3UREOHPRI3LQH)RUHVW+\GURORJLFDO$VSHFWVDQG7KHLU3RVVLEOH
6ROXWLRQV
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
3DGD WDKXQ PXODL WLPEXO SHQGDSDW EDKZD VHWHODK EXNLW VHNLWDUQ\D GLWDQDPL GHQJDQ WXVDP PDND WHUMDGL SHQXUXQDQ GHELW VXPEHU PDWD DLU GL GHVD *RPERQJ 3HNDORQJDQ 7LPXU .HPXGLDQPXQFXOMXJDSHUPDVDODKDQSHQDQDPDQWXVDPSDGD086%$1*+871$6GL%HGXJXO %DOLWDKXQ7DKXQWHUEHQWXNSHQGDSDWPDV\DUDNDWGLNDEXSDWHQ&LODFDS-DZD7HQJDK EDKZDNHEHUDGDDQKXWDQWXVDPWHODKPHQ\HEDENDQWXUXQQ\DGHELWVXPEHUPDWDDLUGDQKDO\DQJ VDPDWHUMDGLMXJDGLGHVD3DGDQJ*DQVLQJ7DQDK'DWDU6XPDWUD%DUDWWDKXQ
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
7XOLVDQ LQL GLPDNVXGNDQ XQWXN PHPEHULNDQ JDPEDUDQ WHQWDQJ WXVDP VHEDJDL WDQDPDQ VHFDUDVHLPEDQJGDULVLVLEXUXNPDXSXQVLVLEDLNQ\DGDQFDUDPHQ\LNDSLKDOWHUVHEXWWHUPDVXN SHQGHNDWDQVHFDUDNHOHPEDJDDQ
,,%(%(5$3$3(1'$3$70(1*(1$,3(1*$58+3(1$1$0$1'$1 3(1(%$1*$1786$07(5+$'$3.(.(5,1*$1'$1%$1-,5
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
GLODNXNDQNDODXRUDQJWLGDNPDXNHNHULQJDQ6DPSXUQR.HHPSDWGLVDDWPXVLPSHQJKXMDQ GDWDQJGDQEDQMLUPXODLPHQJDQFDPWLPEXOSHQGDSDW\DQJELDVDQ\DOHELKFHQGHUXQJPHQ\XGXWNDQ NHKXWDQDQEDQMLU\DQJWHUMDGLGLVHEDENDQROHKUXVDNQ\DKXWDQSHPEDEDWDQKXWDQ
3HQGDSDWGDQNHGXDQ\DEHUWLWLNWRODNSDGDDGDQ\DSHQDQDPDQKXWDQWHWDSLVHSHUWLQ\D PHPSXQ\DL SHQJDUXK \DQJ EHUEHGD \DQJ VDWX PHQJDWDNDQ VHWHODK SHQDQDPDQ KXWDQ PDND WHUMDGLSHQXUXQDQGHELWVXPEHUPDWDDLUVHGDQJNDQ\DQJVDWXQ\DPHQJDWDNDQSHQDQDPDQPXWODN GLODNXNDQDJDUWLGDNNHNHULQJDQ
'HPLNLDQSXODGHQJDQSHQGDSDWGDQNHGXDQ\DEHUWLWLNWRODNSDGDDGDQ\DSHQHEDQJDQ SHQJJXQGXODQKXWDQWHWDSLSHQJDUXK\DQJGLWLPEXONDQQ\DEHUEHGD\DQJVDWXPHQJDWDNDQNDUHQD SHQJJXQGXODQSHQHEDQJDQ KXWDQ PHQJDNLEDWNDQ EHUNXUDQJQ\D DLU VHGDQJNDQ \DQJ ODLQQ\D PHQJDWDNDQNDUHQDUXVDNQ\DKXWDQSHPEDEDWDQKXWDQPDNDWHUMDGLEDQMLU
3HUQ\DWDDQSHUQ\DWDDQGLDWDVPHUXSDNDQPDVDODK\DQJKDUXVGLVHOHVDLNDQROHKNHKXWDQDQ NDUHQDNHJLDWDQSHQDQDPDQSRKRQKXWDQGDQSHQHEDQJDQKXWDQSRKRQPHUXSDNDQNHJLDWDQ NHKXWDQDQ 0DNVXG SHUQ\DWDDQSHUQ\DWDDQ WHUVHEXW VHEHQDUQ\D EDLN QDPXQ NDUHQD VDODK SHQJHUWLDQ DWDX VDODK LQWHUSUHWDVL GDUL DGDQ\D LQIRUPDVL DWDX SXEOLNDVL \DQJ GLDPELO VHSRWRQJ VHSRWRQJVHKLQJJDPHQLPEXONDQNRQWURYHUVLGDODPPHPDQGDQJVHVXDWXSURVHVDWDXNHJLDWDQ %HULNXWDGDODKJDPEDUDQVLQJNDWWHQWDQJSHQGDSDWSHQGDSDWWHUVHEXW $3HQDQDPDQ7XVDP0HQXUXQNDQ'HELW6XPEHU0DWD$LU 