A COLORED DRAWING OF THE MEDEBA MOSAIC MAP OF PALESTINE IN THE UNITED STATES NATIONAL MU- SEUM.
By
I.M. Casanowicz,
Assistant Curator,Division ofOld WorldArcheology, UnitedStates National Museum.
INTRODUCTION.
A
colored drawing of theMedeba
mosaicmap
of Palestinewas
acquiredby
Mr. S.W. Woodward,
ofWashington
City,from
abook
dealerin Jerusalem, whileon
a tour around the world in 1899 in the interest of Christian missions,and by him
presented to the United States NationalMuseum. A
comparison of the drawing with other reproductions of the original,which have been
preparedby compe-
tent archeologistsand
Biblical scholars,shows
that, with the excep- tion ofafew
omissionsand
transpositions, itaffords afairlyadequate view of the original. It has therefore beendeemed worth
while to describe this highly interestingand
importantmonument
for the readers of the pubhcations of the United States NationalMuseum,
the
more
so as acomprehensiveand
detailed discussionofthe subject has hitherto notbeen pubUshed
in the English language.LITERATURE CONSULTED.
C.
Raymond
Beazley, theMadeba
MosaicMap
(The Geographic Journal, vol. 17, 1901,London,
pp. 516-520). Clermont-Gaimeau,The Madeba
Mosaic(PalestineExplorationFund
QuarterlyStatement
(quotedPEFQS),
1897, pp.213-225; 1901, pp. 235-246). A. Jacoby,Das
geographischeMosaik von Madaba
(Leipzig, 1905).Wilhelm
Kubitschek, Die Mosaikkarte Palastinas (Mittheilungen der Kaiser- lich-Koniglichen Geographischen GeseUschaft inWien, vol. 43, 1900, Vienna, pp. 335-380). Adolf Schulten,Die Mosaikkartevon Madaba und
ihr Verhaltniss zuden
altestenKarten und
Beschi'eibungen des heiligen Landes. (Mit drei Kartenbildernund
einer Figuren-tafel,Berlin, 1900, pp. 121,Abhandl.derKoniglichen GeseUschaftder WissenschaftzuGottingen,Philol.-Hist.Klasse,
new
ser.,vol.4,No.
2).
Eusebius
and
St. Jerome,Onomasticon Sacrum
(OS), editionofErichKlostermann
(Leipzig, 1904).The Onomasticon
of Eusebius (bishop ofCaesarea inPalestine, died 340)—
itsGreek
title is:On
thenames
Proceedings U. S. National Museum,Vol. 49—No. 2111- 359
360 I'ROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL iWHEUM.
vol. !.ofplaces in theDivineScriptures
—
isakindofglossaryoftheBibUcalplace names, explaining
and
identifyingthem
with contemporarv"designations, noting the distances
between
the largercities,and
add- ing Bibhcaland
historical reminiscences. Itwas
translated into Latinby
St.Jerome
(331-420).The
edition ofKlostermann
con- tains the originalGreek
textand
the Latin translationon
opposite pages, theformeron
theleft, thelatteron
the righthand.THE TOWN OF MEDEBA.
Medeba
^was
origmally atown
ofMoab
situated almost directly eastofBethlehem, aboutfivemilessouthby
westfrom Hebron,
atan elevation of 2,040 feetabove
the sea level. It is frequentlymen-
tioned in theOld Testament and
played a considerable part in the frontier conflicts of the Israelites, being often takenand
retaken.From
the Moabites itwas
wrestedby
the Amorites(Numbers
xxi, 30). After the conquest ofCanaan
itwas
allotted to the tribe ofReuben
(Joshua xiii, 9, 16). In David's time itwas an Ammonite
point of defence (I Chronicles xix, 7). In the 9th centuiy B. C. it
was
seizedby
Omri,King
of Israel,and
recapturedby
the Moabites.^During
theMaccabean
period itwas
the seat of a robber clanwho murdered
John, the brother of Jonathan, the Jewish prince (IMac-
cabees ix, 35-37). Itwas
takenby John Hyrcan
(135-105 B. C.)and had
tobe
retakenby Alexander Jannaeus
(104-79 B.C,
Jose- phus, Antiquities, XIII, 1, 2, 4;XV,
4).Under
theRomans Medeba was
incorporated in the province of Arabia,which was
estabhshedby
Trajan (98-117 A. D.),and from
the reign ofElagabal (218-222 A. D.) there are extant coins bearing thename
ofMedeba. During
the Byzantine periodMedeba
seems tohave
been a flourislung Christian center. Itwas
the seat of a bishopwho
attended the council of Chalcedon (451 A. D.). Itwas
probablyoverwhelmed and
destroyed eitherby
the Persians under Chosroes II,who
at the beginning of the seventh century wrested the entire Christian S3^riafrom
the eastern empire, orby
the Ai-absunder Omar, who
in 636 completed the conquest of Syriaand
Pales- tine. Since thenand
until the latterpart of the eighteenth centuryit lay in desolation
and
ruinsand
forgotten. In 1880 a Christian colony, mostly ofGreeks,from Kerak
(the BiblicalKir Moab,
IsaiahXV,
1),and
alsosome
Latin(Roman
Cathohc) fathers settled there.In erecting the necessar^^ buddings for the
new
occupationmany
ancient remains
have
been brought to light. These include a large pool with soUd walls (324by
309 feetand from
10 to 13 feet deep),'SointheEnglishBible, inHebrew,Medeva; ontheMoabitestone (9th century,B.C.),Medheba;Jose- phus,Antiquities,XIII,9, 1,Medaba;Euseblus (OS,p. 128),MedabaandMedabba;Ptolemy, Geography (2nd centuryA. D.) IV,17, 6,Medana; themodernArabicnameisMadeba.
2CompareMoabitestone (a plaster cast facsimileofwhichisintheNationalMuseum),line8:"Omri hadtakenpossessionoftlielandofMedeba and(hispeople)occupieditduringhisdaysand halfthedays ofhisson, forty years,butChemoshrestoreditinmydays"; comparealsoIsaiahXV;2).
N0.2111.
