47 "#
2 % &'( ) 1396 . /01 391 - 369
!
" # $%
11 ' 2001
1
&
3 4( 56 (
7 8 "9
5 :
;
< # = 4( #
( 7 8 "9 5>
3
5 : ?
;
) :
25 / 4 / 94 : –
5 / 4 / 95 (
@
&'A /& 8 BC ( ) D E 7
3 7 3 F 1 G0 % H 7 (
7
"9
5( 5IJ . K L A) M
6 C 5 M
;) N 3
E F 1
;C 9 O'
9 3 7 5 ) 24 (
# ( M # R6 3 .
S C < ' 8T ' H (
7
"9
> H 5 5 3
5) 3 ( 4( .U /) %V IV W' 7
8 "9 . 56 = V H E
M
5) 3
&' ( 5Y Z &A 9 S
E M F[ H \ ( F[ (
7
"9 ] &
%V ( H ^
= ] _
;C S(
3 &
3 ( 7 ( 8 % H ` 7 3
# a M
( 9 G % F 1
( 7
"9 H 3 6a H &"
M
\5(
. 3 9 7
( # = 3
' K E M
# M
> ( H ^ 3
5) 3 ' W H S( 8^K
") ( 5 b C 3
. 0) . _ E
M
# ` = M
I H ?>
3 ( 5^ &c WE H %
[ 0[
9 S E
M 3
= # 8 % H 7= 7 .
3
&
E M % `E a>
E
# 5 "
M 5) ( H ^ 3
S( W' H 9 / 11
= S(
"
= 0 R>
3 _( e5
_9 V M 8^K % ( . 0&
.
= % 6f M
5) 3
# W' M I 3 S[K 5^ &c WE H E
M
# M .
.١
: 05138829584
Ranjkesh@hotmail.com
Email:
370
47
"#
2 % &'( ) 1396
$
% %& '( )*+, -. /
(0 &12 (3 %4 5( (6 / 7 8 9 : 7 ;3<'5 =5(7
;37 >75'
? 5 @4+<5 5 (33
. A , B C D E ( F G H I
- '( D34J ' K & ? 5
%L 5 M5(J DI47 : ( =N
)O5P2 F = H Q
7 K EH Q
'(
' %4 5( = .
D 6R DI 5
% K5 % EH %& '( = . E 5
' S (
7 T36 5(
.
< ,
% D 9U
S& @4 K / 2 - '(
L A , /5 B 11 / 9 5 /5 @0V D7 0 )*+, ;
D7 7 W
%
2(
3 C - : 5 D7 3 5 =5 C 9 5' ' 2 L X.'YL (A5 < V )*+, ;
% IZ 3
D&
25
(Boulden & Weiss, 2004:5)
.
&I B / 7 5 (6 U 7 D 25 KF 9.'YL ; B
[ \ 5'
5 C 9 5' / 7 DA , ; 5 D7
Q /
% 4+, /5 Z7 ' @0V B
11 / 9 5 D7 25 D&W5 (L ( 5 ; .
, .5 C
% KF /5 5 A , D B ]
^U B _^J
% ' D7 0 3 5 =5 C 9 5
' % EH - '(
L /5 5 ; A , D DA , ; 5 /5 @0V D7 0 D Z$ V
(
`5( ' 3 ' 7 ( (
H ) J a
= 5 L D 5]`
= ( 25
)5 3
% : 1391 : 43
.(
5 C 9 5' Db R c 5 , D7
11 / 9 %7 / 5 %40V )5 & = . 3Z 7 C
L : 3 (X +J 5
= 3 / B - '( D34J G H
. X % EH
% C . . (W5'5 /5 5 - '( D7 0 3 5 =5 C 9 5' D< U ; 5 B
1980 K
D7 ' Y 7 d 3 (7 K5 ' 5 Z7 ' @0V 4+, /
B 11 / 9 2 (7
%
% . 5
;
U e' /5 9.'YL B
7 3 4
% ' N+.
% 5(7
= /5 Z7 ' @0V @4 K / 2 & %2 (7
A , B 11 / 9 (E7
%
`3 ( - . US 3 7 ) U 3 4
% US /5 D&2 KF 3
J +&H5 [ 4J ) U
% 5 D7 D
4S 3 @ DA , 8 5(
f 5 X 8
% : /5 (L 5 S Q DZV5' KF 5 W 5(
U X R 5 D
% . C : R(.
