• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

ارزیابی عملکرد روش‌های شبکۀ عصبی مصنوعی و زمین‌آمار در شبیه‌سازی پارامترهای کیفی آب‌های زیرزمینی (مطالعۀ موردی: شهر کوهپایه، استان اصفهان)

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2023

Membagikan "ارزیابی عملکرد روش‌های شبکۀ عصبی مصنوعی و زمین‌آمار در شبیه‌سازی پارامترهای کیفی آب‌های زیرزمینی (مطالعۀ موردی: شهر کوهپایه، استان اصفهان)"

Copied!
10
0
0

Teks penuh

(1)

# $%

288 - 279

!

"

#

)

%& ' :

)

* ! + ,

+ )"- (

+ / 0 10

∗∗∗∗1

, 345 / 6 8 0 9 / : ,2

3 ;8 ,

= > 1:&

4

1 . / 4A ,B1 C : D E

F + )5 D 34A , % G H + ,

2 . / 4A ,B1 C : / I ! F

+ ,+ )5 D 34A , % G H

3 .

+ / I !

/ 4A , F

+ ,+ )5 D 34A , % G H

4 . / 4A , ; J ! 64A F

+ ,+ )5 D 34A , % G H

) :

30 / 1 / 1391 - :

24 / 11 / 1391 (

K D/

)*

+ , -.

/ 0 )*

1 2 345 6

7 8 9: 345 + ,

; <=>:

?

@ ?4A + ) ? ?%

B . D

* /

)* 7 8 + ,

EB

@F4 0 7 , 0 B . , 7 G / @ H 8 7 D I

, J HKJ

71 % 7 +

L:4

M A

/ )*

, K . I 7 G E / + ,

/ * + A N AKA O N

? P , O?

/ F ? Q

2R

>SB D T

U 7 7 KV * , >

+ A

- $ SO42 TDS Ca / M 0 D W $>B TH

J Q ? / I -?, ? ?,

>.

8 I /

/ K ) :>8 7 .

D W KV / + ,

50 W T 7J=Z S,KA

Q D? W $>B .$% >B .

7?

K?V

I F= R + ,

KA[

7 B + , >

+ 7 G E WD # ? / \8 ? [] + E5 )

( RMSE ?M \>? , `

D W $>B .

>8

@% Z a J

Q K 7A 48 I 7B ,

Q , >

F Q 2R

>SB D T

U 7 ? ?> ARMSE

M

\> , ` 0U

?;

?>.

+ I 7? ? 8 + ?,

A N AKA O?

N O?

? I / / ?

? * + A N O?

AKA N O 8 AKA I N

O

> ARMSE M

> , `

\ 0U

>. F= R +

A I 7 8 N

O * ? ? , Q

, >

+ 7 G E WD 48 K5 .

/ ! + EL :

F Q 2R O N AKA O N A MLP

7 S,KA RMSE

.

K8

/$=0 HKb WD :

09109774245 eA 1

: 02632229721 Email: a.hamidian@ut.ac.ir

(2)

.

1

/M

-??.

/ ??0

??

1 ??2

?? )*

3??45 6

7 8 345 9:

+ , ?4A + ) ? ?%

)*

+ , B

. W .

1 +

? )*

3? )* ? $ A D?8 K0

fg A 7JE 0

0 h D, ; i ` ?B

K?

D?

W KG*

W $>B D F8

/ )*

, K 7A ?

* ? ? j ? G 7T k #gl

??

j ?? G 7??T ??

7??= ] 8 ?? 8 ??

+ ??F # ] ??.

??

. D??

??

)*

, + )* 7 8

+ , EB

@F4 ?0

B . , 7 / G @ H 8 7 D I

, HKJ

J 71 % 7 +

L:4

M A

/ )*

,

K )

et al., 2011 (HajiHashemijazi

? >?B /

H B + , 5 I + , D >

+ 7 7>1 A B

5 < M #K; m J8 n DA , 7A D?8 K

. ?F

/ I , 7, 7A + ,

5 ? ? 7 K?5 I >? k

B 7>1 I

+ , / * + 7A B 8 K0 /

I

??,

??B 9 ??

??

o>

??, + 8 ??F

# G E WD L:4 W > k

+ Q

W $>B

? / I ?B 7?>1 k # K?% ?, )

Misaghi &

Mohammadi, 2002

(.

/ * 75 ? ?;

+

7? ? ? o> # o0 7A B * -=R p

$G Q 1 ?20 + >5 B - ? J0

? +D?

