)$.725)$.7253(1(178<$1*0(03(1*$58+,3(7$1,0(1$1$0
7$1$0$16(/$',$17$5$.$5(7',680$7(5$6(/$7$1
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
.HELDVDDQ PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD WHODK ODPD GLODNXNDQ ROHK SHWDQL 1DPXQ SDGD VDDW SHQGDSDWDQ SHWDQL PHQLQJNDW NDUHQD KDUJD NDUHW WHUJRORQJ WLQJJL SHWDQL NDUHW PDVLK PHPEXGD\DNDQ PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD 2OHK NDUHQD LWX SHQHOLWLDQ GLODNXNDQ XQWXN PHQJLGHQWLILNDVL GDQ PHQJDQDOLVLV IDNWRU GRPLQDQ \DQJ PHPSHQJDUXKL SHWDQL NRQVLVWHQ WDQDPDQ
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
\DLWX7DQDPDQ%HOXP0HQJKDVLONDQ7%0 +D 7DQDPDQ 0HQJKDVLONDQ 70 +DGDQ7DQDPDQ5XVDN75 + D % 3 6 : D O D X S X Q N D U H W PHUXSDNDQ VDODK VDWX NRPRGLWL DQGDODQ QDPXQ SURGXNWLYLWDV SHUNHEXQDQ NDUHW GL 6XPVHO PDVLK UHQGDK 6DODK VDWX SHQ\HEDEQ\D DGDODK SHQJXDVDDQ ODKDQ SHUNHEXQDQNDUHWGL6XPVHOGLNXDVDL R O H K S H U N H E X Q D Q U D N \ D W \ D Q J SHPHOLKDUDDQQ\DEHOXPRSWLPDO
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
7DQDPDQ VHOD GDSDW EHUIXQJVL VHEDJDL WDQDPDQSHQXWXSWDQDKVHKLQJJDGDSDW XQWXN NRQVHUYDVL ODKDQ NDUHW GDQ PHQLQJNDWNDQ SURGXNWLYLWDV WDQDPDQ NDUHW
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² WRQ+D NHGHODL NJ+D GDQ NDFDQJ KLMDX NJ+D GDQ KDVLO DQDOLVLV XVDKDWDQL SDGD WDKXQ SHUWDPD WHUQ\DWD XVDKDWDQLSDGLJRJRGLVHODWDQDPDQNDUHW PDPSX PHPELD\DL XVDKDWDQL NDUHW VHUWD NHEXQ NDUHW WHWDS WHUDZDW GDQ WHUSHOLKDUD 'MDPKXULHWDO6XULDQV\DK
6 H O D L Q P H P E H U L W D P E D K D Q SHQGDSDWDQ SHQDQDPDQ WDQDPDQ VHOD VHSHUWL WDQDPDQ SDQJDQ GDQ KROWLNXOWXUD WXUXW PHPEHULNDQ NRQWULEXVL WHUKDGDS SHUVHGLDDQ WDQDPDQ SDQJDQ VHSHUWL EHUDV VHKLQJJD GDSDW PHQGXNXQJ SURJUDP NHWDKDQDQ SDQJDQ EDLN GDODP VNDOD UHJLRQDO PDXSXQ QDVLRQDO +DO WHUVHEXW S H U O X G L O D N X N D Q P H Q J L Q J D W O D K D Q SHUNHEXQDQ NDUHW VHOXDV \DQJ EHOXP GLPDQIDDWNDQVHFDUDPDNVLPDO6XQDUZLGL