3 / Q
% : 2 5N75 (
= 5(7
=
@IX @,
?&
3 .(
= (&
C D7 0 3
Q 7 3 4
% 25 . K +. K R K X ($ W ) _3< F D $
% : / 2 D7 0 -. K / $ =(&+ = .(3?& D g F /5 (33? K I -. ' K /
% : 5 =( 5 L ' (&+ = .(3?& e' ; 5 (7
%
`3 (
(Lijphart, 1971:689)
. 5/5
; '
4h5 92(L
% 5 5 C (I4+J D 25 KF &C ;
= 5 3 L 7 / 0 Q
'(
-
L i^U ' 3
X / L 11 / 9 0^ e' (\ /5 3U
% DR /5 '
`Y
% .
% 5 W(7 25
6 5 j Q
D 25 KF K ` '
`Y
% .
% +. K R
% + 3 : 3_
3 : ]L :e(
' 5N75 [5N<5 'F
=
/5 / 7 .
= L K5 ' 11
/ 9 @0V K5 ' D7 0 25
.
K / 2 . S D7 k 2 25 3
L >
3 5(
% D& 75' W 5
[ E_ ' Z KF 7 l 0 5 '
% 7 .
K / 2 @4 D7 K5 J / 2
%
< D 3
d 3
; 5 m_, ' 3
n4h ' 73
; 44+<5
% 25 5 5 :
5(
^[)
# ` = M
> ( /& 8 % H 3
5) 3 W' ...
371
D7 h
% :/ 7 (
= 5 3&
% 5 : 5(7 7 7 ; 5 KF S o S< 7 3
L >
3 5(
% 2 (7 KF 7
%
( .
`(`
% (\
= 4+J '
% [ \ 73
;
@4+<5 7 3 /5 9 R (.
3 N K X . Q 6 . +.
% (0.5
=
3 K ) '(a .
= 5
@4 K / 2 ( ' [ \ ; 25
. ' Q 9. 7 (2 G H /5 L
J +&H5 ) 0A ' Z
% / , .
= DU^
5
= 5N 5 ' K5 9 3
.'(
= (`
:N ( /5 N S
Q
L3 6 3 (
= 5 3 : 2(
3 ' KF '(+4V - E
(0.5 .
= 5 3&
%
? 33 ( . ) h K `(`
C K &W 2 [ \
73
;
@4+<5 0$ : 3Z
% 9U D 25 ) V
. 3
? N 33 (
% 7 . 5 Za' ; 3
D X .
%
? /5 33 / 7 9U ( b+. ' K5(6
3
`(` ;
% 5(
&
73
; 44+<5
% @7 V
7 .5 W . X .
5(7
= 0 33 5 C (I4+J ;
= 5 3 '( 7 / 0 -
D7 ) h 0^
3U
% D7 DJ +g 5
= 5 /
` . (2 G H L ' (2 G H ' ' 3
5 / - . ' Q 7 (2 G H 3
(&X `
< p 3
&
% - , 25 5 '
% 7 / 0 ' ) XV 9. @4 K / 2 L
.
% K R
'(
5 /5 - 0 @7 V (\ ; 33
; 25 . q 25(7
< p ` 3
&
% : ) V .
= r N7
% 5
5 5 Q S (7 5 W 3
>
73
; 44+<5
% +J5 .
5 V5 K F
% . E s R R 5
= 7 3
; 44+<5
%
L3 6 3 (
=
% : / 5
%
& D7 D 3 g B ' [/O (AP
2 3 : &
) 5 V5 (7 @2 & D0 gI
% C . D0 gI 5(`
% 4W5 ' B
\
% 6 . +. K5 U s / 7 iV5'
% 3 . E K
=
73
; 44+<5
% 5 5 ' Q . X
= 25 + V .
5 ['5 . ; 3 ' 5 Q
(2 G H L 3
N
% K5 6
< p 3 - . E D7
= 7 3
; 44+<5
% H . 5(7
= 5 2 t 3
4
% (0 &12
2002 ( F : I 7 Q 5(
.
= Y 5(&25 9 ( F 8
) '(a (7 I D7
`3 (
= C 3 Q
D0 gI (`
5
% d 3 25 C .
