Iranian Journal of Public Policy
2022, Vol. 8 , No. 3 , 115-127
Https://doi.org/10.22059/jppolicy.2022.89546
Copyright © 2022 The Authors. Published by Faculty of Law & Political Science, University of Tehran.
This Work Is licensed under a CreativeCommons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0) R E V E I E W A R T I C L E
Meta-Analysis of Research &Global Experiences of Urban Planning in the Face of the Corona Pandemic
Mohammad Hossein Boochani1, Samaneh Mahdinezhad2*
1- Assistant Professor of Urban Planning Department, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
2- PhD in Urban Planning, Department of Urban Planning, Faculty of Engineering, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
Corresponding Author’s Email: [email protected]
Received: 31 May 2022 Accepted: 17 August 2022
A B S T R A C T
Due to the occurrence of Covid-١٩epidemic &thecreation of conditions contrary to the normal routine of life,examining the effects of the presence of this virus worldwide &methods of managing this crisis can pave the way for studies &planning in these conditions. Due to the dispersion in the approaches andissues raised in this field &the lack of integration in the structure andorder in the results of these studies;The present article is based on a meta-analysis strategy. ٤٥ articles,according to theopinions of experts,were the basis of the present study.The results ofthe research indicate the need to create resilience in different parts of theworld due to the increase in disasters &epidemics.Information &spatial technology is an effective step towards controlling &managing this crisis by collecting spatial data &providing information using spatial counters andinformation software.Also,most of thearticles donot offer practical suggestions
&solutions;Therefore,basic research is needed to obtain sufficient knowledge andapplied research to achieve the desired solutions.
Keywords:Meta-Analysis, Experiences,Urban Planning, Crisis Management, Resilience, Corona Pandemic.
ﺼ2 ﻪ.ﺎﻨ0 ﯽ4ﻮ67 یراﺬ ﺘ ﺎﯿ
هرود ۸ هرﺎﻤ<
،۳ ﺰ?ﺎﭘ
،۱۴۰۱ تﺎﺤGH
.۱۲۷ - ۱۱۵
Https://doi.org/10.22059/jppolicy.2022.89546
8
! - 0 - K= L % - 0 !K= $ KC $M
-
/ C
# g ،1
$ E# / #
2
*
1 - .$
. A A _ $ 6P ! "# $ Ah 9 / 1 A 6 2 !1 \
2 -
$ Ah 9 / 1 A 6 2 )$ 7"# $
"#
. A A _ $ 6P !
&A! ], ! * :? @A,
:4 . $ J.
10
$ $ - 1401
:O . 3 J.
26
$ $ 1401
< 0O
H I F 2 &#<
- 19 0 OF M L & ZD V1 & C < B , > & 5 _ &9 P
U 0 &% + &
& ) &#
X , &' < 2 &K "# . _ &9 ;
@g ]' F S , # B D &
Y =K B "3 D i NJ 4 Y#K C
"#$% &( &G & G
P B # &@ # CY =K i . 9 Q Y ;( F 0 OF $ . € 1
&#<
X ,QA . 9
f F ' ( 1
: ' 0 .7#K B - X ,QA
S& '
HQA ;(
&V‚ S < C
0 &% + & >& 2 4 &] &F " I ' O 7#K : X! & 7# C # \ . 9
X # % & ƒ
2 X # % ( 2 +4 9 > TD +OF # .+ B # $ ' # +OF &
$ ! "
.
; W]
:
. & . # %&T f 1 , - % f% ?) !
ﺶ و ﻞ ﺤ ا رﺎﺠ و
ﻪ ﯽﺎﮫ ب ﯽ ﺪﺎﭘ ﺎﺑ ﻪ اﻮ" # ی %& ی'ر
و() ﺪﻤ+, ﯽﺎﭼﻮ. ﻦ012 رﺎﮑﻤ4 و
& . S& &
- 19
# 1;
% ' @ "# % Om & & % + 1 ; .
' ' .1;
> ; Q ; 2019
)O )C 1 &' % ) q ), %' . , 4 cT )C % +. 4 & . q ),
# %' % )c ' ! ) * & $4 & # s b) 2 & )/ W % $&& , 1! O b) 2 T , )# 4 .1, '
%' P ; $ ]R bc%
11 S%
2020
& . q ), 1, 4 ; 19
)O $ % ) A %
) ' PR A) # Pakzad &Olia, 2020
& . S& & .(
19 %' # ) &
j % > t %' % $ = ,
$ $ % ) % rJ $ ,
% ) =1; ' T % rJ F \Q & )O
S% ; $
& . @ - M T M
>& ) 1; , g * $% +. %' "# Q & F M t $ F% <@ . T 1
( ) Jabareen, 2013
O’Brien et al, 2004; Vale et al, 2014; Sharifi, 2020 ; Litman, 2020;
.(
>&
1 $ T q ), $ > ; & $ #.
) Taken from the book: Covid-19 pandemic, spatial information &community resilience (
# q ), > ;
# q ), > ;
A ; 1320
) ) 1343
&
1347
&
1358
&
1389
1) |$
E 1369
&
1370 t
1249
- 1349
&
1269
&
1281
&
1295
&
1301
&
1384 ) |; - M T
1918 1296
S ) 1321
- 1323 T
. @ - M
1388
CCHF 1349
&
1378 - 1383 & .
19 1398
- .