'HQJDQ SHQDQDPDQ WDQDPDQ VHOD DNDQ PHQLQJNDWNDQ SHQGDSDWDQ SHWDQL GLVDPSLQJ LWX PHPEDLNQ\D KDUJD NDUHW PDND DNDQ PHQLQJNDWNDQ SHQGDSDWDQ SHWDQLNDUHW'LGXJDGHQJDQPHQLQJNDWQ\D SHQGDSDWDQ SHWDQL DNLEDW SHQLQJNDWDQ KDUJDNDUHWPHQ\HEDENDQNHFHQGHUXQJDQ SHWDQLXQWXNWLGDNODJLPHQDQDPWDQDPDQ VHOD1DPXQNHQ\DWDDQQ\DPDVLKEDQ\DN SHWDQL \DQJ WHWDS PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD GLDQWDUDNDUHWSDGDXPXU²WDKXQ2OHK NDUHQD LWX SHQHOLWLDQ LQL SHUOX GLODNXNDQ XQWXN PHQJLGHQWLILNDVL GDQ PHQJDQDOLVLV IDNWRUIDNWRU SHQHQWX \DQJ PHQ\HEDENDQ SHWDQLWHWDSPHODNXNDQWDQDPDQVHODNDUHW .HELDVDDQSHWDQL\DQJWHWDSPHPDQIDDWNDQ NHEXQNDUHWVHODPD7%0XQWXNPHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD PDND VHFDUD WLGDN ODQJVXQJ DNDQ PHQDPEDK SHQGDSDWDQ SHWDQL VHUWD GDSDWPHQLQJNDWNDQWLQJNDWNHVHMDKWHUDDQ SHWDQLNDUHWUDN\DW
%$+$1'$10(72'(
3HQHOLWLDQ GLODNXNDQ SDGD EXODQ $SULO GDQ -XQL /RNDVL SHQHOLWLDQ GL 'HVD 3DQJNXO .DEXSDWHQ 0XDUD (QLP 'HVD/XEXN%DQGXQJ.DEXSDWHQ2JDQ,OLU GDQ 'HVD 0DUWD -D\D .DEXSDWHQ 2JDQ .RPHULQJ 8OX 6DPSHO \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ EHUMXPODK SHWDQL GDQ SHQJDPELODQ VDPSHO PHQJJXQDNDQ PHWRGH SXUSRVLYH VDPSOLQJGLPDQDUHVSRQGHQGLSLOLKGHQJDQ VHQJDMD \DLWX GHQJDQ PHPLOLK SHWDQL \DQJ PHPLOLNL NHEXQ NDUHW 7%0 EHUXPXU
WDKXQ 6XUYHL GLODNXNDQ GL ORNDVL SHWDQL
ORNDOPDXSXQSHQGDWDQJ3HQJDPELODQGDWD GLODNXNDQ GHQJDQ PHWRGH VXUYHL PHODOXL ZDZDQFDUD ODQJVXQJ GHQJDQ UHVSRQGHQ PHQJJXQDNDQNXHVLRQHUWHUVWUXNWXU-HQLV GDWD \DQJ GLNXPSXONDQ DQWDUD ODLQ SURILO SHWDQL VWDWXV ODKDQ \DQJ GLPLOLNL MHQLV SHNHUMDDQ SHWDQL PDQIDDW PHQDQDP WDQDPDQVHODMDUDNNHEXQSHWDQLNHUXPDK GDQSDVDUVHUWDLQIRUPDVLODLQ\DQJUHOHYDQ 'DWDGLDQDOLVLVVHFDUDGHVNULSWLIGDQ NXDQWLWDWLI GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ DQDOLVLV UHJUHVLVWHSZLVH$QDOLVLVUHJUHVLGLJXQDNDQ XQWXN PHQJXNXU EHVDUQ\D SHQJDUXK YDULDEHO EHEDV WHUKDGDS YDULDEHO WHULNDW *XMDUDWL 8QWXN PHQGDSDWNDQ PRGHO WHUEDLN GLJXQDNDQ DQDOLVLV UHJUHVL VWHSZLVH 0RGHO WHUEDLN KDUXV EHEDV GDUL PXOWLNROLQLHULWDV DXWRNRUHODVL GDQ KHWHURVNHGDVWLVLWDV 1D]LU 9DULDEHO EHEDV \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ VHEDQ\DN YDULDEHO 0RGHO GLUHSUHVHQWDVLNDQ VHEDJDL EHULNXW < &D;E;F;Q; 'LPDQD <G 3HULODNXSHWDQLGXPP\PHQDQDP WDQDPDQVHODWLGDNPHQDQDP ;G +DUJDNDUHW5S.J ;G 3HQGDSDWDQWDQDPDQVHOD5SEOQ ;G 3HQJKDVLODQSHWDQLSHUEXODQ5SEOQ ;G 8PXUSHWDQLNDUHW7DKXQ ;G 3HQJDODPDQEHUNHEXQNDUHW7DKXQ ;G .HWHUVHGLDDQ WHQDJD WHUMD NHOXDUJD
