/
0 123 4 15
6 ) 78 6 15 # # 9 :
; : 4
0 123
) :
22 / 8 / –87 :
24 / 10 / 87 (
<
:
!"
.
"$ % & '( ) *+ , - ,"
. -
./ 0$ %1 ,
2 "
3 .( 4
. 56
7 78 $ 7 9 :) , " +
;$< $ 7 (4 6 " < + =% $ , > $
' 6
+ ?6 @
) B ( 3
.
;- 6 $ $ ( , $ .$ ,
"3 " 4 D(4 8 , , 8 , E * "3 3,
.
: 9 0 5>
: - -
- -
G =G%
- H
: * 66409595 Email: [email protected]
$
%&' ()*+ , -. / 0 %&+ 1 / 0 23 (4 50 6780 90(
&:+ % 41 /:;< =1 > ?@A $ &10 .
! " # $ %
&' () * +, -. /, 0' .
23 4 5 6'
7 8 5 9 8:
.
; &< 7+ => " -'
& ?
* @ ) 'A ! B
0' ) ? D " *A 9 8: & . 1
B * , 7 ->)
. & ? 6 ' , ) & E 6
<
F ? ? , ) *A GH I! - ? (+ ' -
8! J H .
K ) - * " L , ) M " 6'
5 * @ ) 'A ! B +N & ? " -' * ? OP .
F Q , * " R ? E ' S *A 6 ( K ) - TUE
8 K ) - 8 -.
. 6' E V J B 'W ' ) " * "
* @ ) 9 8: &.
. ' R? 6' F ) * " 6' ' R?
K 7 ->) 0' ) @ ) *A Q E
. 2
' >) * ' * " - ?
...
* X 5 *A
) 'W ' ) " * " 6' +
V J 'A ! * J " * J I P) '
*A 7 ->) .
68 ; X " H *A ' ) 6'
Q %8H E K ' R?
' 7'Y X! * A
' , X VJ 'A ! : , K ) - ; O
K 7 ->) #Z
.
8 5 - [ \ * ,
8. ( J" * OP E 6 ] > ^
@' ! _W
J 8H 7'Y ,
. 7'Y 6'
7 ->) 'A ! $ %
+, ! `a-X K ) -
. F"W b OP K ) - * "
! 4 + A A 7 ! 6' b - ?
< " F O
' K
) 2' 3 " K ) - +
'
' O) 5 " I P) 5 .
% 8H &'W _ ) ? F +, c , " # OP * " [ ) ) 6' 5 @ 8! J &- 8 * &' () F
* "
» K ) -
«
1 .
6 *A ! U [ M f * ( * @ ) 5Y g 8 J 4 Q
7' 5 5Y .
OP 7+ " -'
J 8H 7 'Y * @ ) V J B & ? 6' )
* " 6 ' ' R? * 5 ' E ' R? E $ %
. Q
" 6' 8X & 8 " * " 6' )
5 'A &' () * @ ) ; ` ( > L > " -' K' @
. 'A ! Jh' & . K ' i) 6 () " # 7 A 2 O>) 6'
>) " 5 U8 * @ ) -
* " - k k :' )
- 7 6 () 'A ! 6' VJ B OP K ) .
" # [ ) ) 6'
5 8- * * @ ) 'A !
OP K ) - * "
7 => L >
.
8 ^ A F"W * @ ) =>
* 9' f) .
M 3
J J 9' f) * "
5 < "
. -. 8H lX I(
* X ' " 5 J 5 l) 8H M ? " -. m %H -. M 5 @ l) *A * K ) - \ ' K ) - 6 ()
)
* 8k 8 1373
$ 8 .(
Q " F 9' f) 6 6'
.
J . 'A ! * @ )
:
1 - D J 8H 7'Y -
2 - DK ) - VJ
3 - K ) - 7 ->)
)
? 1386
$ 12
.(
.
8 * " L I J 8H 7'Y -
. "
+ F .
& ; O f - 6' 6- 5 J 8(E
X ! >) J 8H 'Y , @ * - 6' - ( J 8H 7'Y
@ f , R! " "A ,
.
? ` L 6' v) 7\
" 5 9 fR) *A ` H 7 . * k(:
+ f &.
.
7 'Y ] ) " "A * 3 6 5 * ) 8(E
J 8H
* ) w H w " S 'Y 6 _W f "
x :) *A " * k E 6 .
- ^
) * X'
»
2! ' , ]' ) J 8H 7'Y
A Q $ % " b 8 & 'W + A * @ E ' " "
*A '@k' , * @ ) &. " . - A
(Hinnebuseh, Davis, «
and Hassassin 2000)
.
