IJTech Corresponding Author

(1)

27/01/2023, 15:04 unila.ac.id Mail - [IJTech] Manuscript Submission Notification for ME-4958

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=54076d8543&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f%3A1702123366546119880&simpl=msg-f%3A1702123… 1/1 IRZA SUKMANA <irza.sukmana@eng.unila.ac.id>

[IJTech] Manuscript Submission Notification for ME-4958

1 message

IJTech <noreply@ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id> Thu, Jun 10, 2021 at 3:42 AM

Reply-To: "noreply@ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id" <noreply@ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id>

To: irza.sukmana@eng.unila.ac.id

Manuscript Submission Confirmation

Dear Dr. Irza Sukmana,

Your manuscript entitled "Characterization and potential production of glass-ceramics biomaterial from basalt rock of local Lampung Province" has been successfully submitted to International Journal of Technology (IJTech) Online System.

Your manuscript ID #: ME-4958.

Please quote the above manuscript ID in all future correspondence. If there are any changes in your postal or e-mail address, please log into IJTech Online System at https://ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id/ and edit your contact and/or personal information as appropriate.

You can also view the status of your manuscript at any time by checking your Author Account after logging in to https://ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id/dashboard.

Thank you for submitting your manuscript to International Journal of Technology (IJTech) Online System.

Yours sincerely, Editorial System

International Journal of Technology (IJTech) p-ISSN: 2086-9614

e-ISSN: 2087-2100 https://ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id/

IJTech is currently indexed in SCOPUS and Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI) Thomson Reuters

(2)

27/01/2023, 15:05 unila.ac.id Mail - [IJTech] Result of initial screening for manuscript #MME-4958: Revise

[IJTech] Result of initial screening for manuscript #MME-4958: Revise

2 messages

IJTech <noreply@ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id> Mon, Jul 5, 2021 at 2:40 PM

Screening result: Need Revision

I am writing to you regarding the manuscript #MME-4958 entitled "Characterization and potential production of glass-ceramics biomaterial from basalt rock of local Lampung Province" which you submitted to International Journal of Technology (IJTech).

After we made an initial screening we found some problem including:

1. Unsuitable Format

2. Your references style is not suitable to IJTech format. You may find IJTech references style at our official website : http://ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id/about/4/author-guidelines

We recommend that this manuscript be revised in order to proceed to peer review.

You must respond to this revise and resubmit request before 12 Jul 2021, after which point we will presume that you have withdrawn your submission from International Journal of Technology (IJTech) Online System.

Yours sincerely, Dr. Nyoman Suwartha nsuwartha@eng.ui.ac.id Managing Editor Editor in Chief

International Journal of Technology (IJTech) p-ISSN: 2086-9614

IRZA SUKMANA <irza.sukmana@eng.unila.ac.id> Mon, Jul 5, 2021 at 5:28 PM

To: Yusup H <yusuph_ugm07@yahoo.com>

[Quoted text hidden]

-- ----

Dr. Irza Sukmana

Department of Mechanical Engineering Vice Dean for Academic and Cooperation Faculty of Engineering, University of Lampung Jl. Professor Soemantri Brojonegoro No. 1 Bandar Lampung 35145, Indonesia

phone: +62-812 94836432 | facsimile: +62-721 704947

email: irza.sukmana@eng.unila.ac.id | http://www.eng.unila.ac.id/

profile: //www.researchgate.net/profile/Irza_Sukmana2

(3)

27/01/2023, 15:06 unila.ac.id Mail - [IJTech] Decision for manuscript #MME-4958: Need to be Revised

[IJTech] Decision for manuscript #MME-4958: Need to be Revised

2 messages

IJTech <noreply@ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id> Mon, May 23, 2022 at 11:34 AM

To: irza.sukmana@eng.unila.ac.id, kusn005@lipi.go.id, shirley.savetlana@eng.unila.ac.id, yusu016@lipi.go.id, muha047@lipi.go.id, davi001@lipi.go.id

Decision Result : Revise

Dear Dr. Irza Sukmana

We have finished the review and made decision on your manuscript entitled [ Characterization and potential production of glass-ceramics biomaterial from basalt rock of local Lampung Province ] which was submitted to International Journal of Technology.