MEDEBA MOSAIC MAP OF PALESTINE — CASANO
WIt'Z.301
ruins ofseveral churches, remainsofa colonnadedstreet,inscriptions,
and
mosaic pavements.The
character ofsome
of the ruinsshow
that part of thetown had
pretensions to elegance.The most
inter- estingand
noteworthy discovery,both from
an archeologicaland
artistic standpoint,
was
that of the mosaicmap
of Palestineand
ofpart of Egypt.
DISCOVERY AND CONDITION OF THE MOSAIC MAP.
The
firstnotice of themap came
through amonk
belonging to the Christian colony settled atMedeba,
the find having been uncovered incleanmg
theground
for anew
churchon
the lines ofan
old one.In 1882 this
monk
wrote concerning the mosaic toNicodemus
theGreek
PatriarchofJerusalem,who
simplylaidtheletterasidewithout payingany
attention to the subject. His successor, the Patriarch Gerasimus, found the letterand
sent a mastermason
(with the pretentious title of architect) toexamine
the mosaic with du-ections toincludeitinthenew
churchiffound worth whHe. The
''architect did not find itworth
while.And
thus in the building of thenew
church large portions of the mosaicwere
destroyed.A
pillar of thenew
churchwas
driven through the midst of the mosaic (seenon
the platein rectangularblank at thesouthern extremityof the
Dead
Sea). Large parts
were
coveredby cement
for the flooring of thenew
church. In this condition Father Cleopas Koikyhdes, librarian of the Patriarch of Jerusalem, found the mosaic in 1896and
took steps for its preservationby imbedding
the fragments in the floor of thenew
church.To
judgefrom
the remains, themap had
previ- ouslyundergoneseveralrestorations.For
in several portions a plain mosaic or merelycement
fiUs out destroyed parts.Though
rather a primitiveand
crudeway
ofrepairingworks
of art, it substantiaUy contributed to the preservation of themonument by
preventing further crumbling of the remaining parts.THE BOUNDARIES OF THE MAP.
The
following is suggested asmere
conjecture.The
longest con- nected fragmentreachesan
extensionof about 35feetfrom
the spring ofAenon
nearSahm
in thenorth tothe deltaof the Nileinthe south, while the church ofwhich
the mosaicformed
thepavement
is about55feetwide. There
would
thusremain
alacunaof about 20feet.|It
may
perhaps beassumed
that the regionof the Nfle Delta,which
alone is related to the Biblical narrative because the Israehtes sojourned there before theysetout toCanaan,represents theoriginal1So Kubitschek(p. 348),whogives the dimensions, respectively,"over10.5meters,""17meters,"and
"65meters" Bsazley(p. 517),assumes "thatthe originalonce occupied aspace ofabout49by20feet andthat"whatremainsinaU(is)abouthalfofthecomplete scheme," while FatherCleopasisquotedin the Biblical W^orld for1898(p. 254),calculating that"the fragmentsremamingcontainabout]« s<]uare meters,andthemaporiginaUycovered280squaremeters."
362 PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL MUSEUM.
vol.40.southernlimit of the
map. The
north sidemay have
reached to the northern confines of Phenicia. Itmay
beassumed
that the scalewas
contracted northward, asthat regiongavethe artistless occasionand
opportunityfor illustrationand comment. On
the eastside themap may have
beenbounded by
the River Euphrates,which
in Biblical traditionis theidealboundary
of Israelitepower and
expan- sion (compare Genesis xv, 18;Deuteronomy
i, 7; xi, 24;Joshua
i, 4, etc.), whileon
the west side the MediterraneanSea would be
the obvious boundary. Little weightis tobe attributed to the assertion ofsome
inhabitants ofMedeba
that they read thenames
ofEphesus and Smyrna on
themap
years ago, so that it contained also AsiaMinor
(Bibhcal World, 1898, p. 254).GENERAL FEATURES OF THE MOSAIC
MAP.The Medeba map
isnot onlytheearliestmap
ofPalestine preserved, but also the oldest detailedlandmap
thatwe
possess. Itoriginated in theGreek
partof thew^orld, whileaU
otheritinerariaand maps
of Palestinebelong to the LatinWest and
are inscribedinLatin.Like all the
maps which
are basedon Greco-Roman
tradition, themap
ofMedeba
isorientatedtoward
sunrise; thatis,the eastisplacedat the top, the west at thefoot, the north at the left,
and
the south at the right. This orientation"may be
designated as the ecclesi- astical, aswithoutdoubt
the eastwas
the determinating pointofthecompass
for themedievalgeography
for thereasonthat Paradisewas
there located" (Schulten, p. 112).As
the church ofMedeba
is,according to ancient usage, likewise orientated
toward
the east, the visitoron
entering the church looked in thesame
direction toward the apseand
altar of the church,and
at thesame
timeinthe eastern direction of the sky,and
thus a natural connectionbetween
the pic- tureof themap and
therealitywas
established. Inagreement
with this orientation the explanatory inscriptions are placedon
the west lineand were
tobe
readfrom
the door side of the church. In likemanner
the pictorial representations of cities, buildings, mountains,trees, etc., are placed
on
the basisof the westas the footline.Itisevident that theartist
attempted
tocombine
aview
ofancientCanaan
with a picture ofPalestineofhis time.As
ancient historians oftenprojectedtheirtimeinto thepast, so themaker
ofthemap had
before hismental
eye the land of the patriarchs not separatedfrom
thecontemporaneous
Palestine. Pastand
presentwere blendedinto onepicture.That
the artisthad
Biblical Palestineinmind
isshown
by
theprominence
given to the tribes of Israelon
themap. The
names
of thetribes are inscribedon
themap
in particularly large red letters, areinmost
casesaccompanied by
a Biblical reference, chiefly takenfrom
theso-calledblessing ofJacob
(Genesis,chapterxlix)and
blessing ofMoses (Deuteronomy,
chapter xxxiii)and
quoted afterNO.2111.
