2 &
3 4 5 67
"8 "9
) :
13 / 9 / –86 :
28 / 1 / 87 (
: :
% 26< ( 2 =' >. '?
6 8 @ A B 6 % 6 - # % 2 >2 3 4 C6 C @
. 64 C6 % 26< 32 6 E F 4
=' >.
< 6G HI&8 J B 6 2K .
L864
% 6,4 ( % 64 C 64 @ MN J B 6 C 64 %K
L L L@
L- %K L864
OP9P&
=' >. C6 C @ 4 Q
>2 9 26G L L Q + LME 4 &
J B 6
Q 6R
. 7 2 32 4 < F 4 # R 9 32 4
6 E F 4 < F 6E LF
6L4 ='L >. 'L? 6 E F J B 6 "&< +S ,F =' >. '? 3 4 J4 &
# 3 MF J B 6 2K .
C Q % 7T :
=' >. '?
-
=' >.
-
>. U – ='
>2 -
>2 9 - J B 6
* : 02813780035 [email protected]
Email:
! " # $ %& ' ( )* + , -%.! / -0 )! 1 / 2#3 4 , 1 / :
» -, #! ' 6 " 789 :, !
«
<
= 1372 <
8 30 .
@4#, #AB C D89
' ' E* / E! < E F "E! G 4* -H I#J K%4! L + C M
' = EB N#+ E ' E -EO O P -H ' AQ <I#J ", M 2#3 -9 R 6 89 -AM' @4#, #AB S 9 .
-O L + C M 1 T% U! V W
"! X, ' "7 9 <"& 8 M <" # -
Z 4[ " # ! -
»
@4#, #AB 43
«1
- [ $ , .
4#, #AB 43 -EH E+, IEH R #\ @4E#, #AB -D,F / L #4H H ]0 U! / H 18^ 9
"! G 4*
F
"E! @#E " E9 ' = EB <
% EH -EO E O
"
L 9 ' E "! E8 L EH
AB L H " _7 M " * @4#, #
» A 0' L
«
"%EB C E & -H
<@4E#, #AB ' E 1 E
" 8, 6
"!
O .
"! @4#, #AB 43 4E[ ' `#8& a #bc ,
L EH -EH I#J E
'F .
"%#J / "6 H / L_E [ CF <L E+ C E M 1E L 9 ! #3 -H de! 7, H 9
"! " f+ ! ' -H ' CF H I#J -O ,
. EH < @4E#, #AB C g ! h ' -H "6 H !
O "! I#J L H L M L W6 C & -H CF / -, #H H 7, .
"E! " , -i ' j 4#i @4#, #AB 43 a #bc -O 1 @ER I#J E L EH E,
@A! j ,_H 2 3 1
H k d -O " 9
V W! 3 1
. M ! a #H -g0 W!
-O 9 "! C , H 1 H
' @4#, #AB 43 / L * ' CF L 9 ! #3 ' bF
EM'
, .
" C H/ -H H 1 -O L ' l! am )!
!
<
9 1E EgH / L gH $ O
' R -M ! 3
L H AB 43 " g!
CF EbF ' @4E#, # $ ER
E, . E!
= C D89
M' CF L 9 ! #3 ' @4#, #AB 43 H g ! L 9 E 3 E !/ #, -O
1 ][
.
</ #, 1 -H -M H - 6 E E 8O L + C M 1 "g -0 )! 1
CF #bc ' [ " g! C +! * H
I#J F
!
#[ R " H .
-& 8.! @4#, #AB 43 L
9 - , ' + /
@4E#, #AB L EX, ", Ed! @9 -O
C _E#! EAM / " 4E#, #AB E0' C & -H I#J +%8& @9 ' R = ! O N#+ ", 4, ' "Rf6 = B H CF ( dW, .
H C E "E g! Z' EU! -EH -M
4EE3 L EE / <I#J EE EE F ' = EE* <- EE n[ N#+ EE ' @4EE#, #AB L EEX, ", EEd!
.1 Post – Zionism M o d4, "*fWB
. L H 4U, 1#
$ L ' CF H Uri Ram )
( p E -Eg! M E
= "%#J 1993
H O -H . O #3 "! 8& L H O C A -H k H ! a #H CF / q3 .
4#, #AB 43 "6 H < 9
, "! @4#, #AB ^ H S ! @4#, #AB
" . E $ ' ' #!
"
-, " 9'h3 -4 ! " M ! -, #! ' 6 L
"!
4 , :
» 6 -O "] g p H 4#, #AB 43
EH S ! @4#, #AB 43 < , O -J 9
@4#, #AB ^ .
L Ed & "EH EM ! @4#, #AB +%8& A,F ) & -H / Z/
E9 L
A, L O -H H 1 H H ' "Rf6 .
@A!
4#, #AB 43 -+ CF / ", Ed! 9
H = / 6 1 ' 9n! "Rf6 ,
....
Ed & "EH ' E U EA,F ", E O S E9
4#, #AB 1 6
I#J 0' q# c H 9
. AM of! EO A,F S 9 ' L #[
EE @4EE#, #AB EE U L EEH -EE+%H 4EE#, @4EE#, #AB VfEEB L EEH ' EE "EE] !
«
Wurmser,1999) (.
"
, #0 8#0
"
C 80 3 8, )
4# O (
#3 /' '
@E9 I#J E a r d a /' 1#
"! H 1 [
:
» E#! , @4E#, #AB E^ C E "! -O " #bc -H -M H @4#, #AB 43 .
4E3
4#, #AB 1E -EO E, #Oc ! 4#, T0 U! I#J 0' H -O 49 "& ! 9
O I8& I! O r -H 6 T Q' -H H 0' .
o E s L E L EA E0' E EA,F
, "! -, 3 h, ...
E0' NE -EO #gE^' 1 -H H I#J -O , #Oc o l % '
-d M "! 8 H L A 9 C 3 9
«
Livant ,2000)
.(
[ 1 /
<
1# #3 " 4#, #AB ^ C M C 89 @4#, #AB 43 EO
-
"%+E -EH
M
E E 9 EQ
.
" nE0 E, #0
"
@4E#, #AB 4E3
"
E^ C +] E ' t E#!
1# #3 4#, #AB
"
"! T#B O
Livant, 2000)
@4E#, #AB 43 -O ", 4O ) & -H (.
"! @4#, #AB ^ H S !
< , C M EH C E!_89 C A C #! " 4#, #AB ^ L 9
I+
H @4#, #AB L #[
O /' . ZfE @X& 2UH -+, i
"
=_E 9 ' Eu
"
C nE7, # H /
@4#, #AB
= 9
#0 g =' L 4#, #AB
9 L 9 ' 9 ) , -H 1 ][ 3 AM <
EH EA,F E]0 U! / Zf ' - O -H & CF C A " v _H C d9 - O @4#, #AB
)
<L ' E[
1378
<
w . 27
.(
#) ! ' @4#, #AB 1 [ a R H ! CF L E9
I#+ AM
x]* ' 4#, #AB ^ y* L A 0' T#g^ 9
.
! E n[ EH
-g! M -H "H # L H I#J ", , ' C !/
-EH <S Er K#El! EH " 4E _89 ' 1! L
C M P o .! @4#, #AB ^ ' T0 U! L 9 /' EH C E+! #6 -9 ' ' O
- , S' g! @4#, #AB 43 -H -O , .
"! "+ @4#, #AB ^ H @4#, #AB 43 -O ", 4O IH )!
E, R ", 4O ,
- , @4#, #AB 43 -O "! "%dR " 4#, #AB ^ C M H a' ] ! ' M L
.
[ 1 X, / ] g @4#, #AB 43 < '
"
< E A $ EA]! E#X, L E# H @#9 E]! / M
"7, E7i ' I#J 0' #&' ! ", d! <L A @4#0 , # , <I#J "%! 9 EO V EW! <I#J E E0' -g! M A 9n! 2), ' S r K#l! H k d ' -g! M
. 1 / '
<
6 H -i [ 4E#, #AB 4E3 -EO " E9 ) , / "
EH E O "E! V EW! E9
]0 U!
a B @4#, #AB / - n[ -O " 9
"!
E8& 2EUH "E0' -H ! [
" 4#, #AB 43 C M M
. / [ E 1
<
@4E#, ! 4E3 EH @4E#, #AB 4E3
3 ' - 4, Kd ! , ! 43 H C !_89 -O AQ , L
"! ")% O AQ @4#
E .
@4E#, #AB M z , " * ' @4#, #AB ! @4#, #AB 43 <" H 1# i H "E g!
. -+, i
"
q , H
"
{ ' " 4#, #AB 43 @4#, #AB H +H
- , ' :
»
$_# #8 " ,F -H C A 3 @4#, #AB )
L_# "!
( / E#H -E+%H Ed, E 3 <CF
EH - #, ! & L 9 #gR ' -H C A .
C E! @4E#, #AB ...
-EH C E A "Eg8M E 3
<@4E#0 d#0 <@4E#0 , # , `E r / , #E O C E A CF "Er -EO F "! G 4* -H - #, !
| U <@4#0 # -E! , H <" [
<IE#dR 1E / "%J 4E! ' L 7#! EX, <L E R L_E
" #g8M E O q#E c "E%! L 9 E, #3 EH " #g8M I+ -H "d9n! L 9 , #3 H .
E!
