» «
& /
0 * 1
1 2
34/5 3 6 7 8 /#
) :& 4;
6 <6 * 8= >
(
7 8 2
@A 6
) :
22 / 4 / –90 :
7 / 12 / 90 (
B : D' E 4F 16 G 0 H&4I
=J0 K L I
&M
<6 1 . 4O H& E
= 4L P6I 5
I 1 Q I 1
"F
&M
<6 6 R 4&
1 4O H/ 4;
3 F H 1
"=
RM 1 ,/
E
#
&
&M 3 F # E & R 1 0&
F S' 1 T4U V41
&
3 F T4>
1
&M *
<6 6 /V 4'
+I E
&M W F .
4O X+1 & B T4U 1 :F S' H&
H&
4; F V 4A &JI L4
<6 5
6 R 4&
3 F 4/ ' H/ 4; 4O 1
" F V 14 I V * 3 = 1 Y /Z
.
3 5 R ;[
: 6 <6 0& & F S' &M
* :
: 8292570 - Email: [email protected] 0811
! "# $% &#
' ( ) ( % &# ! *+ ! ,- . " $"# / % 0 ( "1 .
% 3 4 / "5( ( 1 "67+ / % 89:5 ; 9 89:5 ( 5 1 5 1 / % $% &# ( ! ,- . ( <=% &# / >?
@ 1 ' .
A + B $"# $% &# 3 C D E B
9 89:5 " F G5 ! H = B " I B" / % =@ ? ( ( J( % K 5 <L H( ( % K / 9 89:5 / "4 L ! ( ; " $"#
/ % "4
( ' ! 9 89:5 " F G5 "M ! , *
5 9 89:5 @ ="# ( ,- . K
. ( N"+ + B
5 % ! I M 9;= K O@
.
F G5 ! " *+ - G I : B (
9 89:5 4 ( "
P Q 9 89:5 ( , * / % K + >" 09+ ! "R="#
> ( S 5! % TS ( 5
.
% B :5 T#
>" 09+ U + " V+ % ( )
! + > 5 - 8 Q
.
»
X( % ! C /
/( @ ,
« H
» / % =@ 6 ( F G5 Z"4[+ /
B"
I
«
» K ( " 6 ( F G5 Z"4[+ /
« H
.%
K ( # 5! P \
9 89:5 ! 8 (
P Q
@ 1 % K ' :5
@ 1 % K ' " 7+ ( 9 89:5 < :+ / .
! ( +
% 89:5
H 9 89:5
$% &#
Z U / %
O' ]* ( < ( / ? L L E .
1 ( ; 5 5
%
G5 H K ( # ? ^ _ 89:5 ?L
» B «
8 (
»
@ ; RI
89:5 ?L
« .
% >" 4+ , ' C ( K G5 ( ( 4 /
% 89:5 5 ( ' .
*+ 1 (
» " + «
0 =1
HB"="# / %
P Q .
) H 1363 : 240
89:5 / "# T# ( : 4 / (
0 F G5 =1
89:5 F * @ B"="# / %
5 .
) ? / H 1(
1380 : 13 - 14 (
G5 :5 ," *+ (
» « U + R ! +
% 89:5
< H .5 ( / 5
I * # @ j 5
% 89:5
89:5 ?L ( ( [' k9
1 ( ( 89:5 I M " ( H " T" <5 H ; ! H .5 @ .
+
1 ( B ; 11
89:5 ( ," *+ H - 9 89:5 l ' ,R' C
( 5 + 5 9
) ? / H 1(
1380 : 13 - 14 (
! " ( / < ( <5
% 89:5 @ H( ( (
»
/ /(
«
% 89:5
.
» 1( / ? ( ( «
8 (
»
3 4 ( ( / % $R / /(
« (
. 5 " B :
»
% 89:5 / % $R
/ %( X *+ $ = ( (
! 5 1 =# / @ H "
»
/ /(
« H
»
«
» ( ?5 «
% 89:5
F + / * 5 1 ( (
89:5
%
.
" = 5 1 1( H/ /( l 5 B ( 4
"
. 1
5 % K 4 % H ( $R
) 5 (
? R% / R% (
.
B"="# / 4 / /(
) 9:5 "4 1 (
/ "5( ! ( ( _"5 / < ( ".)+
@
) ? / H 1(
1380 : 13 - 14 (
$% &# G5 ( ]* (
»
?L / * « - . ( ( % 1 ( _"5
! ! F V5 % ;% .% 4 ! 89:5 ( / "# T# " 9:5 (( 1 B" [+ 89:5
) * / H 1382 : 56 - 58
.(
l V (
B G5 ( " )+ % 1 ( :5 ," *+ (
?% 1 ( H 1 ( ( k9n B"4 ( ( 89:5 I M "4 "
F V5 89:5 ?L ( = "4 L .
1( / ? 1 ( B" o %
9 89:5 1 ( I M "4 B""R+ / % / * ?L . 5 + 5 / - '
% 89:5
@ 1 G5 ( .
?"1& p4 L 1
% / 5 +
% 89:5
,n ( 5 .; $" > I M
89:5 5 6 9:5 E .M
.
( + H .5 ( 89:5 % & 89:5 % 1 5 1 ,M
% 5 ( 1 "67+ q( M / R% " B" o % U + " H A 89:5
% 89:5
% / ' + 5 ( ( )+
% 89:5
( ( - .
( / % G5 F + 9 89:5 & "3 rK ? %
*+
9:5 / % ! F9 B ( / % )Is t"'( K "5 ( ( ' ( K "67+
%( ( u)M ?5! t:*+ ? ( 09+ % ! ( B""R+ + ( ( ! @ 1
9 89:5 F + / " H89:5 K K ( / ?R" ! O@ _"5
>% @
>" 5 B" [+ ! ! ( 5
) . H 5 v 1388 : 33 - 56 (
1 -
» . 5 « 1 5 ," *+ / % &# ! / # / ?;" ;+ ;
H . 5 _ + 5 ( ( ! ," *+
! / % 5 O ' / ( V
1
H % V E
/ !( 1 9\ % ( (
. w w%
w + R % 0 / ( % &# ! C r*
: / w% <I w w"?
