• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

ARACMP),

Dalam dokumen A Structural Analysis of Three (Halaman 56-65)

48

Initial least-squares refinement of the ARACMP trial model made use of a data set collected with molybdenum radiation. Isotropic refinement of all non-hydrogen atoms converged at an R index of 0.13 using all data collected out to sin2 e/A 2 = 0.35. A difference map calculated at this

juncture revealed the positions of all hydrogen atoms except for that one participating in the 0(10) ••• 0(10) hydrogen bond. Two half-hydrogen atoms were used to represent the hydrogen bonding scheme here, and anisotropic refinement commenced. Two cycles in which the coordinates and six- parameter temperature factors for each heavy atom were varied along with a scale factor reduced the R index to

0.097. No hydrogen atom parameters were refined. During this stage of refinement it became increasingly clear that the quality of the weaker and high-angle data was sufficiently poor to warrant recollecting the data set using copper

radiation. Experimental details for the collecting of this

second set of data have been given (see EXPERIMENTAL-

49

refined with the heavy atom temperature factors and a scale factor; a second matrix contained the coordinates for the heavy atoms. Difference maps calculated after each cycle of refinement failed to indicated anything but a disordered hydrogen-bonding scheme along the screw axis relating 0(10) to 0(10), and so this model was retained through subsequent refinements.

Once again enantiomorph determination was attempted.

Form factors for N and O were corrected as described

previously (49), as was the form factor for P (51), Structure factor calculations for both enantiomorphic sets of parameters were performed, and the results are shown in Table 14, The differences in statistical sums favor heavily the D- structure over the L-, As one might expect, the strength of this

indication is greater than that for the ARAU determination (Table 10), but not nearly as strong as for ARAC,HCl(Table 6), Although .of" for Pin CuKoc. radiation is nearly that of Cl-, the fact that the "neuter parameters" were used in the ARACMP determination and refined D- and L- parameters were used in the ARAC,HCl comparison would likely make the latter a more powerful test. And although the methods of enantiomorph determination for both the ARAU and ARACMP cases were

identical, the much larger Af" of P with respect to the A f"s

of N and o would make the ARACMP test more positive than the

ARAU test. The entire preceding discussion assumes of course

that in all cases the measured intensities are of equal

50

Table 14. ARACMP. 1tl2.Q Enantiomorph Determination

(L) (D)

R 0.062 0.057

Rw 0.01203 0.00993

GOF 2.47 2.25

(for M = 1859 data and s = 289 parameters) .

51

significance statistically. By Hamilton's R-ratio test(52), all three enantiomorph determinations are significant at the Ol = 0.005 level.

Continued refinement converged after 5 cycles with an R index of 0.046, a weighted R of 0.00665, and a goodness- of-fit of 1.69. All shifts were less than o.6~, save three . These three were for coordinate values associated with

0(2'), H0(8) and 0(8), which were oscillating about their means by approximately±~. Hydrogen atoms associated with 0(10) were dealt with in the following waya H(lO) was placed as accurately as possible from previous difference maps;

two half-hydrogens, H(10a) and H(10b), were placed 1/3 the distance along vectors from 0(10) to 0(10) atoms at

(½-x, 1-y, ½+z) and (½-x, 1-y, z-½). None of these hydrogen atoms were refined in the last several cycles. Final

parameters are listed in Tables 15 and 16. Observed and

calculated structure factors are in Table 17.