MEDEBA MOSAIC
JilAl'OF PALESTINE— CASANOWICZ. 363
theGreek
translation of theSeptuagint.Out
of thetwelve tribes of Israel only six are preserved entire or fragmentary, namely,Dan,
Simeon, Judah,Ephraim,
Benjamin,and
Zebulon. In connection withDan
theapostrophefrom
theSong
ofDeborah
(Judges v, 17)isquoted,
"Why
didhe remain
in ships?"The
legendwith thename
of
Simeon
isnow
wanting;Ephraim
is associated with the blessing of Jacobupon
Joseph;"God
blessed thee with the blessing of the earthhaving everything" (instead of "will bless thee with the bless- ingsofheaven"
of the received text, Genesis xlix,25),and
"Blessed of theLord
be his land"(Deuteronomy
xxxiii, 13); withBenjamin
are the words,
"The Lord shaU
coverhim
all theday
long,and he
shall dwell in his territory" (instead of
"between
his shoulders" of thereceivedtext,Deuteronomy
xxxiii, 12); ofZebulon now
onlyfive lettersremain,but
thefragmentcontaining theinscriptionbearingon
Zebulonhad abeadybeen
discovered in 1890, without its connection being then recognized,and
the inscription copied before itwas
de- stroyed. Itread:"Zebulon
shalldwell atthehaven
of thesea;and
heshallbeforan haven
of ships;and
hisbordershallbe intoSidon"
(Genesisxhx,13).^
By
the side of thislegendwas
the representation ofaship,"which some have
triedtomake
outtobe
St.Peter'sboat,"thechurchbeing, accordingto them, dedicated to St. Peter. In this place it is clearly a
mere
symbolical indication of the sea.^ It also appears that the artist wished toput on
themap
besides Palestineall the places
which had been
of importance to the Israelites before then- entrance intoCanaan —the region of Goshen
in Egypt which
held
them
in servitude; Raphidin, the desert of sin;and
themoun-
tain range of Sinai.
But
it is the Palestine of theByzantme
period that is representedon
themap.
Alongside of the Biblical placenames
are often given those in use at the time of the composition.Of
the about 140 placenames
preserved on the fragment, about 60have no
reference totheBiblical narrative.Of
thelattermany
wereepiscopal sees, but a considerablenumber had no
relation either to the Scriptures or the development of Christianity, as far asknown, and
there are alsosome
otherwiseunknown names
of towTis.In its general purport the
Medeba map
is— Uke the mosaic pic-
tures ofsacred history
—
anillustration ofthe Bible ratherthan awork
of geography.
The
artistwas more
intenton
the picturesque details thanon
geography.Much
care is bestowedon
the pictures of towns. In those of large cities like Jerusalem, Gaza, etc., an attempt ismade
to give a viewof the principal streets,marked by
a colonnade,and
to representsome
of theprominentbuildings. Small places are indicatedby
an outline of a wall, flankedby
towers,1PublishedbyGermer-DurandinCosmos,newseries,vol. 18, p. 286.
-Clemont-Sanneau,PEFQS,1897,p. 215.
804 PROCEEDINOS OF THE NATIONAL MUSEUM.
.vol.49.reminding of the cities figured
on Greek
coins of theRoman
periodand on Roman
medallions.Prominent on
themap
is the water.The
Jordan as a compara-tively broad stream falls into the
Dead
Sea.The
deltaarms
of the Nile represent broad stripes.The Dead
Sea forms one of the great features of the mosaic.The
green surface is agitatedby waves
or currents representedby
thick black streaks. In the Jordanand
the Nile (in the latternotseenon
thereproduction) fishes disportthem-
selves, while
on
theDead
Sea, inwhich
fishes can not exist, life isrepresented
by two
vessels, onean
oar boat with one sailorand two
oars, the other
and
larger one, with amast
having ayard at the topand
something like a snake,which
is doubtlessmeant
for a sail;besides
two
oars,and two
visible sailors. Intercoursebetween
thetwo
sides of the Jordan is mediatedby two
bridges.The mountains
ofSinaiand
ofJudah
are depictedin various tints to indicate the different strata,and
fairly produce the effect desired.A
tendency to the realistic genre appears in the desert scene of a gazelle being pursuedby
a lion or panther, in the fruit-ladenpahn
trees, especially
around
Jerico, the ''city ofpalms" (Deuteronomy
xxxiv, 3; Judges i, 16; iii, 13; II Chronicles xxviii, 15),and
Segor or Zoar.On
a freely conceived decorative illustration,which
the mosaic is,in itsgeneralpurpose, itis notto be expected to find the distancesof the places
from
one another or their relative positionsshown
with mathematical accurracy.Thus
Palestine,and
especially Jerusalem, are enlarged out of proportion, in violation of thelaw
ofscale, whileEgypt
is squeezed inon
a small space. Still the location of placesis
on
thewhole approximatelyaccurate,and
the general arrangementis displayed well enough,
and
the picturesque detailsshow
not only thehand
ofan
artist,but
also a careful study of the localities.PLACEMENT OF THE MOSAIC
MAP.The
idea of decorating the floor of a church with amap
of Pales- tine in mosaic is certainly unique,and
the question arises,What
suggested it? Schulten's answer has at least the merit of attractive- ness. His theory (p. 113
and
following) is that the mosaicwas
intended to allow the pilgrimswho
after traversing theHoly Land came
to the East-Jordan region (asshown by
the Itineraria),where Medeba was
situated, to repeatand
recapitulate thereal trip through theland oncemore
inminiatureon
themap.
Schultensuggests that the mosaicmay
be the votive offering ofsome
wealthy pilgrim in gratitude for thehappy accomplishment
of his journey in theHoly
Land,and
that the dedicationwas
lost along with the greater part of themap.
Clermont-Ganneau (PEFQS,
1901, p. 248and
following)makes
the objectionto this explanation thatit "doesn'taccountforthefactNO. 2111.
MEDEliA
!}10SAICMAP OF PALESTINE— CASANOW
JVZ.305
that the pilgrim
had
chosen,among
somany
other basiUcaswhere
hemight have had
thework
executed—
tocommence
with Jerusalem—
justthechurchof a
remote town
atthebottom
of thelandofMoab."
To
thisobjectionmay be
answeredthatMedeba
seemstohave been
intheByzantineperiod a centerofthemosaicartormosaictechnique.