(Maye Kassem) 7 H
@. * @ E *A
' O) J 8H * . )
(Kassem 1999)
. " # * ) [ ) ) 6'
. E " E " "A
! ' * 3 V J
.
* 8k 8 - ^
Samuel Huntington)
? ` :8 5 J * (
, &L 5 J 7 %) ` O * '@J PO ` L 6'
y .
O8 5 2 ' 3 6' 8 -. * * k * @ )
5 5 '@J m % ' ? ? "A ` :8 8 -.
)
* 8k 8
1373
$ 11
.(
J 8H 7 'Y k " # &(H " "A M .
` L
VJ O 'V
. E " "A *
VJ . * - .
* "A & (H " ) H & " "A
68 ` ? z " 5 ? => 68 " { * "
, 6 R)
{' 8 ` H ' * " * @J b '@J ` :8
K ) - ' F J 68 X * " ) v)
.
. " "A * @ A O! ` L
F .
- '
"A " # _W f VJ
E ) k^ 'V ` L "
, 6' 6 | z .
5 O?
c ' 6
(Scott Mainwaring)
(1992:298)
K ' } "A ] } b " "A
'Y v) VJ - E . J 8H -.
EW 7 .
V J " 5 ! " "A " # J 8H 7'Y * - 6' "
.
D 4 (f) i 6' 6 () * 8k 8 - ^
&. ! X * @ ) 4 f 6'
6- M .
J " [O? @, B X 6'
) K :
* 8k 8 1373
.(
. 3 " # ^ M .
" \A VJ * " "A
68 ! 6 " K ) - ' + J &- ` L 6' ' J 8H 7
. 8
(Dankwart A. Rustow)
. VJ
5 7 O) :
1 -
?"
D ` H " UE : 6 `
2 -
* ( ] ) g" H K' 8 5 V
' * ' +
D { K ) -
3 -
5 8 J * @ b' @ ! = ? 0' ) K ) - ' * ` ?
J ,
) 1384
$ 283
.(
• P VJ 9 8: VJ =>
.
*A S ` !a8
V J O * ? J 8H 7 'Y l)
(See D`Donnell, Schmintter, and Whitehead)
. @ VJ * R) ` !a8 6'
' . , ! * - @ . 6 ' * 6' .
5 O?
g (
(Raymond Hinnebusch)
J 8H * . mV. 8.
8. '@J * @ ) -
-
5 - E )
) 5 * ' ' (
€ ? ' E * (E * ^
5 M v
(Hinnebusch,2006)
. 'A ! F 4 VJ * 8k 8 6 ^
` H & 5 9 8: 5 J *A 5 ^ '
5" ( m k' *A ?
)
* 8k 8 1373
$ 136
.(
'A ! ^ { 8
' O) " "A g 8 J [, -' " @ A O! VJ 7 ->) 7'Y k' " *A ; ' +
H
. V J " # 'Y " ; K ) - 7 ->) IH
8 , Iz (S) f
.
` ( ) ) H k' ` (?
3 * JY " J , 68 7->8 @ K' K ) ) :8 k' @ * "
) F 8 1383 117
.(
K ' , 7 ->) P' * 8k 8
" ) (?
: 1 - D (H 7 ->) " &L . } {)
2 - f )
D %8H
3 - D , & ? E 6 ,
4 - D X ) x & ?
5 - D2! ) [ . @ A / L VJ
6 - K ) - 7 ->) `a-X ' ' f , * k(: b
)
* 8k 8 1373 303 - 296
.(
* -' 9 8: I , K ) - 7 ->) 'A ! & ? 6' Bl) 8(E .
6 '
5 l) ]' 6' " F 9 8: * X' 8 .
'A ! " \A " $ %: * @ )
1990 k X
5 * +,
)
* 8k 8 K 1373
.(
M M S 1989
Q 7'Y 9 8:
b * ! >L '" O' !A X X &+ " X " b + ) f M G:X
` . H 7'Y 6' "
) 1384
$ 283
.(
6 '
c , R! O! " . I(PE +, 4
.
! " # $ " %& ''()
f ) * ! F ? ! X E 6 ` L : c , " } 8, ` z
` 3 ()
7 + 8 X ` . 5 W {) ` ( ]
{' & 'W 6' )
6 * " ' O) g 8 J M 78 * H M 3 E
5
) ' HA
1383
$ 26
.(
{' 8 & 'W _ ) ? E 6 * " F +, c , " #
@! k8 (
' + < + ` L *A 8X ! ' b'
)
[fL 1373
$ 65
.(
5 'A H OP * " ` 8 b' @! * %%:)
Vk * @ ) 'A ! f3 H B ) .
