34 5 "6 7 8 98
& 3:; <
7 8 98 =3'> = 5 "6
& 3:; <
) :
13 / 9 / –87 :
3 / 12 / 87 (
? : A B <C D % C B 3 E = B
F # E38 "'D G:
. 9F8
7 8 8 I 5 "6 B % J E K
1990 M' N O & > ; A
C B F# P3FQ
. 3':8 8 8 C C B > 7C 6 7C . A R3<
C B , 3F8 =3 S ; ?
6 7 8 98 7C 8 = B 5 "6
. FB C B "B 8 N,8 '8 T 7C 8
=3T =3T 3 N O 3 E
8 7 8 98 &U 5 "6
GC% 3V .
8 C B :- WX
3Y 3T J E K
&U 8 N,8 ZC Y G # >
GC% [\
.
6 38 C B + 3 S ; 8 '8 ]\8
WXF F " XC F "> + Y = B
6 38 &U = B + 3 S ;
^E 3 8 = B
GC% 3V
; 3 <? C B G B &
6 A ,; 8 7 8 98 7C 8 = B
8 98 I 5 "6 7
% & 8 5 "6 =3 F8 ] % =
# .
= > & 4_
: C B -
%
= <
- – + Y
"> –
" XC – - –3 8
^E - '#
98 7 8 5 "6
* :
66409595 Email: [email protected]
!"# $ %
&
'(
) *+
&,-. / 0 123 4 5 ) ! 6%
.
:
1990 !" #$ %& ' ( )* +
#, #' ) .
./ ( 012
1980
*, + 3415 6 0'78 6+ 69 :6;$< =6 8 6> )? 6@$8 #6 #8 3
A11'
" 46 69 )B 6C 1@ " # ' D4, + E 3 3 6 F"465
(
» 6>
(self) «
"
» 34
(other) «
) I /
" 0J K1 " # 49 C 6I / 3 I 79 "
67 6+ ) 6<+
4L 8 %? + M >
. ( 42 0'78 + F#, )$ ? + )? @$8 3
) F (41 + # 4 7+
1379
.(
F( 6& . #7@ 6 # N #6 6+ 6 0 465 6+ )? 6@$8 O 6;? :6;$< 3 66
" 66
1 EP? . 5 5 3 3
# . % ' A + F#7 K
.
C " Q4$R5 M#,
. 7? 9 ) #7 4 S1@
» ) I8 .#, « )
#6, %? + K1 T1U 7,
4 ) U ( " 415 *, . I8 4U 4U ) I8 " V W* )$ X U Y (
*6, 6X1$ " )6; " ) 6I8 3 #67 4 . 61 ZP 6C D46[ 6+ , 4+ A 34615
)'194 3
(hybrid)
) I8
;
(glocal) ) 6, F#1 69 0\ V +
) . R6 4+ 6+ #6 4 7+
1380
.(
R62 #619 M) 6U 7, > " #6X F 6+ K #15 ) $ / % + . #6
46+ 6
» Z" 6B
« M
F \ , ( )7*, )]; ^ 1& + 8 " M)$1R78 3
1 E " ) 45 6 ) 45
( ) 6
1U ZP C _ ` A$ 1@
)? @$8 )U U 41> 3
) K671*78 1381 :
11
.(
M3K694 3 16U/ M. *\ + 3 # " + K1 " ./ ( a2 " 3" , ), 2"4 #7 4 " J 4 M 1 " >
...
A1+ b+ " 3 @;? ( )>4+ c > 8 6 45 46E ;@\
.
Id Q $e " O I+ M 5#7V 3
."K6 (" 06J M 69 A1+ )$ 3 (4
, 4+ " Z 9 3
T1@ . 17+
3415 A1+ ( M 6 A16+ )$76U #6 12 A$6
\" " )U 1U A$ 45 Nf M ;
46U " #6 #8 )C@8 3 ( A 6 ! *6, . "/46+
U 1U g4? 4+ )7$' >
(politics of identity)
6 ) @ 46+ 6 41h 6 4
A1+ # #8 . K5 9 " #7 4 M I M $> U U );;@\
.
079 4 i4[ (
. 45
" MZP C 3 7' 4+ *;+ M3 3 $> U j U 4+ K1 Q( M X7 M
Mk7 4 M
F " )\ g 3 " + M3l \ m#
) *, 7 I 3 415
) 1 F (4 1384 : 9
./ o 69 (
) ) 7C ) ' + 8 OK;$R ( U
. A 4+ 7+
M )U U ) J ( ) 7C ); ? . 7? +
A1+ 4 A * )$R 2 3 #& " " );;@\
)6 6>4+ ./ )$> 7, 6,
. M=6E "
)$R 4$R+
A1+ b+ " 9 U 45 7C )U 7, 1@ ;@\
) #12
#79 .
pq @C 9 U )\ & A ) $B5
6 4L );6g . 48 ,
b6+ " 3( 462
A1+
)+ ;@\
U $ 45 4E )I8
Lapid 2001: 15)
.(
% + ( )>4+ 9 3 8" + 3
=E "
Y1UP9 " Y1UP9 . 45 )
1U + . *, 3l \ m# 1@ + 8 #7 6U
% + )8 >
\" + r +4 3 )+PJ 3
(
) + # 4 7+
:
$75 1372
%6& ' ( )>4+ K1 "(
TR1\ 4'1\ " TR1\ 4'1\ F#, D4s )
6 );;@\ A1+ 3 I@ l #? E " X7 0J #7
F 0J
)8 > U 1U (
) 6+ # 4 7+
Keohane 1984 : Glodstein and Keohane 1993 t
"(
=E " Z , ( )>4+ )$&
) 45 ) C 8 #7 a$6\ " 679 %6& ' 34 u62
(
) 6+ #6 4 7+
:
Waltz 1979
A1+ b+ " v1` ) J T ) 7C ? 9 U ./ ( )9 & (
46L7 ( ;@\
4L A v 4g 3#1;9 0J ? A M# . 45 4>
)6@ #612 #6779
#67V4 6
) 3 9 49 ? . $+ # , )I$7 + % + . 4+ + .
6X1$ A6 + ./ )Js7 1\
4L A 9 #1U
#779 ( + ) 8 )$ )$& " ) 7C ? 3 4+ # + O48q K1 .
0 "w2 6 4L x41> 3
6U O 6IB A6 6+ Fw6 " 6 7? 4 6 . ( 462 .
6\ J
s+ . 412 9 49
» 079 " M
«
Kratochwil 2006: 16)
" u541h y $9 M(
A1+ U 1U )$ " )? @$8 ? 0J
;@\
) 6 "
1384
)65 Z 6J1J M(
O IB "
» ) #68 34 u62 «
separability)
"(
» K 6@
« differentiation)
O 6IB M(
» ) $R6+
«
boundedness)
Y71\ " # K (
Y61*B 6+ z 6+ )8 > U 1U ( '@9 # , 4+ M4$1\
3#7+(4 /
6V W* ( . 6 K@18 #J MFl U ( ) 6 1+ S6 4[ ( )6]; 6 3 6
. 4
alienation of others)
. 412 4*\/ " "412 , % + M(
» 3 6 (4 " o4 $ 3
411{ ! &
«
Lapid 2001: 10-11)
49 " y ;@& "( (1993)
." A * + /
b6+ " ."461+
A1+
;@\
7? J$ "
F# ( )71|;+ " } O IB A$ 45
» Z" B «
difference)
b+ " 4L (
A1+
;@\
Inayatullah and Blaney 2004)
1CE " A 4 ) @ (
346L 4 %6& ' 9 # "
+ 34L
# 4E ./ . 412 %& ' " O IB 41h ."K (" [ .
A1+ b+ " O U F4d 7 + 9 ;@\
. 46 + $6, 3 61& 6+ 4X7 )>4+ T?(
b6+ " F (
A1+
;@\
1980 F#,
Guillaume 2003: 3)
I8 M(
) 6;@8 ( ) 67C 6 ? 6+ Fw6 "
F#, k7 4 "
U . 6> y $9 #1W\ " 9 49 9 3 u541h Zq J 65( +
A1+ b+ " 4L " k7 4 +
;@\
=@8 F 469 4 6$7 " 3 "/
@I6U #6 ) F#6@?