+2.PLQJJX
S;G -DUDN NHEXQ SHWDQL NH MDODQ SRURV .P ;G -DUDN NHEXQ SHWDQL NH SHPXNLPDQ .P ;G -DUDNNHEXQSHWDQLNHSDVDU.P ;G/XDVODKDQSHWDQLNDUHW+D ;G3HQGLGLNDQSHWDQL7DKXQ ;G7XMXDQ PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD GXPP\ 'LMXDO NRQVXPVL VHQGLUL ;G6WDWXVODKDQSHWDQLGXPP\VHZD PLOLNVHQGLUL ;G3HNHUMDDQ SRNRN GXPP\ QRQ SHWDQLNDUHW3HWDQLNDUHW &G .RQVWDQWD G (UURUWHNQLV 3 H Q H O L W L D Q L Q L P H Q J J X Q D N D Q UHVSRQWHULNDW EHUEHQWXN GXPP\ 7LGDN VHSHUWL UHJUHVL OLQLHU ELDVD SHQJJXQDDQ
UHJUHVL ORJLVWLN PHPLOLNL NHOHELKDQ GDODP KDO SHODQJJDUDQ EHEHUDSD DVXPVL \DQJ KDUXV DGD SDGD UHJUHVL OLQLHU ELDVD VHSHUWL DVXPVLHUURUGDULPRGHOUHJUHVL\DQJGLGDSDW WLGDN PHQ\HEDU QRUPDO GDQ UDJDP YDULDQFHGDULHUURUWLGDNKRPRJHQWHUMDGL KHWHURVNHGDVWLVLWDV SDGD UDJDP HUURU 6HKLQJJD GDUL NHOHELKDQ WHUVHEXW WHUGDSDW NHOHPDKDQGHQJDQPHQJJXQDNDQPRGHOLQL \DLWX GHQJDQ PHODQJJDUQ\D DVXPVL UDJDP GDUL HURU \DQJ WLGDN KRPRJHQ GDSDW PHQMDGLNDQUDJDPPHQMDGLEHVDU(VWLPDVL QLODL<MXJDWHUOHWDNSDGDUDQJH\DQJVDQJDW OXDV GDSDW EHUDGD GL OXDU LQWHUYDO 'HQJDQ GHPLNLDQ VHFDUD PDWHPDWLV SHQJJXQDDQ UHJUHVL ORJLVWLN PHQMDGL OHELK PXGDKGLJXQDNDQ
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
×
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
' D W D S D G D 7 D E H O M X J D PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD SHQGXGXN GL ORNDVL SHQHOLWLDQ PD\RULWDV EHUDVDO GDUL OXDU
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
3URILOSHWDQL )DUPHU·VSURILOH 8UDLDQ 'HVFULSWLRQ 7RWDO 7RWDO 3HUVHQWDVH 3HUFHQWDJH $VDO3HWDQL 3HQGDWDQJ /RNDO 3HQGLGLNDQ 6' 603 60$ 6DUMDQD 8PXU
6XPEHU'DWDSULPHUGLRODK 6RXUFH$QDO\VLVRISULPDU\GDWD 7DEHO3URILOUHVSRQGHQ 7DEOH3URILOHRIUHVSRQGHQWVEDZDK WDKXQ 6HFDUD XPXP VHPXD
