7HUDNUHGLWDVL1R$830,/,3,
3(0%8$7$1%,2(7$12/'$5,/,0%$+.$<86(1*21
'BMDBUBSJB
NPMVDDBOB
0LT%DUQHE\ -:*ULPHV'(1*$10(72'(68%675$7
.216(175$6,7,1**,
#JPFUIBOPM1SPEVDUJPOPG4FOHPO8PPE
)DOFDWDULDPROXFFDQD
.JR
#BSOFCZ
+8(SJNFT
8BTUF6TJOH)JHI-PBEJOH4VCTUSBUF.FUIPE
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
.DWDNXQFL/LPEDKND\XVHQJRQOLJQRVHOXORVDKLGUROLVLVNDGDUHWDQRO
SHQMDUDQJDQ ND\X FHGDU &\SWRPHULD MDSRQLFD
PHQJKDVLONDQ NRQYHUVLVHOXORVDVHEDQ\DN GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ VHOXODVH VHEDQ\DN )38JVXEVWUDWGDQVXUIDNWDQ3(* :LQDUQLHWDO GDQHWDQROVHEDQ\DN PHQJJXQDNDQOLJQLQGHULYDWLYHV&KHQJ<DPDPRWR .RGD7DPDL 8UDNL5DWKQD6DUDQ\DGDQ .DODLVHOYDP PHQ\DWDNDQ GHQJDQ SHQDPEDKDQ ZDNWX IHUPHQWDVL VHODPD KDUL VXEVWUDW OLPEDK VHUEXN SHQJJHUJDMLDQ ND\X J VXEVWUDW JOXNRVD SDGD PHGLXP DJDU
JJ GDSDWPHQJKDVLONDQELRHWDQROVHEDQ\DN
JJ GHQJDQ PHWRGHVKDNLQJ 6HKLQJJD
XQWXN PHQLQJNDWNDQ QLODL WDPEDK OLPEDK GDQ PHQJXUDQJLSHQFHPDUDQOLQJNXQJDQVHUWDSROXVL XGDUD SHUOX GLODNXNDQ SHQHOLWLDQ SHPEXDWDQ ELRHWDQROGDULOLPEDKSHQJJHUJDMLDQND\XPHODOXL SURVHV VDNDULILNDVL VHFDUD HQ]LPDWLN GHQJDQ
SHQDPEDKDQ VXUIDNWDQ GDQVXEVWUDW NRQVHQWUDVL
WLQJJL
3HQDPEDKDQ VXUIDNWDQ 7ZHHQ SDGD
VDNDULILNDVL SXOS EDWDQJ VDZLW
PHQJKDVLONDQNDGDUHWDQROVHEHVDU6XNPDQD 0HQXUXW%DUGDQW,QGL\DQWLGDQ6HOYL\DQWL SHQDPEDKDQ NRQVHQWUDVL VXEVWUDW SDGD VDDW KLGUROLVLV DNDQ PHQLQJNDWNDQ NDGDU HWDQRO \DQJ GLKDVLONDQ VHWHODK IHUPHQWDVL +DVLO SHQHOLWLDQ PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD VXEVWUDW SXOS
7DQGDQ RVRQJ HODSD DZLW7..6VHEDQ\DN. . 6
PHQJKDVLONDQNDGDUHWDQROVHEDQ\DN VHGDQJNDQVXEVWUDWSXOSEDWDQJVDZLWGDSDW PHQJKDVLONDQ NDGDU HWDQRO VHEDQ\DN
'
%DUGDQWHWDO LKDUDSNDQGHQJDQPHWRGH VXEVWUDW NRQVHQWUDVL WLQJJL OLPEDK ND\X SDGD
SHQHOLWLDQ LQL GDSDW PHQJKDVLONDQ NDGDU HWDQRO
\DQJ WLQJJL GDQ GDSDW PHQMDGL VDODK VDWXVROXVL
XQWXN PHQJDWDVL NULVLV HQHUJL 7X OLVDQ LQL
PHPSHODMDUL SRWHQVL NDGDU HWDQRO OLPEDK ND\X
VHQJRQ\DQJGLRODKGHQJDQPHQJJXQDNDQPHWRGH
VXEVWUDWNRQVHQWUDVLWLQJJL
,,%$+$1'$10(72'( $%DKDQGDQ$ODW
%DKDQEDNX\DQJGLJXQDNDQGDODPSHQHOLWLDQ
LQL DGDODK OLPEDK VHEHWDQ VHQJRQ GDUL LQGXVWUL SHQJJHUJDMLDQGL7DVLNPDOD\D%DKDQNLPLD\DQJ GLJXQDNDQ DGDODK HQ]LP &7HFK (Q]LP ¡ VHOXODVHGDQ¢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
6DODKVDWXHQHUJLDOWHUQDWLI \DQJPHQMDQMLNDQ DGDODKELRHWDQRO%LRHWDQROSHUOXGLNHPEDQJNDQ VHEDJDL EDKDQ EDNDU NDUHQD PHUXSDNDQ EDKDQ EDNDU \DQJ UDPDK OLQJNXQJDQ 0HQXUXW %DGDQ 3HQJNDMLDQ GDQ 3HQHUDSDQ 7HNQRORJL %337 WLQJNDW HPLVL NDUERQ GDQ KLGURNDUERQ *DVRKRO ( FDPSXUDQ EHQVLQ GDQ HWDQRO OHELK UHQGDKGLEDQGLQJSUHPLXPGDQSHUWDPD[NDUHQD HWDQRO PHQJDQGXQJ RNVLJHQ \DQJ GDSDW PHQLQJNDWNDQHILVLHQVLSHPEDNDUDQ 6KLQWDZDW\
