.21)/,.7(17$1**$17,58*,121),6,.
3$'$3(1*$'$$17$1$+8178..(3(17,1*$18080
,JD*DQJJD6DQWL'HZL )DNXOWDV+XNXP8QLYHUVLWDV'LSRQHJRUR -O3URI6RHGDUWR6+7HPEDODQJ6HPDUDQJ JDQJJDVDQWL#\DKRRFRP $EVWUDFW0DQ\ FRQÀLFW EHWZHHQ JRYHUQPHQW DQG FLWL]HQV UHODWHG WR WKH SURFHVV RI ODQG DFTXLVLWLRQ IRU GHYHORSPHQWIRUWKHSXEOLFLQWHUHVW7KHSUREOHPZDVVXVSHFWHGEHFDXVHWKHUHVLGHQWGLGQRWDFFHSW WKHJRYHUQPHQWVGHFLVLRQRQWKHIRUPDQGDPRXQWRIQRQSK\VLFDOFRPSHQVDWLRQ7KHUHVHDUFK PHWKRG XVHG WKH SDUDGLJP RI FRQVWUXFWLYLVP ZLWK FDVH VWXG\ 5HVHDUFK QHHGV WR UHEXLOG D QRQ SK\VLFDOFRPSHQVDWLRQSROLF\RQODQGDFTXLVLWLRQIRUSXEOLFSXUSRVHVZLWKDVRFLDOMXVWLFHEDVHG YDOXH1RQSK\VLFDOFRPSHQVDWLRQFRQÀLFWVRQODQGDFTXLVLWLRQIRUWKHSXEOLFLQWHUHVWVDUHVHHQDVD SKHQRPHQRQWKDWWKHFRPSHQVDWLRQSROLF\/DZ1RRIRQ/DQG3URFXUHPHQWIRU'HYHORSPHQW IRU3XEOLF,QWHUHVWQRWH[HFXWHGSURSHUO\VRWKDWYLRODWHV&RQVWLWXWLRQRI,QGRQHVLD .H\ZRUGV&RQÀLFW1RQ3K\VLFDO&RPSHQVDWLRQ/DQG$FTXLVLWLRQ $EVWUDN %DQ\DNNRQÀLNDQWDUDSHPHULQWDKGDQZDUJDWHUNDLWSURVHVSHQJDGDDQWDQDKEDJLSHPEDQJXQDQ XQWXNNHSHQWLQJDQXPXP3HUPDVDODKDQGLWHQJJDUDLNDUHQDZDUJDWLGDNPHQHULPDDWDVNHSXWXVDQ SHPHULQWDKPHQJHQDLEHQWXNGDQEHVDUQ\DJDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLN0HWRGHSHQHOLWLDQPHQJJXQDNDQ SDUDGLJPDNRQWUXNWLYLVPHGHQJDQVWXGLNDVXVNRQÀLNSHQHQWXDQEHQWXNGDQEHVDUQ\DJDQWLUXJLQRQ ¿VLNSHQJDGDDQWDQDK3HQHOLWLDQSHUOXXQWXNPHPEDQJXQNHPEDOLNHELMDNDQJDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLN SDGDSHQJDGDDQWDQDKXQWXNNHSHQWLQJDQXPXPGHQJDQEHUEDVLVQLODLNHDGLODQVRVLDO.RQÀLN JDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLNSDGDSHQJDGDDQWDQDKXQWXNNHSHQWLQJDQXPXPGLSDQGDQJIHQRPHQDEDKZD NHELMDNDQJDQWLUXJLGDODP8QGDQJ8QGDQJ1R7DKXQWHQWDQJ3HQJDGDDQ7DQDK%DJL 3HPEDQJXQDQ 8QWXN .HSHQWLQJDQ 8PXP WLGDN GLMDODQNDQ VHFDUD EHQDU VHKLQJJD PHODQJJDU NRQVWLWXVL88'15,7DKXQ .DWD.XQFL.RQÀ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
.HEXWXKDQ WDQDK EDJL SHPEDQJXQDQ XQWXNNHSHQWLQJDQXPXPGLODNXNDQGHQJDQ SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK \DQJ VHEDJLDQ EHVDU WDQDK KDNZDUJDGDQPDV\DUDNDWGLVHEDENDQWDQDK Q H J D U D W L G D N P H Q F X N X S L O D J L E D J L SHPEDQJXQDQ WHUVHEXW .RQVHNXHQVLQ\D SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK EDJL SHPEDQJXQDQ XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP WHODK PHUDPEDK KLQJJD PHOLSXWL WDQDKWDQDK PLOLN SHQGXGXN \DQJ PHOLSXWL WHPSDW WLQJJDO WHPSDW XVDKD EDLN SHUWDQLDQSHUNHEXQDQVHUWDSHULNDQDQPLOLN SULEDGL ZDUJD PDXSXQ PLOLN PDV\DUDNDW WDQDK NDV GHVD XQWXN NHJLDWDQ PDV\DUDNDW MXJDWDQDKXQWXNSHULEDGDWDQPDVMLGGDQDWDX PXVKROD
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¿VLNROHKSHPHULQWDK 3HPHULQWDK VHODPD LQL KDQ\D PHPEHULNDQ JDQWL UXJL ¿VLN VDMD WDQSD PHPSHUKDWLNDQ JDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLNVHFDUDEHQDUEDJLZDUJD WDQDKQ\D WHUNHQD SHPEDQJXQDQ XQWXN N H S H Q W L Q J D Q X P X P 6 H F D U D H P S L U L N IHQRPHQD VHPDFDP LWX PHQDQGDL DGDQ\D SHUXEDKDQ GDODP NHKLGXSDQ SHPLOLN WDQDK XQWXNNHGHSDQQ\DDSDELODJDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLN WLGDNGLEHULNDQSDGDZDUJD\DQJEHUKDNDWDV RE\HNSHQJDGDDQWDQDK