Table 15. Itmu ARACMP. 3H 2 0 Non-Hydrogen Atom Parameters and their Est mated Standard Deviations. The ~ and ¥.. coordinates have been multiplied by 105; all other parameters have been multiplied by 10 4 . The form of the a.ni.sotropic temperature factor is T = exp[-2/ (la* 2 Uu + ... +k.£b*c*U 23 )]. The final value of ~he extinction parameter g is (o.6~o.4)x 10- 6 e- 2 . X l. z Un - - U22 Uss U1.2 U1.3 U2s N(l) 3215(l6) 34607(16) 7937(6) 269(14) 270(14) 323 (18) 58 (14) -33 (13) ~48(15) C(2) 10348(21) 31695 (20) 7396 (9) 304(19) 311(19) 389(23) 54(18) -32(20) -26(19) 0(2) 16136(14) 33744(17) 8491(7) 311(14) 574(19) 704(24) 71(14) -148(16) -262(21) N(3) 10357(17) 26174(17) 54o4(7) 241(16) 351(19) 4o8 (23) 66(14) 12(16) -41(16) ~ C (4) 4l33(20) 23550(17) 4093 (8) . 319(17) 213(17) 309(21) 21(15) 30(19) 20(17) N(4) 4885(17) 18621(17) 2137(8) 299(17) 361(19) 481(23) 32(15) 13(19) -111(18) C(5) -3005 (20) 26549(20) 4832(10) 252 (19) 327(20) 486(27) 1(15) -19(19) -76(21) C (6) -3145 (20) 31970(19) 6711(9) 279(19) 292(19) 466(28) 41(16) 30(19) -50(20) p -24472( 5) 34556 ( 5) 8810(2) 202 ( 5) 270( 5) 186( 5) -6( 4) 12( 4) -16( 5) 0(5') -18626(14) 41016(14) 8144(5) 333(14) 343 (14) 280(15) -17(12) 30(11) -51 (12) 0(6) -24964(15) 30119(13) 6209(6) 402 (16) 366(14) 290(13) -61(13) 10(16) -40(13) 0(7) -31694(14) 37620(15) 9887(6) 280(14) 501(17) 426(17) -2 (12) -1(13) -120(16)

Table 15 (continued) 0(8) -20247(15) 29873(14) 11055(6) 393(17) 454(17) 321(16) 34 (13) 67(16) 61(16) C(l') 2848(20) 41043(19) 9821(8) 297(19) 309(19) 254(20) 35(15) -47(16) -16(18) O(l') -4260(14) 41129(12) 11156(6) 371(12) 282 (12) 277 (13) 43(11) 26(14) 39(13) C(2') 3560(21) 48357(19) 8247(8) 311(19) 305 (19) 281(23) -15(16) -54(17) -2 (17) 0(2 I) 7674(15) 47845 (15) 5736(6) 343(16) 457(17) 367(18) -10(13) 64 (14) 20(16) c (3') -4784(21) 50304(19) 7763 (8) 336(20) 277(19) 233(20) -17(16) -37(18) 28(16) 0(3 I) -5522 (14) 57879(14) 7327(7) 375(16) 305(14) 579(20) -12 (13) -100(16) 151(15) ~ c (4') -8460(21) 47706(19) 10418(7) 350(20) 240(19) 237(22) 41(15) 18(17) -29(17) C(5') -16831(21) 46096(20) 10365(8) 353(20) 324(22) 327(25) 20(17) 49(18) -64(19) 0(9) 31673(16) 34259(16) 4029(7) 525 (19) 424(19) 631(22) -2 (17) 48(20) -17(22) 0(10) 23258 (18) 46555 (18) 5033(8) 472(19) 616(20) 836(27) 19(16) 76(20) 24(22) 0(11) 39610(16) 37423(15) 9120(7) 464(19) 498(19) 500(24) -54(15) 37(20) -65 (20)

Table 16. Final ARACMP.JH20 Hydrogen Atom Parameters and Their Estimated Standard Deviations. Coordinate values have been multiplied by 103.

Atom ~ Y.. z B!A 2 ~

HN(3) 147(2) 246(2) 490(11) 3.4(1.0) HN(4) 95(3) 168(3) 206(11) 5.4(1.3) H'N(4) 8(2) 165(2) 155 ( 9) 3.3(1.0) HC(5) -74(2) 249(2) 399(10) 2.8(0.9) HC( 6) -74(2) 343(2) 709( 9) 3.9(1.0) HC ( 1' ) 67(2) 405(2) 1110( 9) 2.4(0.8) HC( 2' ) 60(2) 521{2) 9 53 ( 8) 1.5(0.7) HO{ 2' ) 94(4) 499(4) 585(16) 10.7(2,3) HC( 3' ) -72 ( 2) 475{2) 645 ( 8) 0,9(0,7) HO( 3' ) -99(2) 586(3) 683(11) 4,3(1,1) HC(4') -75(2) 512(2) 1165( 8) 2.2(0,9) HC(5') -185(2) 435(2) 1212( 8) 2,5(0.9) H'C(5') -192(2) 505(2) 998(10) 3,9(1.1) H( 8) -225(3) 295(3) 1184(12) 4.4(1.5) H(9) 299(3) 305(3) 383(14) 603(1,5) H' ( 9) 281(4) 376(4) 440(18) 11.1(2.3) H(ll) 367 ( 3) 353(3) 1015(13) 5.2(1.5) H' ( 11) 376 (3) 379 ( 3) 779(14) 6,2(1,7) H{lO) 191{0) 451(0) 523{ 0) 12.0( 0)