6HPXDMHQLVSRKRQGDSDWPHPEDQWXGDODPSURVHVSHQHULPDDQGDQSHQ\LPSDQDQDLUGDULDLU KXMDQNHGDODPSURILOWDQDKWHWDSLVHPXDMHQLVSRKRQPHPEXWXKNDQDLUXQWXNSHUNHPEDQJDQGDQ SHUWXPEXKDQQ\D$LUWHUVHEXWGLDPELOROHKSRKRQPHODOXLDNDUQ\DGDULGDODPWDQDK2OHKNDUHQDLWX GDODPKDOSHQDQDPDQMHQLVSRKRQDSDODJLXQWXNVNDODOXDVWHUPDVXNWXVDPWLGDNEROHKDVDOWDQDP WHWDSLKDUXVPHODOXLSHUWLPEDQJDQVHSHUWLSHPLOLKDQMHQLVSRKRQNHVHVXDLDQODKDQWHPSDWWXPEXK NHVHVXDLDQ LNOLP NKXVXVQ\D FXUDK KXMDQ WDKXQDQ QLODL NHEXWXKDQ DLUFRQVXPSWLYH XVH DWDX HYDSRWUDQVSLUDVLMHQLVSRKRQ\DQJDNDQGLWDQDPGDQUHVSRQGDULPDV\DUDNDWVHWHPSDW
-HQLVSRKRQ\DQJPHPSXQ\DLQLODLHYDSRWUDQVSLUDVLWLQJJLDSDELODGLWDQDPSDGDGDHUDK\DQJ PHPSXQ\DLFXUDKKXMDQWDKXQDQUHODWLIUHQGDKEDKNDQOHELKUHQGDKGDULHYDSRWUDQVSLUDVLMHQLV SRKRQ \DQJ DNDQ GLWDQDP PDND VXGDK SDVWL DNDQ WHUMDGL KDOKDO \DQJ WLGDN GLLQJLQNDQ VHSHUWL PHQXUXQQ\D GHELW VXPEHU PDWD DLU 1DPXQ LVX WHQWDQJ PHQJHULQJQ\D VXPEHU PDWD DLU VHULQJ GLVDODK JXQDNDQ XQWXN WXMXDQWXMXDQ WHUWHQWX ROHK SLKDNSLKDN WHUWHQWX \DQJ PHQXPSDQJ LVX WHUVHEXW GDQ PHQXPSDQJ NRQGLVLVLWXDVL \DQJ GLWLPEXONDQ ROHK IHQRPHQD LNOLP VHSHUWL (O 1LQR VHKLQJJD VHRODKRODK WXVDP VHEDJDL SHQ\HEDE SHQXUXQDQPHQJHULQJQ\D VXPEHU PDWD DLU NHPXGLDQWDQDPDQWHUVHEXW\DQJGLVDODKNDQ %$LU%HUNXUDQJ.DUHQD3HQJJXQGXODQ+XWDQ 3HQGDSDWLQLNHEDOLNDQGDULSHQGDSDWGLDWDV3HQGDSDWLQLPHQ\DWDNDQEDKZDSHQJJXQGXODQ KXWDQSHQHEDQJDQKXWDQPHQ\HEDENDQWHUMDGLQ\DNHNXUDQJDQDLU 8QWXNPHQMHODVNDQSHUQ\DWDDQLQLSHUOXSHQGHNDWDQGHQJDQDNLEDWDNLEDW\DQJGLWLPEXONDQ ROHKDGDQ\DSHQJJXQGXODQSHQHEDQJDQKXWDQ$GDQ\DSHQJJXQGXODQSHQHEDQJDQKXWDQDNDQ PHQLPEXONDQDQWDUDODLQ+LODQJQ\DWHJDNDQKXWDQGDQVHPXDNRPSRQHQ\DQJNHEHUDGDDQ\D NDUHQDKXWDQVHSHUWLKLODQJQ\DWDMXNVHUDVDKGDQKXPXVVHKLQJJDWDQDKWLGDNWHUOLQGXQJDLUKXMDQ ODQJVXQJPHQFDSDLWDQDKVHEDJLDQEHVDUPHQMDGLDOLUDQSHUPXNDDQGDQPHQLPEXONDQHURVL\DQJ GDSDWPHQ\HEDENDQWDQDKPHQMDGLPLVNLQ+LODQJQ\DWHJDNDQVHUWDEDKDQRUJDQLNVHUDVDKGDQ
KXPXV VHEDE HURVL PHQJDNLEDWNDQ SHUPXNDDQ WDQDK PHQMDGL SDGDW DNDQ PHPSHQJDUXKL NHPDPSXDQWDQDKXQWXNPHORORVNDQDLUPHUHVDSNDQDLUNHGDODPSURILOWDQDKPHQMDGLNHFLOGDQ PHQLQJNDWNDQNRHILVLHQDOLUDQSHUPXNDDQDNLEDWQ\DDOLUDQSHUPXNDDQEHUWDPEDKEHVDU.RQGLVL WHUVHEXW DNDQ PHPSHUFHSDW SURVHV SHQJHULQJDQ DLU PHODOXL DOLUDQ SHUPXNDDQ VHODPD PXVLP SHQJKXMDQ VHKLQJD SHPDVRNDQ DLU XQWXN PHQJLVL NHOHPEDEDQ WDQDK GDQ VXPEHU DLU WDQDK