>w?@ $ _@ H ! ( ;)+ R H/ " / % " @ K H ! >V. %x
" A"* ( v (
" ." / R% ;)+ t =+ H 5 )
H 5 " M 1391 : 259 (
w + R .% @ % / ( % :
w4I Q / w w /( w ( w zU=w
H 5 ( I H " 9 B"4+
( wK { w% tw:*+ / w + 5 ; ?5! &+
4I Q ( > ." C *+ Z"3 +H 5 (
) 5 " M H 1391 : 265 (
w ( Zw U / w% w P w\ w w+ (( 1 09+ % &# ! 0 B (
$"# H ?5! ( ]* l
A w 5 ; + ]* ( ! % "
(( 1 - , * .
2 .
I : B / % Q
% 5 * L E
P w\ / R
% " @ .
w ! X w*+ 9 89:5 "% C * .
F ( w*
,- .w
89:5 / $"#
F *
, I B" F G5 X *+
. w @ P \ E w% "
> ( # ?5!
.
| # ( ,"K( / % "}
/ w"1 w? ( w; HA"w* wM w ( 3 C
M \ .
w 5 w? w 5 X w*+ w I B"w A"* HA"* G
! AR+ X *+ K ( A"*
. / w"1 w? w*5 >w% ( w; G
w w5 / w ! 5 w I B" 3 ( 1 5 "1 >" r+ F '
=w w > wM
. / $"w# ,- . H 9 89:5 "% * E % "} B B" o %
B""R+ ! Q"* "6 + H 9 89:5 .
w+ w 9w 89w:5 w ! ( L Q )1 o5! +
( 5 >" +
w % l ' ; ( ( 5 P \ % %
5 L + % B
w 6 w 9 89:5 ! /
w% CX w H w-
>"%(
.
+ R % B
:
/ w w w M 9w 89w:5 / w% w ! C
! { % "~ / < ( 9 89:5 / %
. B"w / w% =w@ w ( F wG5 Z"4[w+
w w+ < ( k ?5 K ( / % =@ ( F G5 Z"4[+ H I
( 5 ( K { % % ! " ( 9 89:5 5 @ ="#
.
1 - 2 . !" # $
% & " ' ( &
w ]w* ( w 9 89:5 ! ," *+ / + % ;
9 / ? F G5 ( ! • V+ 9 89:5 "% + B ( ( '
w)I w 5 / w% $I wL w ! ( F G5 ( /( @ ( 4 +
; € I - w / w%
# ; % "4 :+ % "4 Z"4[+ H % "4 , 4+ "4 " $"#
.
w3 ( % < 4 "5( / / "5( : 4 B
5 •5 ‚ + 5 4 (
. 1 ( B E
O %
wL 5 w
( 5 % K \ >. X ; ".
) . v H "=
1380 : 98 - 145 (
"*".w w ( 8 w~ ( w @ 1 ,;w / [@ HCX B 5 =# ( + / w5 < 5 w Z"4[w+ ( / % ;M ! T# ( : B "I +
w w% w ;M K + T#
w _w"5 w5( w w ;M F9w F w5 w
5( ! / >. X ; .
w Bw ( w w R / w% ;M 1 ( B E B
w % ;M l 5 B ; _"5 9 89:5 C
.
) . v H "=w 1380 : 98 -
145
B ? / % = n ; + 9 (
w5 ( w ( "~ ;M l 5
H w w ( w"~ / % ;M O@ ƒ 4+ ( k - ( ( ;M / % ! { %
{ w% w% w ! w .5 + % U5 % K / _ ( K ( K ;M l 5 B
( B"4+
.
@ 1 G5 ( ;5 L B (
. C
r ( N ~ ;
=5 @ 1 G5 ( B ( "*". F9 / % )+ 5 . <5 .;
. =5 - ,% 4" / % 1 ( " /_ + _"5 F9 ]* ( 9
1 ( 4" F9 t" 1 ( ( @ 1 G5 ( .; ( % ) R
) / 1 \ @ B " ' B"I 4" "5 ( 5 "U ! ' F9 .%
nasr.2006:30-31) .(
5 @ >. X ; / F9 ? ( % I ( K
( R5 ( K 9 ~ " = 5 C 3
) .
H v
1372 : 99 - 110
;) % (
8 5 F9 @ 1 3 @ % I ( B Z4 „ Q*5 5 ( 5 09+ . 5 @ 4 .
/ ( ( 9 / % I ( K >% 1 < ( R
5 ( 5 / "# 8 5 F9 ( B H 5 ( M >. X ; .
+ w% K w < ( + 5 ( 4" I ( ,"3 5 R (
wI ( Bw ( w 5 .w : w5 " 1 >. X ; 3 4 < ( 9 / % ;M _"5 9 89:5 ) F9 5! <5 % I ( < ( ( ( % 1&
5 R @ 1 4" < % @ /( :
.
) . H # Z"QI / % v 1380
: 45 - 75 (
/ ".w 1 w ( E w w w w Bw w@ 1 wG5 ( w w / < ( ;5 H < " *+
/ ".w w ( w @ … w)+ 5 w ( w w "5 w =w 9w 89:5
( / % ;M r 5( : 4 = 5 " ( K #
. + " B (
+ NI 9 89:5 ( ;@ ,=" 1 (
.
w w: 4 V . O"=+ / % = 5 ( 9 89:5 / % " @ w ( w:) 8 ~ • % @ ( % 1& / ( O"=+ N%
. w1& ( /
"67+
+ R O"=+ N% / % M ( 1 1
w F ( : w
)
‚w ( ( $w:5
4" F( 1 5 2
! $:5 4" "5 M ( w B ( u)M ( %
.
! „ wR+ *5 w w%
5 1 , ( B
B" [+ O"=+ N% # / ( w" 8 w~ ( wI † w
: #
( ( "5
) . v . H .w1 5 [ 1384
N% w C w4@ $w:5 / (
4 B ?<5 B ( HO"=+
! / % w ~ }" R+ {9K
"67w+ w*+ w w%
!