R 3 u ;
% : 5 C
= 5 3 ' Y Q 2 /5 5 W
% .
) /5
% : 22:1383
. (
.5 C T
% ' 5(
.
= 7 3
; 44+<5
% K X
% .
? D 33 7 )5(
3
=
< Z 3 .
=
5 C
= 5 3 ' Q 25 D& (` [ g 5 (2 G H L .
5 : E ; D7
D ` 5
= (2 :i D7
h5 4
% (
; iH(
+ 3 -
`3 (
= 7 3
; 44+<5
% 0 25 C @ .
a 3 5 (I4+J n ' ;
Q 5 C
(\ (tI
= 7 3 (&X
= -XR D7
% W . I
% 5 /5 ; (\
D : . ' 5 (I 3 / 2
= EH &I
%
25 .
<'5 8< b 3
; (\
D /5 (L
= e* D 7 (
5 C ' @4 K / 2 (
= 5 3 5
R EH [ \ &I s R
% 0 33 ; . 5 : &I ; '
. (I
= 0t (
= D7 0
5 C
= 5 3 U 7 D
. 3 .
=
< p 3
&
%
< p ' 3
&
% 5 . 5 (7 &I ; 6R 1I
%
(X7 C (2 d
3 5 . D7 ) 0J :(6
(\
D 5/5 (L
%
< +.
N&
: 5 3 5 '
% 5
J a
% @7 V (
=
% v 5 Z
% (`5 DU^
5
= K EH /5 5
% Ew 7 5 [5 V5 DI
372
47
"#
2 % &'( ) 1396
(AP
= 2 /5
= . E
= 7 3
; 44+<5
% 6 [ g 5 3 : ( 7
% 0A
% L ' 5
= 5 3&
% 2 D7 ( / , .
=
5(?H 3
% @U&
% C . 5 (7 8<
D 25 U&J5 ; ) '(a
.
= 7 3
; 44+<5
% 5 s g
%
5 C
= 5 3 2 ' . E (
= 7 3
; 44+<5
% D7 D ` 5
= g
% : e/ 5 .
= EH
% DZ2 5
. . (\ (\ /5 B
U& 5
= 5 : 3 h(J /5 B 7 >75' 3
;
&<'
%
& ( 5(
' D E )5 k (h
h(J B 7 3
; 44+<5
% @IC +
%
`3 ( . H K5 '
@p D K'
&W 2
= ' DU^
5
= D7
/ , Q 5 3 7 3
;
@4+<5 @U&
% C : 5 C 9U
= 5 3 5N 5 L 9 3 5
% 5 ' 3 / 2
=
/ , Q K'
&W 2
= 5 7 3 / , .
=
&W 25(
= L 3
% 7
) :K5/ 7 240:1378
.(
H 3 7 /' N+
s CF / u K 5 W
= >75' 73
;
@4+<5 KF (7 : (2 G H L K5 '
Z )5/5 D7 D 25 K C
3 .'(
= 4 5(
:5(`
U 5 y(S . C
% +J '
= 3 .'(
=
J +&H5
%
& . 3 - . 5 K C Z D7 ( 5 ; 90 H
.
= J +&H5
% (g
% C 5 ' ; 90 H . (7
0
=
< V .
= .
&
% Ew
% 7 . 5(7 7 . E :;
= 7 3
; 44+<5
% D E u 7 l 0 5
=
H 5 _
= 9U
% : DI47
% K5 n^2 (& ` (
= 9 /5 (`
= ' 5 Y
.
=
( D\,* 5 C .
5(7 7
; 5 C
= 5 3 ($ /5 . E z
= T
% : { - .
= 7 3
; 44+<5
% '
5(
.
= K / 2 D&
S (& D7 3
L >
3 5(
% ) 0
% / ' .
!"
(7 {5' Q 7 5 '(
3 ) K / 2 .
= 7 3
; 44+<5
%
& T 3
; 7 Q
5 '5 3
K
` 4H 3 (
= '( )5/ g '
Z H s -
B @4 1937 D7 C D& (`
. Q ]
'(
- D7 K5 J
< Z 3 .