$ %&' aW & %' $ 1; @ ! = )O
Q . , - % %' ? . % t % , $
‚ t $ b< i 4 C & ; ); i 4 C ' @ - %
. ) Fong, 2016 UN-HABITAT, 2020;
.(
f $ , ) % # & %&T
Eskandarian &et al.,. 2019 1; 4 ) T 4& . (
4% & J t , $
) , . (Shamsuddin, 2020; Brennan, 2020; Khayyambashi, 2010 1)\ M b. )@ F \ / S ;
)# & % 5 FR \ $ , %' %' , F 5 ' Q . )w
) Zhou et al, 2020 (
/) O' T &
) Reyes et al,
(2013
$ B , . + ? 4
, F 5 & <$ > . & ) +)# :$ . %' ?5+ ' & )O
, F W & , P ! & 1)\ 4 )C
% ) ] <O ' @ . 1; BQ $
# , Œ%
$ ' , ) Matthews, 2018 .(
$' > t %' ) B &% '% %' \ / ,"O $
% ) I . \ %' !% & 1 R; % & J t - %
& O & R F /@ - $
$ h);T "#
, P % ' -.
f $ , 4 ; k $ F \ / .1;
Q c +) & %&T & $
5; ' & F t * ! O F% G )O ! & % # < $
1;
(Perringes, 2006) f% ;% & \ / .
) 4 %' i '%
& ' BQ $ ƒ q W& < 4 Q; & ' % . F Rt
l! f% 1@ , & $'% W % ) @ %' % > . & 1 %' % "O )do $% 5$ % k $ ))\ %'
b) 2 &
%' ' % . & •) G ' 5 &% f * & 4 ; . , dƒ & T% .
D 7
). h c ' 5 &% ?) ! q 4 &% :)# l) & + $ :$&m# p . h). 4 ' ; . ,
), $ :$&m# F 2*+ & ! $ >& u % 4 5 . C .'4 ' # $ ! u % )G
b
:*
l) % T p 4 ' ; ?) ! F \ / $ a & $
?) ! .1; C% |5 & a 5, p
% T [ @ ]&% A ) & , ,&% C & . )$ % ' ]&% ? , ) w $ & ,
. 1<) $
ﻪ ﺎﻨﺼ7 8 ﯽ ﻮ9: یراﺬ<ﺘ8ﺎﯿ
هرود ۸ هرﺎﻤC،
۳
، ﺰFGﺎﭘ ۱۴۰۱ .
تﺎﺤMN ۱۲۷ - ۱۱۵
C ' F Qd % -)C T +$&m# m & k $ ?) 1 ) 5 1<) k $ ?) ! .
,
) Azadi Ahmedabadi, 2013 :$&m# p h). a ; , ? , ?) ! G P O ; .(
< & , f * $
?) ! p ),4% 1 %' & 5 $ T ,
) P O %' .(Ibid F i FM f * 1<*
! O F% G h / 1)\ & q 0 ' BQ l) 1) ). $ (@ , S ; & O Q@
& ' \ .1;
(@ , >& %' FM - $ % $ 2
' O •%' BQ E & q 0 ' % ' $ f * } , .1;
.' T BQ $ # %' - % 345
$ > ; t %' , + 1399
&
1401 f *
0 J :$&m# \ / Q =S& & F )do ' \ ; , ! % + F Rt = ' O J &' ' %' .' )O% W
> c
> c %' ?) ' ) $ .'&% :)# 22* F \ / 1! O F% G O ) & O
101 & 5,-# I ! G $% 5$ %
180 %' . ' O k"J & ; , 4 ; , 4 J BQ )c &
> c d O 24
1 ; 4 & ' Q Q \ a % ' .
$ , + ;% )c %' & , , "O % . = '
1 45 1! O % W 0 J :$&m# F \ / Q F% C !)
1 FRr\ ' a $ h). \ P O %' .(
4 J %' '% $% &
$ %&' %' , - % 1 %' & ' O ; , •/; %' )O
;%
u % FRr\ &% &% 1 $% 5$ % FRr\ ?) &
(W & $˜@ FM ;% ) w $ .' ,
‚ / , P F \ / & F ) .'' O ,&% +$&m# T $ :$&m# )< '' O
F% C ! 1 c ?J .
>
' ; O )
Source: Authors
(.
>&
2 . FM - $ % $ (@ , & ' \ )
Source: Authors
(
) 64 9
`# % U a ! l) ]&% l) q l) ' 5 &%
' ' %&T
$
U
&#<
]&% ' (*+
' \ ' (*+ )O
$
)
`# % $3 l) %' ;% '% ' \ A)5
#( &5F < 2 &K
•/; %' , %&T a F Rt O . #
$ ; ,
) & c
d c
< l t 4 , ; , ' ;
=n) (345
k"J & ; , Q \ a W ! FM
23=n)
(
5,-# I ! G $% 5$ % M k"J & ; , 101=n)
(
4 ; , 4 J 4 •% @ FM k"J & ; , 180=n)
(
' ; 45=n) (
) & c 4 ?G J ' ; 68 =n)
(
ﺶو ﻞ ﺤ ا رﺎﺠ و
ﻪ ﯽﺎﮫ ب ﯽ ﺪﺎﭘ ﺎﺑ ﻪ اﻮ" # ی %& ی'ر
و() ﺪﻤ+, ﯽﺎﭼﻮ. ﻦ012 رﺎﮑﻤ4 و
`# % g g
: ; , f * ) f C% C l) )+)# i Q > ƒ; )0 !
&J &'
# G ' 5 &%
do & $ & , T ) , - %
1 + i
& % - ! \ & (*+ p 1Qd b) 2 1 %' ' % . $
4 ;
V % W T 4 `# & 1; ' ' [ 2 @ ' @ % F \ / ' \ +) );T % W :$&m# )! s O . # i 4
F \ / . & #&%
>& ) , !T % W } 3
.(
>&
3 . •/; %' F \ / O . # )
Source: Authors
(
\ / '% '&
& !
