2 me age
Jo rnal of Applied Research in Higher Ed cation <onbehalfof@man c ip cen al.com> Wed, J l 6, 2022 a 6:42 PM Repl -To: pa ickble inge @gmail.com
To: mi ka .mmi@ in-ala ddin.ac.id 06-J l-2022
Dea D . Malik Ib ahim:
Man c ip ID JARHE-02-2022-0041.R1 en i led "Lec e Pe cep ion on A hen ic A e men in Time of COVID- 19 Pandemic" hich o bmi ed o he Jo nal of Applied Re ea ch in Highe Ed ca ion, ha been e ie ed. The commen of he e ie e ( ) a e incl ded a he bo om of hi le e .
The e ie e ( ) ha e ecommended majo e i ion o he bmi ed man c ip , befo e i can be con ide ed fo p blica ion. The efo e, I in i e o o e pond o he e ie e ( )' commen and e i e o man c ip . E en al accep ance i con ingen pon add e ing all e ie e ' conce n and he edi o -in-chief' final app o al. The edi o -in- chief e e e he igh o no accep a pape if he a ho doe no add e all e ie e ' and enio edi o ' conce n . To e i e o man c ip , log in o h p ://mc.man c ip cen al.com/ja he and en e o A ho Cen e, he e o ill find o man c ip i le li ed nde "Man c ip i h Deci ion ." Unde "Ac ion ," click on "C ea e a Re i ion." Yo man c ip n mbe ha been appended o deno e a e i ion.
Yo ill be nable o make o e i ion on he o iginall bmi ed e ion of he man c ip . In ead, e i e o man c ip ing a o d p oce ing p og am and a e i on o comp e . Plea e al o highligh he change o o man c ip i hin he doc men b ing he ack change mode in MS Wo d o b ing bold o colo ed e .Once he
e i ed man c ip i p epa ed, o can pload i and bmi i h o gh o A ho Cen e.
When bmi ing o e i ed man c ip , o ill be able o e pond o he commen made b he e ie e ( ) in he pace p o ided. Yo can e hi pace o doc men an change o make o he o iginal man c ip . In o de o e pedi e he p oce ing of he e i ed man c ip , plea e be a pecific a po ible in o e pon e o he e ie e ( ).
IMPORTANT: Yo o iginal file a e a ailable o o hen o pload o e i ed man c ip . Plea e dele e an ed ndan file befo e comple ing he bmi ion.
Beca e e a e ing o facili a e imel p blica ion of man c ip bmi ed o he Jo nal of Applied Re ea ch in Highe Ed ca ion, o e i ed man c ip ho ld be ploaded a oon a po ible. If i i no po ible fo o o bmi
o e i ion in a ea onable amo n of ime, e ma ha e o con ide o pape a a ne bmi ion.
Plea e no e ha Eme ald e i e o o clea pe mi ion o e- e an ma e ial no c ea ed b o . If he e a e pe mi ion o anding, plea e end he e o Eme ald a oon a po ible. Eme ald i nable o p bli h o pape
i h pe mi ion o anding.
Once again, hank o fo bmi ing o man c ip o he Jo nal of Applied Re ea ch in Highe Ed ca ion and I look fo a d o ecei ing o e i ion.
Since el ,
D . Pa ick Ble inge
Senio Edi o , Jo nal of Applied Re ea ch in Highe Ed ca ion pa ickble inge @gmail.com, ble inp@ john .ed
Refe ee( )' Commen o A ho : Refe ee: 1
Recommenda ion: Accep
11/22/22, 12:10 PM UIN A a Ma a a Ma - J a A R a H E a - D Ma ID JARHE-02-2022-0041.R1
:// a . . / a / /1/? = 95 52 836& = & a =a & = a - %3A1737599648477169065& = - %3A1737599648477169065 2/4 Commen :
In gene al, hi i a ell- i en, b ief, and aigh fo a d o k. The in od c ion i ele an and heo e ical ba ed.
Reade can follo he e ea ch' finding b ele an info ma ion p io d Addi ional Q e ion :
1. O iginali : Doe he pape con ain ne and ignifican info ma ion ade a e o j if p blica ion?: The pape i in e e ing and con ain f e h info ma ion ha benefi he eade .
2. Rela ion hip o Li e a e: Doe he pape demon a e an ade a e nde anding of he ele an li e a e in he field and ci e an app op ia e ange of li e a e o ce ? I an ignifican o k igno ed?: The a ho ' opinion a e ppo ed b ci a ion o ele an die .
