Lampiran 1. Rencana Waktu Penelitian

(1)

Lampiran 1

Rencana Waktu Penelitian

No Kegiatan

Juni Juli Agus Sept Okt Nov Des Jan Feb Maret April

2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2014 2014 2014 2014

1 Penyiapan data awal dan Penyusunan Proposal 2 Kolokium 3 Pengumpulan Data 4 Pengolahan Data 5 Penyusunan Laporan Penelitian 6 Seminar Hasil 7 Perbaikan Seminar Hasil 8 Ujian Tesis

(2)

Lampiran 2

Populasi dan Sampel Penelitian

No Provinsi Kriteria 1 Kriteria 2 Kriteria 3 Kriteria 4 Sampel

1 Aceh √ √ √ X -

2 Sumatera Utara √ √ √ √ Sampel 1

3 Sumatera Barat √ √ √ X -

4 Riau √ √ √ √ Sampel 2

5 Kepulauan Riau √ √ √ √ Sampel 3

6 Jambi √ √ √ √ Sampel 4

7 Sumatera Selatan √ √ √ √ Sampel 5

8 Kepulauan Bangka √ √ √ √ Sampel 6

9 Bengkulu √ √ √ X -

10 Lampung √ √ √ √ Sampel 7

11 Jakarta X √ √ √ -

12 Jawa Barat √ √ √ √ Sampel 8

13 Banten √ √ √ √ Sampel 9

14 Jawa Tengah √ √ √ √ Sampel 10

15 Yogyakarta √ √ √ X -

16 Jawa Timur √ √ √ √ Sampel 11

17 Bali √ √ √ √ Sampel 12

18 Kalimantan Barat √ √ √ √ Sampel 13

19 Kalimantan Tengah √ √ √ √ Sampel 14

20 Kalimantan Selatan √ √ √ √ Sampel 15

21 Kalimantan Timur √ √ √ √ Sampel 16

22 Sulawesi Utara √ √ √ √ Sampel 17

23 Gorontalo √ √ √ X -

24 Sulawesi Tengah √ √ √ X -

25 Sulawesi Selatan √ √ √ √ Sampel 18

26 Sulawesi Barat √ √ √ X -

27 Sulawesi Tenggara √ √ √ X -

28 Nusa Tenggara Barat √ √ √ X -

29 Nusa Tenggara Timur √ √ √ X -

30 Maluku √ √ √ X -

31 Maluku Utara √ √ √ X -

32 Papua √ √ √ √ Sampel 19

(3)

Lampiran 3

Data Asli Sample Penelitian

NO PROVINSI TAHUN PDRB PAD Dana

Perimbangan Belanja Daerah PMDN Konsumsi 1 Sumatera Utara 2007 181820 1693846305 951081298 2975150652 9351,30 351576 2008 213932 1897496352 1036905790 3357275712 382,80 391767 2009 236354 933862263 12910108683 18041742502 2060,70 432389 2010 275700 1162868646 13912561923 19403987117 662,70 499693 2011 314157 1608438531 15730294866 21567004417 1673,10 564565 2 Riau 2007 210003 1257064415 2135945285 4482462584 1379,20 492240 2008 276400 1089591356 2373503776 4497307685 1966,80 520258 2009 297173 1050095772 9252213570 17075229046 3386,60 575064 2010 345661 1002811748 12144921035 18051491048 1037,10 598012 2011 413350 1204975465 12397022144 17727902091 7462,60 754634 3 Kepulauan Riau 2007 51826 324999591 662339583 1464840644 3173,60 516636 2008 58575 520231448 658268552 1389000000 74,30 560188 2009 63893 686042380 3302932257 5954797372 240 608110 2010 71615 635100360 4156679449 6830324461 166,90 681998 2011 80243 819081529 3944401436 6537867732 1370,40 904790 4 Jambi 2007 32077 451050872 686556647 1465875749 17586 367568 2008 41056 406306855 713827682 1429178037 1300,60 381042 2009 44127 261552613 4587945744 6339444478 213,90 397618 2010 53817 300261519 5366140598 6961142861 223,30 476495 2011 63268 324670146 5576765750 7382954356 2134,90 586786 5 Sumatera Selatan 2007 109896 847953871 1280897605 2473117006 4447,10 329688 2008 133665 964674822 1499885033 2743352112 378,50 361314 2009 137332 508552952 8734838171 10817034855 580,30 392374 2010 157535 632844688 10409782639 13045125644 1738,40 453722 2011 181776 747130735 11464744945 14620350360 1068,90 519312 6 Kep. Bangka Belitung 2007 17895 203541900 406326724 900066417 565,90 472171 2008 21421 210471858 511474100 868017518 2,06 521091 2009 22998 217723699 2340691299 3885447455 249,30 570535 2010 26565 223267455 2198757152 3499113200 0,40 661834 2011 30255 224044997 2502767920 3386396994 514,40 736645 7 Lampung 2007 60922 674693660 686784795 1724721428 1037,80 329473 2008 73719 714322619 790987140 1730309759 735,20 334055 2009 88935 228655667 5985364246 7372426630 549,90 350855 2010 108379 329904843 6557373426 8754592601 272,30 411603 2011 128409 358291112 8024660218 10560308631 824,40 490180 8 Jawa Barat 2007 526220 4221668696 1756094285 6964665374 19965,80 367263 2008 633283 4055119000 1630811000 6185132000 4289,80 396929