) . " U $, O U F4d 7 F( 6 346L F( & A + " " ( . 5#7R )CU 9 #
F 5
sJ " )R 45 X MF#, A1+ b+ " 34L :s?
" " " 4U k78 . " x ;@\
A1+ b+ " + U F + )$ " ) 7 4 %& ' F4X72 ( A ;@\
. TI Zq U ( )*
\" / 9 U A # #8 %& ' A A1+ O L );g . K5 9 . 7? +
6 ( ;@\
012 ( = 7 "
A11C ./ F#,
9 5
69 A6 6 #6 >4+ #6 #J$C ./ + );g . 48
)6 c 6> = 67 " 6 3 46 . 4 679 6+ 6' 8#7V C 4$R+
# 6, . 6V45
F( U A + ) @ )\" # :;$< ~ J, > ." K1 . # R2 " . # ( T? .
=E " F 5#
! 4'1\ " . 45 :\ <
9 #
\" = 7 "
012 ( A16C 6U 6$
Stein 2005: 303)
=E " F 5# iP>4+ 4 Z '? + .(
\" 0J 3 K5 9 9 ) 45
41e $> U ! Z • M)<
012 ( "
A1+ O L €#J ) ;@\
F( U M#
.
" # 12 ( T
! €1U )5#17
\" 3 K5 9 " M
) ' g
#779
Kratochwil )
2006: 15
k7 4 M); C 3#7 /4 9(
6\" 6 8 6+ )$> U4+ 4U 4U " . 17+
" 6
A1+ O L ./ iP> 4+ ;@\
6U F#1 9 4 + > )`4? Q4•+ );g . 48 9 5
) O E
# <+
. ( U 34L @ R =E "
F 6 42 3#67 /4 " )< 3# m M3
A1+ 1CE " $> U4+ 1 + )\ [ ),4•+
)6@$& " )< 6 41e F + J );;@\
_ 6E \
A1+ O L F4*12 Y1 5 " )\ *\ $> U + )`4? ),4•+ 42 );g . 48 U ;@\
.
. 545 " E M $> U4+ 1 A1@
4 u62 6
" 6 9 49 461'C 6+ 69 6U
)*U" \( 9
(Koslowski and Kratochwil 1995)
. 6*
» 6U 1U A 617+ ! 6 " 4611{
A1+
;@\
« ) T 4 " 1R678 M u6 M 1 E z # #8 )$ =+ 7 " #79 ...
6+ 69
)+4e O IB b;R
» 3# "4I, «
\" y V V 6+ ;
)6, 4 6U F#6, F 4W6U
#6
) g4? + #X
"/
Mansbach 2002:105)
.(
. 545 3"41 . 67? 6+ 6I7 6 ( U
./ ),4 . 17+ )? . 7? + *;+ O IB Y 6\ J ( 3 1R6+ 69 R #7@ #E #E
M 6
A1+ b+ " 4L 3 ) 7C 3 $> U " Z ? ` 6L " # 69 0\ V + ;@\
O
F# #2 A11' " :1g 3 4+ # #8 ) IB A1+ 3
( # );;@\
.
6 Q46 Zq \# " O IB )\ @8 )U 4+ ( a2 \ J A 41h 6 M 6
F F( & 4+
A1+ b+ " )U 1U 3 " 61@9 & M 617 MZ #E ;@8 ( ;@\
F( & " )U @;W
" 3 X7 3 A1+ b+
)6U 4+ 6 4 6+ ~ 6J& " ~P> ;@8 ( ;@\
) 4E T1
.
F U )BR; ) 1+ + K1V 4 )$R1V ( U Z '? ./ : 4C A 4
» 4
./ + 3K1V 9 ‚ / ) #' M R 9 V
#79 .«
S1f )B 4C 9 U ./ 4+ "
4
C A ( X1$ " U O(q =U : 4
» 1 4 79 )$1g >
#7 « )
#
9
» 3 $ " ),K1 ZP @ #8 «
U . A 4+ 7+
M
> ( 4 79 TI
» . @ + 4 79 M. 4 79 4 U / 9 U A + $R+ " ;e TI A 3 7C
) ) @ ( + *, 779
#
« )7 • 71+ #C+ 4 A "
(intersubjective)
)7C t U
, 4+
" 41hƒ ./ 3 7C ( > , 4+ 4+ F"P? K1 . 4 3
» ) O E I$ + " 4 ) "41+ " ) " 3 $> U
#7 <+
«
)
"
1384 : 326 - 325
.(
Z •41e 3# ( )9 & : 4C A 454 841e
(non-essentialist)
+ 'R
U . , 4+
Z • 3 )$ #8 " MK1V 4 9 U A 4+ ‡4
? @X U 34 8
) F ˆ1< 9 Z 1g > ( + h 3
3 7' " ,
) 4E )$
E " 3 4+ . 4 K1 " > 3 4+ 4 79 9 415
#7$R m .
)$, 4+
) $> U4+ 9 U A 4+ #19ƒ 454 841e ,
) + # 4 7+
Hall 1996 :
.(
U Y (
? @X A 9 8" , 4+ A . @$B5
) k7 4 M#? E M4 341'C +
8 ) 7C $> U (
+ 9 #7$R ) O E . 4 79 3
7 <+
# . M4L7 A (
);g $R Y 8" 4+ )7$' " + h 34
»
>
« . ( ! [ 411{ ."#+ 9 R1
F " U A*@ 9 #7V 4 t 45 *,/
, 1'z 01+ " T9 ) .
)>4+ 4L +
)
#7
"
1384
3 I " I / . 1 3 8 #? E M. 4 79 . 1 ZP C ,4U 45 (
8
T1L7 ) I$ M X 341 @ V ) 545 . ( ! [ I / b+ " F#779
" T9 #7
#7 @+ 84+ 2 01+
.
)>4+ M + J )
. 45 $> U R2 Fw " + (
./4+
U U 9 #
p
M $<1R5 01+ " T9
F 2 341'C + )$& " M41{$
(fragmented) F 2
‰1 t U
& " F 5
*;+ R1 V W* " #
" U 4z*$
»
‡4?
. @$B5
" M 1CE " M M f$ " > #$ F 5 " MZ" B$ 3
) $> U4+
, .«
4L7 A (
» ) r +4 ;ŠR A +
=+ 7 ( V 9 # ,
) F B$U . + " .#, #7 4 k7 4 " . +( M ,
....
4+ 7+
A ."
) @ ( +
(representation)
) #12 O E ./ ( ‹ > " #779
...
g & I /
"
(narrativization) 3( U "K\ ,4U M#7$R > (
p
‰1 + #7 4 A ) $> U
R1 ./ )U 1U 3 M) @$B5 3 u541hƒ ) 8"
(Hall 1996: 4) « .