HT / %
»
% "@ B ( 5 (
«
( w+ w B ( B ( H
w w%
wwG5 ( ww ww ( ww M ww K /_ww"L ww F( ww
ww+ ! .ww"5 wwR Bww
.
) . v .
H @
1389 (
B"w o % H w w )1 9w 89:5 / "1 ,; ( B ( $:5 ( o5! +
! ) A 9 89:5 "%
% ;M < ( % 89:5 < ( w+ 5 H
F ;* 9 89:5 @ 1 V" 5 >. X ; / M
. w R5 B" o %
K M % G5 N ~ ( @ … :+ "4 ( ( K 9 89:5 ( 0 @
w tw:*+ ,w ' "~ 9 89:5 / % ! 5( B K ( ;)
( ! % U5 F ( % + M
. L ? + 5 w @ w% ; ( 5 ‡ "4 B"
( 1 + + O5 ,- . ( ! 1( ! 9 89:5
. 9w
.w5 + w@ 1 w' ! / $"w# K K ( / % $I L % * (
5 ? 4 / 1 "67+ / % . >;* . ( K ( 5 ( V
.
/ w =wI L >w% w ( w ( wK ( ( 5 w )1 / wM 9 89:5 ! 9 )1 / w% 1 % = < ( 5 @ "67+ .5 + >% ( ( K ( A . / %
( ? "
) H =K ( 1391 : 29
89w:5 l w' Tw# w M w I M ( B (
+ K ( w w L (_5 ! ( 9 89:5 # _"5 1 ," * I w4+ @ =w"# ( ( w ( ( wK M 89:5 B 5( ( "R="# C
( "#
.
" ' K >? I
% / 5 +
% 89w:5 w # ,w w w + / R"
9 ! ( 89:5 / ! ( ?5! $:5 + ? .
l ( ]* ! "% ( + ; 9
/€ I - .
;R ( )1 " B (
;R H 5 ( R% < # %
%
"6 + ? $:5 B; k ( + x
1 + / + 1
( X ; @ / %
C ? 5 ( ( ‚ 5 %( ,; x )5
2025 ( .
H :":M (
' R% ! ( >" "5 M / R% 4Q: % >"5 +
9 %
/ "1 ( =' ,M ( 3 B" ˆQ ( ! / %
I .
R% ( B " K ( >% x )5 ' N. ( 6 "
@ 1 ' R% } R .
>"5 Z U $U ( ( 5 . C HB" / %
@ 0 .1 "5( 8 5
.
>%
5 < #
» I K "
«
5 . /
»
"+
"
I «
( B
{ 4 < # B" I K 5 < # / Q H 5
? ( (
)
C ; ( _VI
.
www.cic.nyu.edu) (
R% / % K 1 ," *+ K G5
" 5 +
( ! / ‰ rU
/ H " <RU5 " K ( x )5 \ R+ _ ' @
( %
.
•5 C M ( ? ( B ( $:5 : 4 :":M ( /
.
•5 B ( $:5 ? + 5 ! ( ( =" „ R 5 < )1 NI Q +
( ? < ; =5
( ( 5 ? R
. : @! C ( "K X *+ B" o %
) 2001 (
$R B"% + ( + Š B" o %H( ( / 8 ? ( %
R S ( R "# B"% + ( % > "@ 5 5 . : 2012
( "I + ;
( F9 ? + 5 ( ( =5 H
/ % ; =5 •5 B"5 ' l
5 ( " 7+ H > M 5! 4 9 B"5 ' ; 9:5 .
/ "
9 + 9 ;)+ HF9 "M V+ %( = 8 / "5( ( 9 / >G5 >I "I ) >G5 R
,; 5 Q:5 9 ;)+
/ "1
! ‚[5 .
( "K X *+ ( ! ~! ( 9 89:5 / "# G5
! ( ( 8 / "5(
.
/ % 5 0 _1 ( B" o % 2025
~ / # ( 5 . "4 >% =U
"4 0 _1 " $"# ! ( ( ( ‰ r K B" # ( 5 .
15 + 18
" "
)5 . 5 . _" B ="
- 3 ( =% + $ B"
- .% .5 @ ( )
" " ‚ #
)5 ( % ) )5 " " ( M (
5 . 5 ( ' % = ! T# H
4 + 6
( ( ‰ r K ( K ?5! "4 3 ( I! 5 5
) )5 " " >"5 (
v 5 ( H
) 300 )5 _%
(
$ + H )
500 )5 _%
( T"- ) 350 )5 _%
.(
_"5 "I T" <5
( K ( 5 . /( "4 / ( )5 " " >%( =% N"+ + 5 ( ( /
www.cic.nyu.edu)
.(
% 5 1 "R="# B E
I ( ? 5 /
) B"<5 " ="
( (
C + ~ / # H
2025 H 25 + 30 ( % K . " "
.
% =
( % K ( K ' N" + ( 4 ""}+ H .% 5 . $ _@
.
&
:I ,; / ? M 5 I M (
/ 09+
,;= F V.5 / .; / %
(
www.cic.nyu.edu) (
4 C M L 1
"
) B V5 ( ( (
C + ? / %
2025 5 I # 1 5
# H 5 ! ( K K ( " / % ( C / @
"
$
"
(
5 . „ ,- .
*3 %( ,; % K , R+ + _@ 5
# "
1 ((
/ % 5 0 _1 / % ;
2025
( ( # F9 % ?5 (
HE B
5 % K ' / ' % F9
. ' @ {9 K < ( 1
" %
$ + ‹ = F9 ( % K + Q
. 9 "I 4@ $I L
$ 5 +
+ / %
( % *". "I 4@
.
; < ( # "+ H V"5 ( R5 " : @! ( %
' @ ( % K / .
C (
2025 H ' @ < % G5 l + D. ( 4 / %
5 +
$I L R" +
% U.5 R% B"Rr4 H 1 ‹ "M >.". /
/€ I - < (
( % :R\ „ X ; / %
www.cic.nyu.edu)
.(
w w + = 1 5 3 ( B ( ( ( /( 9 89:5
! ( "4 w% K Z"4 "4 B" L l ' C M H > ( 5 >" + ? /
( . w6 ( 9 89:5 / % ! ( , 4+ C M B " $"# B
w? w ! w ( w w E w B H ( ( ( 5 " 5 ( / % =@
% K <5 B ( $:5 > $"# >. X ; /
.
w I M ( B
_w"5 w+ •w5 w# ; =5 + •5 ! ( B ( $:5 ? + 5 > ( % = .