& ! G%'
);T % W 17
37,8
%
); )W & ) ;
9 20
%
#&% % W 11
24,4
%
!T % W 2
4,4
%
5 T % W
T , 5 T) ( ) M & 5
5 11,1
%
:$&m# p + % $
)0 ! FM 4 ? W :* %' . $'
> ƒ; & $ •0 & % t l) $
' (*+
B ! & , (*+ i Q & )+)# W ! FM 4 ) 4 :) ) w $ .1;
17,8 4 G%'
u % FM @ ' # ' % . & (*+ $' +)#
>& %' . 4
GR@
.1; ' O 1Qd :* $% T 4
>&
4 . FM f C% C ;%
)
Source: Authors
(
`# % g g
'% ' '%
& !
& ! G%'
& !
& ! G%'
# &(
8
17,8
37 82,2
> ‚ 17
37,8
28 62,2
#7#K 17
37,8
28 62,2
&J G 19 42,2
26 57,8
O 7#K 8
17,8
37 82,2
' ; l) ]&%
:$&m# %' k $ S ; ,
\; & ' % . $
>& ) , 5
l) ]&% ) w $ .(
& ! G%' ' ' q S ; 53,3
*) T T 4 `# & ). l \ G%' } Q % %' +$&m# •)$ & ,
>& )1; ! F% G › . I ! G F% G 0 J :$&m#
6 .(
>&
5 . , ' ; l) ]&% & ! )
Source: Authors
(
* L & `# % U
&(
&( 3
' ) 4
8,9
' % . 41
91,1
>&
6 . l) ]&% & ! ' ' q S ;
)
Source: Authors
(
H L & `# % U
&(
&( 3
ﻪ ﺎﻨﺼ7 8 ﯽ ﻮ9: یراﺬ<ﺘ8ﺎﯿ
هرود ۸ هرﺎﻤC،
۳
، ﺰFGﺎﭘ ۱۴۰۱ .
تﺎﺤMN ۱۲۷ - ۱۱۵
} 2 0
0
-#2 24
53,3
.# 1 21
46,7
;% '% % T \ %' 48,9
@ ' # '% \ / FM 4 G%' % ' + )# ), T 4 `# &
' ' %&T' O %' & ! +) \ / '% FM %' $
>& ) , 7
.(
>&
7 . $ ' ' %&T' O S ; :$&m# & ! )
Source: Authors
(
' ' %&T' O
& !
& ! G%'
7 #K 21 46,7
@ G 2
4,4
) 22 48,9
* . ]&% , ;% FM %' h c ' ; &
& ), & k $ i 4 F Rt %&T a % -
>& )1; ! O % W ' ; '% $ ]&% ; 1Q< +) & ! % T ]&% T 4 `# & , 8
.(
>&
8 . $ ' ' %&T' O )
Source: Authors
(
7 #K U
&(
&( 3
# 1
2,3
7 &K 3
7
. 2 - 30 69,8
1 11
25,6
GD T 1
2,3
' \ FM +) %' ' T 1; F Rt ]&% & $
' (*+ F% G )O
>& )1;
9 .(
>&
9 . F )G 2@
FM )O )
Source: Authors
(
&#<
&(
&( 3
)
6.7 16
35,6
6.7 29 64,4
U
&#<
6.7 12 26,7
6.7 33 73,3
0 f ? , % T \ %' ;% '% $%
, $ , , 1 % # \; & 5J ' 2 W %&T
% # ? & ? J .% + , 5; & % # \;
;% )c $ . ' ' + , P $ ;% & ,
) 4 %' , ;% (@ , +) %&T f } , ;% FM %' $ # %' - %
, >& ) 10 .(
ﺶو ﻞ ﺤ ا رﺎﺠ و
ﻪ ﯽﺎﮫ ب ﯽ ﺪﺎﭘ ﺎﺑ ﻪ اﻮ" # ی %& ی'ر
و() ﺪﻤ+, ﯽﺎﭼﻮ. ﻦ012 رﺎﮑﻤ4 و
>&
10 .
& . # %' ;% '% $%
) FM %'
Source: Authors
(
2
& !
& ! G%'
&O9 T I
2 4,4
1 13
28,9
0 &% + &
2
4,4
& 'D 2
4,4
2 7 &O9
2 4,4
K ) 3
6,7
&O9 + &
1
2,2
+ B _#% &O9 X 4
2 4,4
@ ' &#j 3
6,7
9 &O9
3 6,7
K " " D
2 4,4
& . # %' ' ; '% $% - & $ 19
>& %' 0 J % T \ ;% lQt 11
' O 1Qd
. 1;
51,1
$ %' 5 %& ! & F Rt 1) $ & ]4% FM 4 G%' )O
).o $ ' .
>&
11 . FM p )
Source: Authors
(
- ; &
&(
&( 3
' ( X ,QA
23
51,1
L 5
11,1
B 0 #4 7
4 8,9
GOK (
2
4,4
7 & G 0 .7#K
3 6,7
@ ' B
&#j 1
2,2
F 9
&#j 1
2,2
+ & & F ; ;( S&
2 &
19 1
2,2
0 .7#K HQA ;( S& '
2 &#<
19 12
26,7
Z( @ 9
- B
#
&#<
6 13,3
K " " D 5
11,1
F% G F \ / lQt ) w $ (@ , $ ƒ ) ! O
1@ ; < B) ? < $ % ) /) $
2*+ ?
y% # ' ! $
;% & ? & ? J $ , ?5, ) 4 1 , $ $
5;
' & $ J & ;% )c $
$ F < % -O $ & '% ' ' & % ' \ } Q % $ )O
ƒ 4 P . b) 2 b) < )c b) < % t $
dƒ a ()2* & 4 ; ,
>& ) 12 1 R •%' .(
) 1 R & } Q % ' & \ (+) -
dƒ ƒ ) } Q % ' & P \ ( b) 2
%' a ()2* & 4 ;
$ )O . ,
ﻪ ﺎﻨﺼ7 8 ﯽ ﻮ9: یراﺬ<ﺘ8ﺎﯿ
هرود ۸ هرﺎﻤC،
۳
، ﺰFGﺎﭘ ۱۴۰۱ .
