Pengaruh Tata Kelola Pemerintahan yang Baik(Good Governance) terhadap Resistensi Sosial Perubahan Pembangunan oleh Masyarakat

(1)

3HQJDUXK7DWD.HOROD

3HPHULQWDKDQ\DQJ

%DLNRRGRYHUQDQFH

7HUKDGDS5HVLVWHQVL6RVLDO

3HUXEDKDQ3HPEDQJXQDQROHK

0DV\DUDNDW

(2)

K

oZW

^

]

h

o]Z

_l

W_vv_lo}o_u]vZv_ÇvP_]l_µ_o]Z_]lvo_vPv_]oZ_P}}

P}Àvv_uµlv_oZ_µ_Áµiµ_µvµl_ovPPvÇ_vP_ÇvP_uviµviµvP

lvvPv_lÇX:_]l_]l]lv_vPv_µZv_Z_uvPµvv_uÇlU_]o

P}}_P}Àvv_µ_l_olv_ÇvP_ZµvÇU_ul_lv_uv]uµolv_l]

µ_]v]_µ_v}olv_]_uÇlX_lv_vÇl_lµ]Pv_v_llv

]o_uvPµvv_µ_uvPPµ_ZlrZl_]_uÇlX W_µZv_Z_µµ

ÇvP_µZ_uv]u]_uÇl_lv_uv]uµolv_v}olv_]_uÇl_µvµl_uo]vµvP]

v]o]rv]o]_ÇvP_µZX,_o_]v]_uvi]_vvPv_P]_u]vZ_ou_uuZu]_ÇvP

]µµZlv_uÇl_P_l]ov_v_liZv_l_Z]ovP_lv_uvPµvvX

<_lµv]W'_}}_P}ÀvvU]v]UµZvUuÇlX

X WE,h>hE 'o}o]]ÇvPluvPP]µ uuvPµZ]P]]vPlZ]µvU o Z µ v Ç u v Ç v µ Z ] v P u ] v Z v o uu v i o v l v uvPµvvX W}uvPµvvÇvP

]olµlvu]vZuµlvvµl

vvvZµZvX ouZo

]v]UµiµvÇvP]]vP]vlvoZuvPµZ

lZ]µvvvPZ]µvuÇl

lµÇvPo]Z]l]oµuvÇX

EuµvouiovvvÇUuÇllv

vµvPuv}olZµZv

µX,o]v]vµµlvvovX

P](l}ÇvP]uvPlvv

]Zu]}oZuÇl]µv]]X

/v}v]u]ZlvovPvlµvÇ

]lvv]o]vv}uU]uvu]vPru]vP

u Ç l u u ] o ] l ]v ] o ] vv } u

À ]u l v ] ]X D Ç l

uvPu]vlvvuolvlv]lv

µX /lv]v]]iµviµvPvPP]lv

uµlvZP]]ÇvPl]iµo}oZ

µZvuvPµvvÇvPuru

]l]uu]vZU]µµl]u

uÇlX>oµUi]lvÇllvo

ou]u}]ouÇlÇvP]iµu]

Á]oÇZÇvPlvuvi]}il

uvPµvvUlZvv}Pu

uvPµvvlvuuolvvvvÇM

DvµµvvPvvµo]UvµlX

Dllvuv]iovµvµl

uolvlvvÇX]]v]oZvu]vZ

vPvvPX ^oZµlµv]µvµl

uvPZ]vvPvµvo]v

l}u]uvÇvPvPP]]u]vZµvµl

uvlv]v]lo}ou]vZv

ÇvP]l~P}}P}Àvvvv]o]rv]o]