SHWDQL NDUHW PHPLOLNL SRWHQVL WHQDJD NHUMD GDODP NHOXDUJD \DQJ FXNXS XQWXN PHQJHUMDNDQ NHJLDWDQ XVDKDWDQL NDUHW 3RWHQVLWHQDJDNHUMDGDODPNHOXDUJDGL'HVD 0DUWD -D\D UDWD²UDWD VHEHVDU +2.PLQJJX.. GL 'HVD 3DQJNXO UDWD UDWDVHEHVDU+2.PLQJJX..GDQ'HVD /XEXN %DQGXQJ UDWD²UDWD VHEHVDU + 2 . P L Q J J X . . ' D W D W H U V H E X W PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD NHWHUVHGLDDQ WHQDJD NHUMDGDODPNHOXDUJDFXNXSGDQWLGDNDGD DODVDQ SHWDQL XQWXN WLGDN VHPSDW PHPHOLKDUD NHEXQ GHQJDQ EDLN GDQ
PHPDQIDDWNDQNHEXQNDUHW7%0WDKXQ XQWXNWDQDPDQVHOD.RQGLVLNHEXQSHWDQL \DQJPHQDQDPWDQDPDQVHODGDSDWGLOLKDW SDGD *DPEDU .RQGLVL NHEXQ NDUHW PHPDQIDDWNDQ ODKDQ GHQJDQ PHQDQDP WDQDPDQVHODVHSHUWLQDQDVFDEDLSLVDQJ SDGLGDQVD\XUDQODLQQ\D$GDQ\DWDQDPDQ VHOD EHUGDPSDN MXJD WHUKDGDS NHEHUVLKDQ NHEXQGDQNHEXQNDUHWWHUSHOLKDUDGHQJDQ EDLN
*DPEDUD 7DQDPDQ VHOD GL 'HVD 3DQJNXO )LJXUHD ,QWHUFURSSLQJDW3DQJNXOG
*DPEDUE 7DQDPDQVHODGL'HVD0DUWD-D\D )LJXUHE ,QWHUFURSSLQJDW0DUWD-D\D
*DPEDUF 7DQDPDQ VHOD GL 'HVD /XEXN %DQGXQJ
)LJXUHF ,QWHUFURSSLQJDW/XEXN%DQGXQJ
*DPEDUG 7DQDPDQVHODGL'HVD3DQJNXO )LJXUHG ,QWHUFURSSLQJDW3DQJNXO
) D N W R U ) D N W R U ' R P L Q D Q \ D Q J 0 H P S H Q J D U X K L 3 H W D Q L 0 H Q D Q D P 7DQDPDQ6HOD
%HUGDVDUNDQKDVLODQDOLVLVVWHSZLVH WHUGDSDW YDULDEHO EHEDV GDUL YDULDEHO EHEDV \DQJ PHPLOLNL KXEXQJDQ NXDW WHUKDGDS SHULODNX SHWDQL XQWXN PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD 7DEHO PHQ\DMLNDQ KDVLO DQDOLVLVVWHSZLVH
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
EHEDV \DQJ WHODK WHUVHOHNVL PHODOXL PRGHO EHUGDVDUNDQ NRQGLVL ODSDQJDQ PHPDQJ PHPLOLNL KXEXQJDQ WHUKDGDS SHQHQWXDQ SHWDQL XQWXN PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD 0RGHO \DQJ VXGDK WHUVHOHNVL WHUVHEXW WHUVHEXW VXGDK WHUEHEDV GDUL VLIDW PXOWLNROLQLHULWDV+DOWHUVHEXWGDSDWGLOLKDW SDGDQLODL9,)6HODLQLWXWLGDNWHUGDSDW NRUHODVL NXDW DQWDU SHXEDK EHEDV +DO WHUVHEXW GDSDW GLOLKDW GDUL QLODLSHDUVRQ FRUUHODWLRQNXUDQJGDUL7DEHO