(4)

NO PROVINSI TAHUN PDRB PAD Dana Perimbangan Belanja Daerah PMDN Konsumsi 2009 689841 22513463797 22513463797 34001804691 4724,90 444186 2010 771594 3640589815 23634169261 37911295243 15799,80 487681 2011 861006 3796798490 24988695712 38950384241 11194,30 608708 9 Banten 2007 122844 1298456276 607804085 2065997712 4048,50 431097 2008 139865 1367391000 658479810 2158281002 1989,10 454453 2009 152556 950804139 4960591218 7866057791 4381,70 518970 2010 171690 1129058866 5533082938 9393899745 5852,50 644138 2011 192219 1289831845 5843857778 9949658210 4298,60 693987 10 Jawa Tengah 2007 312429 2932805173 1419342557 4794746491 1221,30 281365 2008 367136 3365222676 1480002412 5600610600 1336,30 306254 2009 397904 2656774760 22081569896 30792912554 2642,60 337381 2010 444692 3044658121 22494037739 33318453721 795,40 393831 2011 498615 3184922691 24386341460 35974901273 2737,80 463907 11 Jawa Timur 2007 536982 4164250657 1755896027 6855217883 16017,10 295336 2008 621392 3584134000 1719386000 6166796000 2778,30 331954 2009 686848 3336265015 25121666791 37523187739 4290,60 369077 2010 778566 3751637775 25860761125 41299321539 8084,10 411477 2011 884144 4669649943 27791394955 43318902699 9687,50 486426 12 Bali 2007 44003 834475055 525304234 1546287055 665,90 440473 2008 51916 730500904 556948660 1512294541 29 429018 2009 60292 1462727821 4091711546 7615762403 50,80 491271 2010 66691 1730219212 3935431419 7941166002 313,40 623247 2011 73478 1647848273 4170357102 7700399783 313,40 785622 13 Kalimantan Barat 2007 43541 471327210 711607636 1327096037 26362,30 297393 2008 49133 438517780 847685585 1301825615 248,10 349180 2009 54281 6337584725 6337584725 8094632119 517,10 395896 2010 60502 327740462 6595290159 8874636760 1171,70 471360 2011 66780 408101859 7422214630 9368312796 1404 586732 14 Kalimantan Tengah 2007 27932 273180273 726574032 1186481862 20563,70 355716 2008 32760 336565000 851092090 1415299000 681,90 418161 2009 37162 283753691 6261665827 8389974872 1464,80 448259 2010 42621 282280931 6318503103 8191357091 3507,70 511818 2011 49073 355929646 6904231220 8539665429 3376 642867 15 Kalimantan Selatan 2007 39439 690490971 623583487 1586696549 17941,20 414313 2008 45844 779695261 709341664 1776714254 592,80 443508 2009 51460 380590568 6317613697 7964614168 870,90 498190 2010 59821 443558194 6137446843 8405905327 2015 590378 2011 68235 523801316 6709684857 9853562228 2118,30 699417 16 Kalimantan Timur 2007 222629 1381716721 3096452203 7583071884 3010,40 516114 2008 314814 1257530200 2783142681 6166316825 298,70 585302 2009 285591 1190984608 12905062869 23985024428 82,20 693101