%HUGDVDUNDQ GDWD GDUL .RQVRUVLXP 3HPEDUXDQ $JUDULD VHODPD WDKXQ MXPODKNRQÀLNGLVHNWRULQIUDVWUXNWXUWHUNDLW JDQWL UXJL GHQJDQ MXPODK NRQÀLN DWDX \ D N Q L D Q W D U D Z D UJ D G H Q J D Q SHPHULQWDK \DNQL NDVXV GDQ NRQÀLN DQWDUD ZDUJD GDQ SHUXVDKDDQ QHJDUD \DNQL VHEDQ\DN NDVXV %HUNDLWDQ GHQJDQ EDQ\DNQ\D NRQÀLN DQWDUD SHPHULQWDK GDQ ZDUJD \DQJ EHUKDN PHQJHQDL EHQWXN GDQ EHVDUQ\D JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿VLN VHKLQJJD GLSDQGDQJSHUOXXQWXNPHPEDQJXQNHPEDOL NHELMDNDQJDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLNSDGDSHQJDGDDQ WDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP GHQJDQ EHUEDVLVQLODLNHDGLODQVRVLDO.RQÀLNNRQÀLN WHUVHEXWGDSDWGLSDQGDQJVHEDJDLIHQRPHQD EDKZD NHELMDNDQ JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿VLN SDGD SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP \DLWX GL GDODP 3DVDO KXUXI I 8QGDQJ 8QGDQJ1R7DKXQWHQWDQJ3HQJDGDDQ 7 D Q D K % D J L 3 H P E D Q J X Q D Q 8 Q W X N .HSHQWLQJDQ 8PXP VHODQMXWQ\D GLWXOLV 88377DKXQ WLGDNGLMDODQNDQVHFDUD EHQDU VHKLQJJD PHODQJJDU NRQVWLWXVL 88' 15, 7DKXQ GDQ 3DQFDVLOD VHEDJDL SHGRPDQKLGXSEDQJVD,QGRQHVLD )HQRPHQD NHWLGDNDGLODQ VXEVWDQWLI SDGD NHELMDNDQ JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿VLN GDODP S H Q J D G D D Q W D Q D K L Q L P H Q L P E X O N D Q NHVHQMDQJDQ HNRQRPL DQWDUD ZDUJD GDQ NHWLPSDQJDQ VRVLDO GDODP NHKLGXSDQ PDV\DUDNDW +DO LQL WHUMDGL NDUHQD WLGDN GLEHULNDQQ\D JDQWL UXJL \DQJ OD\DN DWDV NHKLODQJDQ KDNKDN NHQ\DPDQDQ NHKLGXSDQ PHUHND DNLEDW DGDQ\D SHPEDQJXQDQ XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQXPXP.HELMDNDQJDQWLUXJLQRQ ¿VLN SDGD SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK EHUEDVLV QLODL N H D G L O D Q V R V L D O \ D Q J L G H D O P H Q M D G L NHQLVFD\DDQ DJDU JDQWL UXJL \DQJ GLWHULPD ROHK SHPLOLN WDQDK PHQMDGL OHELK DGLO GDQ PDQXVLDZLXQWXNNHVHMDKWHUDDQKLGXSVHWHODK WDQDK PHUHND GLOHSDVNDQ XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP .HELMDNDQ JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿VLN \DQJ LGHDO LQL DNDQ EHUKDVLO DSDELOD SHPHULQWDK GDODPKDOLQLDGDODK3DQLWLD3HQJDGDDQ7DQDK 37 NRQVLVWHQ PHPEHULNDQ JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿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ÀLNWHRUL.HDGLODQ-RKQ5DZOGDQWHRUL KXNXPSURJUHVLI
7H U N D L W G H Q J D Q N H D G L O D Q G D O D P SHQHQWXDQJDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLNGDODPSURVHV SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK PDND NHKDGLUDQ KXNXP GDODP PDV\DUDNDW GLDQWDUDQ\D DGDODK XQWXN PHQJLQWHJUDVLNDQ GDQ PHQJNRRUGLQDVLNDQ NHSHQWLQJDQNHSHQWLQJDQ \DQJ EHUEHQWXUDQ V D W X V D P D O D L Q \ D Q J G L L Q W H J U D V L N D Q VHGHPLNLDQ UXSD VHKLQJJD ELVD GLWHNDQ