I R' , ' / 5 + 5 / B
.
_"5 B $"# H B B" o %
9w 89w:5 / % (
( 1 P Q .
w 1 Tw# w; =w5 tw:* B ? + 5 ( % =
w )1 w C wR' w"K / w% C w ( 9 89:5 / % ! K ( { *5 +
=" 89:5 .
9 89:5 ! / % C ( ; C M B
w% ! , 4+
G 5 ( H
.
89:5 = 5 ? + 5 H ( @ … )+ / % = ( k "K +X *+ +
w / w% =w ( M ( 0 .1 = 5 B ; " <5 _5 9
–
/ ' / % K _"5 9
w" Ow@ 9w F ;M / ' ( ;M
w+ w "K X *+ ( 5 5 ( ( ' F( / % K EΠ( H 8 VM
( 5 T5 +
. , I B" F G5 ( 9 89:5 = 5 )1 + N"+ + B
@ ; ! ?5 { %
9w w + ( wV 9w wM
( ( ' H …9K > "59: B ( #
) H/ R% >G4 F : 26
/ 6 / 90 (.
2 - 2 - )) (" * & +' ," - . / 012
w " % _- M ". "I ) ;)+ R I B" F G5 ( + ' / % # .
( w > wM ,w< 5 w' w % w / =w5 =w + $; ,3 5 1 5! F G5 B .
H/( r ' , ; ( 5 G5 R @ 3 + ' / % # H I
( ...
$w:5 w 5 "
) ? .
( N"+ + B ( wV w< ( ( w % H w + ' / ? I ( O' / ".
+ w + ' / % 5 + I ( ( ) *5 R.5 _1 % L 5 ( ?+ E
( 5 ( . w I ( + ' / % # ' ( ( ( " %x B % < ( R
5 =" ( K " ! ' C <5 ? I ( ‰ rK < $ _@
. (
V
,; %( *+ 1 5 ( Z U l 5
( "1
) H 5 'H R "
1378 : 18 - 29 (
+ R ( 5 " K :Q ( Q F G5 9 { % :
†," w O@ w B" [+ B" + † 4 3 / "5( :Q /€ 5 B @ B" [+
" F9 R w; ! •w % @ 0 .w1† 1 ( " >. + R
>. X ; ( ! ( r ' H ( ( V $ # (
hoffhngtonpost,2009) (
w w Bw ( w 5 >"w + 89w:5 w ! / w + % < ( ; I B" A"* 6 9 89:5 / $"# / % 5
w 5 w? X *+ 5
< % @ / % $I L =+ N -
F wG5 Z"4[+ N B; % K "
(( 1 9 / ?
.
w w ( 1 P wQ 9w 89:5 / % ( _"5 B ( +
I B" / % =@ H "R="# o5! E ( w# w H 9w 89:5 "
% K Z"4[+ "= % U5 I \ ! % K .
% =w@ Bw B ?
+ R C M + 89:5 / :
TRw\ G5 > ?+
) 1358 0 (
€ w5 w+(
) 1359 0 (
/( rww ' > ww*+ ww3 * )
ww $ _ww@ C wwM ( ( ( ww ( ww ww+
( H
•ww
" *+
) 1359 - 1367 0 (
.# 0 G5 ?+
)
.5 }@ … M 4
( ...
H =@ / % ;% ; w ? / % = N ~ ! ( ( " *+ •
w5( 9w 89w:5 /€ I - ( ( * C R5( F 3 ( K / % M
. w w
( 1
( wR5 9w / ? F G5 Z"4[+ ? + 5 ( • V "5 o5! E : l @(
( 1 9 G5 ( ( < .R % R6 ] ; .
C w w 9w / ? F G5 " % > *+ l 5 _"5 E : l @( ( C \ (
% > *+ B ( / ". ( % > *+ B F wG5 / w / w ?+ .5 +
/ w " ( w / ".w ( ( 1 F G5 / 3 @ , R+ H 9 / ? ( 5 >% @ = ,K ( ( ) ( K / .
(( 1 v ( /( ? 3 F9 + 3 @ % ?R E : l @(
. Nw"+ + B w
' Z 4+
" M B"4+ $"# ‚ 5 F A + E : l @(
w ( ( wK w ( G5 V+ K ::* =5 t:* • 9
.
Ow)5 w w5 w""}+ U + H K • ? ?j / • B (
B
) + % "
1390 : 159
.(
w%( ( M 4 ""}+ H A . R.5 / % ' / L 5 RI .
( w" / w > w)% w Q' ( 1 NR =5 ." 89:5 * ' _"5 ( (
C | + ( … • (
67 ( / =" { Q45 B"="# / % Q' R.5
%( ' G5 V B""4+ V+ l .
F wV% w F( ‚". {( r Q' B 3 5 A ;5! NI
„ w) Z4w H •w w ( .; / ( R5 / % ?R / Z U =' O"
= B 5 R" =# ( ! " M . … > € w5! w ,w" *+ ( w
( % U5 $U 6 L
. H / + ' ^ _ / % ' / % 5 <5 V" 5 (
C K
1365 C .U5 / % + 1366
( V
! w+ w V 5
» R5 % =@ /&+
« " 5 9 / ? "
.
B " % H w" / w >- ( [ = ‚ # ( 5 V5!
w+ w
/ w% w M w * w 0 w@ w wQ ( =:5 $ K O@ K @ % 5
"
( wK / w% w " O@ w {9 wK \ wK ( ( ) … /( r ' –
>% )+ v = P \ ( .5 5 5
. w w+ w5( ( F_ ( K F_
ww H/ ww / ww% P ww\ / w ww5 1
ww5 Ž ww)* $"ww >ww ww% ! ww % O@ w ww / .