D? A

q A W gR -, 78K 8 3

?l1 ? ;K ?

?? ??V8 ?? 8 * ?? k

)

Hasani-Pak, 1998

.(

1 4 + , 5 8 W $>B HD

+ ,

D K,

@ 7 + k A 7F 3 F0

+ , 2R RK ?2

(ANN)

F= R 1

`B 8 ?B )

Noori et al.,

2008; Azari et al., 2008

.(

D W $>B F

Q 2R RK ?2 ?F= R

o 8 HK=B + , R ?2 rK?GK F 7 ?4T B

7?>1 k ?B . ?8 K0 F ?

Q ?2R HD?

?A

B ->

+ , s E5 P

WD

`]K WD 0 W $>B

/ F0 3 75

+ ?, <?=>:

nK?=R ?BD .

W $>B K

1 .

D A F

Q 2R RK ?2

1. Artificial Neural Network

D>

W + ?, +

?] 5 7?

I K? * K?V

7F 7 7F W K . eSB 7F

W $>B

W + , +

K0 8 G 7 3 B + ?] 5

7 B ? * . ? / ?>8 a ? W + ?, ?] 5

J 7 K 7]K0 7?

?E5 + ? 7 ?B WD? *

8 + , 8 + B D 7 E5 + ?> A o0 ?

D A )

Haykin, 2004

( .

Q W $>B /

I # G E , ?

+ 7?T

t ??5 7??T @??5 K??4A

WD?? n ??N8 ??B

7?

K?

+ 7?A

Abedini

&

Poladi

) (2003

J ? ? Q

I + , / * + A @u N GK O I

+ ,

> B @?u e?FR I Q=?% 1

7? J 3? 8

/ ?0

I 7 ,

QF 2R RK 2 QJE

v ?1

?4:

>?B 7? K= F.A 7? D? Z K

?

>8 / 7?N

B I 7A D8D + ,

O N A QF

2R RK ?2

7 8 I \

+ ?, ?A 7?

7?>1 k WD?

6? ; ?0

D >? , .

Misaghi

&

Mohammadi

) (2002

I + ?,

BgA * 3

/ 7F * + ?,

?2R RK ?2

+ 7 . D +

# Rg D? D?8 ?A 7? kD8

* Q J 7 -, , /?

7?N >8 I 7AD8D ?B + ?,

A N AKA O N

I 7 8 O

+ , ?\

?>.

D > , 7

=R ? = ; ?8K0

I QF ? ?2R

RK 2

@ = 0 8K B k

7 %K0 WD B 7A

7

# K%

A 0 / :0

k + ?, / ? + ? * W $>?B

D8K .

Kholghi

&

Hosseini

) (2009

9, w K5

K R

» Q J )* yEB * + ,

W $>?B ?

I + , 2R ? 1 + A N GK? O «

7?

? /

>8 B 7N -> B 7A D8D t > >B

+ ?1 ? ? 8 ?2R

7 \ I ,

; + 0U + ? ?

* ?

)* yE?B + ?,

? K?5 ?B

Dehghani

) (2009

I 7??B QF ??

??2R ->?? B RK ??2

] > >??B + ??1

?

??2R

??J E0 / ??

?? *

)* yEB + ,

?; ? / J 7?

A D8 7 K

=A 7

>8 / B 7N 7A D8D ->? B I

] > >B + 1

?

; 2R + 0U

+ ? / ? :0 ?0

yEB )*

m J8 HK.N )*

K?5 ? 8 7?

I + , / * 7F

+ , 2R K5 ?B .

? >?B /

Rizzo

&

Dogherty

) (1994

? + / ? 0

(3)

72:4 + ,

3 D ,

)*

K5

> k 8 F ?

` A 0 I

/ * + N A O 7F ? + ?, ?2R

RK 2 7 `B

? K? R O? N A ?

?2R

??B D8D .

Ramirez

??F , )

(2005

??A I

QF 2R RK 2 9

KGK{ K{ ?B I

??B A

D??8 .

Yesilnacar.

??F , )

(2008

??

W $>??B F0

??

3 QF ??

??2R K??\G ??

| 8K??G ->

#KA 8 )* K]K # >

+ , ,

A 0 D8 A * 7 .

* , .8 HD 7 B WD? *

K R 7 KA[ I ip?

71 ?% 7? ?J

R / B* H Z +

D?

)*

+ ?, ?

?