"E! @9 " 9 _H ' +] <C H/ <" 4#, #AB 43 @4#, #AB / EM C E A -EH ' E O
"!
6 -O 9 9 `#dW - #, ! 43 / " , a ##} H
«
Brandeis,1999)
.(
7 S r /
<
"6 H
@4E#, #AB H 6 ^ < 4#, #AB 43 L A C 8 , /
+, '
"! C &
4E#, @4E#, #AB EH E^ L E g! -EH o !'_0 < A,F a ) , -O O .
-+, i
"
q ! " H
"
"! I#J 4#, #AB 43 S' g! 1#6 ! / "+
[ :
»
@, H 4#, #AB 43 6 @9 6 "8, 1!
. 1!
@ 4E9 1E -H ) g! -O X, 1 /
@ 49 4#, #AB H - 0' N H A $ ! -O .
E , 89 E, `* L A $ !
%! 7
@#8 L H 9 E H - " 0' 6 , H L #[
....
"E8, E!
@9 E6
& g ! I m -H 1! / @ 49 - F ' 4#, #AB N 1! -O @ 7H -Rf
0' -H L -
%!
0' ' $ , 0' H -4 )! I#J %! –
E%! – -EH "E, lH :ER ! E7 L E9
O I8& I+ 1 H .
@ 4E9 4E#, #AB 43 N @ 7H @9 6 "8, = * 1#&
I#J E 0' x]* ' q# c @4#, #AB L{ 0 J 8& S 9 -O @ O "! + 1! /
@# R CF -O "W
<
H
«
Hammond,1999)
.(
/ X, @4#, #AB <C +] ! 1
L 3
E - n[ -H `%g ! -EO
-EH E6 T EQ'
, $ .,
<
x]* " , N ! 6 L 9 '
, . H H -H @4#, #AB / ) , 1
e! 2), 1 [ , L g!
d CF H -+%H < 4#, - n[
L x]* L H K C O @9
@4#, #AB L 9 ' K
M
" .
"' #3
"!
4 , :
»
@4#0 , # , C O " g! "8 R ' - AO )
@4E#, #AB (
4E3 L E / I#J E
89 H ` ! L A @4#0 , # , -O 1 H a -H A 4#, #AB .
EU EH A,F
-E E 2 E9 -EH of8& -O "8 4#H C R +! A @4#, #AB -O O "! $f&
.
"! @4#, #AB C O " g! ` ! / A,F -O L -.# , ! 1 , #[
a E! L H -O
4#, / #, @4#, #AB -H ",m r .
! 6 I#J -O O "! + ' [ 1 - 6 E @+l 4
, ! 9 6 "R H - #89 L H -O 6 H " R ' - C i / '
«
) Shapiro,1999
.(
<@4E#, #AB 4E3 ' @4#, #AB ^ 1#H " U ! K6 C # O L M' H
"
_0 Ei
! O
"
#E O <C E A L EH E0' I#+ E IB H C M ' 1 1#H d4, H #Oc H O C #H A,F a' ] .
- , -H
"
! O
"
4#, #AB ^ H -O 49 ", 4O 9
0' N a B -H C A C I+ ' 0' I#+
- ]0 U! %!
. -O ", !/ / n0
/ E\F @4#, #AB H C M 1 ]0 U! O / \F 0' q# c L H 6 Zf @4#, #AB C O ' - -!
. 4#, #AB 43 ! 4E#, T0 EU! E0' I#+ IB H 9
.
4#, #AB H X, 1 / A,F
, X, ~ 9
. - E " #9 E! -Ei E0' 1E -+ !
4E#, #AB 4E3 1#EH < E O E#)g " E9 -i ' " -i H ' H ' E9
4#, #AB EM' X, Sf 6 9
)
Krauthammer,1997
.(
E^ -EO "0 E* 1 H E H
4#, #AB 4#, #AB 43 < O "! "], 0' I#+ IB 9
IEB 1 4E, @%4! H 9
[ < 0' I#+
' #9 ! H 6 L 9 O "! V W! 0' 1 "7, 7i
.
3 L # H ' a ) , "+#+] 1# i M' H 4#, #AB 4
E EA,F @4#, #AB / 9
H 2#3 @4#, #AB H ^ * .
n0 IEdR C ER N / 2#H / -O @4#, #AB ^
2#E3 -E9 ' ' E* / -EO @4#, #AB 43 ' C M -H 7 E+ -EH < E = Eg
- EE #3 EE, . - EE , Z 4EE[ EEb EEH -EEO " yEE / " 4EE#, #AB ^ C EE M L EE) , L EE9
43 4#, #AB 4E3 C E M ' -E E#H EM' / EH C +! @9 @4#, #AB / 9
=m / <@4#, #AB / ) , @4#, #AB 4E#, #AB E^ -EO " 4E! ' 9
V EW! E9
O
H ,
.
" 4E#, #AB 43 C M ' 1 / C E M / "Ed#O
E% U! L E9 T
' " 4E#, #AB E0' ' @4E#, #AB / E) , -E89 < A,F a' ] ! a #Oc @\ -H -O
`] ! CF +%8&
0 )0
" .
•' 'F
"
T#EB C M - / O ! @4#, #AB 43 C M
O / d& -O
:
1 - ' [ C #! -O "8 R " 4#, #AB ^ C M =' C M [ €i L 9
E^ '
H P 8g
. , " d0 N , "! " 3 h, H S ! @4#, #AB -O C M 1
O "! C #H / ", H/ H @4#, #AB / 6 L 9 ) , ' 9 Q .
2 -
# -O ", M $' C M E E 9 EQ I#J E "%6 L 9
. 1E
7 , C #! -O C M
E # E P # ' C -g! M h ' -H C #9
' E9
# O ), -H S r K#l! ' C # #W4 H 6 H I#J +%8&
.
3 - H -O ", M $ C M
@#9 E]! ' IJ 4E! EH E M T g ' 9
L A @4#0 , # , ' C A < A #X, "
E O "E! V W!
. EH o E -EO "] Eg
a' ] ! @4#, #AB L / -J "8 T g
Avruch,1998)
.(
E]#r C E M 1E <" 4E#, #AB 43 L 9 - , ' + #O -H -M H
"
/ 4E[
]0 U! ' 9 ) ,
"! I! " 4#, #AB 0' ' @4#, #AB / 9 E
. 1E / '
", Eg! EH
"! - 6 " ' ] ! O -Bf6 / V -H C "! a' ] ! -O
:
1 -
L 9 ) , / " UH 4#, #AB 43
"
@4#, #AB /
<
' ' @4#, #AB
" 4E#, #AB L 9
' A /
O "! +, .
9 ) , 1 " 9 ) , z , /
EH E^ / E! -O
"! 2#3 @4#, #AB '
/ V -H ' L H -
"!
:
- ! "#
4#, #AB 9
CF = B ' @4#, #AB <
1E 1E L E) & = B ' A 1 H `dW !
"! " g!
< O
!
! C ) J R @4#, #AB Ed! ' = B / " 4#, #AB L 9
' EA 1E ",
O "! A 1 H @4#, #AB ( dW, .
EX, / EA,F L{ 0 J E NE EA @4E#, #AB
' @9 / , C R " 4#0 , # , 0 ! @ 4#H C R I '
. L E9 / !F -H L{ 0 J 1
1 A
"d9nE! "E J R -EJ H # O ' I ! C A "d9n! a ) & '
<= EB /
-E! , H ' S 9 / E E89 E6 EH C E A <" 4E#0 , # , L E9
. 1E / L E EH '
I#%) L{ 0 J E •WE -EH "EA0 "E "0 Eg ! ' m ' •WE / CF < EA 1E -EH -, [
$ R ' " 4#0 , # , =_ -, [
.
< ' l! - , @4#, #AB [ 1 / ' L E!
" EUH
<"EA0 - EE , 1 _7 EM @4EE#0 , # , E7, EE EEO EA 1EE L 7, EAM ' "0 EEg !
) Safran,1978,p.21
.(
n0 A " l, @4#, #AB -EO
' I#EB @#9 E]! "E !
H ' A 1 G , CF / L h, ' "! R T#U ' , L 9
E 'F "E3 .
N 1 H H
" .
"Z #9
E "E l0 EH EA "d9nE! C Ed9 / "E+
/ E) ,
- , @4#, #AB :
» A ^ of! O @4#, #AB .
NE a EB -EH C A 9 6 "! @4#, #AB
O T g "%! 3 .
j N 2d M 1
Washington Post 1979) (
"
1#9 ! - !
"
7 / d9 G O _#, A "d9n! C
"
A k Wl,
"
@4E#, #AB <
- , ' O " g! A k Wl, I! &
:
» -, , 9 ! H 1!
"E! @dE%R E^ * E& E A C'_E /' k Wl, L 9 +E
.
EH -EO - ##} L A VfWB -H @4#0 , # , -H ! C d! #3 ", 4, ' L g! A L # :0' "[ ,/ L H :# ' 1#!/ C 9 6 n3 ,
....
"! 1!
I#J E E%! -EH @9 6
[ H 1# A -H <C 8, d! #3 L 6 L -H @ 7H .
-EH ' E# O E9 @0 E3 , 1#JF
= -O " 9/ ! 1947
1#!/ / I%! C !/ K E 8E -EH "! H G & L 9
[ H G U! -, H ,/ 8 "[ ,/ # O "g '
«
)
<L ' [ 1378
|B<
. 35 - 36
.(
2UH
"! +, A 1 T l I#0 -H @4#, #AB -O " ) ! /
qO O
L E9
49 "d9n!