H(lOa) 247(0) 488(0) 673( 0) 12.0( 0)

H( 10b) 247(0) 488(0) 339( 0) 12.0( 0)

55

Table 17. Observed and Calculated Structure Factors for

ARACMP.3H20• Each set of four columns contains, from left

to right, the h index, 10fF 0 l, lOfFcl, and 10JF 0 2-Fc2 1/~(F 0 2 ).

no 14l l04fl044 1

660 686 _,.

U4 6'tl

,z

,.,. ,,.6 _,

44 l06 -11 441 91'1

JI 16 116 l l \ 140 t>• Z

l ll•

l l l l 2'16 11' l''H •10 6 116 7 HI '10 t U6 U>

_,.

t l'l U 0 10 '14 11 uo zn -u l l '4 Ill -I . , 40 2' 10

14 , , U

15 Ht u, •11 16 12'1 I l l •I 11' 110 104 10 It 141 ,.., t• lll lll 10 ll'5 110

Z1

,o ,. _,

0 ,,,. . . . t i 1 606 60•

l 00 01 40

) z,, HI 11 4 l l l l l ) •l ' " 6 ,61' •ll 6 151 10 11 l' 46 11 2,

I ,11., ,.o

14

• n

,1

10 74 61 U

ll Z6't 169 0

11 n u -10

t1 •z 10•

l4 ZU lOZ •U

u

11,

,n -u

16 ,,. 1.Z U ll 10 1'1 -10

11 n 66

•• uo i,o 10 Ill 161 lJ 11 , , 40

l ,at HO -)

l 401 401 •M

l lltO ll'Jl 11

4 11 26 '

Sl40 IUt -IT

• '60 ,,4 • 7 J,Z )69 _,.

I Uo\ lH 11

• ,oz,., ...

10 uo 1n z•

11 1111• 1"6 - u U l6f ll'l -•

lJ J6

,z

-14 14 -1, 111 -10 1' ZH ZJJ •II 16 201 . . . 6 11 )Z'l' )26 1 I I ll' tJ -10 , . 11116- 110 14

zo

-Z4 10 -•

Zl - n 11 -U

0 111 116 ' l l'l'l l l l •JO Z l'o\l f ) J 10

J Jl JO 0

lZ 42 -14 '5 US ZU I , , . , , . JT f 14, 1'Z U 64

-1•

-JZ

JOZ U6 14 10 ZZ 4Z •U II 10• 116 •1'

u no u ,, ,o -u

1'6

-u

14 Jll Ut -14

u

'1

,4

-J

16 ZJf 24' -11

,, •z

4

I I '1

•• 1•

n -u

zo

,4 44 lJ

u

-10 26

-u

l JO II

l llT UO •U

J 100 201

-z

4 J'56 Uf 6J ' , . . 48' o\l 6 -11

zz -•

1 z,1 zn -•

I

,n ,..

T

• HO H• U

10 HO zn z

II n n

lZ lH 110

-z

11 16 I

. . 44 , .. lJ

" , . , . 0 16 Uf 124 , 11 •Jl lo\ •11

Ill n '4 l

1• IIJ 10, lT

ZO H fl 1

U ,z 44 l4

o no ♦ 14 -z4 I 6JJ 6H l1

1 61' 606 10

J IOI 100 • HI 106 •20

, ZI t 10

6 H6 JTl ·H f Zl'4 Zll •ZO I Z?Z Zf4 ... 4

n1

zn u

10 tH J•I Z

u ,,,

>T6 -6 12 421) 4H •24

IJ JI lT 1

14 IIT U4 •U

IS IJ U I

16 •• 6Z I

If O n -10

11 UI lH 11

,. u

44

-u

ZO '" SI U

21 H 4, 2J

l UJ

,o.

