amp amp

(1)

:

! " #

) :

22 / 1 / –88 :

15 / 6 / 88 (

1 : 1940

! 1970

# $ % & ' ( !

)* + ), -.$ /

, 0 12 # 3 4)#5 /

) )# 7 0 8) 9# )$

% #0 ) ' ) 7 0 ' )!

# $ -: ; < $ = &

(

?) ! '- 4)! @ A B % C D(E @ = FG$ '

(H I 0 J =! ? K# A B < 8 C $ # L M#

1*

), ) +

# 8 N!

-): ; )/ ( ! FN ' = & 4O P D*/ Q 4 $ % E + ! $ '4O 8O . ), '% )S+ )! $ =) & 0 )2 + -: ; - E & $ OT

# $ H B 4O 9 # / - ( ! # $ % &

U )V )/ 4) : ) 0 4

8 . W/ X (Y! $ ' B # -

, CK F V H

)$ )/ -) =) &

A V SV ( ! 8H @ W/ ' @ = FG$ ' 0 $ ,

% W * P W/ ' FG$

# A K9# @ = FG$ $ O

.

# $ - &

K)$ '0 # -: ; ( ! )$ ) /

* F E 8S+

8/ O B # 0 7 Z # # US# N ' / = & [4W 5 $ @ =

4 4S $ 1C&

.

4 / % ; :

( ! ' ( ! 8H '

# W: ; '

# $ , '

-: ; ( ! # $ % &

* : 03518210310 Email: [email protected]

! " #$ % !& ' ' ()' #$*

:

» ( , , -&$ . / 0-1 /' ) :

.)!" 2 -2 ) 3 1

«

# , 0 39

# * 0

4 % 0 1388 .

(2)

1 - :

.)!"

development)

(:)' #$* ; -1 /' <! 1 2 -. => <! 1 ' ()' - !?@ (

.

: :2 A%: & B ' , #$:& !:/! 0 :&' #! 2 '$. )' - !C* , D E" ! <!?@ ' - F=) ,

;.@ 2 $*

#G', 2 , #$* H 2 I '!/ , ' ' H '$. )' !J -

, $*

()' K ' ; C"

. I: '!/ :2 - '$: 2' A % " , $ !" 2 0- ) I '!/ -&!B B , L"

.)!" , $ M A % " ?&N

: , A: 1 , O , :. / - $& :) , H ,N

# ?2 $PQ 2 - H '$ ! -/ :R , -: R' S :& C ' , I : ' : ?2 J H ' 2

-: #$:&'!R .:)!" , H :)!& 0 ' !/, ( ' , # , S, T , $ !" U 'V ' H' 2

!:*

) - T!:

0 1390 W 0 62

.(

-:: Y :: :: J .::)!" <!::?@ :: !::*

, $::* :: $&' ::2 K ' ::

# , 2 Z!2 -[ " \ E 2 ()' ! )'V & $ 2 %= -1 /' #$ 1 S' L" ' H'

&' ()' - . 3 ]^

.

! _&N - . 3 ]^ &' )

1978 (

» a V:2 -&!:B B «

-:

:2 0$: &

# , !:2 # ' b -1 : /' H ? : O 2 V O, ' - . 3 S' L" ' # *' H' .

H %2 c C:*' H!:) :2 : d :2 : d ( d H . 2 .)!" <!?@ $& , 2 ' 2

» $

« 2 , "

H P Q' , -C G! ! C" \ E

» O

« (:)' - . :3 :. / -: . . / "

(Long, 1985, p. 198)

H P: Q' $:* ' e(:)' H %2 -& . , f ." H' ' .)!" <!?@ .

( . T " , $ !" g ' * 2 0c h '! 1 2 # i&N -B$:& -: g ' :* :2 H P Q' H

<

- /!"

-& %&' # , $ N I !" 0c h '! 1 2 -1 /' H $ O " !*

(Peet and

Hartwick, 1999, p. 1)

, -1 /' ( '$1 , ...

.:)!" <!:?@ ' $ % -", @ -& .

()' #$* j' ' .

H 'VB : :2 0 .:)!" : ' ()' ( .Q', ' $ k -2 l H ! m "

2 < n&

-: ]!J :J o: , : $* D E H ' N ' )

(:

- (: , ( H : ' 2 ,

Q q r ( , g)!" #$* J sC H' :2 !:) h '$d 2 -2 ) 0A $@ , A V& * H

( *

! : : H' :2 - I h '$d D E" , -3!PR H =)

<' N :? O (:)

( )' (

!2 # ' ' Q n& $ ' .

( , () ) 2 J B 0I '!/ '

!:) F% 0 !R H

-: ( ! " ' ! q.)!" $&, , # ; ?%" ' -3!PR U[2 H' 2

;: E" : ' 0 :

(*' #$?1 2 ' .)!" 'VB U & !2 ' 2 ' 0- ?&

.

$& !2 %&'! & .)!" c d & .)!" I '!/ 0 i H!) ' )

%:2 , V: & H

%&'! & !

$&' ( 2 .)!" ' 0< /u 0$ -> -. => S !3 2 ' !R -[ " M; C" )

) B < &' - , & H 'VB

;C , "

]!%:E :. / ' U:[2 "

-

!*

: ( , . :&!B 2 ' $ ' ' 0 !R A % ( '$ , ( R 2 ()' ( , ' H'

& 2 - < &' 2 #$* HV

$& ) . :*' , u :2 < %:&' ;: :2 (: , 0 :i S =1 2

(3)

:)

%:: I: '!/ : ' ( '$: H' ::2 : VB : ?2 0An : v $::. -"^ C :" H : .)!"

- ]!%E V & w d c d , #$* ]!%E -i

!*

. 'VB : 0(: , 0 ' 2 2

.)!"

- '$ Q .)!" c d & .)!" I '!/

!*

. 0o: N S 2 ' : ' :2

.)!" ( , 0( , ' B

) .)!" ( ,

#'!R (

- @B

!*

. .)!" ( , : ()' - , 0' B

( x q '

H P Q' H -

-1 /' -

#, B 0 . / !/! -i :) ,

H :

" H' ' , c . 3 1 H ,N!& , - N U & 2 '!" , ;

0 . / f [ H (:?/

U 2 ( ' , # , ?2 -B$& D E"

- # @ )' < < " H' 2 "

$:

. .:)!" (: , 0' :B

- y %2 .)!" ' D E" H' 2 ' . / !/! I2 < " ()' - ,

$

1.

D > ' 0 .)!" 'VB v( , -: D E ' .)!" ' 0 !R H 'V2'

$:

. 0 : 'V2' : '

z: 0 :i=[& { :i& |!:& F%:d :2 0 ! : ',' S ' *' !/, Al 1 H, : / , ! : 2 A d -) ) (: , !:?x ' ;:=Q q: d #$: N U :O H : '

.)!"

(:)' S, @ H ,$d " ! H' 2 0' B .

:)!" : & 2 !& :Q 0W :R !> :2 , .

( , ' H %2 - 3' H 'V2' ,V/ 0 ' V & .)!" & 2 K'$: ' D E" (?/

- ]!%E - q.)!"

!*

2.

< n& 0 'V2' ' ' 0$ %: -& : O H!:i ' H' ' : -

U 2 ( '

()' ' !R 2 H "

. , -:) 2 (:?/ (:)' -:* C 0 *!& '

|!:w!

:

& 2 <V & C , O'G q.)!" $&, .)!" & 2 !& Q U &

! ' HV

) -i&!iJ ( e

- % J , )

( ( :O'G ! .)!" q & 2 !& Q .

!: ] :[ &' H' :2 - :3' ;: ,

()' } ;2 Q O'G -" . r :

' c,' : l : (:)' $:* - . :3 H!i ' %[& O'G 0

O, '

# ,N ' /' 2 j

$&'

) 0~: v 1379 W 0 221

.(

( : O •$: -1'$:" # '!: 0 :O'G < :&

- . 3 - ()' # !2 D ! q.)!" $&, 2 H ! , H P Q' S $Q 0o G! ! C"

. ' <, 0 :

*€B H' ' 0 ! ' H,V -& 0o " H'

) -@ <!?@

( c^ )' 2 -C ,

-i - -) ) - H P Q' )

: (:=h <!:?@

(

# , , N < : " -:@& ' H' ' : :J

- ', ' i

!2 $*

. F 1 ! ' c!E"

-: 0 N -i .)!" , #$&

S :C& $:&'!"