. H -H -M H ' [ 1 $ ER ' -E, [ "%! a [ H 6 "d9n! L 9
]0 U! -, 3 .
! F p E)! 1#, ER -EH „ E+ EH L E g! ' ", *' L -g! M I#+ A,F C
"d9n!
. 4#, #AB -O "W L + K6 1 C #, H -EH -E, [ "E%! "9 E7, EH E9
0' , 89 "%! " 0' q# c < A -
%!
< E, H ER E6 S E9 9
-g! M I#+
" H L -, [ 2# O "! ! p E)! " %! '
"
(Priestly People and a Holy Nation)
, O "! p )! : 80 ~ ! -g! M C & -H A "%! 1r' / ' , O "! #)g .
-g! M E O "[ E,/ E6 ", E H p E)! 1#, ER EH `H EW! E, H A %! CF -O L
Safran,1978,p.202)
E C EE "E! ' EE[ 1E (.
, EE M $'
"
IEEH )! E H / -EEO 4E,
H CF L 9_ . H ' 4 @4#, #AB H C &
A 1 / K%\ L 9 O ]0 U!
.
qO O
"d9n! L 9
<
2 E[ IE#0 -H @4#, #AB _#, "9' [
$ ER L E9 -E, [
"r E, ' "ERf6 = B T0 U! -+%H A 1 T l A -, <
"E! "E g! ", 4 E O
. /
1 '
<
"E! E#%9 M E& / "Eb #! ' " 3 h, / L Ai @4#, #AB E ,
. E
' " E 3 h, EH @4E#, #AB C EH S E ! H " d! l ! I%! C !/ "! 8& :8.! -! gWR
= 3F
1975
O ) [ 1
Avruch,1998,p.1-2)
. (
$ –
% &' ( ' ! "#
ER E E! @4E#, #AB "U a ' @9 @4#, #AB C [ O +, / "9' [ , . ' I#J C n7, # H 4#, #AB
9 ' #&' E! 4EO L H E6 E#, )* a Edb
# O , ,/ @9 $/m "U a 4!
.
@A!
1 -O "
A,F C C E, L H
EO -#+ CF H A 0' I#+ a ' ^ ' 6 #, )*
E, / E d&
: C E A /F
<L A #\ :! M
< E.,F -EH C E A a M EA! $ E7 9 1#W4E% 1#!/ C H * BfH
1#!/ L 6
/ C # #W4% L # 6 …' 6 ' A,F C +0 ! / N0 ! L L 9 1#W4%
.
C !/
q# c
E [ ER / ' L d! a 1 I#J
. E C E7,
† 2#3 C & -H ! 1 -H I#J 4E 7, "E! E EH b L 9
. 1E / '
<
E '
"E #gR ' C & -H "9 7 , I l! •W -i ' -! & •W -i I#J / "8 +, - n3 n3 , .
lEB EH E <P E -EH -9 - ' * n[ / gH !
/ \F @4#, #AB "U L 9 &
. E L E H -)dr -+,F / q3 h ' -H E9 = E
L
/ I#J q# c -#0' [ R C 7 9'h3 # 6 ' … 6 -, ! l! L H -)dr
. n0
" H ", M 2#3 "! 8 CF -O / \F I#J "U L 9
† C & -H -O " 9
' , / I#J "g ' :R ' ! H - n3 @%4! IB
.
" H 1 4#, #AB "U a 4! <"U L 9
"H 9
!F GF / p .
H
C A O ' L /F A
4#, #AB |U ! L/ , C 80F -E}0 d! z ^ ! 1 9
@R ' O , -J _#!F ( \ L 9
. 18^
4#, #AB -E, <C A /F -! 7 9 9
E AM L _H ' -%# ' C & -H CF H -+%H , d, T0 U! L /F A H A "H E
"9 89 6 " # S 9 -H C ,
E,
)
<L ' E[
1367
|EB<
. 73 - 165
.(
EH K%4E E!
, 1#W4%
1#!/ 1 A -, |U ! _#
CF ' E H / C E A -O d, * BfH
/ qE3 -EO EH 1EAO "U -)H L " %! H " #!/ -+%H O HF ' * 4#, #AB ' '
#!/ / '/ -H 9
… 6 6 1
,
)
<L ' [ 1367
<
|B . 185 - 211
.(
-J
' L 9
"U a' ] !
@4E#, #AB -EO < E "9 [ … ' M ! I#J /
, "U R B R - 4
"! " g! "gR ' #\ CF L / -J <
O .
4#, #AB H , # O 89 9
+
! H ' a Edb 6 M ! <"U a 4
O " g! "U 0' N $' I#J .
' C O d & "H
"U E L 9 EA,F
_E#, @4#, #AB +, < "! "U 3 N C & -H I#J "], M ! -+,F 18^
'F "! "3
" . , 8*' ,
"
C & H L -0 )!
"
9/ 3 9/
"
G E O -EH E EH
"
q ! " H
"
= E C 9 A / 'F C # #W4% …' 6 -O 4#, #AB 43 ‡ !
1948 ' , E6 -E.# , -E+%H G E& L 9 O 6 -H H ' # 6 ' L' / -,
O " g! "%#J L 9' #, '/ = 8&
Moris ,1989,p.257)
<(
"!
4 , :
» ' 1#6 ! -O L_#i L E9 # H / E0 E. E, $ E., "U C d%r X, .
I#J -, +] ' ' " # «
Hammond,1999)
( .
_)
* + , - . / 0 1 23 4 "5 C ) ! / L 7 ' [
<
L E70 C E & -EH @4#, #AB O
a E., ' IE!
E A C
"!
O . F, A -E _9 3 "E9 < EA -Eg! M S E9 `E)l L H "9 C & -H @4#, #AB
"!
, . E r I#J $' I4, C #! < [ 1 C
C ' E .
"E R' @4E#, #AB
EEO $fEE& C EE A G nEE& ' PEE, -EEH C C EE 3 2 EE9 EEO / EE\F EE6 EE#0 g .
4#, #AB C A G n& ' P, I! & , H ) g! 9
<
1 E , ' C EAM •WE "[ O 3
%! , 89 " 0' 9
. ' 9 I#+ " 0' C A [ #Oc ' 1 /
EE 9 6 " EE9 EE, [ CF -EEO "H nEE& ' PEE, / EE, #[ EE -EEH EE6 EE!
Herzel,1946)
. (
n[ H / 2#H
=
I#J 0' I#+ /
<
/ " E9 S E9 EH -EO ", A
& ' P, n
< , !F [ 1#W4% G A -,
# , 2 F ' < # ! -H ,
89 -+%H
H ˆ M #[
, W6 † g! 6 '
. -H <1#W4% / … 6 C A -+#0 *
h ' / E - E #3 z ER' -EH C AM •W -O " m l ' ##} H + !F ' 3' C A
-O "W
= 9 M' A,F L H " 3' L 9 O $' ", AM ˆ M / IdR L
" 9 ' ' 1! "[ ,/ -H ' -
- `r ! 1 $ ! , 89 " F
E, . EH
)! 1# i -4
"! p 4* I#J M I4, <L
# ! / A,F <@4#, #AB / L' #3 -O O
"! 7 `r ! -O " F ' O $' l! , 'F -H 4,
E . E7 S Er /
<
'F C }! -H @4#, #AB -D,F x]* L H I#J C A
<
L EA 0' " g
<
E H L EAH
_[
"
H‰
/ , . H L' 4! "9 [ -O " AH
$ 8 E A,F M ! .
I#J E C E A "E R'
C A :^' H 6 :^' )! `r !
"! -4 EAH 1#E i 1 6 3 < O IEH R "
= EdR
%M ,
"8 O . -O "9 [ 1# i Z 4[ -H -M H
» , #0 « 4E3 C E]0 U! / "E+
Z 4[ %& -H " R' @4#, #AB " 4#, #AB 43 - ,
"!
O
"!
4 , :
»
@4#, #AB 43 O s ], I#J " # ˆ 9
.
/ I#J /
- 4E6 ˆ M
•%B L'/ F ' .
Z E! P E H ' , "! - 46 ˆ M / O N $ ! " R'
"!
"! -i L H H -O O
"! ' N , #7 M H ,
- 9 EQ 18E NE a EB
q+& H '
«
Livant ,2000)
.(
C EO EO * ' - E n[ L EW6 E+ @4E#, #AB / L' E#3 I#J E M I4, C M Sf6 H 9
L
"! T#B ", AM O
. I#+ E ' E#%! EH E#Oc - E n[ [ /
H af+ ! / _ [ L H "9 "%! 0'
<
L 9 ,' /' !
"%!
C AM #X,
" [ -)W !
" [
"H M ! @4#0 , # , ' "%! L 9/ ! L d &
. H
p 1
<
E M I4,
-! , H L M L H L O !F A -, I#J @4E#, #AB -E+%H 4E#, @4#, #AB L 9
' O "! +, CF
-.# , C' H ' - _9 3 < d "9
"!
, .
2 - 78
!
A 4#, #AB 43 / "6 H
<
O "8, +, @4#, #AB .
A,F ", E!/ @4E#, #AB , ) g!
), !F M' -H -O
"
' ,/
O ] C A L H de!