*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO

(3)

oµZµUuolvlvuvuµlv hvvPrhvvP EP Zµo]l /v}v]dZµvíõðñX Wu]vZvÇvP]loZ]lou }vZ]ovÇXWvvvu]vZ ouoiµuvPµvv]Pl]vP] i]llvµvvPvlvvPv uÇlvuu}oZµlµvPv]

uÇlXWu]vZviµP]]llv

]li]l}µlÀ]vÇuuo]Zlv

Z]oÇvPuuµuv]vPllvliZv

uÇlvuu]lvuvv

l]ovX /v]oZuvPi]llo}o

u ] v Z vÇ v P l ] l

uuvPµZ] uÇlµvµluolµlv

]v]X lvoolvPµul vµo]]lµvµluuZvPµZ lo}ou]vZv~P}}P}Àvv Z]v]uvPµvv}oZ uÇlX dµo]v]v]]P]ouµ P]vX P]vµ~ílvuuZ

uvPv]lo}ou]vZv~P}}

P}ÀvvUP]vµ~îÇ]µ]v]

}]oZuvPµvvUvP]vP

uvPv]vPµZlo}ou]vZv

~P}}_P}ÀvvZ]v]Xou

uvÇµµvµo]v]v]vµo]uvPPµvlv

u}vlvÇµ]]v}u(ÇvP

]ovPl]vPvµ]µluooµ]r

ÇvPouµlµrµlµUo]µU

]lorlo]vvX D}

vo]]ÇvP]PµvlvoZvo]]

lµo](ÇvP]]uµolvuvPPµvlv

o}P]l]vµl(X X WD,^E íXd<_o}oW_u]vZv Wu]vZµ^'}Àvuv_ ouZ/vPP]]lvP] ^d_Z_µZ}]À_]}v_v u]v]}v_}(_Z_+]_}( uvlÁ}uv_]v_v}vUU_]ÇU _~vPZvvu]v]] ÇvPÁvvPlP]v}vPr }vPouµZvPUvP P]vUl}UvP]vÇXX '_{} À v v} _{o Z} u ] v Z vll P ] v u ] v Z vU µ l v] v µ ] u]vZvvÇX'_}}_P}Àvv vÇu]vZvÇvP]lU Ç]µu]vZvÇvPuv Z µ lµ uUu v P Z } u Z l ]

uvµ]~,DUuvPZP]v]o]rv]o]

ÇvP]vµ}oZuÇlU

v ] u

u u v P µ v( ] o ] µ v µ l

uvµuµZlvl}v}u]uÇlU

]lPo]UvuvPZ}u

lPuvuµlv]UPuU

µ l µU v µ Ç o } l oX'_{} }} P}ÀvvZµµvPvvPv oÇvv]uUÇ]µZµµvPv }v}µµX:]l}lP]v u]vZv]lv]v]r ]v]P}}_P}ÀvvUul í

Z}Áov]ul&vv}W]µU

Z©Wll}Áovz]µX+XPµvuXX]l}Ávo}l.olïò òîòlríïrrlo}oru]vZvX(U]lZ]^µU

íîE}ÀuîìíòµlµoîìXîî

í

(4)

Z]ovÇoZoÇvv]uUv ulvÇoZliZv uÇlX vPvu]l]vUP}} P}Àvv_voÇvv]u uµlvvµvµluÁµiµlv liZvuÇlX DvµµhEW~hv]E}v Ào}uv W}PuUll]l µ]v]ÇvPZµ]vµv ] l u v P l v o u l l vÇovPPvP}}_P}Àvv uo]µW X W ]~ ] } v U Ç]µÁPvP]] luvµvµl]lµ o u } v P u ] o v l µ µ v } o ] lll ] i l v µo]lV