6 , A ' * 8k 8 - ^
? E
5 U' + b O F 4 b' , &
)
* 8k 8 1373 299
.(
[ ) 4 " ' X!
f , *A M 8 8 " "A (8 7'Y ) '
(Pevehouse, 2005:16) + .
' >) ) F R O8f ) &! > " +, 6' " b
O ) *A 7 ->) +, 7+ ? ( 7 ->) .
7 ->) ! 6 '
8 ' >) X 6' ' R? " # * '
) 6' E 1383
$ 111
.(
) " # 6 ^ 1971
K ' E 6' ) b)
%8H
? XJ" ' ! 2 f) )
(Pevehouse, 2005:142) 6 3 .
@ 8'
" # k' )
` 7X *A K ) - E 6 8 : ? b) 2008
K 2 f) X
' >) ' >) *A ' R? 2 f) ' +) 8.
F Q XJ" * " ) O' !A
, *A K ) -
(aljazeera.net)
.
K ) - * " 7 ` L 6'
OP *A 5 A X! 8 *A R? 8. ' E )
J " K ) - .
(* " %& " # " # $ 'A ! (X +, U 8: " " ) * " 6 '
" ' . * @ ) 5 U8
. " 6' " -'
B " "A J 8H 7'Y E . )
»
* ; X
' R?
« . K ' ' ; H * ) * " 6' ' R? IH
, ' X € O. ' ? ;
% 8H } P f z '
8! J Q ' R?
) 5 "
1378
$ 34
.(
OP * " [ ) ) 6'
X € O. ' ? * ^ P' ; X ' R? )
.
M - " - ) ` L 6'
» E 6 ' (8?
X K ) -
(Klebes, 1993:3) « .
`W >) " b ) 1980
1990
5 ?
; X ' R? 3 * ? " 6' )
.
( ; 6' (' , > 6' M > ' .
? 6' M S * ?
) " # a
1960
? ) b )
y E
Adnan Menderes)
5 (
5 a f *A
} :8 ) ? F H F ? *A 6X \ & ) g 'V & E
(See Dodd, 1990)
. f , ' R?
8X )
' >) (
& 'W @
D ' R ? M (H ]' " -' K ) - -. * %8H
f , R? F 4 X & E 6 8X
)
* ' M v) Z (
Ha?
K ) - + TU. H 5@ k
) 8
* 8k 1373
$ 300
.(
5 ' 6'
\ >
(MERCOSUR) .
b ) * 3 @
) 6X A *
Treaty of Asuncion) (
5 ' R? ) *A y (
8 - ) - 8 -.
Pevehouse, 2005:38)
.(
5 a ?
J 8 +f)
fPH 1080
M 1991
+ F J [' %)
5 K ) - E H K K ) - M L * ' E +,
) K 1381
$ 233
M @ * " 6 ' O) . .(
1990
& -) " #
" -' * ? O) &-) 6' H J )
» L m
* "
« .
M ` H 6 8 : " -' @ *A A 1971
F {
{' *A [' % ) Z WW a? * " 6' "
/ L OP
"A 5 • P ! 3
) K 1381
$ 272
.(
6 ' ' R? - '
O ) * " 6' k' a? a? 6' ; X * "
*A ' R? * ; X .
) K ) - F Q , ' R? * ; X [ ) ) 6'
0' )
$ * " ' * " ' R? { ' X $ %:
! " *A w7'Y ? X [ .
) M S
" b ` 50
' >) ' R? M 5 6' 5
"
_ 8( Q 5 + K ) -
. 8 <W M L T! . X 6' b) E
L !a 5 F { M L 6' " ! ' ) " #
5 X 6 ' K ) - F Q XJ" { w` :8 [ ) ) z O8
) 6' E K 1383
.(
6 ' ' R? ' , X J 8H 7'Y E " "A ; X w ' R?
$ " > i * "
) . _aS E " "A
( . 6 '
*A " 5 B| 6 {' , & ? 8H 8! 'V _a „ !
' .
* ( 8X @ *A 7 ->) 5
)
* 8k 8 1373
$ 299
.(
{ 8
@ * " ' , K' 68 " # ) ' R? * ; X
M ? *A .
