,'(17,),.$6,'$18-,0(7$%2/,76(.81'(5%$1*81%$1*81
&2/(86$0%2,1,&86
7(5+$'$33(1<$.,7-$085$.$5387,+
5,*,'2325860,&5232586
',/$%25$725,80
,GHQWLILFDWLRQDQG7HVWRI6HFRQGDU\0HWDEROLFRI%DQJXQ%DQJXQ&ROHXV DPERLQLFXVWR:KLWH5RRW)XQJL'LVHDVH5LJLGRSRUXVPLFURSRUXVDW/DERUDWRU\
&LFL,QGULDQL'$/,0817+( <DQ5LVND9HQDWD6(0%,5,1* 0RFKOLVLQ$1'5,<$172
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
FRQFHQWUDWLRQ 7KH URRW RI EDQJXQ EDQJXQ H[WUDFW ZDV IUDFWLRQDWHG E\ XVLQJ SDSHUGLVFDQGWKUHVXOWVKRZHGWKHVWURQJHVW LQKLELWRU\LQWKHQKH[DQHIUDFWLRQWR FPHWK\ODFHWDWHIUDFWLRQWRFP DQGHWKDQROH[WUDFWVWRFP
.H\ZRUGV +HYHD EUDVLOLHQVLV &ROHXV
D P E R L Q L F X V V H F R Q G D U \ PHWDEROLF DQWDJRQLVWV WHVW :KLWH5RRW)XQJL'LVHDVH
$EVWUDN
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
DNDU GDQ GDXQ EDQJXQEDQJXQ XQWXN PHQJHWDKXL PHWDEROLW VHNXQGHU \DQJ G L K D V L O N D Q E D Q J X Q E D Q J X Q P H O D O X L LGHQWLILNDVL ILWRNLPLD NHPXGLDQ GLHNVWUDNVL GHQJDQ EHUEDJDL SHODUXW XQWXN GLXML WHUKDGDS -DPXU $NDU 3XWLK 5LJLGRSRUXV PLFURSRUXV 3DUDPHWHU \DQJ GLDPDWL \DLWX OXDV SHUWXPEXKDQ MDPXU GDQ SHUVHQWDVH SHQJKDPEDWDQ -$3 +DVLO LGHQWLILNDVL
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
.DWD NXQFL +HYHD EUDVLOLHQVLV EDQJXQ EDQJXQ PHWDEROLW VHNXQGHU XMLDQWDJRQLVSHQ\DNLWMDPXU DNDUSXWLK
3(1'$+8/8$1
3HQ\DNLWMDPXUDNDUSXWLK-$3\DQJ GLVHEDENDQ ROHK MDPXU 5LJLGRSRUXV PLFURSRUXVPHUXSDNDQSHQ\DNLWXWDPDSDGD WDQDPDQ NDUHW \DQJ GDSDW PHQJDNLEDWNDQ NHPDWLDQ SDGD WDQDPDQ 3HQ\DNLW LQL PHQLPEXONDQ NHUXVDNDQ SDGD DNDU WDQDPDQ *HMDOD SDGD GDXQ WHUOLKDW SXFDW NXQLQJGDQWHSLDWDXXMXQJGDXQWHUOLSDWNH GDODP NHPXGLDQ GDXQ JXJXU GLLNXWL XMXQJ UDQWLQJPHQMDGLPDWL$GDNDODQ\DWHUEHQWXN GDXQ PXGD DWDX EXQJD GDQ EXDK OHELK DZDO