X µvZµlµu~µo_}(_oÁU

Ç]µu]vZuviu]v

PlvÇZµlµuviu]vvÇ

ZlrZl]uvµ]V

X dvv]~vvÇU

Ç]µuµl]ilvµo]l

ZµvvUuµo]] }vPu]ovlµµvU o l v vUu µ µ v Àoµ]vÇX µ]v(}u]l }oZZovPV X ÇvPP~}v]ÀvU Ç ] µ u µ o u P u]vZvZµuu]lv oÇvvÇvP]ll u Ç l v  l Z } o ~ ] Z lÇ v P lvvPvV X } ] v ]l } v v µ ~}vvµ_}]v}vUÇ]µ l]ilvÇvP]u]o]lv ]o]Zvr]o]ZvÇvP]lU lvllvuµ µvµuÇlV (X l]ov~µ]ÇUÇ]µ vÇluvÇvPu P]uµÁPvPU]l

ol]rol]uµµvuµvU

µ v µ l u v ] v P l l v liZvvÇV PX (l(v.]v~+À]v v_8]vÇ_UÇ]µ}r } vl P ] vrl P ] v ouPZµuvPZ]olv }µµÇvPµ]vPvµiµv vvÇvP]P]lvUv u v P P µ v l v µ u Ç ]luµvPl]vV ZX lµv]o]~}µv]o]ÇU Ç]µuµlµµv ouu]vZvUouP Á U vu Ç l vPPµvPiÁlµo]l vo u P ro u P lZ}oV ]X s]]P]~P]_Z}oU Ç]µu]u]vvµo]l uu]o]l]À]]P]iµZl

vUuuvPµvuv

ÇvPo]Z]llvv]o]r

î

ï

,v](EµZ}o]Ud}]vWllWu]vZvvK}v}u] ZU~:lW']v}UîììñUZouvïìì

î

/]UZouvïììrïìí

ï

*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO

(5)

v]o]luvµ]vÇvPµv]Ào vuvÇiZlvX <l]l]v ]uµ lv }v]lo}ou]vZv ouuÁµiµlvvPÇvP]o viZX ^o]vll]l] U ] ] v v Po ] v vÇÇ v P

uvÇvPlµlo}ou]vZv

Ç]µW

X DuZlvlvvPv

lµuo]vPu]l]vvouZ

~lZµµvÇl]vvPv lµµvµvµluvPo}l]lv µuÇuvPµvvV X W]}]}o]lU}]oUv l}v}u]]vPµv] }vvµV X D v P ] l µ l v u µ l v v P v ] o u uvvlvvuµuµlv µµl]ilvV X d v v ] v vPPµvPviÁuvi] P]v]vZv]ouoµµZ ]lv]olµllµvvÇV X ] } l ] u ] v Z v

]olµlvvPv(l(U.]vU

v]oV

(X ^µu]Zµlµu]ollv

v]olµlvl}v]vX ]o]Z]]]µ uvµviµllvZÁ]}] Ç v PZ µ ] P v P o u uviovlvP}}_P}ÀvvUÇ]µ uÇlX Wu]vZoZ]

lÇU}oZlÇUvµvµllÇX

îXZ_]v] ^_}]o d_Z W_µZv W_uvPµvv > } v } s] v ] v Z uvµo]U^/_]_]_}_]_Z P]vv]vP_Zv_Z_vX_ <µv µPlvÇµ]vPv l} v ] ]Ç v P vÇ l i ] ] uÇlUZÁ]v]Zu] ]vP]olµlvllu]ovÇµµ }Pv]]uµo]uvlvµµ ÇvPµX Z]v]µv}olv µZvuvPµvv µuµuvÇlvi]ll µµÇvPuvPvuv]o] } v P µ l o } u } l

uÇlX,orZoµµiµP

]vlvPvµZvrµZv

]vvoÇvPouuÇlX

zvPZµ]Zu]oZ

ZÁovuvP

uÇluolµlvoÁvv

ZµZvµW X dlµZluµvPl]vv ÇvPl]lZµ]X WµZvl]l llvX^uµ}vPZµ ZÁllvuµlv µµÇvPluu]lv uvvvÇuvX<Pµv vllZµvZ ÇvPlvi]]luµ]vZ] ð