$* 2 *' 2 $ % 2 - !E" B - ! H' 2 -&',' .

1 .

@ k ! 2 . r H' 2

•R * , .)!" ( , H 0' B

.

‚ :

(@

N 0ƒ , )

1384 ( % S+ ( ! 8 - 1 q / " 0

$ E H$? , H, %R w ' ?" 0H

:

%)k

, -i 2 S E" , S . r •3 0 ' ?" 3 . ' 2' - '

205 - 227 .

2 . 0 .)!" <!?@ 2 „! d , !& Q (=%& ! 2 q. r H' 2 .

‚ :

Davis, K. E. (2008) "The Relationship Between Law and Development: Optimists versus Skeptics" , New York University Law and Economic Working Papers; Available online at:

http://isr.nellco.org/nyu/Lewp/papers/133

(4)

- ! ' , &

$% !&

:

»

- $Q

!R$: " H ! O'G 0HV "

-2 -& 2

- ]!%E Ad

$*

. :O'G 0<, -& :?/ z / ' $.2 ;%& } 0 '

N H & ' H %2 - 3' I= !2 H !

&

? - q: , !j$: , 0 !: V ! " 0 :* $ &

o &, C ' SuN 'V2' |'!&' -

- ] %d 2

$ N

(Dwyer, 1990, p. 9)« .

$&, ' .)!" S 2 '

'! 1 2 O'G .)!"

» - O'G #V . «

Japanese miracle)

()' #$* ( 1.

: ' 0 :)' '

0, : ' ' …(:)! O |!Q, 2 H , ) J 2 , &!iJ 0 O'G •V . ()' † > ;2 Q c'k) d H!i ' $ ‡" < & w d *!&

& 2 ' 2 A :C 2 0HV !: " H *!& & 0

& 2 , ) U & n ' O'G .)!" ' - E" - ', ()' .)!" q & 2 !& Q , HV

.

;P < :n& R :) ' H P: [ f :3!" ' :O : ()' ;C* $2 *!& ' H$ 2

: g2', |!& , < n& ' '€B T‡" H ?& 0 O'G -) ) N

: ' † :> 0 : _ , :

H / 2 *€B , Q ' 0 ?& ' ' H %2 |!w!

.:)!" ;=Q P1 2 Z!2 , #$&

O'G ) ', B! !" P1 (

) W R ]!J J $ % : ' )' - O'G H '

0$:&'

) U[2

?J " , H (

& 2 U & ; E" 2

& 2 !& Q , HV O'G q.)!" $&,

) U[2

A O ( ˆ!:r" ) 0 i S =1 2 , N ,$" - ' J , O'G .)!" & 2 !& Q - % J ,

& 2 O'G .)!" H' 2 HV )

A * U[2 (

(R' O A '!R .

: & < : V: & : O

#$1 Q 2 0‰E2 .)!" & 2 !& Q ( #$ ." ; '!1 ! H'

-: # :*'

: !:*

- ]!%E *!& ' - 3' &

!*

. -@ :3!" 0 :w d *!& U ,ŠO {, -

, -: E"

I / 0 N 'V2'

# ' , S 1^>' H ,N :& [2 !/! I2 '

A:? F: r ' # @ :)' , H'

( ) !/!

()' - & ' H .

2 -

& 2 < n& ?2 ‚ H' 2 -:) ) R :) 2 - *N 0 O'G .)!" q & 2 !& Q , HV

, - !Cd , 0 ! ' •$ # ' ' ; '!1 , , &

()' -&',' ( ' $/', .

0U[2 '

- /!" O'G -) ) < n& -Q! d (R ) 2

< n& /, " C*N ;Q'$d ' J A

1 . 2 $ i 2 0c h H' 2 :

Mohindra, Satish and Vijay Tiwathia (1987) The Japanese economic miracle: lessons for high productivity, Michigan: University of Michigan, Lancer International.

c ) { 'VB -& ?/ o& 2 1993

0 !R

!2 # ' ' Q - P@ . r ) ' O'G ( !E 2 )N „ * #V . |!w!

.

‚ : A World Bank policy research report (1993) The East Asian Miracle: Economic Growth and Public Policy, New York: Oxford University Press.

(5)

-) ) 2 - = -Q! d < n& 0H' , S '$:Q' -&!& Q H 2 -?/, e ' ' Q -) )' !& Q

-) ) ; '!1 H C 1

- -: ; C :" ' H P Q'

$:

. 0 :O'G -:) )' !& :Q F:/! :2

, : 0 : •!:Q :) o C@" 2 -& O < n& H' ' ! ' , ()' < 2 D . ( d ()' j ‹Q .

0 O'G -&! -) )' !& Q c ) 2 Z!2

1947 ()' . ' „!: -:) )' !& :Q :J B'

;3' D2 r -C C" n&

73 c ) -) )' !& Q 1889

) -:v P:1 -:/

(

Meiji age)

N q d^:3' 0(

- - " !& Q -:v ' , -:) )' !& :Q :2 S, @ Œ^ 0 ' IQ', ' B

(:)' -:/

. !& :Q

d ;3' ) q O 2 0 O'G $ $/ -) )' ( %: 0 !:"' s ' -" @ :" U & , < (

, - !:/

- n& , z / -@&

R :* & Œ =%:& , $: $/ -"u!: -: . 0 2 „! d 2 <' d' Œ ?& , H B

()' '! )' O'G .

-: : , ' -& O A % ) O'G 0 !& Q ' F/! 2

National Diet)

( 0

- 1 : , ()' - !Cd B ' "

( !•%: N c :=Q | : /u 2 0 ! : • ' ' ' : , S‡

$& '

) -% j 0 &

1372 W 0 7 .(

- 1 •!Q

! : S $:Q I:/ "

) -&!& :Q :n& ' (

:?& :? " : _ ,

-:: ] %::d ::2 '€::i&!& Q

$:: N )

;::3' 41 ( B$:: & :: ' ;C :: 0

House of )

Representative

(

, ,

'

House of Councillors)

- (

$* 2 . H' ' B$: & :

512 0 N -B$ & • , , # !2 -) 4

()' )

. ] :[ &' < g)!" 0 ' H ‹1'

-

$&!*

. H' ' V & ' ,

252 ()' -) 152

, < : g:)!" N -) 100

]'Vd' -j' N 'V F) " 2 0#$& Q 2 -) - F% H )' ) S 2 [ &' f [

0$

- ; C" ]'Vd' •$* - . H '$ $& '

!*

.

• , ' 6

: , ()' c ) 3

- $ $ " N H ‹1' ' - & S 2 [ &' 0c )

!*

.

- 2

;:E ' B$: & $&'!"

' , c^E&' 2 0-&!& Q \ E 2 ' $ (% &

) 0 : N # B$: ' O'G 1377

W 0 151 e

-% j 0 &

1372 W 0 13

.(

()' #$ B '€B', 2 2 O'G •!Q ) .

;3' 65 .(

(%[& ' F 0 2 ,

- ' , S‡ ,

$* 2 )

;3' 66 .(

(%[&

(%:[& g)!" 0Ž' , , O g)!" 0 , : ,

- ]!P $&!*

)

;3' 67 .(

(%[&

% B$ & 2 ' ( , S‡ Ž' , h ' , ,

- ] [ &'

$&!*

) 0 : N # B$ ' O'G 1377

W 0 152

.(

H• :2 H : & 0; C :" ' :O 0 :O'G q 2

'$& % 1' .