EHUNXUDQJNHFLO+DOWHUVHEXWPHQJDNLEDWNDQEHUNXUDQJQ\DNHWHUVHGLDDQDLUSDGDPXVLPNHPDUDX +LODQJQ\DWDMXNDNDQPHQJKLODQJNDQSDQDVODWHQWUDQVSLUDVLPHQJDNLEDWNDQPHQLQJNDWQ\DVXKX XGDUDPHQLQJNDWQ\DNHFHSDWDQDQJLQPHQLQJNDWQ\DSHQJXDSDQGDUL SHUPXNDDQWDQDKPHQXUXQNDQNHOHPEDEDQXGDUDVHKLQJJDLNOLPPLNURPHQMDGLWLGDN Q\DPDQ+LODQJQ\DWHJDNDQKXWDQGLLNXWLPDNLQEHUNXUDQJQ\DKLODQJQ\DDNWLYLWDVGDULPDVVD SHUDNDUDQGDQPLNURELRORJLVHKLQJJDLNDWDQWDQDKPHQMDGLOHPDKGDQ+LODQJQ\DWHJDNDQKXWDQ SDGDKXWDQNDEXWFORXGIRUHVWPHQJDNLEDWNDQSHQXUXQDQSHUROHKDQDLUGDULNRQGHQVDVLNDEXWGDQ
IRJGULS
&3HQJKXWDQDQGL3HJXQXQJDQ3HJXQXQJDQ7HUXWDPDGL:LOD\DK*XQXQJ$SL0XWODN 'LODNXNDQ.DODX2UDQJ7LGDN0DX.HNHULQJDQ
'DHUDKSHJXQXQJDQDSDODJLZLOD\DKJXQXQJDSLXPXPQ\DDGDODKPHUXSDNDQGDHUDKKXOX DWDXGLVHEXWKHDGZDWHUFDWFKPHQWVGDQPHUXSDNDQGDHUDKSHPDVRNDLUDWDXGLVHEXWUHFKDUJHDUHD EDJLVXPEHUDLUGLEDZDKQ\D
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
'%DQMLU7HUMDGL.DUHQD.HUXVDNDQ+XWDQ 3HUQ\DWDDQLQLEHUDZDOGDULDQJJDSDQDWDXKDUDSDQEDKZDDSDNDKNRQGLVLKXWDQVHEDJDL SHQFHJDKEDQMLUPDPSXEHUSHUDQVHEDJDLSHQFHJDKEDQMLU\DQJEHUEDKD\D"<DPLQ%DQMLU \DQJEHUEDKD\DXPXPQ\DWHUMDGLGHQJDQGLGDKXOXLROHKFXUDKKXMDQ\DQJWLQJJL\DQJEHUODQJVXQJ SDGDZDNWX\DQJODPDDWDXNHMDGLDQKXMDQ\DQJEHUNHODQMXWDQEHUWXUXWDQ+XMDQ\DQJWLQJJLGDQ EHUODQJVXQJODPDEHUKDULKDULDWDXKXMDQ\DQJWLQJJL\DQJWHUMDGLFXNXSODPDGLVXDWXGDHUDK NHPXGLDQPHUHGDUHODWLIODPDNHPXGLDQWHUMDGLODJLKXMDQ\DQJUHODWLIWLQJJLGDQUHODWLIODPDGDSDW PHQJDNLEDWNDQNHPDPSXDQGDULVHPXDEHQWXNSHQ\LPSDQDQSHQDPSXQJDQVWRUDJHDLUPHQMDGL MHQXKEDKNDQOHZDWMHQXKVHKLQJJDVHPXDEHQWXNSHQDPSXQJDQSHQ\LPSDQDQWLGDNHIHNWLIODJL PDNDDNDQWHUMDGLEDQMLUEHVDU0HQXUXW:LQDUVRNRQGLVLEDQMLUDWDXJHQDQJDQDLU\DQJNLDQ EHUNHPEDQJGDQEHUDJDPEHUDVDOGDULNRQGLVLHNVWUHPFXDFDGDQLNOLP\DQJPHQJKDVLONDQNRQGLVL FXUDKDQKXMDQ\DQJOHEDWPHOXDVGDQEHUNHSDQMDQJDQ
%HEHUDSD EHQWXNPDFDP SHQDPSXQJDQSHQ\LPSDQDQ DLU WHUVHEXW PHQXUXW +HZOOHW GDQ 1XWWHU DGDODK 3HQDPSXQJDQ DLU KXMDQ ROHK LQWHUVHSVL,QWHUFHSWLRQ VWRUDJH
3HQDPSXQJDQDLUROHKSHUPXNDDQ6XUIDFHGHWHQWLRQVWRUDJH 3HQDPSXQJDQDLUROHKODQWDL KXWDQ)RUHVWIORRUGHQWLWLRQVWRUDJH3HQDPSXQJDQDLUROHKGHSUHVL'HSUHVVLRQVWRUDJH 3HQDPSXQJDQDLUNHOHPEDEDQWDQDK6RLOPRLVWXUHVWRUDJH3HQDPSXQJDQDLUWDQDK*URXQG
ZDWHUVWRUDJHGDQ3HQDPSXQJDQDLUVDOXUDQDWDXV\VWHPVDOXUDQVXQJDL&KDQQHOVWRUDJH
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