3 U (
) 8 ;ŠR A + M4
+ ZP C ( 3#7 4 . 4 79 9 ,
)7C j U 4+ 34 " > M4 #*
079 3 4+ 9 3 m E 34 " > 3
) ) 4+ # , ) : 4C . 4 34 + 'R > " # ( U
+ > 'R " #779
) ˆ< I /
# ( U
) + # 4 7+
Wendt 1992 : .(
" A M] 9
(practices)
) @$B5 ( T? 6 /
+ 9 #7$R 6 ./ 41e ) P9
) O E ) #1\ ( + I / M#7 <+
) ! V " #779
# ( U . )? @$8 > U A 4+ 7+
" M U " + # 12 + 9 )g > ) 7 4 3
K5 9 "
3
(agencies)
) *,
(Biersteker and Weber 1996: 12)#7 .
. 1 ) (4 + .#, m E OK;$R ./ " 4 79 Y A *
»
>
«
"
» 34 «
a2 U
Z" B OK;$R 3 '$? +
#7$R . Z" B 9 U A 4+ ‡4 3 7'
) 4E 34 K1 " > A$> U
# 415 . a2
» 34 « U Z" B$ : 4C + 7+
. 45
| )7C M , $> U4+ 3 E );*, + Z" B
»
>
« + $R+ "
» 34 « M! & A1? "
U " + Z" B$
. M \ & A Z" B g &
#7$R . M + J
, 4+
) #19ƒ A 4+ K1 ) K1 ./ 3 7C " Z" B 9 ,
Y > #7
U $> U4+
. A
» 34 « Z" B A " 8" !" ; " 9 U '78 9 #7$R1
O E U Z #E ! > Z" B *;+ # )7 * 0<+
. Z" B 45 " )<
! $ 34 " > s+ M#7, + F#, $> U4+
! 1U " 4 ) 4
49 .
(Grossberg 1996: 93-96)
. ) 4L +
" , 4+ #U
(1992)
A K1
» 34 «
9 U
. 7? + 9 U >4+ " ZP C # " " 8" !" ; "
» 34 « 9
) MZ" B$ ) 8 + #
» Z" B$
«
! 1U X1$ " )< K1 " Z" B Z 8 " #, +
> U4+ M#, + ) $
, .
A1+ b+ " . 4 79 9 B5 . $+ # ,
" Z" B ( , 4+ " A #7 K1 ;@\
( 3 E )$, 4+ j U 4+ )* t#7 *, 34 " > + *, " + U A*@ M : 4C X1$ " Z" B
» 34 « )$, 4+ j U 4+ 34 " M f " Z" B j U 4+
" ( 3 E 8
» 34 « + ./ Z" B .#1X7U X1$ "
»
>
«
#C+ ; "
. 4 + 45
, 4+ A ( O #9 O E " (
O E " )+
" M + ./ s+ " Z" B M./ ) <+
)5 +4 0J
(otherness)
A1+ b+ " + S T 4 7+ ;@\
9 T1 > )7 3
B Zq ) I ) I / + P • 9 3 ) MT ( 42
# I / ( ) <+ . .
) V F 5
A * 4+ 1* +
. @$B5 A1+ b+ " );g 3
41hƒ F 5 M U 4L # ;@\
T V X F 5 " M I / + .#1 <+ # #8 3 7C T1 B + . *,
9 A ) ( #
) 7 5 @C )>4+ # A1+ b+ "
# ( U TI + E ;@\
.
@ + ( )
) %& ' A T ( 42
.
U" K @ j U 4+ 1@, ! 9 41'C + U 1U 45 /
Z #E " A@,
T1@
) 7z$U 4 F + 3415
(the exceptional)
) T179 : 4C F 41h T1
A1+ )U 1U );g F( & IV )U @;W " M 17 M 1@9 & MZ #E )7C );;@\
T1 4E )U 4+
. ) . 0<+ A
) V 9 T1
Fw " 9 #
\" 3
1\ B$U" 3 7C )U 1U 4 i]4C T1 B " )];
./ ) K1 " #79 ! " 411{ Q <$U
F V
) + T1 B A ( # #8 )$, 4+
# .
O IB *, " + R< ; " Z #E M)? @$8 O ;? Z 1+ q @C ) 3#7+
, .
Y . 7? + )*
» 1g >
«
3#7@ ? @X )7C
" 4 79 Y 3 . 7? + 34
Y
» s+
«.
. V ) Iz +
» ); Z #E «
)
$75 Pz 1372
( . 7? + Z #E
) 4E 4L # 1g >
415 .
! Z4+
(1991)
: 4C
» s+
3
« Z #E M >
)
$'\
• B M" j E (
. 7? +
» 3 9 O X + y 4 ( + A$, " :\ 4 ( + ) 9
)@ O X Z g A 41e «
) : 4C
#79 .
! "" " +
Barnett and Duvall 2005) (
. 7? + ./
»
> , 4U " b 4, A11C . 4 ( + 3#7@ 4+ 3 u541h «
: 4C
)
#779 . ) 4L + R< F 9 3 8" + s+ #U
! @? " 3#7@ . 1 T1J$R 3
3#7@ 9 U F#, $ 4 u2 @? " + A . 79 M 8" Z #E )
F iP>4+
=E "
K$\ " . V ) 45
(1979)
R1 Z #E s+ Y + #' + E "K\ (
.
O IB j U 4+ V45
» O4 Z #E «
3 i( 8
Nye 2004)
3 "#& ? (
) 4E 8 U 4+ M 415
@? 4+ ( " 4+ 3 *$U 41hƒ , 4+ A j
) ‡4 T1J$R " U 4U €#& ( 01+
, . F U F A ! *,|
3( U 9 U A F#,
)@
#7 /4 ); C " );+ J Ss7 # " k7 4 " #79 o )$U + 3( U
y V V )]; $R+ 3
" + 4> ) 45 Z • 3 $> U
" 7C ) #@
) O IB
#79 . 9 F#? J\ )]; 4 . ( U 0 #12 R1 E F 5# A M @ . 7? +
)@ @? 3 9 ‰1 = 7 y V V
#79 A11' #79
) Z #E " s+ . 412 #1B )z + 3 4+
+ # 4 7+ I8 . @$B5 Murshed 2003 :
.(
./ MZ #E ( > F#1‚12 , 4+ ! "" " + ); C Z #E +
» 4+ Z #E
«
power over)
)7 * Z #E " (
» + Z #E «
power to)
) T1RJ (
#779 . )7 * Z #E
) 4R1 . 4 79 )? @$8 A * S 4[ ( . 4 4+ 3 u541h ,
.
=E "
M
19 )7 * Z #E 7 K5 " )? @$8 . 4 ( + )$R1V " )$R
ˆ< I / 3 4+ A*@ 3
)
#79 . A$> U4+ Z #E M)7 * Z #E A 4+ 7+
4L i # + S+ s . 4 3
U
Barnett and Duvall 2005: 42-6)
.(
./
M3 I M3 $> U Z #E + Z #E A17‚@
) T1RJ #]\ " 3 '8 779
# . Fl U A * 3 7C + #]\ Z #E S 4[ ( )? @$8 3
» O L
> 7, 3 «
systems of knowledge)
"(
»
"
) @$B5 3 «
discursive practices)
U (
.
+ # 12 #]\ Z #E =E "
. @$B5 O L " )? @$8 3 #7 /4 M
M#1\ + )$ 4C 3
) 7C ) 545 " 1'z 2
# ( 4 . ) v1` #]\ Z #E 4 Z '? + 9 #
. @$B5
"
A1+ b+ " 3 I + )g > . 4 ( + V ;@\
8"
) # "/
Barnett and Duvall 2005: )
(55-6
.