We have decided that your manuscript Need to be Revised

We also send you the review result from the reviewers. Here is the detail review result:

Notes from Editor:

1. Please revise according to the reviewer's comment, and highlights the revised in different color 2. It is suggested to include at least 3 relevant IJTech articles as references

Reviewer (1) Introduction:

See comment for other section, Methodology:

See comment for other section, Results and Discussion:

See comment for other section, References:

See comment for other section, Other:

I have read this paper and found that the discussion on the relationship between the composition, structure, and morphology of glass-ceramics biomaterials from basalt rock of local Lampung Province is unclear. The data generated by the analysis of X-ray Fluorescence, X-Ray Diffraction, density and microstructure need to be linked to each other so that the structure-properties relationship can be seen clearly. This is the main result of the characterization that has been carried out. If this is not presented clearly, then the reported results will be meaningless. Therefore, I suggest that this paper needs to be improved by taking this aspect into account. The criteria for glass-ceramics biomaterials that have good performance need to be clarified. Does the material produced in this research fit into these criteria?

Besides, the image quality, especially Figs 3 and 5 needs to be improved. Fonts and images are not clear.

Originality 3 (average) Technical 3 (average) Methodology 3 (average) Readability 3 (average) Practicability 3 (average) Organization 3 (average) Importance 3 (average) Attachment from reviewer:

-

(4)

27/01/2023, 15:06 unila.ac.id Mail - [IJTech] Decision for manuscript #MME-4958: Need to be Revised

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=54076d8543&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f%3A1733590479494951665&simpl=msg-f%3A1733590… 2/2 Reviewer (2)

Introduction:

No clear statement to the background why the local basalt should be used as raw materials for glass ceramics. A literature review of previous studies related to this specific topic should be included.

Methodology:

The reason or purpose for the chosen parameter, i.e. the thermal treatment, should be stated. What information or knowledge will be built from the results of the experiments.

Results and Discussion:

Good References:

Good Other:

It is difficult to understand the author. The manuscript shoul be re-written in standard English. Some correction on errors of the English structures are given in the file attached.

Originality 4 (above average) Technical 4 (above average) Methodology 3 (average) Readability 2 (fair) Practicability 5 (excellent) Organization 3 (average) Importance 3 (average) Attachment from reviewer:

Click to download

Please login into application https://ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id/login for more detail.

You must respond to this revise and resubmit request before 30 May 2022, after which point we will presume that you have withdrawn your submission from International Journal of Technology (IJTech) Online System.

Yours sincerely, Dr. Eny Kusrini Managing Editor

International Journal of Technology (IJTech) p-ISSN : 2086-9614

e-ISSN 2087-2100 https://ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id/

IRZA SUKMANA <irza.sukmana@eng.unila.ac.id> Mon, May 23, 2022 at 1:02 PM To: Yusup H <yusuph_ugm07@yahoo.com>, yusu016@lipi.go.id

Siang Pak Yusup...

Kabar baik... Good news Pak.

Coba Bpk cek dan baca hasil review nya. Boleh juga Bpk draftkan revisi nya sesuai yg diminta.

Thanks

-- ----

Assoc. Prof. Irza Sukmana, Ph.D.

Department of Mechanical Engineering Faculty of Engineering, Universitas Lampung Jl. Professor Soemantri Brojonegoro No. 1 Bandar Lampung 35145, Indonesia

phone: +62-812 94836432 | facsimile: +62-721 704947

(5)

27/01/2023, 15:06 unila.ac.id Mail - [IJTech] Decision for manuscript #R1-MME-4958: Accepted

[IJTech] Decision for manuscript #R1-MME-4958: Accepted

1 message

IJTech <noreply@ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id> Thu, Jun 23, 2022 at 10:44 AM

To: irza.sukmana@eng.unila.ac.id, kusn005@lipi.go.id, shirley.savetlana@eng.unila.ac.id, yusu016@lipi.go.id, muha047@lipi.go.id, davi001@lipi.go.id

Editor Decision on #R1-MME-4958 : Accepted

Ms ID #R1-MME-4958

Title : Characterization and potential production of glass-ceramics biomaterial from basalt rock of local Lampung Province

Author(s) : Irza Sukmana, Yusup Hendronursito, Shirley Savetlana, Kusno Isnugroho, Muhammad Amin, David Candra Birawidha

Dear Dr. Irza Sukmana , Greetings from Depok,

The editorial board is delighted to inform you that your paper entitled "Characterization and potential production of glass-ceramics biomaterial from basalt rock of local Lampung Province" has been accepted to be published on IJTech. Congratulation!