% H U G D V D U N D Q D Q D O L V L V U H J U H V L VWHSZLVH YDULDEHO \DQJ GLJXQDNDQ DGDODK ; ; ; ; GDQ ; 'DUL DQDOLVLV WHUVHEXW GLKDVLONDQ PRGHO SHUVDPDDQ VHEDJDLEHULNXW
< ;;²; ;²; 6HODQMXWQ\DPHQJDFXSDGDDQDO\VLV RI YDULDQFH $129$ VHPXD YDULDEHO EHEDV \ D Q J G L J X Q D N D Q V H F D U D V H U H P S D N EHUSHQJDUXK Q\DWD WHUKDGDS SHULODNX SHWDQLGDODPPHQDQDPWDQDPDQVHOD+DO WHUVHEXW GDSDW GLOLKDW GDUL QLODL 39DOXH 1 L O D L W H U V H E X W O H E L K N H F L O /DQJNDK 6WHS .RQVWDQWD ; 79DOXH 39DOXH ; 79DOXH 39DOXH ; 79DOXH 39DOXH ; 79DOXH 39DOXH ; 79DOXH 39DOXH )9DOXH 3U!) 5ð DGM
7DEHO+DVLOVHOHNVLYDULDEHO\DQJPHPLOLNLKXEXQJDQNXDWXQWXNPHQDQDPWDQDPDQVHOD 7DEOH7KHVHOHFWLRQUHVXOWRIYDULDEOHWKDWKDGDVWURQJOLQNWRSODQWLQWHUFURSV6XPEHU 6RXUFH ') 66 06 ) 3 5HJUHVVLRQ 5HVLGXDO(UURU 7RWDO
7DEHO+DVLO$QDO\VLVRI9DULDQFH$129$ 7DEOH5HVXOWRIDQDO\VLVRIYDULDQFH
6XPEHU'DWDSULPHUGLRODK 6RXUFH$QDO\VLVRISULPDU\GDWD
GLEDQGLQJNDQGHQJDQQLODLNHVDODKDQ WDUDIQ\DWDGDQEHUGDVDUNDQXML)QLODL ) KLWXQJ GDQ ) WDEHO \DQJ EHUDUWL QLODL ) KLWXQJ ! ) WDEHO +DVLO DQDO\VLV RI YDULDQFH $129$ GDSDW GLOLKDW SDGD7DEHO
3HQJDUXK YDULDEHO EHEDV VHFDUD LQGLYLGX WHUKDGDS YDULDEHO WLGDN EHEDV GDSDWGLOLKDWGDULXMLW-LNDQLODLWKLWXQJ!W WDEHO DWDX QLODL 3YDOXH Â PDND YDULDEHOEHEDVWHUVHEXWEHUSHQJDUXKQ\DWD WHUKDGDSYDULDEHOWLGDNEHEDV%HUGDVDUNDQ KDVLO UHJUHVL VWHSZLVH GLSHUROHK QLODL 5 6TXDUH5ò\DQJDUWLQ\DOLPDYDULDEHO EHEDV WHUVHEXW PDPSX PHQMHODVNDQ SHULODNX SHWDQL XQWXN PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD VHEHVDU VHGDQJNDQ GLMHODVNDQ ROHK YDULDEHO ODLQ \DQJ WLGDN
GLWHUDQJNDQ GDODP PRGHO 8QWXN PHOLKDW VLJQLILNDQVL YDULDEHO EHEDV WHUKDGDS SHULODNX SHWDQL PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD GDSDW GLOLKDW GDUL QLODL3YDOXH OHELK NHFLO GDULÂ1LODL3YDOXHGDSDWGLOLKDWSDGD 7DEHO
%HUGDVDUNDQ 7DEHO NHOLPD YDULDEHO EHEDV EHUSHQJDUXK VLJQLILNDQ WHUKDGDS SHULODNX SHWDQL GDODP PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD SDGD WDUDI Q\DWD × )DNWRU²IDNWRUGRPLQDQ\DQJPHPSHQJDUXKL SHWDQL GDODP PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD DGDODK 3HQGDSDWDQWDQDPDQVHOD; 3HQGDSDWDQ GDUL WDQDPDQ VHOD EHUSHQJDUXK Q\DWD WHUKDGDS SHWDQL XQWXN 9DULDEHOEHEDV ,QGHSHQGHQW YDULDEOH 9DULDEHOEHEDV ,QGHSHQGHQWYDULDEOH 9,) ; ; ; ; ; 3& 39DOXH ; 3& 39DOXH ; 3& 39DOXH ; 3& 39DOXH