. ' -E]#Q' @4E#, #AB
" !cE!
, !/ = * ' z ^' ' K H ! A -g! M #4! -O @4#, #AB -O "
!F M H
<
A& H CF
[ R .
4#, #AB < !c! ' -]#Q' 1 p H EAM 9
C E A C 'F E[ <L EA #\ :! M / / C A C O … 6 '
<L EA 1Er
L A 0' I#+
' -E 3 @#+l L H Zf ' A,F 6 -H C A , C ‰ L E9
a R , E IE8& ' EA E%! : E ! xE]* ' E0' 1E x]* S 9 H A 0' .
@4#, #AB 9 ' E ' EO IE8& #) ! H ' " -H T Q' 1 L M
E[ _H "
"
, !
CF #de ' L A 0' .
- . -+%H < O +, CF d, A -, ' 1 /
CF H
"! [
".
"L ,'
G O
"
4#, #AB C' H I#J
"9
"!
4 , :
» a EE., EE! "[ EE,/ <@4E#, #AB .
EE ' 4EE#, #AB #\ NEE -EE+,F / qE3 1EE!
+, Z ! 1 _[ 9 $ 4#, #AB ^
$
«
Avnery,1968)
.(
' [ 1 EH -E+%H <CF L # H = B AM -, <@4#, #AB / ) ,
C C E, L
Tg^
CF L 9 I*
L A -g! M IJ 4!
"E! Zf M K E O
. EH - EA,F E) &
-g! M M IJ 4!
L A <
I*
"! M L 9 d%r
. E!
E O "E! @4E#, #AB
#E -EH
- n[
IJ 4!
O I*
. / n0 _M & IJ 4! I*
. 1 H H E), $ 8 H @4#, #AB
"
-EO
q# c AM
x]* ' -EH CF E H ' #E C 3 -H 2 !c! N < O ] I#J
H ' A, L O O "r -! " _7 M G U ,
)
<L 8l! N%!
1378
|B<
. 13 - 15
.(
4#, #AB 43 X, / @4#, #AB " O , O "! _ . @4#, #AB / n[ -O " 9
H am l / " , ' -E)W ! •WE <I#J C' -O " #
C EAM z ER' -EH
- #3 .
2), <L A 9 < A 0' C i "8#9 ]! L 7,/ H 1 # H a ##} 1
E O 3 C A H I#J C A k d ' # 9n!
L ' E^ :E! M E7
- 6 .
! C' H @4#, #AB ' @#9 E]! 1E / E6 L 9 #4] H <a ' ^ 1 -H -M
# H O
#Oc M IJ 4! H 6 H - n[ L 9 .
M ! ! 1 ,F
EA
$ [ ' 9 `#dW / K H 6 , , bŠ!
-g! M ' 0' af+ ! I* AM L
, H L A
. 1 / '
<
L A 0'
K E E6 : ! ' S 9 #)g L H I#J
<@4#, #AB / n[ _M "9 M H ' T g -J '
E M K E EH `EdW ! " 9
, . -%* ! ' M & @4#, #AB ‹! L H " f @4#, #AB 43 [ 1 H
"! ")% @4#, #AB -%* ! / gH L .
1
%* ! - H E6 L M " 4#, #AB L 9
H ' 9 #4] -H 9 "! " @#9 ]! / L M L 9
' "E -d M -+,F / 2#H -O
" #& ' " #\ -d M H - "d9n!
Evron,1995) (.
- 9 / 4 1: * ;<'
" 4#, #AB 43 L 9 - , Z 4[ -H -M H
@A! <C A C #!
2 3 1
EH L A C +] ! j 9 6 I#J F H L #bc -i L + C M 1 -O H 1 4E3 L 9 ! #3 ' bF <CF C ) ! ' @4#, #AB -H d4, 6 [ -H -M @4E#, #AB
O $f& ' … U ,
.
@4#, #AB r -O C ,F "E] ! @4#, #AB 43 bF 49
- 4,
"! !F O , ' O "], @4#, #AB -O ", 4O ! , ,
<
H 4E3 de! L 9 ! #3
#Oc @4#, #AB O
, .
# O -O _#, C ))l! / "6 H -, W#H "H / ,
E 9 -EJ L
<' 9 <@4#, #AB 43 "] ! ' de! bF -H , O
" .
" $ '
"!
4 , :
» 4E#, #AB 43 1# E#3 L{ 0 J E 1 _7 EM E M N { 0 J E L E d! NE E9
)
@4#, #AB (
E7 "E AM / ' "[ ,/ E -Ed M ' de! AM N / -O , O
"d U -d M ' "] !
)«
Wurmser,1999
.(
»
", [ «
! 'F I 7 , g
) :
» "E] ! ' Ede! -EM' ' @4#, #AB 43 .
4E3 -EM' Ede!
CF -EO E E) g!
2 9 #H -H @4#, #AB
# . 0' A L ' q#E c L ' EH IEH R E#\ I+ -H
„ #* L d& C H/
.
"E # @4E#0 , # , -EO E, E) & Ede! @4E#, #AB 43
)
@4#, #AB (
C 3 -H
E -E C 3 2 !c! 9n! ) g! -+%H #
. 1E /
' M L -%* ! -H I#J -O #Oc '
O - -H L/ #, C Ed9 ' 9nE! y*
4#, "d9n!
. C E M $ E! ‹E! & C #! @9 ' C +] ' C #! @9 [ 1 .
E!
+ F "] ! @4#, #AB 43 J
E 4E#0 , # , E^ ' 4E#, #AB E^ L{ 0 .
1E
L{ 0 J IB
A %! M !
"!
O - E n[ C ER [ E C E89 ' EH
O "! # c @4#, #AB .
"E f J [ E 1E E
/
C E r
qO E ' "Er L E9
€i "U ( ] N I#J M ! -O "r L 9 , "!
«
Gorny, 1996)
.(
1 . / >
- 9 / 4 ?@
H H I#J
<-E [ I+E CF #9 ! ' 0' / " 4#, #AB L 9 '
L EA "E 0'
. EA 9n! p H a R ' #8O * = 8& L g! -H @9 I#J 0' C H L A
A -H 0' 1 `%g L g! -H @9 ' C
.
-O " 0' I#J 0' H 1 H
1E `Edr E6 1#, ER ' & R ' T g < A 9n! ", d! p H 6 #&' ! O "! M ' :^' 9n!
. 1#E.& 7 + H # ' 9n! <" 4#, #AB H n0
, .
! 1
O !
C 4+
' [ L 9 L A
#0 g
"! ' l! " # L 9 / E
.
7 L /
<
C E A E#\ -O CF L g! -H C A -H I#J 0' 1 4, `%g !
, , " M I#J .
H ! I#J E 0' "d9n! #9 ! @9 <" 4#, #AB 43 L 9
2, O $ 8 -H `%g ! " 0' I#J -+ @9 ' "], )
-, C E A EA (
E TE g
. C E+! @9 CF -O N# O ! " 0' -H L A of! O " 0' / H I#J A,F X, / ' O E! C E+! L EA TE% U! L EA9' [ @E9 ' H @9 C A #\ $ \ ' GnM
[ I d < H - #0 g .
H H 4#, #AB 43
$ A]! / 9 0'
<
%! T g A
E 9 6 ##} _#, .
4#, #AB E%! / L yE& C EAM / L - [ 9 L A 9 < A %! T g 9
, "! A .
L 9 EO -Ei ' E H E!F E[ 1#!/ N C A 1 -i = *
H O 3 T% U!
.
"! A %! C AM C A -89 A,F
a M EA! E 6 '
49 I#J -H A,F
Evron,1995)
.(
4#, #AB T g 9n! ' #! R I! & < %! / 9
" 2), .
4#, #AB 43 "0' E , 9nE! ' #! R I! & %! T g 9
9 "! %M #89 @O ' , #[ "!
.
n! #! R L A,F X, /
E[ ~ ! 9
/ L -E& 8.! %! -+%H < F "8, G 4* -H %! N < H O 3 C AM O ' - [ 49 0' N #8O * ' l ' , !F [ 1#!/ N -O ", 4,
, 2), ~ ! " , 1 6 ' .
4E9 I#J E -EO ", 4O $ 8 T g 1 H
) L A #\ ' L A (
F "! G 4* -H I#J %! / "J_M .
I#J E / … 6 C A !
, "8, G 4l! I#J %! „_M
Avnery,1968,p.173)
.(
4#, #AB 43 T g a' ] 4E#, #AB T g H 9
$ EA]! ' E0' E#9 ! / E9
"! L ,' A `* ' #gH / T g ##} M ! < %!
. E9 " 4E#, #AB E H
I#J ,' A C AM / - [ 9 L A [ "! ! AH CF / " , ( )* / '
.
! 4#, #AB 43 -O "4O 9
@#)!
I#J [ " *
I#J E ,' A d, L A
A,F ( )* -O , "! TQ ! 0' ' "!
8, 1#8y .
4E3 TE g 1 H
4#, #AB G & L H H I#J 0' , ) g! 9
L 9 I#J E ' $ E8 L ,' AE ( E)*
= 8O
#7H X, .
4#, #AB 43 -O "] g H -EJ I#J E ,' A ' %! $ A]! / 9
!