/RQJVRUODQG VOLGH GDSDW WHUMDGL SDGD NDZDVDQ \DQJ GLEDZDK WDQDK WHUGDSDW ODSLVDQ EDWXDQOLDW\DQJNHGDSDLUGDQPLULQJGDQGDODPNRQGLVLMHQXKDLUVHKLQJJDPDVVDWDQDKGLDWDV ODSLVDQ WHUVHEXW PHOXQFXU GLDWDV ODSLVDQ NHGDS DLU WHUVHEXW VHKLQJJD SHUPXNDDQ ODSLVDQ \DQJ NHGDSDLUWHUVHEXWVHEDJDLELGDQJOXQFXU
6HWHODKWHUMDGLWDQDKUXQWXKORQJVRUWHUVHEXWPDNDPDVVDWDQDK\DQJUXQWXKDWDXORQJVRU
GHEULVDYDODQFKHVWHUVHEXWEHUVDPDDOLUDQDLUGDQVHPXDPDWHUL\DQJEHUVDPDUXQWXKDWDXORQJVRU
WHUEDZDDOLUDQDLU\DQJEHVDUPHQMDGLPXGVDQGIORZGHEULVIORZPDVVZDVKLQJGDQPHQHUMDQJDSD VDMD\DQJGLOHZDWLQ\DNHMDGLDQWHUVHEXWELDVDQ\DGLVHEXWEDQMLUEDQGDQJ
$SDELODNRQGLVLQ\DVXGDKVHSHUWLLWXPDNDKXWDQVHEDJDLSHQJHQGDOLDOLUDQVXGDKWLGDNHIHNWLI ODJLEDKNDQSRKRQSRKRQKXWDQGDSDWLNXWWHUEDZDROHKEDQMLUEDQGDQJWHUVHEXW)XQJVLKXWDQ VHEDJDLIDNWRUSHQJHQGDOLDOLUDQNHPDPSXDQQ\DWLGDNWDNWHUEDWDVWHWDSLWHUJDQWXQJSDGDFXUDK KXMDQ MXPODK GDQ LQWHQVLWDV WRSRJUDIL NHPLULQJDQ OHUHQJ MHQLV GDQ VLIDW WDQDK DWDX NRQGLVL JHRORJL 6HODPD FXUDK KXMDQ PDVLK EHUDGD GLEDZDK NHPDPSXDQ WXMXK EHQWXN SHQDPSXQJDQ VHSHUWLGLDWDVGLKDUDSNDQEDQMLU\DQJEHUEDKD\DWLGDNWHUMDGL
'L VDPSLQJ LWX NHPDPSXDQ SHQDPSXQJDQ GDUL PDFDPPDFDP SHQDPSXQJDQ GLDWDV GLSHQJDUXKLSXODROHKNRQGLVLWDWDUXDQJWDWDJXQDODKDQIDVLOLWDVGUDLQDVHNHEHUDGDDQUHVHUYRLU DODPLVHSHUWLGDQDXVLWXUDZDGDQVWRUDJHEXDWDQODLQQ\D
,,,6,6,%$,.'$16,6,%858.786$0
7XVDPVHEDJDLWDQDPDQPHPSXQ\DLVLVLEXUXNGDQVLVLEDLN6LVLEDLNDGDODKQLODLQLODL\DQJ PHPEHULNDQ NHXQWXQJDQ GDQ NHPXGDKDQ DSDELOD GLEXGLGD\DNDQ GHQJDQ EDLN VHGDQJ VLVL EXUXNQ\DDGDODKQLODLQLODL\DQJGLDQJJDSWLGDNPHQJXQWXQJNDQWHUXWDPDGLWLQMDXGDULOLQJNXQJDQ
7DEHO 6LIDWVLIDW WXVDP 7DEOH3URSHUWLHVRISLQH
6LIDW3URSHUWLHV 6LVLEDLN*RRGVLGH 6LVLEXUXN%DGVLGH
$NDUSDQMDQJGDQGDODP 6LPELRVLVPXWXDOLWLV GHQJDQMHQLVPLNRUL]D &HSDWWXPEXK &HSDWVHEDJDLSHOLQGXQJ &HSDWPHQJKDVLONDQJHWDK %DQ\DNPHQJJXQDNDQ DLUPLQHUDOGDULWDQDK 3LRQHUEDQ\DNUDJDP WHPSDWWXPEXK 'D\DWDKDQKLGXSOHELKWLQJJL 7DKDQNHEDNDUDQGDSDWWXQDV WXPEXKVHWHODKNHEDNDUDQ 'DXQMDUXPNHUDV 6XOLWODPEDWWHUGHNRPSRVLVL 6XOLWPHQMDGLKXPXV KXPXVWLGDNVHPSXUQD %DQ\DNPHQJLNDWKDUD %DQ\DNPHQJDPELODLU 3+UHQGDK 7DMXNUHODWLIWLGDNEHUDW GDQWLGDNULQJDQ 5HODWLI 5HODWLI $6LVL%DLN7XVDP 7DQDPDQSLRQLU
