,3(1'$+8/8$1
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
8-,620$7,.,1.203$7,%,/,7$6
*DQRGHUPDVWH\DHUWDQXP
<$1*0(1<(5$1*
.(%81%(1,+
$FDFLDPDQJLXP:LOOG
',:212*,5,-$:$7(1*$+
6RPDWLF,QFRPSDWLELOLW\7HVW
*DQRGHUPDVWH\DHUWDQXP
ZKLFK$WWDFN6HHG2UFKDGRI
$FDFLD
PDQJLXP
DW:RQRJLUL&HQWUDO-DYD
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
*DQRGHUPDVWH\DHUWDQXPPHUXSDNDQSHQ\HEDESHQ\DNLWEXVXNDNDU\DQJPHQ\HUDQJ$FDFLDPDQJLXP7XMXDQGDUL SHQHOLWLDQLQLXQWXNPHOLKDWNHUDJDPDQJHQHWLN*VWH\DHUWDQXPPHQJJXQDNDQXMLVRPDWLNLQNRPSDWLELOLWDV.HEXQ %HQLK$PDQJLXP)GL:RQRJLUL-DZD7HQJDK0DWHULJHQHWLNEHUXSDLVRODW*VWH\DHUWDQXP\DQJGLSHUROHKGDUL .HEXQ%HQLK$PDQJLXP)GL:RQRJLUL-DZD7HQJDK6HWLDSLVRODWGLSDVDQJNDQGHQJDQLVRODWODLQQ\DGDQGLXODQJ NDOL3HQHOLWLDQGLODNXNDQGHQJDQPHQJDPDWLPRUIRORJLMDPXUGDQVNRULQJPHQJJXQDNDQPHWRGH/DWLIDK+R\DQJ WHODK GLPRGLILNDVL +DVLO XML VRPDWLN LQNRPSDWLELOLWDV PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD VHPXD SDVDQJDQ LVRODW GHQJDQ VHVDPDQ\DVHOISDLULQJPHPEHULNDQUHDNVLNRPSDWLEHOVHGDQJNDQLVRODW\DQJEHUSDVDQJDQGHQJDQEXNDQGLULQ\D PHQXQMXNNDQUHDNVL LQNRPSDWLEHO* VWH\DHUWDQXP \DQJ PHQ\HUDQJNHEXQ EHQLK$ PDQJLXP ) GL:RQRJLUL PHPLOLNLNHUDJDPDQJHQHWLN\DQJWLQJJLGDQWLGDNEHUDVDOGDULNORQ\DQJVDPDGDQLGHQWLN5HDNVLLQNRPSDWLEHO GLWXQMXNNDQ GHQJDQ SHPEHQWXNDQ ]RQD MDUDQJ ]RQD EHQGXQJDQ GDQ SLJPHQWDVL EHUZDUQD FRNHODW RUDQ\H NHPHUDKDQ
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
3HQHOLWLDQLQLEHUWXMXDQXQWXNPHQJXMLVRPD WLNLQNRPSDWLELOLWDVWHUKDGDSVHUDQJDQMDPXU* VWH\DHUWDQXP SHQ\HEDE SHQ\DNLW EXVXN DNDU SDGDWDQDPDQPDQJLXP\DQJPHQ\HUDQJNHEXQ EHQLK PDQJLXP JHQHUDVL SHUWDPD GL :RQRJLUL -DZD7HQJDK7HVVRPDWLNLQNRPSDWLELOLWDVPHUX SDNDQ VDODK VDWX FDUD XQWXN PHPDKDPL SROD SHQ\HEDUDQ SHQ\DNLW DJDU GDSDW GLNHPEDQJNDQ FDUDFDUD XQWXN PHQFHJDK PHOXDVQ\D VHUDQJDQ SHQ\DNLW
,,0(72'(3(1(/,7,$1 $,VRODW-DPXU*VWH\DHUWDQXP