JI Z Ill llt -1 J 466 4"4 •J4 4 , . , , . , 16 ' lfl' •I UI • ""

-z

1 , . .

nz

1.0

I JZ .z, '

• n -n

10 U4 lH U

ll ZOI ll4 •14 U 11' \Of 14 IJ Ul 1'8 •14 14 - u 1 - u

1' 4J II 16

16 II 41 •lf 1T . , , 141 •I II II 61 J4

t• H I 10

lO '4 Z, I

,Z41 11 lZ U6 111

l l l 18 ll 16 )0

Ill IU zt

m u )4 • •

.Z'I.Z zo 11

" ' -10 111 ll'l I) l 11• ll7

,o -11

161 ll'I -12 a,6 U6 lJO 120 ZZ

1, "

UI Ul 0

l'I fl t )44 U6 •24

I'll l'lf -10 ll

4S 40 \O'J 100

fl 10 6)

2 It UT lU l0

ll lJ _, 12 u 40 u

l• -10

lU -17

l f 'I?

JlO 310

1011' 10111'1 1n zoo . , , 11•

4)7 4 0

•"6

4)7

•n •• ,

,i,

SU

1)1 UT

lJI 20 Ut 11' 6114 610 1111 191 10 'ltl , , '5111

lH lfS

'12 11'5 68 4T IOl'l 100 ]ti 40 IC.S 44 117 11'1 al' '"

11 9' ff U

16 111 10'1 -10 If U '11 14

18 6W ,~

-ll

"

12 0 I

"

10

II 10

"

•I

..

10 n

"

104 191 ))4 Hl 1)2 11'1 llq 121 16

"

l>4 14G 161 -21 l0C'

..

-IS , •• 148

"

·12

"

266 tl'J -tl' 0 •ll ·1"'

,., ,2 >••

-zo

636 P l 17111 1l '51 'JC

::: ::: ·:: ::: ... , ::: m .:: ;;; ,. -•

::: :;; -:~ 1i ''.: .. : "mm_:: ;;; ;;; ...

;; :: .H : ::r ::: .. t! :~~ ;;; :'.: '.: ::: :;; ·:'.

40 Z8 1 ,z "

lll 116

fl 7l 0

I 2

U6 Ill 12 I

•IJ IC.

JC ll ll

l<t \1 16 ll •S l ) 10 107 100 19 , .

11114 10 tT

.. "

"

151 " ' 67 61 •l 18 ZIT 112 -10

211 zo•

lU 140

29' 20

llC lfO

<tt 'Jl -1 -ZT 32 n •II _,

"

69 '1 HI

'

11' ITS ,

U ll 0

,ij ,g ·:: '; :11 :~ ·;; :: ~ 1 :: ::;

0 U II

I U '1

l 114 172 ) -u 7

• ' ' ) l UI lJJ •H

48 4) S

"

Ill t i t

, , )2 ' 40 lJ

I tlZ4 807 , n , . , u 1 • n 610

1n no lt) , •1 16

41) Z1 J?O 276

,. u , zn zu l l l 224 II 110 104

211 6'

1• 1• •20 906

112 164 17 ZJ6 tl6

Ill 111 •I 10 )4 to II •11 11 14 ll JJ0 U• l ll lH lll' 1u nt u -10 16 105 11' •Jf 14 IOI 110

) J 42 l5 204 110

lJ'f 214 11 16 110 lU

52 l IT , . 61

n >• -1 u -20 11

100 I• lU Ill'

61 56 2t H 16

10 '" -n Ill US 29 ZJ JJ •6

1?6

n, z

44J 461 -n

n

61' 111 Jll' -11

•1 .0 l

211 UJ -U

11' MO n

146 14)

"

) )

-•

42

.,. ,1

16 5

u•

11•

u

-lJ lT •12

• JI -u

n 11 z l1 l l 10

0 )14 ) I ) l JU )'6 2 "'• 4'6 l 7Z6 TU

. "

5 611 61T 6 166 UI 7 lll U6 I 72' 204 t .. .,, 401 It' 5'1 11 HI Zt) IZ IU 141 U 1'9 164 14 llO 101 U Zl6 Z44 16 IZJ u , ll' lll Zll 11 lU 106 l'I tlT II

'5) , . 11

zc

'6 ,o

446 . , , l<'I IU Tl 6' 104 201 4 ) IZ

....

•T 21 t ♦ IZ

26 Zt

-, '

\4(1 116

-11 ,

, . 21 l l JI Z6 ' 110 .zu UJ Uf Zl l l

10 14'

_.,

II -ll II

.