,QGRQHVLD PHUXSDNDQ VDODK VDWX QHJDUD \DQJ PHPLOLNL LQGXVWUL SHQJRODKDQ ND\X \DQJ FXNXS EDQ\DN +DVLO DNKLU GDUL LQGXVWUL SHQJJHUJDMLDQ ND\X DGDODK OLPEDK LQGXVWUL \DQJ EHUXSD VHUSLK GDQ VHUEXN ND\X \DQJ PHQXPSXN GDQ NXUDQJ GLPDQIDDWNDQ VHKLQJJD GDSDW PHQ\HEDENDQ SHQFHPDUDQ3XUZDQWRPHQ\DWDNDQEDKZD L Q G X V W U L S H Q J J H U J D M L D Q N D\ X U D W D U D W D PHQJKDVLONDQ OLPEDK VHEHVDU YROXPH \DQJWHUGLULGDULVHEHWDQSRWRQJDQND\X
GDQ VHUEXN JHUJDML 0HQXUXW
GDWD.HPHQW ULDQ.HKXWDQDQ5HSXEOLN,QGRQHVLDH SURGXNVL ND\X JHUJDMLDQ WDKXQ PH FDSDL P GDQ SDGD WDKXQ Q VHEDQ\DN MXWD P \DQJ QDLN GDUL WDKXQ VHEHOXPQ\D VHEDQ\DN MXWD P HKLQJJD V SRWHQVLOLPEDKVHUEXNSHQJJHUJDMLDQND\XVHWLDS WDKXQ EHUOLPSDK 8QWXN PHZXMXGNDQ LQGXVWUL
KLMDX GL ELGDQJ SHQJRODKDQ KDVLO KXWDQ PDND
SHUOX GLODNXNDQ SHQJRODKDQ EDKDQ PDWHULDO
OLJQRVHOXORVDVHFDUD HILVLHQVHKLQJJD PHPHQXKL
NULWHULD OLPEDK PLQLPDO ]HURZDVWH GDQ DWDX
SHQLQJNDWDQQLODLWDPEDKOLPEDKDWDXELRPDVVD
+DVLO SHQHOLWLDQ \DQJ WHODK GLODNXNDQ
¢JOXNRVLGDVH SURGXNVL 1292=<0( UDJL
6DFKDURP\FHVFHUHYLVLDH7ZHHQXUHD GDQ13.
3HUDODWDQ \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ DQWDUD ODLQ DODW
KLGUROLVLVUHDNWRUIHUPHQWDVLXQLWGLVWLODWRUDODW
SHQJDGXNQHUDFDKRWSODWH EXUHW EUL[PHWHUS+
PHWHUGDQDODWJHODVNDFD
%0HWRGH
7DKDSDQ SURVHV SHQHOLWLDQ \DQJ GLODNXNDQ DGDODK
8MLSURNVLPDW
'LODNXNDQ XML SUR LPDW NV DQDOLVLV NRPS VLVLR
NLPLDWHUKDGDSEDKDQEDNX\DLWXNDGDUDLU NDGDU
DEXNHODUXWDQGDODPDONRKROEHQ]HQDDLUSDQDV
DLUGLQJLQNDGDUOLJQLQ GDQNDGDUVHOXORVD
3HUVLDSDQEDKDQEDNX
6HEHWDQ ND\X GLSRWRQJ NHFLO NHPXGLDQ
GLODNXNDQ SURVHV GHOLJQLILNDVL SUHWUHDWPHQW
GHQJDQ PHWRGH VXOIDW SXOSLQJ SHUEDQGLQJDQ
NRQVHQWUDVL1D2+GDQ1D 6VXKX& VHODPDMDP 6DNDULILNDVL 6HEDQ\DNP/DVDPVLWUDW& + 2 0 GLPDVXNNDQ NH GDODP J HODV NHPXGLDQ GLWDPEDKNDQGHQJDQ7ZHHQVHEDQ\DNGDUL YROXPH VHWHODK WHUFDPSXU GLWDPEDKNDQ HQ]LP
VHOXODVHGDQ JOXNRVLGDVHVHEDQ\DNGDQ¢
)38J VXEVWUDW .RQWURO GLVLDSNDQ WDQSD SHQDPEDKDQ VXUIDNWDQ 0DVLQJPDVLQJ SXOS GHQJDQ NRQVHQWUDVL GDQ ZY GLPDVXNNDQVHGLNLWGHPLVHGLNLWNHGDODPODUXWDQ GDQ GLDGXN VHODPD MDP 3DGD WDKDS LQL DNDQ GLKDVLONDQ JXOD \DQJ VLDS XQWXN GLIHUPHQWDVL PHQMDGLHWDQRO
)HUPHQWDVL
*XOD \DQJ WHODK GLKDVLONDQ GLDPELO VHGLNLW XQWXN GLDQDOLVLV NDGDU JXOD SHUHGXNVL GHQJDQ PHWRGHWLWUDVLPHQJJXQDNDQODUXWDQOXIIVFKURRO 61, 6HGDQJNDQ VLVD ODUXWDQ GLIHUPHQWDVL GHQJDQ PDVLQJPDVLQJ GLWDPEDK
NDQ XUHD 13. GDQ UDJL 6DFFKDURP\FHV FHUHYLVDH
)HUPHQWDVL EHUODQJVXQJ VHODPD KDUL VHODQMXWQ\D VLDS GLODNXNDQ SHQ\XOLQJDQ XQWXN PHPLVDKNDQHWDQROGHQJDQDLU
3HQJXMLDQJXODGDQELRHWDQRO
D$QDOLVLVNDGDUJXODSHUHGXNVL
3HQJXNXUDQJXODSHUHGXNVLGLODNXNDQGHQJDQ PHWRGH /XII6FKUROO 6HWHODK SURVHV VDNDULILNDVL
GDQVHWHODKIHUPHQWDVLGLDPELOP/ODUXWDQQ\D GDQGLDQDOLVLVJXODSHUHGXNVLQ\D
E $QDOLVLVNDQGXQJDQHWDQRO
$QDOLVLV NDQGXQJDQ HWDQRO SDGD VDPSHO PHQJJXQDNDQ*DV&KURPDWRJUDSK\*&PHUN $JLOHQW1GHQJDQNRQGLVLNRORPFDUERZD[ 0 GHWHNWRU ),' VXKX LQMHNWRU & VXKX DZDO&GDQVXKXDNKLU&GHQJDQNHQDLNDQ VXKX&SHUPHQLW