3. Me hodolog : I he pape ' a g men b il on an app op ia e ba e of heo , concep , o o he idea ? Ha he e ea ch o e i alen in ellec al o k on hich he pape i ba ed been ell de igned? A e he me hod emplo ed app op ia e?: The a emen in he pape i ba ed on a olid ppo of he heo . The e ea ch fea e a ell-de igned f ame o k and accep able e ea ch me hod .
4. Re l : A e e l p e en ed clea l and anal ed app op ia el ? Do he concl ion ade a el ie oge he he o he elemen of he pape ?: The o come of hi e ea ch a e p e en ed clea l and i abl .
5. Implica ion fo e ea ch, p ac ice and/o ocie : Doe he pape iden if clea l an implica ion fo e ea ch, p ac ice and/o ocie ? Doe he pape b idge he gap be een heo and p ac ice? Ho can he e ea ch be ed in p ac ice (economic and comme cial impac ), in eaching, o infl ence p blic polic , in e ea ch (con ib ing o he bod of kno ledge)? Wha i he impac pon ocie (infl encing p blic a i de , affec ing ali of life)? A e he e implica ion con i en i h he finding and concl ion of he pape ?: Thi egmen i ela i el ong.
6. Q ali of Comm nica ion: Doe he pape clea l e p e i ca e, mea ed again he echnical lang age of he field and he e pec ed kno ledge of he jo nal' eade hip? Ha a en ion been paid o he cla i of e p e ion and
eadabili , ch a en ence c e, ja gon e, ac on m , e c.: The pape i ell- i en
Refe ee: 2
Recommenda ion: Majo Re i ion Commen :
Thi pape need ome imp o emen , ee commen Addi ional Q e ion :
1. O iginali : Doe he pape con ain ne and ignifican info ma ion ade a e o j if p blica ion?: Ye , he o iginali of hi e ea ch i b ho ing a gap anal i ega ding a hen ic a e men a a e and p i a e ni e i ie d ing he co id-19 pandemic.
2. Rela ion hip o Li e a e: Doe he pape demon a e an ade a e nde anding of he ele an li e a e in he field and ci e an app op ia e ange of li e a e o ce ? I an ignifican o k igno ed?: Ye . The e i a lo of app op ia e li e a e on a hen ic a e men in gene al and d ing he co id 19 pandemic (a e men li e ac ), b lack of li e a e on echnolog ool fo a e men . On he o he hand, he e i no m ch impo ance in e ealing a hen ic a e men be een lec e a a e and p i a e ni e i ie .
3. Me hodolog : I he pape ' a g men b il on an app op ia e ba e of heo , concep , o o he idea ? Ha he e ea ch o e i alen in ellec al o k on hich he pape i ba ed been ell de igned? A e he me hod emplo ed app op ia e?: Ye eno gh. The me hodolog i e plained in mo e de ail ega ding pa icipan , da a collec ion, and da a anal i in bo h age of he e ea ch
4. Re l : A e e l p e en ed clea l and anal ed app op ia el ? Do he concl ion ade a el ie oge he he o he elemen of he pape ?: The anal i e l ha e no been compa ed i h he e l of o he imila die . I ha no ho n academic deba e.
5. Implica ion fo e ea ch, p ac ice and/o ocie : Doe he pape iden if clea l an implica ion fo e ea ch, p ac ice and/o ocie ? Doe he pape b idge he gap be een heo and p ac ice? Ho can he e ea ch be ed in p ac ice (economic and comme cial impac ), in eaching, o infl ence p blic polic , in e ea ch (con ib ing o he bod of kno ledge)? Wha i he impac pon ocie (infl encing p blic a i de , affec ing ali of life)? A e he e implica ion con i en i h he finding and concl ion of he pape ?: In concl ion, i i be e no o e-e p e he
e ea ch objec i e . The implica ion of hi e ea ch ha e no been able o become a ol ion o he na ion' p oblem . Thi e ea ch onl fo nd he p oblem of a hen ic a e men d ing online lea ning.