3DGD SHUDNDUDQ WDQDPDQ VDNLW WDPSDN EHQDQJEHQDQJ MDPXU EHUZDUQD SXWLK GDQ DJDN WHEDO UL]RPRUI )DLUX]DK 'DOLPXQWKH .DU\XGL 6XU\DPDQ :LGKD\DWL
3HQJHQGDOLDQ SHQ\DNLW GHQJDQ PHPDQIDDWNDQ VXPEHUVXPEHU QDEDWL
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
)HEEL\DQWL
%DQJXQ%DQJXQ EHEDQJXQ SRNRN XEDW EDWXN UDMD EDQJXQ KDWLKDWL KLMDX DWDX VHGLQJLQ DWDXSXQ QDPD LOPLDKQ\D 3OHFWUDQWKXVDPERLQLFXV&ROHXVDPERLQLFXV PHUXSDNDQ VHMHQLV KHUED ZDQJL GDQ GDSDW GLPDNDQ 7DQDPDQ EDQJXQEDQJXQ PHQJDQGXQJ VHQ\DZD ELRDNWLI VHEDJDL DQWLRNVLGDQ 3DWHOHW DO DQWLEDNWHUL GDQDQWLIXQJL0DQMDPDODL1DUDOD+DULGDV *UDFH3HUWDKDQDQELRNLPLDEHUXSD VHQ\DZD \DQJ GLKDVLONDQ \DLWX VHQ\DZD KDVLO PHWDEROLVPH VHNXQGHU IODYDQRLG
D O N D O R L G J O \ F R F L G V H Q \ D Z D \ D Q J GLNHOXDUNDQVHEDJDLHNVXGDWVHQ\DZD\DQJ PHQJKDPEDWWLGDNPHQJKDVLONDQVHQ\DZD \DQJGLLQJLQNDQSDWRJHQ'L,QGLDWDQDPDQ EDQJXQEDQJXQ LQL GLSHUFD\D GDSDW PHQ\HPEXKNDQ EHUEDJDL SHQ\DNLW VHSHUWL GHPDPPDODULDKHSDWRSDWLEDWXJLQMDOGDQ NDQGXQJ NHPLK FHJXNDQ EURQNLWLV FDFLQJDQ NROLN GDQ NHMDQJ EDWXN EDKNDQ KLQJJDSHQ\DNLWDVPDNURQLN+DOLQLNDUHQD G D X Q E D Q J X Q E D Q J X Q P H Q J D Q G X Q J EHUEDJDL MHQLV IODYRQRLG VHSHUWLTXHUFHWLQ D S L J H Q L Q O X W H R O L Q V D O Y L J H Q L Q G D Q JHQNZDQLQ
7XOLVDQ LQL PHPEDKDV WHQWDQJ
PHWDEROLW VHNXQGHU EDQJXQEDQJXQ \DQJ PHPLOLNL SRWHQVL VHEDJDL SHQJHQGDOL SHQ\DNLW -DPXU $NDU 3XWLK 5LJLGRSRUXV PLFURSRUXV SDGD WDQDPDQ NDUHW 7XMXDQ GDUL SHQHOLWLDQ LQL XQWXN PHQJLGHQWLILNDVL PHWDEROLW VHNXQGHU EDQJXQEDQJXQ GDQ PHQJHWDKXLWLQJNDWNHPDPSXDQGDULIUDNVL PHWDEROLW VHNXQGHU EDQJXQEDQJXQ GDODP PHQJHQGDOLNDQSHQ\DNLW-DPXU$NDU3XWLK VNDOD ODERUDWRULXP 8ML SHQGDKXOXDQ GL ODERUDWRULXPPHQXQMXNNDQEDKZDWDQDPDQ LQL PHPLOLNL SRWHQVL GDODP PHQJKDPEDW SHUWXPEXKDQMDPXUDNDUSXWLK!