(%:[& : ' ;C : 0 O'G -) ) < n& •!Q 0H : ,

12

0 & [" ' , 9

S‡ o , , ,

; % -) 2

) ] %d 2 -B$ ) c!•%

q& :) :

( , ( ()' . 0 w d c d 9

, ' ' :Q , : : , o: :?&N •• : :) 8

, ! % 24 (%[& n& -B$ &

- # ' ' Ž' , ' -C , , 0$&!:*

F "

- ; C " ' O'G q •!Q -& )

$

) G 0 : N # B$: ' O' 1377

W 0 152 0-:&' ?" !:s 1 e

(6)

1372 W 0 69

.(

(%[& g)!" 0 •!Q ‘ '! < "

:2 0 2 , •!Q •$ & '! 1 2 ,

- j' ' O

!*

.

# B' , - 1 '! g)!" j ‹Q •!Q H j O H

- < &' "

; :* : !:*

8

0- 1 # B ' 50

d & # B ' 0H'

50 , # '!& R # B ' 452

- ŽV/ # B '

$* 2

) 0 : N # B$ ' O'G

1377 W 0 152

.(

0 O'G •!Q

» ! % « ' ' - 3' U &

.

! %: : '

:

0- 1 S % / 2 %

#$?1

U :2 H '

- :3' , :"

‰:E2 : ' :J $ %: H :"

0 :

P" , S' '€

A H B ! % - S !3 >!2 H

: B . 0 B$: & : 18

' , , ! %

16

$& ' ! % .

2 #,^1 0

4 0 :/ !2 ! %:

! % ) ( !•% , ; 1 • !d 0-> =‹&' , H ' ' 0-) 2 %d -

U 2 - f x, 2

& [" ' , r d , ) ,

' ( 2 r - , H .

! % 0 B$: & : H

! % - d $& ' n& ' H / , H ' ' ! '

c!> ; 2 0 ' , H

U 2 • , U :2 0c^:E&' :rR :2 :?/'! <$1 , ' "

: & 2 -:) 2 :2 :"

, :

() )

- - H

$& ' O .

! S ' , • , : ()' } ;2 Q C& ' 0 #!Q

A , # "! 0 '! ' H %2 ' "

2 ()' c ) .

() ) ' , 0, ' '

& [" ' , - H :

2 , - †!r) ' A , *' n& - '

< : FP:& , cV:1 , S : jV/ "

H :

#

- ( R f [ H

$ . Aj Q S' , !:2 ' Œu!: . , H ' ' <

2 :) 2 H :

' S n& & [" ' , - ! ' 2 0()'

) - &

0# ' 1372 W 0 73

.(

0' , : ()' - d '

() ) ;2 (%:[& :2' 2 Œ P[ , 2 n& ! K'$ ' ,

!: ' # !:d 0 : ,

r" , Z!2 & [" ' , H C 1 , H /

$ % c!•% 2 K'$ ' 2 N D2 .

3 -

! "

#$ % &' () * + , +

& [" ' , 0- !> 2 2 -& B 2 , I 3 H

-: '

(Ministry of International Trade

and Industry (MITI))

- ' ' S ' , ,

(Ministry of Finance (MoF))

, A:? H, 2 , 0 , (:

-) )' :w d c :d -: d , H P Q' H ) 2 ' , ! ' o "' , !2 ?& "

- ]!%E

$&!*

. 0 P Q' H = ' H' 2 ' H Tk H u %&'! H 'V2' 0 O'G 0( )' n& 2

2 -& B 2 , I 3 S ' , ] & W!PR 2 :2 :" (:)' # ,N !:/, :2 -: '

, H ' Q 2 , H ' ' # i :) 0(:) ) 0(: , - :1 †!r) !/! q& 3 g2', ( ! "

( * (1 >' 0a V2 "

' -3!PR H

»

; . ' ! ) M- ' /'

« S ' , g:)!" #$* 3

2 -& B 2 , I 3

$ ‹" ' - '

) 0( )' 1377 W 0 150

7.(

' @&

10 (%[&

O'G ,

2 c ) H 1957

"

1986 (%[& ' U O 0 :2 -& :B 2 , I 3 , 0H ,

: -: '

(7)

-

$& !2 -"

. c ) & [" ' , ' 1881

S ' , '! 1 (E"

» S " , H , «

:2 lN

. c ) 0 >!2 & [" ' , 1925

< & 2

» S " , (. 3 S ' , «

: ' ' !R 2

' . c ) & [" ' , ' < &

1949 S : " , I :3 S ' , 2

» :2

-: '

« (: : L"

.

- , #$:* :)‡" S : " , (. :3 S ' , 2 -& B 2 &'GN K^ j' , E"' D > ' -"

c! A % ( !•%

() ) H$ 2 () ) H' /' , H P Q' H

' -/ :R -& B 2 H

(*' #$?1 2

) 0-) =1 1385

•3 0 117 - 118

.(

2 2 q:. r ,$:2 O'G .)!" 0 !%& / J ,

q %/ 2 U &

- -"

(% & A? ;2 Q 0

(Johnson, 1982, p. 13)

. c ) ' 0 & [" ' , ' < &

2000

< l ' , S d^3' -R 2 c =& 2 , S ' , 2 -& ) H

» P Q' , I 3 «

: '$: O : L"

& 2 $.2 S E@3 c!> 0 *!& ' ' - <

: $: '!R : :& [" ' , : ' ' -"

.

& [" ' , V & O'G - ' ' S ' , -

-"

! : : ' q.)!" $&, - u 2 ( ' ' 0

()' ' !R 2 .

U[2 0H$.2 H (R' O A '!R & [" ' , ' U & 2 .

0 :O'G .)!" $&, Tk ) ,' 0-[ " \ E 2

» h" :) H P: Q' (: =

(The «

Headquarter for Economic Stability)

!2 12

c ) S,' 1946

$* )‡"

. : 0 ) '

: (: B ;C:* (?/ N ' 0$& !2 2 H' , $d N H ‹1' , (*' -&',' S $Q () ) < " " !2 < u () ) , H ' rw' H

:) o O'G H ) 2 2 Z!2 H

’ , ’ ' , $&!* < l '

# i ) F P& -i / O Œu! . - , -: , H :

- -3!PR U[2

$ N ; 1 2 H B! / 0 !*

.

!:2 : , (%[& •$?1 2 ) ' ()

) -: &

0# ' 1372 W 0 312

.(

:) ' f x, y $" 2 0z / O 2 Z!2 d g ' * (*€B 2

#$* A

& 2 ) )‡" 2 ( ?& , H P: Q' HV

(Economic Planning Agency)

c ) 1955

( U N S' R' 0

.

& 2 $ $/ ) ; 1 $ q@ x, H P Q' HV

& 2 ,$"

!:2 , : : , ( :v) H' ' 0(*' #$?1 2 ' O'G ^ H .

:) : '

& !>

- & V & ;=Q U[2 ' ! -: : ' ' !R 2 _ 0$

$:

. : '

U & 0

» O'G o& 2 «

() ) ( '$ V &

(:)' /!" ;2 Q %2 ! H P Q' H .

c!>

W!PR 2 , *€B H

H 50 , 60 ( :* 0H ^ : 2 -: O'G H :

) ' ' !R & ! H

† > D >

- ‡" -C& 2 H

$&

.

" - B 0 '$ ' 85

- ; * ' ) $3

$*

) 0 V , O 1355 W 0 144

.(

0 :O'G o:& 2 D: > ' ( ,

<', ' H :

( * o& 2 ;2 - O'G a V2 H

-: (: d

: . c!:O H !:/! :2 0 :O'G o:& 2

o& 2 N -C& 2 S 1 , -" " H

&

-: c : 1' H$ $:* S n& ? :

.

F:/! {, : '

- ( * & ! q ) ‡" 0K > o ' " $*

C ' 0 :i K :> ' , !:* €:O

$* 2 *' ! H P Q' $* •!E& ( '$ , S n& - ? , • %d U & O'G ( , .