&$QDOLVLV'DWD
3HQHODDKDQ GDWD KDVLO SHUFREDDQ IHUPHQWDVL
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
3HUVDPDDQPDWHPDWLND\DQJGLJXQDNDQXQWXN UDQFDQJDQWHUVHEXWGLDWDVDGDODK
<GDWDLLM X.L%+LHLM
.HWHUDQJDQ X QLODL WHQJDK XPXP .L
SHUODNXDQ NRPELQDVL DQWDUD IDNWRU )38 \DQJ WHUGLUL DWDV GXD WDUDI GDQ IDNWRU VDPSHO EDKDQ
\DQJ WHUGLUL DWDV WLJD JURXS +L NDGDU JXOD
SHUHGXNVL VHEHOXP IHU PHQWDVL VHEDJDL SHUDJDP % NRHILVLHQ UHJUHVL DQWDUD . WHUKDGDS <GDWDL HLM JDODW HUURU <GDWDL LM DVSHN \DQJ GLDPDWL VHEDJDL UDJDP \DLWX PHQFDNXS NDGDU JXOD SURGXNVL VHWHODK IHUPHQWDVL <GDWD <LHOG NRQYHUVL VHOXORVD <GDWD GDQ NDGDU HWDQRO <GDWDU SDGD XODQJDQNHM
6HODQMXWQ\D GDODP PHQHUDSNDQ SHQHODDKDQ GDWD GHQJDQ DQFRYD WHUVHEXW GLEDQWX GHQJDQ SDNHWSUR6$6
,,,+$6,/'$13(0%$+$6$1
$$QDOLVLV .LPLD %DKDQ %DNX GDQ 3XOS /LPEDK.D\X
+DVLODQDOLVLVSURNVLPDWEDKDQEDNXGDQSXOS OLPEDK ND\X GDSDW GLOLKDW SDGD 7DEHO 'DUL WDEHO WHUVHEXW GDSDW GLOLKDW EDKZD NDGDU OLJQLQ PHQJDODPL SHQXUXQDQ \DQJ VDQJDW GUDVWLV GDUL EDKDQ EDNX PHQMDGL VHWHODK GLODNXNDQ SHUODNXDQ SHQGDKXOXDQ EHUXSD VXOIDW SXOSLQJ 7DQSD SHUODNXDQ SHQGDKXOXDQ DWDX
SUHWUHDWPHQWNRQYHUVLVHOXORVDPHQMDGLJXODVDQJDW UHQGDK \DLWX NXUDQJ GDUL /\QG 'HQJDQWLQJJLQ\DNDQGXQJDQOLJQLQSDGDGLQGLQJ VHOWXPEXKDQDNDQPHQJKDPEDWMDODQQ\DHQ]LP VHOXODVHNHVXEVWUDW\DLWXVHOXORVD6HKLQJJDSHUOX GLODNXNDQ HNVWUDNVL OLJQLQ VHEDJDL VDODK VDWX
PHWRGHSUHWUHWDPHQWXQWXNPHQJXUDQJLNDGDUOLJQLQ
VXEVWUDW VHKLQJJD HQ]LP VHOXODVH DNDQ OHELK PXGDK PHQJNRQYHUVL VHOXORVD GHQJDQ SURVHV KLGUROLVLV
.DGDUVHOXORVDEDKDQEDNXOLPEDKND\XVHQJRQ DGDODKVHEHVDU7DEHO6HWHODKGLODNXNDQ
GHOLJQLILNDVL NDGDU VHOXORVD PHQLQJNDW VHLULQJ GHQJDQ PHQXUXQQ\D NDGDU OLJQLQ 3XOS OLPEDK ND\X EHUSRWHQVL WLQJJL XQWXN GLMDGLNDQ EDKDQ EDNX SHPEXDWDQ ELRHWDQRO GHQJDQ WLQJJLQ\D NDGDU VHOXORVD +DVLO NDGDU VHOXORVD GDQ OLJQLQ WHUVHEXW VHVXDL GHQJDQ KDVLO SHQHOLWLDQ NDGDU VHOXORVD GDQ OLJQLQ \DQJ WHODK GLODNXNDQ VHEHOXPQ\D \DLWX VHEHVDU GDQ :LQDUQL .RPDUD\DWL 'MDUZDQWR
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
.DGDUDOSKDVHOXRVD$OSKDFHOOXORVH FRQWHQW .DGDUKHPLVHOXORVD+HPLFHOOXORVH FRQWHQW 7DEHO$QDOLVLVSURNVLPDWEDKDQEDNXGDQSXOSOLPEDKSHQJJHUJDMLDQND\XVHQJRQ 5BCMF1SPYJNBUFBOBMZTJTPGSBXNBUFSJBMTBOETBXNJMMXBTUFQVMQPGTFOHPO $QDOLVLVSURNVLPDW 3UR[LPDWHDQDO\VLV
%.DGDU *XOD 3HUHGXNVL 6HEHOXP GDQ
6HVXGDK )HUPHQWDVL GHQJDQ .RQVHQWUDVL (Q]LP)38J6XEVWUDWGDQ)38J 6XEVWUDW
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
6HPHQWDUD LWXNDGDU JXOD SHUHGXNVL VHWHODK
IHUPHQWDVL PHQXUXQ NDUHQD JOXNRVD \DQJ WHUEHQWXN VHWHODK VDNDULILNDVL GDQ GLLNXWL SURVHV IHUPHQWDVLDNDQPHUXEDKVHEDJLDQEHVDUJOXNRVD WHUVHEXW PHQMDGL HWDQRO GDQ DNDQ PHQ\LVDNDQ VHGLNLW JXOD SDGD ILOWUDW 0HQXUXW 6XNPDQD DQDOLVLVNDGDUJXODSHUHGXNVLWHUWLQJJLSDGD SXOS EDWDQJ VDZLW \DLWX PJP/ GHQJDQ