%$+$1'$10(72'(
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
DOXPLQLXP IRLOSHODUXWRUJDQLNQKHNVDQD HWLO DVHWDW DVHWRQ PHWDQRO \DQJ GLSHUROHK GDUL0HUFNGHQJDQWLQJNDWNHPXUQLDQ GDQ EDKDQ SHQGXNXQJ ODLQQ\D $ODW \DQJ GLJXQDNDQGDODPSHQHOLWLDQLQLDGDODKERWRO YLDO JHODV NLPLD HUOHQPH\HU JHODV XNXU SLSHW WHWHV FRURQJEXFKQHU URWDYDSRU DODW GHVWLODVL VHQWULIXJDWRU SHWULGLVK WDEXQJ
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
8ML ODQMXWDQ GLODNXNDQ GDUL KDVLO IUDNVLQDVL DNDU EDQJXQEDQJXQ GDQ GLXML GHQJDQ WHNQLN NHUWDV FDNUDP \DQJ GLLQRNXODVLNDQ EHUGHNDWDQ GHQJDQ LVRODW MDPXU DNDU SXWLK 6HWLDS SHUODNXDQ WHUGLUL GDUL EHUEDJDL GRVLV WHUPDVXN NRQWURO 7DKDSDQSHODNVDQDDQSHQHOLWLDQDQWDUDODLQ 3HUVLDSDQ&RQWRK
&RQWRK DNDU WDQDPDQ EDQJXQEDQJXQ GLSHUROHK GDUL KDVLO SDQHQ SHUEDQ\DNDQ EDQJXQEDQJXQ GL JDZDQJDQ 7%0 NDUHW $NDU \DQJ WHODK GLNHULQJDQJLQNDQ NHPXGLDQ GLJLOLQJ PHQMDGL VHUEXN 6HUEXN DNDU LQL DNDQ GLHNVWUDNVL GDQ IUDNVLQDVL PHWDEROLWVHNXQGHU\DQJVHODQMXWQ\DDNDQ GLXML DNWLYLWDVQ\D WHUKDGDS SHQ\DNLW WDQDPDQNDUHW
(NVWUDNVLGDQ8ML3HQGDKXOXDQ
(NVWUDNVL DGDODK NHJLDWDQ SHQDULNDQ NDQGXQJDQNLPLD\DQJGDSDWODUXWVHKLQJJD GDSDWWHUSLVDKGDULEDKDQ\DQJWLGDNGDSDW ODUXW GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ VXDWX SHODUXW (NVWUDN DGDODK VHGLDDQ NHQWDO \DQJ GLSHUROHK GHQJDQ PHQJHNVWUDNVL VHQ\DZD DNWLI GDUL VLPSOLVLD PHQJJXQDNDQ SHODUXW \DQJ VHVXDL 6HQ\DZD DNWLI \DQJ WHUGDSDW GDODPEHUEDJDLVLPSOLVLDGDSDWGLJRORQJNDQ NH GDODP JRORQJDQ PLQ\DN DWVLUL DONDORLG IODYDQRLG GDQ ODLQODLQ 3HPLOLKDQ SHODUXW GDQ FDUD HNVWUDNVL \DQJ WHSDW DNDQ OHELK PXGDK DSDELOD VHQ\DZD DNWLI \DQJ GLNDQGXQJVLPSOLVLDGLNHWDKXL3HODUXW\DQJ GLJXQDNDQ DGDODK HWDQRO DVHWRQ GDQ Q KHNVDQD 'HSDUWHPHQ .HVHKDWDQ 5HSXEOLN ,QGRQHVLD 6HUEXN DNDU WDQDPDQ EDQJXQEDQJXQ GLPDVHUDVL VHODPD [ MDP SDGD VXKX NDPDU PHQJJXQDNDQ PHWDQRO+DVLOPDVHUDVLGLVDULQJNHPXGLDQ ILOWUDWQ\D GLHYDSRUDVL VHKLQJJD GLSHUROHK HNVWUDNNDVDU
)UDNVLQDVL (NVWUDN $NDU %DQJXQ %DQJXQ