(8)

!> 2 H ' ' < n& 0-

'€B T‡" ?& , -2Vd < n& ,1

: $ %: O'G -) ) < n&

- ; C " O'G ' S $Q ‰ h 0-3!PR U[2 #' 2

$ . 0 O'G -2Vd < n&

' J B

: ? Hu :2 - $& ) '!" , S $Q ; 2 ' (% & ' !R 2 -[ " H!Q H

! : !:/! ]V:d )

S' !: c' := ]V:d

(Liberal Democratic Party(LDP))

( :2 0

-> W!PR c )

H 1955

"

1993 H!Q -2Vd < n& 0

#$: N !:/, :2 ! ' H'

()' . (:) ) ' )' ‰1 2 0S $Q ]Vd ' !‹d ' )' , ',' S $Q

$:* - :

† > ! ' }!@& 2 , $ " $Q H ' ' < n& q ), 2

!2 #$* HV

(White, 1998, p.41)

.

d '

(2 Q !/, Al 1 0]V

!:/! S :1^>' :2 < :n& 0-" 2 [ &' ' N (=%& 2 H

H ' N ( 1 2 -&!& Q <'V ' 0 ! H ' N •$:* R :* ( :) :2 D:d , -&$: H :

&' )‡"

]'Vd' i 2 K^ j' 2 - ? " 2 0-) ) H )

K^ j' N -

V: &

(*' u 2 () (

(:*' (:) ' S $:Q

(Brooker, 2000, p. 120)

. : (:)' , : ' '

0 :O'G -:) ) < n& ; E" 0 '$ $&' ' H %2 ]V:d o: H' ' -:) ) < :n& ' N

- g % e$ &'

-3!P:R U:[2 , $: N H ' ' < :n& ' O'G 0- ?& ; E" J B 2

() ' -.Q', S $Q $ % , O

$& ' . & 0 ' ! &

) , ?& •$

H

()' O'G -) ) < n& '€B T‡"

.

. ' ' < n& '€B T‡" U & ! !%&

- q& [" ' , W!PR 2 , O'G H

!:R ;: E" 0 ! : : ' q.:)!" -"

()' # j' ' -?/!"

. .

‚ :

Johnson, Chalmers (1982) MITI and the Japanese Miracle, Stanford, California: Stanford University Press.

2 . 'G , ' H ! g % ]Vd o 2 -) ) < n& ! 0 O

.

‚ :

Ferdinand, Peter (spring 1994) "The Party's Over: Market Liberalization and the Challenges for One - Party and One - Party Dominant Regimes: The Cases of Taiwan and Mexico, Italy and Japan", Democratization, 1/1, pp. 133-150.

(9)

* 1 - K ^ _#

-: ; 8H 7 4& J! # )

4WK (

. G HI:

. G HI: J %I B ? = ,5

B 5

%4 .

K 4% L C > M & LC ;

B ;

@ K

!" # $

! %&

' (

) ) )

4 - .

+ , / 0$ % *

R ) H ) ) - P Q' , MH d c :d : !i ' <,'$:" i& :& 0 :O'G :w

H

!:/!

3 1 H 1 /' f [ -

' c ) H

& ?/ z / ' ;=Q -

(:)' <,

(Cox, 2002, p. 109)

.

[2 0 J B' -

! $&, ' (

N V

"' ! )'V ! L" , :O'G :

:R 2 - ' :* & 0 : ?&

- '

- O 2 !2

& = - ' Su ' 2 $E H /

! B H R ' {V

& :?/ z / ' $.2 O'G -

!2 # ' „ @"' <, 0

E" '

;

?&

- 0

!?x < :n&

#Š: , ) :) - :* ,

#!

:3 R -

< :n& '

P Q' ) ' 0H ( ) , ?& ' )' %2 -

' ( B S !3

: :. / '

S$

;=Q

(*' !/,

.

R {V P Q' H ' , ' O'G H !:"' s '

:v - -:/

) 1868 - 1912 (

$:* :lN .

P:1

v

- -/

2^ &' O'G -

L" , u 2 ' S'

K i*

2 " ' .

' -: Su!E" ' ' :)'

?&

' b . v ( , - -/

> ' 0 D S' , !2 H

$/

$ 2 / H S' , !:2 :

H c' !:•

# ' ' -

$*

. , - ' 0IQ',

&'$ J S, @" , -

2 :C

$ i

$ :*'$&

: ' :2 #, :B , :

'

* i - N . /

$ *' D ." O'G .

' 2 H h c 0 1 -

"

(%O : H :v (: , - -:/

0

2 D . j' ! ) - - G !2 A

;=Q ) B! !"

', ( ( $R -

$&

' :2 : : S, :@"

j' ! ) ' Œ "$ 1 -

H () ,

"

$& !2 . 0, ' ' -

'!:"

(:@B ' : :r2' : -

:

$ H

(Clientelism)

H P Q' H 0 ) ) - 0 i - , n&

- 0 o:J! ,$:2 :"

L"

: H

Q 2 -

& , $&

q O '$

H ' P" < " !2 g2', A

B H H u 2 ‘r) 0

, !J ,$2

% ) ;C* 2 , ' J

& ) F"' -

O S => K > ' :"

' :/' :2 -:

$: N . :J :B'

R ' ' !R H / H ' , |!w!

- ' !• H )

!: ' ( :2 s:) , H !:"' s ' :2 '$: 2'

(10)

0< n& $* ' ' $ ( *

oJ! - ' !• H ' , ;3' 0c d ' 2 ' ) ,

"

C& H L"

. P Q' A % ) O '! 1 2 H ' , ;3' 0', B! !" A G ' , -Q^R' , H

- “ =" , y , " 0 O'G . /

$*

. H P Q' A % ) ' -

( $:R 0 ( ' 0-Q^R'

-: :3^R , N - ' !• . / -i& i 2 $:*

) -: &

0# ' 1372 W 0 51

.(

H : 1' < :n&

-

‡:" , "u 2 2 ( $R ( ' V & <, -& ?/ z / ' $.2 O'G -Q^R' K'$: '

- 3^R - I , . /

$*

.

F: l' ' ()' #$* j' ' -@ [ S' n& J B' 0 O'G 2 A d H P Q' < n& |!& # 2 Fd 3 ) < n& ' -3 R |!& !/, 2 $ . 0 ' n&

$ % ! ' H '

. 0o: &, u

) ' O'G H '

» ) -. / H '

(collective capitalism) «

&!B - . ) ' H'

H '

K^ j' { %B D > ' ( , N U:[2 : , : H, : & -& ) H

U: & 0-3!PR U[2 ( ! " , ( Q^R !?x H' 2 H P Q' g E H ) %2 , -3!PR -: H :2 P Q' 3 1 - ? -: 0$:

$:&'

(Lazonick, 1993, pp. 37-38)

. : ' 0V j! :)

' -3!PR U[2 , ( , z " i " H C

» K :> , ( :w

(reciprocal consent) «

-

$ &

1.

‚u ) 0 ,, ) ' O'G H '

- $ $/ H ' M-P:[* g:2', 0 N $ &

# %B , ' O

B$ $ !" H' -

' !/, -) ) ' = , & B 2

(Lockwood,

1970, pp. 659-660) .

) $* lN ' -[ " \ E 2 ' , g)',' O'G H '

v

-

„ :> :2 (: , 0-/

- ( R P Q' f [

. ( R &!B ' T' $: $O H$ $/ H ?& y $" 2 0

#$ 1 $&$ N N -BŠ , "

# ?2 0

<V & C ' H ' 2

- H

: ;C* $2 !2 S, @

:2 ;:)!" :2 , H * ' - !O < n& H ' Q 2 ), 2 ( , : (:) )

0- : , - !:O H

( R ! H P Q'

I / , I !" n& -

H P Q' / ' c!O - @i H ,N

- ! .

*' ' ' V & ! " <, -& ?/ z / ' O - d 0S 3!PR '

?&N ' ,

”' '! 1 (E"

:*€B H

(common heritages)

-: :

!:*

) -: &

0# ' 1372 W 0 76

: ' .(

( R - S !3 H P Q' ' N < n& 0 P Q' ( , - VB H

: : ( B

( )

(*' O'G -1 /' H

. N !/, 2 0F " " $2 0 :O'G H P: Q' < :n& :

) < n&

( '$ U & ( , ' 0()' H '

< n& , ' #$?1 2 ' #$

2 ! ' H ' '

(:)' # ' ' :Q !:R S :n& : ' H P: Q' < n& 0f [ „ >

) 0-:) =1 1385 W 0 154

.(

'

' - ( , 0$ ] ' ! - ‘ P , I / 0, :2 ' -3!PR U[2 $&'!"