(5)

NO PROVINSI TAHUN PDRB PAD Dana Perimbangan Belanja Daerah PMDN Konsumsi 2010 321905 1093515171 15094888407 23736399000 7881,30 793438 2011 390639 1234446302 16164029196 24345901293 6569,10 894044 17 Sulawesi Utara 2007 24081 252324235 496496761 842693748 177,50 350807 2008 28698 238947500 608329840 1099810708 42,20 341496 2009 33034 215498658 4674302003 5814526234 49,50 385041 2010 36912 233716298 4841610879 6749234593 95,80 506633 2011 41505 338034928 5322687843 7688486323 331,60 617669 18 Sulawesi Selatan 2007 69272 992252464 810026105 2075749997 3951,10 291929 2008 85143 1113291487 908790027 2118268459 1105,20 321043 2009 99955 760601054 9776555779 13527997909 1137,80 364835 2010 117862 784776085 10029311627 13991292077 3212,30 461810 2011 137390 1133335794 11386233098 15697649544 3986,30 506323 19 Papua 2007 55380 345419705 2043981643 6433759440 19840,40 351408 2008 61516 311982700 1951060000 5558790700 294,70 329173 2009 76887 453581072 11430038104 6620281263 41,10 430042 2010 87777 497369748 13611975318 6507380652 178 498350 2011 76371 507655346 15556402076 6514323072 1377,80 556491

Lampiran 4

Data Setelah Transformasi Data

No

LOG

PDRB LOG PAD LOG DANA PERIMBANGAN

LOG BELANJA

DAERAH LOG PMDN LOG KONSUMSI

1 5.260 9.229 8.978 9.474 3.971 5.546 2 5.330 9.278 9.016 9.526 2.583 5.593 3 5.374 8.970 10.111 10.256 3.314 5.636 4 5.440 9.066 10.143 10.288 2.821 5.699 5 5.497 9.206 10.197 10.334 3.224 5.752 6 5.322 9.099 9.330 9.652 3.140 5.692 7 5.442 9.037 9.375 9.653 3.294 5.716 8 5.473 9.021 9.966 10.232 3.530 5.760 9 5.539 9.001 10.084 10.257 3.016 5.777 10 5.616 9.081 10.093 10.249 3.873 5.878 11 4.715 8.512 8.821 9.166 3.502 5.713 12 4.768 8.716 8.818 9.143 1.871 5.748 13 4.805 8.836 9.519 9.775 2.380 5.784 14 4.855 8.803 9.619 9.834 2.222 5.834 15 4.904 8.913 9.596 9.815 3.137 5.957 16 4.506 8.654 8.837 9.166 4.245 5.565 17 4.613 8.609 8.854 9.155 3.114 5.581 18 4.645 8.418 9.662 9.802 2.330 5.599

(6)

