Sharing session:
Pengalaman menerbitkan artikel pada jurnal internasional
bereputasi
Vita Lystianingrum
Departemen Teknik Elektro, ITS Surabaya
Workshop Penulisan Artikel Ilmiah Pada Pendidikan Vokasi Politeknik Perkapalan Negeri Surabaya
Kamis, 31 Agustus 2017
1
Perkenalan
2
Experience as an Author
1. V. Lystianingrum, B. Hredzak, and V. G. Agelidis, "Multiple model estimator based detection of abnormal cell overheating in a Li-ion battery string with minimum number of temperature sensors,"
Journal of Power Sources, Elsevier, vol. 273, pp. 1171-1181, 1/1/
2015.
2. V. Lystianingrum, B. Hredzak, V. G. Agelidis, and V. S. Djanali, "On Estimating Instantaneous Temperature of a Supercapacitor String Using an Observer Based on Experimentally Validated Lumped Thermal Model," IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion, vol. PP, pp. 1-11, 2015.
3. V. Lystianingrum, B. Hredzak, and V. G. Agelidis, "Multiple-Model- Based Overheating Detection in a Supercapacitors String," IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion, vol. PP, pp. 1-1, 2016.
3
Experience as a Reviewer
• IEEE Transactions on Industry Application
• IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion
• Many IEEE conferences
4
My Writing-related Experience;
How about yours?
• Sebelum studi S3:
• mandiri (tidak ada pembimbing, tidak ada yang memberi feedback)
• Kurang memahami bermacam-macam tipe jurnal
• Artikel ditolak di jurnal nasional bereputasi, ada juga yang diterima di jurnal internasional tanpa review
• Saat/setelah studi S3:
• Ada pembimbing, ada sesama rekan penulis banyak ilmu baru terkait teknik penulisan, ada yang memberi feedback
• Menggunakan referencing software
• Memperhatikan etika mengutip
• Menjadi reviewer di jurnal internasional bereputasi
5
▪ Materi / isi manuskrip jurnal
▪ Strategi (sebagai dosen) terkait (hasil) penelitian
▪ Teknik penulisan
▪ Bahasa Inggris
▪ Pencarian jurnal yang tepat dan submission
▪ Respon untuk hasil review / rebuttal
6
Outline
▪ Where to Start?
▪ Tips: English Reading & Writing
▪ Writing article draft
▪ Finishing draft
▪ Submission
▪ After submission and review result
▪ Miscellaneous
7
Where to Start?
8
Tips: English reading and Writing
9
10
Reading & Writing Tips:
www.englishfriday.wordpress.com
11
Reading & Writing Tips
12
13
Reading & Writing Tips:
Making use of Ms-Office
▪ Thesaurus
▪ Language proofing / spell checker
14
Ms-Office Thesaurus
15
Ms-Office Thesaurus
16
Ms-Office Language Proofing / Spell Checker
17
Ms-Office Language Proofing / Spell Checker
18
• Use simple sentence
19
When the basics are Mastered, let’s write the article draft
20
Writing Tips
▪ Title, Abstract, Introduction, Conclusion: All should be in line.
21
22
Writing Tips
▪ “Introduction” chapter:
1. Summary of background and literature review 2. Include this sentence:
“. . . However, so far no technical paper has [done what you're proposing in this paper].”
3. Then, in the next paragraph, address the purpose of your paper:
“The purpose of this paper is to [do the things haven't done yet by previous references, just like what is stated in previous paragraph].”
4. Close the Intro section with paper organization.
“This paper is organized as follows. . .”
23
Finished Draft: Ask For Feedback
24
Tips: Feedback
Working with “Track Changes” option in Ms-Word
25
26
Contoh 1
27
Contoh 2
Response to reviewer
• file 1
• file 2
28
29
Ready For Submission
30
Journal types
Review process
▪ Single blind
▪ Most of the existing journals
▪ Double blind
▪ IEEE Trans. Industrial Electronics
Special requirements, eg.:
▪ IEEE Trans. Industry Applications requires submitted paper to be presented in its society conference beforehand.
▪ Special Issue of IEEE journals: special submission invitation
31
Journal types
Review process monitoring and duration
▪ Most can be tracked online
▪ Most have a clear time frame
▪ IEEE Trans. Energy Conversion: guarantees feedback in 3 months.
32
After Submission
33
Review Results
▪ Rejected, Major Revision, Minor Revision, Accepted
▪ Response to Reviewer
34
Sharing: My ExpErience As A Reviewer
35
Checklist For Reviewing & Marking
36
Checklist For Reviewing & Marking
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
Miscellaneous
How to reuse part(s) from another source(s)?
▪ Permission of Reuse
47
48
Thank You
49