) H 1385H128 (
( F w5 Uw / w% ;% w; ! I ( ?5! E ( Q F G5 ;5! 39K
9 ( R% † ( ( ) ? <5 (
x )5 ' ?j / "1 8 ~
; 5 &% ' 5 ( K >% / :Q
. ( wo w" Bw (
<" ; ! K A / :Q / T"- E % :
5 " K :Q ( / (
B @ w # ! r"rK B + l
O)5 5 ; ! ""}+ :Q ; ! Q
) H R "
1389 : 121 (
/ w "67+ .5 5 ? + 5 % > *+ ( 6 89:5 %( V+ H," *+ / ( 4 9:5 "M N" ! w w 1 w" V+ E w ;
w w _w"5 9 89:5 / 3 @ V ] ~ 1 ," *+ K { .
.w5 + w% U5 w % > *+ , I B" A"* 5 / % =@ + 3 ( B K >% @ _"5 @ ="# / % " M 5 Z"4[+ 89:5 ( w 5 w%
.
) . w " v
H + % 1390 : 157 - 172 (
( w 5 „ R w _"5 ~ 1 ," *+ K G5 ?j + "4 B .
w5!
! _"5 % ," *+ K ( M ( 5 / 6 % > *+ 5 B (( 1 _"5 :+ N % > *+
% > *+ B >~ 9 9 / ?
5 "# ( Z U / % 3 ( Q / % ( ! ( .5 + .
leveret,2011:28) (
( ," *+ + _"5 < ( R l .
9w 89w:5 O' ( ," *+ B (
$I wL , I B" F G5 > M / % V % w "5 =w
. 89w:5 Ow' (
P Q , I B" F G5 / =@ 9 .
, I B" F G5 B I
9 89:5 / # "67+ C M (
)
H ( =M
1385 : 17
.(
w w C wn / w
"5 &% >G5 R ( V ( 9 89:5 $:5 w" + w; ! / wR% w C wR"I
† w 9 / ?=R / "1 ,; " F9 / "M , 89:5 w5 (
w "=w $I wL w ( w X ; C R"I , I B" F G5 >G5
snyder.199.43) (
w; w Z"4w w / l ' C M ? + 5 B
F wG5 9w 89w:5
:+ C M ( 9 .
w?5! ' Z U / % # / (
:
H w E w@ ‚"w K < w B + + 'H )5 "I + B ?
$w:5 / (
% _ % < +H 5 " K :Q F9 ? ( / B""4+
w1 1
w % H w w? w:Q ( / " # -€ "4' / (H( ( " K ( ? )5
? % # B F + ( ( € I - N ; ?
w w 1& %(
3 4 / "5( ( 9 89:5 .
x , ' B ( / < ( l / w"R4+ w w •w % @ ]* H
• % @ 5 ?
. w% =w / ".w w 5 ? € # ( 1 ( B E
w / w w ; ( / w ; ! 09+ ( "1 ' ; ( C R"I • % @ "67+ *+
C ( / "<"# ? ( %
) . H 5 " v 1391
: 95
.=5 6 (
T# _"5 9 89:5
w% K wV Z4w w ; ( C R"I • % @ B @ 1 ' "67+ *+ + 1 . w / w ;5 + " B ( .
]w* w 5 w? w ( w /( w@
( 5 5 ( 5 >" + ! ( 45 H 5 .
w % w + O5 B
w
( 5 .
% 5 + :":M ( R ;
•w % @ w =5 ;= < % @
5 B _< ( K .5 + % U5 ; ( C R"I .
_"5 B >" 5 u)M ( K % >" R # { % % ! + 3 ( % U5 t:*
. B
;=w B"w L l w' w+ w 8 w Q w< % @
( " B ( >% % N43 ( T / RI ( 5 / "1
( ( .
3 - 2 .
) " 4 $! ," - . / 012
B ( 5 >" + + 9 89:5 ! / % < ( ; H w " w =w+ 5 K ( A"* 6 9 89:5 / $"# / % 5
F wG5 w" M Z"4[w+ Nw = F G5 ( / ! 5 H < % @ ' Z"4[+
% K 9 89:5 / %( ( % ! 3 @ ( V ":@ X
.
B ]* (
/ + l ( K ( ( +
/ ( .1 % 9 89:5 / "# / ( ( 5 0 @ R5 ."5 > ( Z U / % 1 / )
,R' Q ( ( B K
.(
% ! (
3 ( / / % $I L 9 F G5
( =5 "Rn+ F G5 % ( K (
@ ( " ?I ! O ' % <5 ( ( .1 ". K ( / % 5 + ". 9 89:5 / "# T# "I ( ( K ( "4
( + O"
.
1 4
) ". R4 C
"G5 A "G5 6( ( M ( ( ( K ‰ K 8 L ?L K ( 18
"+
87
C ( H>%( ( / ? U 5 4 q( M
1388 M _"5 / %
( =5 B ( % K I / 5 ( .1
89:5 (
( K ( L % ( K ( / % 5 =# >% % 9
/ N" ! .5 5 + 4"R\ / = % ( RI ( ( =
( ( =
. _"5 9 89:5 # N _"5 ( K ( "4 B
.
{ ; ( V ( B ( ( G5 " 5 RI
P Q ( %
( =" V Z U
.
H U • E : l @( # " K F C *+ T#
~! 9 / ? , :+ / (
.
/ / _@ U ( K M B (
: ( K
( ( / _@ F 5 .
" H/( r ' H < % @ Z U ( 4 F 5 • 5
/
M B F + ( B ( ( ( C 4@ %
. k 4Q' / R% r ,M B F + (
( + ‚". ( ":R 6 * ( % QK O@ O@( N ; B""R+ - F( / %
+ ( B"
F
% 89:5
$:5 H 9 89:5 ‰ rUI
B""4+
$I L ( /
* %
/ %
U F 5 • # ( ! (
( ( ( K K ( B (
) . v .
# "4 / * :
1390
.(
( C D ":@ X M ]* " B ( ."5 / + l !
.
' / ;@ / % % 1 K V% ( 9 89:5 / "# /
B | # ( 9 / ? 1 " 5 " =U / 5 1 @ 1
( l .
.5 / =" ! ( ":@ X 1 ?R M
R
" # _"5 l B V% % ! ( ( M .