,VRODW MDPXU* VWH\DHUWDQXPEHUDVDO GDUL LVRODVL WXEXK EXDK MDPXU \DQJ WXPEXK SDGD SDQJNDOEDWDQJWDQDPDQPDQJLXPGHQJDQQRPRU SRKRQ \DQJ EHUEHGDEHGD GL NHEXQ EHQLK PDQJLXP JHQHUDVL SHUWDPD :RQRJLUL -DZD 7HQJDK,GHQWLILNDVLMHQLVMDPXUGLODNXNDQVHFDUD PRUIRORJLWHUKDGDSLVRODWKDVLOLVRODVLWXEXKEXDK MDPXU ,VRODW GLWXPEXKNDQ SDGD PHGLD 3'$ 3RWDWR'HNVWURVH$JDUGHQJDQNRQVHQWUDVL JU PO DTXDGHV $GD LVRODW MDPXU*DQR GHUPD \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ GDODP SHQHOLWLDQ LQL 'HODSDQLVRODWWHUVHEXWDGDODK $ %&' ()*+
,VRODW MDPXU *DQRGHUPD \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ XQWXN WHV VRPDWLN LQNRPSDWLELOLWDV GLVXENXOWXU GDULNROHNVLNXOWXU\DQJGLVLPSDQGDODPPHGLD \DQJ EHUEHQWXN DJDU PLULQJ NH GDODP SHWULGLVK LQLWLDOSODWH7XMXDQSHPEXDWDQLQLWLDOSODWHLQL DJDULVRODWMDPXUPHPSXQ\DLXPXU\DQJVHUDJDP GDQ SHUWXPEXKDQ \DQJ VHUDJDP GDODP KDO PHULVWHPDWLV YLDELOLWDV GDQ YLJRULWDV 3HQJDP ELODQGLODNXNDQVHFDUDDFDNDGD\DQJEHUDVDOGDUL SRKRQ \DQJ WHUOHWDN EHUGHNDWDQ VHUWD DGD \DQJ EHUDVDO GDUL SRKRQ \DQJ WHUOHWDN EHUMDXKDQ %HULNXW OHWDN SRKRQ PDQJLXP GL PDQD WXEXK EXDK*VWH\DHUWDQXPGLDPELOXQWXNXMLVRPDWLN LQNRPSDWLELOLWDV GDODP SHWD NHEXQ EHQLK PDQJLXP):RQRJLUL-DZD7HQJDK
.HWHUDQJDQ SRKRQ$PDQJLXPGHQJDQWXEXKEXDK*VWH\DHUWDQXP
*DPEDU)LJXUH 'LDJUDPVHEDUDQWXEXKEXDK*VWH\DHUWDQXPSDGDNHEXQEHQLK$PDQJLXP)GL :RQRJLUL-DZD7HQJDK'LDJUDPRIWKHVSUHDGRI*VWH\DHUWDQXPIUXLWERGLHVRQ WKHVHHGRUFKDGRI$PDQJLXP)LQ:RQRJLUL&HQWUDO-DYD
E
G
D
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
$ 3HQJXMLDQ 6RPDWLN ,QNRPSDWLELOLWDV MD
PXU*VWH\DHUWDQXP