Z}Áov]ul&vv}W]µUKX]X

ð

ñ

tZÇµv]vP]Z^v}U

Z©Wll}XP}}PoX}ul}µuvllíÌí&sl<ÁE,<' D'òPyEîYuôZôPKshl]U]lZ]^µUíî E}ÀuîìíòUµlµoíõXïðUvPvuvuZlvv vµo]

î

(6)

]v]lvuv]uµolvlµX X dlµlvlPPovX W µ Z vu u µ v P l ] v l v uvµvµuÇlµvµl u u ] o ] l ]l u u µ v v ]olµÇvPµZ]vPP uv]uµolvllZÁvlv PPoouuviov]ZoÇvP µµX X d] l l v P v lµµZvlvµZvX WvvPuvPµvv

uµvPl]vuZÁovPlZ

µÇvPulvvPoZ ovPlZÇvP]lvvX WZouµvPl]viZÁ o v P l Z µ l ]µµZlvuÇlX X dlµlZ]ovPvµµÇvP v]o]P]vÇX D Ç l v µ] v P ] v

uvPZµ]P]uvul

uvPµvvulX :]l

uÇl]vZÁullv

lZ]ovPvµµUulul

vµlvuv}olX X vPPvuv]vPPolvÁ]oÇZ ÇvPµZvÇuvX <oµ]Á]oÇZÇvPµZ uu]lvlvÇuvvvµ uvPvµvP]l}X (X <lZuvvlv lÇvX DÇluv}olµZv llulluuZu] } µ µ vÇ vu v P v P P ZÁµZv]i]ZvÇ lvuuv]] ÇvP]}oZX ^]µ]

u]l]vi]]ol

lÇvv]ZlÇvP uvPµµolvµZvvPv uÇlX PX <lÇvX D Ç l ] u v P o u ] l}v]]llÇv vPlvvµX KoZlv ] µUu Ç l u v } uuZvlvµµ}X D Ç l v P P vµ v µ l µZiµPlv]v]}]oU vo]vlvul]l

l]uv]o]~Àoµ_ÇuÇvP

o(ovPPvPvul]l]

]lluvvv]ZX }u]v]ÇvP]lvuÇlX }u]v]]v]uµvµo]]Zlr]Zl Ç v Pu o l µ l v u v P µ v v µ X o o u v P l vU ^W]v]µuµuuÇlZÁ] uv}u]v]Uullv oÁvv~v}olvZ }u]v]UvP]vPvv }Çlov(vvPP]uv

uvPµlZ]µv}]o~ooW

íõõóUÆÀ]]X ^]u}u]v]uvµµ

to t]vl~íõõîoZlo}u}l

}}]µvÇvPuullv

*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO

(7)

lµvÇ]Zlo]vUµ] ] l l vl o } u } lrl o } u } l }u]vvµvÇvPuullv lµvÇ]Zlo]vµvµl]]lµ u]lvvPvvÇX<vul oZlo}u}l}u]vvul

}u]v]ulµZuvi]