In order to ensure the readability and the quality of the journal, Starting from 1st of January 2020, all accepted articles to publish will be subjected to article processing charge (APC) of US$ 550 for Regular Publication or US$ 650 for Special Edition Publication, plus 10% VAT, as announced in IJTech's website.

This fee covers the review process, line editing, layouting, DOI deposit, printing, and shipping cost. An invoice will be sent to you in a separate email.

Warmest regards, Prof. Mohammed Ali Berawi Editor in Chief

International Journal of Technology (IJTech) p-ISSN: 2086-9614

(6)

27/01/2023, 14:57 unila.ac.id Mail - [IJTech-EECE-4958] Result of Line-editing of the Paper

[IJTech-EECE-4958] Result of Line-editing of the Paper

3 messages

IJTech <ijtech@eng.ui.ac.id> Tue, Sep 13, 2022 at 9:00 AM

Cc: yusu016@lipi.go.id, shirley.savetlana@eng.unila.ac.id, kusn005@lipi.go.id, muha047@lipi.go.id, davi001@lipi.go.id

We have conducted line editing for your paper as part of the publication process in IJTech. Enclosed, please find the comments from the line editor indicated by the character in color besides black.

We would like to ask you to complete the following:

1. Please make necessary revise the paper accordingly to the line editor's comments.

2. Please complete the detailed information for the name of the author(s), and affiliation of each author(s).

Please refer to Guideline for Author to write the affiliation section (https://ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id/about/3/online- submission)

After the revision is complete, please send it back to ijtech@eng.ui.ac.id by reply to this email, no later than September 16, 2022

We will proceed to the next step (Layouting, Final proof & Copyright) of the revised paper before printing.

We are looking forward to receiving your revised paper soon.

--

Kind regards, Secretariat IJTech

International Journal of Technology (IJTech) ISSN : 2086-9614

http://www.ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id

2 attachments

R1-MME-4958-20220527190331_Clean Version.docx 1050K

R1-MME-4958-20220527190331_Track Version.docx 1054K

IRZA SUKMANA <irza.sukmana@eng.unila.ac.id> Tue, Sep 13, 2022 at 7:57 PM To: Yusup H <yusuph_ugm07@yahoo.com>

-- ----

phone: +62-812 94836432 | facsimile: +62-721 704947

2 attachments

R1-MME-4958-20220527190331_Clean Version.docx 1050K

(7)

27/01/2023, 14:57 unila.ac.id Mail - [IJTech-EECE-4958] Result of Line-editing of the Paper

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=54076d8543&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-f%3A1743818033055671207&simpl=msg-f%3A1743818… 2/2 R1-MME-4958-20220527190331_Track Version.docx

1054K

IRZA SUKMANA <irza.sukmana@eng.unila.ac.id> Fri, Sep 16, 2022 at 9:32 PM To: IJTech <ijtech@eng.ui.ac.id>

Cc: yusu016@lipi.go.id, shirley.savetlana@eng.unila.ac.id, kusn005@lipi.go.id, muha047@lipi.go.id, davi001@lipi.go.id Dear Sir,

Thank you for your email.

Attached, please find the files regarding the revision of our manuscript, i.e., the file with reply comments for the Editor, and the clean version file with detailed information for the authors.

Please let us know if you need any other requirements. We hope now you may consider our article for the next publication steps.

Thank you for your cooperation and consideration. We are looking forward to hearing from you.

Regards, Irza ----

phone: +62-812 94836432 | facsimile: +62-721 704947

2 attachments

R1-MME-4958-20220527190331_Clean_Version.docx 1043K

R1-MME-4958-20220527190331_Reply_Comments.docx 1058K

(8)

27/01/2023, 15:02 Characterization and potential production of glass-ceramics biomaterial from basalt rock of local Lampung Province

https://ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id/dashboard/detail/submission/4958 1/3

 Detail Submission

^R1

Author(s):

1. Dr. Irza Sukmana 

irza.sukmana@eng.unila.ac.id

(mailto:irza.sukmana@eng.unila.ac.id)  Mechanical Engineering Department, Engineering Faculty, Universitas Lampung, Jl. Prof.

Soemantri Brojonegoro No.1, Bandar Lampung 35143, Indonesia

2. Mr. Yusup Hendronursito 

yusu016@lipi.go.id

(mailto:yusu016@lipi.go.id)

1. Mechanical Engineering Department, Engineering Faculty, Universitas Lampung, Jl. Prof.

Soemantri Brojonegoro No.1, Bandar Lampung 35143, Indonesia 2. Mining Technology Research Center – National R

3. Dr. Shirley Savetlana 

shirley.savetlana@eng.unila.ac.id

(mailto:shirley.savetlana@eng.unila.ac.id)

Mechanical Engineering Department, Engineering Faculty, Universitas Lampung, Jl. Prof.