3HQJXMLDQ VRPDWLN LQNRPSDWLELOLWDV GLODNX NDQXQWXNPHQJHWDKXLPRGHOSHQ\HEDUDQMDPXU * 6WH\DHUWDQXPGDODP VXDWX ORNDVL VHODLQ LWX GDSDW MXJD GLJXQDNDQ XQWXN PHQJHWDKXL NHUD JDPDQJHQHWLNGDULVDWXMHQLVMDPXU*VWH\DHU WDQXP 3URVHGXU SHQJXMLDQ XQWXN WHVW VRPDWLN LQNRPSDWLELOLWDV PHQXUXW /DWLID +R \DLWX 'XDLVRODWMDPXU*VWH\DHUWDQXPGLSDVDQJ NDQSDGDPHGLD3'$GDODPFDZDQSHWULEHU GLDPDWHUFP %ORNLQRNXOXPGLDPELOGDULLQLWLDOSODWHGH QJDQXNXUDQPP GLOHWDNNDQGHQJDQMDUDN ± PP DQWDU GXD LVRODW EHUGHNDWDQ WHWDSL WLGDN EHUVHQWXKDQ 3HPEXDWDQ EORN LQRNX OXP GLXVDKDNDQ PHPSXQ\DL XNXUDQ \DQJ VDPD DQWDUD \DQJ VDWX GHQJDQ \DQJ ODLQQ\D GDODP VHWLDS FDZDQ SHWUL DJDU PHPSXQ\DL SHUWXPEXKDQ\DQJVHUDJDP
,VRODWLQGXNSDUHQWVFXOWXUHGLEXDWGDULLQL WLDOSODWHXQWXNVHWLDSLVRODW\DQJDNDQGLXML WXMXDQQ\DVHEDJDLUHIHUHQVLLVRODWGDODPPHP EHULVNRUXMLSDVDQJDQ 0DVLQJPDVLQJ NRPELQDVL LVRODW \DQJ GLXML GDQLVRODWLQGXNGLEXDWGDODPXODQJDQ .XOWXUMDPXUGLLQNXEDVLSDGDVXKX &GD ODPUXDQJLQNXEDVL $GD DWDX WLGDNQ\D NRQWDPLQDVL GLDPDWL GDQ
GLXNXU OXDV SHUWXPEXKDQ GHQJDQ PLOLPHWHU EORN VHWLDS KDUL VHNDOL KLQJJD PHQFDSDL SHQXKPHPHQXKLFDZDQSHWULDWDXNRQVWDQ +DVLOXMLSDVDQJDQGLHYDOXDVLVHWHODKKDULGL
WDQDPGHQJDQPHQLODLUHDNVLLQNRPSDWLELOLWDV DQWDULVRODWEHUGDVDUNDQWLQJNDWSHUWHQWDQJDQ Q\DGHQJDQPHQJJXQDNDQPHWRGH$GDVNDYHJ *LOEHUWVRQ GDODP /DWLIDK GDQ +R \DQJWHODKGLPRGLILNDVL/XDVPDVLQJ PDVLQJ MDPXU GLXNXU GHQJDQ PHQJXQDNDQ PLOLPHWHU EORN VHWLDS KDUL VHNDOL KLQJJD PHQFDSDLSHQXKPHPHQXKLFDZDQSHWULDWDX NRQVWDQ
%$QDOLVLV'DWD
'DWD\DQJGLSHUROHKEHUXSDIRWRIRWRGLDQDOL VLVVHFDUDGHVNULSWLIVHGDQJNDQGDWDOXDVGLXNXU PHQJJXQDNDQ NHUWDV PLOOLPHWHU EORN GDQ KDVLO Q\DGLNRQYHUVLNHGDODPVDWXDQPP
,,,+$6,/'$13(0%$+$6$1 $ 'DWD6NRULQJ8ML6RPDWLN,QNRPSDWLELOL
WDV-DPXU*VWH\DHUWDQXP
+DVLOGDULXMLSDVDQJDQGXDLVRODWMDPXU*VWH\D HUWDQXPEDLN VHFDUDVHOISDLULQJ DWDX GHQJDQ LVRODW \DQJ EHUEHGD SRKRQ PHQXQMXNNDQ UHDNVL \DQJEHUEHGDXQWXNVHWLDSORNDVL5HDNVLSHPD VDQJDQ DQWDU GXD LVRODW MDPXU* VWH\DHUWDQXP GDSDWGLOLKDWSDGD7DEHO
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