'V ` L ' R ? " # ]' 6' …O ^ ` L 6'
6' ' R? ) * "
2 f) X .
' R ? ]' …O E . 6' )
" 4 { ) OP E 6 * "
* "
(Hyde-Price,
1994:246)
.
UE : + , ' * " # , ! ) (EA M S
< RH 5 H * E
, g ' J 8H
. { 8
, ! UE : b' @!
5
&' A 1992 2 f) < RH 5 H &> * E
Pevehouse, 2005:129)
.(
? ' . 7\
70 L 8 E ` H "
' -' A X * " , !
(OAS)
>) a? ` @E _ 8. L J 8
y I { Pz ya, ` ? F -> , ! ` H
(Bahamas)
.
` H UE : 8 , ! * " 6 ' X € O. * N OAS
({ *A X! >) 5 5 ) ( " # ya , 6'
* # { K' } :8 ` :8 ' , K' Pz
+f8 • 3 ' , * H '
.
y fPH R { 8
b ` (8? K P? ' > *A R ? OAS Pevehouse, 2005:130-31)
.(
' >) F ) 8E F ? ` L *A ' R ? 2 f) 8' O' !A
5 ?
" 6' " H -. 8H
.
" ]() * @ ) OP * " k' "
i
»
` Q «
fz
. 7+
S> 6' )
=> • P " 6'
»
` :8 ` Q
« .
` :8 E 6 ` Q
f , 68 I P +, "
8E " E 6
7 *A $
` :8 k * @ m E *A
6 8
5 } )" * @ ) - ' E
) . {E
eastlaws
.(
5 &' () 5 ? X " ` Q [ ) ) 6'
, bE ' ,
"
` ? X
8 -. '
M (O8 E 6 ` Q " _W f ' * .
8(E
• P ` :8 ` Q 6' * X'
)
> ! ? 2008
.(
"
*A 6 ` Q
.
* "
6
E
) b * ? " 6 ' "
g 'V 3
5 U8 7'Y K' * K ) - .
" ' * R ? &' 'Y ` L 6'
! 'V * " *A ` Q * " ' R? *
.
1990
- X K' ` :8 6 8 : X { A
8! 'V 8H 5 K )
O ) 6 8 .aL * N " 5 J ' K' ` Q >)
F { E
' ? "A ` :8 f &H . ` :8 J * A J
5
)
* 8k 8 1373
$ 10
.(
* " * X
-
M "
1990
" b * + ) * ) 150
` Q E 8 ' ` :8
8
) 5 f 2005
.(
' >) M " @ ' O' !A 1990
+ , ' ` :8
F ! E
40
8 ` Q R? X
) K 1381
$ 259
.(
+ $ , - %. & / , 0 ! $ 0 !
* , .
(Jon C. Pevehouse)y i
»
* J «
»
* J "
«
• P ' , .
bE " -' O8f
6 ' ,
i VJ 'A !
(See Pevehouse, 2005) .
` H
5 J * @ ) " A " "A +, 5 J @ k
* OU } € 8 k'
)
* 8k 8 1373 152
' H + - ^ .(
' , + 8
J &-
»
* J «
»
* J "
« • P
(Przeworski, 1991)
. ' +) m 3 " ' , K ) - 7'Y .
- '
, R ) † ( * I! T! . 7'Y ' +) * J Q
) H (S) TU. +, 5 J 6'
' 5 A
. 5 Of
W @ E
(1992:66)
6 , †
` H 0 X8 fz 6'
+f8 fH K' J
. X 8X
*A " @ _ fH 5 * @ ) M .
) ' "
1384
$ 188
.(
* "
OP K ) -
* J " * J * +f8 2' 3 " )
O ; O ' ! K ) - 7 ->) * @ ) 'A ! .
'VZ - ` Q F ) 2' 3 " * J 68 +f8 .
K ' [ ) ) 6'
{ ` :8 - ' , w ( * A ` :8 + ) * "
` Q @ k' 5 J K' * A .
* " 'A ! & * J ` +f) g 'V 8(E
.
* JY * 6 " & * J 6 X 8! { A "
` "
> (8f ` +f) * * X + A ' )
(Pevehouse,
2005:33)
. * " " ? X [ 8? [ , { 8 .
@ " 6'
K *A I' ) ) VJ 'A ! ` Q * "
.
bE * J " ' ,
. I z " ' 5 J
K ) - F Q K' >) )A 8 , 6- X * ' ,
) ` 5 ) > + )
(Valenzula, 1992)
. 6 - 8(E
»
* J "
« 5
[ :8 7'Y VJ
v) 8 6 '
' ga) 'V
(Przeworski, 1991)
. ` L @ E . 6'
&H . 8 F ? " '
" \A ? F H _W 8. * X'
. ) 5 " 5 J 6' ) 5 ?