.

2

'

-, . '

I

...

-H

'

6l '" 10

6l T4 •I

ZZI Zo\Z •JI

Zl • 6

)4 lT 4

n H 2 210 zu -4

'" n

4 lJ IO •10

1,

I

-n z

-n

fZ 60 lf

• l l Zl •10

•16 \Ill •6

11 IO 1

)OC l l l •Z) 1111 JII 14 UC Zl"

" ' )7 J6 1"t 141

le II -14

• ll -l

to• Ill - l 56 .,, , , . 11 0 Ill' 16• ll'

-z• n

-11 0 1010 IOU I •l'l 911 2 11114 419 J 7'9 Tl') 4 UI I "

' , . , zc,

6 zu 290 T o\l(I 406 I , . , 11101 t 111 , . . 10 Z•2 JOO

WI

Clo\UlJI) 1 no, ..

l Tl4 TU

) 716 TU

" U4 111 5 T)II Tito 6 )06 291 f ))(I )21 I ZT2 261 9 '64 , . , 10 IU UZ 11 201

zoo

U Tl n

I ) z,.z ,,.

14 461 o\79

" ., ,.

U Ill 101

ll :ii :H

U I

l >1 -16

l IZI -,

J 141 -,

' " -1 ' " " 101 -10 11

10• -IJ

I 13

o 629 uz 10 -to -16 I 490 •l<t 11 1"

l J•5 l64 61 lZ ll4 Ito

I) 280 , , . 16 I ll4 Ill

l OZ Z9

) 400 foOO O O II 1' l

149 ll'J 24 1 1'T UJ I 5 61 6T -I 2 Zl<t 207 26

96 •I J Ill 110 ll

1'" l'U 11 116 ll2 I

I )1)6 )011 5 IZ4 tn 2

-)0 U •U 50 U •l

H iH H: -l6 • tH 1!i -;;

~!

MO • 6 :~

I!~

120 ::

0 I 2

. '

1

10 ll 12

..

ll

"

16 16 201

'" ,.

I l l

'"

...

,o

0 U U

I ll ll U

Z 2' Zl 1

J l4 2, 0

q .H

Ill

...

... ...

Ill

..

...

12•

11•

.,

11

101 11

104 lG6 5• 63 ' 21

"

.. "

.,

12

_.,

II

:l

l4 lT

)11 )26 -17 201 116 -zo ll'J I l l U , , . )60 •19 102 lOJ •1 J6T )l'J - u 199 lOO •l 15) )63 • l t

.. "

)64 )80 •Jl

ZJ 14 J

114 ZCl

-J•

IJZ UJ -l

I T4 -19

"' _,

10 fl f'I -2

· " 16 -10

" '

'6 )9 20

u n t

U6 119 1f l l , . 26 ,., n lfO 166 U

C UO lZG 1 ll 20

l ll )4 -1•

, Sl . , lJ

...

)JJ 12

"'

Ul -12

IC•

.. ...

24 10 ISt'

"

24f 2

17) - I f

"

1.8)

"'

IOI He

"

...

"

n t 2u 10 1"6 l lOI 211 Ill 114 -z

'"

..

ZSl!i lH 211 ZZJ Ill 11'1 -t

" "

"

60 t•

.. .

211 zn )•

154 U5

"

108 211 -•

193 II) lJII) 263 40 ZOI ZOl

"

148 ISl' at 21') Zif 281 11) 211 167 I'll 02 11

. ,

.,

2) I l l 112

.,.

ZZ

LOI 1111

...

11• ]01 25 171 -)Z lfl 261 1•

""' •o,

,,.

u u, )1, e -21 lJ -•

13 -a, IJ6 IJ) l50 166 -Jf

12 4)7 UI -19 -11 II 10'1 UI •H

'1 . . _,

IH Ul

20 •12 llJ Ill

)I 21

" 0

414 , . . )1 421 41)

z,.

lltl 111 11 61, IZ 127 11'1 111 ZfO lfC 0 191 l'IIII _, 146 1'2 -I•

-11 14 - l 111' 2ZZ -II

•z 19 Ill 111 -ll

fl fZ •l 1('1 100

" 1l "

1ft Ill

, ..