تﺎﺤMN ۱۲۷ - ۱۱۵
>&
12 . b) 2 dƒ $ ƒ } Q % ;%
$ %' a ()2* & 4 ; ) )O
Source: Authors (
- ‚
&#<
#% 64 9
+
- #
+
+4 0 _#% " ,
+
, F " ,
+
T.7 " , (
&
+
„ K
&O9 +
# B + &
+
&O9 "'9 &##5
+
&
&O9 ; +
P F " " D
+
, F +
Q 1 XQ#T% X $F
+
@ '
&#j +
F
&#j +
. } $ 1) ;% %' % 5 $ & ~ 4 Q
&
19 ; 1) S • & @ ' #
% f /0 4 , @ & ' 2 W F % <@
5 ' ! \ 1; ! O % W z '% +) . 0
) Rajabifard &et al., 2021: 264
& . S& & % rJ )do .(
19 & 1; S P' O 4 & , ' \ $
O O' >& %' . , ' + IR . T 4 ?G J $ 13
\ / '% FM %' '% $ : C $ ' 5 &% &
: C %' , u % $% 5$ % &
.1; ' O 1Qd $
>&
13 . : C FM %' , u % $% 5$ % & ;% '% $ )
Source: Authors
(
$ : C '%
;%
: C %' ' ; '% % 5$ %
&.19 k$ &%# \;SDG) $
(
& . )O $ 0 J > J %' 19
: C % 4 5 .1; ' % # \; k $ ) ;' )< %' $
: C ' ' & P )< %' % "O )do & b $ '
22* ) . . 1; J %' & , • G & aW $
? 4 ; 5 F Rt 1 (UN-GGIM)
; C y%' ]R > J %' %' 5 F Rt 4 '
)O $ j; # %' 5 $ ' ' b <); . )do & $ : . & 4 Q) +# 1
& . 19 . ,
&.19 1 &)4
5; ? 4 ; % # \; k $ 4 +*
f > , $ $ , & $ ).o % # & %&T
; % ) $ %' .
;% $' $% ;
$4 ; & 1@ ; 4 ; &% %' S ) %' % $% 5$ % ;% )c
& . 4 `# )J & 4 ;4 19
;% 1
\; 4 ; #&% %' ? 4 ; ' 2 W )<) . % 5 $ ) ; . 1; ' u % ;% )c $
(UNECE) % ' + ) ); % !
(FIG) ) 4 1 %' % . f-J &
. ,
$ (@, ) }Q% q), & /)&.19
& . q ), & /) $ (@ , ) } Q % ' & Q ' \ F \ / 19
& 1; ! O F% G &GIS
; %'RS ;
& . \ / 19
$ $ & . & %' . 1<) J %' . , ! O % .
% ) [ 2@ %' ; , )O h c % ' )O & $
. & 5,-# h ' . ! O ' % % ) )! s $ 0% & ' -. % ) >
]&% % . %' 0 J > J %
)i 5 $ %& ! ' ' Q $ & (%&' % 4 : ;)RS
1 ( )! s F Rt ;)GIS
# O F% i & :
' )O & $ % ) g * $ . ! O % W ' ; '% %
ﺶو ﻞ ﺤ ا رﺎﺠ و
ﻪ ﯽﺎﮫ ب ﯽ ﺪﺎﭘ ﺎﺑ ﻪ اﻮ" # ی %& ی'ر
و() ﺪﻤ+, ﯽﺎﭼﻮ. ﻦ012 رﺎﮑﻤ4 و
%) ) }Q% & <$)W$%#
@ ' # ) W $ % # & < $ % ) ) } Q % ) 4 %' \ / +$&m# 4 ' \ .
4 ?G J p
:$&m#
% ) ) t Q % ' & O $
# & < $ ) W $ %
> \! 1 < ) 4 ' %' $ B , & ,
dƒ lt 4 @ %' S& & ,
& 2 l t 4 $ )O $ 4& q ), %' dƒ /) ? ) ;' & , .1; "# 5 % $
$ ? })O< B)1@;
Qt 2 1)$ & ' 1 R; 1@ ; < B) ? ) } Q % 4 . J . \ / l
!
& . )O $ ' 19
=
(@ , &% ' )# 1) W & )\ b. , $ 1@ ; 4 r! ; ;' ) & $
} )O $ ?
1@ ; < B) . ,
$ y%# :$ < %',&. )O19
' )# $ )< & 4 $ r! $ , $ J $ T 5 '- & , $ y% # ! O F% G F \ / lQt
% $ 1G ! &
' &% 1 R; ' Q 1 %' & ]4%& & < 1) \! : -! 1 % Q;
! & %&T 4 $ y% # 5 '- %' . ; '
% '% @ &% & < 1 R; M •/;
& . %&' %' v< 1) $ . , 19
O 4 % $ 1 '& .
.1+O $ r! q 5 + h & ' O ,&% =' > P'
&. )do19 , -%
& . %&' %' .'4 ' | $ , %' , ?u < & . S& & q ), , \; & - % 19
B) 1) $
, f% .' "# ? % %&' $ 1 '& $ r! ' & & ' O ,&% O 4 † $ C $
+ ). & % # ; † . J t & $ 4 ; . ' '
- . ' &
b - @ & T ' `# 4 1) !
