49
"#
3 % & ' 1398
* +,- -764 745
)
(
1
2& 34 & 5
2 67 8 9 3& 2&
) :
4 / 3 / 1396 : –
21 / 6 / 1396 (
: 5#
3;
' 3<
3:
&
8 8:
=>
?
@
&
A ' ' BC D3<
E F
G
<3H 6
"@
3 7
&
.
%
&
J
"
&
E G 3 6 K % 9 3LE A ' ' C K3H F
=>
M 3N ' 6 3 G G
&
E O#
G A ' ' 5C B=
3N
&
P
"
97
Q - 9 3R +N S 9 34 3<
7 9 5#
F
&
P '
&
B=
6 6
&
G T 5U
3<
F . G 5#
3;
&
P F <
5A 3< 3<
G E G 5V G F OLN W
8 E3 X6
E G 5 K3H B=
3N
&
P S
< L+
3 K % 9 3LE
A ' ' C Y
<
Z G F M 3N <
9 3LE
&
[ JL @ A ' ' 5C F
\
&
J 3 G
3 7
&
<
C N <
,5 6 3#
&
] 5V G 8 E3 BF
3<
3 7
&
&
E O#
G A ' ' 5C <
* V 3<
.
<
@ N <
&
+N
^ 3;
+N F , X
9 67 E
G 97 - N , - +N E D <
.
_ E G G F
<
5A 5V G OLN W 8 E3 M 3N A ' ' BC 3F .
١ .
[email protected] Email:
746
49
"#
3 % & ' 1398
!
"#$
%
& ' ( )'"
!
*+ ' ,# "
-$
#
*.
/(
"
0 1 - "2 ' 34 ( 5 - "6 ( 7 8 7 9 ,# "
' : ' ' 8
; <
=(
*
>
*??<
.
&(
)'"
! ,# "
?<
A B C4#
( D A0 E "
7 ' F %
&' C G*.
H ( ! ) 34 ( 5 - "6 ) 5%.
6(
"
! I # J BC?
+ & &
( KH
"< # 7 L
!
"M 7 J N
*?
. H )'
"
! O - H - H3N
( A 8<
) ( - *
"6 P ' E "
7 3N ( O '
H ( ! ' ,# "
Q 7
# 7
*?#
R 34 ( 5
<S#
( B )
( B TU?#
7 ' 5 V
? # 7
*?<
.
' L W 8 .S6 C4#
( D A0 + & &
( H X"
7 R L /<
A B &
(
* G "<
R
"<
7 L 7 O+ Y#
8??T#
8 G '$
* R V Z
"Y#
8 ' G*.
* ' 1"[
W
( 7 L /<
! X -)
*V
"V"
G "<
* .
! "
F \#
*?]
F X (
"
*L .
L ' ! X 7
"
! DA0
^ "#
(
1O R DA0 )$
!
"
2B R DA0
)$
- L
3*_
R DA0
`(
* Z ) J
4- ' DA0
^ "#
5>
K . ' G 6'
' ,]
- "N C4#
( # J J& +
"CL 6
C W 3#
77 8H "
R + ( c F . d #
+
?
87 +(
7 ' DA0
»
"
! )$
! « X (
"
'
9) *3 (
* E "
7
*?3L
*? HL .
&' ! V".
7 R T # ( DA0 . d ( H (
10h
R- Y#
C
*.
DA0 (
11)*
( A (
" / 8 #
5 . ' J # 83dH#
*.
8<
$ j # 7
" "
( 5
- " # 8
&' Y
*??<
. J kT l #
&' ( H R 8%3
"#$
% ! m ( J KL - "CL
+ & &
( H (
J ,]
"6 - V ! 9 G "<
* .
! "
F \#
*j ) 6 L
12)' ] R
( no%
' ' # o_'A ' 13
' '
14O+ # +(
!
"#) Z J - "CL
*? HL )
Remmer,
2012:
972-974 (
.
1. Swiss peoples party
2. Austrian Freedom party 3. Swedish Democrats 4. Greece's Golden Dawn 5. Danish peoples party 6. Marine Le pen 7. Front National
8. Matteo Salvini's Northern 9. Geert Wilders's party for Freedom 10. Neo-fascist Jobbik party 11. Fidesz
12. Hugo Chavez 13. Nicolas Maduro 14. Evo Morales
BC A ' ' G 8 8: & 3: 3<
3F
<3H G E ...
747
- "CL + & &
( H 7
*? #
*+ ' R,# "
# J J& + R
"
" L
"CL 1
DA0
E "
7
"
RB Y 5
"
2I
"CL DA0 FoT
3N ( O ' X (
"
' ) *3
"CL DA0
p "
"6
!
» )$
! «
*?3L R L /<
! ) !
* /#
' L N+
! # V A0 7
q#
?<
7
"M 7 r ((
"
G
* . n <
#
*T j#
8<
*?]"L W?(#)
Qs (
"
D A0
+ & &
( H t "M G*.
R J F 0 $ '
"<
7 L
! ) ! - + &
L
! L /<
!
u3 # 8 G '$
* )
De Lange, 2012:
899-918
( .
$ ( B ) 11
"< # 7
"M 7 )
83
"
RB +(
R
*_
R Y#
R- _(
RO R>
8H "
' ...
' vo _ L
! +' 7
G*.
*
# ' ( N ( J - / ) $
!
# "#
7 '
"<
7 L
! 7
O+ Y#
SN V
!
CH 8 L W 1960 '
" "
G*.
w
?j 7 ) 1 / 5
*1 8 2 / 13
*1 ( G*
)
Poring & Manow, 2016 (
.
A B C4#
( A0 D ' G'"6 L
! + & &
( H '
*.
"6 B
! L 8 "& P '
# 7
"6
H ( ! )
"< # 7 L !
