLVZD SDGD PDWD SHODMDUDQ HNRQRPL NHODV ; ,36 GL 60$ 1HJHUL
7XQMXQJDQ.DEXSDWHQ%ORUDWDKXQDMDUDQ"
7XMXDQ3HQHOLWLDQ
7XMXDQ \DQJLQJLQGLSHUROHKGDULSHQHOLWLDQLQLDGDODKXQWXNPHQJHWDKXL
GDQPHQJDQDOLVLV
0HQJHWDKXL DGD WLGDNQ\D SHQJDUXK FDUD EHODMDU WHUKDGDS KDVLO EHODMDU VLVZD
SDGD PDWD SHODMDUDQ HNRQRPL NHODV ; ,36 GL 60$ 1HJHUL 7XQMXQJDQ
.DEXSDWHQ%ORUDWDKXQDMDUDQ
0HQJHWDKXLDGDWLGDNQ\DSHQJDUXKOLQJNXQJDQNHOXDUJDWHUKDGDSKDVLOEHODMDU
VLVZDSDGDPDWDSHODMDUDQHNRQRPLNHODV;,36GL60$1HJHUL7XQMXQJDQ
.DEXSDWHQ%ORUDWDKXQDMDUDQ
0HQJHWDKXL VHEHUDSD EHVDU SHQJDUXK FDUD EHODMDU GDQ OLQJNXQJDQ NHOXDUJD
WHUKDGDSKDVLOEHODMDUVLVZDSDGDPDWDSHODMDUDQHNRQRPLNHODV;,36GL60$
1HJHUL7XQMXQJDQ.DEXSDWHQ%ORUDWDKXQDMDUDQ
0DQIDDW3HQHOLWLDQ
0DQIDDW\DQJGDSDWGLSHUROHKGDULSHQHOLWLDQLQLDGDODK
ϭϭ
0DQIDDWWHRULWLVGDODPSHQHOLWLDQLQL\DLWXGDSDWPHQDPEDKNKDVDQDKLOPX
SHQJHWDKXDQ DWDX PHQJHPEDQJNDQ SHQJHWDKXDQ EDUX GDODP GXQLD
SHQGLGLNDQNKXVXVQ\DSDGDPDWDSHODMDUDQHNRQRPL
0DQIDDW3UDNWLV
0DQIDDWSUDNWLVVHWHODKGLDGDNDQSHQHOLWLDQLQLDGDODK
D %DJL6HNRODK
0HPEHULNDQ VXPEDQJDQ SHPLNLUDQ NHSDGD VHNRODK WHQWDQJ EDJDLPDQD
SHPEHODMDUDQ HNRQRPL \DQJ EDLN GLOLKDW GDUL VHJL FDUD EHODMDU VLVZD
WHUKDGDSKDVLOEHODMDUHNRQRPLPDXSXQGDULVHJLOLQJNXQJDQNHOXDUJD
E %DJL*XUX
0HPEHULNDQPDVXNDQNHSDGDJXUX\DQJGDSDWGLJXQDNDQVHEDJDLEDKDQ
HYDOXDVLGDQPHPEHULNDQPRWLYDVLXQWXNPHODNVDQDNDQWXJDVQ\DGHQJDQ
EDLNGDODPSHPEHODMDUDQVHUWDPHPEHULNDQSHQJHWDKXDQ\DQJOHELKOXDV