. a < 1 %&' %' FM
$'.%. ;% ';;, \
$ ?J % & \! 4 ?G J FM % \ & , - %
.% . S ;
+ , \ ' ; ; $'
$' b) 2 F% W $ , O 1 \ \ & % ' , )O
, T dƒ & f / - %
& , \; !T4 4 ) & 1; 4 ) '%
r! - % ) $ %' & ,
> ) ' ; %
%& ! & 4 ; $
.1, ' $ @ -; :
4 `# %&' %' $, T&.19
b) 2 )/ W 4 `# & %&T f $ , } > G )/ W %&' %' %' ' 4 $ , 4 ; R@ u %
P ! 1 %' @ ' # )
?J % ' % , 2 &
& $' % A)! & , - % FR5+ u ' $
, h) & % i 4 %&' v< $ , ?5, ))s & ? 5 . 1;' % # & %&T f 1 ; $ %&' %' . C .
fR %&' & ` < % 4 j % 4
r! 1; ' & , 1 R; . \ G 4 `#
. $
) $ , %' < O 4 O 1i! &R $ , 1; ) 1 %' . ' , J t , $% )\ S ; ,
<$ )O $ % ) %' & , 4
! ' 2 W $ . ' O ? Q %&T f & ' +
$
& . )O 19
$ O' T ' ) w $ & & S ) %' y%' ; % %' $ )O
1; , 1.% + 5 1@ ; 4 ) o h T %' \ )
Rajabifard &et al., 2021: 540 l 1 .(
+ k $
$ % - % . %' 5 $ ' ' 4 ?G J P # A ) %' & 1; 4 ) 5 F Rt & \W & 4
' T & P' P ;% $ OT } $ ?J % & $ ' ' ?) & - 5 % $ T 4 ;
1 .
& . )O $ 19
y , b F Rt % "O
%' ,R %' < 4 r! } zJ Q 22* B;
! O F% G S ) )! s F Rt b <); A & 1;
(GIS) 1; ' ' % C% |5 & ; )# b
$ OT F ) 2 .
'' O T [ 2@ %' &
) Rajabifard &et al., 2021: 64 l 1 .(
A ;% '% FM k $ 4%& +. & "s 4 ; WB
1, 4 ; FAO @ G% WHO
1, ' 2 W % 5 $ & \; 4 ; GHO
OECD 1<# ' ) %' % 4 ; UPU
. ) ); % ! IMO ? & ? J :* .%
r! & % ' + P ' &ITF SSSI
$ ; &
$ ' ' $ 1@ ; 4 NSDI
) 4 1 $ ;
5 $ ' ' # LAS - UN
' ' # GGIM
GHS_POP ' ' aQ
Worldpop 1 5; ‚ 0& # M
$ O HRSL 1)\W ; f
F Rt ; GPS
)! s &4 T GIS
OSM FIG UNECE )! s F Rt C% |5 f C% C
& % T f C% C &IGIF
5 GSGF a a
>& %' \ / '% FM S ; . , .x F Rt %&T 14
% - & $
' +)#
.1; ' O u % % 5$ %
ﻪ ﺎﻨﺼ7 8 ﯽ ﻮ9: یراﺬ<ﺘ8ﺎﯿ
هرود ۸ هرﺎﻤC،
۳
، ﺰFGﺎﭘ ۱۴۰۱ .
تﺎﺤMN ۱۲۷ - ۱۱۵ >&
14 . ) FM ' +)# $% 5$ %
Source: Authors
(
% 5$ %
% 5$ % • +
5 F Rt 4 ' ;
' ' %&T a 1 4 ) '% % - '%&T b$ ! l t 4 5 F Rt q W& > J %' 4 + ) )J $
4 ; )Q, 1 Ž ' } ; , & S '% j; # $ )s 4 ; > 4 ' ; p
& /@ # $ 5
A . 4 ) $ 4 :) . $ 5 ;%
. <$ T
: . & 4 Q) +#
& . 19 4 ' ;
5 F Rt
4 ; 5 F Rt 1 22* ) . ?
(UNGGIM) + $ b) 2 x * k $
& y
$' $% & ; ); $ f C% C %' 5 F Rt ' % . [ 2@ %' $ 1! )$% % ; h;
& . 5 : . & 4 Q) +# 1 19
u % % .
' $% - & $% -! P 1 % /0 '%
& . 19
& . )O $ %&' %' -
19
<*
+O 4 ; 2 & %&T a S ) 4 5 $ ' ' % )
*+)# l t 4 &
4 ' \ $ O % W S ;' %' - )5# $ + ' &WHO
..1; !
S '%
, O $% -! P \;
$
! 1 ; % %' 5 -)! S '% %' A . 1 , $
& . R Q ' -
19
5 F Rt 1\ G ; 4 ) & dƒ $ 1.% + 4 T q ), 4 )O . ,
Q *+)#
+
*+)#
-) + Q $ ' S ; '% $% -! P
& . )O 1< 4 ?G J $ ' 19
, @ ; .1;
+ 4 ' ; $' 4 $ % ) q ), y%' 1 $
1850 ' ' ; '%
4& 5 .1;
%&' 4 ;T & \ ; ?W (*, A 1; ' $
G ? i :* %' q ), )J A 4
+ = , )! s % ' )O & $ S& & 1 )J % - $
k& \ $ *+)# 4 5 . ,
& . *+)# = ) 4 %' 19
- )5# $ - + ' E @ & %' . ,
2020 .' '
& . )do ?) P # 19
#
*+)
& . )O $ %' + Q $ -
19 S ) %' . , ! O % . 1 g * ‚ /; %' &
*+)#
' ' > & ?) %&T a $ 4 ), $
$ OT & & 5J 1 ) %' & $ ;%
ƒ )O $ ? %' O' T : -!
)O $ )do ?) . C . , aW & d & ' 2 W 1 R;
-. \ . ,
4 & r! ?)