= H
% N7 ' 4J D D 5 3 D ) h <' 8
%
`3 ( h '
5 J X,' g B
( :[
' | W | TC5 (Z 25 [ ( /5 | W '(`
25 C }
) (E+` N7
= : 184:1390
.(
+J i+g
% @4 K / 2 5(7
=
<'5 3 '( ~ a 7 ; 5 -
D7 ) h
(0 &12 @U& ~ a 8 1972
L (7 : B 7 I&75 3 D7 ': V' @ ( ` '( c 5 , 0
p5(25 O 3
5 5(V DH @
(Peterson, 2004:179)
.
'( ~ a ?C5 K / /5 -
1990 5 C
= 5 3
•(^
D7 k (h 5 C '
' h D Z^V .
= | W _& 5 + : Z^V B 1044 2 1998 A , /5 L B
4+, B
'(
&
% 4J 3 , D
% Z^V ' ( y 0 B
1189 2 1998 / 3 B )*+,
'(
&
% 4J 3 D D T _2 .
= ( F I 3 5N ' 3 b+. ' 3 Z^V ; B 1267 2 1999
D7 K C D&X 0 ) +41
.
= 5 5(
% (C 5N }
v
<3 c 5 , /5 L ;I 11
/ 9 5 C
=
5 3 D7 ) h H
= '( 7 / 0 •S7 5' C -
) ' X
% - , ' : 5/
67:1391
.(
5(
^[)
# ` = M
> ( /& 8 % H 3
5) 3 W' ...
373
5(7
= / 2 9 5' 9g 2
@4 K D Z^V : ; 5 &25 3 5 =5 C s = .
: & . 9.'YL D 5(R
5 ; D Z^V : . 3 : 5 C % V ' %+2 3,*h ' ) V K X 5
% . . D7
$
| W
‚ L 4+, /5 Z7 ' @0V 5 }4&T @ J B
11 / 9 D Z^V . D U
% -3 :
`5( [5N<5 3
: 5 Z v(
+.5 3 : ) C ' 5 &S :
_&25 ' q(&2 ) 'N4 Q
@4 K / 2 v- '( 7 W(7
D Z^V -g L ' .
>2
<' .
= uJ
@4 K / 2 .
03 (
% ; 5 /5 ƒW C . 4+, D7 3 5 =5 C 2 L %6 6R /5 %7 W y5 5 B
%& '(
11 / 9
% -.5( 5 .
# $
%&
$' ( ) *+ % #
!"
1 ..
+ / 0(
1 '
$&2 ) 3
!"
@4 K / 2 X C5
Q '( D7 -3U&
DR - D7 K5 J
*J /5 %I z
DR ' D7 K5 J
E
=
;37 n4h ' 3 5 D7 0 7 [ %44+<5
25
(Luck, 2004:97)
. Db F X
K 37 9C ' ‚ L @
% 5 _3w' D 25 ; 5 B
3 5 ' n4h m_, 3 5 =5 C
73
; 44+<5
% z7 ^ @4 K / 2 „5 .5 ' h5 7 :
Z3 3 )5 E ; 5(7 H
= n4h
h ' D 5/' g& ) 5 V5 3
B
… T 5 [/O ) 5 V5
= uJ5 K5 W5( ' : (7
(S - .
=
2 ' = &V5 V5 (
L ) 5 3
6X 3 (
= /5 :/' g (S - . D34J % \ ) 5 V5 [ g 5 '
K5/' g&
25
(http://www.un.org/Docs)
.
$ - '( D g F /5
% +& K'(V
= = E
5(7
= 3 5 ' n4h 73
; 44+<5
% 25 '
<' . 5 - '(
D7 7 t B I
% /5 D† † .
= %4 '
4S
% U4 W
% ( 5 : 5/5
; ' 4 (&+
B '(
@4 K / 2 D7 5 - D< ,5
5 5
(Luck,
2006:1)
. . (W5'5 D4 ; 5 5 B
1980 ' 1990 (33?
.
2 1989
@p D7 3 5 =5 C ' 7 (I %` 32 % EH - '( D7 l 7(
L3 9 5 /5
; (& ` ~ a : 2 Q
- '(
4†5 +J i+g >2 ' %
D7
$ ' >2 Y
+ 3&
B % +J i+g -XC )
+ 3&
B V U,
% (
% %` 32 C
(Rostow, 2004:479)
. i+g
D7 ;37 = I+. ' %J 8 (X (0X3L 0
<' . Z2 B
% V s R R 8
;37 7 - '( ~ a D7 ;&W5 (L =5(7 %44+<5 .