V H N H F L O N H F L O Q \ D 3 H Q J R U J D Q L V D V L D Q NHSHQWLQJDQNHSHQWLQJDQ \DQJ EHUEHQWXUDQ LWX GLODNXNDQ GHQJDQ PHPEDWDVL GDQ PHOLQGXQJL NHSHQWLQJDQNHSHQWLQJDQ WHUVHEXW 7HUNDLWGHQJDQNHELMDNDQJDQWLUXJLQRQ ¿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¿VLNSDGDSHQJDGDDQ WDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP \DQJ EHUNHDGLODQ VRVLDO GL ,QGRQHVLD 'LWHPXNDQ EDQ\DNSHQHOLWLDQPHQJHQDLSHQJDGDDQWDQDK \DQJ KDQ\D PHPEDKDV JDQWL UXJL ¿VLN \DQJ V H O D O X P H Q L P E X O N D Q N R Q À L N D Q W D U D SHPHULQWDKGDQZDUJD\DQJWHUNHQDGDPSDN SUR\HN SHPEDQJXQDQ XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP
'DUL EHEHUDSD MXGXO GL DWDV PDND SHQHOLWLDQGHQJDQPHQJNRQVWUXNVLNHELMDNDQ JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿VLN SDGD SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP EHUEDVLV QLODL NHDGLODQ VRVLDO EHOXP SHUQDK GLODNXNDQ 3HQHOLWLDQLQLVDQJDWSHQWLQJXQWXNGLWHOLWLGDQ GLNDML GDODP VHEXDK GLVHUWDVL GLGDVDUNDQ EDQ\DNQ\D NRQÀLN \DQJ EHUNDLWDQ GHQJDQ SHQHQWXDQEHQWXNGDQEHVDUQ\DJDQWLUXJLQRQ ¿VLN GL PDV\DUDNDW \DQJ VDPSDL VHNDUDQJ PDVLK PHQLPEXONDQ EDQ\DN SHUPDVDODKDQ +DOLQLGLVHEDENDQWLGDNGLWHUDSNDQQ\DVHFDUD EHQDU NHWHQWXDQ JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿VLN SDGD SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP \DQJ WHODK GLDWXU GDODP 3DVDO KXUXI I 8837 7DKXQ VHKLQJJD WHUMDGL SHODQJJDUDQDWDVSHQJKRUPDWDQNHSHPLOLNDQ KDNDWDVWDQDKUDN\DW\DQJWHODKGLDPDQDWNDQ .RQVWLWXVL 88' 15, 7DKXQ GDQ 3DQFDVLOD 3HUPDVDODKDQGDQ7XMXDQ3HQHOLWLDQ ' D U L S H Q H O L W L D Q S H Q H O L W L D Q \ D Q J WHUGDKXOX EHOXP SHUQDK GLWHOLWL PHQJHQDL SHQHQWXDQEHQWXNGDQEHVDUQ\DJDQWLUXJLQRQ ¿VLN VHKLQJJD PHQLPEXONDQ NRQÀLN \DQJ EHUNHSDQMDQJDQDQWDUDSHPHULQWDKGDQZDUJD PDV\DUDNDW 2OHK NDUHQD LWX SHUPDVDODKDQ SHQHOLWLDQ LQL DGDODK 0HQJDSD WHUMDGL NRQÀLN PHQJHQDL JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿VLN SDGD SHQJDGDDQWDQDKXQWXNNHSHQWLQJDQXPXPGL 'HVD/HPDKLUHQJ.DEXSDWHQ6HPDUDQJ" %DJDLPDQD NRQVWUXNVL EDUX NHELMDNDQ JDQWL UXJL QRQ ILVLN SDGD SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQXPXP"
0HWRGH3HQHOLWLDQ
3HQHOLWLDQ LQL PHQJJXQDNDQ PHWRGH SHQHOLWLDQ NXDOLWDWLI \DQJ GLKDUDSNDQ GDSDW GLWHPXNDQ PDNQDPDNQD \DQJ WHUVHPEXQ\L GLEDOLN RE\HN PDXSXQ VXE\HN \DQJ DNDQ GLWHOLWL 3HQHOLWLDQ GHQJDQ SHQGHNDWDQ6RFLR /HJDOGHQJDQ PHWRGHGDQWHRULLOPXVRVLDO WHQWDQJ KXNXP XQWXN PHPEDQWX SHQHOLWL PHODNXNDQ DQDOLVLV 5DKDUGMR
3HQGHNDWDQ LQL GLODNXNDQ XQWXN PHPDKDPL KXNXP GDODP NRQWHNV PDV\DUDNDWQ\D =DPURQL3HQGHNDWDQLQLWHWDSGDODP UDQDK KXNXP KDQ\D SHUVSHNWLIQ\D EHUEHGD 'DODPSHQHOLWLDQLQLPHOLKDWIDNWDSHQHQWXDQ EHQWXN GDQ EHVDUQ\D JDQWL UXJL \DQJ WHUMDGL SDGDSHQJDGDDQWDQDKGL'HVD/HPDKLUHQJ
.DEXSDWHQ6HPDUDQJ
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