"M 7 ) K #
"
J
*&
G*
L
! -"V .
8 8
"UX
! L
*.
*&
* Z
<S#
"
!
"< # 7 '
*#
( 51 0 ) -$
R j+ U#
W
"x 0 7&
"
7
"]
7
' N N]
7
*.
+ & &
( KH D"M .
8 8 8%?
*+ ' ,# "
( A
"
L ( J
" H 8
&(
)'"
! (
* J ) R ' j+ U#
W
"x 0 [ ! X
<s (
*
"
5# [ T # (
*+ ' ,# "
!
"#$
% - #)$
*L X
"<
.
W?(#)
^ =#
V(
y + & &
( KH j (
"
' j u ) ! ' :o '
L
!
*j # !
"
!
?.
7 D A0 ' BC?
L
! ( 7 8<
J 8
*?
!
"V # 7 6(
* "
R 1 8 "6
. 8=+z#
L
!
=3 # 7 # 7 -
"
! + & &
( KH {"U#
"<
.
|j 7 -$
8 - ?[
h F*#
"CL ! R # %0
|j 7 8
\#
W h } + _*
! ' X"
7 8 W+A?#
- =6 8 -$
G N # 7
*??<
.
d ! R _o<m + & &
( KH [ 7 H=
(
"
8<
»
^ "#
« -$
5%.
# 7
*?L . J - =6
+ & &
( KH 8<
8 J
~ x # - %#
# 7
*L 8<
8 X
L
!
| # Y .
) Laclau,
1977:
(165
. J F 0
•m j#
+ & &
( KH 8 - ?[
8=H3
! ( G*
# 7 . 8<
5T[
'
| (3
^ "#
[
! )
"\<
: # X ( (
" / ) - < 0
"T H#
# 7
* . + & &
( KH K/X '
* (?
7
[ (T 7 CH 8 8 L
! # *? # h L
! R€ A
<".
L
! 3#*?]
( 7 R
1. Norbert Hofeer
2. Nigel Farage
748
49
"#
3 % & ' 1398
0 1 - "2 R8
( - *
R ?#
- NC R"%=?.'
# T#
+' 7 R - ?. <
3[
7
'
*? '"Q - 8 H "
) "
# 7
*?<
. qV ' + & &
( KH
^ "#
[ !
• • D X ' F Tj#
# 7
*
' $
" "
) NC 7 8<
1"[
W
*V ' (
*? HL R
"2 # 7 6(
"
)
Canovan,
1981 :28-29 (
.
- "CL ' D A0 + & &
( H L j.
! X 8 8 6
!
"
( K # 7
*??<
8<
Z
^ "#
4 Qs (
"
"V
*?L ' 7&
*? # 7
%
# [ 7 '
"V - $
" "
( K H
"T H#
( 7
* .
+ & &
( KH
%C 7 ) ( 8<
»
^ "#
« 8
‚-
» L (s 8 < 0 « ' - *# "
# %0 # 7 ) * ' 9 -$
*/L ! Z
8%?
( L ! ƒ 8 J H ( G*
' o%/#
F 0 I'"X ) F" ?<
( K H
"T H#
. + & &
(
„KH TU?#
7 ( 7 8<
4#
-$
*
‚7 [ ( y
^ "#
) TCE K< 0
) RO 1395
(.
8 - ( 2?#
-' # 8 L
! 31 7 + & &
( KH R # 7 - 8
=+ # jx'
( R #
"6 * V 7 '
# 7
"6 7 8 - ?[
8
" ?[
7
&
+ &
( KH G .
"<
)
Mudde, 2007
( .
A B v %.
L
! V ! '
" "
! L
! TCE 7
?<
- "4 L
! L 7 ' N?L"
7
# 7
* 8
*.
D A0 ' G'"6 L
! + & &
( H 7
*# Y?(
.
X"
7 0 1 - "2 ( 7
* *T j#
8<
I #
*
* + & &
( KH RD"M O%j?#
*??<
Z
A B
" "
! V ! ' [ 7 q#
8 "#
. 8 C+
J Fm*
8/
L
!
7 m E 7 .
"
! F \#
8L
! L 1950 ' 1960 ' ' L
! o<
( Rh
{oU1 + & &
( KH k ( # ( J + (
1 H`
' ( 5
25 - *&
8j#
?.
7 R
"
!
x (
… . ( KH R- +$
} &
3KH 8H "
' 3 <"#
( KH
"#$
% 8
<
# 7 .
"L
^ *<
) J BC?
L 8 - ?[
/?< ' 7
"6 * V 8
3[
( 8
*#
( R8 5%.
"6 ' 3M )
0 A<" # ) '}
! Rh] <
" $ <
- ? Rh] <
G) r#
- R R- "
j?1 - <
=< X ' - ) ' /<
5T H#
X"
)
Lipset, 1960: 175 (
.
X"
7
"N ( A J x S&
:"
Fm*
+ ( H`
' 5
* *T j#
BC?
L
! E "
7 q#
)'"#
A B &
(
* G "<
* '
"L )'
"
C4#
( $ G 'A # 7 . . J G'"6
"
J
* '
8<
BC?
L
! E "
7
"
!
"
x 7 R -'*
% ( 8 G 6 R H%.
G X R 7 R
? 7 R
"6 * V R ] 'A ! [ 7 ' H<
7 8<
] 7 + *[
7 V ! G*.
* R S (
*
1. Symon Martin Lipset
2. Daniel Bell 3. Poujadism
BC A ' ' G 8 8: & 3: 3<
3F
<3H G E ...
749
)
Sauer, 1967: 404-424 (
8 .
C[
"N R
" H
*.
BC?
L
! + & &
( H 7 ' E "
7 R TCE 7 )
8j#
*? HL 8<
8 3[
" "
! L
! R # . 0
( W
~
"V 8 "6
* .