) F# 9 5 . @
A Z #E s+ " 3#7@ + 8 8" + M ,
! ( @1J$R ) " M , 4+
)@ 4+ 4U )\"
*, " "/
'78 ( "K\ Z #E s+ 3415 3
F
(voluntarist) 45 R1
.
A 4+ 7+
M ) + Z #E \ J F + % + O IB A$ 454L B5 . 5
3
) 9 F + F# #2 0 #12 ( .
O + 3
» Z #E ) <+
«
identification power) (
4+ O ) I8 g4?
.
> M4@$R 3#7 4 )]; 4 " )]; "4 M)]; . 4 79 9 7C A +
) 4+ > + s+ 34 " 34 + s+
# ( U . 079 A 45 . 1 A . 45
#7 $+
O L vsU o4$ 01+ " T9 )$, 4+ + 34 " > + ) <+
+ A1 ) m 34 " > ( 9 )$, 4+ K1 . 4 )7C #779 #' ;@\
T1IU #779
./ M# ( U , u5 #7 > 41hƒ K1 . 4 3 $ " = 7 4+ F 5
.
U # 12 ./ + 1@9 & );> " )8 > #C+ "
. + 1@9 & )8 > #C+
9 U 7C A 079
A1+ O L | 8 x. 45 ) . ?• # #8 | 1@9 & 8" + ;@\
" #779
./ 4 Z '? +
» ) U 7, « ) 4E
#7 . + \" Y | 1@9 & ) U 7, M=E "
m E )$\" 3 7C U ./ 3 4+ .#,
. ) U 7, " X1$ . 7? + 1@9 & a2
F#? E Y )8 >
) *, )$\" + )7C U A 4 /
# .
A ( . + >4+ M! & A1?
»
@9 &
« K1 ) L$ " :1\ * M~ J&
) X
#79 . TI ~ J& + O 4$& ( 3 >4+ M)$\" A$, ( ), S& A 4
U \" 8 S& " )71 (4U
)
" M + # 4 7+
1384 : 407
#C+ +
.(
)7$' Z L$ " :1\ *
F#, ! $ . ( ! [ " #7$R c > )< b 4, =+ 0J A 4+
( )9 & A " #
U ./ . + 34 841e " ) $R O#?
.
" 4+ T9 & 3 X7 411{
) U 7,
\"
Y1 49 3 I 8" A1 (4U 4+ )* K1 b;R 1@ ( ~ J& ? "
. 4 + ! [ )71C " #& " ) 1;@? 3 7C )8 > 1@9 & 9 U 1CE " A 45
71 ( + " $, # . * " . (
#7 . 49
contexualization)
" (
. 49 #7
historicization) (
) 4$I+ MO IB A )R 45 .
./ ) 7C 3 )U 4+
) 9 F #1B " B \ J + #17
Biersteker 2005
.(
Z L$ " :1\ * 9 U @9 & O IB 411{ + M4 . 1+ +
\" ( ) 411{ T9 & 3
#+
.
3 7C + 1@9 & );> #C+
» c > 3"4@;E + 'R ) e #$E 8"
« U
(Biersteker and Weber 1996: 2)
.
#C•+ A 34 )$ 3" ? 0\ V + P@? 1@9 & (
U F#, "4+"
. 4& " u M J'[ M 1R78 M w z # #8 )$ =+ 7 F("4 9 4V
F 49 Id + + E ! & 9 #
. # \"
(Mansbach and Wilmer 2001: 56; #
Mansbach 2002: 103-7)
.
! *, A V45 A 4+ 7+
." 4+ a 49 4L + # #8 )$
2001:134)
»(
3 4+ €@* 0J 4g )71 (4U 3
« ) 3( +
\" ! &4 + #779
g4? 8 ( :? f 9 )];
F( & 3 u5 " 3 4+ )8 > " );> 3 3
# 4L + 9 U $ 45 012 3# #8 )$ U 1U 4E > • B i
) 461 :
1386
»(
F"45 Y 7C #1\ 3 4+ O(q |Z #E 4+ !4$79 R9 4U 4+ 4@$R 0*@ 9 )?
U )? @$8
«.
4 1@9 & " A 4+ 7+
P 9 " # )$> U4+ )$1 "
T
F#17 + t#
5 F( & ) #12 + 4X7 9 3 3 7C 9 U F#, # #8 • B 3
| 1@9 &
U F 411{ )]; \"
.
U A 1@ 1@9 & " . 1 # 12 F + % + 9 34 TI $*
\" + )71 (4U \" A$R i 4$ " 1@9 & j U 4+ . # \" : 4C 9 -
;
R K1 )]; A$ 45 *, 3 7C + .
p U U A
."4+ )$1 u5
"
Z" B .
9 U @9 & \" +
» 3 >
«
"
» 34 «
> A1 (4U )U U 4+
‹ > "
(Walker 1993)
) : 4C )J; 1+ #, + )]; 3 (4 3 " a9 4 " ,
) 45 .
\" 9 U O IB A1@ + 4 U _ ' " > _ ' F " 17 + 'R
\"
) #12 :1;* " 1\ ŠR 3 7' )]; 3# "4I, " #779
) 4E ) <+
" 415
) I8 1 R
) + # 4 7+
Linklater 1998 :
.(
49 " 41'C +
(1993)
*, " 1@9 & . @$B5 +
A$ 45 9 A ( . # D4, 9 U T9 & 3
»
« 4 )$ 3" ? T1$R 9
& + ) 1, y 7$8 M > " #
) )J; 4 u2 " . @$B5 A > * / ! & 45
F# #2
#7$R )< ) .
!
1;J , 4+
4L Π45 " 4s> ( 1 3 7C + 17 M);g . 48 . ( 42
\" )* K1 Z 1& 8 $ |# #I U
. F( U IB .
K1 F 5 " )71? # #I O
\" + 17 O IB A$> U "#
\" " )71? )$, 4+ ./ =' + "
(statist)
(
) U 17
#7 .
\" ) sU
# #I ( )7 • , 4+ + % + )$E" M
(threat perception)
"
) $> U4+
(constructedness)
) 17 O48q M#U
: 4C 4+ 34 " >
»
>
« (
) 4h )7 17 u5
.
a j
- ) A2 9
# 5 :
» ( $U >4+ M# #I ( , 4+
A1+ O L Z #E )71? $> U Q( 3" ( . 4 ( + *;+ M R1 );;@\
3 X7 "
3 94, + 9 M);> 3 #7 /4 4+ T9 &
O L . , A1+
) *, );;@\
$ #7 <+
) r '7$U I / )8 >
#779 «
) O . K ( J + 1386
: 736 + # 4 7+ A17‚@ t Wendt 1992
.(
=E "
+ X7
\" )7 " 17 ./ 0J " + J$ ) <+
) 8 , .
\" vsU A1@
4B178 M4 34L7 ( .K$1
(Mitzen 2006)
(
» 17
3 8"
«
ontological security)
) : 4C j U 4+ 9(
) ' g M ,
A*@ 9 #79
\" )* K1 17 + f U
\" U A*@ 9 7C A + t 415 4E 3 4+
A1+ O L 3 K5 9 j R& " . 4 " > ( : 4C O" #
;@\
> )* K1 17 M
1'z : 4C S 4[ A ( # "4+ . 4 + ?( 7 ! 'J$U + " $> # 4s> + F#,
( 3
U"
/
> " A@, /
)$ 3 (4 A D `" " 1 B, ( " # "/ U + 34
#779 0 / " . 71@[ j R&
. + U A*@ 3 8" " )* K1 17 F 5# A
U F#, F . 4 ( @ 9 #779 #12 j *C s+ 4 #*
:
A 4+ 7+
M F( U F 5# A j U 4+
F( U O" # " •B& 9 4 u2 # +
)$ 3
TI ( )*
e#e A 4 U )C@8 " 3 4 vsU 34 + 3
./ RR5 C'[ "
) . R )* K1 " ) " 17 " F#, )J; )$ Z # #I + z + # +
( # 4s>
.