Many
beautifulmosaicswhich
belonged to churchesand
monasteries of the fourth, fifth,and
sixth centurieshave been
uncovered,and
may
stillbe seeninhovels, stables,and
farmyards. Mosaicsofmuch
artistic taste are also
found
in private houses. According to eye- witnesses almost every housewas
adorned with this decoration.It has therefore
been
called"The
City of Mosaics." * Thiswould
account for suchan
elaborate piece ofwork
as themap
is having been undertaken atMedeba.
Clermont-Ganneau'sown
theory,advanced by
liim as"pure
conjecture," is: "It is necessary to con- siderbeforeaU
the positionofMadeba.
Itissituated closetoMount
Nebo. In itsimmediate
neighborhoodMoses
received the order to climb thesummit
of Pisgah,where
hewas
to die,and
to contemplate in onesupreme
vision inaU
its extenttheLand
of Promisewhich was
to belong to his people,
but where he was
not himself allowed to enter"(Deuteronomy
xxxii, 48-52; xxxiv, 1-8;compare
iii, 27;Numbers
xxvii, 12)."Thisgeographicalpicture,
which was
virtuallyunrolledunder
the eyesofMoses,was
intended to reproducein themosaicof thebasilica ofMadeba —that is, in the neighboring town
to this memorable
scene."
"One
could thus explainwhy
thismap
comprises not only thePromised
Land, properly so called,but
also lowerEgypt;
thatisto say, the scene of the high deeds ofMoses and
the events preceding theExodus which
tookplace in this region."DATE OF THE
MAP.The
art style of themosaicwhich
indicates thetransitionfrom
ihe antique tradition to the conventionalschematism
of the Byzantine periodwould comport
with the sixth century A. D.,more
specifically with the age of Justinian (527-565 A. D.).With
this datewould
also agreethe neatnessof the charactersintheinscriptions,
which
are almost freefrom
ligaturesand
abbreviations,which was
lateron
in vogue,and
the substantially correctorthography.PLACES AND INSCRIPTIONS ON THE
MAP.The
places are illustratedby some
picture orvignette representing atown
or building (some ofwhich
arewanting on
the reproduction).
Inaddition tothe geographical
names
there are insome
cases added,•Lamtnens,Etudespubli^espardespftresdelaeompagnie deJiJsus,I,73, 721,andI,74, 44,quotedby Jacoby,PasgeographischeMosaicvonMadaba,p. 21; comparealsoPEFQS,1895,p.208.
360
I'liOCEEDlNOSOF THE NATIONAL MUSEUM.
vol.49.ashas
been
statedabove
(p. 362and
following), biblicalquotationsor brief references tosome
historical events.The
geographicalnames
are regularly ^vTitten
above
the placeswhich
they designate; the additional legends are placedbelow
or beside the places towhich
they refer.The
lettering is in blackon
light ground, in whiteon
dark ground,and
in redwhen
the inscription is of special importance.Itis generally agreed that the
map
isdependent on
theOnomasti-
con of Eusebius. This is evidencedby
the fact that the additional legends areliterally, or almostso, taken overfrom
the Onomasticon.Kubitschek (Die Mosaikkarte Palastinas, pp. 353, 358, etc.)
and
ClermontGanneau (PEFQS,
1901, p. 236) are even inclined to the assumption that the topographicalwork
of Eusebiushad been
pro- vided with amap, and
that thismap was
usedby
the mosaist ofMedeba
as a copy, or at least as amodel.In the following enumerationofthe placespreserved
on
themosaic therewillbe
first given a transcription ofthenames and
translation of the additional legends as restoredby
themost competent
authori-ties, followed in case of biblical locahties,
by
theform
of thenames
in the English Bible with the biblical references,
and where
it is of interestthe version of theOnomasticon
of Eusebiusand
St.Jerome
willbe quoted.
For
the sake of a better survey the area of themap
is divided into six zones orsections, beginning at the north:1.
FROM THE
JORDAN TOTHE
SEA,NORTH
OFTHE
SECOND BRIDGE OVERTHE
JORDAN.Aenon, near Salem.
—
Eusebius (OS, p. 40) adds: ''HereJohn
bap- tized."— Aenon, near toSalim (John iii, 23), identified by some
with
modern Ainun
(seePEFQS,
1881, p. 47).
Koreous (part ofthe representation of a building is
wanting on
the reproduction).—
^TheKorea and Koreae
of Josephus (Antiquities,XIV,
3, 4;War,
I, 6, 5; IV, 8, 1),Modern Karawa.
Archelais.
— Named after Archelaus, son of Herod, King
of Judea,
who
built it (see Josephus, Antiquities,XVII,
13, 1;XVIII,
2, 2).It
was
lateran
episcopalsee.To
theleft ofit isPJtasadis (restored), erectedby Herod
inmemory
of his brother of the
same name
(see Josephus, Antiquities,XVI,
5, 2;
XVII,
8, 1;XVIII,
2, 2). Still preservedunder
thename
ofAin
el-Fasail.Eastern frontier of Judea. Akrabhim,
which now
is called Akra-bitte.
— Themosaist hashereapparently confusedAki'abatta, themain
place of the mountain
district of Akrabattene (Josephus, War,
II,
20, 4; IV, 9, 4; 9, 9), modern
Akraba, which
he rightly locates here
inthe north, withAkrabhim,
in theextreme southofJudea (Numbers
N().2111.
MEDEBA MOSAIC MAP OF PALESTINE— CA8AN0WI0Z. 367
xxxiv, 4;Joshua
xv, 3; Judges i, 36; see Josephus, Antiquities, XII, 8, l).iNeajyolis
— modernNablus, and Sychem
or Sikima
in the region of
Salem,
which
Jacob gave to Joseph,and
Sychar,where
is the well of Jacob.—
These three places are usually identified with one another.The
mosaist has correctly separated them.For
Neapoliswas
not (xactly situatedon
the site ofShechem, and
Sychar is onemile east ofShechem.^For
the expression,"Sychem
in the region ofSalem"
see Genesis xxxiii, 18. There is at present east of
Nablus
a village calledSalim (Jacoby,Das
geographische Mosaicvon Madaba,
p. 81).Sychar
and
the well of Jacob arementioned
inJohn
iv, 5, in the storyof theconversationofJesuswiththeSamaritanwoman.