34 ( 5 L 7 8<
† X D A0
+ & &
( H # 7 . R
$ 8 5%.
L ' ' ?[
J
u3 # 8TCE
*?
! # 7
*??<
w L'"6 7 8
‡ 4+
} + _*
h J D A0 8TCE
*?
! G "<
' )
' ?[
? 7 - ] E "
17 '
2F %
"
!
$ G = # 7
*??<
)
Kitschelt &
Mcgann, (1997
X" .
7 - 6*?H (
A ) {oU1 . d
(
3 H
"
! J D A0 G =
# 7
*??<
8<
8 E
? x 7
$ 8 . ( KH 7
+(
' - +$
&
(
* # 7
*?L . G'"6
^ )
' ?[
? 7 - ] + & &
(
4 H ' + & &
( H
57 R F %
+ & &
(
6 H
+ & &
( H 7
7F %
"
! J D A0 G =
# 7
*??<
' 0oU1
7 8<
" <
ƒ ' J D A0 $ 8 X ?.
# 7
* . R 0oU1 7
*? # D A0
*x ( K H
( 7
"T H#
'8
D A0
*x
" # ) 9
Widfeldt, 2010: 9-10 (
.
3M 34 ( 5 L 7 8<
8 .S6 {"U#
# 7
*.
R D A0 + & &
( H
&' 8 H ' 8
? {
# 7 H .
# G)'"#
J CH 8<
- ?<
8 ( 8 X ?.
G*.
R
"N
7
*
^ j D A0 + & &
( H (
- /
*L
) Aytac & Onis , 2014: 41-49 (
.
# 8%?
?<
+ & &
( KH R ,]
+ & &
( KH ( A D"M F 0
:" H6
R
"
*
"<) T j#
* :
» - ' c?
R "
D A0 ,]
# ( 8 - 7
"3
"
(
' ( 5 3<
( - ?
"#$
% 8– A<"#
A h
"
* *.
' ) J ' #
%.
7
* *.
8<
) !
+ & &
( H L
"&
*.
. J RF 0 J v %.
- "4 + # 7 F L
! 2008 - 2007 + X 7
* #
« .
' !
"
J ' 8<
» J
<
#
*.
G X
L
"#$
%
"
3(
- L m '"Q
X )
*?L*
'
;"
(
% ! L /<
7
*? # -
'
` ( 20
*1 '
(
" / A B
* 8<
) -$
- #) - ?<
L ( J 8 6 V 7 G* #
«.
)
"2 '
! J
".
k
CYj 7
* 8<
8 F C
" * J - "4 V ! ) - '
»
<
€ A
« 8 J R ,]
+ & &
( H 7 }"
! G)
! 8
« )
, 2016 Zakaria ( .
1. Extreme Right
2. Radical Right 3. Neo-Fascist 4. Populist Right 5. Right-Wing Populist 6. Populist Radical Right 7. Radical Right –Wing Populist 8. Anti-Political Establishment 9. Anty-Immigration
750
49
"#
3 % & ' 1398
,# "
( A / 7 ) I #
" H6 Z + & &
( KH ' F 0 -*
- D"M .
J
I # # 7 - L /<
7
".
k
•o# <
' = #
* w )
*_
8 - ?[
/<
! y #
/<
- "4 ) Z - . (
" / R L /<
+ & &
( KH 8 - ?[
/C?
7 ) &
H ( - V 7
*L X
w* #
*?]"L /C?
7 8<
B *V F 0
) -*.
. X"
7 R"N
*? #
R- Y#
F 0
*C 5 -*.
8 } + _*
! + M .
#
"T
• C 8 L R + & &
( KH 8
# [ 7
8 X 3 G "<
)
Zakaria, 2016 (
.
D A0 + & &
( H KL { ? 7
R KL
`]
7 ' KL # ( 8 '
*? HL . + & &
( KH } + _*
!
( R H 8%3 h yU?#
( 7 R
?j 7 )"E
"%=
! Z ( .
# 5%
) <
‚J
- D <
X Z
+ & &
( KH $
"#
% 7 8
^ "# ^ + & &
( H 7 -$
[ 7 - )
1 ( u # 7
*?<
w
» ) 7 8<
‚- ?
‰-$
^ "#
[ ! q
".
u '
" "
!
# 7
*?
8<
?
8 8TCE '*4#
7
* . .
$ - NC u+ # X G X X '
M(
"< # "
( h # 7
*?
'
# 7
*?. <
^ "#
[ ! 3[
( 8 - NC H ( ƒ
*??<
) - 7 RO 1395
.(
8% $ &
( )'"
! ,# "
!
"#$
%
" /(
0 1 - "2 ' 34 ( 5 - "6
( 7 ( ] '
0 (
"
"<
R X"
7 0 1 - "2 ( 7 R H ( &
(
" / ' n "
34 ( 5
".
k 3X 7
"#$
% R 9 ,# "
' + & &
( KH
† X ' R
&(
B (?
7 G "<
* .
^
%H# ]
17
% 7 ) J 34 ( 5 - "6 .
"<
O AYL + T#
W
»
" * ) -$
] ( A !
8<
:"%
# 7
?<
(
*
2« R J
?(#) 8 # 7 6
* :
»
%H# ] 7 R B.
F 5CV 8 J#
=6 jx' (
H ( C.
( 8 jx' ( ' Z ' - +$
' ( J
".
k )'"#
"#$
% ' - ' '
L C.
L
! 5 V 7
'
« .
%H# ] 7
*T j#
8<
^ "#
)
^ 2 + &
7
#(
*
G*.
* . - ' ' jV ' ( - . 8 J 8<
. ( H L R ( F
"< # L
H%.
R* * 8%3
^ "#
) D A0 + ( F "C ' 82 4#
<
"=
*? . .