.1

*$%+, #-. / ! $ .

1 :

Somuels, R. J. (1987) The Business of the Japanese State: Energy Markets in Comparative and Historical perspective, Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

(11)

?/

$ ( '$ -3 R ( .

-: !: : ' !% 2 ‚

$%: !&

: :&!B !:?x ' W :R H'

) ) H!i ' ' & O'G H '

%: o: , #' o: :2 P:E ? " 0H '

c! * ?/

(%: & !* # O #! * o 2 - % 2 .

: g:2', 0 :O'G

& , -3!PR U[2 0( ,

&!B 2 H, : B :) -: .:)!" (?/ # %B H'

()' .

‘/ : ' 2 <V & C 2 - .)!" D E" F Q -1 /' K'$ ' F ." 0!i ' ' ()' # !2 .

& [" ' , , S' ' ' 0 ! '

&!B 2 0-3!PR U[2 #' 2 - , H H'

r H P Q' R ) o D R (?/ c . $& ( d ]!

(Beeson, 1999, p. 62)

(: ', .

-BŠ , A ) " 2 V &

) < n& H N 0- O'G H '

'

» .)!" A% "' O ! ' B

(developmental «

corporatism)

-

$ &

: .)!" A% "' O ! < n& ' -3 R ;C* 0 O'G

1' B

: ' !/,

()' 2 PE 0 !R |!&

. n& ' : :E"' H' :2 : O , $?1 ' -3 R ;C* 0<

, g % -) ) ]Vd o 0H ' ' < n&

( * H$ !" a V2 H

- ()' #$* ' Q 2 H "

(White, 1998, p. 41) .

) < n& W R -BŠ , $ J -> ! ' <!) , ?& <,'$" ;3 d 0 O'G H '

()' # !2 R' Q

2. J J 0< n& '

‰: h F Q ;=Q U[2 -3 R R ) ]!

()' <'!Q 0$* A ) " S $Q F"' % ) .

]Vd = 0',' ,' , _ '

» :*

! :*

«

-&' [) 28

; ,N 1997 ' (: .Q', ' 0‚ ! ! & C N -/ R g2', H' !* !R

- 2 (d' 3 2

$ : :) $ :* 0 !:R ! : # '!

0 :& B 2 0 '$ :) ) {

# !2 ' u %&'! , B$ $ !"

,$" < n& • )' 2 A ' # ' ' 0 ' u %:&'! g:)!" :

-

3 !*

) 0 O'G Su!E" -) 2 1376

W 0 67

.(

- R' O |!w! ' 2 $.2 U[2 < :n& !*

1 . 2345 , )%6 ! 7 8%9 *!( 4 : ; ! < += ( ) $> ! ( ? @6, $ = A B

> ( CD< E ! <

F EG% $,

) $&$ $C H$I ) , J J K "L ( H$I ) : #- 5 :M

. H8%E9 $E A EB E *)E4 ? E E

)N O 2P Q " ! <

)

$J = ( $ = (

%E ' E3R E ( : ! A B ( ST6 ) , K"L *

U .

#-. / ! $ $ %P !

* ( @6, $ = A B .

1 :

V *! MW

) 1379 ( :

N% + OP. Q ?6

B ?

$E7 * : [EN *:E ($ ' +E%

166 - 165 .

2 .

# $ $%+, #-. / ! $

*)4 ] O !

. 1 :

Yamamoto, Shichihei (1992) The spirit of Japanese capitalism and selected essays, New York: Madison Books.

# $ ? :^ ! $

* W - _,T` ( ! .

1 :

Boyer, Robert and Toshio Yamada (eds.) (2000) Japanese Capitalism in Crisis: A regulationist interpretation, New York: Routledge.

1 .

# $ )T= ' %P M )- *2P

# J # += < 7 $D% # #5 ! $ %P !

:4= a,N .

# $ $%+, #-. / ! $ ( L $ $R ( * !

)75 . 5 ' ; ! .

(12)

-) ) - h F: Q , S P: [ : ' 2 O'G H P Q'

%: ) ‰:

S $:Q F:"' -

< :n&

) : & 2 $&, ' H % J 0W R H '

! : .:)!" (:?/ H P: Q' HV:

& 2 Œu!3' 0 ? N ' … ! O - : & J 0 O'G .)!" $&, .)!" & 2 &'!Q , HV

…()' *' #$?1 2 ' 5 . 3 4 3 ! 5 *6.

#$ % 0. 7

() N

.)!" , ]! r H P Q' 2 -2 : & 2 F l' - 3' K$ 0

.:)!" H :

- ]!%E O'G

!*

. : & 2 0- !> 2 .:)!" F: Q '$: 2' :O'G .:)!" H :

& 2 F Q 0$.2 d , H P Q' H P Q' .)!" H

-

!:2 :/!" !: -1 : /'

#

()' . , < : :/!" ' $:& !2 S =1 K'$ ' ) 2 H P Q' .)!" ( ! ,' - 3' ; )

#' , K'$ ' ! O'G < Hu 2 Œ =%& | /' 0H P Q' # ( ' 2 O'G i=[&

H :

H P: Q' .:)!" ( ' ! - O'G i=[& A? 0( ?& , H P Q' .)!" 2 -2 ) /

%: ) !:2 :" 2 H' :2 H P: Q' " 2 S $Q 2 -2 ) <,V , , ' ? F:"'

2 < n& S $Q

; ' .

- ! ' ! ! % ,

$% !&

: -: ' C*N : (:@B '!:"

(. 3 ) P Q' 2 Z!2 Su! , (

' D: r S $:Q -: d , w d O'G . / # '! 0

()' # !2 ' '

)

! 0 1379 W 0 263 .(

- ' H ; u

!:> 2 ' } O'G .)!" $ N ( ! - ' J ; } '!"

' $& !2 S =1 ; '!1 ' A? ) , 0- :

: :O'G H P: Q' .:)!" H!:i ' 0 :C ' c,'

2 ( V 2 Z!2 $1'!Q K^R 2 0 C*N !>

' N ' :2 <V & C , -=%& H S !:3

H$: 2

( d & 0#$*

, : (:) ) .:)!" (: , T!: H :* ' H

D: > ' : !:2 ' :B

& [" ' , - $ " $Q H

-: c 1' O'G o& 2 , H , S ' , 0- ' ' S ' , 0-"

$:*

.

( d ." H

; . ' ! ) , -2 [ &' MI 3 2 S' = 1' , I2 -E / " I !" , H' H

' '

& [" ' , ' H 'V2' / ' H

$& !2 .

!) 0 N <, ;

!: -:i H

()' , 2 ' 2 ()' $ "

» N ' ;=Q 0 O'G H P Q' $*

: & 2 : & : #, :B HV:

:O Hu :2 b :& : & 0$* 2 &' P Q' ' -CJ!

, : :2 < : $ $:* ;: " , '$:&'

Shigeto, Tsuru (1993) Japan s Capitalism, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press;

Fallows, James (1994) Looking at the Sun: The Rise of the new East Asian Economic and Political System, New York: Pantheon.

(13)

([) ()' - O'G N -*!

«

) - &

0# ' 1384 W 0 66

.(

A:? U: & Al : 1 0c :d : ' :2 1

@ k .)!" ( , !/, 0 O'G .)!" -i H : ' .:)!" D: E" - 3' ; 1 ' B

()' # !2 !

2. .)!" ( , o ]!J J S : d, , :2 H' :2 (:3 ()' ' B

" S Q^R' , .)!" '$ >

.)!

@ k ' 0 N !=& , #$* ' ' B f .‹" -i H

-

$&!*

. .)!" ( , ]!J J 0, ' '

: !2 F) -i g E = ' , ' B

()! O |!Q, 2 - O'G .)!"

.

- n& 2 … !2 J ! .)!" D E" H' 2 ( , - 3' 'V2' ' :& [" ' , , : $:)

- -"

& 2 ) #' 2 - ' ' S ' , , O'G o& 2 , H P Q' HV

H : 1950 -

1980

$ *' #$?1 2 $&, ' ' - ? U &

.