' , ? , P
8 :
* Q %8H * k(:
. * X
5 J 6 ' k 7
9 H 8 ! 7 ->) 'A ! )
. - k' m 3 "
) 5 J 6' O OP * "
7 6 (
.
5 J ! %8H * k(: " Q
7 'Y * I! 8 '
5 " %8H 5 k' , ` " 8 VJ 'A ! 5 6 X J 8H .
' + *A 8' z 5 J 6' I! , ) F ?
6 -
+8 ? *A F H
. - ? -E € O. " ' . F ?
F ? + ) %8H * k(: 6- J ` O ' %8H 9 fz
K' >) *A ? W f! F H - 7'Y K' " ' .
(Pevehouse, 2005:31)
. - ^
(John Sheahan)(1986:163)* +
*
» " , ' +) "A ` :8 ^
J 8H * ' ) " Z L % -E & 68!
«.
6 '
? K' >) * ' J 8H .
7 + & ? " -' % 8H 9 fz - ? 5 a?
; O
. f , * 8f L %8H
8: ! 5 ^ 8! X
) 5 A K ) - 7'Y g 'V
)
* 8k 8 1373
$ 298
.(
O! - & H \ B ) A /P .
2 ! J
K' @ A + A K) K) _ (' O) f M v) * ' Z " 7' k 8 VJ M
K ) - 5 > X
.
" # H X *
1989 8 5 > 6' W • P A ' + A -
f' K + , * 8 +E
* 8 { -
X: F ->8 ?
. 6' w ) * A ' + A
) 6 ' ' 5 >
– (EA
–
W 3 "
m L ' )
) ' "
1384
$ 78
.(
' , [ ) ) 6'
" ' O #
8X .
bE ( 0 %8H " 7'Y 6' ^
) 'V [ A
(Pevehouse, 2005:161)
.
) b ) ) ) M S
Fa 5 a?
@ ) " b %8H - ? B ) >) ' J
) K
6' E 1383
.(
& E 6
? 7 7\
Fa }@. * A E ? J
Fa + , # < 6 8 : * ? + , ' &J ‡ (? * 8. f )
5 @ *A ? H ) b) J
. M ) % 8H 2001
"
E 6' ' * >
M A * 2002
) 2007 ` (B
'W .
'
L % ! ' b' @ ! ` 6 ' , VJ
"
! ' UH * 7 8E {) b:
) ' H 1386
.(
[ ) ) 6'
%8H 7
5 6 f) K'
b) )
(Londregan
and Poole 1990)
.
ˆ @ 6- @ b)
^ $ %: K ) - 7 ->) I 6' )
5 6 X J 8H -. " X:
(See Aguero 1995)
.
I! b ) ^
( P `
F H ? _W 8.
.
$ % :
k' 5 J m 3 " ^ )
%8H * k(:
( 2' X) .
k8 ( F {
VJ 'A ! ? b)
(See Haggard and Kaufman 1995)
. [ ) ) 6'
H M 8. k8 b) ^
' b' @! *A F .
5 J ^ 5 a?
k' )
%8H * k(: M S (
" b ) 'A " * JY L
5 6 f) " * J ) 6 ' ' * " ,
)
\"
1374
$ 63
.(
6- ` L 6'
5 J " b)
]H k'
.
* "
* J 68 +f8 2 ' 3 " ) @ " 6' OP
" ' . % 8H * k(: (8f ` +f) P? -E € O. ` {)
M € O.
A K' >) F H I *
? + .
K [ ) ) 6'
OP * " %8H
? F H & O - K ) - 7 'Y
. 6'@k' , { A "
J F H " b [ \ f! 7'Y
* k F Q :
(Pevehouse 2005:35)
"
OP * W 2' 3 " )
kX >) 6 " - ? F H '@ *
. '@ * W
5 J F H
) O I z 2' 3 " 8 * " f 6' z
7'Y " ' . + A M ?w K ) -
K' P:) ` L
E "
' R ?
E 8.
- ? B ) >) ' * "
5 J I
z .
5 J 6' F H " b '" ` ( >
F {
! ' F H " &L . " 8X F H '@
.
* "
OP
! . K 2' 3 " ) 6 ^ *A , ) b) *
F ? X z ) TU. ; &< &< "
Vk B ) b) E
. 7 + 6 ' b ) F \ 2 ' 3 " )
K' w OP Q w* "
6' ) , '
Q 8X
'A .