"=
) $ 8<
. ( H L &
( )'"
"<
. qV ' )
! L H ( 8 *? . L J
"=
*#
"
* "<
.
^ "#
"#$
% 8 F 0 C. X G
* 8<
"CL <
#A (
% 7 5\#
v) h#
<
37 Š
(
4- H%
- 2[ ' 3Y ' (
5 H 9 G "%
* .
"6
?]
( J H<
7 (
* ' 8 V 1
^ "#
#
D UX
"V R*L
*L X H
8 C 6 X"
7 R
#(
* ! ' K/X
~'"/#
^ "#
"#$
% '
1. Noam Chomsky
2. "It’s Worse Than You Think"
3. Joseph Mak Karti 4. Richard Nickson 5. Evangelist
BC A ' ' G 8 8: & 3: 3<
3F
<3H G E ...
751
- *T
"L
~ &
R8 #
‹ ! - $ 8 X 3
*?<
. ' 8
! - ' Z )
! L R
( - L ' - "6 <
" # 5# [
* 7
^ "#
"j#
7
*L X
"<
' 8 #
*L X
=6 8<
- ?<
=(
L*
!
"<S#
- 6*. "E 8j#
* w '
*L X
=6 8<
#
* ) X ' - ".
~
?<
( K w
# 7 H
*V
# 2 ( - T
?<
( K R 8 "6'
"CL ! - )
L X ( K
. m G*4 #
*V 7 7 R 5\#
- +$
*V 7 8TU?#
! ( R H 9
?]
( J H<
7
"
! - G"E #
#$
( A
) Hedges, 2016 (
.
&(
B (?
7
%H# ] 7 8
~ V' &
( ' ,# "
8 - ?[
F 4#
".
k - # H V ! '
N?L"
7
"#$
%
"
I # x 7
^ "#
*.
' 8 *? . L x
7
^ "#
8 q=
X
*#
"
"<
. 8% $ ,# "
' 8# "
L B k - NC ( 7 ) !
*? # I"
'
15
4#
82 <
R
"
7 ) * (
+(
R H
2:
! G X ' + ( A
3- '
+(
F "C ( +(
H 8
*.
# 83 0
"V
"6 R G C . /(
"
34 ( 5 - "6 ( 7 J 8<
".
k 3X 7
"#$
% ' Qs (
"
J
".
k
"
r ((
"
‹
! L 7
^ "#
G*
*? "6 '
• "1
=+ # L
! - NC ( 7 - y #
'
"2
*? "6 .
- ? ,# "
<"
(C 7 )
<
( h L
! /0'
" $ J 3[
( 8 - 3H#
' A%#
% 7 L R -) ( A
!
7 R KL dE W CV 3[
( 8 ' ' 83 T#
'A ! ( X 7
"#$
% . + & &
( KH '
8/
J [ ! ' . 8<
:
» ' CH 8 ( K H #
"#$
% h X 7
«
) Inglehart & Norris, 2016: 5 (
.
,# "
*T ( K H ( 7
"#$
% ' A6 <
7 8<
F 0 Z J ( K H
* R
J 8 6 8
^ "#
"#$
% T+
"<
8<
F ')
#PL 7
"#$
% ' F 2[
-$
8 U ' W J
- A6 <
* ' : X
*? # L W - "CL + & &
( H ( R
"
! ' = # ' ( 8 N
J ( K H 8<
# 7
* 7 ' 0 (
"6 2[
'
* V 3CV 7
"#$
%
*.
R - ?[
"<
' J
"
!
# "#
7 8<
]
#'"4#
( L
!
*.
* V ! ' o%/#
' 7
* R 8
*.
D S
. ,# "
O%["
L ( o ! 3<
( - ? V(
"< # X 8<
%
# [ 7 8 ( K H
"T H#
8 H ' R
8 - ?[
h # (3 (
R8 X X
X 8
- ?[
&
( '"/
'
"CL /C?
7 8<
|[
! -$
^ "#
[ !
"#$
%
%/
( 5 # 7
* R {"U#
"<
. 8 '
>" /#
# "#
7 8<
)
,# "
0
* "<
J 8<
L W $ ) H ( K H 0 RK<
( - * 7
=<
R
1. George Will
2. Jeb Bush 3. Elizabeth Warren
752
49
"#
3 % & ' 1398
-mm F '
"
R - "%=?.'
"C% # ' ( - * + ( F "C
"=? #
* ' ,# "
( A
^
"?
7 L
! 7
X J G'"6 L 8
*.
# 83 0
"V # 7 )
Noriss, 2016 (
.
h
"
*?
N HC L 7 '
? C#
7
"
* j HL 7 X ?.
7
# 7 -
=6 + & &
( KH ,# "
* ' 8 &
W 31 7 : 83 0 8 - NC
* to
#)
17 R
# "
W
*x 7 ' F'
"#$
٢% ' '
"%
S0 7 '
"& P 7 .
1 . !"#
$ %
) L W 1980 R
*+ ' ,# "
R
" $ <
J # (3 ( ' . ( 3 A 7 . 8]"6 ,# "
V !
:
"<
8<
H (
*? '"Q R
)
"2 : X '
|[
- NC ( 7 C w NC 7 8<
)
"2 ,# "
L ! ( 7 ' V ! D" # X
F dH#
p T /<
* . RqV ' o 0 ,# "
8 - NC ) ' 6P 7 L
! ) + & &
( KH
,# "
. G = ) 0oU1
# [ ( 8
*? # » G* "
« ' » G* )
« h hC
# 7 K<
# 8 '
( u ) + & &
( KH T
"<
. ,# "
<"0 7
8L *C+
R - ) '*?
( A ' - ?
8 ?%. X 8<
. ( Z _W -$
) 3 A - 8 X #$
R KL E # X
^"6"
# 7
"<
' KL T # ( ( 7 X x
(
… # 7 . F L J
?(#) 8 -*36 . J '
^ "N?