GDODP SHQJXPSXODQ GDWD,QGHSWK LQWHUYLHZ
GLODNXNDQ GHQJDQ SHUWDQ\DDQSHUWDQ\DDQ WHUEXNDRSHQHQGHGQDPXQWLGDNPHQXWXS NHPXQJNLQDQ DNDQ GLODNXNDQ SHUWDQ\DDQ SHUWDQ\DDQWHUWXWXSFORVHGHQGHGWHUXWDPD XQWXN LQIRUPDQ \DQJ PHPLOLNL EDQ\DN L Q I R U P D V L W H W D S L D G D N H Q G D O D G D O D P PHQJHODERUDVL LQIRUPDVLQ\D WHUVHEXW 1DVXWLRQ ' L V D P S L Q J P H P D Q I D D W N D Q GRNXPHQWDVL GDQ REVHUYDVL SHQJXPSXODQ GDWDWHUXWDPDGLODNXNDQPHODOXLZDZDQFDUD G H Q J D Q S D U D U H V S R Q G H Q . H J L D W D Q SHQJXPSXODQGDWDPHOLSXWLSHUWDPDPHQFDUL GDWD SULPHU NHPXGLDQ GDWD VHNXQGHU 'DWD VHNXQGHUDGDODKGDWD\DQJWHODKGLNXPSXONDQ GDQ GLVLVWHPDWLVLU ROHK SLKDN ODLQ GDQ GLJXQDNDQ MXJD GDODP SHQHOLWLDQ LQL 6WHZDUW
7HNQLNXQWXNPHQHPXNDQGDWDSULPHU GLODNXNDQ PHODOXL ZDZDQFDUD VHFDUD EHEDVWHUEXND DWDX WDN WHUVWUXNWXU VHFDUD ODQJVXQJ GHQJDQ UHVSRQGHQ \DQJ GLWHPXL \DQJ GLDQJJDS SHQWLQJ XQWXN PHPEHULNDQ GDWDGDODPSHQHOLWLDQLQL0HVNLSXQWHUGDSDW GDWD VWDWLVWLN \DQJ GLGDSDW PHODOXL GDWD VHNXQGHUPDXSXQZDZDQFDUDWHUSDGXWHWDSL SHQHOLWLDQ LQL OHELK EHUVLIDW¿HOG UHVHDUFK GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ SHQGHNDWDQYHUVWHKHQ
DWDXKHUPHQHXWLF'LVDPSLQJLWXREVHUYDVL GLODNXNDQ GDODP UDQJND XQWXN PHPSHUROHK GDWD WHQWDQJ ORNDVL SHQHOLWLDQ GDODP DVSHN ¿VLNQ\D PLVDOQ\D SROD SHQJJXQDDQ SHQJXDVDDQ WDQDK GDQ SHULODNXSHULODNX ZDUJD\DQJEHUKDN
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
3HQGXGXN'HVD/HPDK,UHQJPHQFDSDL MLZD GDQ PD\RULWDV PHPSXQ\DL PDWD SHQFDKDULDQ EHUWDQL KDO LQL VHVXDL GHQJDQ NRQGLVL GHVD \DQJ EDQ\DN WHUGDSDW VDZDK 0HUHND DGD MXJD \DQJ EHNHUMD VHEDJDL SHWHUQDN WXNDQJ RMHN GDQ PHQMDGL EXUXK SDEULN 3HQGXGXN GHVD /HPDK ,UHQJ VDQJDW PH\DNLQL EDKZD WDQDK PHPLOLNL QLODL HNRQRPLV PHUXSDNDQ VXPEHU GD\D DODP \DQJVDQJDWEHUKDUJDEDJLNHKLGXSDQPHUHND VHODLQLWXMXJDPHPLOLNLQLODLVRVLDOGDQQLODL EXGD\D \DQJ WLQJJL 6HFDUD JHRJUD¿V'HVD /HPDK ,UHQJ DGDODK SHUEXNLWDQ GDQ PDVLK EDQ\DNPHPEHQWDQJVDZDKODGDQJGDQXQWXN VHEHODKXWDUDGLEDWDVLSHUEXNLWDQSHUNHEXQDQ NDUHW 6XPEHU PDWD DLU XWDPD XQWXN NHKLGXSDQVHKDULKDUL PDVLKPHQJDQGDONDQ FXUDK KXMDQ \DQJ WHUVLPSDQ GDODP VHQGDQJ NRODP MXJD VXPXU 2OHK NDUHQD LWX VDZDK SXQ PDVLK PHQJDQGDONDQ DLU KXMDQ 6HWLDS VDDW PDVLK WHUOLKDW SHQGXGXN 'HVD /HPDK ,UHQJ \DQJ EHUSURIHVL VHEDJDL SHWDQL PHPEDMDNVDZDKQ\DPHQJJXQDNDQVDSL
'DUL VHJL SHQGLGLNDQ PD\RULWDV SHQGXGXN'HVD/HPDK,UHQJUDWDUDWDKDQ\D VHNRODKGDVDU6'VHNRODKWLQJNDWSHUWDPD 6/73GDQVHNRODK0HQHQJDK7LQJNDW$WDV 60$6HODLQVHNRODKIRUPDODGDMXJD\DQJ VHNRODK GL PDGUDVDK DWDX EHODMDU GL VHNRODK NHDJDPDDQ GDODP KDO LQL DGDODK Q\DQWUL GL SRQGRN SHVDQWUHQ 3XWXV VHNRODK PDVLK GL WHPXL NDUHQD EHUEDJDL K DO PLV DOQ\ D NXUDQJQ\DELD\DGDQWLGDNDGDGXNXQJDQGDUL NHOXDUJD
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
! .RQÀLNPHQJHQDLJDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLN S D G D S H Q J D G D D Q W D Q D K X Q W X N NHSHQWLQJDQXPXP