D8 A . a >8 B

* , 48 , *

+ /?

I

8 7

\ I ,

;

% + >4

K?5

B . 7G J / 7]K0

7 ,

* ?

%K25

f

ZK8 345 7 8 3?45 n ?G

D?

% y

* B WD B 7 ? / ? T I

?,

K 7>5 .

KV / , 7 QF

2R RK ?2

>SB D T

U 7 )

1(MLP

8 I + , / ? * +

A N AKA O N

O + 7 ? ?B + ?, >

+

SO4-2 TDS Ca 2

W $>B TH

D .

2 .

1.2 . M'

%& ' D/

JE Q 7 G E WD?

? S,KA Q \?B_ + 9?:

+ ?,

.$??% >??B

"

40 25' 52° ??0

"

10 27' 52°

1 o] HK ?

; ?

"

10 42' 32° ?0

"

20 43'

32° 1 o] } R ?

G ? ?B ? 667

?,

B 7>1 k ; >F, .

$0 * ~ 1750 yE?B >

B . S,KA . 7

70 A > K?=

+ .? • ?

B WD ; .$%

. K, )*

+ S,KA .?

? 7

)* ~K8 K,

345 B 7A +

> 0 *

0 42 U 7]

+ @; D?Z ?0 >? $?%

7 -

7]

H 0 $%

A D .

`?G s + , I .]

; ?

? ? s ?B

7?JE ? 0

??0 h ?? + ?\ ~K?8 i ?=

n ??8 7?

75 B ; .

@F 1

;K JE

Q 7 G E WD

48 m J8 9 A D,

.

7' 1 . 9- :;

, 0 < ;

=>

? :@ A 4 # 0@- @

*

2.2 . N O

W / \8 7 G E / + ,

7 mK 50 7?J=Z

H ??B ?? W ??T + ??,

1380 ??0 1385 D?? W $>??B .

1. Multilayer Perceptron 2. Total Dissolved Solids

n 8 , 1 + W $>B WD?

? 9, w? /

SPSS 16

n 8 ?1 / ? ? * + n ?8 GS+

?1

ArcGIS 9.3

MATLAB

K .

\8 W / + , , 7 mK 78U B

7JE 7 B D 0 H 8 k + W + , mK?

+ , o> 3 , 7

SO4 -

TDS 2

Ca

?BK0TH

(4)

B € kK GKA K * €K8

n ?8 ?1

SPSS 16

D n N8 n 8 W $>B eSB

, 1 +

GS+

9.3

ArcGIS

??

I + ??, / ??

?? * + A N O??

AKA N O K0 ? 8 ?F ?, >

+ A

- ?$

SO4 2

TDS Ca

D TH

? P , / W $>?B ?

n 8 1

MATLAB

QF 2R

>SB D T

U 7

] , >

+ KA[

* . D

3.2 . P 6 ! ! P 6 !

I + , / ? + ? * ?, o> / ? :0 +

W 8 F ;K HK.N m J8 7>1 k V8 8 ,

W / ? m ? 0 K ?,

7?

HD? 3? # K?%

7{ M K

. WD? A * + ?,

/ ? + ? *

- 8 3 nK= J W $>B HK.N J * 8 o0 D A

. 8

- 8 o0 GD

?M ?B 7?A 7?

K?V

40 y

\>BK 8 F

3 o>

7 A ? . 7?

/ KV n U B

~K N

@M $0 t

?J8

7A 7

=% 1 Q nK=

DF h

\

; D8 7 B

@ J -B h

K . G Q 1

@F 2 n 1 0 B

8

=A 3 8 o0 - 8 48 D ,

.

) 1 (

n

i i

i

(h) (Z(x h) Z(x ))

n =

γ =

+ 2

1

1

2

7??E /??

) γ(h n kK?? 7 ?? D??J

7=??% 1 ) (h ) (x h Z i + W D??8 D??J

WD?? + ?? k

F o>

) (xi Z ) (xi+h W D?8 DJ

+ ? k

F o> WD ) n

(xi : W D8 D 0 + ? k

+ ?,

n N8 WD D

7 G E WD?

?B

) Marofiet

al., 2009

.(

7' 2 .

@ (4

@ BC D @ ) Marofi et al., 2009 (

O N A

(Kriging)

7?A B / :0 I 3

8 ?? 6??E ??

• ?? > / \ ??B K>??B

/ :0 / >.

B ` 8 E5 k .

P , / m ?