/ "# "K / % C q( M
; =5 Z"4[+ ? + 5 ":@ I < ( ( =5 _"5 ( K ":@ I F(
( 5 u)M ( K <
.
>% B
C r* _@
V B ( / H/
; N
‡ 9 89:5 Z U O\ : ( 1 5 ' / * "59: 1
( ,M 89:5 ,- . ( 5
) . v .
# "4 / * :
1390 (
3 .
%5 6 $" 6 " 76 " 8' + 9
w)1 w+ w @ 1 ,; ! E 9 89:5 % 1& (
w
w ! w / ~ w\ ( w?5 G ( M / R 9 89:5
( / ! B ( R ! ( ;M
.
>"% wU + 3 ( B
( U w+ ‚ w 5 ( ) w w w+ >" 5 "R=+ ?I ‹ "R5 M 9 89:5 ( 5 9 89:5 ! ," *+ % M 5 <
.
‹ w"R5 >" .% 5 @ 9;= % 5! 9:5 M ‹ "R5 ( | + C \ (
5( 1 ! ?I
.
Bw w w w% ~ w\ w ( wK 9;= B ;
M .
5 K / ‹ "R5 ( L % w w :":M / M >" + (
( 5 QK / ". O@
. ( w"1 w w3 / w % ( K ! N"+ + B .
R w"# w 9:5 w M 7+ 9 / % ! ( ) _"5 9 89:5
@ 1 3 F9
. ( +9;= 9 F9 R "#
Tw# w ( F9w w (
w $ w' ( R H F9 / R ( ;M ,";=+ t@ ;5!
( C R5( . ,- R' < ( .
{ % % ! 9 I ( ,";=+ ( R "# : T# M B ( 5 C R5( 3 K .
I ( H
( 1 / ( .1 K / % $I L 9
. Bw
D.w w 9w F9w R w"# / :Q @ / :Q / % $I L , % $I L
O@ w w $ w' B" o % ( ? H { \ ,- R' F9 / "5( ( ( … )5
H ( @ QK F9 0 .1 5!
( 1 .
) .
H )4 C v
1383 : 557 - 562 (
w w w r+ @ 1 ' "4 ( % F9 R "# "4 B ( L % ( 1 t@ Z U / % • ( R "# ( 5 / D. B @ % K B" k9
5 R6 ( K "5 :M + .
( C n
! w w w rw+ w 8 _M •
5 5 ' F9 /_"L H 5( ‚". R "# " . "G <=I I M B ( H 5( @ 1 ' ( ( K ( / " 5 E7 ( 5 . / ".
; %( r5 / "# ? + 5 R "#
w w%( w w w?I M E
% K ˆ @ 5 . ( F / \ S / . / % ‡
.
Q + H %( B F9 R "# 5 ( ( B NI ;5 w /_w" ! U. + B*I :@ > < 5 . K 5 ( ' ! ( 5 .
1 R "#
» B"w w < % ( ( ; G*I % > 3 * _ R (
%( / . ‡ + ' 5! >
«
%( =5 @ R B
( wR5 ! / " •"% 5( @ 1 ' U ". 3 * "4 ( 5 . .
w
( 5 . ,3 M / "# H :":M ( / R M ; +
.
w; ?w ( Z"4w / w ~! ( 5 5 . ( 5 > K / "# B 5 ˆ @ F / \ S + 5 t@ ( ( 5( ( ,";=+
) . w )4 v
H 1383 : 557 - 562 (
>"I w4+ / w R w ! / % ! { % + 3 ( _"5 9 89:5 ( + H >"5 9 ( M F ;M / 9 ;M ,";=+ G ?I
( 5 ," *+ ! F9 | + " V+ / R .
( wK tw:*+ / 9 89:5 E B
5 R t:*+ ! / % ! { % B + >? " / "# + ( 5 \ U
( 1 5 / % 3 + ( 9 4 ( F9
) . H 5 V5 " v 1384
H 452 - 500 (
/ ".w O@ w ( wK w ( ( w; 9w 0 w<5 w w + w 9w 89:5 ' % K w5 QK .
F9w •w" R+ $ w' =w w / Q5 w % k w:"'(
89w:5 H w 5 w : Zw U / w% _w F9 + 5( 09+ 5 B"< =K w5( 5 : ! ( v 5 QK 5! / _"5 9 .
/ w w
_ ( ) l ' w F w5 •w w}" R+ / w% _ "o % G5 _ H > *+
K ( # 9 / ? F G5 :
) . H 5 V5 " v 1384
(
w =w ( ( / _w"5 .w ( F9 0 .1 / ( % 5 B" % = 9+ U • F 5 • H > *+ _ ( ) R w"# 89w:5 w ( + 5( 5 0
5 / "1 .
w5! / w / wV" 5 w 5( 5 ( ) _"5 M B ( % !
5 . F9w ?5 ( / "# V ( ( 5 ~! R "# M ; V" 5
F9 , : % /€ I - @ 0 .1
w + w w 1 Tw# 5( ( .
@ C @
) . H / "? v 1371
H 45 - 65 (
R w"# ! A w @ 1 ' ! ( 9 89:5 Q >"% U 1 C M ( 5 "# ( ? + NI ‚ 5 + >" . : .
+ 9 89:5
( K & <5 =w H /( / % /€ I - "= $ L B" o % 5 ? ,- .
@ 1 ' ?+ ( 5 ? ' /
. w @ 1 w I B"w / w% > *+
5 ( ) F 5 • B" o % 5 / % ( K G5 M ?+ + / %
( ) ! 4 (
.
w5 <5 % w 5 >%! w@ 4 / / ( "4 B; _"5 A B RI ( ! >% w@ ! 9w 4 F9 R "# / ( "4 B .
9w w
Bw; _w"5 ( w"1 w 3 "4 ( 89:5 ( / ‹ }" R+
B 5_ B ( l .
Z"4[w+ w R w"# w o % _"5 K ( :@ B" o %
( w w5( 1 w4 ( w@ " ( ( + ( V N 4 ( ) Š ( V "M
( w Q w ! H ( w : w 5! ( ( + { % % ! + 3
K 9 89:5 G 5
( % .