ThereisstiU at present a place
named Askar
nearNablus which
isusually identifiedwithSychar
oftheGospel (Jacoby,p. 82, see alsoClermont-Gaimeau, PEFQS,
1901, p. 237).To
the right of Neapolis is the picture of a building with around
towerand
overit theinscriptionSanctuaryoftheHoly
Elisa.—
Itrep-resents the sancutary erected
on
the site of the springwhose
bitter waters the prophetEUsha
rendered sweet, as related inIIBangs
ii,19-22. Underneath.
Tour
Goheland down
to the left,Tour
Garizin—
^Themountains Ebal and
Gerizimfrom which
the cursesand
blessings respectively were pronounced, whilehaK
of the tribes stoodon
onemount and
half
on
the other(Deuteronomy
xi, 29; xxvii, 13;Joshua
viii, 33.)On
the original, thesemountains
are also represented near Jerichounder
thenames
of Gebaland
Garizeini. This double placing ofthemountain
pair is also found in Eusebius (OS, p. 64). There weretwo
traditions asregards the siteof thetwo
mountains.The
Samari- tansand many Arabian
geographers placethem
nearNeapolis, while Eusebius, (OS)locatedthem
intheneighborhoodofJerichoand
Gilgal.The
mosaic takes account of both traditionsand
apparently giving preference to the probablymore
correctone ofthe Samaritans.Below
isarenmant
ofthename
ofEpJiraimand
the blessingrelating to Josephand Ephraim which
hasbeen
already quoted (p. 363).On
detachedfragments, next to the margin, are thefive letters of thelegend connectedmth
the tribe of Zehulon (Za. . .Kes) forwhich
see
above
(p.363),and Aghar — Lagrange would
identifyitwithAkha-
baramentioned
inJosephus,War
II, 20, 6and
Joseph, Life, 37, as atown
inUpper
Galilee, whileClermont-Ganneau (PEFOS,
1901, p.240) sees init the
town
ofGabarah
orGabaroth
of Josephus, Life 10, 25, 45and
47^ considering theA
as prosthetic.1Schulten,Die MosaikkartevonMadaba,p.8;compare E.Schuerer,Geschichtedes juedischenVolkes iraZeitalterJesuChristi,ed.2,Leipzig,1S86, vol. 11, p. 13S, n. 437.
'See George Adam Smith, Thehistoricalgeography oftheHoly Land, I>ondon, 1904,pp. 3tj7-372;
PEFQS,1878,p. 114.
3G8 riiOVEEDJXas or
TJINXATIOXAL
MUf<EUM. vol. 49.2.
BETWEEN THE
SECOND BRIDGE OPTHE
JORDANAND
JERUSALEM, Galgalii,which
isalso called theTwelve
stones.—
Gilgal,where
theIsraelites erected twelve stones in
commemoration
of their passage of theJordan
(Joshua iv,20). Eusebins (OS,p. 66) adds:"And
to the presentday
isshown
a desert placetwo (Roman)
milesfrom
Jericho,
which
is heldby
the people in veneration."Modern
Tel Jeljul.Jericho.
—
Illustratedby
extensive buildingand
surroundingpalm
trees
(Deuteronomy
xxxiv, 3).Louza,
which
isalso called Bethel.—
Genesisxxviii, 19; xxxvi,6.—
Modern
Beitin.Goplina.
—
Ophni,Joshua
xviii, 24, see Josephus,War,
1, 11, 2;V, 2, 1, etc. It isidentified with Jufna, a village situated
between
Jerusalemand
Nablus.Gahaon.
—
Gibeon,Joshua
ixand
x; later place of sanctuary,I
Kings
iii, 4; I Cln-onicles xvi, 39;Modern
El-Jib.Rama. —Several placesin the mountain
districts of Palestinebear
the name
ofRamah, which means
"height." The
presentRamah
is
mentioned
together withGibeon
inJosuha
xviii, 25, as being north ofJerusalemand
belonging to the tribe of Benjamin.Near
itlay the grave of Rachel, according to Jeremiah xxxi, 15,
who
repre- sents thisancestor as appearingon
her graveand
uttering alamenta- tion for the exile of her children. InMatthew
ii, 18, this passge isquoted in connectionwith the slaughtering of the children caused
by
Herod.The
mosaist places anotherRamah
near Betlilehemand
followingMatthew
erroneouslyquotesfrom Matthew and
Jeremiah(as alsoEusebius,OS, p. 148) thewords:"A
voicewas
heardinRamah,"
butin this quotation doubtless the
Ramah
near Bethel is meant.—
Identified with
El-Ram,
about five miles northfrom
Jerusalem.Bemmon. —Several plans with the name Rinimon
occur in the Old
Testament; here is probablymeant
the Rimmon
of Judges xx, 45.
—
Identified with
modern Rammon,
eastfrom
Bethel (on thedrawingit isincorrectly placed nortlnvest of Bethel).Armotliem or Arimatlie.
—
Arimathaea,Matthew
xxvii, 57;Mark
XV, 43;
Luke
xxiii, 51;John
xix, 88.—
Identifiedwith BeitRima.
T/if^ms^is.—Identified
by Clermont-Ganneau (PEFQS,
1897, p.218) with the ruinsof DeirAsfin.
Betomelgezis.
— Clermont-Ganneau (PEFQS, 1897, p. 218), suggests
theBethmelchi orBethmelchis of theCrusadersin the neighborhood
ofMe
jdel Yaba.
Adiaeim
(o)' Adlathim),now
Aditha.— Jacoby (p. 71) suggests the
modern
ElHaditha
near Diospolisand
refei-stoIMaccabees
xii,38;xiii, 13; Josephus,
War,
IV. 9, 1.so.'nn.
MEDEBA
MOtSAlCMAP OF PALESTINE— CASANOWICZ. 369
3.JERUSALEM
AND
SURROUNDINGREGION.Jerusalem.