W $>B /

:0 / k / B 7?A o>

? K0 ?

H ?? 8 7>??

D??

)

>,

??

??F , 2010

(

G Q * 7 # K%

B :

) 2 (

n

i i

i

Z Z ( x )

=

=

λ

0 1

) (xi D???J Z W D???8 ??? o> WD??? + ??? k

??F ) (xi Z0

?? o> WD?? W / ?? :0 D??J 7EJ8

(x )0

λi

: W ? o> 7 WD Q?EJ0

x

i

: n

> 7A J8 D 0 * ? o

?, W D?8 WD? + ? k

B . ? ?E5 O N A O N A ~K8 / D? 8

.

E5 ` A 0 B W n

.

I / W gR

J * ? WD?

?

+ E5 / :0 ?,

7?EJ8 ? 8 L:?4 ?

K?

) Hasani-Pak, 1998

.(

8 F * I

AKA N O

(Cokriging)

8 / :0 <=>: + , o> / \> , v B

(5)

W K . ; o> I / ,

+ ?F A

W $>B ? ?%K25 / 7A K

D?8 K0 ` ?B

/ :0 >4 ; ,

71 % K]

7? , ?, ) ?

78K 8

> A + ( K . G Q } ?1 O N AKA

3 K]

‚ ? 7? =?% ? o> 3 F A o>

B :

) 3 (

n m

i i j j

i j

Z (x ) Z (x ) Z (x )

= =

= λ

+ λ

0 1 1 2 2

1 1

* 7A :

)

2(xi

: Z 7 K8 i F A 8 F o>

)

1(xj

: Z

=% 8 F o>

) (x0 Z : 7EJ8 o> nK= 8 DJ x0

m 7?? n

m ??J8 D?? 0 `?? 0 0 7??8K 8

+ ??

=% F A + , o>

i

λ1 j

λ2

# R D8 ƒ ?2>5 + ? * + ,

W ?F A =% + , o> 7 WD

) Hasani-pak,

(.1998

4.2 .

!

>

QF 2R 7?

?A 7?>1 ?

7? G E / >S?B

D???? T U

????

7

(Multi- Layer Perceptron)

K????

.

H D?>

/ ?0 7F ? ?, 9 ? ? @?Z @{ ?

?E5 s QF ?

?2R >S?B D? T

7? U ?B

) Dehghani, 2009

/? .(

7F ? 3?

Q? U +

3 Q U ?] 5 3?

? D? T Q? U / ?

* ?, 7?A

7 K?

- J>?

7?

W + ?, +

a ?>8 ?] 5

@??2>

D >?? 8

@ F??40 7??>1

D??8 . + ,D??Z Q?? U

+ ?. 0 7?$ „ ? K0 +

?, 7?

Q? U D?

Q U ] 5 ? 8 …?B H \ ?B + ?, ?] 5 7?{

D, . / 7? U ? ?8 ?, ? ? ?

+ , ] 5 , ?B 7? U ? 7? U + ?, ?.

$ „ Q m 0 7? U + ?, +

7?

7? U + ?, ?] 5

7??

WD??.R D??8

. QF ??

??2R

>S??B

D?? T 7?? U -> K??\G

??2:4 + ??

/ ?? 0

??

7 U + , . 8

?, K?]

D?8 /?

?

`?=s 7?

I ?B ?E5 n ?N8 ? ? k

) ., 2009

Salajegheh et al

(

?? .

/ 9, w??

?? 7F ??

??

3

U ?8 D? 0 7A 7 + ?,

?$:

* ? ?0 3 ?

3 K 8 W $>?B

D?

. ? + Q? U ?$:

?0 H ?? 1

+ ??B D {K \ ??B

??

+ Q?? U

??] 5

??0

H ? 1 + ??B

??E5 D?? 7??>1 k ??V8

. / ?? P ,

7 G E / 7?

?=R

?A k ?B R ?B

?

-> K\G K *

| 8KG

# KA W $>B D

.

D 7 ?B ?>8 D? * I @?% Z a

+ ?,

/ * + F Q 2R 7 KV J Q / a >8

+ , M \>? , ` ?4

Q / \8 ? n

G 7A D W $>B E5 Q

B Q ?; 7? *

E Q 4 B :

) 4 (

( )

n

i i

i

RMSE [ Z(x )ˆ Z(x ) ] / n

=

=

2

1

† * 7A

) ˆ(

xi

:Z DJ

* EJ8 WD

i Q x

) (xi :Z W D8 DJ EJ8 WD + k

i Q x

:i m J8

:n m J8 D 0 WD, 4

WD B .