?) r! $ - 4
% ) 1 1 $' 5 &% 4 . , )O $ $
<);)GIS F Rt b
P # A ( )! s r! ?) 1
- ; 4 '% 5 $ ' ' 4 $ ' ' 4 C% |5 '
% W ' ; r! $ , @ & $ ; , %' & ' )O
- 4 ) % )<
. ,
4 )@ + E& #
4 )@ + E& # (OSM)
)! s F Rt aQ O%- 4& . ' ' E& # & Q t& '
%' )! s 4
> ; 4 , 2004 , 4 cT $ + ' p . %' ' ' .1;
% )< & S ;' ? W 4 R . # %' ' $
' ' 4 a);&
. <$ )! s $
IGIF F Rt C% |5 f C% C)
( 5 9 IGIF
' Q$ % )<
5 \; ' $% & Q P' & %& ! & 5J )do 1 4 ; C% |
' %' . , $% +. $ %' 5 F Rt } a ) ;' & 1 & +* P 5 ;
$ %&
)O
& . % $% +. 0 J > J -
19 T : . & &
.'4 ;
) 4 1 ;
A "s & 4%& +. 4 ; &(WD)
(FAO) ' @ .% + l t 4 : p & CP
; ; LAS
& ( ) 4 1 ;)
%' R ? %' %&T f ' Q %' ( 5 $ ' ' 1@ ; 4)NSDI & •/;
4 ' # )O $ & R %' %&T f 1 5 F Rt ) ;' % = . C . $
?u < & , NSDI
+* d -) %' % : & 5J } &LAS
. NSDI
%' ' Q # %& ! 1) W
$ )O
& . O q W&
- 19 %' T F )do &
g * $ Q F% i 1 %' A) % $ %& ! ; ;
$
$ !% FM 2 ? J &R $' Q # . ! O% W ' ; '% T q ), :$ . & ; , A . & )O F -) &
) ;' & %&T a F% i O & !& 5) ) %&' , -) l t 4 5,-#
Rt . % ' -) % F
5%
ﺶو ﻞ ﺤ ا رﺎﺠ و
ﻪ ﯽﺎﮫ ب ﯽ ﺪﺎﭘ ﺎﺑ ﻪ اﻮ" # ی %& ی'ر
و() ﺪﻤ+, ﯽﺎﭼﻮ. ﻦ012 رﺎﮑﻤ4 و
$ & R : -!
f ' 4 ) ) g * } %' $ )O %&T
$ . ,
& . )O 19
] <O
' b. $% +. ( * B ! v< & ' ' + . 4 F %' % S& & 1 ; •/; %' T%
' Q B; T%'
% 1; 4 ) . , # -) )O $ : . & %' W $% +. & 1;
J
$ ? . ' Q 1 q ), ? ;% & \ / lQt . ; % # ' )O % W ' ; '% )O
% )
$ $
%' )O S ) %' * % $ %&' > t 5 = , %' +) 5 -)! B &% . 1! %'
b$ ! % % ) +) q ), & ] <O ]&% 4 = % ) > a/W 1 %' * % $ %&' > t %' .'%&T
) 0 J > J < ;% . 1; , ' ; )/ W Q; % 5$ % )/ W ]&% 4 ' ; & . %
$ % ) q ), % . \W %' .' $ * )O $ ' & ?) ' , ' FRr\ a!% 1 %' +) 1) $ 5 ] $ , Q 5 )/ W & S '% l t 4 )O
& , 1)\W . C . 4
$ % ) q ), . , T q ), & R Q : . & 1 G r! A )O
1\ G . ,
% ) f / : . & & y%' %' 5 ?) $ ]&% & $ %& ! $ ' ' -. 5 F Rt } & . S& & )O $
% :
4 % )< . + ' % . $
)do F% i A . k $ %
+ . , $' & \ dƒ : . & ; % %' , & ) F @ T } Q % & T 1 % ) q ), % '
r! a 4 4 -
; % %' -) % ) 4 : •) G FR@
%' , $ $% -! P & %& ! &
' $ @ dƒ 5 -)! S '%
& . % { . -
19 T O 4 & P' 1 R; f * & F )do % . %' $
& , 1 QX F )do 4 %' 5 ? & P W :* %' B ! , - %
h; ) ' ! $ & 4 ;
, ' -) 4 J $ :$&m#
' 5 &% f * & 1 %' ))s 4 ) y%' G ! )O $ q W& .1;
\ k $ l 1 %' F 5 & a 4 1;%' ' ; & T h;
FM ' \ & ! . ,
@ ' #
& . # %&' %' $ , %&T f v< , -
19 + '% $ 4& 4 %' ƒ . $'
% W b$ & ' )O f z Q T % . &% & q W& ) 4
' \ ;% ! . 1G ! %&T
w $ & 4 %' "# )do & % "O )do & a ) o 4 ) $ , ' %&T f . C .' ' $ * % T > . )
h; $ 1@ ; 4 ' :)# 4 ?QW . ,
ƒ @ ' # .' , ) & ' O )
f
; , ! & > s Q 1 % . %' %&T ,&% y%' '% \ / ]&% 4 ' ; .' , ' |
i '% < %' l i '% $' Q$ % % "O )do -) & < & 1)\W 4 ()*+ 5 & ' ,
b$ ! % l! & l!