— Above the city plan is read in large red characters,
"Holy
city Jerusalem."For
the various parts of the city itself are used green, red, yellow, black,and
white. Contrary to the later medieval plans of Jerusalem,which have
a circular outline (perhaps influencedby
the idea thatJerusalemwas
the centerofthe world), divided into fourquartersby two
streetscrossingone another atright angles, theplanof thecityon
themosaicis oval oreUiptical, with the streets running parallel to one another.The
southeast corneris destroyedon
the mosaic.The
cityissurroundedby
awall,which on
the east sideshows an
irregularhne
ofjutting-out towersand
buildings.A
series ofgates provides for the intercourse of the citywith the outside.Entering the city
from
thenorth (left) side thereis a gate flankedby two
towersleading to a semicircularspaceon which
is a column.It corresponds to the
modern Damascus
Gate,which
still bears thename
of ''gate of thecolumn (Bab
el-amud)."From
this gate issuetwo
streets, linedon
either side with columns.One
of the streets runs in a straightline almost through the entirelength ofthe city; the othermakes
aboutmidway
abend
eastward, crossing a lesserarterywhich
entersfrom
the easterngate,and
thence proceedsdue
south, parallel to themain
street.The
western colonnade of themain
streetisbroken by
stepsleading through three portalsto a greatchurch buildingwhich
abutson
the westwall. Itis generally agreed thatit represents the church of theHoly
Sepulchre builtby
Constantineand
Heleneand
dedicatedin 336 (Eusebius, Life ofCon- stantine, III, 37). It consists of a basihca, the Martyrium,on
the alleged site of Golgotha,and
a rotunda in the middle ofwhich was
the
tomb
of Jesus, called the Anastasis (place of the resurrection).The
basihcais atthe eastand
therotundaatthe west.At
the north- east extremity of the city is another church, perhaps that of the NativityoftheVirgin(now
St. Anne).The
gateinaboutthemiddle of the east side corresponds to the present St. Stephen'sGate (Bab
Sitti
Mariam) and
the streetissuingfrom
itwestward would
be the Via Dolorosa of tradition.South from
it is another gate—
theGolden Gate (Bab
el-Daheriyeh).The
large building at the south- west, at theend
of themain
street,may
represent theChurch
ofHoly
Zion,alsoknown
asthechurchoftheLastSupper
(Caenaculum).
On
the westside one gate can be discerned,which would
answer to the present JaffaGate (Bab
el-Khalil).It
may
beassumed
that the picture of Jerusalemon
the mosaic,which
bears evidence of being executed with great care, preserves agood summary
of thecity'smain
featuresin the timeofJustinian.S1022°-Proe.N.M.vol.49—1.^) 24
370 I'ROVEEDINGS OF THE
l^iATIONALMUSEUM.
vol.40.Above,
near the Jordan: Beihabara, of theHoly John
of the bap- tism.—
Supply: Sanctuary, or church of .But
even so the construction is curiousand shows
that the mosaist'sknowledge
of
Greek was
not very strong. Eusebius (O S, p. 58) has"B
,where John was
baptizing,"and
adds:"The
place is still shown,where many
ofthe brethren (i. e.. Christians) like tobe
bathed."—
Itrefers to the narrative in
John
i, 28,where some
scholarsread (aftersome
old manuscripts) Bethaniainstead ofBethabara.^Alon
Atath,which
isnow
called Bethagla.—
Eusebius (OS, p. 8) has:"Alon
Atad,which
is across the Jordan.Here
theymourned
Jacob.
The
place is three(Roman)
miles distantfrom
Jerichoand
abouttwo (Roman)
milesfrom
the Jordan,and
isnow
called Bethagla,
which means
circuit, because here themourners made
acircumambulationaround
Jacob."—
It refers to the narrative in Genesis 1, 10.(Where
the English Versionhas, " threshing-floor of Atad").Both
Eusebiusand
the mosaist following him, errone- ously identify themourning
station of Jacob withBeth-Hogla
(Joshua XV, 6).The
formerwas
probably east of the Jordan, while the latter ison
the westbank
of the Jordan, identical withmodern Ain
(or Kasr) Hajla,between
Jerichoand
the Jordan, south of Gilgal.EpJiron or Ephraia.
—
^The original has the additional legend:"Thither
went
the Lord,"and
Eusebius(OS
p. 90), adds:"with
his disciples."
— Johnxi, 54, compare
II Chroniclesxiii, 19.
To
the right of thelast-named place, Ailamon, here thesun
stood stniby
(the son) ofNaue
(Nun).—
Refers to the episode ofJoshua
x, 12 (where the Septuaginttranscribes
Aj
alonby
Ailon).—
Eusebius(OS, p. 18),
more
correctly— "the sun stood still in answer
to the
prayerofJoshua," and
adds: "Still at present avillage called Ailon>
three
(Roman)
miles east of Bethel, nearGabaata and Rama,
the cities of Saul."To
the north of Jerusalemand
close to the periphery of the city is thename
ofBenjamin and
theprophecy
bearingon
it,which was
referred to previously (p. 363). Further
down: The
Fourth,and
Nine,which
are interpreted to refer toRoman
military stations or garrisons.Underneath
to the south is,Betlihoron.
— Joshua x, 10; xvi, 3, 5.—
Represented to-day by
Beit
Ur
el-Fokaand
BeitUr
el-Tahta, near it.£'roi/ia.—
Clermont-Ganneau (PEFQS,
1897, p. 220and
1901, p.238), identifies itwith
Kefr Rut
near BeitUr
el-Tahta, to the west- northwest;Schulten (p. 94), sees in it Kirjath-Jearim,Joshua
ix,17;XV, 9, 60, etc.,
which
Eusebius (OS, p. 114) places at the ninth milestonefrom
Jerusalem towardsDiospolis orLydda.
Thiswould
1SeeG. A. Smith,nistoricalGeographyoftheHolyLand,p.49(5,n. 542,PEFQS,1S75, p. 72; 1878, p.
120; 1881, p.4fi.
NO. 2111.
MEDEBA MOSAIC MAP OF PALESTINE— CA8AN0WIGZ.
37 1suitthe positionof
Karyet
el-Enab,which
is aboutthree hoursfrom Lydda.