3 .A Q

1.3 . R :5 ;65

+ A I G 8* n N8 N

8 O - o0 + ?, 8

??, > n D??A ??, +

SO4 -

TDS 2

Ca

?? TH

n ???8 ???1 GS+

??? P , D??? -???B I /

8 O N AKA 7

:0 KV 8 ?F /

n D?A ?,

, >

+

> KA[

+ 7?

Q?G ?F A ? o>

? o> ? \>? , ` ?M / >4 7A D W $>B V8 K 7>?

D?

. + ? `?B HD? eS?B

D?J 7? 7]K0 N0 + 8 o0 - 8 + I

1RSS

) ~K N

; D8

# ( 8 > A

C0/(C0+C)

7A > A D 5

/ 0 D? ) ?:>8 D?

.

@??A D??J 7??T 7??A ??B * € ?? ?? 8 /??

o0 7 E; i + [ 7 ]K0 +

D A

) Taghizade

Mehrjerdi et al., 2009

H D???] (.

1 + ???, >

I n kK W

W 7 WD + ?,

SO42-

TDS Ca

I HD / >. TH

W n kK? 7? WD?

48 @ KR / n DA , + D,

.

1 .Residual Sums of Squares

(6)

H >I 1 . & J K- * + 5 #

= 0 =>

L 03<

+

& H> / 5M

= J K- 0 =>

RSS C0/(C0+C)

HD )* $ A >

147 / 0 828 / 0 BKk

SO42- (meq/l)

168 / 0 949 / 0 + A

Ca (meq/l)

186 / 0 803 / 0 BKk

TDS (mg/l)

165 / 0 861 / 0 BKk

TH (mg/l)

2.3 . R :5 ;65

@ ; 7 A HD

QF 2R ,

m 0 D ,

8 + , 7F / 0 D8K

. 7?

/ ? , n ? 0 K?V

W , + / D0

>5 B HD 7 7B W k D8D? - J0 .

/ G W k W , 7?

Q?G W + ?, I K? * )

Training

( Data

+ / 0 + ,

7F 7 A ? 7?A D?8

7 G E / 60

W D%

7? ?, Q?G

W + ?, I K? *

WD W $>B /

W k W

, 7A W + , + ? >R

(Validation Data)

WD 8 D8K

? + ? a ?>8

Q=Z I K * - 20

+ k ƒK?25 <?;K0

I K? *

W $>B 7F D8K

20 D%

W 8 , D?

K?V /

D8D ) :>8 .8

20 W D%

, 7 KV / ? 0

; HD 7 0 R K * HD W $>B / K?B

W k W , W

+ , K *

(Testing Data)

7A

/ D0 HD W $>B WD48 D8 n ?N8 ? K?

. 7?A ?N8*

W D 0 + ,

W $>B WD?

? / 9, w?

K? -?A

I

Cross validation

W $>B D

. D?

D?> K?V /

W , 7 1 20 K 7

a J0 7>B -

D8D?

?,

7=Z ; 7B ?

? ; a ? / ?

60 D?%

W , 7 QG I K *

7 ; 3

QG ? >R N ?B

) 20 D%

(

8 ; 3

? 0 K? R 7 )

20 D?%

@A W , ( D 7>1 k V8 .

D n k + W ?, 7?A

Q=Z 7 @ ; Q?G

W $>?B ? 0 D?

K? R 7? D8

W + , W $>?B I K? * D?

D8 ? 3 Q>?B ?\

W 7 , ?G Q W + ?, ? 0 ? >R

N ?B ?B

D D8 . , 7 A / ?0 ?1 k n ?N8 K 8 /

n ? 0 7?F

W 7>B a W $>B 0 W K R 7 3

D8D?

.

.8

>8 />1 k V8 7?=Z a ? ?, 7 mK a

??>.

0 7F ?? >5 ??B /

??

/ D??

. QF ??

??2R

+ , G 7 7 # K%

1 20 0 / ? D8K?

. ? /

] HD 7A , G Z ?

?>8 K?

# ?$> * a

Q=Z

= ; B . / ? ? 3 ? ?]

HD? ?A

8 7 K0 Q?N >8 D?B )K?=E .

D?

K?V / ?

/

9, w ?] ? .T HD 7=Z ,

D?