) A17‚@ 1; A
5 €@C );*, + V 9 # . #
(paradoxical)
"
=E " 3 ? iP>4+
17 . 45
\" x) 8 M)* K1 vsU
U A*@ I /
#7 4E 4s> ‡4C > 3 8" 17 •B& F 17 A .
)* K1 17
17 3 8"
\" " 4 )$ 3 8" Z 1& F("4 9 49 . ?• # + 8 . 7V (
) TI
17 " v;g . 412 % + M49 " y . 1+ + 9 U F#, >4+ 17 : 4C )@
8 # )U U 3 ? ( 3 #
*7 ) ? t#, + ) R 4
) V MT1$R 9 ) T1, + # + 9 ) 8 + T1$R 9 ) 8 ( V " T1, + T1 >
T1U
Ruiz 2002: 342)
.(
Ž3K1V V ( 17 )7C )$17 %& ' !" #$ Zq U 79 =E "
1U" + 17
\ E 9 )\ U MŽ3 K+ V + 17 " Ž)R9 V ;
» )? @$8 17 «
societal security)
" )\" 4L ( (Ole Waever)
) D4[ . *
! U M#+
» 3 4+ 17
Ž)R9 V
«
:;$< _ 9 U
" )$1R78 ;@8 ( " )$\" 41e 3
) )$17 %& ' #79
Hoogensen and Rottem 2004: 155-6) .(
+ 17 MF 5# A Z g
j U 4+ 34 + 4 vsU " \" ( ‹ > )+ X : 4C I / )? @$8 3
) , .
\" 17 7C A + . R "
s+ 4 #@ + 3 8" " )* K1 17 K1 "
@ " 9 # T1J$R
F#, F . •
# :
A 4+ 7+
M : " 41'C +
2003: xvi)
» (
RV4+
)$ 3
«
identity labels)
( (
3#7+(4 T1J$R \ > S 4[
*, M)$ 3 S;> " M# #I ( . K5 9 o + .
17 M#7$R A 4 /# #I . 4 4L ( 9 )
\"
. R "
4E 41h
)
# . .#@ >4+ 4L 4L #19ƒ ( 3 @
4+ " k7 4 \ J 41h 4+ . ( 42
+ 17
) @,
# /
)
O . K
1386 : 737
.(
4 M)C@8 " 3 4 + ( 1 =E "
) "
A1+
»
«
"
» I / « K @ 3 > (4 j U 4+ # #I ( > o " F#, m E /
41e
#7 . U 3 >
) . " A11' 3 4+
A1+ ?( 7 ( )$> 7, + # 4 7+ :\ < Z 4L " # #I o " );;@\
:
Stein 2005; Shannon 2007; Gartzke and Skrede 2006; Rousseau and Garcia- Retamero 2007
.(
MF"P? +
\"
)$17 #7 4 S 4[ (
(securitization)3( U
\" 9 U
4 3
) 4+ A@, # #I @ V4U . 7? + + )7C t# ( U
. 7? + I / + ) <+
» 34
)* K1 17
\" 17
"
. R \" 17
)? @$8 17
"
I R 17
17 3 8"
o 4s>
«
" ( ‹ > " c > Z #E ) O(q F4 (" 3
1CE " #7 @ 3
» ) 7z$U « : 4C )
#779
) + # 4 7+
Huyzmans 2008 :
.(
" #
A1+ . 4 ( + A1+ r ' #7 /4 ./ )U @;W ( O U4 : 4C ( K1 42 3 4+ );;@\
) k78 #
)
"
1383 : 715
.(
+ z + )U @;W M# #8 : C
» U ) R )$1C`"
\" R ( +4X ( 9 3
) 4 4 1@9 & 3
"
« K@18 41'C + "
» O L
A1+ C 8 )[ ' );;@\
« U . )$\" . K5 9 + "# )U @;W M# #8 : C A
) " R1 9 ) 8 4 #
» ) F# " # 8" )$ 3 (4
# , « 8"
#, + $, .
) 3 I )U @;W AU 8
#
3 0J 9
» C 8 )? @$8 #1\ ( +
\"
« A1+ O L
\" 9 U 3 I )7C t ;@\
A1+ O L ;@\
) #1\ ( + " F . U
#79
Josson 2005: 213-17)
.(
#7 4 Y )U @;W M4 Z '? +
U ( U .
y $9 K1 a "48 4 " Ss7
A1+ b+ "
;@\
8 )U @;W 0J A + .
079 U #J$C "
\"
• K+ o4$ 17 • )? y V V K8 4
"
)+ Y1 @;W 3 U 7C
) i 1386 : 491
+ )8 > U 1U @? K1 );, ‚ .(
8"
» S+ U ] )7 • 71+
[ 4+ Mo4$ A @ "
M # " + ) 41RB .# > 3
Q >
" 3#7+ $> U M #+ 3 41RB . 49 k7 @ " M
3( U )C@8 3( U
«
) $R+ "
#
) i 1386 : 460
.(
) 411{ ./ " 4h )U @;W 4+ K1
# . ) @$B5 . 7? + )U @;W 45
) @? O ? ) sU 0<+
M#79 4E 41hƒ )U @;W T c > 3
)
#7 .
" )," 411{ 5 " )U @;W i]4C 4g 7? ( )* . 7? + )$ 4 7? A
U F 49 X )U @;12 I ) $ .
c > 1 9 T # , )," 411{
1CE
situation-specific)
( . 4 ( + @ ./ 9 1CE + 'R
079 " Mc > 3
) . )I+
4 ( + 1 + #7 3 4$R+ + . 4 ( + 9 U F#, #'
) 012 ) " B$ ) 49 u 3 4' MZ" B$ ) 7 4
# 415 . + F("4 4 Z '?
F " 4' MZ 9 ),( " )$ ?
i4[ 3 9
u 3 F49 1@ ( F#779
F#, >4+
A1+ Z 49 u A11' " # # 415 4E 8 # + );;@\
(Josson 2005:
219-20) .
U F#, K1 )U @;W ) $ 411{ + 4X7 .
9 T 4 uW+ 45
» U 1U Z @1@
Y ( )8 >
) C b;R U
\" 9 # Fw+ +
@$8 3 ) )?
3 U ( " #7
# > ( 9 )@I 4 «
) F (41 1384 : 357
.(
*, . * A 4+ 7+
" 3415 " # #8 3
" J 8" 9 A1+ 3
. 411{ + 4X7 ‚ / =E "
. @$B5 3
) 9 A1+ Y1 @;W " )U 1U ( + )$ Z 411{ M ,
" )]; M)]; "4 . 4
*, . * 9 )]; 4
" 3415 9 A1+ Y1 @;W @ > $U" 3
) T 4
#79
Neumann 2002: 648)
A 4+ 7+ .(
M )5#1‚12 " 411{ + 4X7 I7
Q"
) *;+ U F#, Y1 @;W 3 17+ ) @$B5 " ) $ Z 411{ #
K1 A
+ 9 A1+ b+ "
"/ 8"
.