No

LOG

LOG BELANJA

19 4.731 8.477 9.730 9.843 2.349 5.678 20 4.801 8.511 9.746 9.868 3.329 5.768 21 5.041 8.928 9.108 9.393 3.648 5.518 22 5.126 8.984 9.176 9.438 2.578 5.558 23 5.138 8.706 9.941 10.034 2.764 5.594 24 5.197 8.801 10.017 10.115 3.240 5.657 25 5.260 8.873 10.059 10.165 3.029 5.715 26 4.253 8.309 8.609 8.954 2.753 5.674 27 4.331 8.323 8.709 8.939 301 5.717 28 4.362 8.338 9.369 9.589 2.397 5.756 29 4.424 8.349 9.342 9.544 -398 5.821 30 4.481 8.350 9.398 9.530 2.711 5.867 31 4.785 8.829 8.837 9.237 3.016 5.518 32 4.868 8.854 8.898 9.238 2.866 5.524 33 4.949 8.359 9.777 9.868 2.740 5.545 34 5.035 8.518 9.817 9.942 2.435 5.614 35 5.109 8.554 9.904 10.024 2.916 5.690 36 5.721 9.625 9.245 9.843 4.300 5.565 37 5.802 9.608 9.212 9.791 3.632 5.599 38 5.839 10.352 10.352 10.532 3.674 5.648 39 5.887 9.561 10.374 10.579 4.199 5.688 40 5.935 9.579 10.398 10.591 4.049 5.784 41 5.089 9.113 8.784 9.315 3.607 5.635 42 5.146 9.136 8.819 9.334 3.299 5.657 43 5.183 8.978 9.696 9.896 3.642 5.715 44 5.235 9.053 9.743 9.973 3.767 5.809 45 5.284 9.111 9.767 9.998 3.633 5.841 46 5.495 9.467 9.152 9.681 3.087 5.449 47 5.565 9.527 9.170 9.748 3.126 5.486 48 5.600 9.424 10.344 10.488 3.422 5.528 49 5.648 9.484 10.352 10.523 2.901 5.595 50 5.698 9.503 10.387 10.556 3.437 5.666 51 5.730 9.620 9.244 9.836 4.205 5.470 52 5.793 9.554 9.235 9.790 3.444 5.521 53 5.837 9.523 10.400 10.574 3.633 5.567 54 5.891 9.574 10.413 10.616 3.908 5.614 55 5.947 9.669 10.444 10.637 3.986 5.687 56 4.643 8.921 8.720 9.189 2.823 5.644 57 4.715 8.864 8.746 9.180 1.462 5.632 58 4.780 9.165 9.612 9.882 1.706 5.691 59 4.824 9.238 9.595 9.900 2.496 5.795 60 4.866 9.217 9.620 9.887 2.496 5.895

(7)

No

LOG

LOG BELANJA

61 4.639 8.673 8.852 9.123 4.421 5.473 62 4.691 8.642 8.928 9.115 2.395 5.543 63 4.735 9.802 9.802 9.908 2.714 5.598 64 4.782 8.516 9.819 9.948 3.069 5.673 65 4.825 8.611 9.871 9.972 3.147 5.768 66 4.446 8.436 8.861 9.074 4.313 5.551 67 4.515 8.527 8.930 9.151 2.834 5.621 68 4.570 8.453 9.797 9.924 3.166 5.652 69 4.630 8.451 9.801 9.913 3.545 5.709 70 4.691 8.551 9.839 9.931 3.528 5.808 71 4.596 8.839 8.795 9.200 4.254 5.617 72 4.661 8.892 8.851 9.250 2.773 5.647 73 4.711 8.580 9.801 9.901 2.940 5.697 74 4.777 8.647 9.788 9.925 3.304 5.771 75 4.834 8.719 9.827 9.994 3.326 5.845 76 5.348 9.140 9.491 9.880 3.479 5.713 77 5.498 9.100 9.445 9.790 2.475 5.767 78 5.456 9.076 10.111 10.380 1.915 5.841 79 5.508 9.039 10.179 10.375 3.897 5.900 80 5.592 9.091 10.209 10.386 3.818 5.951 81 4.382 8.402 8.696 8.926 2.249 5.545 82 4.458 8.378 8.784 9.041 1.625 5.533 83 4.519 8.333 9.670 9.765 1.695 5.586 84 4.567 8.369 9.685 9.829 1.981 5.705 85 4.618 8.529 9.726 9.886 2.521 5.791 86 4.841 8.997 8.908 9.317 3.597 5.465 87 4.930 9.047 8.958 9.326 3.043 5.507 88 5.000 8.881 9.990 10.131 3.056 5.562 89 5.071 8.895 10.001 10.146 3.507 5.664 90 5.138 9.054 10.056 10.196 3.601 5.704 91 4.743 8.538 9.310 9.808 4.298 5.546 92 4.789 8.494 9.290 9.745 2.469 5.517 93 4.886 8.657 10.058 9.821 1.614 5.634 94 4.943 8.697 10.134 9.813 2.250 5.698 95 4.883 8.706 10.192 9.814 3.139 5.745