7XVDP VHEDJDL WDQDPDQ SLRQLU \DQJ GDSDW WXPEXK SDGD EDQ\DN UDJDP WHPSDW WXPEXK 0HQXUXW :HEE GNN GDODP 3XGMLKDUWD WXVDP GDSDW WXPEXK SDGD NRQGLVL GDHUDK VHSHUWLSDGD7DEHO 7DEHO.RQGLVLWHPSDWWXPEXKWXVDP 7DEOH6LWH&RQGLWLRQRISLQH -HQLVSRKRQ 7UHHVSHFLHV &XUDKKXMDQ 5DLQIDOOPP .HWLQJJLDQWHPSDWPGSO 6LWHHOHYDWLRQDVO R 6XKXXGDUD & R 7HPSHUDWXUH& 7XVDP&RQWLQHQWDO SURYHQDQFH ! 7XVDP,VODQGSURYHQDQFH GDQOHELK
&HSDWWXPEXK 7XVDP\DQJWHUJRORQJWDQDPDQFHSDWWXPEXKDNDQOHELKPHQJXQWXQJNDQVHEDJDLSHOLQGXQJ WDQDKWHUXWDPDXQWXNWDQDKWDQDK\DQJWLGDNVXEXUGDQSDGDSDGDQJDODQJDODQJSDGDGDWDUDQ WLQJJLPDXSXQGDWDUDQUHQGDK 7DKDQNHEDNDUDQ %HUEHGDGHQJDQMHQLVSRKRQODLQQ\DWXVDPGDSDWWXPEXKGDQPHQ\HEDUVHFDUDDODPVHWHODK WHUMDGLNHEDNDUDQVHGDQJMHQLVSRKRQODLQQ\DPDWLVHWHODKNHEDNDUDQ 0HPEHULNDQNHXQWXQJDQUHODWLIFHSDW
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
7DEHO3HOHSDVDQKDUDNHWDQDKGDULVHUDVDKGDXQMDUXPGDQVHUDVDKGDXQOHEDU 7DEOH([KDXVWRIQXWULWLRQWRVRLOIURPQHHGOHOHDYHVDQGEURDGOHDYHVOLWWHUIDOO +DUDPLQHUDOOEDFUH1XWULWLRQOEDFUH -HQLVVHUDVDK6SHFLHVOLWWHUIDOO 1 3 . &D 0J 'DXQMDUXP1HDGOHOHDYHG 'DXQOHEDU%URDGOHDYHG 0HQ\HEDENDQWDQDKGLEDZDKWHJDNDQWXVDPEHUHDNVLPDVDP 'L VDPSLQJ VLIDWVLIDW \DQJ NXUDQJ PHQJXQWXQJNDQ GL DWDV WXVDP MXJD GLDQJJDS PHQ\HEDENDQWDQDKGLEDZDKWXVDPFHQGHUXQJPHQ\HEDENDQS+UHQGDK0HQXUXW6DJDOD
GDODP %UDPDVWR S+ WDQDK ORNDVL VXPEHU EHQLK WXVDP GL &LOLOLQ %DQMDUDQ &LNROH GDQ
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
,96,5.8/$6,$,53$'$786$0
6HEHQDUQ\DVHWLDSMHQLVSRKRQWHJDNDQSRKRQPHPSXQ\DLIXQJVLGDODPVLUNXODVLDLU3DGD NHVHPSDWDQLQLDNDQGLEDKDVWHQWDQJVLUNXODVLDLUSDGDMHQLVWXVDP6LUNXODLDLUSDGDWHJDNDQSRKRQ WHUPDVXNWXVDPGLJDPEDUNDQROHKOLPDSURVHV\DLWX,QWHUVHSVLWDMXN&URZQLQWHUFHSWLRQ$LU ORORVDLUWHPEXV7KURXJKIDOO$OLUDQEDWDQJ6WHPIORZ(YDSRWUDQVSLUDVL&RQVXPSWLYHXVH GDQ$OLUDQSHUPXNDDQ6XUIDFHUXQRIIGLEDZDKWHJDNDQ
:DODXSXQVHPXDMHQLVWHJDNDQGDSDWEHUIXQJVLGDODPVLUNXODVLDLUDWDXSXQWUDQVIHUDLUPHODOXL SURVHVSURVHV LQWHUVHSVL WDMXN DOLUDQ EDWDQJ DLU WHPEXVORORV HYDSRWUDQVSLUDVL GDQ DOLUDQ SHUPXNDDQ WHWDSL WHQWXQ\D EHUEHGD GDODP QLODLEHVDUQ\D DLU \DQJ WHUMDGL SDGD PDVLQJPDVLQJ SURVHV GL DWDV$GDSXQ \DQJ GLPDNVXG GHQJDQ SURVHVSURVHV VLUNXODVL DLUSHUHGDUDQ DLU SDGD WHJDNDQWXVDPDGDODKVHEDJDLEHULNXWLQL
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