? /

.T *

,

>. 7A / 7? D8 )K]

Q?G

+ , . ) :>8 7 D8D

. 7 :0 KV ?, > /

+

A

??$

7?? G E WD??

3?? A 7??

QF ??

??2R RK ??2

W + , 1 o] # 2>:

8 ? W + ?, 7? mK?

B

>

, 7 QG + V8 K >

7 K? R

] 5 1 7F 7 eS?B D?

n ?N8 ? ?B

+ E5 1 . >5 B 0 7F 7

D / .

7 KV Q J

>8 I @% Z a + ?,

A N O?

AKA N O QF 2R

>SB D T

U ? 7 ? /

a ??>8

??M

\>?? , ` D?? W $>??B RMSE

) H D??]

2 .(

??>8 a ??48 @??% Z 7??A

K??

Q?? ,

, >

QF 2R

>SB D T U ? U ? ?; 7

I 7 8

+ ?, A N AKA O?

N 7>? O?

??

?? I /

?? * / + A N AKA O??

N O??

AKA I N

O U ; > ARMSE

K?5

48 .

H >I 2 . N 5@

0 6 => 1

* + 5 #

* 6

=>

> O N A O N AKA >SB

RMSE

R

RMSE R RMSE R

SO42- (meq/l) 10/26 0/45 10/03 0/47 6/58 0/83

Ca (meq/l) 8/17 0/41 8/09 0/43 4/01 0/90

TDS (mg/l) 2460/69 0/57 2441/17 0/58 984/98 0/94

TH (mg/l) 840/89 0/52 834/34 0/53 195/51 0/98

(7)

3.3 .A R- 0 Q

!

"

%& ' D/

>8 @% Z a

* ?, >

-+

SO4

TDS 2

Ca

A I 7B , TH

N AKA O N

O F ? Q

2R 7 K 7A K # K% / ? ,

Q ?, >

F Q

>SB D T

U

>. 7 / ?, * ?

+

+ , >

7 G E WD n ?N8 .

?N 7?

G ? @ J1 , K 8 D 0 K

, K 8 + 7 B WD? *

BK0 F

Q

>SB D? T

U ? 7 7?{

?B WD?

)

@F??

3 .(

?? P , /

@F??

4

??J

* ??

WD??

??, >

+ A

??$

7?? G E WD??

??BK0 I

+ ??,

A N AKA O??

N UD T >S??B O??

??

7

J J 7 0 D, 4

W * B WD .

7' 3 . - @ * + 5 # A 4 # SO42-

TDS Ca 1 TH ' 6-C =>

,

> Q 5R6 # 0 S

4 . 6 A S:

E

?$ A + ?, > 7? G E /

SO4

TDS 2

Ca

?? .$??% >??B ??; 7?? S,KA ?? TH

W ?.

I + ?? k + ?,

O?? N AKA O?? N A

F Q D T >SB 2R * 7 U

D . 7 KV

?? * ?? I / ??>. / ?? 0 + ??,

` ??M

\>?? , W $>??B RMSE

D??

. ??G Z /??

48 > ARMSE

D , ?> A + ?E5 U ? ;

7 I A 7>1 B . ? J @% Z a >8 Q

RMSE

I 7B , )

H D]

2 ( ? , K? 7?A ?48 Q

7? G E + , >

WD?

F ? Q >S?B ?2R

D T ; 7 U +

I 7 8

+ , O? N A

a ??>8 ?? 7??A O?? N AKA

Abedini Poladi

) (2003 Dehghani

???F ,

) (2009

???J E

???

.

Dehghani

???F ,

) (2009

K???

/ D? T / ; )* yEB

I D??8 A W $>??B .

* ?? J ?? ??, Q

??F= R

I + , D T >SB / ? 7? U

/? 7? ? *

D T >SB I 7A D8D B 7N >8 7?]K0 7 U

DJ 7 I 7? ? 8 + 0U ; > ARMSE

O N A .

Misaghi

&

Mohammadi )

(2002

?? J ??

Q I / ?? ??F= R + ??,

F ??

Q ??2R

I RK ??2 + ??,

/ ??

O?? N A + ?? *

7 . O N AKA /? 7? kD?8 # Rg +D

I 7A D8D B 7N >8 + ,

/ ? 7? ? 8 + ? *

F ?? I Q

??; RK ??2 ??2R + >??4

D?8 J E 7 G E / a >8 7A D8 K5 .

?