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
8ML )UDNVLQDVL (NVWUDN %DQJXQEDQJXQ WHUKDGDSSHQ\DNLW-DPXU$NDU3XWLK .HPDPSXDQ PHWDEROLW VHNXQGHU GDODP PHQJKDPEDW SHUWXPEXKDQ MDPXU DNDU SXWLK GLODNXNDQ VHFDUDLQ YLWUR 6XVSHQVL GDUL VHWLDS IUDNVL PHWDEROLW VHNXQGHU GLSHUVLDSNDQXQWXNGLXMLDQWDJRQLVGHQJDQ MDPXU SDWRJHQ %DJLDQ KLID WHUOXDU GDUL MDPXUSDWRJHQGLFHWDNGHQJDQFRUNERUHUGDQ GLLQRNXODVLNDQ SDGD EDJLDQ WHQJDK PHGLD 3'$XQWXNMDPXUGDQGLLQNXEDVLVHODPD MDP SDGD VXKX UXDQJ & 6HODQMXWQ\D VHEDQ\DN PO VXVSHQVL
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
7( GLPDQD 7( 'D\DHILNDVLSHQJKDPEDWDQ [ /XDV SHUWXPEXKDQ MDPXU SDGD NRQWUROFP \ /XDV SHUWXPEXKDQ MDPXU SDGD SHUODNXDQ HNVWUDN DNDU EDQJXQ EDQJXQFP
3HQJDPDWDQDEQRUPDOLWDVKLIDMDPXU -$3GLODNXNDQGHQJDQGXDFDUD\DLWXVHFDUD P D N U R V N R S L V G D Q P L N U R V N R S L V $EQRUPDOLWDV SHUWXPEXKDQ KLID SDWRJHQ \DQJGLDPDWLEHUXSDSHPEHQJNRNDQXMXQJ KLID KLID SHFDK KLID EHUEHODK KLID EHUFDEDQJKLIDOLVLVGDQKLIDWXPEXKNHUGLO
+$6,/'$13(0%$+$6$1
+DVLO ,GHQWLILNDVL )LWRNLPLD $NDU GDQ 'DXQ%DQJXQ%DQJXQ
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
7DEHO +DVLO LGHQWLILNDVL ILWRNLPLD VLPSOLVLD GDQ HNVWUDN SDGD GDXQ WDQDPDQ EDQJXQ EDQJXQ
7DEOH 7KH UHVXOWV RI SK\WRFKHPLFDO LGHQWLILFDWLRQ DQG SRZGHU VLPSOLFLD H[WUDFW RQ OHDI RI EDQJXQEDQJXQSODQW
.HWHUDQJDQ PHQJDQGXQJJRORQJDQVHQ\DZD WLGDNPHQJDQGXQJJRORQJDQVHQ\DZD 1RWHV FRQWDLQLQJWKHFRPSRXQG GRHVQWFRQWDLQWKHFRPSRXQG 7DEHO+DVLOLGHQWLILNDVLILWRNLPLDVHUEXNVLPSOLVLDGDQHNVWUDNSDGDDNDUWDQDPDQEDQJXQ EDQJXQ 7DEOH7KHUHVXOWVRISK\WRFKHPLFDOLGHQWLILFDWLRQDQGSRZGHUVLPSOLVLDH[WUDFWRQURRWVRI EDQJXQEDQJXQSODQW 1R ,GHQWLILNDVLILWRNLPLD 3K\WRFKHPLFDOLGHQWLILFDWLRQ 'DXQEDQJXQEDQJXQ /HDIRIEDQJXQEDQJXQSODQW 6LPSOLVLD 6LPSOLFLD (NVWUDN ([WUDFW $ONDORLG )ODYRQRLG *OLNRVLGD 6DSRQLQ 7DQLQ 7HUSHQRLGVWHURLG
.HWHUDQJDQ PHQJDQGXQJJRORQJDQVHQ\DZD WLGDNPHQJDQGXQJJRORQJDQVHQ\DZD 1RWHV FRQWDLQLQJWKHFRPSRXQG GRHVQWFRQWDLQWKHFRPSRXQG