11/22/22, 12:10 PM UIN A a Ma a a Ma - J a A R a H E a - D Ma ID JARHE-02-2022-0041.R1
:// a . . / a / /1/? = 95 52 836& = & a =a & = a - %3A1737599648477169065& = - %3A1737599648477169065 3/4 6. Q ali of Comm nica ion: Doe he pape clea l e p e i ca e, mea ed again he echnical lang age of he field and he e pec ed kno ledge of he jo nal' eade hip? Ha a en ion been paid o he cla i of e p e ion and
eadabili , ch a en ence c e, ja gon e, ac on m , e c.: hi pape need a li le imp o emen on ce ain en ence
Refe ee: 3
Recommenda ion: Mino Re i ion Commen :
Good Job
Addi ional Q e ion :
1. O iginali : Doe he pape con ain ne and ignifican info ma ion ade a e o j if p blica ion?: e , i doe 2. Rela ion hip o Li e a e: Doe he pape demon a e an ade a e nde anding of he ele an li e a e in he field and ci e an app op ia e ange of li e a e o ce ? I an ignifican o k igno ed?: e , i doe
3. Me hodolog : I he pape ' a g men b il on an app op ia e ba e of heo , concep , o o he idea ? Ha he e ea ch o e i alen in ellec al o k on hich he pape i ba ed been ell de igned? A e he me hod emplo ed app op ia e?: e , i ha
4. Re l : A e e l p e en ed clea l and anal ed app op ia el ? Do he concl ion ade a el ie oge he he o he elemen of he pape ?: e , he a e
5. Implica ion fo e ea ch, p ac ice and/o ocie : Doe he pape iden if clea l an implica ion fo e ea ch, p ac ice and/o ocie ? Doe he pape b idge he gap be een heo and p ac ice? Ho can he e ea ch be ed in p ac ice (economic and comme cial impac ), in eaching, o infl ence p blic polic , in e ea ch (con ib ing o he bod of kno ledge)? Wha i he impac pon ocie (infl encing p blic a i de , affec ing ali of life)? A e he e implica ion con i en i h he finding and concl ion of he pape ?: e , he e a e
6. Q ali of Comm nica ion: Doe he pape clea l e p e i ca e, mea ed again he echnical lang age of he field and he e pec ed kno ledge of he jo nal' eade hip? Ha a en ion been paid o he cla i of e p e ion and
eadabili , ch a en ence c e, ja gon e, ac on m , e c.: e , i ha
Refe ee: 4
Recommenda ion: Mino Re i ion Commen :
The a icle i ge ing be e no , cong a la ion!
Onl e e al hing need o be imp o e, namel : (i) he P adi, e .al., 2020 ci a ion in page 1 line 55, didn' ho p in efe ence , (ii) he e plana ion ega ding "ho lec e ie he implemen a ion of a hen ic a e men f om he inp , p oce , and o p age .." a men ioned in page 3 line 15-16, ha no een clea l in he concl ion, and (iii) if he comm nica ion and lang age can be imp o ed again, i ill be e en be e .
Addi ional Q e ion :
1. O iginali : Doe he pape con ain ne and ignifican info ma ion ade a e o j if p blica ion?: Ye , he pape con ain ne and ignifican info ma ion o p bli h.
2. Rela ion hip o Li e a e: Doe he pape demon a e an ade a e nde anding of he ele an li e a e in he field and ci e an app op ia e ange of li e a e o ce ? I an ignifican o k igno ed?: Ye , i ge ing be e no . Onl he (P adi, e .al., 2020) ci a ion in page 1 line 55, didn' ho p in efe ence .
3. Me hodolog : I he pape ' a g men b il on an app op ia e ba e of heo , concep , o o he idea ? Ha he e ea ch o e i alen in ellec al o k on hich he pape i ba ed been ell de igned? A e he me hod emplo ed app op ia e?: Ye , he ec ion of me hodolog i e plained mo e de ail and be e .
4. Re l : A e e l p e en ed clea l and anal ed app op ia el ? Do he concl ion ade a el ie oge he he o he elemen of he pape ?: The e l al o ge ing be e . Onl he e plana ion ega ding "ho lec e ie he implemen a ion of a hen ic
a e men f om he inp , p oce , and o p age .." a men ioned in page 3 line 15-16, ha no een clea l in he
11/22/22, 12:08 PM UIN A a Ma a a Ma - J a A R a H E a - A a
:// a . . / a / /1/? =b95 52 836& = & a =a & = a - %3A1737162125268030411& = - %3A1737162125268030411 1/1 Mis kat Malik Ibrahim <mis [email protected]>
J al f A lied Re ea ch i Highe Ed ca i - A h da e
1
Journal of Applied Research in Higher Education < @ . > F , J 1, 2022 10:48 PM
R -T : @ .
T : . @ - . . , . @ - . . , @ . .
01-J -2022
D A ( ),
I "L
P A A T CO ID-19 P " E
D .
,
D P B
E A , J A R H E
@ .
11/22/22, 12:03 PM UIN A a Ma a a Ma - J a A R a H E a - D Ma ID JARHE-02-2022-0041
:// a . . / a / /1/? = 95 52 836& = & a =a & = a - %3A1726570420759877112& = - %3A1726570420759877112 1/6 Mis kat Malik Ibrahim <mis kat.mmi@ in-ala ddin.ac.id>