. :
- L
*?X -*
8 ,# "
R
*V # 7 6(
* "
) 2016:79 Kia Hall,
.(
&(
/ (?
W ,# "
)
! R
#"6"
7 ' Y R 8 "Y ' # 1 X 7
"
! ' ! KL "
"<
G ) C#
7 R X ) - NC ( 7 ' X
"T H#
*
*?<
' X
8 - ?[
h
"
» X 7 « ) ( 8 N ( K H ( 7
"T H#
(
"j#
7
?<
* .
% 7 ) :' L
!
,# "
"
! J #
" H ( - * ' TCE W ( 7 K< 0 G =
)
^ L
!
L ( J
#$
( A . G = )
^ j H#
» L ( o ! 8T0 )
3«
"
! L ( o ! 3<
(?
-
#*X
T 1
*?
! - NC 8 - ?[
*
) ,2019 Trump Twitter Archive
،(
+ 0 7 8<
C[
) R L Y?L
"
! ( - *
? 7
"UX
! L
! (H 8 G " L R
# J
"#
*? )"#
! ,# "
TCE W ( 7
"T H#
' DS $
! TCE x
7
"Qz#
.
,# "
- =6 8C
( A W X 8
:' L
!
=3 # 7 F j
"<
. .
* 8 H "
"
J
j.
' » to 3(
8
?<
(
*
« .
» to
« 8 ["
8 A D 3U#
,# "
"
!
"
( K TCE W
( 7 K< 0
*C 5
*.
) Biegon, 2019
.(
1. the ‘corrupt’ elites of the establishment ‘swamp
2. The anti- globalist and ‘America first’ agenda 3. Crooked Hillary
BC A ' ' G 8 8: & 3: 3<
3F
<3H G E ...
753
,# "
8 . ( G
! H%
7 kT B ) j Z
» to
« v j#
"<
qV ' .
<
,# "
» AY W X
!
« 8<
' ! - #A L »
( +(
KH V
!
« ' »
?#
( 3#
7
'
< 0 (
« F C # 7
"<
. J
#) ( R8?
H ( J &
(
?/
' ! BL <
( B ) 30
*1 )
W m W )'
# 8 X .
+' ,# "
- #A L BL <
W )'
#
8 X
* V . q ?#
B
"#$
% T <
*?
&(.
?/
+' ( W 8 5# . 54 # (3 (
m AL
? W x 7
"
! )'
~ R A / 7 8<
8 X
! X /(
"
) W m W
)'
# 8 X
) Biegon, 2019
.(
,# "
) h v"E - NC K< 0
*
* 3V # 7
"<
' ) !
"N R
#(
- L '
G'"6 L
! u3 # G =
) ) ! BL <
- A B 8 vo X # 7 X * ' O`
)
| ! G*. Y G"
"
! # 7
"<
.
2 . ' () * +
,- .
/ 0 1
,# "
( A
*? #
"
Π! y
"#$
%
•o# <
8
"6 ?\
7
"#$
% 7 T [ R
#
' = ' ,# "
)
^ =#
"6 ?\
7
"#$
% '
"
Π!
"#$
% ) J
^ =#
J 8<
,# "
' H ( ! )
! - L X
"N qV '
^ =#
"6 ?\
7
$
"#
% + V
» ' . ( KH 3#
17 « {"U#
G "<
'
* *T j#
8<
"#$
% 8
?
"N /<
L ' = # R
8%3 ) - "N ( A
" "
w 8 C+
"
Π!
"#$
%
( A 8 J
" "
! T [
*? . R
# -$
*? # ,# "
…x ' ' 7 G "&
{"U#
7
* "<
. J
' = 8<
,# "
*T j#
"
! 8% $
"#$
%
" "
'
?\
V 7
* R
*
".
k
?<
7
"
5_ H#
3X 7 X (
" / A<"
*?<
' ) L W L ! 7 ' ( J 33 + 7 ' - *4 # X
! T V 3X 7 X G =
*?<
' - ] 8L L
!
=3 # 7
"
!
…31 '
?#
( - AL 8?
X "&
"<
G R )'"#
L W (
* - "C J AL 8?
L ( K
*?.
. 8 L ( J 5(+
8<
#) 7 8<
} W 2017 G"N?<
)
^ N?L yU K "#
34 ( u ( Z
» . "
G %.
« /<
X C41 # 7 R "<
"#$
% 8 - ?[
3#
7
?#
8<
`HL c?
7
"N ! R
"j#
7
"%
. ,# "
Z 5 X
"
!
0 (
! V 3X 7 '
#*X 7
8
»
# - "
' - ) : # "
G*.
« C41 # 7
"<
8<
'
8
*V
* *
) - <
' C ((
RJ 1397
.(
qV ' ,# "
j 7 G "<
j.
» F' $
"#
%
« AN J } ' Z
»
"6 ?\
7
$
"#
% 7
«
*?<
. ,# "
C ((
J (
» F'
"#$
% « 8 - ?[
P "
!
?#
( 3#
7 X
"
1. National chauvinism
754
49
"#
3 % & ' 1398
]
~ x # # A<"
# 7 . . ' !
# 7 6
* :
» P "
!
?#
( 3#
7 J#
h K/]
) *
P "
h
"
! 2 4#
)
^ "#
"#$
% '
•=0 . ( Z 6* ) 7 R # :" H6 G
R #
•=0
…31
)
"E y
*V ' &
(
"/
• =
"#$
% - '
«
) Trump, 2017
.(
* Z
» F'
"#$
%
«R h G 6*
[ (
• T 3#
7
"6 8 8<
-$
q ?#
3#
7
"#$
%
?