* ??8 K0 ?? = ; @?? G 7?? 7??A D??8 A ?? ??,

I + , F ? Q ? @? = 0 RK ?2 ?2R

/ +U R B k B 7 7]K0 8 8K B k I I /? I K? * e? # ?B , ?,

(8)

7 D 8 K0 I ? A 0 # K%

+ ?, O? N A

W $>B O N AKA K?

D8 . K? 7?> G $>?B

I A 0

+ , F Q I ?\ 2R ?,

. ??4 ?? 8 8 ??F / ?? :0 + ,

??BK0 + ??\

\4, w <=>:

WD B . H ?u K? R 7?

Rizzo

Dogherty )

(1994

O N A A 0 I

?

`B 2R

9, w D8 A K5

Salajegheh

??F ,

) (2009

?? 8 ?? A 0 I

+ 1 - 7 ? 6? ; 2R D? 1 + ?B

I - D > 8 ) 8 .

7' 4 . : ,

1 :

& =>

* +

> Q 5R6 # T U 4-4 T U 4 C >+ V : 0 S

(9)

,

?? P / Q?? J

??

/ I + ??, / ??

?? * +

A N AKA O??

N O??

??, > K??

-+

SO4 2

TDS Ca

7?A D L:4 TH

AKA I N

? O?

D??J

??> ARMSE

0U ?? ??;

+ I 7?? ?? 8

A N K O Q ,

, >

+ KA[

?B 7?A

a ????>8 ????

HajiHashemijazi

????F , )

(2010

Dagostino

???????F , )

(1998 TaghiZadeh

Mehrjerdi

) (2009 Rizzo Mouser (2000)

?J E

.

Dagostino

???F , )

(1998

???

+ ???B

# ??> 8 ??V=s 8 ?? 8 ??F # ?? o0 )*

+ ??,

I O? N AKA O N A + , W $>?B

D8 A .

* a >8 O? N AKA I 7A 48 , ` ?B

?B WD? # ?> 8 V=s * ; 9 1 .

Rizzo

Mouser (2000)

W . k + I + , / ? * +

B 7 , >

+ ? - =A - DB # $GKB =A

D?? >5 + K??

. a ??>8

* I 7??A ??48 ??,

)* ?? $ A * ?? + ??>. ??; O?? N AKA + ??,

. 0 ?>8 7 7]K 7=?% Z a

? 7? G E /

??

K??0 7??N >8 k

??

+ I 7??A ??A QF ??

??2R

>SB D T

U 7 I 7? ? 8 + ?,

/ ? ? * +

A N AKA O?

N O?

U ? ?;

7 ? ?B +

>

, + A

$ 7 G E WD B 7>

. / ? /

7?? G E 7??

Q??G

??>.

I /

??

/ 7??

) ??:>8

K . 7 7]K0 ,

+ n N8 D? L:?4 WD?

@ R V=s 7A + ,

A

$ )K ] )K ] s

) ?s

7JE 9 Q J 6 ?B W K? / 7?A

?

> % 7 7]K0 7

ƒK25 $>B

? DZ 9

)*

??

??

?? ?? ??4A /

??, +

??

+

JE 7 H >Z U

V=s K /

@ R , ? /

, 7 7JE G /

D @ . ? / . ?4 ?

K?

9, w , ?V=s 7?A H ? >Z /

@? R ?,

)K ] )K ] ? s

7?JE ) ?s G 7?

? > ?% @

. + k # K?% ?B 7JE K ?

. ? P , ? /

G F45 7 7]K0 ,

+ 5 D?8 $>?B ?

? 7

)*

, + ?E5 7?A

K?

? D?

/>?1 /

/ , + 4A + D8 7JE 7?JE

0 D 7 A D,K5

% )* y + ?, ?

??

7??JE / 7??]K0 >??4

K??

. .8

??

. ??4

B 7A K I

, + / * + 7?

K?V Q? J

>. 7T , I >4

, + / ? * + I ? ?, +

/ K

D8 .

REFERENCES

1. Azari, A., Shariati Niasar, M., Alborzi, M., Bakhtiyari, A., 2009.Assessment of Natural Gas Demand Load for Tehran Using Artificial Neural Network. Journal of faculty of engineering (University of Tehran) March.

2009; 42(8 (118)):961-968.

2. Abedini,M., and Poladi, J.,2003. comparison of artificial neural network by others methods in special estimation of daily rainfall. 6th International Conference on Civil Engineering.

May, 5 to 7. Isfahan University of Technology.