7DEHO.ROHUDVLDQWDUSHXEDK 7DEOH&ROHUDWLRQVEHWZHHQYDULDEOHV.HWHUDQJDQ5HPDUNV3&3HDUVRQ&RUUHODWLRQ
PHQDQDPWDQDPDQVHOD+DOWHUVHEXWGDSDW GLOLKDW SDGD QLODL 39DOXH OHELK NHFLO GDULWDUDIQ\DWD
×
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² \ D Q J PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD VHWLDS ELD\D \DQJ GLNHOXDUNDQ VHEHVDU ,'5 PDND DNDQ PHQGDSDWNDQ SHQGDSDWDQ NRWRU VHEHVDU ,'5²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
3 H Q J D O D P D Q E H U N H E X Q N D U H W PHUXSDNDQIDNWRUSHQHQWXXQWXNPHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD +DO WHUVHEXW GDSDW GLOLKDW SDGDQLODL39DOXHOHELKNHFLOGDULWDUDI Q\DWD
×
9DULDEHO LQL EHUSHQJDUXK SRVLWLI WHUKDGDS SHULODNX SHWDQL GDODP PHQDQDPWDQDPDQVHOD+DOWHUVHEXWGDSDW GLOLKDWSDGDNRHILVLHQEHUQLODLSRVLWLI $UWLQ\D VHPDNLQ ODPD SHQJDODPDQ SHWDQL GDODPEHUNHEXQPDNDDNDQPHPSHQJDUXKL SHWDQLXQWXNPHQDQDPWDQDPDQVHOD+DO LQLEHUEDQGLQJOXUXVGHQJDQKDVLOSHQHOLWLDQ VHEHOXPQ\D \DQJ GLODNXNDQ ROHK +HUDWK3UHGLNVL
3UHGLFWRU
.RHILVLHQ
&RHIILFLHQW
7
3
.RQVWDQWD
;
;
;
;
;
56TDGM 67DEHO+DVLOUHJUHVLVWHSZLVHXVDKDWDQLNDUHWUDN\DWGL6XPDWHUD6HODWDQ
7DEOH5HVXOWRIVWHSZLVHUHJUHVVLRQRIIDUPLQJV\VWHPVPDOOKROGHULQ6RXWK6XPDWHUD
6XPEHU'DWDSULPHUGLRODK 6RXUFH$QDO\VLVRISULPDU\GDWD
GDQ7DNH\D\DQJPHQ\DWDNDQEDKZD
GHQJDQ ODPDQ\D SHQJDODPDQ EHUNHEXQ NDUHW PDND DNDQ PHQLQJNDWNDQ PRWLYDVL SHWDQLXQWXNPHPEXDWLQRYDVLEDUXXQWXN PHQLQJNDWNDQNHVHMDKWHUDDQSHWDQL
%HUGDVDUNDQ SHQHOLWLDQ UDWDUDWD SHWDQLPHPLOLNLSHQJDODPDQEHUNHEXQNDUHW
WDKXQ
8
WDKXQGDQ8
WDKXQ 'HQJDQ SHQJDODPDQ VHODPD LWX SHWDQL VXGDK PHQMDODQL PDVD GLPDQD KDUJD NDUHW PDVLK UHQGDK VDPSDL KDUJD NDUHW PHQLQJNDW 2OHK NDUHQD LWX SHWDQL NDUHWPDVLKPHPSHUWDKDQNDQWUDGLVLXQWXN P H Q D Q D P W D Q D P D Q V H O D 6 H O D L Q PHPSHQJDUXKL SHULODNX XQWXN PHQDQDP WDQDPDQVHODSHQJDODPDQODPDEHUNHEXQ M X J D P H P S H Q J D