F ' k
Pridham) (Geoffrey
(1994:196)
X
* H
»
' k b) bO * E 6 -. 6' ) 8 5
^ ' * " K' ) *
«.
1 * " 2
M Q ) * ) ) b)
1960 1971 1980 8 VJ ,
) 6' E 1383
$ 111
.(
‰ @ ) k' b) =? ?
5 * -
Necmettin Erbakan)
E f b) @ (
k a 3
\
) " # X! IH ‰ * k 7 O8 1980
' * " [ , "
%) & H \ M ? * J ) ? .
_ ! L * " 6 ' (H )
" H 5 U8 „ 8?
.
% 8 E . 6' ) ' * J )
–
) " # 1971
-
5 K'h) 8 >8 ? 8X X! I -' A
.
5 k ! \ Š_ fH ) ' * ' 8 m 3 " *A ) b) " ' O8
(Kuniholm 1985:225)
. f ,
O! ) % 8H
2 f) )
OECD K
2 f) _ 8H @ ) R. 5 9H 8 )
(Karaosmanoglu 1991:162)
. -' A + ) )
c , ]' & E (
H )
f ,
* M Y ( ) " ) A X! )
(Kenan Evren)
& E
Q ! L )
(Dagi 1996:127)
. k' -' A >8 `W ' c , * ' " #
) b) " * ( 8X E
. ) M Y & E 6
@ 7 O8 H * - J Fa E & O
. - 0 ! 2' 3 " f
f , & E * 6
E ) $ % (
v) F @ E $ %
5 -.
.
M ) b) ) (?
1997
» 7 «
" )
) K
: ' "
1384
. (
* - b) X! B 18
6< Y 1997 Uf8
) 6' E 1383
$ 147
.(
6' _W 8.
X 6' -. " b) >) 6' A F H )
7 O8 \ 3 (
.
) -' A * - E , fz , ) b) IH
5 .
5 } { * - F @E
) 6' E 1383
$ 133
.(
8! & E + , ' &J ‡ (? * 8. f ) E ? }@. * A
* " 6 X E ? }@ . -. " + A ' . ) * J ) '
5 `W >) J 5 Q _ ! L ) b) f ) .
, & ? K' IH
({ )
@ M ( E `W >) :
' >) ' R? Q8 *
* X 5 ({ )
. (8 ) # { 2001
+
.aL ' >) f X ) [' %) * H
J"
) ' "
1384
$ 91 - 90
.(
M ) 5 a?
1999 & E + A " H ' X +! y‹ )
5 ' - X € O. ' 5 J X € O. ' ? F ?
) ' 1387
$ 112
.(
'@ *A E ? b) F H F ? 7+ & ? " -' 6' b ) F H
W I(PE ` % '
. }@ . -. 5 'A * ) - ' ' +
Q f (X *A M (H b) )A - ? f ) E ?
" *A (+ %8H " E (S - ? F ) ` L X € O.
) ' * " b , ) @ 1980
5 ! }@ . E f! I
1998
@ -. ? H b)
.
3 1 * 0
` 7X ) " # 2008
+(, L !a 8'
6 UE :
&- *A ? E +(, ! J
}@ . + * E # < : E f
UE : M ? &L ) ! X k8 ( X >) 8' ˆ @
8 ) ( @'@fE (? E > M Y
(SwissinFo.org)
. @ X " 4
' >) ' >) O' !A ' >) a # U * " 5 >8 `W '
} ?
X 6' H F Q XJ" 8 5 F -> )
(aafap.org)
. 5 a ?
2 f) 8' K ' X ! 5 >8 `W '
.
'@fE (? E > M Y { 8
L !a + , ' ` 8 @
Fa?
» X'
m U ` :8 6 ' 7 7 8 ` :8 ,
K ) -
(news.bbc)« .
6 X! b' @! ` " @ *A " # " $ % : E
' >) m 3 ' >)
O' !A
O ) - @'@fE (? E
‡ (? Œ XE E > ) 8-' !
5 F H .
* ^ X 6 ' `W >)
6 Q8 X 6' * Q Q F + " E G:X
b
E 6 $ % : /P '
8 )
(H ) +
X , X 4 " X † _ (' O) * Q (
K ) - X
J"
.
4 0
* " 'A ! * @ ) B J J & ? " ` U8 ]'
'V . & ? 6' " -' 5 &' () " 6' VJ B ?