"
O EO E9 6 ##} G & ' C # #W4% -H 9 "%#J " Z 7,
Wurmser,1999)
.(
3
<I#J q# c / q H
"%#J E C E#! G & ' C # #W4% -H d4, -O " 7, … ' E9
<
A,F
")* A -,
" M ' , , I#J
H
"E3 -EO , E "! ", 8 -+%
L H , 49 I#J
. 1 / '
<
-E! , H E # ' E9 EAM E89 < E9
! C EO ' El
- #!/
E EH C # #W4% #0 g L 9 .
E!
E H EH 4E#, 4AB 4E3
"
' C # #W4E% <
G &
' < ,' AE C & -H -+%H F "8, G 4* -H I#J 18 A -, I#J 1O L 9 , "! - 6 I#J %! / "J_M .
Œ& H -D,F
% EH " 8E ' ˆE M -H C # #W4
A E A,F ( E)* 1 E[ E , H 2 [ C
Mc Dowal, 1990)
nE0 (.
E[
<C E A
E O E & A,F L ,' A `* ' H #8 -H C # #W4%
<
EM ! -EO "%! E&
"! C # #W4% C #! "%#J ^ a 4* 1 U#7, H
"! 1#H / [ '
'
"E8J ˆE M
# #W4% ' C A 1#H E "! "] ! C
. EH p E 1E
<
V Er E. L EH TE% U! L E9
-J C A ' C # #W4% 1#H " 789 ' " 4 _89
Gorny, 1987,p.41-43)
Zf '(
" 9
a EB O ", , R ' - A, C # #W4% ' C A 1#H •#gd -O " #, R VfB L H _#,
1 - [ .
H [ L 9
4#, #AB 43 9
#[ R I8& L d!
"
L A 0'
"
L EM I#J
-H 6
"
N# O ! " 0'
"
"!
9 . -EH L EA #\ ' L A / @& I#J C O $ 8
"r -O ", # #W4% ' , "! - 6 %! N C &
9 = 'F a EB -H ",m r L
-O ", 4O a B -H ' < , H I#J E ,' AE E[ E ' , !F "8, G 4* -H ,' A
< E "E! E6 H EA,F H ' -M ,' A a H , "! G 4l!
- a EB -EH -Ei
I#J E E O 7 " %! a B -H -i ' I#J ,' A -
L ,' AE IE! O ( E)* /
3
" .
"
80 !
" # ! 1984&1985
' 1986 ) * + ,- . /0 12 "23
3 23 . 4 56 78 39 + : ;012 <=-2 .
# ! 1992 > ? @ !23 4 2 A 2 "2 7+ BC623!2 ,- . DC
2 BC623!2
"
" E6 -'
"
"
FC823 + ' " E6 -'
"
6 3CCG8 .
9 6 6 H .
S + " #g^' 1# i J E ",' L 9
S +E -Ei I#
1#EH L E9
S + -i ' C # #W4% ' C A "E,' $ .4E, ' EH "E! 29 EO C E A E6 1#H 9
[ "! @#+l I#J .
CF :Ed -EH ' C # #W4E% EH I#J ",m r - R ! 7 S r /
I#J ' G & -&/ ! 2O'
"!
O
" 4 _89 - #!/ ' I#J ' G &
@9
"!
[ .
2 -
- 9 / 4 "52 / >
4#, #AB 43 I+ ! C' H " 4#, #AB 43 I#J , Zf 9
M
< E 9 E%
4#, #AB 43 Z 4[ L 9 ! #3 "! X, -H !
@ E d, de! I#J L H @9 C i .
B L A J R [ R I#J I#+ L d! -D,F < E%! < E0' <C i "8#9 ]! / " 4#, #A
H C 7 H C A k d ' A
. 4#, #AB H H 9
4E, E6 hE ' L E9
9 , #3 7 + -H C AM O 3 C A .
C E A -E89 -O L l, -H "g8M C M'
1#H , H %! N -H `%g ! 6 C AM / - [ 9 k Ed < E, 'F EM' -EH EA,F
WE 1 6 E H ' ,/ R H N#, [ a B -H 1#W4% 1#!/ H O 3 C A
")* Ž#9 C' H C # #W4% ' @%4! 1#W4% H C A `* <- 6 IH R #\ 9 Q -H L 9 9 %M 1#W4%
. 4#, #AB 9 J R 1 H E,' 4, 9
"Er L/ E E%!
'
A 0' $ , -H " 0' O q#
x]* ' L 9 H H 0' 1 '
8, . [
J R " 4E#, #AB 4E3 L E9 J R <@#, H I#J $ )! ' 9 I+ " 4#, #AB L 9
"!
[ . ! CF =_0_ -H , .
" 4#, #AB 43 J R 4EU,
-E.# , 1#
-EO L 1#EH /
- 6 9 Q -H = B ' 9 ' H 1
"H M ! -O @4#, #AB n3 , "E 3' ' L Ed &
W
" # H L 9 9 6
E E A,F H I#J -O
". ˆE '/ E,
"
_#E
W C & -H W H I#J # H -O " 9
' O "! Os A, A,F 4 , "!
:
"
W 1 H a -H I#J
E E E9
. EH " 4E#, #AB 2dE M EA,F C' EH
E9 6 E / C E A L EH E6 #H nM ' 9 6 ' -H ' L M a W6
«
weig, 1969,p.70)
.(
E A,F H I#J -O O "! Os W -& 8.! ' _#, L ' [ {' E
.
- , -H
» E O "E! -E#M 6 L 9 # 9 W 1 -H „ + H I#J L ' [ .
L 9 ' ' A 1 / 6 " _[ ' L R L 9 J R < A / W 1 H I#J H ' 8, -J -, [ 9 / • ' n3 , - 6 " J R a B -H "U A,F -H +
I+ " 4#, #AB 0' «
)
<L ' E[
1367
.(
Ed & "EH H @4#, #AB 43 ' 1 /
- 3 :R ' <@4#, #AB L 9 W C O L 9
I#J
"H / "! n3 # F ' d &
.
"H W L d &
EA E0' -E X, <@4#, #AB 1 # H L 9 EH
"
Ed &
"E!
E / .
0'
#&' ! ' 9 CF p H ' 49 - X, N - 3 H 89 9 '
' S 9
=F 9 T g 6 L O "!
.
", Ed! ' E 9 TE g C E L X, • l0 / " 0' [
, , ' H - , 6 #&' !
= E! -%^ - ! -H "H "7, 7i ' 9
X, O @#
<
, ! "! / H 6 $' / .
- X, - 3 H I#J
"
EA 0'
"
EH -EO
0 ! @4#, #AB L{ 0 J
. 43 4E#, #AB E6 E[ "E * E9
, H @4#, #AB -H '
<
=_E0_ ! @4E#, #AB 1 E# H E9 WE -EO "9 [ V r H
"!
d! / - 6 d & "H A 0' L X, ", ,
.
"H 1 H I#J E <L EX, L d &
C ! F ' S 9 C %M ", 4, ' 6 a R C O " g! z' ! < 6 9 T g L 9
9 6 ' -H ' C lH H 6 .
E # " F O / A -, #&' ! ' 9 C lH L E9
"! I#J H 9 O 9 "! R W6 † g! 0' 1 M ! -+%
.
7 S r /
<
J R ( E)* ' E%! < E0' C Ei "8#9 E]! / " 4E#, #AB 4E3 L 9
-.# , <L ,' A ' C E A GnEM # H I#J CF p H -O "3 "%8& L
! , H / I#J -H a M A! -H A,F ` -
nE* 6 L 9 L EH "E9 EB ' E O S
G & GnM F H " #W4% C [ 'F ' 9
. E#0 g H H -O " #, R :, E! C # #W4E% L E9
G & - / ( )* `)l L H Zf ' O Sn* O "! . 1#W4% 1O L 9
8, / \F .
! C 6 C M -H e! -H C A a M A! C M -H I#J
a E#* $' E L H
"! - 4 7, 0' 1 '
» E !/ #, L A #g8M x]* -H 6 L )H L H I#J
«
Avnery, 1968, p.114)
.(
EH G E& E#g8M -Ed%\ ' I#J " #g8M #O ##} / ", 7,
E - E = } E! E6 -EH I#J E C Ed9 E89 <L A #g8M
)
! 1#W4E% a Eg0 W
<
1378
|B<
. 53 - 83
.(
#gR ' 1 -H -M H H -H I8& 9
L E g! -EH " 4E#, #AB 43 L 9
E -EH I#J E "E #g8M E#O E##} -EH NE8O ' C E A a M EA! C O ' l!
G &
9 . H 1 C "%8&
A 1 [ R #%R "3 -O L -.# , 9 C
1#W4% #g8M H H .
@ { H `)l [ , H ) g! I#J C n7, # H -O L_#i
"8, " 4#, #AB - 3 ,
H - " db H L 9
Barzohe, 1970,p.112)
. (
EH C [ 4 , / "6 H -EM
" #bcE 1#E i -EH
<
4E#, #AB 4E3
@ E ) EM !
2d M #W4% ' "H & L 9 "
' C # #W4% 1 [ a R , "!
. EH C # #W4E% 1 [ a R
1O E C # #W4E% <" #W4E% E0' I#+ E L H A,F "7 #89 ' "8J 6 -H -M 1#!/
"0 } L 9 1948
H / 9 6 , #3 C # #W4%
. / C # #W4% a B 1
R #%R C A ' … 6 #%R [ 9 6
. :^' 1 ! #3
» E9 6 " #g^' C 89
EEH EER EE 7 a EE -EEH 4EE#, #AB C EEd9 2#EE3 = EE EE. 3 -EEO EEH
«
Hammond,1999)
7 L / (.
<
E -EH "E #g8M E#O ##}
C # #W4E%
<
I#J E
O 9 6 T#gy a -H G & L 9 O IH )!