» {^" V ?& ' H' :2 :O'G H

D > ' ! H P Q' .)!" (?/ z ( o { %B () )

0- . 3 H

) ?" , K > o '

$ :*' ' Q i K > ' 0I 3 H' 2 < u

(Beeson, 1999, p. .«

.71)

0 ,' , -) )' H & I " <, -& ?/ z / O ' O # ,

» (: =h" )

H P Q' « (*' #$?1 2 ' O'G H P Q' H = ' .

;: ',' : : ' c^E&' ' O

1950 - S ' , 0

"

& 2 ) , - ' ' S ' , #' 2 - H P: Q' HV

)

#' : :2

O'G o& 2 (

' S P" #$ 1 0 H P: Q' .:)!" , S : " 0(. :3 0- : H :

-

#$?1 -1 /' N " W!PR 2 e$& !2 '

# ?2 /

- Z!2 - I2 ' H B

- 0$*

-:"

(*' #$?1 2 ' U & "u 2 .

.2 :/ R !: ' S ' , 0 O'G H P Q' S $Q U 'V ' 2 0 $

& [" ' , I / 2 V &

o: :w 1 , ’ :R :2 H P: Q' g:2', ! € H H :

$* # ,V ' -/ R

) 0-&' ?" !s 1 1372

) f ' (

•3 0 156 - 157

- S ' , 0; ' .(

' -"

7

& 2 V " () ) ' ' O'G 0()' #$* ; C " a V2 H' !* o ,

!:R $ 2 HV

# ?2 ()' # $

) 0c ), 1377 W 0 8 .(

: & 2 : ,' 0<, -& ?/ z / ' $.2 ' , : c :)

H 1954 - 1949 K$: :2

F )N P Q' H d' , H ) 2

† > z / ' #$

$:* ' :/' , HV .

(:?/ :2 : & 2 : '

0 ! : Iw, I ) !=?2 ' !2 #$* ,$" 0; H !2 & ' V B H' 2 O'G . / S , w

1 . $%+, #-. / ! $

*U J:

. 1 :

Tresize, Philip H. and Yukio Suzuki (1976) “Politics, Government and Economic Growth in Japan” in H. Patrick and H. Rosovsky. (eds.), Asia’s New Giant: How the Japanese Economy Works, Washington, D. C.

2 . .( ($ ( $ #-. / ! $

! <

#-

$ )75 . 5 ' ; $ #. ^ * , W b$M $J .

Nordhaug, Kristen (2006) “The Development State: The East Asian Perspective” in Ahmed S.

Huque and Habib Zafarullah. (eds.), Handbook International Development Governance, Boca Raton, London: CRC Press, pp. 205- 218.

(14)

U 2 Œ ) !2 H P Q' & 2 > R 2 "

1950

$* <^1' .

#, :B D ! :" :2 H :

c ) '$ *! 2 0 B 2 M;C 1954

& 2 ( !•% ( '!

' H P Q' HV

i2 #$?1 2 .

) ! )' $ P Q' H

(Federation of Economic Organization) H 0

(:) ) :" $ :)'!R (: , ' Œ O'G (. 3 , -& B 2 „ "' , O'G H P Q' .)!"

:["' ! .)!" H' 2 ' -. / , - H P Q'

$: } . H :?& : :O'G H P: Q' :

& 2 H' !* o " ! & ? O ( , 2 !2 - , l , - ! 1 A n " H' 2 H P Q' HV

() )

& 2 ?" , < !" ,$E 2 Z!2 H S : 1 H ' '! 1 2 & ) H

& [" ' ,

$ ' ( , 2 %2', S %)k ,

. 2

& 2 ) 0 = ' H P: Q' HV:

j,G 1995

& 2 ( !•% , )‡"

(: B #$?1 2 ' ! .)!" H' 2 HV

) 0 : V , O

1355 •3 0 254 - 255

.(

c :) : !" : 2 g)!" 0( , - ) & 2 ,' 1955

,$:"

$*

. - :C"' !R & 2 '! 1 2 ) y O & 2 ' H P: Q'

(Five Year Plan for Economic

Self- Support 1956-1960)

$* 2 $ ) , ; c L *' , H P Q' c^ )' K$ 2 , 5

/ 3

%

c :) ' : & 2 ' H' /' H' /' !2 ' Q e$ N ' /' d 2 1956

:" , |, :*

1960

$ '$ O ' ' .

& 2 ' H' /' c,' c ) , ->

c :) :" $: B < u , ‡:" N K'$ ' 0 1958

& 2 B ,$" H$ $/

. c :) ' !2 ' Q ) y O & 2 , K$

1958 :"

1962

&u ) H P Q' $* 2 -B$& H '$& )' , ; c L *' h '$d 2 -2 ) 0$ N ' /' 2 5 / 6

!2 $3 . ) , V & & 2 ' K'$ '

$* D E 0< "' ' " , c .

$: 2 & 2 0 &

c ) R',' H$ $/ S$

1960

† > '$C ' 2 g)!"

:2' 2 , 0 N K$: : $* HV

-> - $ N 10

!2 c ) . -: $: N 2' 2 , & 2 '! 1 2 & 2 '

->

c ) H 1961

"

1970 $* b & 0 2

/ 7

$3 U O ' H : ' 2 ? " ' J !2 # - 2

- $* b &

$:2 () !R K'$ ' 2 (%&'!"

. : ' H P: Q' $:* 0;: 1 : ' 8

/ 10

( "' V & $3 .

: $:* < : -B$:& : V , < !" U 'V ' ‰1 2 I ) $* '

'! 1 (E" 0 & 2 ' -&',' S' &' 0 N &

» -& 2 Q

$:* H :O -1 : /' #

«

$* † r . c ) & 2 J B' 1965

: & 2 : ' ' 0$* fQ! !" ) ! % ' 2 g)!"

c ) 68 - 1967 :? " ?/ a V2 P Q' , 2 O'G , $ ) & 2 23

' :O c :)

$* ; $=" z / O

) -: &

0# ' 1384 W 0 669

.(

' :/' -:> :O'G ( , 2 : 0 : & 2 : ' H

& 2 V N ) $ J & 2 o 2 ' ' 2 H ' N (%&'!" 0;=Q H

(Bronfenbrenner, 1965,

p. 523)

J -BŠ , ŽV/ 0$* # *' ) < n& H

!2 - O'G H ' .

'V: 0 c,$/

U O H P Q' $*

- 2

& 2 ) ' -> ' -.Q', $* , #$*

- &

$ .

(15)

4+

1 - -: ; = & 4O 1956

! 1970 Shirakawa, 2012) (

& 2 c )

' /' H U O

$* b & g)! - 2 -.Q', $* b & g)!

c,' & 2 1960

- 1956 5

/ 3 10

%

<, & 2 1962

- 1958 5

/ 6 10

%

<!) & 2 1970

- 1961 2

/ 7 8

/ 10

%

G ( , J B

c ) " O' 1992

H P Q' .)!" & 2 # 0 -

' /' , ,$" ' -1 /'

& 2 ' ' -: () '$ ' < " 2 0 !R |, * c,' c ) ) , 0

$:

. :2

H P Q' .)!" A * & 2 0c h '! 1 -

-1 /' c )

H 1970

"

1975 .:)!" K$ 2

, '! H P Q'

$* ' /' , ,$" -B$& H' 2 F) M O'G 2 -2 ) .

c :) & 2 '

1973 -> ' H$ $/ & 2 ( , , ( () !R K'$ ' 2 c )

H 1973 :"

1977

,N ' /' d 2 .

(:)' † :> ;:2 Q A:? c'k:) , 0 :/ ' .

: ' c,'

<V & :C 0 :

& 2 ()' &!iJ O'G HV ' <, , …

.)!" $ N .)!" & 2 !& Q , & 2 0

…(*' - & J O'G

& 2 ,$"

' ^: K$ o ;P ) o , (%[& '$ 2' 0 O'G H P Q' H

H P Q' HŠ"' )' #$ CJ F Q -

- ? O S$ ! -1 /'

:) , $

& 2 P Q' HV N ,$" @ x, 0H

' #$?1 2 ' .