7DEHO ,QWHUVHSVL DLU ORORV DOLUDQ EDWDQJ HYDSRWUDQVSLUDVL GDQ DOLUDQ SHUPXNDDQ SDGD WHJDNDQWXVDP 7DEOH ,QWHUFHSWLRQWKURXJKIDOOVWHPIORZHYDSRWUDQVSLUDWLRQDQGVXUIDFHUXQRIIRI3LQH VWDQG ,QWHUVHSVL ,QWHUFHSWLRQ $LUORORV 7URXJKIDOO $OLUDQEDWDQJ 6WHDPIORZ (YDSRWUDQV SLUDVL (YDSRWUDQV SLUDWLRQ $OLUDQSHUPXNDDQ 6XUIDFHUXQRII .HWH UDQJDQ 'HVFULS WLRQ -HQLV SRKRQ 7UHH VSHFLHV 8PXUWK $JH \HDU &XUDK KXMDQ 5DLQIDOO PP PP PP PP PP PP 7XVDP
6XPEHU6RXUFH 3XGMLKDUWDGDQ6DODWD8PDU3XGMLKDUWD
3XGMLKDUWD$VPXULGDODP3XGMLKDUWD
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
%3HUROHKDQ$LUGDUL+XMDQ1HWWR$LU/RORV$LU%DWDQJ
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
'(YDSRWUDQVSLUDVL&RQVXPWLYH8VH7XVDP
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
)5HDNVL7DQDKGL%DZDK7HJDNDQ7XVDP&HQGHUXQJ0DVDP
8QWXNPHQLQJNDWNDQS+WDQDKGLEDZDKWHJDNDQWXVDP\DQJEHUHDNVLPDVDPS+UHQGDK GDSDWGLDWDVLGHQJDQSHPEHULDQEDKDQGRORPLW&D0J&2
9,3(1'(.$7$16(&$5$.(/(0%$*$$1
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
0DNLQ OXDVQ\D KXWDQ WDQDPDQ WXVDP WHUQ\DWD WHODK PHUHVDKNDQ VHEDJLDQ PDV\DUDNDW WHUXWDPDPDV\DUDNDWVHNLWDUDWDXPDV\DUDNDW\DQJPHQHULPDGDPSDNQHJDWLIGDULDGDQ\DKXWDQ WDQDPDQWHUVHEXW:DODXSXQNHEHUDGDDQKXWDQWDQDPDQWXVDPWHODKGLWRODNVHEDJLDQPDV\DUDNDW QDPXQEXNDQEHUDUWLWDQDPDQWHUVHEXWWLGDNEROHKGLWDQDPGLEXGLGD\DNDQOHELKOHELKWXVDPROHK 3HUXP3HUKXWDQLPHQMDGLMHQLVNHODVSHUXVDKDDQNHGXDVHWHODKNHODVSHUXVDKDDQMDWL7HFWRQD JUDQGLV $JDUGDPSDNQHJDWLI\DQJGLGHULWDROHKVHEDJLDQPDV\DUDNDWGLVHNLWDUKXWDQWDQDPDQWXVDP GDSDWGLPLWLJDVLGDQSLKDNSHUXVDKDDQ3HUXP37GDQSHPHULQWDKWLGDNNHKLODQJDQEDKDQEDNX NRPRGLWDVQ\D PDND VHODLQ GHQJDQ PHQJXEDK WHKQLN EXGLGD\DQ\D VHSHUWL MDUDN WDQDP SROD
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
+XEXQJDQ3HPHULQWDK3URSLQVLGHQJDQ.DEXSDWHQ.RWDKDQ\DNRRUGLQDVLNHUMDVDPDGDQ NHPLWUDDQ1DPXQGDODPKDOLQL*XEHUQXUVHODNX:DNLO3HPHULQWDKVHFDUDDGPLQLVWUDWLIPHODNXNDQ SHPELQDDQ GDQ SHQJDZDVDQ WHUKDGDS .DEXSDWHQ.RWD .DUHQD LWX GDODP SHQJHPEDQJDQ .HOHPEDJDDQ3HQJHORODDQ+XWDQ%HUVDPD0DV\DUDNDW3HPHULQWDK3URSLQVLPHQJNRRUGLQDVLNDQ SHODNVDQDDQ SURJUDPSURJUDP SHPEHUGD\DDQ PDV\DUDNDW VHGDQJ 3HPHULQWDK 'HSDUWHPHQ .HKXWDQDQVHEDJDLIDVLOLWDWRU
3RVLVL /HPEDJD3HPHULQWDK 3XVDW 3URSLQVL GDQ .DEXSDWHQ.RWD GDODP SHPEHUGD\DDQ PDV\DUDNDWXQWXNPLWLJDVLGDPSDNQHJDWLI\DQJGLUDVDNDQPDV\DUDNDWDNLEDWNHEHUDGDDQKXWDQ WXVDPDWDXKXWDQODLQQ\DGDQXQWXNPHOHVWDULNDQNHEHUDGDDQKXWDQWHUVHEXWGDSDWGLJDPEDUNDQ VHSHUWL*DPEDU
9,,.(6,038/$1