. E3 C E) ! / "6 H EH @4E#, #AB 4
E! #3 1E -H 9
<
@4E#, #AB 4E3 E , "E! ~ E, W6 I#J E L EH
" . ' #3 E
"
"!
4 , :
» 49 @4#, #AB 43 p "H ' Ir H a [ C +] ' / ' [ 1 .
EA,F
B l! " 9 O 2 -%# ' -H I#J -O , O Z ! ..
. EA,F S E9 -O
_#i N A :
I#J L H ,
«
) Shapiro,1999
.(
"
! O
"
%! -4 )! H @9
%! ' Ni O L 9
%! <v _H L 9 "4EO -H Ni O L 9
W6 -Xl0 9 2 M ! -O O "! -#d .
"E %! I#J E L' <-E! )! 1E EH
T#B L H , W6 89 -O Ni O
"! ' O "!
4 , :
» L , !{ 0' ##} TR' 6 @4#, #AB 43 8,
EO E. @4E#, #AB -EO
. -E 1#EH / L H E, W6 -O " B A ! " / H S 9 0' 1 ##}
H . W6 -O "W E " EO 6 S E9 1 L #[ "3 M' L H ,
. I#J E
%!
4# c /
"
! 4#, +i O %!
"
-O O l! CF C "!
. CF El! = E8 *
4#, #AB ^ L B -O "W 4E#, #AB 4E3 L 9 A E#3 H %H 9
-EO E9
"! V W! #3 ' ", 4, IJ 4! C & l
#H «
Krauthammer,1997)
.(
- ,
S + " 4#, #AB 43 L 9
"! _#, C A ",' L 9 O
. 1#EH -&/ !
4#, #AB 4#, #AB 43 ' 9
C M ' 1#H L X, L -&/ ! o 8& 9 .
1E / "+
'
<"d9nE! = EB / "E # "E J R EH -EO `E%g I#J E =' I4, -H o 8& C M
#
"g ' O @#X 6 L 9 -! , H ' 9 "d9nE! L E9 - H " #, R
/ L ' L M -g! M ' " # $ X, .
4E#, #AB 43 " g $' C M -EH o E8& E9
`%g I#J $' I4, .
E E O "E! ' m +E "9 [ E C M 1 ' I#J E
# 9 O T g d! 1 H CF .
-g! M I#J L
( E / -O ", A / O !
, !F [ C AM G \ ' .
a B -H 7 + H ' O :8M @9 ' -H #g8M 1 -D,F
4#, #AB L / -O H "0 B / , #3 %! N E V EW! "d9n! ' " " J R H 9
.
4#, #AB 43 -O "W
! $f& L ' ^ #\ ' Z' U! = B 1 9 x]* O "
"! R ! . -g! M $' ' C A 1#H L 9 , #3
#[
". E, 9'
"
$ , H "H O
"
"%#J
`H L 9
"
S + -H -M H :E! M -EH `%g ! C A 1#H M ! L 9
!F [ I#J -O T% U!
#AB 43 _#7, H Sf 6 a #bc H ,
"! @4#, 4 , :
» _M -H I#J -+ L
"d9n! < 9 d p' / O ! -+
<"Er L 9
~ AE C # E,
4#, #AB 43 <"r 9 6 I d M L 9 d "R ' 9
«
Hammond,1999)
.(
- , -, [ ' a #bc -H -M H -Eg! M "7i ‰+ ' a *' H " 4#, #AB 43 L 9
A I#J C
"
",'/ 9
"
C & H "H O
» EA 0' «
4E3 [ E EAM -EO
4#, #AB = 9
2000 O !
<
, :
» -, <"! X, L 9' #, /' ! -O A ' @4#, #AB 43 Z 4[
<a #H < 9 < 9
7 , 2UH 7 ' 9 I#J L 9
' L W6 <- [ H _#i $ 8 L H "gR
E9
"
E
4#, #AB C d9 ' =_ 9 -O Zf
"H # L H CF -H
H ,
«
Hazony, 2000,p.27)
.(
, 2 : ! &
"
' 4E#, #AB ", EAM E7 O 1#! EAi 17
"E0 21 1EJ'{
2002 E#H
O E E _E[ H p )80 -E! gWR ' EB EH E7 O C [ E O
/ E6 E 8* L
, O $f& @4#, #AB .
!F -! gWR 1 / " UH :
» E0' -EO "0 E* ' E H @4E#, #AB @i 3 " 4#, #AB 2d M -O "0 * I#J E E0' -EO "0 E* ' E E T g " 4#, #AB 0' N C & -H I#J
4#, #AB ", AM 7 O ( %U!
) -H
# 4U, AE 4E#, #AB ", AM 7 O 1
= q#J =/ H
1897 L EH ZfE CF ' E _E[ H =_E 9 ' Eu -H -O
# -H A 0' q# c
( NE I#J E -O 1 "! - [ -O L -.# ,
N# O ! ' 4#, #AB L A 0'
...
E#Oc E7 O n0 L E9 -E! , H $ E8 -EO
H @4#, #AB ' " O ! < A IB - L' H H I#J 0' " / !F .«
' `#8g AM L_ -! , H L H I#J 0' / 6 18^ 7 O -! gWR R <C M I4, 1#H @4#, #AB ' @4#, #AB H 2, ' a &fr 2 _ L M $
C M H -%H )! L H 6 @4#, #AB T0 U! L 9
. E7 O 1E EAM 1
Z/ !F ' [ N C I+ 6
EH -EO - 4E+ -E, ))l! ' 4E[ a EB
~ H L + E < E9 S Eg80 ‘ J ' E9
E^ ' L EA E^ 1#! yE! ' E O "E H E9
Sn* A,F / " 4#, #AB O
) world zionist congress resulotions,2002
. (
-H !
"
-EO E CF / "O E* <@4E#, #AB EH 4E#, #AB ", EAM 7 O 1#! Ai'
8 R L y* <C D89 @4#, #AB .
-, E, ' @E9 L E7 L E g! E#Oc 1 !
p ", 7, ' 4#, #AB
4E3 ' C ) ! 1 [ a R / 9 , #AB
4E#
E 9 . hE ' -EH
- , Z 4[ L H Zf H #Oc
L H A,F C O 8, ' C , M 1#H " 4#, #AB L 9
"! q+g ! ", 7, 1 "H 6 -H <C ) ! -H 1 ][ 3 /
. 1 / C E D89 E][ H '
ŒlH @4#, #AB
"0' L l! 2), CF F ' A 0' -H k H ! L 9 - E ,
L E9
- "9 7 M " 4#, #AB 43
"! -O , 9 R #bc l I#J -g! M ,
.
"! " B @4#, #AB 43 -EO E H - E 89 -H I#J L H de! L bF ,
-g! M I#J - 3 H " d! ' <-i ‰+ ' @.4 ! L
@#, H @+l 4! " 9 .
-H -M H E,'
I+
-Eg! M -O I#J ", O #g^' -H -M H ' H "g#dr #\ L ,' -O I#J L #[
L
S + L ' g ! L 9
E 3 @4E#, #AB ", , -H -M H ' C [ , [ af+ !
"! X, -H <C A M I4, L 9/ #, / L #4H -H 1 ][
' "] ! bF C M 1 G U!
H H CF de! bF / 2#H I#J L .
n0 4#, #AB C 7, a -H 9
, . N / A,F
- , P ' L H $ R a ' ^ H
"! #Oc CF = B / z ' " 4#, #AB L 9 ' E O
# L #[ "3 H 7 L / " 4E#0 , # , a 4E* -EH C / 1! ' "r ' L 9
L A
"!
" 4#, #AB 0' / z L 9 _#7, O 1#H
O ) C A .
' de! bF -H -M H -EH <L E / C E+] ! E ! @4#, #AB 43 L H -O "] !
-, #! ' 6 h '
<
# O - , #b , " 4#, #AB 43 L 9
@#E I#J F H
O . 43 "9' [
"E! @4E#, #AB C E8 ][ C' ", 8 ][ C' ) , N @4#, #AB -
, ' C M O ", M CF
"! G 4* -H I#J "%6 L 9 IE* L H -O , 'F
C lH -J ' H' A,F H I#J -O " 9 .
C +] ! 1 X, / E#8* -E+, D,F
L 8*
)
1385
<
w
(11
, -H A,F / I) 4 , "!
» 4E[ C lH -H "U 3 A @4#, #AB 43
@4#, #AB F ' I#J -g! M .«
'
» L E H E . @4E#, #AB 43 -.# , eO *
„ )H L H -O @4#, #AB / " UH a ' ^ CF " 3 '
.«
)
< ", EU#%&
1378 w<
19
1 / (
" f @4#, #AB 43 [ S E9 EH -EO I#J E "E +! M' @# L H
-J "M 6 ' "%6 L 9 / 1 O .
» 4E3 -EH C #0 g / M H I#J
4#, #AB 9
"!
N# +! " 0' 6 O
<
U -O 9 ) , 1
"g, ! ' n3
"8, . C ) ! #0 g H
< O g!