* "
OP .
* " 6 '
-) 7 y [ \
(Complimentarity)
5 # )
+ X # ) " #
Similarity)
(
5 )
I! ) B +, R? X "
+, k' -' m
5 H
.
K ) - { 4 * @ ) 4 68! J `
F Q /, [ E \ 9 8: 23
E 8 -.
R ?
* "
OP K ) - &' ()
.
* " 6' { 8
B| ?
&' () * @ ) 'A ! 9 8: &.
.
* "
' >) * '
E ' R? * K ) - ; 8U
Iz .
b
' >) ' >) ' O' !A
` ) } ?
2008
* X 8'
- -.
5 >, " @ * " 6' K ) .
* " 6'
R ? X * @ ) Bl) ` U8 - "
R? \ 8.
. F Q * K ) - * " 6' ' R? * ; X
(X B| ? 8 -.
' R ? " b X .
" 6' +f) 5 a?
*
*A ' , K ) - 7'Y +f) 8E * @ )
W 2 ' 3 " 6 f } *A * J " * J ' >) 5 ' O)
'@ *
; X K K ) - z - ?
{ .
' >) - ? ) M (H
) " # $ % 1980
?
&' () X *A b) E ' >) (X
. 6 '
6 ' *A 7 ->) (X [, @ H X M (H - ?
X
.
OP K ) - * " ^
* ? * @ ) (X
8 K ) - ! 5 'A 9' f) m " -'
7 * +,
.
8UJ b -
* " 6' )
) B ?
* @ ) 'A !
&' () .
3.5 $ 6! &
:
8) . , :
1 . ' HA .
* "
E 6 .
* - & ` X8 .
F Ž 1383 .
2 . Y Y [fL . E 6 * " F +U ) .
1373 ( 4 ' , ) .
k ! ? ` X8 .
M Ž .
3 . z ? \"
) . 1374 ( b) .
# H X ..
4 .
&
) . 1384 ( 7'Y K ) - \ .
+UL f z ? , )
.
' ` X8
.
5 . K . ' / L )
1381 (
* " >8 & * " bO OP
c , " kX .
a + , )
L . E 6 ` fE P 8!
. M Ž .
6 .
"
' ! ' ) . 1384 ( 7 E ( E ' E D "A 5 'A .
" 6 . , ) .
• 3 ` X8 .
Ž
M .
7 .
? ? ) . 1386 (
* ' * @ ) .
5 JA ` X8 .
8 .
! ' H
) . 1386 (
"
. K ) Z' +X .
7 U 5 . ' + .
9 .
? ' ) . 1387 (
k ! I , ' '
. b h @
a # {
.
10 . z 5 "
) . 1378 ( E 6 + "
.
* @ X -
8 J X
. M Ž .
11 .
> 6' E ) .
1382 (
* J + , )
.
6 . , )
.
@
` fE P ? +X h
K'h) 8 .
12 .
&< * 8k 8 ) .
1373 (
78 5 * ' F 4
.
+ . , )
.
" ` X8 .
: .
! ; :
1 . T! . 5 f .
»
‰` :8 W ? E H E , > 6> &
«.
% R+
. 24 / 07 / 2005 .
2 .»
E 7 W
? I! ' U E 8' }aO 6' ) 5 >8
«.
6 org : . aafaq ://
.http
3 .
> . {E .
»
` :8 W ? E E H E E E m W
«.
OE • > W .
OE fE ` f E -(
.
6 com : . eastlaws . www ://
.http
4 .»
8' }aO ...
E F O W E E …! E [? 8 6
«.
6 org : . swissinfo .
www ://
.http
5 .»
8' }aO f E # { & -X)
«.
6 uk : . co . bbc . news ://
.http
6 . {' > ! ? .
» fE M E ! ` :8 W ? E E H E 3 O ' E
«.
E F f E fE { E .
@
fE 5 . E ` .
fE 18 . I 2008 . GL 26 - 9 .
7 .»
aE > ) f(8 ' 8' }aO < H
` :8
«.
6 net : . aljazeera . www ://
.http
<
.
= . :
1. Aguero, Felipe. 1995. Democratic Consolidation and the Military in Southern Europe and South America. In The Politics of Democratic Consolidation, ed. R.
Gunther, N.P. Diamandouros, and H. Puhle, 124-65. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
2. Dagi, Ihsan D. 1996. Democratic Transition in Turkey, 1980-1983: The Impact of European Diplomacy. In Middle Eastern Studies 32(2): 124-41.