$ %!
"
A1+ b+ " 3 X7 #C+ " . 1 s+ + 0<+ A 4 + ~ J& F( & " ;@\
) ~P> "
) . " T ( 42 Q4 " O IB V 9 T1
U E
A1+ 4 + ~ J& O L ;9 , . 17+ " #79 411{ Q <$U );;@\
3# #8 )EP> 3
"/ 8" + ) I8 g4?
.
&'(
"
\" 4*B j U 4+
8" + )EP> )? @$8 > 3 (4 > \" M
) A1+ vsU " "/
\" 4 U + # 12 );;@\
T9 3"4@;E ( 01+ "
Q(
) 4E );> 3
\" . 1 9 ) 8 3 "# )EP> ! g " 415 I / 4U 4+
A1+ )5# ( + F #, + $, 8" S ) );;@\
#7+
. )EP> _ @$8 A A * 3 ?
" y 94U ! & A1? " k78 + Z ' ./ Jm ) S 4[ ( \" bU )B
U 4 3
.
\" )EP> _ @$8 =E "
S + ^ * + \" M
. 1 3 X7 A1+ g4? > 4 # + . # )U 1U 3
) );;@\
( 42 .
\" !4$79 " F | > M , 4+ A
» y > >
«
good violence)
" (
!4$79 ( ‹ > >
> )7C \"
) E " )' u M)$ 3
»
>
#+ 3 «
bad violence)
) )J; (
# ,
Mansbach and Wilmer 2001: 51-2)
.(
A 4 Z '? +
\" ."41+ " ." . # "4I, A1+ 3 X7 " )EP> s+ 9 U \" ; ) : 4C
#79 .
& g ( 3 1R+ 4L + F("4 M R1 )7$ 4 u2 ) 1\ B$U" x3 X7 xTL A M. 4L
? @X 45 9 4V
./ . 1 s+ " . 4 M > " + ( 3 : 4C
T179
Fearon and Wendt 2005: 66)
./ (
F 5
» + i sC ~P>
« F 12 41'C +
2005)
+ M(
s+ . 7?
A1+ 3
»
>
«
"
» 34
« ) )J;
pP+ J$ 9 , ) O E 4 #@
#7 <+
.
./ 9 ~P> ( . # )J; ( 4 4 =E "
? @X A "# b+ ` " #? E ( 3
+ F#,
;1U"
Fl U ) T*& . 4 Y ( ), 1\ ŠR J$R )71 12 3 !" ; " ~P> M#
. 7? + 1\ ŠR
! 'E
» 4 3
« ) )J;
, . 4 Z '? + M
M $ Z" fE
V 9 U A + $R+ " M#, + b+ ` " #? E + $R+ " * / ( 01+
» q ŠR s+
1 @ 41e
34 + >
« T1U 7 + 1@U + .
A M4L7 A ( 9 U A TI $*
» 34 «
. R 4g
$R1 4 3 + # + _ @$8 #;2 Š\ . 1+ + *;+ #7
5 : 4C ( + 3
9 T179
» o >
y/ M A1 ( @ 9 " Z 1& M. 15 M «
415 4+
. )7C A +
» )EP> s+
« F 3 7C + 9 " 34 M > + # #8 s+ " .#1@I MA$R # #8 3
U )$R . I8
Ruiz 2002: 338-9)
.(
. U4$2 1 . 1+ + " 4L7 A (
Paterson 1996)
)$R + J$ b+ " ( . I8 (
1*
) #12 O IB + J$ )$R ( ) $R'@ Y Z 8 @ " U F#,
#779 . A 4+ 7+
+ z + ~P> ‚ 7V
» )EP> s+
« ) @ + ~P> MT179 : 4C )$R . I8 + >
F 4E + r 7 " $R+ "
+ tT 5 M. I8 + > s+ ( : 4C 54 9 3
4+ sU "P+ )EP> Z "K;
. . I8 ~P>
+ ./ s+ " 4 + ~ J& 4+ )7$' ! @,
49 T1 > )U 4+ 1 B + #C+ 0<+
.
Z" B " + 8 M! & A1?
$ 3
k7 4 ( ), ) .#@ "
MZ" B$ 3
) 012 34 )EP> ;ŠR Z" B + >4+ ) V ./ " "/
A1+ vsU );;@\
U . F 5# iP>4+
. I8 3 A["
. I8 ~P> ! ' + 9 3 M#7$R ! @,
F 5#
. I8 Z 1EP> + 1 . * O#? 4+ 4 )
! @, . 1 3 5( U O#? + 8 +
R ( . I8
# #19ƒ 8 Z" B$ 3 .
) K1 @?
4 d + ! g F 5 4 9 T171+
. I8 F( & . 1 #7+ 1+ ˆ< ) $ # + ! @,
)$ 3
- 4L iP$> :;$< ) 7 4
) 012 Z" B ./ ( 4 4 )$& " # / ."
. 1 ) #@
< 3 )@ :;$
.
45 F#
. ) I7 12 ) 1EP> X7 Z" B + 'R I7 9 ,
M#, + j R&
Z" B + O 4$& 3 7' 4+ *;+
415 *,
) + # 4 7+
Inayatullah and Blaney 2004 :
.(
)* &
+ . ( U 3 4+ )+ V V 4 + ~ J& ! @C [
" )
\" A1+ b+
34 + 4 "
) )J;
, .
| 1?"4 ( ) <+ 9 #7$R )7 * 3#? E 4 + ~ J& M4 Z '? + 079 "
\" 345 ) : 4C
#779 . . @ )7C
\" 3 4+ 1@9 & 9 5
0J 9 ) @$B5 ( ) <+ . 7? + K1 4 + ~ J& . @$B5 M )7 4 /
@9 &
\"
) : 4C ) @? M#79
) " #79
\" , %? + #
9 A + 8 +
) > + . @$B5 A + #& V A1+ C 8 # ( #7 <+
);;@\
) " B$ 3
#779 #12 . , 4+ + > 3 8 4 + ~ J& ( )$]7U , 4+ 4U k78 ( a2 # #8 3
9
# 12 )]; " 3 4 ~ J& A1+ ./
3 ) 8 t # 8" T* $R
$B5 F("4 9
)
\ E 9 , + > 3 8 4 + ~ J& . @$B5 )]; 3
" )]; "4 3
F )]; 4 ( ' g A 4 + ~ J& " #
» ) 7 4 #7V 3# "4I,
(multicultural «
citizenship)
) ,
Koenig 2008: 96-102)
.(
\" 4 F("4 9 U" A ( F#7 @
Y )]; _ @$8 )@ )J; )$U
# + *;+ t# , 1?"4 9 _ 7$ )C@8 3
. I8 4 + ~ J& ( >
) U + ! @,
#7U 7 + 1@U + # "/
. )>4+ V45
) U 7, # #J$C 3
ZPfC ( )* + , 4U A11C S& 3 s? $R , )C@8
A1+ b+ " 3#8 U F#, !#+ ;@\
Greenhil 2008: 361-3)
+ )\" M(
4 )R 45 ! &
./ 4 + ~ J& . @$B5 ."
49 " 3# 4 ./ + A$> 42 Z "4` . $ 9 R #E .
@ 49• + X7 ) Zq A ( )
O IB yu8 41h T ( 42
T1 . 4 + ~ J& . @$B5 .
» 3 w ’1C' " w + s+ *R 1 P?