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
%HEHUDSD ZDUJD GHVD /HPDK ,UHQJ PHQJKDGDSLNHKLGXSDQ\DQJOHELKEXUXNGDUL VHEHOXP WDQDKQ\D GLEHEDVNDQ GDQ LQL P H Q J D N L E D W N D Q J H M R O D N V R V L D O G H P L PHPSHUWDKDQNDQNHEHUDGDDQNHKLGXSDQQ\D N H O X D U J D Q \ D G D Q N H K L G X S D Q EHUPDV\DUDNDWQ\D EDLN ELGDQJ DGDW EXGD\D GDQ ELGDQJ NHDJDPDDQ 3HQLODLDQ JDQWL UXJL ¿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¿VLN \DQJ GLGHULWD ZDUJD \DQJ WHUNHQD GDPSDN SUR\HN MDODQ WRO 6HPDUDQJ ± 6ROR 7L P S H Q D N V L U K D U J D K D Q \ D E H N H U M D EHUGDVDUNDQVXUDWWXJDV\DQJGLEHULNDQ37 VHEDWDVPHQLODLXQWXNJDQWLUXJL¿VLNVHPDWD
'DODP WHPXDQ WLGDN GLQLODL GLKLWXQJ JDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLNGDODPSHQJDGDDQWDQDKGL 'HVD /HPDK ,UHQJ 3DGDKDO EHUGDVDUNDQ
3DVDO KXUXI I 8837 7DKXQ WHODK GLVHEXWNDQ GHQJDQ MHODV EDKZD JDQWL UXJL \DQJ GDSDW GL QLODL JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿VLN GLQLODL .ULWHULDQ\D GLMHODVNDQ GDODP 3HQMHODVDQ 3DVDO KXUXI I WHUVHEXW 3HQMHODVDQ3DVDO+XUXII881R7DKXQ \DQJGLPDNVXGGHQJDQ³NHUXJLDQODLQ \DQJGDSDWGLQLODL´DGDODKNHUXJLDQQRQ¿VLN \DQJ GDSDW GLVHWDUDNDQ GHQJDQ QLODL XDQJ PLVDOQ\D NHUXJLDQ NDUHQD NHKLODQJDQ XVDKD DWDX SHNHUMDDQ ELD\D SHPLQGDKDQ WHPSDW ELD\DDOLKSURIHVLGDQQLODLDWDVSURSHUWLVLVD
3HPHULQWDK VHKDUXVQ\D PHQFDULNDQ MDODQ NHOXDU EDJL NHKLGXSDQ ZDUJD \DQJ EHUKDN \DQJ DNDQ PHQGHULWD DSDELOD NHKLODQJDQ WDQDKQ\D VHEDJDL VXPEHU NHKLGXSDQQ\D +DO LQL WHUNDLW GHQJDQ WXJDV XPXP GDUL SHPHULQWDK VHQGLUL PHPSXQ\DL NHZDMLEDQXQWXNPHOLQGXQJLPHQJDPDQNDQ GDQ PHQVHMDKWHUDNDQ PDV\DUDNDW VHFDUD N H V H O X U X K D Q W H U P D V X N V H P X D Z D UJ D PDV\DUDNDW \DQJ WHUNHQD GDPSDN GDUL SHPEDQJXQDQ SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK 7LGDN GLWHUDSNDQQ\DNHWHQWXDQJDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLN GDODP SURVHV SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP PHQXQMXNNDQ KXNXP \DQJ WLGXUVOHHSLQJ ODZ EHUDNLEDW WLGDN W H U F D S D L Q \ D N H V H M D K W H U D D Q U D N \ D W VHEDJDLPDQD GLDPDQDWNDQ ROHK NRQVWLWXVL +DO LQL GLVHEDENDQ SDUD SHODNVDQD KXNXP WLGDN NRQVLVWHQ PHQMDODQNDQ DSD \DQJ WHODK GLSHULQWDKNDQ GDODP NHELMDNDQ SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK\DQJEHUODNX
:DUJD'HVD/HPDK,UHQJWHWDSPHQXQWXW S H P H U L Q W D K W U D Q V S D U D Q G H Q J D Q PHPSHUOLKDWNDQ KDVLO SHQLODLDQ GDUL WLP S H Q L O D L K D U J D W D Q D K W L P D S S U D L V D O LQGHSHQGHQ WHUNDLW SHQLODLDQ RE\HN SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK (NVHNXVL \DQJ GLODNXNDQ SHPHULQWDKWHUKDGDSRE\HNSHQJDGDDQWDQDK PHUXSDNDQ EHQWXN SHODQJJDUDQ KXNXP NDUHQD SURVHV KXNXP PDVLK EHUMDODQ GDQ SXWXVDQNDVDVLEHOXPWXUXQ%HUEDJDLNRQÀLN WHUVHEXW EHUPXOD GDUL GLJXQDNDQQ\D NHNXDVDDQGDQZHZHQDQJOHPEDJD\DQJDGD GLGHVDNHOXUDKDQXQWXNPHQHPSDWNDQSLKDN SHPLOLNWDQDKSDGDSRVLVLEDZDK%HQDUDSD \DQJ GLJDPEDUNDQ ROHK 