NRQVHQWUDVL VXEVWUDW VHEDQ\DN VHEDQ\DN )38JVXEVWUDW6HGDQJNDQXQWXNVXEVWUDW SURVHV VDNDULILNDVL DWDX SHUXEDKDQ VHOXORVD PHQMDGL JXOD WHUXV EHUMDODQ PHVNLSXQ WHODK PHPDVXNL SURVHV IHUPHQWDVL GLPDQD PDVLK WHUGDSDW VXEVWUDW \DQJ GLKLGUROLVLV ROHK VHOXODVH \DQJPDVLKEHNHUMD
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
1R 6DPSHO6DPSOHV )38JVXEVWUDW )HUPHQWDVL6HEHOXP %HIRUHIHUPHQWDWLRQ PJP/ 6HVXGDKIHUPHQWDVL $IWHUIHUPHQWDWLRQ PJP/ 6 & 6 & 6 & 6 & 6 & 6 &
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV6 6DPSHO6DPSOH& .RQWURO&RQWURO6 6DPSHO6DPSOH& .RQWURO
&RQWURO6 6DPSHO6DPSOH& .RQWURO&RQWURO
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
/HELK ODQMXW SHQJDUXK NRPELQDVL . \DQJ Q\DWD WHUKDGDS NDGDU JXOD SHUHGXNVL VHVXGDK IHUPHQWDVL GLXML OHELK ODQMXW GHQJDQ XML W
/DPSLUDQ3DGD/DPSLUDQ WHUVHEXW GDSDW
GLOLKDWEDKZDQLODLNDGDUJXODSHUHGXNVLVHVXGDK IHUPHQWDVL SDGD EDKDQ FRQWRK 6 FHQGHUXQJ OHELKWLQJJLGLEDQGLQJNDQQLODLSDGDNRQWURO& 6HODQMXWQ\DSHQLQJNDWDQQLODL)38GDULNH XQWXN NRGH EDKDQ 6 GDQ & PHQ\HEDENDQ SHQLQJNDWDQ NDGDU JXOD SHUHGXNVL VHVXGDK IHUPHQWDVL<GDWD6HEDOLNQ\DSHQLQJNDWDQQLODL )38WHUVHEXWXQWXNQLODLEDKDQ6GDQ&GDQ 6 GDQ & PHQJDNLEDWNDQ SHQXUXQDQ NDGDU JXOD VHVXGDK IHUPHQWDVL +DO LQL GLVHEDENDQ
GHQJDQ VHPDNLQWLQJJLQ\D NRQVHQWUDVL VXEVWUDW \DQJDNDQGLKLGUROLVLV PDNDVHPDNLQODPD ZDNWX \DQJ GLEXWXKNDQ VHOXODVH XQWXN PHQJNRQYHUVLVHOXORVDPHQMDGLJOXNRVDPHVNLSXQ VXGDKPDVXNSURVHVIHUPHQWDVL &.RQYHUVL6HOXORVD0HQMDGL*XOD 3DGDSURVHVKLGUROLVLVVHPXDVDPSHO6GLEHUL WDPEDKDQVXUIDNWDQ\DLWXYYWZHHQGDQ WLGDNDGDSHQDPEDKDQVXUIDNWDQSDGDNRQWURO& 1LODL NRQYHUVL VHOXORVD NRQWURO PHQXQMXNNDQ DQJND \DQJ OHELK UHQGDK GDUL VHPXD VDPSHO GHQJDQSHQDPEDKDQVXUIDNWDQ+DOLQLGLVHEDE NDQ VXUIDNWDQ GDSDW PHPEDQWX NLQHUMD HQ]LP VHOXODVHVHKLQJJDEHUIXQJVLVHFDUDRSWLPDOXQWXN PHQJNRQYHUVLVHOXORVDPHQMDGLJOXNRVD.RQYHUVL VHOXORVDWHUWLQJJL²GLWXQMXNNDQSDGD NRQVHQWUDVLVXEVWUDWGDQDNWLYLWDVVHOXODVH GDQ )38J VXEVWUDW *DPEDU .RQYHUVL VHOXORVD PHQJDODPL SHQXUXQDQ SDGD ZDNWX SHQDPEDKDQVDPSHOPHQMDGLSDGDDNWLYLWDV VHOXODVH GDQ )38J VXVEWUDW +DO LQL GLVHEDENDQGHQJDQVHPDNLQEDQ\DNQ\DVXEVWUDW \DQJGLPDVXNNDQSDGDVDDWKLGUROLVLVGLEXWXKNDQ ZDNWX \DQJ OHELK ODPD XQWXN PHQJNRQYHUVL VHOXORVD PHQMDGL JXOD .RQYHUVL VHOXORVD SXOS
MDSDQHVHFHGDU GHQJDQ NDGDU OLJQLQ VHEHVDU DGDODKVHEHVDUGHQJDQNRQVHQWUDVLVXEVWUDW VHEHVDU NRQVHQWUDVL HQ]LP )38J VXEVWUDW GDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ 3(* VHEDJDL VXUIDNWDQ 6HGDQJNDQ NRQWURO WDQSD VXUIDNWDQ PHQFDSDL:LQDUQLHWDO
+DVLO DQDOLVLV VWDWLVWLN GHQJDQ DQFRYD /DPSLUDQ PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD SHQJDUXK NRPELQDVL . DQWDUD IDNWRU )38 GDQ IDNWRU
Wolµv ~duv . RQ YHUVLVHOXORVD &HOOXORVHFRQYHUVLRQ
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV6 6DPSHO6DPSOH& .RQWURO&RQWURO6 6DPSHO6DPSOH& .RQWURO&RQWURO6 6DPSHO6DPSOH& .RQWURO&RQWURO