« ) 1978 (
UNESCO Declaration on Race and Racial Prejudice)
" 4 (
F"45
#8 " 34 + 3
» S&
Z" B «
Right to Difference)
" (
»
) 7 4 S&
«
Right to cultural identity)
$R (
F#,
# . U $ 45 4E 34 + ~ J& A1 E ! @, K1 u .
\ E )' u 3 (/
) 7 4 A$,
» u 4+ )7$' ’1C' " R O#? ! *, @ ^ {\ 1 P?
J$?
« ) 1981 (
Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and )
Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief
U F#, $> 7, 1@U +(
.
~ J& . 1R1@9
F ( > 41RB # $ ; 4 + 19
A1+ . 1R 79 ) # ~ J& );;@\
- s+ )U 1U
@f$ # ' 9 Y c > u Y b;R 9 U F 49 #19ƒ )' u 3 (/ + A
4V t#, + 4 u #` 4+ ’1C' F("4 u 9
» 34 + o4$ “ 41 «
) )J;
,
. @ "
9 [
»
v;g k7 4 ^ J u 0J F + *R 1 P?
« ) 1994 (
UNESCO Declaration on the Role of Religion on the Promotion of a Culture of Peace)
F# / (
* + U
3 ? ( )
» ) 7 4 _ 7 «
U F#, #' .
1;E ~ J& + s+
3 #7+ K1 ) +( " )' u M) E M)]; 3 1
"
5 F 2 1 P?
1;E + S;C$ 4 ~ J&
! U y ) +( " )' u M) E M)]; 3 1992
=@X M
\" ( # $ ; ) @?
) ( 9 # >
1;E + q C " F 49 3 #U 2
# ( 4W+ I / b 4, ^ J .
#7+
4 + 'R ’1C' O#? " 34+ 4+ 9 U F# / F . @
( q C 3 #U 2 S 4[ ( 4g 1;E 4 ) A1@f I / )C@8 3
,
)
% + 3 4+
C 8 + # 4 7+ s+ A #1B )$> 7, Koenig 2008: 105-7 :
.(
( 4 + ~ J& Z 1+ F("4 A 4+ F"P?
» ) $R'@ ~ J&
«
Solidarity Rights) (
» )C@8 ~ J&
«
Collective Rights)
) . 1 + ' g (
)U4$U S& Mv;g S& , 9 # /
o4$ “ 41 9 S& MT\ U R ( b1 ( 3 >4+ S& MZ ?P[ + (/
S& M34 + Y@9 S& " CU
U $U" 4 + 3
Meyer 1998: 11)
) . 9 (
4 + #
4g 7? 1J+ ( ( $@ )mK8 > " 4L # #X > ( 45 4 | "# : 4C T *;+ M I / 4+ b;R " )s1 " ) 412 ) : 4C I / ( 4[
#79 .
" )C@8 : 4C A17V
) R ( $R'@
> c > )EP> Z "K; K1 .
) D4s $* A M4 34L7 ( " ! & A1?
8 . @$B5 #& V 9 ,
Z" B ;ŠR 4 + ~ J&
. I8 3 ? #& V " $ 45 4E 8 )$ 3 )\ @,
) <@ ) I8 vsU )$ #C " 4z* ( ), Z 1CE " + ./
. 9 3 8" +
F#? E );g . $ D4s 4 + ~ J& #? E 3 48 Z" B$ ) 7 4 3 4$R+ + 8 ( U
" U ~P> " ~ J& ( );*, )$, 4+ j U 4+ 4$ 1+ 4 + ~ J& 8 . @$B5 " F#, . I8 2 A1@
) > )\ @,
" ~ J& ( );*, , 4+ A1@ 9 #7 /4+ )>4+ M#
P>
F# #2 Z 1E . I8 3
) . ! 4'1\ )$, 4+ " R1 ! @,
# . )@ 4L +
#U
F#7 / 012 + E 3 + 9 U ./ TI $* #U4+ ) X 4U + 71 ( A Z 4d 7 )71+
*, ) 8 3#8 ) \ V + 4 + ~ J& . @$B5 M " Z" B . @$B5 3415 ,
.
% +
$*
Y ( 9 U A 49 F , ./ + # + \ J A O 84 . 7? + 9 3 O IB Mi4[
! " ! €1U €1 1\ + F#7+
F( & MQ A1+ b+ " A 17+ Zq J "
;@\
i4[ ( " F 49 ) IB 411{ Q <$U Q4 M4
( A )B 4C 0<+#
A1+ b+ "
> , . 7? + ;@\
U F#, 34 + 0 ( 3
.
Q4 " 45 9 4V
A1+ b+ " Π2 T1 B )R 45 + 4X7 M 1@9 & MZ #E )7C ;@\
" 4 + ~ J& M)U @;W ...
./
) q + I / 49• 9 5 ! #8 Y, ."#+ M ,
A > A 17+ )R 45 "
R K1 )@;? $, .
? )? + O IB =E "
A1+ b+ " $, x u5 . "
F( U " ) IB 3 (4 ( ;@\
F( & + A1 12 x34L 3 3
! " ! €1U U ) 79 ( " 4 ? + S+ s 34 + 0 ( $
.
A1+ b+ " $, + Q4
F# A O IB ”4X72 ( ;@\
@?
4+ 45
F( & 9 A1+ b+ " ) IB 3
) 5( U . I8 4]z*$ Z €1CE " + ;@\
#79 . Z '? +
) 4 . 1 Z C\ s ) *, 3 4+ o4$ Œ71 ( X + #
$, O ;? 4 U + 3
A1+ b+ " $, M)? @$8 F#1 <+ ) 34L ) $R ( ;@\
# #8 ) IB . +( "
+ ) I8 Œg4? ‡ C$ 3 # " 1; 3 4+
+ 9 ) # " t "/ 8"
[
B\ 41h F#7 K
# 4E )$ 3
.
, ! -(
:
. .
" 0 :
1 .
‚ MK71*78 )
1381 (
"'D C B . 4I M3#@& ‹ @84 M
: , 0 "w2 " 4 F( 41
.
2 .
# q" M. R 4+
) 1380 (
& # :D :
= a;
:D b B3 "'D = B . 4I M3 q 2 ! @9 @84
:
%\ h 4 .
3 . 41@& MF (41 )
1379 ( 38 =3T = U B ]O D
"'D = . 4I M : )71@> O F#* "w2 )
F .(
4 . 41@& MF (41 )
1384 ( C3T A ,;
8 = B 7 8 9 5 "6 . 4I M :
@U .
5 . )8 a M $75 ) .
1372 ( :' &
F (41 41@& @84 .
. 4I : A1+ " )U 1U Z C\ s 4$
);;@\
.
6 . . 4+ M "
) 1383 (
» )U @;W
« M 1@U 1$U " a1;1+ . 8 :D
& # :
7 8 98 5 "6 7C F 3
M
TU J\ + @84 . 4I M. 4 " )7@V F
: . 4I 4g C 4+
.
7 .
# R*\ M "
) 1384 (
7 8 "'D C3T
5 "6
@84 M 461@&
. 46I MF (41 6 :
Z 6C\ s 46$ Z 6$
A1+ " )U 1U );;@\
.
8 .
# Mi ) 1386 (
»
$* # 3( U4+
A1+ b+ " 4L 3 4+
;@\
« M4$1;*71\ " # / cY
= F ' FC3T FC 34
=% 38 d' . 4I M 1[ `41;? @84 M :
4$ Z $
A1+ " )U 1U Z C\ s );;@\
.
1 .
"2 ( :
1. Appiah, Kwame Anthony (2005) The Ethics of Identity. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
2. Barnett, Michael and Reymond Duvall (2005) “Power inInternational Politics.”
International Organizations 59:39-75.