O "
.«
)
< ", U#%&
1378
|EB<
1 - 21
"E 7, 1# i H(
O "8, . I#J -g! M L ##} C i @4#, #AB 43 AQ .
< [ 1 IH )!
' 1 E# H L E##} @4E#, #AB 4E3 -EO M' ", 4O X,
, #! "%#J ' L A C +] ! 1#H " 6 i .
[ 1
E E) g!
EH 4E3 EAQ
E 9 6 E. " 4E#, #AB -g! M ' 9 - , " 44[ @4#, #AB .
@4E#, #AB 4E3
-Eg! M ' @4E#, #AB EH ", E 3 -EW), ' EO E9 6 . I#J -g! M @#X& " + n[ 9 6 " 4#, #AB .
I#%l 1 / G E& EH "! EX, ` r / I#J -i [ C [
/' #3
<
! " 3' = * q+& H ' , ` ! 7 • l0 /
)
< L 8*
1385
<
w 11
.(
-H I#J F ' O 9 6 . L # H a ##} @4#, #AB 43 [ 1 H -
-, [
#8O * C ' H a' ] !' 7 L 4#, #AB
9 / 9 6 @R .
-H -M H [ 1
S + T% U! L 9
<I#J -g! M S + C = g L H "%! & @4#, #AB 43
L E9
S + AQ ' 1# #3 - #!/ ' / L 9
"! " g! I#J " 3 ' L H L O
.
)
< -]# * 1380 (
H [ ' 1
#9 ! -H -M S + ' @4#, #AB 43
M ! L 9 EH ' I#J E
<z , 4*
44[ "7, 7i ' C _#!
"
O
<@4E#, #AB 43 AQ / q3 - I#J E -Eg! M
"! . , O -J 6 I#%l
.
! -EH -EM EH "g :H ! / "6 H
<"& 8 M ' " # L 9 ' @4#, #AB 43 1#H d4, L 9 E! #3 ' bF
CF I#J E
"H / .
4+ "H / _#, bF 1 E, EM' @4#, #AB 43 L 9 ! #3 H ",
.
-# * C 8 ][ N @4#, #AB 43 bF 1 / "6 H IEB EH E#O EH ' " g! L
" 4 C 8 ][
9
"E # L -
"E # ' "& E8 M L 9 E " E 3 IEH )! ' "& E8 M
-.# ,
-O L #[
»
"8, @4#, #AB 43 44[ ,
" E0 i @4#, #AB "
[ G 4l! I#J 0' ' -g! M L H L # H .«
)
<L 8*
1385
<
w 25
E! (
EbF / "E6 H
' "E # L 9 E -EH -M H -O < - 6 M ", 8 ][ @4#, #AB 43
"& E8 M
E 1 E[ a ER = E* I#J -g! M M
. [ E 1E /
<
# L 9 E ' "E
9/ #, M "& 8 M L
EA,F C 'F EH C E @4E#, #AB C E8 ][ -O 'F M H " ,
, .
! ' M K L H , ", 8 ][ @4#, #AB 43 H
C E8 ][ -EH CF C I d
<K%4!
-# * -H @4#, #AB C 8 ][
' "!
. A, # H $ 8 ' 1 /
"
E @4#, #AB H -O
9 6 =_0_ ! , .
E CF H I#J #&' ! -O A 0' - X, " *
"! -M ! C lH H .
< AQ = * C 8 ][ C & -H @4#, #AB 43 n0
"!
", lH ,
# ! ' . I#J L H U CF
O A .
)
<"8 R 1380
<
|B 318 - 323 (
4 H -D,F
"
C 8 ][
9 ' Tg^ -.# , ' "& 8 M ' " # L 9 " 3 '
", , C 8 ][
9 -E, 80 & ' `#R - ][ "& 8 M ' " # L 9 H L n[ #b L H
<
! H C 8 ][
9
"! ( B K%4! L O
-, 9 C 8 ][
K%4! / 9 -O AQ = * L
, , . AQ -H -M = '
9 C 8 ][
_#, @4#4O ! C 8 ][ -%8M /
- +, 1 !
.
EH E89 4E, H AQ = * C 8 ][ N C & -H -O "W @4#4O ! C 8 ][
-J H ' ' H 2#3 -H "& 8 M ' " # L 9
=F C ! F ' 9 9 ^ ) H ! " 9
' / " , L 9/ #, NE ' E* ' E I d K%4! C 8 ][ -H "& 8 M ' " # L 9
E9 ER #b l T% U! :! M "& 8 M " # am l C R .
1#E89 E!
-EO
H I d K%4! C 8 ][ -H C AM / "g# ' 4[
-
", E, ' " 4E IE#0 -EH P
"& 8 M ' " # L 9 H "9 89 T#g^
… 6 - lB / ' .
<C K%4! <1 [ a R < AQ -6 i '
o A, C … 6 C #! / ' Tg^
C 8 ][
E9
@ 3 C H C #! / ' 1 [ a R < AQ -6 i -H #4H G O 19 O p ! -O 9
Gf), 6
-#d O V W! "8%& L 9
Kuhn,1970)
O X, / (.
@ E3 19
E9
"! K%4! -+,F / q3 ' ' AQ -%* !
"E8%& L 9/ #, -H " 7U 3 " , ,
= P -H ! ,
@ 3 -O "! V W! L M L 9 " 7UE 3 C E K%4! L 9
, , A,F -H .
M @ 3 -%* ! 1 L
E. H ' O "! AQ P -H E
K%4! @ 3 " , H
<
"! O -H CF G M -O 6 ' ,/
= E L EH / E L 9 L E9
"! CF L M M
#[
.
@ 3 " .H M -H . ! -6 i 1 4E[ a ##} ' 9
-B &
-EB & CF :Ed -H ' "8%& L 9
"E! "& E8 M L E9 E
)
</ 80 Ei 1374
|EB 113 - 127
.(
8 ][
C 9 ' " # L 9 -H #4H ' AQ -%* ! _#, EA,F EH ' N _, "& 8 M
49 `dW ! .
1 /
"8, @ i -H C i A,F " 4 '
#4H K%4! C 8 ][ H p #R ' F
"! X, -H 3 .
"! = d) A,F / a -H 1 H H
"! ' [ #b , H n
. E!
I Ed K%4! C 8 ][ -H ' , # 6 = 8O -H ' , O "r 6 I* ! -+,F / gH ,
<
"E! -%B "& 8 M ' " # L 9 ' A,F 1#H P H E
-EH 1 E][ E 3 '
"! C , 9 1 / " , a ! _0 ,
. n0 / 6 L n[ #b a R
"!
E 9
-H 6 L M '
C 8 ][
9
"! "d#R L , M L 9/ #, -H 1 ][ 3 C -O , ‰
.
H @A! - +, C 8 ][
9
"! F -O 1 AQ = * L I Ed K%4E! C 8 ][ -H ,
, j #6 H - 4H ' C 8 ][ " 4 -H -+,F / 2#H = 1 -H 3 -O CF ( EdW, -H
"7 4H "& 8 M ' " # L 9 H ' AQ -%* ! .
EH ˆE 9 89 @ 4E#H C ER IE ' ' @9 / , C R 6 ' @4#, #AB am El
' "E #
"& 8 M
<
C & -H C A 1#H N
E I Ed K%4E! C 8 ][ -H ' O AQ C 8 ][
.
C C 8 ][ 1 -O "W C E8 ][ EA E "& E8 M ' "E # L 9 H ( dW,
= dR ! H C A 1#H
.
", !/ ! EH ( EdW, C E " 4E IE#0 -EH C E8 ][ 1E -O
< EE / "& EE8 M ' "EE # L EE 3 L 9 EE C EE8 ][ EEAQ L EEH -EE #!/
4EE3
4#, #AB "
#A! @4#, #AB #R C & -H .
' E -E%* ! / 9 M C 8 ][ 1
E E, I Ed K%4! C 8 ][ -H ' I! + = * .
1E / ' "E # L 9 E EH '
' C AM •W M "& 8 M -EH " 7UE 3 C E / 9 ' ( dW, I#J -g! M
E / "& E8 M ' "E # L 9 / " , a ! _0 ' 9/ #,
E E,
. 1#E i
" 4 ' 9 " 3 [ " #g^' C 8 ][
9
<@#9 R I#%l L d!
"E! -E.# , @ E#[
E6 C E ' a ER P E H K%4! C 8 ][ C & -H @4#, #AB L 9 E EH ( EdW,
' / "& 8 M ' " # a ' E^ ' E9/ #, -H 1 ][ 3
-Eg! M L E9 I#J E
C , .
1 / E#3 EAQ C E+! / ", 8 ][ C & -H @4#, #AB 43 C 8 ][ '
NE C E & -EH <"& E8 M ' "E # L 9 -H -M H -O "W ' O
# Q ' C +! AQ = * C 8 ][
' K%4! C 8 ][ -H C I d .
<I#J E -Eg! M M ! K C' ' E = Eg C E D89 @4E#, #AB -Ei [
"! G 4l! K%4! C 8 ][ ' - , I#J
<
-EH _E#, " 4E#, #AB 4E3 L 9 - , !
Z 4E[ <I#J E AQ , "& 8 M ' " # L 9 ' M K H C R dW, I#0
=m H ' -
' 9
< 4! ' @+l! 9 4#, #AB L 9 &
E#d%r 20 i -H 9 E,
.