*L
*??<
Z + j ( L
! m G*4 # -
' J q ?#
8 { x'
"j u G*.
8Š $ . J
G*
*
* R 8 A<"
"
•=0 +'
"#$
% ' 8 T [ 8
?\
- m G*4 # ' 8 0 7
^A[
» 0 ( ! 2[
"#$
% !
€ A «
) Economist, 2016
R (
- ] L W J G*
L ) - #) c?
7
^'
^ +' L
! &
( / ( J m G*4 #
G
* R
*?]"L 8 . ( G L
! u3 # ( - G*.
' &
( L*#
!
=3 # 7 X 8 G " L 8 .
* .
'$
! D" # '
"%
,# "
8
* Z
» F'
"#$
% « J 8<
' !
#
*T j G
( -*
8 J Rv*L ) ( J - "
* j ' o# j # ( J 33 + 7 .
*?]"L ,# "
7&
AN J - "<
J T T
*
* R AN J - "<
J
* j
* j
*
* h ŽX K2 7 Y
*L X
*.
8<
# 7
* 5# 0 - "4 L
! u3 #
#
*?
Rc?
7 CQ 7 '
"T
*.
.
% W - . 8
"N J 8<
*?]"L T
! ( +(
KH
"#$
% 7
"2 # ,# "
*.
*
» 7 -*.
« ' T4 (
"
NC 7 G " L 8<
)
"2 ,# "
8 (&
* j
X 7
"#$
% :" H6 G
'
*L j#
( J 33 +
‚7 T # G "<
* 8<
8 q=
- . X
RG
# 8 G '
#o - "6 <
"#$
% 7 8 U+
G ) .
#
* 8 . 8<
=+ #
,# "
7 -*.
+ 0 7 t = # 7
* 8<
J 7 -*.
G 8<
8
*.
:" H6 ) <
R L ?
#) ( J L
! Ru36 I"
L R 5 L L '
"
8 . L
!
*+ '
"
,#
"Qz#
G
. qV ' ,# "
W 7 -*.
h
"`#
! H<
<' 7
] ( RJ
Rn '*?L '
R^ ? R: oN?
<"
( R8 R*?L R*?3L A '*
! R ' 3 7 R R- +$
"<
Z
? 7 '
A%#
h G ) *
! G "<
) Abrahamian, 2016
. (
3 .
3$ 4
+ 0 1
%5 +
'
"%
/X $
#(
A R 8 "& P '
? C#
7
"
G N L
! . ( H 7 8<
,# "
"?
7 L
!
X
^ 3C (r 7
{"U#
"<
'
*j ) : ' ' 8
; <
=(
*
*.
'
*0
(
" / ! -$
+ V /<
7 ( J
"#$
% ' A%#
h ' r+
'
*
~ C X"
7 ) L /<
!
- 3H#
*? # R- "
R8 RJ + # 7 ' ...
' j # )
' ' $ 8
"#$
R % I "X
BC A ' ' G 8 8: & 3: 3<
3F
<3H G E ...
755
- " # '
...
8#
R # ( -
"#$
% 7 L 7 8<
y3j # 8 TCE &
( RJ K<
R E "
7 R
" # ( RA 3Y ' ( H ' u+ # - 3H#
R*
- * "E (
" / ! . .
,# "
- L 8 6 8<
D <
X
?[
€ A -
"%
J<
#1
7 6
* R (
%#
7 3 #
Q CX ) #
7
* 8<
-$
^ "#
7&
J /<
KL
*? HL . ,# "
4 Qs (
"
( K3 L
!
" HN 6 ! 8<
- '
< <
7 G*
R
*T j#
*? # ( K3 L
!
" HN 6 !
"L O<
"
q
"
8. #
*/%
R
&(
)'"
' J ( :' 6* ) 7 jV ' 7 J 8<
5CV ) 8%?
8 /<
.
! R /%
7 )
Teramp & Zanker, 2007: 139 (
" ? .
J ' G 0 ( ! 2[
"#$
%
L X"
! S0 7 CV ' - ? . 2[
"#$
% # 7
* . )
"2 ,# "
A%#
% 7 L
"#) Z
K #
"
J - ? .
"#$
%
*? HL .
! "
F \#
' ! J_'}
2015 4=1
W (
"
X
# 7
*H :
»#
^ "#
A%#
h ' K
R +' 7 A%#
% 7 L # '
* * .
$ #
)"#
# 7
*?/<
R
$ 5 V <
' Y #
*? HL
« . ,# "
G # m ! ( A
"2 9
!
M(
jV '"
7 # 7 6
* :
»
# %0 A%#
h
^ "#
X 8<
3M )' Y # - ' ŠV ] V ( - #
* * # CY#
# 7
*?<
8<
8
"#$
%
* '"
« )
Berlet, 2015 (
.
qV ' J
~ G N 8<
5# 0
*? )"#
! ' /<
7 L 7 ' T
! X
! - "N # 7 (
*?
R 8/
"%=
+ & &
( H 7 '
•m j#
".
U 7 8<
8j#
o%/#
V
! R L 7 ' N?L"
7 8 # # 7 . R - "CL + & &
( H
"
!
&(
)'"
!
' DS
%
# [ 7 -$
{"U#
# 7
*??<
' 5 8
?% "
7 R o%/#
8j#
8 - ? . x"
7 CH # 7
*?L .
! "
F \#
,# "
- " # ' - 3H#
- ? . 2[
"#$
%
"j#
7
# 7
*?<
.
% W X 8 J 8<
D A0 ' - "CL + & &
( H
#) 7
* ' C4#
( # 7
* . ' # 0
%
# [ 7
"V # 7 6(
* "
8<
8j#
o%/#
V ! ' - "4 L 7 ' N?L"
7 8 # . .
? '
*L .
"C j#
! W?(#) A B
* '
" "
!