$. S % / H 'VB 2 2 0 ) '

H ‹1' !‹d 2 , :& [" ' , :i B$: & 0 :) :2 g=" H

Œ 3!P:[ 0 :

& [" ' , - H

-3!PR U[2 B$ & _ , - ' ' , -"

# i &' $ " )' ,1

' 0

& 2 - ,$" '

$ . - 2 A $ " 0 ,$" ' O & 2 '

!*

. H ‹:1' H ‹ '

' S, w 0 & 2 ' - ?& F !P" H' 2 2 .

# :O , 2 S !3 0 d ' ' H'

- S !3 >!2 † > -" d^3' 0 & 2 @ 2 S' &' B

. o: F: Q 0 & 2 '

- 2 E u

) B$ & 2 '$ 2' (

- A $ "

: F !P:" :2 $: 2 , !:*

$) 2 . ! %: :2 :n& !: :E u V: & : -: # ' | :/ ' :>!2 H :

e !:*

! %

#, B !‹d 2 Œ ! 1 - -: % / ; C " I@& H} H

$:

. : ' :2 #$:1 Q

u f [ B$ & ' ) N ()' - 0$ % ( , E

' ;:=Q : d , $ &'!"

2 j' ' )

2 F !P" d (

F !P" ' $.2 d , )

S' : &' : &'

1 .

! c $,Rd

< =$M

* += ! A B $ : ( :D% , $ )4 Q " ! .

1 :

Rothacher, A. (1993) The Japanese Power Elite, New York: St Martin’s Press.

(16)

& ) E u 2 Z!2 (

$& '€i2 T‡" N 2

(Bieda, 1970, p. 62)

-:) ) R ) ; 2 .

-& O < n& ' )' , O'G 2 A d

† :> , ‘ '!: Œ ! 1 0g % ]Vd |!& ' n&$: H :

-: V: & F !P" 2 0 2 g % < /u , g % ]Vd

$ :) . , : ' '

- & F !P" ' E u 0 D Q H . 2 O - n& c 1v' N 2 C 2 $

$ .

& 2 H' /' ( ?& , ,$" , -d' > $ J ' H ' ' < n& 0 O'G .)!" H

! ) - ?& , & [" ' , ?J : & 2 :) 0- ' ' 0-"

:O'G o:& 2 , H P: Q' HV:

(

U 2 : & 2 :@ :2 H '€:B T‡" :2 #,^1 0V & ! ' O ' ' ' A?) "

H :

- 0#$* ,$"

P: Q' 2 -3 R &'!Q F !P" D > ' $&'!"

H : T‡:" :O'G ! : H

# i*, !& Q $ & 0$* 2 *' j,G a V2 H

1956 )

:*, # R ' ( d K$ 2

( 0

Hu!:/ -*, # R S " ; $." H' 2 #Š , 2'$" !& Q 1959

)

: ,$:E K$: :2

- 2 Q H U , -*, # R H ' 2

( H " H $d', H' 2 O !& Q 0 o:J!

Hu!/ g)! , 1963

) :& R H :)!& K$ 2 H $:d', < :l ' 0HG!: ! C" !:=?2 0 :

N - 2 Q ( 2 Q 2u 2 (?/ oJ!

U 2 S' 3 ,

"

( c :) !& :Q 0 1965

:2 Z!:2

O'G S "

) 0 V , O 1355 W 0 38 W , 44

'! ,(

&N : -: ' /' : () ' ' H :2 0 :?

& [" ' , 2 -& B 2 , I 3

()' #$* — !@" - ' .

N F / N &'!:Q : ' '$." 0

N (M2V & / ()' J -: O'G H P Q' $* #$ $ '

$:&' :

» H ! : 0 :O'G

- H P Q' $* H$ F/! ' , $d ' , # %2 S' 2 ()'

!:*

.«

) 0(2V &

1385 W 0 61

.(

& 2 ) : &' :2 (=%:& F:" !:> :2 :O'G H P Q' HV

K$

H P Q' ^ H -

M-1 /' 5 ) 10 -: <'$Q' )

$:

.

# B$: † :>

: ' H :

# B$ -1!& 2 ) # :i / , ! : - . 3 -"N R ) ! ( , S$ $ 2 H

'$ Q -& ?/ P Q' O'G -

#$ :[2 ! : ' H P Q' 3 1 2 -3 R ( @* 0 !*

()' . ' ' A? - ?& ; E" 0 O'G H ' ' < n& 0, : & 2 <V & :C P: 1 :"

HV:

S =T , U[2 ( @* P 1 , ! ' H P Q'

]!%:E ! : H P: Q' 3 1 2 '

-

!*

. ) #' 2 g % -2Vd < n&

H :

M-: : , -3!P:R U:[2 c :.

& 2 c O 0V & ! .)!" = O - ; C" ' O'G ! HV

$ .

: & 2 H' /' , -d' > 0 O'G .)!" -& , ,' ;d' 0 i H!) ' H :

5 , 10

$ *' ! ' .)!" $&, - ? U & 0 ! .)!" ) .

: & 2 '

" H : 0 .:)!

Y 1 O'G . / $ 2 ' H$&, IQ', 5

10 - •[ 0$ s2 #$ N c ) , $:&

-: ." ' ! S$ C 1 , (*!& ) 0H =." 2

$:&

. : ' (: ' ;: :2

& 2

# %:B f: > : !2 ! .)!" $&, , I :3 ' $: ; :* : , & ' H'

(17)

i 2

# H " H -

:& [" ' , ' $: 0H B H C $ ) B$ & 0H$ !"

0-: , H :

) ! % , % B$ & 0( ?& , ]'Vd' ' = , c!•% H N H

$ *' c . ( ! '

. () ) (?/ H' 2 A? ' ˜R H

2 ! P Q' 2 -

& 2 D=>

-: •[ : D > , ' 0#$* ,$" H

$&$:*

:

; . ' ! :) : -: ' /' H :

-:: S ' , #$::?1 ::2 Œu!:: . ! :: &u ::) ::/ !2 , !::2 -::"

.

!:: :: ', , ::

; . ' ! ) - - ' /' H

$% !&

: 0-Q * H )N H !

» H ' ' H ! ( '$

«

( '$ H' 2 ' u %&'! ), 2 I2

( * -: 2 @ H

, . 0 ! : : '

A $ ‡"

U :2 :/!" , *' !/, -Q! d - c!3' 2 H "

c : c : 1v' :2 H :"

: :

(% ' ! ‡ $ $d^3

)

*$E4 ( 1379 ] * 86

.(

2 n& | /' < n& 0- ?& ; E" , 0 = ' 2

.)!" H' 2 < u H 'V2' , K'$ ' )

; . ' ! ) , ! , !

< :n& -: ' /' H :

]!%:E $:&, : ' ;: C 0 : O -Q!: d &'!:Q , *' #$?1 2 ' - 3' U & 0H ' ' -

!*

. / !2 < n& ! - V & HV

: :2 0 ! : / !2 ,$" @ x, (@B '!"

()' - ' ' S ' , / !2 .

' , S' ? O 0 '

& ["

: . :2 , -) 2 ' f [ H

N 0 ! .)!" & 2 ' ' Q - An / !2 F Q '

(Bieda, 1970, p. 85) $ .

6 -

#$ % ! #. . 9 3 ! 5 : 9

O'G .)!" -& , ,' ;d' 0$* # *' !>

) R',' ' 40

:"

:

70 (

& 2 0 K$ 2 , P Q' ( !E 2 .)!" H

•R :* D: E" (:?/ H '€:B H :

$* ' /' , ,$" H P Q' Hu 2 .

& 2 0$&, ' ’,' 10

-> - $ N 2' 2 , )

c ) H 1961

"

1970

!2 . c!>

c )

& 2 0<, -& ?/ z / ' O H - :) HV

, O'G ()' # !2 L .)!" & 2 &'!Q H' /' S$

. : & 2 ' -:R 2

# , 0 : H' 10

i -R 2 , )

)

& 2 F l' (

& 2 0

$:& !2 :) y :O - .