1'0 l52 56 '1 1'2 l'l

l f l JfJ •2 16 13

..

134 111 Z7

"

lCO 1"

l'i6 UT •Z l l •10 166 165 Z

"

Jl6 111 144 1'2 -16 ll6 Ill •lt ll6 ZtC -I 4Z ,~ -ll ICI 111 -5 n ,e -u

"5 SC -.5 101 -14

19 H l

Zl' 16

U2 20 n

4C4 Jt6 16 u1 ,n n ,en zn l' Z,4 ZS4 0

,u ,u ')

lJ6 us 2' Jtl 4GI -20 IIJ LU •ll )lJ )10

-t•

106 106 0

z•z z4,

241 241 ?

U 4! -u

226 1)4 -11 161 lU ·12 lit ll6 •16 l'1

2,

1• 11

101 ti 21

A4t 'J06 •IS 212 Z'l6 n 5Cl' ,o, -l

'

441 U) •J UT ISZ IZ 20'1 zu HO 241 221 zz, 11> ltJ u• nt 121 11•

Zl6 212

.,

114 U•

11' IC

1l -15

H H -2•

10 110 l i t 11 9'1 . , 11 '!2 41 l) 1J 101 . ,

62 •12

' ' '

10 161 lfO

166 lZ 1"

JU ll z,

:~r\:;,~ .

I) I l

' ' "

6 7 ti 101 lU

''"

Utl 147 . . ••

"

,

'"

HZ 129 uo us 6J •U •IT •IZ .z z 10 11 12 O 1 Z J 5 l'4 UI uz UO an u, u, 20 62 2Z )T ' UC 151 116 IZJ an l4

,c

ZJ Z6 -•11 -z •Z 12 U 11 u

, •• 16'0 -u

114 20 15

151' ,~2 -u 0

IJO n i,:, s,..

,.,

15'1 2"4 0 ll 26 2H tll l

l6l J

l 5

,1

Jt ll

"

IH 148 Ill lZ)

tlto •10

ll l

"' " .,

"

, ..

51' t,) 15 )16 Jll 10

•11 2'-1

2 ,2 6' -15 Jl'I ) ) I -lll t•O 2J6

"

' I l l ' l ll"i 164

4J )II lZ 156 U'I

ll l\6 ll• -, -1 I•

II

-'7 10 -II 16 ))

11' Z6

Ill l2 H'I 272

lll ll"

274 II

165 166 Ito')

...

-2

"' _,,

2)1 1.)Q

'" .,

"

10• l')T lit )0

11112 218

•JI 158 ' "

Zlil ll

lll 2'>6 ·12

)I · I -1 I 163 112' -1,)

111 1 a,o -J:>

Ill IOI> 15 IU lllll

'1 ,s _, 111 17'1

4l 116 121

1 TO 16~

216 l2'•

'" -l ll

160 us 110 tU 11 11, 142 - 1 )

H 12 l U -10

II 1C' 151' 156

40 14 If

I IS 162 15:1

l5 11' IS

lt'O H If

,,

0

•ZI 10 10

?I l Ill l it

0 l

•S l 121 ll6

I'>' 246 )OS

ll4 JU tf• U6

J

10 11 l

11'4 Ill JO l>l

.. ,

l)~

...