*#$
' G D"M n "
p T j?1 R X
"
- 7
<
R Rm <
R^ "#
#"
8 ) 8
† X
"
- - " # '
- 6*?L ?&
(R
"
B ( '"
! - #) 8 R <
BL <
G R L ' ( L
! x 7
+' L
! + d ( RF "C ' .
J A B
" "
! ) L W 1970 8
*j
~'".
G*.
'
) ?L 8#
. F 0
"x 0 # ( - A
" "
!
%+ # (
#"
8 m
*4 # Z
"#$
% )
3M L /<
(
" /
" " '
&' ! F 1900 8 .
C[
"N R 90
*1
#"
8
"/V 10
*1 ! m ! 8j#
) Piketty, 2014:438 (
.
1. Think Big
756
49
"#
3 % & ' 1398
qV ' 8Š $ C
*.
"#$
% + & &
( KH ,# "
&
( )'"
. '
*j ) ! )
L /<
!
"M 7
*? # +(
R R*_
R8H "
3N ( RO _(
O ' ...
D A0 E "
7 ' + & &
( H
# ( -
^ "#
C4#
( ) ! 8 (
* ' R
*.
-'A )' 7
+ *[
7 '
" "
! V !
' r ((
"
N?L"
7 '
#' T#
:) L
!
? 7 . J ' 5# [ # G*.
*
7
^ "#
r ((
"
[ (T 7 Y . 8<
J B 8 -$
8 X "&
# 7 . .
1 . 3 . + 3 6 + 738
' L W X (
"
L /<
!
"M 7 o%/#
V !
*[
G*
! 8 # G
* . 8% $
v %.
L
! u3 # TCE 7 R H?
7 R 3H 7 R ) 7 R N?L"
7 R CLS#
7 ' ...
D"M ' R
# v %.
TCE 7 ' ' = # ( - A G '
*#$
V ! BT (
" /
! 9 + & &
( KH
J L /<
8 . .
/(
"
H<
7 8<
8 D A0
+ & &
( H 7
# 5 # 7
* . R
"
!
*? HL 8<
8 +(
5 o%/#
V ! 8 H
* ) G [ 7 X"
*?.
'
4 ( o m 7 8 .
*?.
.
! "
F \#
n "
Y? "2 7
! 8<
" " CNN
F
2016
^ Y R v %.
.) #$
7
"#$
% BT !"(N /]
0 ) ,# "
=
"<
.
8 E # ( N ( J
• "1 h
^ ] H<
7 8<
8 ,# "
‹ !
* R
• 4 + ( 5 G*.
* '
( 7
"N
?j 7 '*0 45 *1
"N H<
7
* 8<
4 ( o 8U # -$ ) " <
*? . '
•A /V K<
8j#
* )
Norris, 2016 (
.
y U#
J
"2 A B
?#
7 V ! '
#'"4#
( [ 7 # K/X
*.
*
^ "#
) G'"6 L
! ( 7 G*.
. T [
"
J 8<
' - "6 <
M(
"L #"
L A !
K<
R (
%
! L
! m E 7
*#
R
L X
! T(
"
R
G X
L
! h R "&"
- ?<
J< H#
# [ 7 R j ( T(
"
=(
&*
7 8<
8 C K< "
R- " # -'
L | !
" . ! 6* ) 7
# 7
*??<
R /V &
( J
~ 8<
# 7 R "6 ( 8 N n "L '
*j H#
=+ #
"T - " #
R*? HL 8 G"
"
! BC?
L R D A0 ' - "CL + & &
( H "Y?#
G*.
R 8 E
! 8<
$
( K H L
!
"T H#
8 C 3 RG 1"
L
! 3r.
7 ' G
# [ 7
^ "#
B )"
# 7
*??<
)
Inglehart & Norris, 2016:2 (
.
`(
c?
- *
- V 1
' 8j#
n ?.
H "
W
<
7 R
*T j#
8<
' 5
-"V ( H ' K%
q#
R8 "#
h TCE W &
( J
*
* 8<
3M (
J j ( K<
A<" # R
G*
# 7 . . ' !
*T j#
8<
TCE &
( J ) 8T $ 7 (R K<
# A
K<
'
" <
J
?#
( 3r.
7 8<
" "
"UX
! L [ 7
$ ( S&
"
* ' H<
7 8<
8 5(+
1. Esping Anderson
BC A ' ' G 8 8: & 3: 3<
3F
<3H G E ...
757
H%.
L
! +' RG q#
8 "#
p T G "<
* R
" *j H#
J 8TCE
"
! S&
:"
L j.
! + & &
( H 7
*? HL )
Anderson & Biorkland, 1990: 195-217 (
.
"#$
% W # ! [ !
<S#
. ) ( J J
?(
- j?1 7
"#$
% R I #
*.
*
(
% ! - "6 <
"#$
R %
#'"4#
( KY0 ' (j 7 ) j (
"#$
% )
#*X [
7 R
v %.
L
! u3 # j#
W
"#$
% ' 7 +' + d ( F "C W?(#) 50 J o%/#
R
BT # 7 9 ,# "
=
"<
* 8<
J # ( - v %.
L
! TCE 7 R H?
( 7 ' P !
j#
W
"#$
% BT 8 H "
"
!
*? . .
1 . 1 . 3 . 9 1-
":
+
8j#
- ?.
W?(#) v %.
TCE 7 j#
W
"#$
% 8 E
"T C 7 ƒ?&
8TCE ) KL
*
# 7
*??<
8<
C[
* ):
1 . TCE W m ' - NC 5# . - "
' RDA0 - C0 1
<".
L !
3#*?]