Below,Modeeim,
now
Moditha,whence came
the Maccabeans.— Modern
el-Medieh, Underneath,
Lod,
which
isLydea and
also Diospolis.— The Biblical Lydda
or
Lod,
Ezra
ii, 33;Nehemiah
vii, 37; "Acts ix, 32. Itwas
an episcopal seeand
the place of St. George.To
the right,Thamna,
hereJudah
shore his sheep.— The Biblical Timnah,
Genesis, xxxviii, 12,
Joshua
xv, 57, Underneath,Anob,
which
isnow
Betoannaba.— Anab, Joshua xi, 21, xv, 50,
Modern Annabe.
4.
BETWEEN
JERUSALEMAND THE DEAD
SEA.Across (east of) the
Jordan below
the scene of the gazelle chasedby
a panther or Hon,Aenon,
where now
is Sapsaphas.— As in the case of the mountains
of
Ebal and
Gerizim (see above, p. 367) so,itseems, there alsowas
current a double tradition as regards the site ofAenon where John
baptized, the oneplacingit (correctly) nearSaUm
(see above, p.366), the other near Bethabara,and
the mosaist took account of both traditions.To
the right,Hot
spring ofCallirhoe.— Mentioned in Pliny's NaturalHistory, V,
16, 72, Josephus, War,
I, 335. Identified with modern Hammam
ez-Zarka Main.
West
of the Jordan,Tliekoue.
—
Biblical Tekoa, Birthplace of the prophetAmos,
IISamuel
xiv, 2;Amos
i, 1, etc.Bethlehem
—
Ephratha.— On the Mosaic as well as in the Onomas-
ticon (pp. 45, 82,
and
172)Bethlehem and Ephrathah
are noted astwo
separatedlacalities, while usuallythey areidentifiedand Ephra-
thahisconsideredascognomen
ofBethlehem. Itmay be
thatEphra-
thahwas
thename
of the whole district inwhich Bethlehem
lay;compare
Genesis xxxv, 19;Micah
v, 2.Modern
BitLahm.
Rama
. . . See p. 368.Akl Damma, Compare Matthew
xxvii, 8.BethJhoron.
— Wrongly placedon
the reproduction; see p. 370.
Nilcopolis.
— A later name
of Emmaus, Luke
xxiv, 13; compare
I Maccabees, ix, 50; Josephus, Antiquities, XIII, 1, 3. It is still
preserved
under
thename
ofAmwas.
Gedour,
which
is also called Gidritha.— The site would
suit the
Biblical Gezer, while the name
suggests Gedor, Joshua
xv, 58,
modern
Jedur,six miles northfrom
Hebron. Eusebius (OS, p. 68) registers the placeunder Gedour and Gedrous and
states that itwas
situated ten(Roman)
milesfrom
Diospolis (Lydda).£'7ieto&a.—Identified
by Clermont-Ganneau (PEFQS,
1897, p. 221) withEn Tab
in theTalmud.
372
I'lWVEEDlNGISOF
TUI'JNATIONAL MUSEUM.
vou 10.Geth,
which
isalso called Gitta,oneof thefive capitalcities.—
Bibli-cal Gath, one of the five royal or princely cities of the Philistines,
Joshua
xiii, 3; ISamuel
vi, 17, etc.lahnel,
which
is also called lamnia.—
Jahneel,Joshua
xv, 11; Jab- neh, II Chronicles xxvi, 6.Below
is,Safrea.—^o
readby Clermont-Ganneau (PEKQS,
1901, p. 238)and
identifiedby him
withmodern
Safiriyeh.To
the right is,(Sanctuary) ofthe holy Jo/ia.— Otherwise
unknown.
5.
THE
SURROUNDINGS OFTHE DEAD
SEA.Khara
Moha.—
Biblical KirMoab,
Isaiah xv, 1,modern
Kerak, about ten milesfrom
the southeast corner of theDead
Sea. Itwas an
episcopal see.*Betomarsea
which
is also calledMaioumas. — Clermont-Ganneau (PEFQS,
1901, p. 2:^9):"Buchlor (Rovne
d(^sEtudes
Juives, 1901, p. 125) hasjustdomonstratod . . . thatBetomarsea
isno
otherthan the transcription of BeitMarzeah
(comp. Jeremiah xvi, 5),^^ that Marzoiili, orMarzoiha, means, likeMaioumas,
a great Syrian feast of licentious nature,and
that this double denominationmust
apply in thiscaseon
themap
to the placewhere
populartradition located thefamous
sccMio of the fornication of Irsael, wlion they allowed tliem- selves to be initiatedby
tlie beautiful daughters ofMoab
into theimpure
ritesof BaelPeor"
'*Aia.
— Jacoby (p.9.'i)would
seeit inAi of Jeremiahxlix, 3,situated
not far
from Heshbon; Clermont-Ganneau (PEFQS,
1897, p. 220) identifies it with the Aie of Eusobius (OS, p. 10),which
the latter placesto the east of Areopolis-RabbathMoab.
r^arais.—Clermont-Ganneau (PEFQS,
1897, p. 220) suggestsmodern Khurbet
Talha,between Kerak and
theDead
Sea.Barou.
—
So is tlio arouon
the original roadand
referred to St.Jerome (OS
p, 44),where
he says:"There
is to the presentday
an important place nearBaaru
in Arabiawhere
hot water bubblesup from
theground, <U,('.";compare
alsoJosophus,War,
VII, 6, 3,where
a placeby
thename
of Baaras is mentioned.Dead
Sea.— The superscription reads: Salt Sea (see Numbers
xxxiv, 3, 12, etc.); Asphalt sea (Josephus, Antiquities, I, 9, 1),
and Dead
Sea.West
of theDead
Sea is,Bethsoura Sanctuary of the holy Pliilip.
Here
it is said theKen- dake ennuch was
baptized.—
Refers to thestory of Acts viii, 26 andfollowing.
The
mosaistmade
of thequeen Kandake
a people.Bethzurof
Joshua
xv, 58.'CompareProceedingsoftheSocietyofBiblicalArchaeology,1901, p. 240.
-'In theKnglishBible,rendered"houseof inoiimlng."
'Compare Numbers,chapterxxv.
No.lilll.