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
GDUL VXDWX WDQDPDQ \DQJ PHOLPSDK GL ,QGRQHVLD +DVLO LGHQWLILNDVL ILWRNLPLD LQL GDSDWPHQMDGLLQIRUPDVLXQWXNPHQHQWXNDQ D N W L Y L W D V Q \ D G D O D P P H Q J H Q G D O L N D Q SHQ\DNLW
+DVLO 8ML 3HQGDKXOXDQ (NVWUDN $NDU %DQJXQ%DQJXQ GDUL %HUEDJDL 0DFDP 'RVLVGDQ3HODUXW$VHWRQ(WDQROGDQ1 +HNVDQDWHUKDGDS-DPXU$NDU3XWLK
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
7DEHO 3HQJDUXK LQWHUDNVL GRVLV GDQ SHODUXW WHUKDGDS OXDV SHUWXPEXKDQ MDPXU SDGD SHQJDPDWDQKVL
7DEOH 7KH LQIOXHQFH RI LQWHUDFWLRQ RI GRVDJH DQG VROYHQW RQ JURZWK DUHD RI IXQJL LQ REVHUYDWLRQDWGD\VDIWHULQRFXODWLRQ
$QJNDUDWDUDWD\DQJGLLNXWLKXUXINHFLO\DQJVDPDSDGDNRORPGDQKXUXIEHVDU\DQJVDPDSDGDEDULV \DQJVDPDEHUEHGDWLGDNQ\DWDPHQXUXW8ML-DUDN%HUJDQGD'XQFDQSDGDWDUDI
)LJXUHVLQWKHVDPHFROXPQIROORZHGE\WKHVDPHVPDOOOHWWHUDQGQXPEHUIROORZHGE\WKHVDPHFDSLWDOLQ WKHVDPHURZDUHQRWVLJQLILFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWDW'XQFDQ0XOWL5DQJH7HVW3
,QWHUDNVL GRVLV GDQ SHODUXW WHUKDGDS
OXDVSHUWXPEXKDQMDPXUDNDUSXWLKGDSDW GLOLKDWSDGD7DEHO3DGDSHQJDPDWDQKVL PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD OXDV SHUWXPEXKDQ MDPXU WHUNHFLO PDVLK WHUGDSDW SDGD GRVLV GL VHWLDS SHODUXW \DLWX VHEHVDU DVHWRQ QKHNVDQD GDQ FP PHWDQRO7DEHO3DGDGRVLVVDPSDL GHQJDQGRVLVOXDVSHUWXPEXKDQMDPXU WLGDNEHUEHGDQ\DWDSDGDSHODUXWQKHNVDQD GDQ PHWDQRO VHGDQJNDQ WHUKDGDS SHODUXW DVHWRQWHUGDSDWSHUEHGDDQ\DQJQ\DWD
3DGDSHQJDPDWDQKVLSHUWXPEXKDQ -$3 SDGD NRQWURO VXGDK PHPHQXKL FDZDQ SHWUL GHQJDQ OXDVDQ VHEHVDU 7DEHO +DO LQL EHUEHGD Q\DWD G H Q J D Q S H U O D N X D Q O D L Q Q \ D \ D Q J PHQXQMXNNDQ DGDQ\D LQWHUDNVL \DQJ EHUSHQJDUXKQ\DWDDQWDUDGRVLVGDQSHODUXW VHSHUWL \DQJ GLEDKDV SDGD SHQJDPDWDQ GDQ KVL \DQJ PHQ\DWDNDQ GRVLV PHPLOLNL OXDV SHUWXPEXKDQ MDPXU WHUNHFLO SDGDVHWLDSSHODUXW3HPLOLKDQSHODUXWSDGD HNVWUDNVL\DQJWHSDWDNDQOHELKPXGDKELOD