*DPEDU)LJXUH .RORQLWXQJJDO\DQJWHUEHQWXNSDGDUHDNVLNRPSDWLEHOSDGDSDVDQJDQVHOISDLULQJ DWDPSDNDWDVGDQEWDPSDNEDZDK6LQJOHFRORQ\IRUPHGE\WKHFRPSDWLEOH UHDFWLRQRQVHOISDLULQJDUURZVLJQDWRSYLHZDQGEERWWRPYLHZ 5HDNVLNRPSDWLEHODWDXWLGDNDGDQ\DNHUDJD PDQJHQHWLNGLWHPXNDQSDGDXMLSDVDQJDQVHFDUD VHOISDLULQJ$$%%&&''(())* * ++ 3HPDVDQJDQ LVRODW MDPXU* VWH\D HUWDQXP WLGDN PHPEHQWXN JDULV SHPLVDK GL DQWDUD NHGXD PLVHOLXP 6HPXD LVRODW WXPEXK EHUVDPD GDQ PHQ\DWX GHQJDQ LVRODW \DQJ ODLQ PHPEHQWXNNRORQLWXQJJDOVHSHUWLSDGD*DPEDU DQWDUDSDVDQJDQLVRODW&+DOWHUVHEXWVDQJDW ZDMDUNDUHQDLVRODW\DQJGLSDVDQJNDQPHUXSDNDQ SDVDQJDQGHQJDQGLULQ\DVHQGLUL\DLWXSDVDQJDQ LVRODWEHUDVDOGDULNXOWXULQLWLDOSODWH\DQJVDPD \DQJ EHUDUWL EHUDVDO GDUL NORQ \DQJ VDPD MDGL WLGDNDNDQPHQXQMXNNDQUHDNVLLQNRPSDWLEHOGDQ DNDQ PHQ\DWX PHPEHQWXN NRORQL WXQJJDO 0HQXUXW :RUDOO WHUEHQWXNQ\D NRORQL WXQJJDO WHUVHEXW WHUMDGL NDUHQD PLVHOLD MDPXU VDOLQJ EHUJDEXQJ GDQ KLID PHQJDODPL DQDVWR PRVLV\DLWXSHQJJDEXQJDQGXDKLID\DQJEHUEHGD PHQMDGL KLID GLNDU\RWLN \DQJ GLLNXWL GHQJDQ SHUSLQGDKDQ LVL KLID $QDVWRPRVLV SDGD KLID ELDVDQ\D GLLNXWL GHQJDQ WHUEHQWXNQ\D VWUXNWXU VHSWDO NKXVXV SDGD PLVHOLD MDPXU \DQJ GLVHEXW GHQJDQFODPS FRQQHFWLRQ \DQJ PHUXSDNDQ FLUL NKDVSDGDJRORQJDQ%DVLGLRP\FHWHV
8QWXNOXDVMDPXUSDGDSDVDQJDQVHOISDLULQJ WLGDN PHPSHQJDUXKL DQWDU SDVDQJDQ LVRODW 0DVLQJPDVLQJMDPXUWLGDNVDOLQJPHQJKDPEDW SHUWXPEXKDQ GDQ VDOLQJ PHQ\DWX DQWDU SHUWH PXDQNHGXDPLVHOLXP*DPEDU+DOWHUVHEXW WHUMDGL NDUHQD NHGXD LVRODW MDPXU EHUDVDO GDUL NORQ \DQJ VDPD 7HUOLKDW PLVHOLXP GDUL NHGXD LVRODWVDOLQJPHQ\DWX
*DPEDU)LJXUH =RQDMDUDQJDQWDUPLVHOLXPSDGDUHDNVL\DQJLQNRPSDWLEHOWDQGDSDQDKDWDPSDN DWDV GDQ E WDPSDN EDZDK 5DUH ]RQH EHWZHHQ P\FHOLXPV LQ WKH LQFRPSDWLEOH UHDFWLRQDUURZVLJQDWRSYLHZDQGEERWWRPYLHZ
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