' ]&% 4 ;% '% FM 4 ) '& J . . % )< F ) &
v< . @ ' # $ )s ) / % q y%' ; , P & , $ )s •) G 1@ , P ?) '
J %' .'% ' :$&m# q 0 4 •) G y%' ' Q 4 + < & & ? < )s ; , <Q $ :$&m# . 1;
;% ?) ' \)Qt B , %' $ )s / %
) w $ . 1;' i '% ) 4 %' ' % . & h; F Rt
:$&m# 4 . ' \ @ ' # % 5$ % & ' +)# u % $
&
& (*+ )0 ! & > ; ' & P ?) '
:$&m# 4 ' \ . , :$&m# %' •0 & ! $ •) G y%' P z q 0 . ' Q (*+ i Q % ' $
! & F Rt 4 ht * :$&m# $
:$&m# 4 ) 4 :) .' , a!% T $ :$&m# %' P & '' O $
* . ]&% 4 ' ; -
% 4 J $ :$&m# 1) $ . 1; , , ' ; :$&m# Q
+ T $ $ ! •0 & & W' G u % & :$&m# A P •) G )< 1 % . $'
) P i +, . l) ]&% .'' O T $ :$&m# %' •) G )O % ' . 1; :$&m# k $ ) ;' 1
P O 2*+ $ ), k $ S ; l) q & 1; l) q ))\ l) ]&% & %' P O ) & . ,
' ' %&T' O ' ' 1)$ & $
))\ $ l) 4 % )< ' \ ;% '% % T \ %' .' ,
' % . $ & ,
' & , ' ) ! O F% G F ) 4 . ' \ ' ; . 1; +$&m# ' % . l) . 1; J %
]&% $% !% ;% > . & ' Q % i ' ) F ) p 4 $ & $% @ ; F ) ? ;& $% - $
P < a ' ; '%
; [ @ ) 4 A %' ' % . : ' \; T k $ & ' , ' \ % 5,T kR @ & 1
ﻪ ﺎﻨﺼ7 8 ﯽ ﻮ9: یراﺬ<ﺘ8ﺎﯿ
هرود ۸ هرﺎﻤC،
۳
، ﺰFGﺎﭘ ۱۴۰۱ .
تﺎﺤMN ۱۲۷ - ۱۱۵
%' & , . ' ) F ) Q ' % . F ) . 1; T 4 . J ' % . & ' ) FM
# € ), 1)$ g+. ' ) l) . 1<) J
% v : 4T 1@ ; & ) W > G $ )s ) B &% & $ $
i &
$ A . ,% : ' $4 \; & '4 ' # ) B &% ))Q :$&m# q ; ; k $ &
' ) l) ' & & 1; [ @ ) 4 A %' ' : ' '&-! & $ i 4T $ # u % Q
\ P 0 J > J %' .' )O % W f / $% 5$ %
& . S& & ' -
19 , @ , , O 4 & , T )do &
S <J ? . J & ! . 1@ , > 2J 1 ' ) F ) 4 ) , & . )do ) 4 %' .1<) a ; ) ;' ]R 4 + ' % . F ) ' & ' ! t 4 .' ,
% 5$ %
1 ? W $
%' l! & l! f% h<. 1 %' dƒ O . 1; , T )do & S& & , @ , ' \ ; % % $ & ,&% % T $ :$&m# )< & ,
. References:
1- Ahmadi, Fereshte; Zamani, Mohammadreza. (2020). The role of resilience of cities in the era of Corona Virus &post-Corona Virus (case study: Shiraz). The first national conference on the production of health knowledge in the face of Corona Virus &governance in the post- corona Virus world, Najaf Abad [in Persian].
2- Azadi Ahmedabadi, Qasim (2013). A meta-analytic approach: capacities &gaps. Journal of Social Sciences, No. 71, pages 88-82 [in Persian].
3- Eskandarian; Gholamreza. (2020). Evaluation of the consequences of the corona virus on lifestyle (with an emphasis on the cultural consumption pattern). Social impact assessment, No. 2, special issue of the consequences of the outbreak of the Corona virus, pp. 65-85 [in Persian].
4- Fallah, Massoud, Massoud, Mohammad &Navai, Asadollah (2014). The role of designing flexible &resilient urban spaces in crisis management, the 5th International Conference on Comprehensive Management of Natural Disasters (INDM-2014), 1975-1984 [in Persian].
5- Ganji, Abbas &Heydari, Zahra. (2018). Investigation of the strengths &weaknesses of crisis management in Iranian cities. Safety Culture, Year 12, Number 26, Pages 101-111 [in Persian].
6- Gasparini, Paolo, Gaetano Manfredi, &Domenico Asprone. (2016). Resilience &sustainability in relation to natural disasters-A challenge for future cities. Translated by: Hossein Hataminejad &Morteza Nosrati Hashti. Tehran: Arad Kitab Press [in Persian].
7- Pakzad; Behnoosh &Olia, Mohammad Bagher (2020). Corona virus pandemic, restart button of the planet. Journal of Shahid Sadougi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Volume 28, Number 1, Pages 2234-2229 [in Persian].
8- Pourahmad, Ahmad; Ziari, Karamatollah et al. (2019). Analysis of the resilience criteria in worn urban texture against earthquakes with an emphasis on physical resilience (Study case: District 10 of Tehran Municipality). Research &urban planning, 19(36), pp. 1-21 [in Persian].
9- Qazi Tabatabaie, Mahmoud &Vedadhir, Abu Ali (2010). Meta-analysis in social &behavioral research, Tehran: Sociologists Publications [in Persian].
10- Rajabifard, Abbas, Daniel Paez, &Greg Foliente. (2021). COVID-19 pandemic, geospatial information, &community resilience: global applications &lessons. Translated by: Hadi Pendar, Soroush Masumzadeh &et. al, Tehran City Planning &Studies Center, volumes 1 &2. First edition [in Persian].
11- Seddiq Sarvestani, Rahmat (2000). Meta-analysis of studies conducted in Iran. Social Science Letters, No. 15, pp. 67-103 [in Persian].
12- The most important measures of the big cities of the world &the metropolises of Iran in dealing with the corona virus. Planning Studies Center of Tehran [in Persian].
13- Afrin, Sadia; Jahan Chowdhury, Farhat; Rahman, Md. Mostafizur. (2021). COVID-19Pandemic: Rethinking Strategies for Resilient Urban Design, Perceptions, &Planning. Frontiers in Sustainable Cities | www.frontiersin.org.
14- Agudelo-Vero, Claudia M. (2012). Harvesting urban resources towards more resilient cities. In Resources, Conservation &Recycling. 15- Arefi, M.(2011),Design for Resilient Cities, reflections from a studio,In:Banerjee,Tidib &Loukaitou- Sideris, Companion to Urban Design, Routledge,Abingdon.