VHQ\DZD DNWLI \DQJ GLNDQGXQJ VLPSOLVLD GLNHWDKXL +DVLO VNULQLQJ PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD DNDU GDQ GDXQ EDQJXQEDQJXQ SRVLWLIPHQJDQGXQJVHQ\DZDSRODUGDQVHPL SRODU\DNQLIODYDQRLGJOLNRVLGDGDQVDSRQLQ 6HQ\DZDLQLODUXWGDODPSHODUXWDVHWRQGDQ PHWDQRO 6HPHQWDUD SHODUXW QKHNVDQD & + \DQJ PHUXSDNDQ JRORQJDQ DONDQD GDQ WHUPDVXN NH GDODP SHODUXW QRQSRODU PHQJDQGXQJ VHQ\DZD QRQSRODU \DNQL WHUSHQRLGVWUHRLG
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
7DEOH 7KH LQIOXHQFH RI LQWHUDFWLRQ RI GRVDJH DQG VROYHQW RQ JURZWK DUHD RI IXQJL LQ REVHUYDWLRQDWGD\VDIWHULQRFXODWLRQ
$QJNDUDWDUDWD\DQJGLLNXWLKXUXINHFLO\DQJVDPDSDGDNRORPGDQKXUXIEHVDU\DQJVDPDSDGDEDULV \DQJVDPDEHUEHGDWLGDNQ\DWDPHQXUXW8ML-DUDN%HUJDQGD'XQFDQSDGDWDUDI
)LJXUHVLQWKHVDPHFROXPQIROORZHGE\WKHVDPHVPDOOOHWWHUDQGQXPEHUIROORZHGE\WKHVDPHFDSLWDOLQ WKHVDPHURZDUHQRWVLJQLILFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWDW'XQFDQ0XOWL5DQJH7HVW3
'RVLV 'RVDJH 3HODUXW 6ROYHQW $VHWRQ $FHWRQH QKHNVDQD QKH[DQH 0HWDQRO PHWKDQRO .RQWURO G $ F $ G $ F % E $ F $ EF % E $ E $ E % E $ D $ D $ D % D %
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
KDQ\D PDPSX PHQJKDPEDW VHEHVDU (NVWUDNVL DNDU EDQJXQEDQJXQ GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ SHODUXW DVHWRQ PHPLOLNL NHPDPSXDQ PHQJKDPEDW -$3 O H E L K U H Q G D K S D G D G R V L V E L O D GLEDQGLQJNDQ GHQJDQ SHODUXW ODLQQ\D GLVHEDENDQ NDUHQD VLIDW VHQ\DZD \DQJ GLHNVWUDNVL GHQJDQ SHODUXW DVHWRQ DGDODK SRODU+DVLOSHQHOLWLDQPHQXQMXNNDQEDKZD VHQ\DZDSRODUGD\DHNVWUDNVLQ\DWLQJJLSDGD GRVLV
'RVLV 'RVDJH 3HODUXW 6ROYHQW $VHWRQ $FHWRQH QKHNVDQD QKHNVDQD 0HWDQRO 0HWKDQRO .RQWURO G $ G $ G $ G % F $ F $ F % E $ E $ E & E % D $ D $ D & D %
7DEHO 3HQJDUXK LQWHUDNVL GRVLV GDQ SHODUXW WHUKDGDS SHUVHQWDVH SHQJKDPEDWDQ -$3 SDGDSHQJDPDWDQKVL 7DEOH 7KHHIIHFWRILQWHUDFWLRQRIGRVDJHDQGVROYHQWWR:5'LQKLELWLRQSHUFHQWDJHDWGD\V DIWHULQRFXODWLRQ 'RVLV 'RVDJH 3HODUXW 6ROYHQW $VHWRQ $FHWRQH QKHNVDQD QKH[DQH 0HWDQRO 0HWKDQRO .RQWURO H $ H $ F $ G % G $ E $ F % F $ D $ E % E $ D $ D $ D % D $