MEDEBA MOSAIC MAP OF PALESTINE— CASANOWICZ. 373 The oak which
isalsocalled the terebinthofMamre. —Genesis xiii,
18. Eusebins (OS, p. 76) adds,
"To
the present is the terebinth shown,"and
St.Jerome
(OS.,p. 77) says that itwas
pointed out in his infancyand down
to the reign of Constantius (337-361). Ac^cording to Sozomcn, Hist. Eccl., ii, 4, 1-2, the place
was
sacred to Christiansbecause theSon
ofGod
appeared therewitlitwo
angels toAbraham
(Genesisxviii, 1-2).Sokholi.
—
Socoh,Joshuaxv,35,etc.Sapliitha.
— Clermont-Ganneau (PEFQS, 1897, p. 222) identifies it
with
modern
Tell es-Safie.Beth ZaJchar.
— A fortress Beth-Zacharia is mentioned
in I Macca-
beesVI, 32, compare
Josephus, Antiquities, XII, 9, 4; War
I, 1, 5.
Sanctuary ofthe holy Zecharia.
—
Probablymeant
thetomb
of theprophet Zachariah.
But
early the prophetwas
confounded with the father ofJohn
the Baptist,Luke
i, 5,and
with bothwas
confounded the Zechariah ofMatthew
xxiii, 35.Morasthi,
whence came
the prophet Micah.—
Mareshah,Micah
i, 1, 15;Jeremiah xxvi, 18.Geth
which
isnow
calledAkkaron.—
ETcron, one of thefive cities of the Philistines, ISamuel
vi, 17, etc.The
mosaist confounded itwith Gath.
To
the southis,Asdod,
and
fartherdown,
Azotoson
the sea.— Both refer to the
Philistine city of Asdod, I Samuel
vi, 17, etc. There were
distin-
guished two
Asdods, one on
the sea, the other inland. Both
cities,
which
were about onehour
distantfrom
oneanother, were connectedl)y several small
towns
(Jacoby, p. 57).Aslcalo7i,
and
to the right, Gaza.— Both Ukewise cities of the
Phihstine PentapoHs, I Samuel
vi, 17, etc.
6.SOUTH OF
THE DEAD
SEAAND
EGYPT.On
top is the picture ofashrine,but
thename
of the saintwhose name
it borehasdropped
out.Balalc,
which
is also called Segorand
Zoora.—
Zoar, Genesis,xiii, 10; xix, 22, etc.Bersahee,
which
isnow
calledBerosdbha.So
farextendthebordersof
Judea
southward,from Dan
toPaneas which
limitsitinthenorth.—
Beer-sheba, Genesis xxi, 31; xxvi, 23;
Joshua
xv, 28, etc.Modern
Bir es-Saba.
From Dan
to Beer-shebawas measured
theextreme
length of Palestine.Gerara, once a royal city of the Philistines
and
border of the Canaanitestoward
the south.Here was
the Geraritic Grove.—
Gerar as royal seat of the Philistines is mentioned. Genesis xx, 2;
xxvi, 1. It is identified with
modern Umm-Jerar,
nearGaza
(See Genesis x, 19), or (less probably) withWadi
Gerur.374 PROCEEDINaS OF THE NATIONAL MUSEUM.
vol.49.Oga.
— Jacoby (p. 52) reads Adroga and
refers to Reland, Palaes-
tina, p. 222
and
228.Asalea.
— Jacoby (p. 52) refers toSozomen,
Hist. Eccl.iii, 14.
Sohila.
— Unknown.
Bethagidea,
— Unknown.
£'(Zrom.—
Clermont-Ganneau (PEFQS,
1897, p. 223); ''PerhapsKhurbet
el-Aar, eight kilometers south-southeast ofGaza"; Jacoby
(p. 52) identifies it with Eder,
Joshua
xv, 21.Thauatha.
— Jacoby (p. 53) refers to Thabatha m Sozomen,
Hist.
Eccl. iii, 14.
Sanctuary of St. Victor.
—
^A St. Victor 1,Pope from
189 to 198 or 199, ismentioned
in theCathohc
Encyclopedia, vol. 15, p. 418.Prasidin.
—
Is generallytaken tobe
Latin praesidium; thatis,mili- tary station orgarrison.Thamara. —
^Eusebius (OS,p.8)has:"Asasan Thamar
(i.e.,Hazezon Tamar,
Genesis xiv, 7).There
dwelt the Amoriteswhom
Chedor- laomer cutdown.
It is said thatThamar
is a day's journeyfrom Mampsis on
the roadfrom Hebron
to Jerusalem,where
at present a garrison islocated."Mod.
—
^Unknown.Mampsis. —See above under Thamara.
Arad,
whence
are the Aradites.—
^Aradwas
asouthern Canaanitish town,Joshua
xii, 14, etc.,modern TeU
Arad, southeast of Hebron, while the Araditeswere
the inhabitants of Arvad, Genesis x, 18.Ezekielxxvii, 8, 11,
modern Ruwad. The
mosaist confoundedthem
with the inhabitants of Arad.Jethor,
which
is alsocalled Jethera.—
Jattir,Joshua
xv, 48;modern
Attir.
Or^a.— Clermont-Ganneau (PEFQS,
1897, p. 223):"The
positionwould
suitKhurbet Umm
Adra, transposing thed and
r."^ea7ia.—
Clermont-Ganneau (PEFQS,
1897, p. 223) identifies itwith
Kh.
Sihan, about nine kilometers southeast ofGaza.Madehena,
which
isnow
called Menois.— ^Madmenah, Isaiah X,
31.
SyTcomazon.
— Was
an*episcopal see.OstraMne.
—
^Frequentlymentioned
(see Josephus,War,
IV, 11, 5;PHny,
Natur-Hist., V, 14). According to a legend the prophetHabakkuk
fled thither beforeNebucadnezar from
Jerusalem. Tra- dition also located there thetomb
of the Apostle Simon,who
carried the Gospel as far as Egypt.RhinoTcoroura.
—
^Thename
occui's in theGreek
translation of the Septuagint to Isaiah xxvii, 12; see Eusebiusand
St.Jerome
(OS, p. 148-9).Phny,
Natur. Hist., V, 14, mentions it under thename
of Rhinocolura. It