U X K L S H W D Q L G D O D P S H Q J D P E L O D Q N H S X W X V D Q X Q W X N PHPEDQJXQ NHEXQ NDUHW 1XUIDWL\DK 'HQPDU 3UDVDNWL 3HQGLGLNDQSHWDQL; G 3HQGLGLNDQ IRUPDO PHUXSDNDQ IDNWRU SHQHQWX GDODP PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD+DOWHUVHEXWGDSDWGLOLKDWSDGDQLODL3 YDOXHOHELKUHQGDKGDULWDUDIQ\DWD
×
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
7DEHO.RQWULEXVLSHQHULPDDQSHWDQL 7DEOH5HYHQXHFRQWULEXWLRQIDUPHUV 1R -HQLV WDQDPDQVHOD .LQGRI LQWHUFURSSLQJ +DUJD 3ULFH ,'5 3HQHULPDDQ 5HYHQXH ,'5 %LD\DSURGXNVL &RVWRI SURGXFWLQ ,'5 3HQGDSDWDQ ,QFRPH ,'5 5&5DVLR 5&5DWLR &DEDL ± ² ² ² 3DUH ² ² ² ² 3DGL 1HQDV .DFDQJ3DQMDQJ ² ² ² ² ² 7DEHO3HQGDSDWDQSHWDQLGDULPHQDQDPWDQDPDQVHODSHUô+DSHUWDKXQ 7DEOH)DUPHUVLQFRPHIURPLQWHUFURSSLQJô+D\HDU 6XPEHU'DWD3ULPHU 6RXUFH3ULPDU\GDWD )DNWRUIDNWRU3HQHQWX\DQJ0HPSHQJDUXKL3HWDQL0HQDQDP7DQDPDQ6HODGL$QWDUD.DUHWGL6XPDWHUD6HODWDQ
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
7XMXDQPHQDQDPWDQDPDQVHOD; %HUGDVDUNDQKDVLOUHJUHVLEHUJDQGD YDULDEHO LQL PHUXSDNDQ IDNWRU SHQHQWX XQWXNPHQDQDPWDQDPDQVHOD+DOWHUVHEXW GDSDWGLOLKDWSDGDQLODL3YDOXHOHELK UHQGDK GDUL WDUDI Q\DWD
×
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
9DULDEHO ; PHUXSDNDQ YDULDEHO GXPP\ GLPDQD QLODL QRQSHWDQL NDUHW GDQ SHWDQL NDUHW 3HNHUMDDQ SRNRN PHUXSDNDQ YDULDEHO \DQJ EHUSHQJDUXK Q\DWDSDGDSHULODNXSHWDQLXQWXNPHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD +DO WHUVHEXW GDSDW GLOLKDW SDGDQLODL3YDOXHQLODLWHUVHEXWOHELK NHFLO GDUL WDUDI Q\DWD
×
9DULDEHO LQL EHUSHQJDUXK QHJDWLI WHUKDGDS SHULODNX SHWDQL XQWXN PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD KDO WHUVHEXW GDSDW GLOLKDW GDUL QLODL NRHIHVLHQ EHUWDQGDQHJDWLI 1LODLNRHILVLHQDUWLQ\DEDKZD MLND SHWDQL PHQMDGLNDQ EHUNHEXQ NDUHW PHUXSDNDQ SHNHUMDDQ VDPSLQJDQ PDND SHWDQL WLGDN PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD QDPXQ MLND SHWDQL PHQMDGLNDQ EHUNHEXQ NDUHWVHEDJDLSHNHUMDDQSRNRNPDNDSHWDQL WHUVHEXW DNDQ PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD %HUGDVDUNDQ NRQGLVL ODSDQJ EDKZD EHUNHEXQ NDUHW VHEDJDL SHNHUMDDQ XWDPD EHUMXPODK VHGDQJNDQ SHWDQL PHQMDGLNDQ EHUNHEXQ NDUHW VHEDJDL SHNHUMDDQVDPSLQJDQ:DODXSXQEHUNHEXQ NDUHWVHEDJDLSHNHUMDDQVDPSLQJDQQDPXQ SHWDQLPDVLKWHWDSPHQDQDPWDQDPDQVHOD .