5DOI 'DKUHQGRUI EDKZD PDV\DUDNDW PHUXSDNDQ SHUVHNXWXDQ \DQJWHUNRRUGLQDVLVHFDUDSDNVDLPSHUDWLYHO\ FRRUGLQDWHG DVVRFLDWLRQV 'DKUHQGRUI .RQÀLN\DQJEDQ\DNWHUMDGLWHUNDLWJDQWL UXJLQRQ¿VLNGDODPSURVHVSHQJDGDDQWDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP \DQJ GLODNXNDQ SHPHULQWDK KDUXV GLSDQGDQJ VHEDJDL SHQRODNDQ PDV\DUDNDW WHUKDGDS WLQGDNDQ SHPHULQWDK GDODP PHQJDWXU PHQJXUXV GDQ P H Q J D Z D V L W D Q D K . R Q À L N W H U V H E X W P H U H À H N V L N D Q E D K Z D S H Q J D W X U D Q SHQJXUXVDQGDQSHQJDZDVDQDWDVWDQDK\DQJ GLODNXNDQ QHJDUD VHODPD LQL EHOXP GDSDW PHPEHULNDQNHVHMDKWHUDDQ\DQJEHUNHDGLODQ NHSDGDPDV\DUDNDW.DUHQDLWXXQWXNGDSDW PHZXMXGNDQ NHVHMDKWHUDDQ UDN\DW \DQJ EHUNHDGLODQ IHQRPHQD NRQÀLN KHQGDNQD GLUHVSRQ XQWXN PHODNXNDQ SHUEDLNDQ SHUEDLNDQ DJDU KXNXP EHQDUEHQDU GDSDW PHZXMXGNDQWXMXDQQ\DXQWXNPHPEDKDJLDQ PDQXVLDGDQPDV\DUDNDW
7HUNDLW SHUVRDODQ NRQÀLN DQWDUD SHPHULQWDK 37 GHQJDQ PDV\DUDNDW 'HVD /HPDK ,UHQJ LQL GLDQDOLVLV GHQJDQ WHRUL NRQÀLN5DOI'DKUHQGRUIPHQMHODVNDQEDKZD NRQÀLN WHUMDGL NDUHQD DGDQ\D SHUEHGDDQ NHNXDVDDQ GDQ NHSHQWLQJDQ GDODP VLVWHP VRVLDO2OHK NDUHQD LWX WHUKDGDS NRQÀLN NRQÀLN \DQJ EHUSRWHQVL PXQFXO GDODP PDV\DUDNDW \DNQL DQWDUD QHJDUD GDQ ZDUJD LQLPDNDNHELMDNDQQHJDUDKDUXV PHQVLNDSL GDQPHQJHORODNRQÀLNLWXVHEDJDLEDJLDQGDUL U H D O L W D V V R V L D O P D V \ D U D N D W \ D Q J W D N W H U V H O H V D L N D Q 1 H J D U D V H K D U X V Q \ D PHQJKRUPDWLKDNKDNPHUHNDEDLNKDNDWDV LGHQWLWDV KXNXP GDQ VXPEHUVXPEHU KLGXS PHUHND\DQJGLOLQGXQJLROHKNRQVWLWXVL 'HPL WHUZXMXGQ\D WXMXDQ QHJDUD KXNXP DJDU WHUFDSDL NHVHMDKWHUDDQ UDN\DW \DQJEHUNHDGLODQVRVLDOEDJLVHOXUXKUDN\DW PDND SHUOX GLEHULNDQ JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿VLN G D O D P S H Q J D G D D Q W D Q D K E D J L X Q W X N NHSHQWLQJDQXPXPEDJLZDUJD\DQJWHUNHQD GDPSDNSHQJDGDDQWDQDKWHUVHEXWGLGDVDUNDQ SDGD QLODLQLODL OXKXU 3URNODPDVL GDQ 3DQFDVLOD GHQJDQ NRQVHSWXDOLVDVL QLODLQLODL NHDGLODQVHFDUDSURJUHVLIEHUNHVHMDKWHUDDQ
.RQVWUXNVL %DUX .HELMDNDQ *DQWL 5XJL 1RQ )LVLN 3DGD 3HQJDGDDQ 7DQDK8QWXN.HSHQWLQJDQ8PXP
'DODP UHDOLWDVQ\D SHQHQWXDQ EHQWXN GDQ EHVDUQ\D JDQWL UXJL PHQHNDQNDQ SDGD SHQFDULDQ NHEHQDUDQ IRUPLO VHULQJNDOL
PHQLPEXONDQNHWLGDNSXDVDQSDUDSLKDNDWDV SXWXVDQ37+DOLQLWHUMDGLGLVHEDENDQ37 PHQDIVLUNDQ3DVDOKXUXII88377DKXQ V H F D U D W H N V I R U P L O \ D Q J W L G D N PHPSHUWLPEDQJNDQQLODLQLODLGLPDV\DUDNDW 2OHKNDUHQDLWXEHUDUWLSHQHQWXDQEHQWXNGDQ EHVDUQ\D JDQWL UXJL \DQJ EHUSLMDN SDGD NHEHQDUDQ IRUPLO EHOXP GDSDW VHSHQXKQ\D PHPEHULNDQ SHUOLQGXQJDQ GDQ MDPLQDQ WHUFLSWDQ\D NHDGLODQ EDJL SDUD ZDUJD \DQJ PHQJDODPL NHUXJLDQ DNLEDW SHPEDQJXQDQ XQWXNNHSHQWLQJDQXPXP