*DPEDU)LJXUH 3HPEHQWXNDQ]RQDEHQGXQJDQEHUXSDGLQGLQJVFOHURWLDWDQGDSDQDKDWDPSDNDWDV GDQEWDPSDNEDZDK7KHIRUPDWLRQRIWKHEDUUDJH]RQHRFFXUHGLQWKHIRUPRI VFOHURWLDDUURZVLJQDWRSYLHZDQGEERWWRPYLHZ
7DEHOOXDVLVRODWSDUHQWDOMDPXU*VWH\DHUWD QXPEDKZD LVRODW MDPXU ) VHGLNLW OHELK FHSDW GDULSDGDLVRODWMDPXU$VHKLQJJDSDGD*DPEDUE GDSDW WHUOLKDW MXJD EDKZD OXDV MDPXU ) VHGLNLW OHELKOXDVGDULMDPXU$
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
+DVLO UHDNVL LQNRPSDWLELOLWDV MXJD GLWXQMXN NDQGHQJDQDGDQ\DGLQGLQJSHPLVDK\DQJPHUX SDNDQGLQGLQJVFOHURWLDGDULSHQJJXPSDODQKLID \DQJ WHUEHQWXN SDGD SHUWHPXDQ GXD PLVHOLXP MDPXU6HSHUWLSDGD*DPEDU\DLWXDQWDUDSDVD QJDQLVRODW)GDQLVRODW+\DQJNHWLNDGLSDVDQJ NDQPHPEHQWXNGLQGLQJVFOHURWLD
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
' '
*DPEDU)LJXUH 3HPEHQWXNDQSLJPHQWDVLEHUZDUQDFRNHODWRUDQJHNHPHUDKDQDQDNSDQDKSDGD ]RQDJDULVGHPDUNDVL\DQJPHUXSDNDQSHUWHPXDQDQWDUGXDLVRODWSDGDXMLSDVDQJDQ $*DWDPSDNDWDVEWDPSDNEDZDK7KHIRUPDWLRQRIRUDQJHUHGGLVKEURZQ SLJPHQWDWLRQ DUURZ VLJQ RQ GHPDUFDWLRQ OLQH ]RQH ZKLFK LV WKH PHHWLQJ SRLQW EHWZHHQWZRLVRODWHVLQ$FRXSOHWHVWDUURZVLJQDWRSYLHZDQGEERWWRPYLHZ
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
%3HUWXPEXKDQ ,VRODW 3DUHQWDO -DPXU* VWH\DHUWDQXP
7DEHO PHQXQMXNNDQ OXDV LVRODW SDUHQWDO MDPXU*VWH\DHUWDQXP\DQJPHQFDSDLOXDVPDN VLPXP PHPHQXKL FDZDQ SHWUL GHQJDQ ZDNWX \DQJEHUEHGDEHGD
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
*DPEDU)LJXUH 8MLVRPDWLNLQNRPSDWLELOLWDVDQWDUDLVRODW%;(DWDPSDNDWDVEWDPSDNEDZDK 6RPDWLFLQFRPSDWLELOLW\%;(LVRODWH DWRSYLHZEERWWRPYLH Z
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
'$)7$53867$.$
'HSDUWHPHQ .HKXWDQDQ 3HUDWXUDQ 3HPHULQ WDK5HSXEOLN,QGRQHVLD1RPRU0HQKXW,, WHQWDQJ3HGRPDQ3HQLODLDQ.HEHUKDVLODQ 5HNODPDVL +XWDQ -DNDUWD .HPHQWHULDQ .HKXWDQDQ
'HSDUWHPHQ.HKXWDQDQ6WDWLVWLN.HKXWDQDQ ,QGRQHVLD 'HSDUWHPHQ .HKXWDQDQ -DNDUWD
)ULHV 1 6RPDWLF LQFRPSDWLELOLW\ DQG ILHOG GLVWULEXWLRQ RI WKH HFWRP\FRUUKL]DO IXQJXV