(8)

Lampiran 5

Statistik Deskriptif

Descriptive Statistics

N Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation

Y 95 17895.00 884144.00 189546.3158 2.11336E5

X1 95 2.04E8 2.25E10 1.4394E9 2.51204E9

X2 95 4.06E8 2.78E10 6.7619E9 7.15299E9

X3 95 8.43E8 4.33E10 1.0106E10 1.03901E10

X4 95 .40 26362.30 3503.3537 5418.57673

Z 95 281365.00 904790.00 484300.7263 1.36102E5

Valid N (listwise) 95

Lampiran 6

Uji Linearitas Setelah Transformasi Data

ANOVA Table

Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Y * X1 Between Groups (Combined) 18.593 93 .200 6.149 .312

Linearity 12.896 1 12.896 396.650 .032

Deviation from Linearity 5.697 92 .062 1.905 .529

Within Groups .033 1 .033

Total 18.626 94

Measures of Association

R R Squared Eta Eta Squared

(9)

ANOVA Table

Linearity 5.508 1 5.508 104.755 .000

Total 18.626 94

Y * X2 .544 .296 .993 .986

ANOVA Table

Linearity 9.336 1 9.336 65.937 .001

Deviation from Linearity 8.723 89 .098 .692 .774

Total 18.626 94

Y * X3 .708 .501 .985 .970 ANOVA Table Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Linearity .009 1 .009 .065 .816

(10)

Y * X4 .023 .001 .988 .976

ANOVA Table

Y * Z Between Groups (Combined) 15.666 82 .191 .775 .760

Linearity .002 1 .002 .010 .924

Deviation from Linearity 15.664 81 .193 .784 .751

Within Groups 2.959 12 .247

Total 18.626 94

Y * Z .011 .000 .917 .841

Lampiran 7

Uji Normalitas Setelah Transformasi Data

One-Sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov Test

Unstandardized Residual

N 95

Normal Parametersa,,b Mean .0000000

Std. Deviation .18582619

Most Extreme Differences Absolute .092

Positive .056

Negative -.092

Kolmogorov-Smirnov Z .900

Asymp. Sig. (2-tailed) .393

a. Test distribution is Normal. b. Calculated from data.

(11)

Lampiran 8

Uji Multikolonieritas Setelah Transformasi Data

Coefficientsa Model Unstandardized Coefficients Standardized Coefficients t Sig. Collinearity Statistics

B Std. Error Beta Tolerance VIF

1 (Constant) -3.807 1.125 -3.384 .001 X1 .539 .071 .505 7.557 .000 .439 2.276 X2 -.422 .157 -.504 -2.695 .008 .056 17.881 X3 .959 .204 .961 4.689 .000 .047 21.428 X4 .000 .000 .036 .810 .420 .983 1.017 Z -.230 .192 -.060 -1.202 .233 .773 1.293 a. Dependent Variable: Y Collinearity Diagnosticsa

Model Dimension Eigenvalue Condition Index

Variance Proportions (Constant) X1 X2 X3 X4 X5 1 1 4.998 1.000 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 2 .998 2.238 .00 .00 .00 .00 .98 .00 3 .002 46.391 .03 .04 .03 .01 .01 .01 4 .002 55.575 .02 .38 .00 .00 .00 .05 5 .000 175.911 .95 .12 .00 .00 .00 .94 6 6.059E-5 287.190 .01 .45 .96 .99 .01 .00 a. Dependent Variable: Y

(12)