(6,038/$1 G ) D N W R U ² I D N W R U S H Q H Q W X \ D Q J PHPSHQJDUXKL SHWDQL XQWXN PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD DGDODK SHQGDSDWDQ GDUL WDQDPDQVHODSHQJDODPDQEHUNHEXQNDUHW SHQGLGLNDQ SHWDQL NDUHW WXMXDQ PHQDQDP WDQDPDQVHODXQWXNGLMXDOGDQSHNHUMDDQ SRNRN SHWDQL NDUHW 9DULDEHO \DQJ EHUSHQJDUXK SRVLWLI WHUKDGDS SHULODNX SHWDQL XQWXN PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD D G D O D K S H Q G D S D W D Q W D Q D P D Q V H O D SHQJDODPDQ EHUNHEXQ NDUHW GDQ WXMXDQ PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD 6HGDQJNDQ \DQJ EHUSHQJDUXK QHJDWLI DGDODK SHQGLGLNDQ SHWDQLGDQSHNHUMDDQSRNRNSHWDQL%HUGDVDUNDQ SHQHOLWLDQ \DQJ WHODK
G L O D N X N D Q S H W D Q L G L K D U D S N D Q PHPDQIDDWNDQ NHEXQ NDUHW \DQJ XVLD NDUHWQ\D PDVLK 7%0 WDKXQ GHQJDQ PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ VHOD 3HQJHPEDQJDQ WDQDPDQ VHOD GDSDW GLODNXNDQ GHQJDQ PHQDQDPWDQDPDQVHOD\DQJPHPLOLNLQLODL MXDO .DUHQD GHQJDQ PHQDQDP WDQDPDQ \DQJPHPLOLNLQLODLMXDOWLQJJL3HWDQLNDUHW GDSDW WHUPRWLYDVL XQWXN PHUDZDW NHEXQ G H Q J D Q E D L N V H U W D P H Q L Q J N D W N D Q SHQGDSDWDQUXPDKWDQJJDQ\D
3867$.$
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
3HQHOLWLDQ.DUHW
5RV\LG0-7DQDPDQVHODNRSLGL SHUNHEXQDQ NDUHW :DUWD 3XVDW
3HQHOLWLDQ.DUHW 6XQDUZLGL3HQJXDVDKDDQWDQDPDQ VHOD SDGD JDZDQJDQ WDQDPDQ NDUHW 3URVLGLQJ3HUWHPXDQ.DUHW3DQJNDODQ %HUDQGDQ ,QGRQHVLD %33 6XQJHL 3XWLK )DNWRUIDNWRU3HQHQWX\DQJ0HPSHQJDUXKL3HWDQL0HQDQDP7DQDPDQ6HODGL$QWDUD.DUHWGL6XPDWHUD6HODWDQ
6XULDQV\DK+DVLOSHQJNDMLDQVLVWHP XVDKD SHUWDQLDQ EHUEDVLV NDUHW EHUZDZDVDQ DJULELVQLV GL .DEXSDWHQ %DULWR 8WDUD .DOLPDQWDQ 7HQJDK 3URVLGLQJ /RNDNDU\D 1DVLRQDO +DVLO 3HQHOLWLDQ GDQ 3HQJNDMLDQ 7HNQRORJL 3HUWDQLDQSS 3DODQJNDUD\D ,QGRQHVLD%DODL3HQJNDMLDQ7HNQRORJL 3HUWDQLDQ3DODQJNDUD\D