6XLOOXVOXWHXV%ROHWDFHDH1HZ3K\WRO *DQGMDU,QGUDZDWL6MDPVXULG]DO:GDQ$UL\DQWL2 0LNRORJL'DVDUGDQ7HUDSDQ-DNDUWD <D\DVDQ2ERU,QGRQHVLD *OHQ 0 1HDOH /% $QWKRQ\$) 6XVDQ 41 /HH665DJLO/.DUHQ0%&KULVWRSKHU /% 0RKDPPHG&/*DQRGHUPD DQG $PDXURGHUPD VSHFLHV DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK URRWURWGLVHDVHRI$PDQJLXPSODQWDWLRQWUHHV LQ,QGRQHVLDDQG0DOD\VLD$XVWUDODVLDQ3ODQW 3DWKRORJ\ *XOHU36RPDWLFLQFRPSDWLELOLW\LQ$JDULFXV ELWRUTXLV 4XHO 6DFF$IULFDQ -RXUQDO RI %LRWHFKQRORJK\
*XOHU 3 %LFHU + 7KH 6RPDWLF ,QFRPSDWLELOLW\ LQ7UDPHWHV YHUVLFRORU/ /\RG
+HQHVV\& 'DO\$*DQRGHUPD'LVHDVHV 'DUZLQ1RUWKHUQ7HUULWRU\*RYHUQPHQW3ODQW 3DWKRORJ\'LDJQRVWLF6HUYLFHV
+HUOL\DQD(1'DUPRQR7 +D\DWL0 3HQ\DNLWDNDU*DQRGHUPDVSSDGDVHQJRQGL -DZD %DUDW GDQ -DZD 7LPXU-XUQDO 0DQDMH PHQ+XWDQ7URSLND;9,,, +LGD\DWL18MLUHVLVWHQVLEXVXNDNDU/DSRUDQ
+DVLO 3HQHOLWLDQ %DODL %HVDU 3HQHOLWLDQ %LR WHNQRORJL GDQ 3HQHOLWLDQ 7DQDPDQ +XWDQ %DGDQ /LWEDQJ .HKXWDQDQ 7LGDN 'LSXEOL NDVLNDQ
/DWLIDK = +R <: 0RUSKRORJLFDO FKDUDFWHULVWLFVDQGVRPDWLFLQFRPSDWLELOLW\RI
*DQRGHUPD IURP ,QIHFWHG 2LO 3DOP IURP 7KUHH ,QODQG (VWDWHV0DOD\VLDQ -RXUQDO RI 0LFURELRORJ\
3XUZDQWLVDUL6 %XGL5+8MLDQWDJRQLV MDPXU 3K\WRSKWKRUD LQIHVWDQV SHQ\HEDE SHQ\DNLW EXVXN GDXQ GDQ XPEL WDQDPDQ NHQWDQJ GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ7ULFKRGHUPD VSS,VRODW/RNDO-XUQDO%LRPD 3XVSLWDVDUL ' 5LPEDZDQWR $ 8ML
VRPDWLN LQNRPSDWLELOLWDV*DQRGHUPD SKLOLS SLLXQWXNPHQJHWDKXLSRODSHQ\DNLWEXVXNDNDU SDGD WDQDPDQ $ PDQJLXP GDODP -XUQDO 3HPXOLDDQ7DQDPDQ+XWDQ
6XZDQGL +DPLGVRQ + 1DLWR 6 'LVWUL EXWLRQRI5LJLGRSRUXVOLJQRVXVJHQRW\SHLQD UXEEHU SODQWDWLRQ DV UHOHYHDG E\ VRPDWLF FRPSDWLELOLW\0\FRVFLHQFH :RUDOO -- 6RPDWLF LQFRPSDWLELOLW\ LQ %DVLGLRP\FHWHV0\FRORJLD :RUDOO--6XPPHUKHDWDQGDQHSLGHPLFRI F\WRVSRUDFDQNHURI$OQXV&DQDGLDQ-RXUQDO RI3ODQW3DWKRORJ\