Lampiran 9

Uji Multikolonieritas Setelah Transformasi Data dan DAU Dikeluarkan

1 (Constant) -10.305 2.648 -3.892 .000 x1 .340 .111 .325 3.059 .003 .478 2.093 x2 .216 .128 .161 1.685 .097 .592 1.689 x3 .033 .113 .030 .293 .770 .528 1.895 x4 .250 .080 .296 3.111 .003 .595 1.681 z 3.361 .960 .300 3.500 .001 .736 1.359 a. Dependent Variable: y Collinearity Diagnosticsa

Model Dimension Eigenvalue Condition Index

Variance Proportions (Constant) x1 x2 x3 x4 x5 1 1 5.979 1.000 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 2 .019 17.731 .00 .00 .00 .00 .67 .00 3 .001 76.921 .02 .80 .01 .04 .10 .00 4 .001 86.863 .03 .00 .17 .37 .18 .05 5 .001 104.872 .00 .02 .74 .58 .03 .00 6 7.323E-5 285.733 .95 .19 .08 .01 .02 .95 a. Dependent Variable: y

(13)

Lampiran 10

Uji Autokorelasi Setelah Transformasi Data dan DAU Dikeluarkan

Runs Test

Test Valuea -.00079

Cases < Test Value 47

Cases >= Test Value 47

Total Cases 94

Number of Runs 37

Z -2.281

Asymp. Sig. (2-tailed) .023

a. Median

Lampiran 11

Uji Autokorelasi Setelah Transformasi Data, DAU Dikeluarkan

dan Tahun Penelitian Dikurangi

Runs Test

Test Valuea -.01477

Cases < Test Value 32

Cases >= Test Value 32

Total Cases 64

Number of Runs 33

Z .000

Asymp. Sig. (2-tailed) 1.000

(14)

Lampiran 12

Uji Hipotesis Setelah Transformasi Data, DAU Dikeluarkan

dan Tahun Penelitian Dikurangi

1. Koefisien determinans (R

2

)

Model Summary Model R R Square Adjusted R Square Std. Error of the Estimate 1 .788a .621 .596 .275964 a. Predictors: (Constant), x4, x2, x1, x3

2. Uji statistik t

Coefficientsa Model Unstandardized Coefficients Standardized Coefficients t Sig. B Std. Error Beta 1 (Constant) -10.305 2.648 -3.892 .000 x1 .340 .111 .325 3.059 .003 x2 .216 .128 .161 1.685 .097 x3 .033 .113 .030 .293 .770 x4 .250 .080 .296 3.111 .003 z 3.361 .960 .300 3.500 .001 a. Dependent Variable: y

3. Uji statistik F

ANOVAb

Model Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

1 Regression 7.376 4 1.844 24.213 .000a

Residual 4.493 59 .076

Total 11.869 63

a. Predictors: (Constant), x4, x2, x1, x3 b. Dependent Variable: y

(15)

ANOVAb

Model Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

1 Regression 7.376 4 1.844 24.213 .000a Residual 4.493 59 .076 Total 11.869 63 a. Predictors: (Constant), x4, x2, x1, x3

4. Uji residual

Coefficientsa Model Unstandardized Coefficients Standardized Coefficients t Sig. B Std. Error Beta 1 (Constant) 2.499 .152 16.481 .000 x1 .053 .013 .566 3.940 .000 x2 -.021 .017 -.178 -1.246 .218 x3 -.003 .015 -.029 -.191 .849 x4 .004 .011 .056 .389 .698 a. Dependent Variable: z Coefficientsa Model Unstandardized Coefficients Standardized Coefficients t Sig. B Std. Error Beta 1 (Constant) .018 .032 .582 .563 y .001 .006 .029 .229 .820

(16)

Lampiran 13

Uji Hipotesis Setelah Transformasi Data dan

Menggunakan Data Belanja Modal

1 (Constant) -6.686 1.375 -4.864 .000 X1 .723 .095 .626 7.600 .000 .580 1.724 X2 -.005 .121 -.004 -.040 .968 .450 2.225 X3 .238 .155 .152 1.531 .129 .401 2.495 X4 .052 .040 .096 1.312 .193 .728 1.374 Z .440 .137 .207 3.223 .002 .952 1.051 a. Dependent Variable: Y