10, 100 •c -11

Ill I 4t'Z J•l' lCi et

•l 11" 116 II 11'4 l7l

IZ9 15 ) 141 140 Z 12 'IJ

100 104 -11 241 241 0 1l

,c

11 -10

IP I l l -10 1, 10, 100 16

,o,

101

Ill 120 )O If 92 ll l5

2'-ll •10 lOl ICf -11

,,o

n 10 11 51 ' ) •16

154 IS6 12 11)4 t<'• 0 0 41

IU ll'O •I 161 •l• I 14111 i , , -21

llJ l)O •1'5 UO •ll l S

,zz ,2) •l IS 2f )II tll 24to -2'1

164 161 •2 - n II\ ·IZ lOl •21

111 106 12 IT U 111 -I

II 102 2,6 20) -lS

J 10 Ill 101 21'0 l f l

41 I JH JU 0

101 ti"> -1 zo• zo, o

II IC 141 UJ

0 •21 S'I 61

1 1 114 Zlt •U 12 Zl )2 -J

H 21 II JI] lll 1J 1'4 lS4

JSt 1''1 •l'I t• 102 91 10 IU l'-l ·20 IS 109 104 II

, l?l >6• 'I) 104 -16

)48 10 t•O 1o;11 •l 2'6 265 -10 Ill It• -l6 tltl Ul' l I llJ 116

161 l64 -JI O 14) l"6

10 216 l ZS, l6l -U

T5 -a, ll 211 UO za, ZU •IT

11' lll 12 ) 14S l4l

lillt HZ O U l i t lfl Zl IJI 135

IU 1"4 14 110 101 1 S ll4 Ill I

IZO 117 , 15 1'6 161 •U 11 fl 1l

1211 n , •14 16 J5 39 •) 12, Ill -15

8'1 l ll 115 ue ll 0

- l f _., u -u .,

1l1 -z 1'1 11 IC' I l l 116

s• •16 11 t i 15 -]

II 12 IJ2 120 Z7

121 Ill 21 I) fO '5

106 100 II O 14 - I f

I 1115 ti lS 107 -z

lll 221 0 If> -16 -10 llJ 12C -15

no JIIO -1, u1 u1

u , 120 5 214 21" •U

tolO 42) •14 16' 11) •JO O 2ftl 218 -21

IH \fl 10 10 1 2ft ll'f

lit 2'11 •11 l IZ) Uf

lff 11114 •1' 111 174 -ll ) 116 106 17

10 llllf as 86 -I

!,J 11 56 "'" 20) -11

14<\ 14' -2 IZ l l t t•t •14 141 IJ9

102 ll -20 1Z 1' U

llf 10 •11 14 l0 1'6 '11

• l l l<t •U 1S 12J Ill'! 14 <tZ -12

120 lU 16 114 115 -z ll'JI 109 -1

)) H O 17 1)0 Ill 11 IOS •J Zl

tlO IU ltl II H 12 167

f ) I) "

111 102 Zf Ill Ill 21

l5 101 1J

0 H fl I

I 1, i , C:

111 171 -1 l HJ 2'1

150 U'I •IQ l JU )61 IC: lU 11) -ll

51 4'8 Of> ) I 111' UA •l

•1 S 11.4 121 l 2• 16

IN IM •It 11, 114 1 l l ) f Z40

ts> 1'2 1 41 ZO

10, 1?1 ' I 114 114 19T 147

If '13 Ill 62 166 167 -l

IJ'I 1'-6 -14 10 l-'1 ll6 II U t ) •14

146 10 11 .,,. u•

10, •ll', 12 IC tf, 11'6 -l

91 .> l) 'JO 1(1 '6 \7 •I

16 ZZ 10 14 11-' Ill' 11 1,1 1'l

61 lS 11 12 ,a

11 U 16 IJ) IH 1J l('I U

•2 11 tl' &C ,r 14 14 'I) tit

1' ll t• 10 U 51 l9 20

100 Ml •II

6l u -z ., . , z• u 101 11,

l'fl )15 •ll' l l)C' Ill -1 1110 lit -10

12" t n I l ,so no 1 U6 uo 146 " " -11 J 13'1 14" -1) ) 7', - u

106 tO• lCJ 2(4 -l llf l'Jt -16

'II IJ tf-2 251 1" 61 •ll

105 \('I 1-'l 1'( •15 " 67 - l l

Ill 24111 t l f lto ll l4

4) 92 )21 12('

n 1l 119 1111' 61 6' l

61 10 ZZO 211' -1, lC· 10 )C

104 'I\ t• II 161 16• -IZ l1 ") ll

SI J.11 •lO IZ 2CJ 206 1Z SO 42 10

ZI I) 11 )I ,, l 11 '6 , .

114 Ill 1'1 , ••

11'11 •t 221 114

"

14'1 14) tn u1 2115 7.51 41) I~

46 •o

I-' lC''I 1011 I 14 lJI IZ'-

1, J6 )4 I

16 as •I

If 4) lf . , 15

-21 16 -11 ,u ]tit) , 1''1 lU •14

zs, z••

•t 10~ -14

14"

..

141 Z . , Tl' ZO)

....