*DPEDU*UDILNNRQYHUVLVHOXORVDPHQMDGLJXODSDGDEHEHUDSDSHUODNXDQ 'JHVSF$FMMVMPTFDPOWFSTJPOJOUPHMVDPTF JOTFWFSBMUSFBUNFOUT ôóUð ôð ôóUò õíUõ ôõUî õì ôîUï ôõUñ ôïUî ôòUñ òïUî óóUñ íìì ôì òì ðì îì ì íñríîUñ^íñríîUñíñríñ^ íñríñ îñríîUñ^îñríîUñ îñríñ^îñríñ ^ïñríîUñ ïñríîUñ ^ ïñríñ ïñríñ
VDPSHOEDKDQMXJDQ\DWDWHUKDGDSQLODLNRQYHUVL VHOXORVD 'HPLNLDQ SXOD NDGDU JXOD SHUHGXNVL VHEHOXPIHUPHQWDVL+MXJDEHUSHQJDUXKQ\DWD WHUKDGDSQLODLNRQYHUVLVHOXORVD<GDWD7HUQ\DWD SHUDQDQ NDGDU JXOD VHEHOXP IHUPHQWDVL + SRVLWLI SXOD WHUKDGDS QLODL NRQYHUVL VHOXORVD GHQJDQ NRHILVLHQ UHJUHVL % DWDX GHQJDQSHUNDWDDQODLQVHPDNLQWLQJJLNDGDUJXOD SHUHGXNVLVHEHOXPIHUPHQWDVL+PDNDVHPDNLQ WLQJJL QLODL NRQYHUVL VHOXORVD <GDWD /HELK ODQMXW SHQJDUXK NRPELQDVL . \DQJ Q\DWD WHUKDGDS QLODL NRQYHUVL VHOXORVD GLWHODDK OHELK ODQMXWGHQJDQXMLW/DPSLUDQ
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
'.DGDU (WDQRO GHQJDQ $NWLYLWDV (Q]LP GDQ)38J6XEVWUDW
3ULQVLSQ\DIHUPHQWDVLDGDODKSHUXEDKDQPRO JOXNRVD JXOD PHQMDGL PRO HWDQRO GDQ PRO NDUERQ GLRNVLGD 3DGD SURVHV IHUPHQWDVL HWDQRO UDJL DNDQ PHODNXNDQ PHWDEROLVPH JOXNRVD GDQ IUXNWRVDPHPEHQWXNDVDPSLUXYDWPHODOXLWDKDSDQ
UHDNVL SDGD MD XU (PEGHQ0H\HUKRI3DUQDVO
VHGDQJNDQ DVDP SLUXYDW \DQJ GLKDVLONDQ DNDQ GLGHNDUERNVLODVL PHQMDGL DVHWDOGHKLGD \DQJ PHQJDODPLGHKLGURJHQDVLPHQMDGLHWDQRO
*DPEDU PHQXQMXNNDQ VHPXD NDGDU HWDQRO NRQWUROGDQSHUODNXDQPHPHQXKLWDUJHWNHOD\DNDQ
SURGXNVLNDUHQDPHQJK VLONDQNDGDUHWDQRO!D
YYSDEULNDONRKRO0DGXNLVPR6DSXWUR 6HPHQWDUD LWX VHPXD NDGDU HWDQRO NRQWURO OHELK UHQGDK GDUL NDGDU HWDQRO VDPSHO SHQDPEDKDQ VXUIDNWDQSDGDVHPXDSHUODNXDQ0HVNLSXQWLGDN
DGDSHUEHGDDQ\DQJVLJQLI NDQSDGDNDGDUHWDQROL
NRQWURO GDQ SHUODNXDQ SDGD NRQVHQWUDVL VXEVWUDW GDQSHQDPEDKDQVHOXODVHGDQ)38J VXEVWUDW 3HUEHGDDQ \DQJ VLJQLILNDQ OHELK WHUOLKDW
VHWHODKNRQVHQWUDVLVXEVWUDW GDQ PDVLQJ
PDVLQJSDGDZDNWXKLGUROLVLV
.DGDUHWDQROWHUWLQJJLGLKDVLONDQGDULSHUODNXDQ NRQVHQWUDVLVXEVWUDWGHQJDQDNWLYLWDVVHOXODVH VHEDQ\DN )38J VXEVWUDW GHQJDQ UHQGHPHQ GDQ WHUHQGDK DGDODK UHQGHPHQ \DLWX NRQWURO GHQJDQ NRQVHQWUDVLVXEVWUDWGDQDNWLYLWDVVHOXODVH )38J VXEVWUDW 6HPDNLQ WLQJJL NRQVHQWUDVL VHOXORVDSDGDZDNWXKLGUROLVLVPDNDVHPDNLQWLQJJL Wolµv ~duv . DGDUHWDQRO (WKDQROFRQWHQW
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV6 6DPSHO6DPSOH& .RQWURO&RQWURO6 6DPSHO6DPSOH& .RQWURO
&RQWURO6 6DPSHO6DPSOH& .RQWURO&RQWURO
*DPEDU.DGDUHWDQROSDGDEHEHUDSDSHUODNXDQ 'JHVSF&UIBOPMDPOUFOU PGTFWFSBMUSFBUNFOUT óUíô îì íô íò íð íî íì ô ò ð î ì íñríîUñ^íñríîUñ íñríñ ^ íñríñ
îñríîUñ^îñríîUñîñríñ ^îñríñ ïñríîUñ^ïñríîUñ ^
ïñríñ ïñríñ óUîñ óUóð ôUôî õUîï íí íìUî íîUó íìUî íðUî ííUó íóUó
HWDQRO\DQJGLKDVLONDQ+DOLQLVHVXDLGHQJDQKDVLO SHQHOLWLDQ \DQJ GLODNXNDQ ROHK %DUGDQW HW DO VHPDNLQ WLQJJL VXEVWUDW SXOS 7..6 VHPDNLQ WLQJJL NDGDU HWDQRO \DQJ GLKDVLONDQ