]uÇvPiµP]]lvµ

]µlvovuvvvÇX

DvPv]}PuuZµv

vvÇvP]µiµlvµvµl

uµZ]olµuÇlUZo

µuµlvµÇÇvP

vPi]olµlvPµvuv]vPllv

vPl]vlvuooµ]lP]v

]vÀv]vPvvµvvPv

uZµv]oµ]u}]o

uÇl~}µ]_ZvP_PvX Dvµµ >]]©~íõòõU ov~ô(l}ÇvPuvi] vÇi]vÇ]v]}]o ouuÇlZ}Pu µZvvvUÇ]µW X :] l µ i µ v } P u u Z µ v] µ l ]]v(}u]lvvPvµlµ i o v ] u v P } o Z uÇlV X :]l}l}Zr}l}Zluµl ouuÇlU]l(}uo uµµvv}v(}uol]]lµ l v o u Z v v v~ ] v }PuV X :]lµµo}PuµZv vv]lvl lvvPv~ov]] }vPµ}vP uruV X :]lv}urv}uµÇU v}]oUvl]vr l]vuÇl]]lvV X :]ll}uµv]l]ÇvP lµvP]lvvPo}o }PuvPvuÇlÇvP lvvvPvµZv]µV (X :]lllZÁvlv lPPovouolvv }PuU]lvPo}o } P uu µ µ v o u uÇlV PX :] l ] Ç µ Z v] µ ]lvooµuZoUµ ] u o vÇ v P ] } o Z u Ç l ] µ Z v µlµvPuu]V ZX :]llvlvP]lv oZuuµlvP]P]v uÇlX ïXW_vPµZ d <_o}o W_u]vZv d_ZZ_]v]D_Çl ^ÇvPµZ]Z] Uu Ç l Z l o u ò ó

v]oEµZuUDîììõU

ò

^µÇt]iÇU

íõXïî

ó

(8)

uuµµlvl]ilvÇvP]u]o u]vZX ouZoµZv uvPµvvUuÇlZl uvPoµlvvvPvvÇX ] ]v]oZµPu]vZou uviovlv]v]r]v]v]] P}}_P}ÀvvX Wu]vZZµ uviu]vZlrZl]uÇlX P ] u v i ] l u v P µ v v µ u v P P µ , D v ulll]ovM :]l u u v P u v P µ v vÇ v P ]vvPu]vZ]lUul u]vZZµvvv u u ] l v v P v v viovluÇlU lvµZµZvlv u v ] u µ o l vl l vX Du]lvviovl u Ç l i µ P Z µ u u Z l vu } Ç v P ]PµvlvUlvuÇl

uu]o]l]oolvPÇvPr

X À]~îììíuvPµµolvP vlvÇvP]lv o uu v P ] ] v ] uÇlUÇ]µ(}_ZvP PÇUµÀ_ZvP_PÇU v}volo(r]v_ZvP PÇX µÀ_ZvP_PÇ Ç]µuvPµl]uÇlµ u u ] l v v P Z µ v v ]v(}u]vvPoµvÇµµ µ Z v X D o o µ ] µl]]ZlvlvuuZu] vvPvÇµZvZ]vP P u l µ v l vu v ] u µZvµXZ_}volo(r ] v _{Z v P}_{P Ç}Ç ] µ uvµviµllvv.~lµvµvPv ÇvPlv]}oZ]v]À]µ] ]lvvÇµµµZv Z]vPP]v]À]µµvPv v]]vÇlv]luolµlv µ Z vr µ Z vX hv µ l vlv(}_ZvP_PÇU

vµo]uu]o]l]l]uvPvlv

Z o ] v ] X & _} _{Z v P} PÇuµlvµZvZµ i]~]llvv}vPÇvP uvPZµlvi]vÇ µZvoZ}vPÇvPuu]o]l] llµvUÇ]µ]u]vvX <l ]u]vvÇvPuu]o]l]llµv

(}uooZuuµµlvvÇ

µ Z vUu l µ o ] lZ µ u v ] u µ Z v µ X Wvlv]v]lvµµli]l ]lvP]ovPlZu ]v]vPlvvPvµvlv ÇvPo]vX :]lZoµi]U ulu]vZluvlv ]v]P}}_P}ÀvvX ou}vlvUoµ ]uvPlvvÇvÇvP