Zll

.,

•U

_,

12111 Ill IS

"

52 )4 II

)ti ' "

112 lU l>

11, )2

"

. "

10 n ll •118 1l 174 ll 7l 14 19 1S IZ

'I) 146 . . ,

-z

67 fC 21-lZO 10 61 6l 11'0 9 11 52

60 l1 U )'5 -20

TS ll

9C' •J

I 12 l7

-11 •ll l t u ll

~=

5~

~~

l

~~!

2~: O : ::: : : : l<t

6l -ll

'1 -11

"'

-6, z4

-10 123 Ill'

'

111 1Cl 141' 142'

' "

) 161 11'1

'

·I

llG 107 '11

lOI Zll -ll 51

102 1')6 10 IO<t 106

"

ll

II

.

S 161 IU 115 I'll '10 IS 11 l4 22 l

"'

Ill ll5 0 UO ti~ 10

)I ll 116 ll'I I l4 10

lOl lOO

10 •)O l l -11 l

11 t,\ 41 lZ'-

1'11 191 6) SI 5 11' llf

100 I? IJ 15' 1"1

)14 23

)II 12._

2ft -u 140 141

IN O 16 10 16 11 111

701 11-' I 142 141 I ll II 22

67 -> l tC

Zll lll ')

UI 140 l l 121 lll -U

IJ ll l O 4C

lO l?I 'II U l 11

\4'1 l4S 1' )ti -l l 11 ))

H 1l tit ) lO

ll 'U

t') lll 104 JO 112 10t

IU 1('1 10 104 11' 45 4)

ti IZ l0 6l

ll •ZG IJ -11

...

2

... "

245 l•l

"

1(4 tJ 11

211 i:, 40 2S 10

lll 290 51

••C 2l ll 0

2U -a, 61 )1 JI I 162 165

-2 U 83 •) l 121 UC 1'

IH ll'l 11' 11!

U'I -15 ll ZS I

2Jl -U I 5 61 U

4) "' -1' l4 lS C'

144 U 1, Tl

61 •14 10 •ll 12 I 6J

ll 11 -IZ

-26 21 12 4( )'I 1 10 )I

1' )0 •10

0 ll -l

l 91 2" 260 -ll 14" 146

62 69 6f 2

2'1 Z,S C

41 ' U SI

t•O 246 -ll S

141 10 62 -16

n ,,

IOI 104 9' l

41 l'l 20

lllJ l II 24

154 " " -2

\OQ 1('4 e

f5 f6 -I

100 104 0 ,c

-1' I 1'5 If

M 61 •Z

I) •2 ) l'i S'I

5 U l'S ll

61 l l

69 II

1~ I Ill O 54 42 11

Jsn h i ) l('I 102 14

91 ? ai, SI 11

1,0 -12

14'1 21

)l',4 )6~

l l l l l f -lO 2ll 129 161 165

2"4 10 8'1 . ,

100 l'l

"

' " 4) 14" 11 '"

112 1oz

"

14 lC

"

lJI 21

-zz U -10 ,. •s 63

.,

21 -10

.

•• 2

29 21 l

141 131 1"1 140 15

4' )4

5)

,o

l

II) Jt

u

..

·2 ))

..

14 ll C

6l 2'1 101 lC6 Z

l'

-ll 11 24

"'

. . UC ,,, -11 I )

-n 11

"

H -ll

"

-za IC -I•

21 l 11' 14 10

., '

-If 19 -lt'l

1

•z

•e

) 61 , ,

...

20T Zll Ill 131 •2\. 6 IU llf J

l'1 l'l

11'1R 20'1 •l 1)6 l•'l

"

"'

2J(I 2)) l"I l'll

..

-ll IZ'- l l l '

1111 TS 111 ll•

tfl) >I

J'I ll Zl

l'I' C

1611 tl'I , , . 174 20C 201

" 2

U -I

1'1 1'7 1.H Zlfl I)

"

611 11 _, l

"

10 l'1

"

..

·IZ

101 1l

109 lC12

rue I 71 2 , . l f

11

"

11" 11

H U

2,

-10

"

ll

C 21 10 12

I 11' Ill I f

2 h 6l

, 121 114 •o

t, ,c, 101 12

I -tfl l •to\

0 I " l'- zr.

14 1 9l 111

1J 17 lt:I

,.

IOI ,,, .. 11'6

_,

Zll 19 ll6 IGI

..

-24 11

•H 26 -U

57

Dalam dokumen A Structural Analysis of Three (Halaman 56-65)

Dokumen terkait