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
NHPXGLDQGLXUDLROHKUDJLPHQMDGLHWDQROVHODPD MDP IHUPHQWDVL 3DGD NRQVHQWUDVL VDDW IHUPHQWDVLVHOXODVHWLGDNPHPSXQ\DLODJLVHOXORVD XQWXN GLNRQYHUVL PHQMDGL JXOD +DO LQL \DQJ PHQ\HEDENDQ NRQVHQWUDVL VXEVWUDW WHODK PDNVLPDOGLNRQYHUVLVHOXODVHSDGDVDDWKLGUROLVLV
(.HOD\DNDQ3URGXNVLGDQ.HOD\DNDQ+DUJD 3RNRN3URGXNVL
.HOD\DNDQ SURGXNVL GDQ NHOD\DNDQ KDUJD
SRNRNSURGXNVLPHUXSDNDQVDODKVDWXNRPSRQHQ \DQJ GDSDW GLNDML VHEDJDL VXPEHU \DQJ GDSDW PHQGXNXQJ KDVLO \DQJ WHODK GLGDSDWNDQ SDGD SURVHVSURGXNVLELRHWDQRO0DVLQJPDVLQJNDMLDQ LQL PHPLOLNL EDWDVDQ GLDQWDUDQ\D NHOD\DNDQ SURGXNVL GLQ\DWDNDQ OD\DN MLND KDVLOQ\D HWDQRO VHGDQJNDQ NHOD\DNDQ KDUJD SRNRN SURGXNVL GLQ\DWDNDQ OD\DN MLND KDUJD SRNRN SURGXNVLPLQLPDOVHWDUDGHQJDQKDUJDSHUWDPD[
.HOD\DNDQSURGXNVLELRHWDQROSXOSOLPEDKND\X
'DODP SURGXNVL ELRHWDQRO WHUGDSDW VWDQGDU NHOD\DNDQ SURGXNVL GLPDQD NHOD\DNDQ PHQJDFX SDGD NRQVHQWUDVL ELRHWDQRO \DQJ GLGDSDWNDQ 6WDQGDU\DQJGLWHWDSNDQSDGDSURGXNVLELRHWDQRO DGDODKOLPLWHWDQRO.HOD\DNDQSURGXNVLLQL GLGDVDUNDQSDGDNRORPGHVWLODVLDONRKRONRPHUVLDO 37 0DGXNLVPR <RJ\DNDUWD +DVLO SHQHOLWLDQ \DQJ GLODNXNDQ XQWXN IHUPHQWDVL GDUL WLJD SHUODNXDQ \DQJ WHODK GLODNXNDQ PHQXQMXNNDQ VHPXD SHUODNXDQ PHQXQMXNNDQ KDVLO VHVXDL VWDQGDU\DLWXVXEVWUDWGDQ .HOD\DNDQKDUJDSRNRNSURGXNVLSXOSOLPEDK
ND\X
6HODLQ NHOD\DNDQ SURGXNVL PDND KDUXV DGD WLQMDXDQPHQJHQDLKDUJDSRNRNSURGXNVLVHEDJDL DFXDQ EDKZD SURGXNVL ELRHWDQRO LQL GDSDW GLODNXNDQGDODPVNDODLQGXVWULVHEDJDLVDODKVDWX DOWHUQDWLI SHQJJDQWL EHQVLQ .RPSRQHQ ELD\D SURGXNVLELRHWDQROGLVDMLNDQSDGD7DEHO
6HODLQIDNWRUNHOD\DNDQKDUJDSRNRNSURGXNVL SHUNHPEDQJDQ ELRHWDQRO GL GXQLD NKXVXVQ\D GL ,QGRQHVLD GLSHQJDUXKL MXJD ROHK KDUJD SHUNHPEDQJDQ PLQ\DN PHQWDK GXQLD +DUJD ELRHWDQRO GLKDUDSNDQ GDSDW EHUVDLQJ GHQJDQ KDUJD EDKDQ EDNDU GL SDVDUDQ .LVDUDQ \DQJ GLGDSDWNDQ XQWXN KDUJD ELRHWDQRO DGDODK 5S VHGDQJNDQ ELRHWDQRO GLKDUDSNDQ GDSDW PHQ\DPDL DWDX OHELK UHQGDK GDUL SHUWDPD[ VHEHVDU5S
.RPSRQHQELD\D &RVWFRPSRQHQWV -XPODK $PRXQW +DUJD 3ULFH5S 3XOS3XOS %XUXKGDQXWLOLWDV/DERUDQGXWLOLWLHV 6HOXODVH&HOOXODVH 5DJLGDQQXWULHQ1XWULHQWDQG \LHVW 7RWDO%LD\D 5PUBMDPTU OLWHU [ [ OLWHU D %LD\DSURGXNVLSXOS5SNJVHWDUDGHQJDQRQJNRVSURGXNVLSXOSSHU'HVHPEHU%LD\DSURGXNVLWHUVHEXW VXGDK WHUPDVXN ELD\D SHQJLULPDQ EDKDQ EDNX XSDK EXUXK HQHUJL OLVWULN EDKDQEDKDQ NLPLD \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ VDW SURGXNVLSXOS
E %LD\DXWLOLWDVOLVWULNSHQJRODKDQOLPEDKODEDGDQEXUXK5SOLWHUVHWDUDNLQHUMDEXUXKEHUGDVDUNDQVLVWHP\DQJ GLWHUDSNDQROHK37360DGXNLVPR3HUXVDKDDQWHUVHEXWPHQMXDOSURGXNQ\DVHKDUJD5SOLWHUGHQJDQODED\DQJ GLSHUROHKVHEHVDU5S
F .RQYHUVLVHOXORVDPHQMDGLJOXNRVD!GHQJDQKDUJDVHOXODVHEDKDQEXUXKXWLOLWDVVHWDUDNLQHUMDDPLODVH G .RQYHUVL JOXNRVD PHQMDGL HWDQRO ! GHQJDQ NHEXWXKDQ UDJL GDQ QXWULHQ WDPEDKDQ EDKDQ EXUXK