3. Biesteker, Thomas J. (2005) “State, Sovereignty and Territory.” in Walter Carlsnaes, Thomas Risse and Beth A. Simmons, eds., Handbook ofInternational Relations.
London: Sage Publication.
4. Biesteker, Thomas J. and Weber, Cynthia (1996) “The Social Construction of State Sovereignty,” in Thomas J. Biesteker and Cynthia Weber, eds., State Sovereignty as Social Construct Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
5. Brown, Chris (2001) “Borders and Identity in International Political Theory” in Mathias Albert, David Jacobson and Yosef Lapid,eds., Identities, Borders and Orders:
Rethinking International Relations Theory. Minneapolis: University ofMinneapolis Press
6. Dahl, Robert (1991) Modern Political Analysis. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
7. Fearon, James and Alexander Wendt (2005) “Rationalism v. Constructivism: A Skeptical View.” in Walter Carlsnaes, Thomas Riss and Beth A. Simmons, eds. Handbook of International Relations. London: Sage Publication.
8. Gartzke, Erik and Kristian Skrede Gleditsch (2006 ) “ Identity and Conflict: Ties that Bind and Differences that Divide.” European Journal of International Relations12, 1.
9. Goldstein, J. and Keohane, R. (1993) “Ideas and Foreign Policy: An Analytical Framework,” in J. Goldstein and R. Keohane, eds., Ideas and Foreign Policy: Beliefs, Institutions, and Political Change. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
10. Greenhil, Brian (2008) “Recognition and Collective Identity Formation on International Politics.” European Journal of International Relations 14, 2.
11. Grossberg, Lawrence (1996) “Identity and Cultural Studies- Is That All There Is?” in Stuart Hall and Paul Du Gay, eds., Questions of Cultural Identity London: Sage: 87- 107.
12. Guillaume, Xavier (2002) “Foreign Policy and the Politics of Alterity: A Dialogical Understanding of International Relations.” Millennium 31, 1.
13. Hall, Stuart (1996) “Introduction: Who Needs Identity?” in Stuart Hall and Paul Du Gay, eds., Questions of Cultural Identity London: Sage: 1-17.
14. Hoogenson, Gunhild and Svein Vigeland Rottem (2004) “Gender Identity and theSubject of Security.” Security Dialogue 35, 2.
15. Huyzmans, Jef (2008) “The Jargon of Exception: On Schmitt, Agamben and the Absence of Political Society,” International Political Sociology 2, 2: 165-83.
16. Inayatullah, Naeem and David Blaney (2004) International Relations and the Problem of Difference. New York: Routledge.
17. Josson, Christer (2005) “Diplomacy, Bargaining and Negotiation.” in Walter Carlsnaes Thomas Riss and Beth A. Simmons, eds., Handbook of International Relations.
London: Sage Publication.
18. Keohane, Robert (1984) After Hegemony. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
19. Koenig, Matthias (2008) “Institutional Change in the World Polity: International Human Rights and the Construction of Collective Identities.” International Sociology 23, 1.
20. Kratochwil, Friedrich (2006) “History, Action and Identity: Revisiting the ‘Second Great Debate and Assessing its Importance for Social Theory.” European Journal of International Relations 12, 1.
21. Koslowski, R and Kratochwil, Friedrich (1995) “Understanding Change in International Politics: The Soviet Empire’s Demise and the international System,” in Richard N. Lebow and Thomas Risse-Kappen, eds., International Relations Theory and the End of the Cold War. New York: Columbia University Press.
22. Lapid, Yosef (2001) “Introduction” in Mathias Albert, David Jacobson and Yozef Lapid, eds., Identities, Borders and Orders: Rethinking International Relations Theory.
Minneapolis: University of Minneapolis Press.
23. Linklater, Andrew (1998) The Transformation of Political Community. Cambridge:
Polity Press.
24. Mansbach, Richard and Franke Wilmer (2001) “War, Violence and State System as a Moral Community” in Mathias Albert, David Jacobson and Yosef Lapid,eds., Identities, Borders and Orders: Rethinking International Relations Theory. Minneapolis:
University of Minneapolis Press
25. Mansbach, Richard W. (2002) “Deterritorializing Global Politics,” in Donald Puchala,ed., Vision of International Relations: Assessing an Academic Field. Columbia:University of South Carolina Press.
26. Meyer, William (1998) Human Rights and International Political Economy in the Third World Nations: Multinational Corporations, Foreign Aid and Repression.
NewYork: Macmillian
27. Mitzen, Jennifer (2006) “Ontological Security in World Politics: State Identity and the Security Dilemma.” European Journal of International Relations, Vol. 12, No. 3.
28. Murshed, Zubair (2003) “Power and Identity in the Discourse of Jihad.” Gender, Technology and Development 7, 3.
29. Neumann, Iver B. (2002) “Returning Practice to the Linguistic Turn: The Case of Diplomacy.” Millennium 31, 3.
30. Nye, Joseph (2004) Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics, New York:
PublicAffairs.
31. Onuf, Nicholas (2003) “Foreword” in Jamie Frueh, Political Identity and Social Change: The Remaking of the South African Social Order.Albany: State University of New York Press.
32. Paterson, Mathew (1996) “Green Politics,” in Scott Burchill, Andrew Linklater et. al., Theories of International Relations, Houndmills and London: Macmillan, pp. 252-74.
33. Ruiz, Lester Edwin (2002) “Culture, Politics, and the Sense of the Ethical: Challenges for Normative International Relations,” in Paul Wapner and Lester Edwin J. Ruiz, eds., Principled World Politics: The Challenge of Normative International Relations.
London: Rowan and Little field Publication.
34. Shannon, Vaughn P. (2007) “Threat Perception and Psychology of Constructivism.”
International Studies Review, Vol. 9.
35. Stein, Janice Gross (2005) “Psychological Explanations on International Conflict.” in Walter Carlsnaes, Thomas Riss and Beth A. Simmons, eds., Handbook ofInternational Relations. London: Sage Publication.
36. Walker, R. B. J. (1993) Inside/Outside: International Relations as Political Theory.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
37. Waltz, Kenneth (1979) Theory of International Politics. New York: Random House.
38. Wendt, Alexander (1992) “Anarchy Is What States Make of It,” International Organization 46, 2: 391-425.
! " # $% & ' ( ) * + :
"
8'- &,4 94 :% : ; <= 6
"
> 5 78
% -) 5 –45
"
(A
% BC $ > , :
<= 6 D.
% /E D-+6 $
"F G
> 5 78
% -) 5 46 -
"5
; D-+2I J> ,> 3 E % K , ,-
"
D> 5 81
% -D) 5 57
"- : ; D <=D 6
J> ,> & , 4 K,. 2
"
> 5 82
% -) 5 59
"-
$% > N . ; -A $ +2I
"
D> 5 83
% -D) 5 63
–
"
N ; E 4 $% >
8'- &,4 94 :%
"
> 5 83
% -) 5 –65
"
9D4 :% % $ D + D N / ,4 D4
&,4 8'-
"
> 5 84
% -) 5 –67
"
/ B6 P N N
:
$ - A J : 1 : . DQ % I R $ .
"
D> 5
85
% -) 5 –71
"
S E 4 '-T: 1+ /6% U J> ,> % <U V :
, ; -+2I $ .
"/'U
% -) 5
2
; + 4 A 5 86
"5
&,4 P N / W % +U > : S E ,'E Q X Y 6 8'-
"
% -) 1
% B4 5 87 .