' D O D P N R Q W H N V N H D G L O D Q \ D Q J WHUNDQGXQJ GDODP KXNXP \DQJ EHUZXMXG SHUDWXUDQ WHUOLKDW GDODP SHQJDWXUDQ JDQWL UXJLQRQ¿VLNVHEDJDLPDQDGLDWXUGDODP3DVDO KXUXI I \DQJ PHQ\DWDNDQ ³3HQLODLDQ EHVDUQ\D QLODL JDQWL UXJL ROHK SHQLODL GLODNXNDQELGDQJSHUELGDQJWDQDKPHOLSXWL INHUXJLDQODLQ\DQJGDSDWGLQLODL´ 'LVLQL 37PHQDIVLUNDQNHUXJLDQ\DQJGDSDWGLQLODL VHEDJDL JDQWL UXJL ¿VLN \DQJ GDSDW GL QLODL SDGDKDOGDODP3HQMHODVDQ3DVDOKXUXII 8837 7DKXQ PHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZD ³<DQJ GLPDNVXG GHQJDQ NHUXJLDQ ODLQ \DQJ GDSDWGLQLODL DGDODKNHUXJLDQQRQ¿VLN\DQJ GDSDWGLVHWDUDNDQGHQJDQQLODLXDQJPLVDOQ\D NHUXJLDQ NDUHQD NHKLODQJDQ XVDKD DWDX SHNHUMDDQ ELD\D SHPLQGDKDQ WHPSDW ELD\D DOLK SURIHVL GDQ QLODL DWDV SURSHUWL VLVD³ +XNXP \DQJ WHUZXMXG GDODP SHUDWXUDQ 8837 7DKXQ PHPDQJ PHQJDQGXQJ QLODLQLODL NHDGLODQ EDJL ZDUJD \DQJ EHUKDN DWDV NHKLODQJDQ XVDKD DWDX SHNHUMDDQ ELD\D SLQGDK WHPSDW DOLK SURIHVL GDQ QLODL DWDV SURIHVL VLVD$NDQ WHWDSL GDODP SUDNWHN KDO KDO WHUVHEXW WLGDN LNXW GLQLODL GDODP SURVHV SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK VHKLQJJD SXWXVDQ 37 WHQWDQJSHQHQWXDQEHQWXNGDQEHVDUQ\DJDQWL UXJLVHODPDLQLWLGDNPHPEHULNDQJDQWLUXJL QRQ¿VLNSDGDZDUJD\DQJEHUKDN
+XNXP SURJUHVLI EHUGDVDU GDUL DVXPVL EDKZD NHKDGLUDQ KXNXP EXNDQ XQWXN GLULQ\D VHQGLUL PHODLQNDQ XQWXN VHVXDWX \DQJ OHELK OXDV GDQ EHVDULWXODK
VHEDEQ\D NHWLND WHUMDGL SHUPDVDODKDQ GL GDODP KXNXP PDNDKXNXPODK\DQJKDUXV GLWLQMDX GDQ GLSHUEDLNL EXNDQ PDQXVLDQ\D \DQJ GLSDNVD XQWXN GLPDVXNNDQ NH GDODP VNHPD KXNXP 'DODP NRQWHNV SHQHQWXDQ EHQWXNGDQEHVDUQ\DJDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLN\DQJ EHUEDVLVKXNXPSURJUHVLISHUOXGLZXMXGNDQ NHDGLODQ SURJUHVLI 2OHK NDUHQD LWX GLSHUOXNDQ SHUXEDKDQ DJDU GDODP SUDNWHN GDODPPHQHQWXNDQJDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLNGDODP SURVHV SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP OHELK PHQHNDQNDQ SDGD VXEVWDQVL VHKLQJJD \DQJ GLKDVLONDQ DGDODK NHDGLODQ SURJUHVLI
0HWRGHPHQXMXWHUZXMXGQ\DNHDGLODQ VXEVWDQWLI GDODP SHQHQWXDQ EHQWXN GDQ EHVDUQ\D JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿VLN GDODP SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP WHUVHEXWELVDGLODNXNDQGHQJDQUXOHEUHDNLQJ
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¿VLN SDGD SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQXPXPEHUEDVLVKXNXPSURJUHVLI WLGDNODLQDGDODKXQWXNPHZXMXGNDQNHDGLODQ VXEVWDQVLDO 6HOXUXK SURVHV EHNHUMDQ\D LQVWUXPHQ SHODNVDQD KXNXP 37 WHUVHEXW KDUXVELVDGLYHUL¿NDVLNHGDODPIDNWRUIDNWRU NHDGLODQ NHVHMDKWHUDDQ NHSHGXOLDQ NHSDGD UDN\DW GDQ ODLQODLQ \DQJ NHVHPXDQ\D LWX WHODKWHUNDQGXQJGDODPQLODLQLODL3DQFDVLOD
& 6LPSXODQ
%HUDQMDN GDUL GDWD GDQ SHPEDKDVDQ WHUVHEXWGLDWDVPDNDGDSDWGLWDULNVLPSXODQ VHEDJDLEHULNXW .RQÀLNPHQJHQDLJDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLN S D G D S H Q J D G D D Q W D Q D K X Q W X N NHSHQWLQJDQXPXP 'DODP NRQWHNV NRQÀ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
.RQVWUXNVL %DUX .HELMDNDQ *DQWL 5XJL 1RQ )LVLN 3DGD 3HQJDGDDQ 7DQDK8QWXN.HSHQWLQJDQ8PXP %HEHUDSD XSD\D \DQJ KDUXV GLODNXNDQ EHUNHQDDQ GHQJDQ UHNRQVWUXNVL NHWHQWXDQ JDQWLUXJLQR¿VLNSDGDNHELMDNDQSHPHULQWDK WHUVHEXWDGDODK