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
EDQJXQEDQJXQ PHUXSDNDQ NHORPSRN V H Q \ D Z D I H Q R O \ D Q J P H P S X Q \ D L NHFHQGHUXQJDQ XQWXN PHQJLNDW SURWHLQ VHKLQJJD PHQJJDQJJX SURVHV PHWDEROLVPH MDPXU 3ROLIHQRO SDGD NDGDU WLQJJL GDSDW PHQ\HEDENDQ NRDJXODVL SURWHLQ GDQ PHQ\HEDENDQVHOPHPEUDQPHQJDODPLOLVLV 3UDVHW\R 6DVRQJNR6DPDKDOQ\D GHQJDQ VHQ\DZD VDSRQLQ \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ VHEDJDL DQWLPLNURED 0HQXUXW PHNDQLVPH VDSRQLQ VHEDJDL DQWLPLNURED OHELK NDUHQD DGDQ\D HIHN PHPEUDQROLWLN GDULSDGD PHQJXEDK WHJDQJDQ SHUPXNDDQ PHGLD HNVWUDVHOXOHU
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
0HQXUXW SHQHOLWLDQ 9DOHUD HW DO
GLNHWDKXL EDKZD WDQDPDQ EDQJXQ EDQJXQPHQJDQGXQJPLQ\DNDWVLUL \DQJ EHUIXQJVL GDSDW PHODZDQ LQIHNVL FDFLQJ DQWLEDNWHUL DQWLMDPXU .DQGXQJDQ VHQ\DZD ODLQ WHUGDSDW SDGD GDXQ EDQJXQ EDQJXQ DGDODK IODYRQRO \DQJ GDSDW
PHQJKDPEDWSHUGDUDKDQGDQVDSRQLQ\DQJ EHNHUMD VHEDJDL DQWLPLNURED 6DMLPLQ 3XUZDQWDUL6XWHGL 2\R
+DVLO8ML/DQMXWDQ(NVWUDN(WDQRO)UDNVL Q+HNVDQDGDQ)UDNVL(WLO$VHWDWWHUKDGDS -DPXU$NDU3XWLK
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
*DPEDU-DPXU$NDU3XWLKGLPHGLD3'$VHWHODKSHUODNXDQHNVWUDNEDQJXQEDQJXQ )LJXUH:KLWH5RRW'LVHDVHLQ3'$PHGLXPDIWHUWUHDWPHQWRIEDQJXQEDQJXQSODQWH[WUDFW D E P P *DPEDU0LVHOLXP-DPXU$NDU3XWLKSDGD.RQWURODGDQ3HUODNXDQE )LJXUH0LFHOOLXPRI:KLWH5RRW'LVHDVHLQFRQWURODDQGWUHDWPHQWVE.(6,038/$1
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
3HQJHPEDQJDQ 3HUWDQLDQ DWDV SHPEHULDQ GDQD SHQHOLWLDQ PHODOXL SURJUDP ..31 G H Q J D Q Q R P R U N R Q W U D N +0,. 7DQJJDO 0DUHW
'$)7$53867$.$
%LODOLV ' .DNDERXNL , .DUNDQLV $ 7UDYORV , 7ULDQWDI\OOLGLV 9 +HOD ' 6 H H G D Q G V D S R Q L Q S U R G X F W L R Q R I R U J D Q L F T X L Q R D &KHQRSRGLXP TXLQRD :LOOG IRU GLIIHUHQW WLOODJH DQG IHUWLOL]DWLRQ1RW %RW+RUWL$JURER