$LUKLODQJNDUHQDLQWHUVHSVLWDMXNFURZQLQWHUFHSWLRQORVVWXVDPVHEHVDUGDULKXMDQ WDKXQDQ 8QWXN PHQJXUDQJL NHKLODQJDQ DLU NDUHQD LQWHUVHSVL GDSDW GLODNXNDQ GHQJDQ PHPSHUEHVDUMDUDNWDQDPWXVDPP[PGDQSHQMDUDQJDQ
3HUROHKDQDLUKXMDQQHWWRDLUORORVDOLUDQEDWDQJWXVDPFXNXSEHVDUGDULFXUDKKXMDQ .RQGLVLLQLPDVLKGDSDWGLWLQJNDWNDQGHQJDQSHQMDUDQJDQVHKLQJJDDLUORORVGDSDWGLWLQJNDWNDQ 8QWXNPHQLQJNDWNDQSHUROHKDQDLUGDULDOLUDQEDWDQJWXVDP\DQJUDWDUDWDQ\DUHODWLIUHQGDK
GDULFXUDKKXMDQGDSDWGLODNXNDQGHQJDQSRODWDQDPFDPSXUDQGHQJDQMHQLVSRKRQ\DQJ EHUNXOLW EDWDQJ OLFLQKDOXV VHKLQJJD LQWHUVHSVL ROHK NXOLW EDWDQJ GDSDW GLSHUNHFLO GDQ DOLUDQ EDWDQJEHUWDPEDKEHVDU
.HFHSDWDQGHNRPSRVLVLVHUDVDKWXVDP\DQJODPEDWDNDQPHQJKDPEDWWHUEHQWXNQ\DKXPXV +DOWHUVHEXWGDSDWGLLPEDQJLGHQJDQSHUODNXDQSRODWDQDPFDPSXUDQGHQJDQMHQLVSRKRQ\DQJ PHQJKDVLONDQ VHUDVDK \DQJ FHSDW WHUGHNRPSRVLVL VHKLQJJD SHPEHQWXNDQ EDKDQ RUJDQLNKXPXVEDJLWDQDPDQGDQWDQDKGDSDWGLSHQXKL
3HQMDUDQJDQGDQPHPSHUEHVDUMDUDNWDQDPWXVDPGDSDWPHQLQJNDWNDQDOLUDQSHUPXNDDQ\DQJ VDQJDWNHFLOSDGDWHJDNDQWXVDPGDULFXUDKKXMDQ3HQLQJNDWDQDOLUDQSHUPXNDDQ GLPDNVXGNDQ XQWXN PHQJXUDQJL DGDQ\D NRQVHQWUDVL ]DW]DWEDKDQEDKDQ \DQJ GDSDW PHQLPEXONDQUDFXQDJDUWHUODUXWGDQWHUEDZDROHKDOLUDQSHUPXNDDQ
(YDSRWUDQVSLUDVLNHEXWXKDQDLUWXVDP\DQJPHQXQMXNNDQDQJND\DQJWLQJJLGDULFXUDK KXMDQWDKXQDQPHPHUOXNDQSHUKDWLDQDJDUWXVDPGLWDQDPSDGDGDHUDKGHQJDQFXUDKKXMDQ \DQJOHELKWLQJJLGDULPPSHUWDKXQGDQGHQJDQMDUDNWDQDP\DQJOHEDUDWDXGHQJDQ SHQMDUDQJDQ
3HQGHNDWDQ VHFDUD NHOHPEDJDDQ VHSHUWL SHQJHPEDQJDQSHPDQWDSDQ SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ EHUVDPDPDV\DUDNDWGDQKXWDQNHPDV\DUDNDWDQSHUOXGLWLQJNDWNDQ
.DML XODQJUHYLVL SURGXNSURGXN NHELMDNDQ SHUDWXUDQ NHSXWXVDQ SHGRPDQ SHWXQMXN SHODNVDQDDQ SHWXQMXN WHNQLV PHQJHQDL EXGL GD\D WXVDP \DQJ VXGDK WLGDN VHVXDL SHUOX GLODNXNDQ 6RVLDOLVDVLSHQ\XOXKDQSHQ\DGDUDQGDQSHOD\DQDQPDV\DUDNDWSHUOXGLODNXNDQ '$)7$53867$.$ $QRQLP+XWDQ3LQXVGDQ+DVLO$LU3XVDW3HQJHPEDQJDQ6XPEHU'D\D+XWDQ3HUKXWDQL &HSX $QRQLP5HQFDQD.HUMD.HPHQWHULDQ1HJDUD/HPEDJD5HQMD./'HSDUWHPHQ.HKXWDQDQ .HS0HQWHUL.HKXWDQDQ1R6.0HQKXW9,,
%XGKL\RQR %DPEDQJ (NR 3HQGXJDDQ QHUDFD DLU GDODP VLVWHP KLGURORJL '$6 :DVSDGD *DUXWGHQJDQ$QDOLVD6LVWHP7HVLV6DUMDQD.HKXWDQDQ,3%%RJRU