]luµllv &]~íõóìUZÁ

^ouuvPZ]]u}]o

ô

tZÇµv]vP]Z^v}UKX]X

ô

*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO

(9)

uÇlivPvl]v }oZr}oZuÇllZµ µvuvPv]µµZoÇvP lvvvPvµÇlÇvPlv ]µZ_X DÇlllv u o l µ l v ] ] v ] ] o u v P µ v v µ l uvPPvPPµÇvPou]v] ]lZµ]uÇlvÇvP l]lZµ]u]vZX ouuvPµvvU u ] v Z i µ P Z µ u u Z l vl ] o v v l i Z vu Ç l X W u ] v Z Ç } P Ç v Ç µ µ v uvvPlvuoZÇvP

lvi]i]lu]Zuolµlv

uvPµvvµX:]luuvP u]vZ]vP]vuolµlv u v P µ v v µ U µ Z ZµvÇu]vZuuZu] vuvvPovPlZÇvP Zµ]µZlrZluÇll PvPPµUuv]uµolv uvv]oX hµoZ

uvPµvviµPivPvur

uµvµllvvPv}vP

µlo}u}l]v]À]µÇvPlv

uvPPµlvvPvµo]lX,o]µ

u i u u ] l v ] u

}u]v]ÇvPvÇrvÇlv

uul]ovvliZv

uÇlX :]lP}}_P}Àvvolv vPv]lvvµZvÇUul lvÁµiµvPÇvP]ov iZX X <^/DWh>E

Wu]vZZµuvlvlo}o

u]vZvÇvP]l~P}}_P}Àvv

vPvvµZvÇX DÇll}oZ

oP]o]ZP]}iluvPµvvXZlÇ

Zµuvi]µiluvPµvvXhvµl]µU

l]ilvouµZvluvPµvv

ÇvP]olµlvu]vZZµuooµ]

}]uvuÇlµvÇllµv

µvµluvvµlvvuuvPµZ]}

uvPµvvX K]v]uvPµvvZµ

]µiµlvµvµlliZvvl]ov

uÇllouvvPZlÁZX

WuvPµvvZµvrvuviu]v luÇlµvµluv]lu u v P µ v vU vu v i u ] vZ lrZ l uÇl]ouvPµvvµl uvPµvµvPlvP]uÇlX

*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO

(10)

&dZWh^d<

µlµ

EµZ}o]U,v](Ud}]_vW_llW_u]vZv_vK_}v}u]_ZU~:lW']v}Uîììñ

t]vv}Uµ]U'_o}o]]W_oµvP_µ_vuv/_v}v]U~:lWovPPUîììô

t

v]oEµZuUDîììõU

íõXïï

Z}Áov]ul&vv}W]µU

u]vZvX(U]lZ]^µUíîE}ÀuîìíòµlµoîìXîî

Z]^µUíîE}ÀuîìíòUµlµoíõXïî

tZÇµv]vP]Z^v}U

]lZ]^µUíîE}ÀuîìíòUµlµoíõXïð

awtMqajszqnx

^Z/ h>/^,_UoZ]] :lUó ^uíõõñX :vivPv]]lvvÇ

oZd<WovP]l]U^E:luìól]U^DWEíõî:lU^DE

òó:lUv]v]]&lµo,µlµuhv]À]]}vP}}^uvPX

WvZuvi]vPP} Wo]µ Á vPo WD< &, hv]îìíðrîìíñU

<}}]v}Wo]µÁvPoWD<&,hv]îìíñrîìíòUvPP}Zl] >WD 'u <]ovîìíðU Zlµ Wolv D] Kvo]v >WD 'u

<]ovîìíñUv]v]P]ZlµWolvDioZv:µvo

>WD'u<]ovîìíòXu]oW]µo]ZPu]oX}uX

Pengaruh Tata Kelola Pemerintahan yang Baik(Good Governance) terhadap Resistensi Sosial Perubahan Pembangunan oleh Masyarakat

3HQJDUXK7DWD.HOROD

3HPHULQWDKDQ\DQJ

%DLN*RRG*RYHUQDQFH

7HUKDGDS5HVLVWHQVL6RVLDO

3HUXEDKDQ3HPEDQJXQDQROHK

0DV\DUDNDW

K

oZW

^

]

h

o]Z

*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO

*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO

*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO

*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO

*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO

awtMqajszqnx

*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO

%DLNRRGRYHUQDQFH

]

o]Z