: ' : -: ' /' $:&,

& 2 .)!" & 2 0 '! ' H %2 ()' ( .Q', ' i& &

c ) ' /' ,' H

'$ ' 2

- () !R K

( . ' c ) K$ H, d .)!" & 2 0 H B

•[ : H :

) < n& o r2 $& !2 H P Q' , ' :2 H : , & H C F Q , W R H '

-: ' :/' d 2 , ,$" 0$ N H ' ' < n& H = 2 ( ,

$:&$ N . : & 2 : ' :

E J 0 O'G P Q' H!Q ‚

' , #$* D E (1 ) 2 0 ?&N •[ K'$ ' $&!2 H'

† > S , w 0, '

& 2 HV -: H :i : & 2 H' :/' , † :> F/! 0$ $/ H

$:*

(Bieda, 1970, p. 68)

.

(18)

& 2 U:[2 - $: H!:i ' :2 0 .)!" & 2 &'!Q H' /' , -d' > , H P Q' HV

B T " V & O'G -3!PR

!2 *'€

. c ) - E"

1952 H, 2 200 a V:2 ( *

' F l' $* •[ !2 #$* < &' - O'G ( *

: & 2 $Q 0

$:& !2 . c :) 1961

) .)!" & 2 !) lN c ) (

' U 2 87

% ' ' ( * : & 2 !:R H' 2 0a V2 H

H'

, # -d' > S$ $ 2 84

% N ' 0

& 2

& 2 • )' 2 ' !R H -:

g:)!" : H'

& 2 ) $& !2 # A n " 0 !2 # ,$" H P Q' HV

(Watanabe, 1965, pp. 70-78)

.

& 2 0 ' 2 2 ( '$ ? " & 0 ! .)!" H' 2 ( , H

:C 2 !:2 ! ' P Q' #$

& 2 $" H' 2 -3!PR U[2 MH!i ' - R' H

( * - ]!%E V & a V2 H

$:*

.

& 2 ' 0$ J I 2 /!" 2

( *

† > - O'G a V2 H -: HV

: ' 0$&$:*

, I :3 S ' , $: & :O'G -: , - :3' H : ?& : H %@" , - I 0- ?& ; E"

2 -& B 2 0$ *' - I ' ' - '

: & 2 ' ( -: •[ : ' :

: . : '

& 2 C=* D > ' - R' I 3 !/! H ?& H

, %:= | /' o %2 ,1

- () !R -@ , - K'$ ' 2 (1 ) 2 0$E (

.

H!Q O'G H P Q' < n& J - "$ &'!" ! ' -3!PR U[2 , "

‘r) 0$*

( R H - U V & P Q' 2 - , H 'V2' T‡" , ( , (

. : ' ' - / " ' '

- !2! *! , - ! '$ O

$ % !&

: : ' ' : ()' ( .Q', ' $ k !/! $ '!*

& 2 0 O -: :/'! (%C* 2 O'G HV

(Moriaki and Yoshinobu, 1997,p. 23) !:*

.

& 2 H ' O'G #$* c!E 80

- '$ O '$&' A J F Q 0$.2 2

$ .

& 2 .)!" H

3 1 $ 2 ! ' H % Œ "$ 1 0 O'G R‡

-&' E2 Z & 2 <•!" $ s2 S, @ H

r 0- R' -1 /' , H P Q' 3 1 !/!

:2 , H'

-: :*, -: '

, $: &

." 0IQ', (?/ #$

()' - ( d H' 2 - 3' H

) 0-&' ?" !s 1 1372

) ] ( W 0 114 .(

*€B , ->

) ; ',' - ' E2 ' O W!PR 2 1990

(

< :n& (: ! " 2 0

.)!" ( , f .‹" , ' 2 -BŠ , 0' B

& 2 H : & 2 , # : : L" V & O'G .)!" H

O o S !3 2 .)!"

U (:)' #$:* c!:E :O'G :. / i=[& M| /' ! M- 2 .

» : '

& 2 U O 0 - j' ' - , U[2 , -3!PR U[2 H -i&!iJ ' H Tk - 2 $:

; %& O , H P Q' A? ; '!1 2 0 ^ , R ‘r) , , { %B H' 2 U[2 , H

( .

! ' ’ R , ;R' !R H -

$& ' O .

& 2 ' - i& H, d 0( 0

1 .

$

#;3M 2^ $%+, ' e8I 6= ! ! 7 ! <

* #- . 1 :

Krauss, E. (1989) “Politics and the Policymaking Process” in T. Ishida and E. Krauss. (eds.), Democracy in Japan, Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, pp. 39 – 64.

(19)

{!R ()' -3!PR , - ! 1 U[2 , H 2 & 2

(Bieda, 1970, p. 61)« .

: '

? " 0 d ( *

<V & :C :2 /!" 2 -3!PR U[2 w d oJ! , a V2 H H :

2 Su!E" , - R' ' 2 ' H' /' , ,$" 2 0- '

S$: : , S$: # "! M- K'$

- !R

$& ' O .

<V & C ( ! "

0-: .:)!" : ' (: , H 'VB : f .‹" , ' 2 H

-) ) < n& 2 -BŠ , -

()' # !2 R' , -> O'G H P Q' .

K'$: ' ' -C $ *

& 2 ' ,$" H' 2 ( , 1' U 'V ' 0 &!B '$&' A J H

( * :2 (=%& - O'G H

2 P Q' R' - ' E2 , 2 2 ' J 0$* 2 #$ N T‡:" , : 1' ! ( ' 0; '

C 1 2 N ( *

U 2 0-3!PR H (:)' #$* C*N U O '

. : & 2 : ' !& : 0 :

V i&' 2 1' ( *

- ]!%E -&! c!E" c d H & - O'G H

&!*

$ .

7 -

<

:

=>

-

3 ! 5 + ? 00@ # A* B 5

H P Q' < n& ]!J J O'G .)!"

$:* D: E -3 R H ' ' , -) ) 0 .

:

# V/ ' N ' 0#$* $E H

- :1 ' H P: Q' ( O ' - u 2 ‘r) 2 -2 ) /

!2 " 2 H' 2 A?

' V B 0 !R

» 2 ‡%

1«

- . / -i %= ™@d ,

.:)!" 0$ :*'$ O

$:& -: " !R H' , , ' & , - I 2 Z!2 H ' ' H P Q' .

0 : : '

† >

.)!" ( , 'V2' '! 1 2 .)!" & 2 !& Q H' /' , HV Œ 3!P:R 0 :O'G H' :B

" -& , ,' ;d' #$:?1 :2 :O'G -i : .)!" -) )' , A? U & 0 ! ' .)!

(*' . ->

c ) R',' H 1940

"

1970 .)!" & 2 !& Q 0

< :n& :r2 H'

$ N H ' ' < n& ' ;C u ) -1 /' )

-: S ' , (: !E 2 0-: ' ' S ' , 0-:"

& 2 ) 2 , H P Q' HV

O'G o&

( - :3' ]'V:d' ' := , c :ˆ. -3!P:R U[2 0

) S' ! c' = ]Vd Œ 3!PR (

; . ' ! :) D: > ' , ,$:"

H ' ' < :n& -: ' /' H :

- ( ! "

! : .:)!" -:) )' U & 0H P Q' $* M-ˆ K'$ ' 2 ',' /!" 2 0$*

(*' O'G

. -> Œ 3!PR 0 d ' H

1950

"

g)',' 1960 , O H ' ' < n&

()'!R 2 E P !n 2 " !=& != 0 O'G U:[2 H

0 ' B : $: & (:) , H :

& 2 ]!J ?J H P Q' K'$ ' (E P: H'$: ' .)!" H

, H ' :@&' -:) ) H :

1 .

< += #- ! $ V8 ^ #.d6 ,D< $%+, #-. / ! $ < +E= E $ : U: _& :L

M #-5 $ $ ",C $ _ d K %= # *) 4= U:,f, ! , .

g (:. *(

) 1384 ( 4 5 &

: R = & : $6A @ K B ? %A i :E3e D` #D5$ *

$E7 *U :

$+E

[N * $%O 161

- 192 .