16- Banai, R Meagher, K., El Achi. (2020). Pandemic &the planning of resilient cities ®ions, Cities,106(3): 102-110. Doi: 10.1016/j.
cities.2020.102929 .
17- Doyle, I, H, (2003) "Synthesis through Metaethnography: paradoxes, Enhaneements, &Possibilities", Qualitive Research, 3,321-345. 18- El-Gazzar, A. (2019, August 07). The path to city resilience international conference. Retrieved from MSA university:
https://msa.edu.eg/msauniversity/the-path-to-city-resilience-international-conference-about.
19- Folke, C.(2006). "Resilience: The emergence of a perspective for social ecological systems analyses", Global Environmental Change 16, 3, Pp. 253-267.
20- Fong, M. W., Gao, H., Wong, J. Y., Xiao, J., Shiu, E. Y. C., &Ryu, S. 2020. Nonpharmaceutical measures for pandemic influenza in nonhealthcare settings-social distancing measures. Emerging Infectious Diseases, 26(5): 976–984.
21- Godschalk, D. R. (2003). Urban hazard mitigation: creating resilient cities. Natural hazards review, 4(3), 136-143.
22- Hassankhani, Mahnoosh; Alidadi, Mehdi; Sharifi, Ayyoob; Azhdari, Abolghasem.(2021). Smart City &Crisis Management: Lessons for the COVID-19Pandemic. International Journal of Environmental Research &Public Health. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2021, 18, 7736 .
ﺶو ﻞ ﺤ ا رﺎﺠ و
ﻪ ﯽﺎﮫ ب ﯽ ﺪﺎﭘ ﺎﺑ ﻪ اﻮ" # ی %& ی'ر
و() ﺪﻤ+, ﯽﺎﭼﻮ. ﻦ012 رﺎﮑﻤ4 و
23- Jabareen, Y. 2013. Planning the resilient city: Concepts &strategies for coping with climate change &environmental risk. Cities, 31: 220–
229.
24- Litman, T. (2020, May 4). Lessons from pandemics: Disaster resilience planning. Retrieved from Planetizen: urban resilience towards pandemics/Lessons from Pandemics_Disaster Resilience Planning - Blogs _ Planetizen.html.
25- Matthews, K. (2018, June 10). How city planning can affect how diseases spread. Retrieved from Planetizen:
https://newseu.cgtn.com/news/2020-07-08/COVID-19-and-the-city-How-past-
26- Mayunga, J.S. 2007. Understanding &Applying the Concept of Community Disaster Resilience: A capital based approach. A draft working paper prepared for the summer academy for social vulnerability &resilience building, 22-28July 2007, Munich.
27- Moore-Cherry, N., & Tomaney, J. (2019). Spatial planning, metropolitan governance &territorial politics in Europe: Dublin as a case of metro phobia?. European Urban &Regional Studies, 26(4), 365-381.
28- O’Brien, K.; Sygna L., &Haugen, J. E. 2004. Vulnerable or Resilient? A Multi-Scale Assessment of Climate Impacts &Vulnerability in Norway. Climatic change, 64(1-2): 193-225.
29- Perrings, C. (2006) Resilience &sustainable development. Environment &Development Economics, Vol 11, No 4, pp 417-427.
30- Rajabifard, Abbas; Foliente, G &Paez, D. (2021). COVID-19Pandemic, Geospatial Information, &Community Resilience: Global Applications &Lessons. First edition published 2021by CRC Press 6000Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300, Boca Raton, FL 33487- 2742&by CRC Press 2Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon, OX144RN.
31- Reyes R, Ahn R, Thurber K, Burke TF. Urbanization &infectious diseases: general principles, historical perspectives, &contemporary challenges. In: Challenges in Infectious Diseases. Springer; 2013. p. 123–46.
32- Servi, M. (2004). Assessment of Vulnerability to Earthquake Hazards Using Spatial Multi Criteria Analysis: Odunpazari, Eskisehir Case Study, The Graduate School of Natural &Applied Sciences of Middle East Technical University.
33- Shamsuddin, S. 2020. Resilience resistance: The challenges &implications of urban resilience implementation. Cities, 103: 1-8. 34- Sharifi, A., & Khavarian-Garmsir, A. R. (2020). The COVID-19pandemic: Impacts on cities &major lessons for urban planning, design,
&management. Science of the Total Environment, 749, 1-14 .
35- Sharifi, A., 2020. Urban resilience assessment: mapping knowledge structure &trends. Sustainability, 12(15): 5918.
36- Sharifi, A., &Khavarian-Garmsir, A. R. 2020. The COVID-19pandemic: Impacts on cities &major lessons for urban planning, design,
&management. Science of the Total Environment, 749: 1-14 .
37- Turner, M. D. (2013). "Political ecology I An alliance with resilience?" Progress in Human Geography: 0309132513502770.
38- UN-HABITAT. UN HABITAT; 2021. Cities &pandemics: Towards a more just, green &healthy future.https://unhabitat.org/un-habitat- report-on-cities-and-pandemics-towards-a-more-just-green-and-healthy-future , May. Retrieved from .
39- UN-HABITAT Urbanization &development: Emerging futures. World cities report. 2016. https://wcr.unhabitat.org/ Retrieved from. 40- UN-HABITAT. (2020, Jun 15). COVID-19demonstrates urgent need for cities to prepare for pandemics. Retrieved from Reliefweb:
https://reliefweb.int/report/world/opinion-covid-19-demonstrates-urgent-need-cities-prepare-pandemics.
41- Vale, L. J., Shamsuddin, S., Goh, K. 2014. Tsunami + 10: Housing Banda Aceh after Disaster. Places, December 2014.
https://doi.org/10.22269/141215.
42- Zhou C, Su F, Pei T, Zhang A, Du Y, Luo B, et al. COVID-19: challenges to GIS with big data. Geogr Sustain. 2020;1(1):77-87 .