3. Dodd, C.H. 1990. The Crisis of Turkish Democracy. 2nd edn. Huntington Eothen Press.
4. Haggard, S. and Kaufman, R. 1995. The Political Economy of Democratic Transitions. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
5. Hinnebusch, Raymond. Authoritarian Persistence, Democratization Theory and the Middle East: an Overview and Critique. In Democratization, 2006. Vol.13, No. 3, pp.
373-395.
6. Hinnebusch, Raymond. 2000. Liberalization without Democratization in Post- Populist Authoritarian States. In Niles Bulenschon, Davis, Uri and Hassassin, Manuel.
Citizenship and State in the Middle East. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press, pp.
123-45.
7. Hyde-Price, Adrian G.V. 1994. Democratization in Eastern Europe: The External Dimention. In Democratization in Eastern Europe: Domestic and International Perspectives, ed. G. Pridham and T. Vanhanen, 220-54. London: Routledge.
8. Karaosmanoglu, Ali L. 1991. The International Context Of Democratic Transition in Turkey. In Encouraging Democracy: The International Context of Regime Transition in Southern Europe, ed. G. Pridham, 159-74. New York: St. Martins Press.
9. Kassem, Maye. 1999. In the Guise of Democracy: Governance in Contemporary Egypt. Reading, Hampshire, UK: Ithaka Press.
10. Klebes, Heinrich. 1999. The Quest for Democratic Security: The Rule of the Council of Europe and U.S. Foreign Policy. Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace.
11. Kuniholm, Bruce R. 1985. Turkey and NATO. In NATO and the Mediterranean, ed. L. Kaplan, R. Klawson, and R. Luraghi,215-37. Wilmington: Scholarly Resources, Inc.
12. Londregan, John B. and Keith T. Poole. 1990. Poverty, the Coup Trap, and the Seizure of Executive Power. In World Politics 42: pp. 151-83.
13. Mainwaring, Scott. 1992. Transitions to Democracy and Democratic Consolidation: Theoretical and Comparative Issues. In Issues in Democratic Consolidation, ed. S. Mainwaring, G. D`Donnell, And A. Valenzula, 294-342. South Bend, IN: University of Norte Dame Press.
14. D`Donnell, G., Schmitter, P. C., and Whitehead. 1986. Transitions from Authoritarian Rule: Latin America. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
15. Pevehouse, Jon C. 2005. Democracy from Above: Regional Organizations and Democratization. Cambridge University Press.
16. Pridham, Geoffrey. 1994. The International Dimension of Democratization:
Theory, Practice, and Inter-regional Comparisons. In Building Democracy? The International Dimension of Democratization in Eastern Europe, ed. G. Pridham, E.
Herring, and G. Sanford, 7-31. New York: St. Martins Press.
17. Przeworski, Adman. 1991. Democracy and the Market. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
18. Sheahan, John. 1986. Economic Policies and the Prospect for Successful Transition from Authoritarian Rule: Comparative Perspectives. ed. G. ODonnell, P.C.
Schmitter, and L. Whitehead, 154-64. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
19. Valenzula, J. Samuel. 1992. Democratic Consolidation in Post-Transitional Settings: Nation, Process, and Facilitating Conditions. In Issues in Democratic Consolidation, ed. S. Mainwaring, G. D`Donnell, and A. Valenzula, 57-104. South Bend, IN: University of Notre Dame Press.
# 1 / D "E 1%F )G 0 9 3 H% D% F :
"
/ CD5(< E =+CF $ G0(C?$ HI :+ 0 90 ' (J-;K =F ($
"
CF , 76
% ;C' , 36
"M 9 C< (N<0
&?* H- G 5 F 0& > OPF
"
F , 82
% ;' , 59
"M G0(C 0 Q C$ ()C$ R I G : :; O 1 )
C>
50
= 7F0 S7 10 95E(:>
( F 60 G * $ , 82
"M 0( 0 = 7F0 9 T;U =U V F :F G
W+U G0 E )<
F )
=< 41 $ F :F / 0 = >E 0 P U % 4 U $
"( F 85
% ;' , 73
"I
= C>E 0 C ? 0 % C4 U
=D&15 F % E G0( 0 = 7F0 9 T;U =U V F :F
"
,
% E 37
% ;' , 3 , F 86
"M (C 50&C10 X)CY
G&' =1 TU ( K
"
,
% E 38
% ;' , 2 F , 87
"M
* ' a + , , k 5"
& ' M (H
"
.H
% E 39
% ;' , 1 F , 88 .