'HSDUWHPHQ.HVHKDWDQ5HSXEOLN,QGRQHVLD )DUPDNRSH,QGRQHVLD(GLVL,9 -DNDUWD ,QGRQHVLD 'HSDUWHPHQ .HVHKDWDQ
)DLUX]DK = 'DOLPXQWKH & , .DU\XGL 6XU\DPDQ 6 :LGKD\DWL : ( .HHIHNWLIDQ EHEHUDSD IXQJL DQWDJRQLV 7ULFKRGHUPD VS GDODP ELRIXQJLVLGD HQGRKHYHD WHUKDGDS S H Q \ D N L W M D P X U D N D U S X W L K 5LJLGRSRUXV PLFURSRUXV GL ODSDQJDQ
-XUQDO 3HQHOLWLDQ .DUHW
0DQMDPDODL $ 1DUDOD < +DULGDV $ *UDFH % 0 9 $QWLIXQJDO DQWLLQIODPPDWRU\ DQG *&06 RI PHWKDQROLF H[WUDFW RI 3OHFWUDQWKXV DPEERLQLFXV /HDI,QW - &XUU 3KDUP
5HV 1R .RQVHQWUDVL &RQFHQWUDWLRQ PJP/ 'LDPHWHUGDHUDKKDPEDWDQ 'LDPHWHURIDUHDLQKLELWLRQ PP (NVWUDNHWDQRO (WKDQROH[WUDFWLRQ )UDNVLQKHNVDQD QKH[DQHIUDFWLRQ )UDNVLHWLODVHWDW (WK\ODFHWDWHIUDFWLRQ $ % & ' ( *'062 .RQWURO )$TXDGHVW .RQWURO 7DEHO'DWDKDVLOSHQJXNXUDQGLDPHWHUUDWDUDWDGDHUDKKDPEDWSHUWXPEXKDQ-$3 7DEOH7KHDYHUDJHGLDPHWHURI:KLWH5RRW'LVHDVHDUHDLQKLELWLRQJURZWK
2GXJEHPL7$WH[WERRNRIPHGLFLQDO SODQWV IURP QLJHULD <RED/DJRV 1LJHULD8QLYHUVLW\RI/DJRV3UHVV 3DWHO 5 ' 0DKRELD 1 . 6LQJK 0 3
6LQJK$6KHLNK1:$ODP* 6LQJK 6 . $QWLR[LGDQW SRWHQWLDO RI OHDYHV RI 3OHFWUDQWKXV DPERLQLFXV /RXU 6SUHQJ 'HU 3KDUPDFLD/HWWUH
3UDVHW\R ' 3 6DVRQJNR + $NWLYLWDV DQWLEDNWHUL HNVWUDN HWDQRO GDXQNHUVHQ0XQWLQJLDFDODEXUD / WHUKDGDS EDNWHUL%DFLOOXV VXEWLOLV GDQ 6KLJHOOD G\VHQWHULDH VHEDJDL PDWHUL SHPEHODMDUDQ ELRORJL 60$ .HODV;XQWXNPHQFDSDL.GSDGD NXULNXOXP -83(0$6,3%,2
5DVLQHQL*.6LGGDYDWWDP' 5HGG\$ 5 )UHH UDGLFDO TXHQFKLQJ DFWLYLW\ DQG SRO\SKHQROV LQ WKUHH VSHFLHV RI&ROHXV- 0HGLFLQDO 3ODQW
5HV
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
6XU\DQWR ' 0XQLU ( 3RWHQVL LVRODW EDNWHUL NLWLQROLWLN ORNDO XQWXN SHQJHQGDOLDQ MDPXU KD\DWL3URVLGLQJ 6HPLQDU +DVLO+DVLO 3HQHOLWLDQ 8VX
S 0HGDQ ,QGRQHVLD
868
9DOHUD'5LYDV5$YLOD-/$XEHUW/ $ORQVRDPHODW 0 8VELOODJH $ 7KH HVVHQWLDO RLO RI &ROHXV D P E R L Q X V O R R U H U L R F K H P L F D O FRPSRVLWLRQ DQG HYDOXDWLRQ RI LQVHFW D Q W L I H H G D Q W H I I H F W V & L H Q F L D 0DUDFDLER9HQH]