%UDPDVWR<6WXGLYDULDVLSHUWXPEXKDQVHPDL3LQXVPHUNXVLLMXQJKHWGH9ULHVGDULEHEHUDSD VXPEHUEHQLK%XOHWLQ3HQHOLWLDQ+XWDQ%RJRU1R &KRZ97+DQGERRNRI$SSOLHG+\GRORJ\0F*UDZ+LOO7RURQWR1HZ<RUN +HZOHWW-'DQG:/0XWWHU$Q2XWOLQHRI)RUHVW+\GURORJ\6FKRRORI)RUHVW5HVRXUFHV 8QLYHUVLW\RI*HRUJLD 0RNRERPEDQJ0XODLJXQGXOKXWDQGLVHNLWDULULJDVL'RPRJD.RPSDV 1R7DKXQ;9, WDQJJDOEXODQ
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
BBBBBB 3HUDQDQ EHEHUDSD MHQLV SRKRQ KXWDQ GDODP PHQWUDQVIHU DLU KXMDQ %XOHWLQ 3HQHOLWLDQ+XWDQ1R
BBBBBB$VSHNKLGURORJLWHJDNDQ 3DUNLDMDYDQLFDVZHHWHQLDPDFURSK\OODGDQ3LQXVPHUNXVLL SDGDSHQHOLWLDQOLVLPHWHUGL%RJRU%XOHWLQ3HQHOLWLDQ+XWDQ1R
BBBBBB 3HUEDQGLQJDQ SURGXNVL GDQ SHQJKDQFXUDQ VHUDVDK GL EDZDK WHJDNDQ 3LQXV
PHUNXVLL6PDFURSK\OODGDQKXWDQDODPGL-DQODSD-DZD%DUDW%XOHWLQ3HQHOLWLDQ+XWDQ1R
BBBBBB$SOLNDVLSHWXQMXNSHPLOLKDQMHQLVGDODPNDLWDQQ\DGHQJDQSURSRUVLFXUDKKXMDQGDQ HYDSRWUDQVSLUDVLMHQLV7XVDP(XFDO\SWXVVSGDQ$PDQJLXPGDQSHOXDQJSHUROHKDQDLU ,QIR+XWDQ1R BBBBBB$VSHN+LGURORJLGDUL(XFDO\SWXV%XOHWLQ3HQHOLWLDQGDQ3HQJHPEDQJDQ.HKXWDQDQ 9RO1R 6DPLQJDQ7MDKMRQR7KHHFRQRPLFRIWKHFRQLIHURXVIRUHVWLQWKHWURSLFV%DJLDQ(NRORJL 7XPEXK7XPEXKDQ'HSDUWHPHQ%RWDQL)DNXOWDV3HUWDQLDQ,3%SS 6DPSXUQR$LU$LU$LU.RPSDV1R7DKXQ;9,,WDQJJDOEXODQ
:LQDUVR '$ 3HUXEDKDQ LNOLP GDQ IHQRPHQD EHQFDQD EDQMLU GL NDZDVDQ '., -DNDUWD 0DNDODKGDODPORNDNDU\D3HUXEDKDQLNOLPGDQLPSOLNDVLWHUKDGDSEHQFDQDEDQMLUUHQFDQD WLQGDNDQWLVLSDVLDGDSWDVLGDQPLWLJDVLEHQFDQDGDQGDPSDNEDQMLU-DNDUWD
<DPLQ$%HQFDQDDODPGL6XPDWHUD6HODWDQOLQJNXQJDQ\DQJSHUOXGLNDML.RPSDV1R 7DKXQ;9,,KDO,9WDQJJDOEXODQ
*DPEDU 3RVLVL 3HPHULQWDK 3XVDW 3URSLQVL GDQ .DEXSDWHQ.RWD GDODP SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ EHUVDPD PDV\DUDNDW )LJXUH 3RVLWLRQ RI &HQWUDO *RYHUQPHQW 3URYLQFH DQG 5HJHQF\&LW\ LQ &RPPXQLW\ EDVHG IRUHVW PDQDJHPHQWV
3HPHULQWDK 3XVDW'HSW+XW )DVLOLWDWRU 3URSLQVL.RRUGLQDVL .HUMDVDPD .HPLWUDDQ
.DEXSDWHQ.RWD 2WRQRPLSHQXK\DQJ EHUWDQJJXQJMDZDE 'XQLD8VDKD0DV\DUDNDW $GPLQLVWUDWLI 3HPELQDDQ 3HQJDZDVDQ 3HODNX ,QYHQWDULVDV L )DNWDNHFHQGHUXQJDQ 3HUXEDKDQ3HQJJXQDDQ 3HPDQIDDWDQ)XQJVL 6'$+XWDQ 5HYLVL3URGXN 3URGXN
.HELMDNDQ3HUDWXUDQ.HSXWXVDQ 3HGRPDQ3HQJHORODDQ 3HPDQIDDWDQ)XQVL6'$+XWDQ
.DMLDQ8ODQJ3URGXN3URGXN .HELMDNDQ3HUDWXUDQ.HSXWXVDQ 3HGRPDQ3HQJHORODDQ 3HPDQIDDWDQ)XQJVL6'$+XWDQ
6RVLDOLVDVL 3HPEHUGD\DDQ0DV\DUDNDW
3HQJHORODDQ+XWDQEHUVDPD 0DV\DUDNDW +XWDQ.HPDV\DUDNDWDQ
<DQJGLODNXNDQ
0DV\DUDNDW+XNXP
$GDW
0DV\DUDNDW6HWHPSDW 6HNLWDUGLOXDU.DZDVDQ+XWDQ ODLQQ\D
/HPEDJD.HPDV\DUDNDWDQ .HWHUDQJDQ