D 3URGXN SHUDWXUDQ SHUXQGDQJXQGDQJDQ WHUNDLW JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿VLN GDODP SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK \DQJ WLGDN VHVXDL GHQJDQODQGDVDQQLODL3DQFDVLODVHEDJDL
UHFKWVLGHHKDUXV GLODNXNDQMXGLFLDO UHYLHZGDQKDUXVVHJHUDGLJDQWL
E 3URVHV SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK NKXVXVQ\D GDODP SHQHQWXDQ EHQWXN GDQ EHVDUQ\D JDQWLUXJLGLGXNXQJROHKSHPHULQWDKDQ \ D Q J E H U G D V D U N D Q S U L Q V L S J R R G JRYHUQDQFH
F 3HUXEDKDQ SDUDGLJPD GDUL SRVLWLYLVPH
PHQMDGLSDUDGLJPDSURJUHVLI
G 0HPEDQJXQ NRPLWPHQ EHUVDPD XQWXN PHZXMXGNDQNHVHMDKWHUDDQPDV\DUDNDW GDUL VHOXUXK NRPSRQHQ \DQJ WHUOLEDW GDODP SHUPDVDODKDQ WHUNDLW JDQWL UXJL QRQ¿VLNGDODPSURVHVSHQJDGDDQWDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP WHUPDVXN NRPLWPHQ SHPDQJNX NHSHQWLQJDQ
VWDNHKROGHU 3HPHULQWDK GDODP
EHQWXNSHUDWXUDQGDHUDK\DQJPHQJDWXU PHQJHQDL JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿VLN EDJL PHUHND \DQJ WHUNHQD GDPSDN DNLEDW SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP
'LDNKLUWXOLVDQLQLSHQXOLVPHPEHULNDQ VDUDQ EDKZD XQWXN SHQHQWXDQ EHQWXN GDQ EHVDUQ\DJDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLNSDGDSHQJDGDDQ WDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP GLSHUOXNDQ NRQVWUXNVLEDUXNHELMDNDQJDQWLUXJLQRQ¿VLN .RQVWUXNVL GDSDW GLPXODL GDUL SHUEDLNDQ V X E V W D Q V L S H U X Q G D Q J X Q G D Q J D Q \ D Q J PHQJDWXUPHQJHQDLNHELMDNDQJDQWLUXJLQRQ ¿ V L N S D G D S H Q J D G D D Q W D Q D K X Q W X N NHSHQWLQJDQ XPXP 6HFDUD VXEVWDQVL N H W H Q W X D Q P H Q J H Q D L N U L W H U L D G D Q XNXUDQSDUDPHWHUGDODPSHQHQWXDQJDQWLUXJL QRQ ¿VLN GDODP SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK XQWXN NHSHQWLQJDQXPXPKHQGDNQ\DGLFDQWXPNDQ VHFDUDMHODVGDODPNHELMDNDQSHQJDGDDQWDQDK \DQJEHUODNXGHQJDQEHUEDVLVQLODLNHDGLODQ VRVLDO .RQVWUXNVL VHODQMXWQ\D DGDODK VHFDUD VWUXNWXUDO EHUXSD SHQJXDWDQ OHPEDJD OHPEDJD \DQJ WHUNDLW ODQJVXQJ GHQJDQ SHQHQWXDQ JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿VLN SHQJDGDDQ WDQDKXQWXNNHSHQWLQJDQXPXP%DJLDQODLQ \DQJ SHUOX GLNRQVWUXNVL DGDODK VHFDUD NXOWXUDO GLPDQD SHPHULQWDK VHPHVWLQ\D PHPSHUKDWLNDQQLODLQLODL\DQJKLGXSGDODP PDV\DUDNDWVHKLQJJDDNDQPHQFHJDKNRQÀLN GDODPSURVHVSHQHQWXDQEHQWXNGDQEHVDUQ\D JDQWL UXJL QRQ ¿VLN SDGD SHQJDGDDQ WDQDK XQWXNNHSHQWLQJDQXPXP '$)7$53867$.$ 'DKUHQGRUI 5 .RQÀLN GDQ .RQÀLN 'DODP 0DV\DUDNDW ,QGXVWUL 6HEXDK $QDOLVD.ULWLN-DNDUWD&95DMDZDOL )DLVDO63HQHOLWLDQ.XDOLWDWLI'DVDU
GDVDU $SOLNDVLQ\D 0DODQJ<D\DVDQ $VDK$VLK$VXK
1DVXWLRQ 0HWRGH 3HQHOLWLDQ 1DWXUDOLVWLN.XDOLWDWLI%DQGXQJ 7DUVLWR5DKDUGMR 6 /DSLVDQ /DSLVDQ 'DODP 6WXGL +XNXP 0DODQJ %D\XPHGLD3XEOLVKLQJ 6WHZDUW':6HFRQGDU\5HVHDUFK ,QIRUPDWLRQ 6RXUFHV DQG 0HWKRGV /RQGRQ6DJH3XEOLFDWLRQV1HZEXU\ =DPURQL 3HQJHPEDQJDQ 3HQJDQWDU
7HRUL6RVLDO<RJ\DNDUWD7LDUD<RJD