3. - Dagostino, V.; E.A. Greene; B. Passarella and G. Vurro. 1998. Spatial and temporal study of nitrate concentration in groundwater by means of coregionalization. Environmental Geology.

36: 285-295.

4. Dehghani, A.A. M., Asgari., Mosaedi, A., 2009.

Comparison of Geostatistics, Artifitial Neural

Networks and Adaptive Neuro-Fuzzy Inference System Approaches in Groundwater Level Interpolation (Case study: Ghazvin aquifer). J.

Agric. Sci. Natur. Resour., Vol. 16(Special issue 1-b), 2009.

5. Hajihashemijazi, M.R., Atashgahi,M. and Hamidian, A. H.,2011. Spatial distribution of ground water pollution maps as a tool for management of this water resource. 7th National Seminar on Watershed Management Sciences and Engineering. April 27–29, 2011. Noor, Iran 6. Hajihashemijazi, M.R., Atashgahi,M. and

Hamidian, A. H.,2011. Spatial estimation of groundwater quality factors using geostatistical methods (case study: Golpayegan plain). Iranian Journal of Natural Resources , Natural Environmental Journal. Vol.63,No.4,2011,PP.347- 357.

(10)

7. Hasani-Pak, A.A., 1998. Geostatistics. Tehran University Press. 360p.

8. Haykin S., Neural Network, Pearson Education, 2004.

9. Kholghi, M., Hoseini, S.M. 2009. Comparison of groundwater level estimation using ordinary kriging and Neural-Phazy methods. Environment Modeling and Assessment Journal. 6: 729_753.

10. Marofi, S.; A. Toranjeyan and H. Zare Abyaneh.

2009. Evaluation of geostatistical methods for estimating electrical conductivity and pH of stream waters in Hamedan-Bahar plain. Journal of Water and Soil Conservation, 16: 169-187.

11. Misaghi, F.., Mohammadi, K.. 2002. Estimation of groundwater levels using conventional interpolation techniques and comparison with geostatistics technique, twenty-first meeting on Earth Sciences, Geological Survey and Mineral Exploration of Country, p. 588 to 590.

12. Noori, R., Ashrafi, Kh.,and Ajarpour,A., 2008.Comparison of ANN and PCA based multivariate linear regression applied to predict the daily average concentration of CO: a case study of Tehran. Journal of the Earth & Space Physics, Vol. 34 , No. 1, 2008.

13. Ramirez, M. C. V., H. F. C. Velho and N. J.

Ferreira. 2005. Artificial neural network technique for rainfall forecasting applied to the São Paulo region. J. Hydrol. 301: 146-162.

14. Rizzo, D.M. and J.M. Mouser. 2000. Evaluation of Geostatistics for Combined Hydrochemistry

and Microbial Community Fingerprinting at a Waste Disposal Site: 1-11

15. Rizzo, D.M., and Dogherty, D.E. 1994.

Characterization of aquifer properties using Artificial Neural Networks: Neural Kriging.

Water Resour. Res. 30:2. 483-497

16. Salajegheh, A., Fathabadi, A., Mahdavi, M., 2009. Investigation on the efficiency of neuro- fuzzy method and statistical models in simulation of rainfall-runoff process. Journal of Range and Water shed Management, Iranian Journal of Natural Resources, Vol 62, No.1, 2009.pp65-79.

17. Taghizade Mehrjerdi, R.; M. Zareian Jahromi;

Sh. Mahmodi; A. Heidari and F. Sarmadian.

2009. Reviewing methods of spatial interpolation to investigate the underground water quality parameters, Rafsanjan plain.

Journal of Iranian Watersheds Science and Engineering. 2: 63-70.

18. Yesilnacar,M.I., et al.2008. Neural network prediction of nitrate in groundwater of Harran Plain, Turkey. Environ Geol: 56:19–25.DOI 10.1007/s0025400711365.

19. Zehtabian, Gh., Janfaza, E., Mohammad asgari, H., and Nematollahi, M.J., 2010 Modeling of ground water spatial distribution for some chemical properties (Case study in Garmsar watershed). Iranian journal of Range and Desert Reseach, Vol. 17 No. (1).

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

موب رطخ یبایزرا ّمس رصانع یتخانش کاخ رد ی ا یخرب یارب یحطس ز هورگ علاطم یروناج یاه ۀ ناتسلگ ناتسا :یدروم 495 کااش رد یاااه 2 ا 6 ، ۀااشون رااطخ موااب یتخانااش هوراگ یاراب رظن