' 1 1#H -O " 0 i
"& E8 M ' " # am l !F M' -H I#J L + C M
4[ #bc
"! ' L . ! L 7 T#gy ' "+ ) -H ,
. am El -+, i
)& / IdR C d0 G M " # ,
= I#J 2000
a M EA! … E! C -H ' <L f#!
1#H am l / gH I#J -H C A EM ! -O , -9 I ' ' 9 -9 6 ' "%%80
' / C A 4[ ' ' -
Z/ !F / -O E, H ' -EH " 4E#, #AB L 9
- I#J E -EH
C M :^ ! < [ 4#, #AB 43 L 9
O ) "
. / EgH 1#W4E% am l q+& H
1#H am l "6 H 1# D89 <$' -^ ] , / \F ' •%B a O n! 4+
"E%%80
= E E9 L
4#, #AB :^ ! #6 8, ) 9
.
"E%! EH -EO 1#W4E% am l ' " #W4E% "E [
:^ ! "6 H 7 S r / ' #O " #W4% 0' q#
L #[
1#H L 9 EH "%%80 - hE '
0' L /
<" #W4% 0' q# a ' ^ H " d! " 3' L 9
"%! -O
" #W4E% "E [
O )
<
"%! ) M ! - , ) -.# , ' L A " [
" 4E#, #AB L E9
E E _E#, I#J
". Ei "EH
"
-E0 )!
-E! ,/' L
"
a , E9F
"
EH
#bcE
L #[
L 9
= 9 I#J ' C # #W4% 1#H #6 L , @4#, #AB H
:
» - n[ = )
1#W4E% $' -E^ ] , / IEdR (
EAM L E#[
' " 4E#, #AB 4E3 L E9
[ I+ ,' -H -M H -O " 9 -EM ", EAM CfEO E#%! N -H ", AM +9 L #[
H #Oc H <
C "8 R AB
@4#, # EH -E Z 4[ ! C #!
. E#6 t E* E!
O „ #* @4#, #AB .
...
"%#J ' C A L H @4#, #AB 9
E6 2#3 = N -O
"! ", AM -g! M ,' A -%# ' -H 4,
I d 6 / z L H L
«.
1#H am l #bc H L' AB „ #* H "%%80
"! @4#, # 4 ,
:
» H H L H Zf 4,
" 3 h, H @4#, #AB 1
<
%#J E E^ a ! R '
"
...
"E g! '
[ 8g C & -H L A @4#0 , # ,
<
" #W4E% @4#0 , # , 1 6 #8 -H IH )! '
) = C H ' pfM -H 2001
c / E 8* " E3' L 9 EO :^ ! ' q#E
" #W4% 0' (
[ L A @4#0 , # , @#+l ' ) M !
«
Bechor, 2002)
.(
, P ˆ M 33 E n[ L EM H -E, [' L #b C d0 /' .
I#J E "! EO , -E.# ,
"E8, "dE ! IE* ˆE M -O " 4#, #AB 43 [ "! X, L/' #3 4O E,
EH '
H / "! X, a ! R Sn*
-! , L 9 4#, #AB 9
<
E#O G & ' C # #W4% H 7 ][ '
<
) .
I#J 0' -O ", 4O [ 'f& -H [ 1 -! , H L M
6 L 9
G_* H H
"! " g! !F O , C d0 ’ E, O
<
a E) , / L E … E!
E^
E0'
U#7, H I#J " 4#, #AB , E I#J I8& ' - , L # H a *fB 6 '
.
ˆ M _#, "6 H IH )!
33 A ' W6 M' / ", , /' L H
EA E%! ' 0'
, O " g!
. -EH @4E#, #AB ! ! A -, " 9 A 1# i M' H -O #O A
x]* L H -+%H # , C 3
I#J 9 E A IH )!
E8, E ) CF E H .
1E
' [ H
- , )
- 3 @#+l ' " 4#, #AB L 9 E, O E#O A 0' L 9
. E! 1E
C M :^ ! )
43 IH )! " 4#, #AB L 9 4#, #AB
9 89 -H .
+ # EH "& E8 M ' "E # am El #bcE -EH -M H - E ,
' " 4E#, #AB 4E3 L E9
H ' @4#, #AB
"r I#J -g! M <I#J L + C M ' 1 7 M -H -M
= E9 L
L #[ O F ' CF H -O " R ! ' 9
-EH 1#EH 20 Ei ' " ' E ' - lEB < E '
4#, #AB 43 ' 9
4#, #AB H 9 6 9
. am l / 20 i 1
" # -
#bc "& 8 M
"!
"! _#, #bc A,F H ! n3 n[
. 1 H H
<
1 E[ a ER :, E! E, H @4#, #AB -+
E O xE]* K%4! C 8 ][ C & -H 6 #gR ! ' @4#, #AB 43
<
4E3 -E+ E
„ ) 6 #gR ! ' ,_H O @4#, #AB , H @4#, #AB UH
<
-H L EH A,F " ,
I#J -g! M ", O L 9/ #, -H C 3 .
z E R E 3 E, H @4#, #AB [ E O
L
am d, L H
"8 4E#H C ER am E / ' 4#, F @4#, #AB H C i -O "%4,
4#,
<
9 -J
<
"!
E9 -E! E6 a E#* -H , .
, @4E#, #AB E[ E!
4E3 ' E,
L EM P E -EH E H E M E9/ #, ' am L 7U 3 ' O 3 „f6 1 @4#, #AB @4#, #AB E9 6
E[
1 . E E O E # -EB & ' a E!
#bcE "E%8& L E9
43 4#, #AB 4#, #AB / 8O 9
A O %M .
"! X, -H ! +E EH a E! %H E
B Tg^ C
< M "& 8 M ' " # L 9 H ( dW, @4#, #A - E ,
4E3 L E9
I#J -g! M " 4#, #AB o )#8&
9 6 R #bc l .
A4 2 7B
:
-
"9 D :
1 -
< #8* <L 8*
) 1385 (
"<
" # L 9 -
' "& 8 M
I#J E @4E#, #AB 43 C 8 ][ AQ
"
<
L L
8 <
71 .
2 -
< 8* <-]# * )
1380 (
<
&' >. =2T :
Z P L M @ +0 d& -8M <
) C A :
C 3 ‰ a ,
.(
3
"- I# "8J ", 7, #g8M
"
) 1378 (
<
3 [' + R9 [
$' 8 <=' = <
.
4 -
< S 10F </ 80 i )
1374 (
<
= &' : <
<$fO d / #g -8M )
C A :
"7 9 ' "8%& a , .(
5 -
< dO "%& <", U#%&
) 1378 (
"<
@4#, #AB "! A]! L A#[h '
"
<
C [ + R9 [
a Eg0 W! ' "8%& L A 9'h3 _O ! <
=' 8 <-, #! ' 6 N h .
6 -
< @O * < "8 R )
1380 (
<
%K C @ ? J B 6 "B & % 6,4
<
)
<C EA 7 E, < " # $ %& L O -! , C 3
" # $ %& ' ( )* + , .(
7 -
< {' <L ' [ )
1378 (
<
J 2 6 =' >. "Q ,
<C 7 ' ]gM -8M <
) C A#O a , <C A .(
8 -
< {' <L ' [ )
1367 (
<
F \2 ]2 F :
[
@
J 2 6 ^5 4 C
<
<T #.! -8M
) C EA : -4E !
"7 9 a ! 6 .(
9 -
< ^ #8* <L 8l! N%!
) 1378 (
"<
4E4[ N n[ N / "! AH <@4#, #AB 43
"
<
3 ['L + LR9 [
=' 8 <=' = .
$ -
"E B :
1-Avnery, Uri.( 1968) Israel Without Zionists: A Plea for Peace in the Middle East, (New Yourk and London: Macmillan).
2-Avruch, Kevin. "Political Judaism and Post-Zionist Ara", (Spring,1998), http://www.Findarticles.com/mo411/n2-V47/21042657/P1/article.Jhtml
3-Barzoher, Michael.( 1970) Ben Gurion: A Political Biography (Tel Aviv, 1977) Vol.2.
O.641. and Moshe Sharett. Diaries, (Tel Aviv) Vol.1 P.112.
4-Bechor, Guy.( 2002) "The Palestinian Contribution to the Revival of Zionism", Yediot Ahronot, (March).
5-Brandeis,Eben.(1999) "Post-Zionist Zionism: Towards the Jewish Democratic State", http://www.newhouseofisrael.com/rp-postzionism.htm
6-Evron, Boas.( 1987) Jewish state or Israeli Nation?, 1995.
7-Gorny, Yosef. Zionism and the Arabs: 1948-1982, (Oxford) PP.41-43 8-Gorny, Yosef.(1996) http: //www. tau.ac.il/taunews/96winter/zion.html.
9-Hammond, Andrew.(1999) "Poison or Cure?" , http://www.Cairotime.com/content/region/newhist.html.
10-Hazony, Yoram.(2000) The Jewish state: the Struggle for Israel,s soul, (New York:
Basic /New Republic Books) P.27.
11-Herzel, Theodor,(1946), The Jewish state,( New York:American Zionist Emergency Council)
12- Krauthammer, Charles.( 1997) "the New Republic", (September).
http://www.Yahoodi.com/peace/postzionism.html
13-Kuhn, Thomas.S.,(1970), The Structure of Scientific Revolutions ,(Chicago: University of Chicago Press).