( 7 ' ....
w 2 TCE. W k # m
5# . R- *? # - *V T0
R L - G N/
' ...
w 3 CE. T W
k # &
( J 8<
- *?# <
' - "6 <
"L # - C0 1 5M /#
"X h] <
5# . # 7 . w
4 TCE. W
"6 <
8<
- "6 <
[ ! 8 X <
L 5# . # 7 . w ' 5 TCE. W T(
"
8<
( - % '
Š 2 7 L 8<
0 7 7
*?
( L) ! 31 7
?j 7 R> X R> . &
J%H#
' - # L !
# [ 7
#s ( J R*??<
5# . # 7 . . 8 E
"T C 7
*#$
m W TCE W F' ( B ) 500 AL
m ' TCE W KY?&
" <
) 15 AL m . TCE W F' h
*1 8j#
#"
7 6(
"
'
TCE W KY?&
24
*1 . n "
BL'P&
( 3N ( A )
- V
{"U#
"#$
% 7 R K<
40
*1 ) '"Q m G*4 # X
(
? h
*1 - * '" .
"#$
% 7 .
* 7
» '"Q «
»
*#$
« ' = # '
8 h3
#) ( RJ R8 X H z#
Y
! R
^ n
'
*? # J G . )
( H 7
" E 7 R 1395
(.
% W + 8 J 8<
^ - "4 L
! V ! 8<
"#$
% Y # 7 . R
(
" / J Qs (
"
"
8 TCE W k # R
"6 <
' T(
"
8j#
# 7 S6
! " . F \#
) F 1975
1997
#(
- A N H%. ' 7
L
"#$
% 8 3%.
7 N /]
(
"
A B 8<
J # ( - (
" /
8 H%. ' L
) TCE W k # 8j#
* )
Ehrig, 2003: 4 (
.
.
*
% 7 ) m 3 7
<
8 TCE &
( J
"#$
% ' '*0 40 # (3 ( -
"#$
% 7 8<
)
#*X
[ 7
^'"4#
* R ) ,# "
0 R* "<
o 0 ,# "
8 ( K H ( 7
"T H#
"#$
R %
<".
L R h L
!
€ A ' ...
8<
^ "#
[ !
"#$
% 7 + *[
7 L
! V ! '
"T X
. 7 ) ' $ # 7
? H
* .
758
49
"#
3 % & ' 1398
2 . 1 . 3 . - 9 1
;) 3 +
lX . 7
H?
7 R lX . T#
8H
! # ( - ' O?
8<
+' ( J F
2006
k J Y 7
V
"j#
7
*.
. J lX . ' =
L
! # ( - ' O?
]
*j ( 7 R V
! R :) #$
' . *
"
7
# 7
*?<
)
http://www.hoshdarnews.ir (
.
jC (
‘
*x - ) j#
W
"#$
% j
<S#
8
% 7 ) K #
"
J B+ ] L
! j#
W
"#$
%
*C 5 G*.
. J jC (
‘ B
t T0 ' A
•o# <
/#
.
- )
"#$
% 7 CH 8 - "#
"#$
% 7 5r.
L
! 8 /#
' 4 ( o # 8 / A
" <
! #
7
*??<
.
! "
F \#
- )
?1 q M(
# 2 "
7
" "
"L m ! 8<
- "#
# 7
*??<
R B
#*X . *
7 ' [ 7 kT 72 R ? B
+(
* 76
R ? Y
G "X .'"
7 79
? '
#*X .) #$
7 88
? #
7
*??<
) Us. Census Bureau, 2016 (
.
"#$
% ( B ) 15 # (3 ( - X k
- ) G # 7 . ' ) J
*j 29
*1
?j 7 4 / 374 / 354 X )
"
kX
"T
"V
* . 8 E # ( N ( J - )
"#$
% 7 8<
^ V'
<
# 7
*??<
R 8 U ' W v %.
A R 8 )' 840 # (3 ( m ) # 7
*?L )
Us. Census
Bureau, 2016
(.
v %.
A
"
! - ) N ( J &
"#$
% [ ( y
"
. # ( - ) 7 8<
^ V' <
# 7
*??<
R
" "
"L m ! 8<
- "#
=(
&*
8 A - "#
` ( 7
# 7
*??<
R - )
" $ T 7 C 8 E F j#
63 R ? - ) m (?
7 C 54
? ' - ) $ ( 7 C
85
? #
7
*??<
)
(Ibid
.
…U 4 ( o KL 8 H J
v %.
A ) ( J
"C .
! "
F \#
) 7 8<
> *#
?. <
7
*.
* R CH 8 h m
! 8<
- "#
"#$
% 7 L ( J
> *#
4 (3 7 #
7
*??<
R 72
? A
# 7 6(
* "
' ) 7 8<
!
> *#
" <
!
*? HL
( A CH 8
"#
7 8<
L ( J
> *#
4 (3 7
* R A
" <
! #
7
*??<
) (Ibid .
j#
W
"#$
% kT 5 / 19
*1 - "#
8 5%.
[ 7
<
# 7
*??<
' A &
( J
# 7
*??<
R + 0 7 8<
J
#$
"
! - ) ( B ) 31
*1 )
Ehrig, 2003: 8 (
.
8% $ ,# "
L N 7
•o# <
A ! 8 - ) '
- L 8 6 8<
B(&
) L
8C0 # L B
^o[
G "<
8<
-)
"
! ' ' (3 W
• S + '
» 7
*L X J jV ' (
- ?&
*?<
8<
- ) ) C ' '
' L
( 8/
B "E 3 # ) - ) ) C
*.
«
) Terump & Zanker, 2007: 269
(R J F 0 B 2[
( 7 ) - )
"#$
% 7 8 U ' W
jC (
‘ L
! H?
7 8<
j#
W
"#$
% 3[
( 8 $ F [ # 7 . R ) D L ( o ! 3<
( - ?
A#
-)
"< # 7 8<
H ?#
8 ( K H
"T H#
"#$
% R X !
* "<
.