Soemantri Brojonegoro No.1, Bandar Lampung 35143, Indonesia

4. Mr. Kusno Isnugroho 

kusn005@lipi.go.id

(mailto:kusn005@lipi.go.id)

Mining Technology Research Center – National Research and Innovation Agency, Jl. Ir. Sutami Km. 15 Tanjung Bintang, Lampung Selatan 35361, Indonesia

5. Mr. Muhammad Amin 

muha047@lipi.go.id

(mailto:muha047@lipi.go.id)

6. Mr. David Candra Birawidha 

davi001@lipi.go.id

(mailto:davi001@lipi.go.id)

Title:

Characterization and potential production of glass-ceramics biomaterial from basalt rock of local Lampung Province

Article type:

Research Article Abstract:

Glass-ceramics were fine-grained polycrystalline materials produced by controlled crystallization in the glass phase to have outstanding characteristics. The establishment of basalt from Sukadana - Lampung Province into glass-ceramic begins with the process of reduced size and milled under 200 mesh using an ASTM sieve.

The initiated glass-ceramics formation was created by melting the basalt powder at a temperature of 1,250 C for 2hrs to obtain the glass phase. Glass parent crystallization begins with the stage of nucleation growth.

The nucleation process occurs at a temperature 600 C for 1hr. The crystallization temperature at variations of 850, 950, or 1,050 C for 3 and 8hrs. The mechanical hardness test result was 637.28 HV of the sample with 1,050 C heating for 3hrs. The highest hardness value is at 837.33 HV for a sample of 1,050 C heating for 8hrs. The hardness value was decreased at samples for 3hrs heating, while it increased for 8hrs of a heating process. All of the heating treatments formed olivine and Anorthite phase but a pyroxene phase was initiated from 950 C heating process for 3hrs. The use of glass ceramic as an engineering material and biomaterials are promising. It is necessary to continue the development studies on the production process of local basalt resources.

Keywords:

Basalt; Crystallization; Glass ceramics; Hardness; Phase

 Show References

o

o 1N

o 1N o

o

(9)

Submitted Date:

10 Jun 2021 - 03:41

Submitted By:

Dr. Irza Sukmana

(irza.sukmana@eng.unila.ac.id)

Current status:

Published History:

Initial Screening by Editor Started : 11 Jun 2021 - 12:38

Decision : Accepted - Proceed to screening by Secretariat Notes : -

Initial Screening by Secretariat Started : 14 Jun 2021 - 11:35

Decision : Revise - Send back to Author

Notes : Unsuitable Format;

1. Please reduce the pages, the maximum paper length 10 pages.

2. Delete author information, The submission will undergo the blind-review process. Hence, the submitted file MUST NOT include any author information. Author information will be added after the blind-review process.

Initial Screening by Editor Started : 21 Jun 2021 - 07:32

Notes :

Please move to metallurgy and material engineering.

Initial Screening by Editor Started : 01 Jul 2021 - 19:53

 Manuscript Activity  Review History

Files:

Manuscript DOC/DOCX Manuscript PDF

Graphical Abstract - Images Cover Letter



Files after Review Round 1 (R1):

Manuscript DOC/DOCX Manuscript PDF

Graphical Abstract - Images Cover Letter

Response Letter



(10)

Initial Screening by Secretariat Started : 05 Jul 2021 - 14:39

Notes : Unsuitable Format;

Your references style is not suitable to IJTech format. You may find IJTech references style at our official website : http://ijtech.eng.ui.ac.id/about/4/author- guidelines

Initial Screening by Secretariat Started : 13 Jul 2021 - 11:25

Initial Screening by Secretariat Started : 13 Jul 2021 - 11:25 Similarity Rate : 7%

Decision

Started : 23 May 2022 - 11:34 Decision : Revisions Required

Notes : 1. Please revise according to the reviewer's comment, and highlights the revised in different color 2. It is suggested to include at least 3 relevant IJTech articles as references

Decision (R1)

Started : 20 Jun 2022 - 10:52 Decision : Accepted

Notes : -

Decision (R1)

Started : 23 Jun 2022 - 10:44 Decision : Accepted

Notes : -