XWLOLWDV VHWDUD NLQHUMD UDJL SDGD HWDQRO GDUL PRODVHV \DQJ GLGDVDUNDQ ROHK VLVWHP \DQJ GLWHUDSNDQ ROHK 37 36 0DGXNLVPR
7DEHO%LD\DSURGXNVLELRHWDQRO 5BCMF&UIBOPMDPTUQSPEVDUJPO
,9.(6,038/$1'$16$5$1 $.HVLPSXODQ
.RQYHUVL VHOXORVD WHUWLQJJL DGDODK VHEHVDU SDGDSHUODNXDQNRQVHQWUDVLVXEVWUDW GDQVHOXODVH)38JVXEVWUDW6HPXDSHUODNXDQ VDPSHOPHQJDODPLSHQLQJNDWDQVHEDQ\DN² NRQYHUVL VHOXORVD GLEDQGLQJNDQ WDQSD VXUIDNWDQ 0HWRGHVXEVWUDWNRQVHQWUDVLWLQJJLPHQJKDVLONDQ NDGDU HWDQRO WHUWLQJJL VHEHVDU GHQJDQ UHQGHPHQ SDGD SHUODNXDQ NRQVHQWUDVL VDPSHOGHQJDQDNWLYLWDVVHOXODVH)38J VXEVWUDW
3DGDSHQJJXQDDQPHWRGHVXEVWUDWNRQVHQWUDVL WLQJJL SHUOX GLODNXNDQ SHUODNXDQ SHQGDKXOXDQ XQWXN PHQJHWDKXL NDGDU VHOXODVH RSWLPDO \DQJ GLEXWXKNDQSDGDVDDWKLGUROLVLVDWDXSHQDPEDKDQ ZDNWX VDNDULILNDVL DWDX IHUPHQWDVL DJDU JXOD
SHUHGXNVLGDQNDGDUHWDQRO HELKPDNVLPDOO
8&$3$17(5,0$.$6,+
3HQXOLV PHQJXFDSNDQ WHULPD NDVLK NHSDGD
3XVDW3HQHOLWLDQGDQ3HQJHPEDQJDQ+DVLO+XWDQ
3++ \DQJ WHODK PHPELD\DL SHQHOLWLDQ LQL PHODOXL ',3$ 3++ WDKXQ GDQ VHPXD SLKDN \DQJ WHODK PHPEDQWX GDODP SHODNVDQDDQ SHQHOLWLDQ WHUXWDPD SDUD WHNQLVL GL ODERUDWRULXP .HOWL3HQJRODKDQ.LPLD(QHUJLGDQ+DVLO+XWDQ %XNDQ.D\X
'$)7$53867$.$
%DUGDQW7%,QGL\DQWL 6HOYL\DQWL7 6WXG\ RI UHVSRQVH VXUIDFH PHWKRGRORJ\ 560 RQ WKH HIIHFW RI VSDQ LQ KLJK VXEVWUDWH ORDGLQJ HQ]\PDWLF K\GURO\VLV
RI SDOP RLO ()% 'DODP7KH .RUHDQG
,QGRQHVLD :RUNVKRS ,QWHU QDWLRQDO 6\PSRVLXP RQ %LRHQHUJ\ IURP %LRPDVV SS
&KHQJ1<DPDPRWR<.RGD.7DPDL< 8UDNL < $PSKLSDWKLF OLJQLQ GHULYDWLYHV WR DFFHOHUDWH VLPXOWDQHRXV VDFFKDULILFDWLRQ DQG IHUPHQWDWLRQ RI XQEOHDFKHG VRIWZRRG SXOS IRU ELRHWKDQRO
SURGXFWLRQ%LRUHVRXUFH7HFKQRORJ\
GRLMELRUWHFK
&RQYHUVH $ 2 2RVKLPD + %XUQV ' 6 .LQHWLFVRI HQ]LPDWLFK\GURO\VLVRI OLJQRFHOOXORVH PDWHULDOV EDVHG RQ VXUIDFH DUHDRI FHOOXORVHDFFHVVLEOHWRHQ]\PHDQG HQ]\PHDGVRUSWLRQRQOLJQLQDQGFHOOXORVH
$SSOLHG%LRFKHPLVWU\DQG%LRWHFKQRORJ\
'XWD'.3HUWDPLQDLPSRU%%0 MXWD EDUHO SHU EXODQ 'LDNVHV GDUL K W W S V Z Z Z F Q Q L Q G R Q H V L D F R P HNRQRPL SHUWDPLQDLPSRUEEPMXWDEDUHO SHUEXODQSDGDWDQJJDO$JXVWXV .HPHQWHULDQ .HKXWDQDQ 5HSXEOLN ,QGRQHVLD 6WDWLVWLN NHKXWDQDQ ,QGRQHVLD .HPHQWHULDQ.HKXWDQDQ-DNDUWD /\QG/52YHUYLHZDQGHYDOXDWLRQRI IXHO HWKDQRO IURP FHOOXORVLF ELRPDVV" 7HFKQRORJ\ HFRQRPLV WKH HQYLURQPHQW
DQGSROLF\$QQXDO5HYLHZRI (QHUJ\DQGWKH
(QYLURQPHQW GRL
DQQXUHYHQHUJ\
3XUZDQWR ' $QDOLVD MHQLV OLPEDK ND\X SDGD LQGXVWUL SHQJRODKDQ ND\X GL
.DOLPDQWDQ 6HODWDQ -XUQDO 5LVHW ,QGXVWUL
+DVLO+XWDQ
5DWKQD * 6 6DUDQ\D 5 .DODLVHOYDP 0 %LRHWKDQRO IURP VDZGXVW XVLQJ
FHOOXODVH K\GURO\VLV RI $VSHUJLOOOXV RFKUDFHXV
DQG IHUPHQWDWLRQ E\6DFKDURP\FHV FHUHYLVDH
0LFURELRORJ\$SSOLHG6FLHQFH
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
FRWWRQ VWDONV%LRUHVRXUFH 7HFKQRORJ\
GRL MELRUWHFK