( ( G5 R5 ;5 " B ( RI .
w 9 89:5 ; !
w { % % ! / =@ # B @ 1 ,; ‰ K @ % % ! E
w%( ' 9 89:5 / $"# Q !
.
w + w3 ( B w
Bw
( _w"5 w Q ! k 4R\ > "< 3 @ 9 89:5 C 3 B" o % { % % !
( % U5 9 89:5 G 5
.
F9w R w"# 89:5 ( "4 5 % )
‰ (
H =w w M Tw# ( ( /
R "# I 3 % ! )
‰ ( w w @ 1 w3 @ ( w ( w 5 >" +
w4 ! Tw#
( 1 +9;= 9
. > M 9 4 ( 5 F9 R "# T#
/ w / _w w w Bw ( ( 5 •" R\ 1 "5( ( 9 C 3 {9K ( 1 ( ) { % B "
.
=w# w 5 . + N B" % / w% @
( A . 5! .5 + 8 ~ @ Z4 v > ( / ( .1
.
w ( w "4w B" L 9 89:5 9 R C M ( +
. (
w"5( ( w ( Sw w @ w 9 89:5 "I { % C 3 H % ! + 3 R \ @ H 1 w R5 H(( w1 w"L 9w 89:5 "I { % C 3 1 , V+
w w +9;=w w% > w*+ w% ?+ , : ( 5 9 89:5 ( G 5
5 1( . H 5 ( 5 >" + ! / % ' .
M / ( 9 89:5 M + B
H w ( 5 >" + ‹ "R5
"4w Bw / w _w"5 F( w w 5 / =w@ # ( K / % ! C 3 + 3 ( 89w:5 H( w"1 w3 _w"5 F X / w •w % @ " B ( ( F X 1( ! wR w? ( w% w w< ( / <I "1 @ 9:5 ! ( 9 w
9w 89w:5 / $"# I B" / % 3 @ + ( % K 5 ? R; . "S @ ="# I 4+ .5 + % K .
R Q B" L + _"5 ( @ 1 G5 ( t":*+ / % ƒ ) o5!
@ ( .
9 89:5 ) B E
/ w% =w 5 % 4w w 7+
% 5 F9 3
. F( w /€ I - w H/ wR% Bw w ( 9 89:5
4" < K V+
.
w M u)M %( ( / M 9 89:5
89:5 B F ( # 4 ?5!
.
w' K 9 / ?
‚ w w "
w " $"w# w% &# w ! w4I Q w ' ( 9w 89:5 ! 9 89:5 8 Q / % "4 .
: / w% 0 w; w .w 5 w 0 ( ) + > ( 09+ I : B (
( S 9 89:5 ! " *+ H % &# ! >
.
w ( L Q
>" K ( # 5! % ( 1 P Q 9 89:5 ! .
@ 1 3 / % E
C w M CX Z"4[+ ?5! K H
G5 "4 H 9 89:5 / ?5! l ' .
w / w% ! C / ,w"I(
wK ,w" *+ ( B" o % 5 / "5( ( B ( Z"4[+ / ( )5 H ( /( @ w :5 H ! T# X *+ 9 89:5 "% ( ~ <=% &#
> ( 5 Z"4[+ ! O' C M K ( # .
( % ( ) B" o % w:5 9 89:5 T# U + / %
/ w% =w@ w6 ( w 9w / w? F wG5 Z"4[w+ l / < ( /
>" K ( # P Q I B"
. 89w:5 / $"w# / % w5 H w Bw E w
5 ? X *+ 5 I B" A"* 6 9 / w% $I wL =w+ N
< % @ - (( 1 F G5 Z"4[+ N B; % K "
. V+ :":M (
w w4 w N" ! "67+ .5 5 ? + 5 % > *+ ( 5 6 89:5 %(
~ 1 ," *+ K { 1 " V+ E ; ( ( wV ]
_"5 9 89:5 / 3 @ .
A"w* 5 / % =@ + 3 ( B
> *+ , I B"
@ ="# / % " M 5 Z"4[+ 89:5 .5 + % U5 %
( 5 % K >% @ _"5 .
( .1 / % ( ! ( 9 89:5 _"5 • % @ ]* ( ( • % @ 3 ( /
( , I B" ˆQ .
w _w"5 w < % @ > ?+ l _"5 89:5 /
( 5 N. ‹ rM , ' % ":@ >" .% : C M ( F 5 • l .
> ( w 5 >"w + 9w 89w:5 w ! / / < ( / / $"w# / % w5 H
Z"4[w+ Nw w " w =+ 5 K ( A"* 6 9 89:5 w":@ X F G5 " M Z"4[+ N = F G5 ( / ! 5 H < % @ '
( w @ 4 9 89:5 / %( ( % ! 3 @ ( V
. w Bw ‘( (
% CX _"5 -
.
w ( w K ( w w w ( w + ;
% w 9w 89w:5 / w"# / w ( ( 5 0 @ R5 ."5 / + l
> ( w Zw U / w% w1 / w / ( .w1 .
w 9w F wG5 w% ! (
$I L
K ( 3 ( / / %
/ w% w5 ( w =5 "Rn+ F G5 % (
( ( .1 ". K ( .
w K ( w w w) ".w R4w C w w w 1 4
"G5 A B + ( M ( ( ( K ‰ K 8 L ?L 18
"+
87 w4 q( wM
( H >%( ( / ? U 5
C 1388 / 5 w ( .1 / % M _"5
( 5 ‡ 3 K … )+ ( % K I
. C Dw w ":@ X M ]*
."5 / + l >% ! ( .
wK w V% ( 9 89:5 / "# /
5 1 @ 1 ' / ;@ / % % 1
/ w? 1 " 5 " =U /
( l B | # ( 9
. w< w ( ( =w5 _w"5 "K / % C q( M
( 5 u)M ( K < ; =5 Z"4[+ ? + 5 ":@ I .
/ B
O' ") L ! >" + / 5 + 5 (
.
9w 89w:5 ! + > ( 5 09+ / % ‘( ]* T#
> 5 < ( / E
.