6XNPDQD + 3HQJJXQDDQ SXOS ND\X NHODSDVDZLWGDODPSURGXNVLELRHWDQROGDUL OLPEDK OLJQRVHOXORVD 6NULSVL 3URJUDP 3HQGLGLNDQ 6DUMDQD ,QVWLWXW 3HUWDQLDQ %RJRU%RJRU
:LQDUQL,.RPDUD\DWL6 'MDUZDQWR )RUPXODVL UDJL FDPSXUDQ XQWXN SURGXNVL
ELRHWDQRO GDUL OLPEDK ND\X VHQJRQ-XUQDO
3HQHOLWLDQ +DVLO +XWDQ GRL
MSKK
:LQDUQL,2LNDZD&<DPDGD7,JDUDVKL. .RGD. 8UDNL<,PSURYHPHQW RI HQ]\PDWLF VDFFKDULILFDWLRQ RI XQEOHDFKHG FHGDU SXOS ZLWK DPSKLSDWKLF
OLJQLQ GHULYDWLYHV%LR5HVRXUFHV
/DPSLUDQ$QDOLVLVVWDWLVWLN
"QQFOEJY4UBUJTUJDBMBOBMZTJT
/DPSLUDQ3HQJDUXK NRPELQDVL IDNWRU )38 GDQ 6% . WHUKDGDS NDGDU JXOD SHUHGXNVL VHVXGDKIHUPHQWDVL<GDWDGHQJDQXMLEHGDW
"QQFOEJY $PNCJOBUJPOFGGFDUPGGJMUFSQBQFSVOJUGBDUPSBOEUSFBUNFOUUPSFEVDJOHTVHBSBGUFS GFSNFOUBUJPOVTJOHUUFTU
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV<GDWD UHUDWDGDULXODQJDQGLWHUDSDGDNDGDUJXODSHUHGXNVL+ $YHUDJHRI UHSOLFDWLRQV
DGMXVWHGRQUHGXFLQJVXJDUOHYHOV+ $QJNDSDGDNRORP<GDWD\DQJGLLNXWLVHFDUDPHQGDWDUROHK
KXUXI \DQJ VDPD WLGDN VDOLQJ EHUEHGD Q\DWD 6% 6XEVWUDW ) DNWLYLWDV HQ]LP )38J VXEVWUDW . SHUODNXDQ7KHQXPEHUVLQFROXPQ<GDWDIROORZHGKRUL]RQWDOO\E\WKHVDPHOHWWHUVDUHQRWGLVWLQFWO\GLIIHUHQW6% 6XEVWUDWH
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
/DPSLUDQ 3HQJDUXK NRPELQDVL IDNWRU )38 GDQ 6% . WHUKDGDS QLODL NRQYHUVL VHOXORVD <GDWDGHQJDQXMLEHGDW
"QQFOEJY $PNCJOBUJPOFGGFDUPGGJMUFSQBQFSVOJUGBDUPSBOEUSFBUNFOUUPDFMMVMPTFDPOWFSUJPO VTJOHUUFTU
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV<GDWD UDWDGDULXODQJDQGLWHUDSDGDNDGDUJXODSHUHGXNVL+ UH <GDWD DYHUDJHRI
UHSOLFDWLRQVDGMXVWHGRQUHGXFLQJVXJDUOHYHOV+ $QJNDSDGDNRORP<GDWD\DQJGLLNXWLVHFDUDPHQGDWDU
ROHK KXUXI \DQJ VDPD WLGDN VDOLQJ EHUEHGD Q\DWD 6% 6XEVWUDW ) DNWLYLWDV HQ]LP )38J VXEVWUDW . SHUODNXDQ 7KH QXPEHUV LQ FROXPQ < GDWD IROORZHG KRUL]RQWDOO\ E\ WKH VDPH OHWWHUV DUH QRW GLVWLQFWO\ GLIIHUHQW
6% 6XEVWUDWH) HQ]\PHDFWLYLW\)38JVXEVWUDW. WUHDWPHQW
/DPSLUDQ1FOHBSVI LPNCJOBTJ GBLUPS '16 EBO 4# , UFSIBEBQ LBEBS FUBOPM :EBUBS EFOHBOVKJCFEBU
"QQFOEJY $PNCJOBUJPOFGGFDUPGGJMUFSQBQFSVOJUGBDUPSBOEUSFBUNFOUUPFUIBOPMDPOUFOUVTJOH UUFTU
.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV<GDWD UHUDWDGDULXODQJDQGLWHUDSDGDNDGDUJXODSHUHGXNVL+ <GDWD DYHUDJHRI
UHSOLFDWLRQVDGMXVWHGRQUHGXFLQJVXJDUOHYHOV+ $QJNDSDGDNRORP<GDWD\DQJGLLNXWLVHFDUDPHQGDWDU
ROHK KXUXI \DQJ VDPD WLGDN VDOLQJ EHUEHGD Q\DWD 6% 6XEVWUDW ) DNWLYLWDV HQ]LP )38J VXEVWUDW . SHUODNXDQ 7KH QXPEHUV LQ FROXPQ < GDWD IROORZHG KRUL]RQWDOO\ E\ WKH VDPH OHWWHUV DUH QRW GLVWLQFWO\ GLIIHUHQW
6% 6XEVWUDWH) HQ]\PHDFWLYLW\)38JVXEVWUDW. WUHDWPHQW
1R 6% ) . .RQYHUVLVHOXORVD &HOOXORVHFRQYHUVLRQ <GDWD 0XWX*UDGHV 1LODL6FRUH 6 R $% & S & 6 T $ & U $ 6 V % & W ) 6 X ( & Y + 6 Z & & [ ' 6 \ * & ] *+ 1R 6% ) . .DGDUHWDQRO (WKDQROFRQWHQW <GDWD 0XWX*UDGHV 1LODL6FRUH 6 R & & S $ 6 T ' & U % 6 V ( & W * 6 X ) & Y + 6 Z ( & [ '( 6 \ % & ] (