( w 9w 89:5 ( B E
( w w wM \ F9w R w"# w M % 4 7+ ‹ "R5 M / + 3 1( w ! "4w B / _"5 F( 5 / =@ # ( K / % ! C 3
9w 89w:5 H( w"1 w3 _w"5 F X / w • % @ " B ( ( F X
R; .w w wR ? ( % < ( / <I "1 @ 9:5 ! (
( % K 5 ? ,r@ ( 9 89:5 / $"# I B" / % 3 @ +
"S @ ="# I 4+ .5 + % K H ! 1 / % .
/ w" l
w? ( >w? 89w:5 w L w ( ( / , I B" F G5 ( "4 9
@ B" o % ( 1 V 8
/ w% =w & w w? ( % $R "1
9w 89w:5 w " "M / / I ! B " 7+ H #
%( ' " 7+ ( .
% 5 F9 3 / % = 5 % 4 7+ 9 89:5
B ( + 3 (
( 5 % K \ I 4+ @ ="# 5 .
( 89:5 B
/ R% B -
w %( w ( / M 4" < K V+ F( /€ I -
89:5 B F ( # 4 ?5! M u)M
.
w V+ % ( ! (
%( =5 89:5 %(
( w w% K 9w 89w:5 wG 5 ( Q !
. F wG5
C( w ":@ X ( O ( ? † * ( 4 "59: / R 1 ( "
4 …9K t:*+
) . v . H # "4 1389
( / w% # w%( w ( ( wK =w w
! @ ( K " # - / % 5 + ' Bw / w ! 4Q'H /
) w@ # w L %
N"=5 ( ( % K # ( .
; < =&
:
/("
. ' :
1 .
# HC ) 1384 ( F S' &M * 8= > 3 F P _K "4 + H
H @( O 3 F % &# ! _
?+ H K 5 l9\ 5 4
2 . H 1 ) + (
? H / 54 R 4& <6 H + H
3 . HB".M H "=
) 1380 ( R 4& 6 3 c"Q # 8 Q H
<5
?+H 5
4 .
HC H )4
) 1383 (
6 d& I
) 4e ' 4 ( H >' H ,"I(H 1383
.
5 .
H ' * H ( =M
) 1385 ( R 4& 6 <6 f& / gM
= 5 H
?+ H = 5 5
6 . HC9 H =K ( )
1391 ( 54I & 42 6 41 R 4& 6 <6 4 gJI – r@H
=% &# =% &#
HC C H 9 89:5 2
7 . H H .1 5 [ h h
3 F
» 5 i
« 1
» R 4& 6 <6
« H ! V H 7
? H 1384 .
8 . 5 H
"
H ) 1388 M(
&
6 <6
&
c#
4c>
r@H3
=% &#
89:5 4I Q
9 C H H>=
18
9 . H H 5 "
) 1391
& ( 4 jI
&
k 1 4 M
&
6 <6 l eA
&
R 4 1 3 6
V – r@
=% &#H =% &#
H 9 89:5 2
? H
10 .
"
H R H ) 1389 ( Q V 4 M
&
4+I
&
@ F 3 Q
&
c"Q 3 6
&
R 4 (H r@
=% &#
$5 (
"
F ( H>= C H
11 .
"
H R 5 '
"
|
=5
"
H 9 HB
) 1378 ( H 1 m1 H i "=
&
" n cQ +/ O o -
=5 ?+H
H F ( ’ L .
12 . / "?
H H )4 "
) 1371 6 +I d& I( H
H ?+ H 1371
13 . H“[+ H”( "
) 1386 ( :e Q R 4& p 6 <6 6 R cQ q F
H
=5
= 5 … H 3
14 .
"
5 V5 H 4 R H ) 1384 ( 6 <6
&
F 3 RM
?+ H :
\ = 5
H
15 . H " M H ) 1373 (
4- 8 6 &
• H K H
3
16 . H( * >"M * H + % "
) 1389 +I 3 M ( R 4& 6 <6 41
{ 4 =5 H>'H
17 . H,=" @ ) 1389 ( T 1 R cQ k& T R 4&
H 5 =5 ?+ H 1389
18 . H "<5 ? H ) 1385 RM &M Z& I 14 I c, < B B ri "= H 1 SF ( F $% &#
H "
3
19 . H ?L H/ * )
1386 ( 6 cQ < IE 1 6 <
?+ H 9 = 5 • % @ <=% &# = 5 H
20 . H H/ M )
1385 ( R 4& 41 RM 4 g I s F4 R # cQ
R\ R\ 9 <=5 ( 5 # H
21 . P " H j 5 H/ ' I
) 1384 (
&M I c, E 3 2 4Q
?+ HB 5 O 3 _ H
22 . H HB ) 1363 (
<6 cB # e= 5
?+ HF ’ L H 696 B.* + H
: 5 =5
23 . H H/ <.
) 1386 (
<6 &M :
?+ H HF ’ L H = 5 5 = 5
24 . H( ( H 1( / ? )
1380 ( 4 3 c e Q 3E 3
?+ H 9 = 5 • % @ <=% &# H
25 . H/ * H ?L ) 1382 ( 1 0& 6 <6 F <6
0 4 3
>' H : C ’ L H{ 4
26 . H( 4. H # "4 / * )
1390 (
34eF @O8 &4& ke 41 @5 l -
t& A c l4/ 5
* 1 Z/
1388 HC HC C H 9 89:5 =% &# =% &# r@H .
.
27 . ( 4. H # "4 H
) 1389 ( ,=u
vV # F
"V ; & E 8 I 3 F
) (
=% &# r@ H
H B"
49 .
7 . 5 :
1. Makridakis, S. and Wheelwright, S. (1989). Forecasting Methods For Management,5th. Ed, John Wiley, and Sons, Inc.
2. www.cic.nyu.edu/internationalsecurity/docs/NIC_final.pdf, Global Trends 2025: A Transformed World.
3. leveret,Hillary Man,(2011),us politics towards Israel&Iran available on raceforiran.
comarchive/us polices/29651/access 28 Des www.
4. Snyder/Robert.(1999)”The us and Third world revolutionary states:understanding The breakdown in reletions, international studis Quarterly.