+J -E2 Q
i+g : E 3 ' D
2 3 N . Z 7 25 D7 D D0 H
.
=
%& '( ) 5 V5 }4&T
% /5 (L
http://untreaty.un.org
. (
7 ; 5 /5 3 D7 . Z /5' :;
4W5
% 2 -. . X 3
'
[/O 25(HO5 .
7 )5 . Z 3
J a (6
% K b+.
:% 7 +3L5 . TC
3 .
=
+,
=(36 `'(` : :
D7
`3 (
= D& . 5 (g_ 5 :=5
Q
&2*L 3 I
% ' % K `' :
% 5 . 5 . +J (
; ' &2 i+g
(0.5 a EH %+ '(
% -&X.
(0 &12
2006 25 9
http://daccessdds.un.org/doc/UNDOC .(
5
; / 3 D [5 V5 •($ :
374
47
"#
2 % &'( ) 1396
) (The Plan of Action
/5
% 2( EH 5 3
@4J - DX
5
= / 3 B N36 5 :%& '( = .
D 3 / D 3 / :- '( 7 / 0 ' =(36X3L = . 5 = .
g (w 3 .
= (
= -
&<'
% / 0
' - '( 7 /
3 D .
% +u EH 3
+ , ' (X7 M U, D7 [5(&,5 ; 3
K V (7
% (`
.
2 1989 5 C ;3<'5 Z^V B W 7 - '( 5 D Z^V
| W (g_ 5 Q
&2*L 3 I
% D7 M _ 5 ( h 5 F .
& C )5 '5 G
D 25 U&Z 1
6 5 3 N Q C DH . % EH - '( D7 3 5 =5 B
1990 D7
^25' B L 3 (X .
= H
3 / B
< Z 3 .
=
;37 - '(
25 7 %44+<5 .
5 )*+, ˆ F D. ; 2d :
3 ) '
K5 '(EC . X
f ) _4 ' )5 W 5 Z : 7 >2 - '( v & 9 5N 5 5
DI0C 7 C % EH %4 5( = . E v
'(
. 0
% /5 _&25 (7
•*2 .
= D& . :=5
I { < 37
% H % 3+3C '
= ZV5' '
% D7 (\
% 2 3 9U ' '(
.
= +,
&<'
% q S ( 7
(Oudraat, 2004:151)
.
Z^V B 635 :
@4 K / 2 5 =5 C '
3 5 D7 N (
= 5(7
= '( 7 D47 U 0 -
W 2 .
;37 3 5 ' n4h =5(7 = E 5 - '( D Z^V ; 5 %44+<5
D7 K5 J -E (
;
† † B 5 C 5(7 5 D 3 / ' •(^
=
< Z 3 F
% KF 3 / B 3E - '(
(
) (E+` N7
= :
38:1390
.(
%7 3Z$ V ' J(2 7 3 5 =5 C bT =(3\
B 4 K / 2
@ Z^V : B
1386 5 4h B 24 J 2 L /5 5 ; 4+, B (
(Luck, 2004:85)
. D Z^V ; 5
D7 %& '( )*+, D Z$ V ( F
I ( [ IS 5 :
» 5 C 4 7 / 0 D7 3
B E C )5
% '( ) 5 V5 /5
&
% 5(7
=
;37 n4h ' 3 5 %44+<5
-+
25 7 v D7 +2 3 z, ;&W C 5…
%
~
%Z+H ' z7 ^ = ( X
k S (h 7 '
Z$ V 3 )*+,
%& '( y &X,'
11 / 9 5 [5 V5 (. 5 %< +J5 ;3 R ' [ IS
;37 %& '(
%44+<5 :
;37 3 5 ' n4h D7 0 = E U4 %44+<5
%
% «
(UN Security
Council,S/RES/1368 )
.
Z^V B y(&X [5 V5 &25 W ]
<' . S D7 0 +
B 0I ( :K K / 2 K ` .
, ' 3 '( )*+, K
&
% Z H /5 ' C B
;37 44+<5
% 25 W e*
.
= W 5(7 5
=
` 4H 3 (
= s (2 ' [5 V5
.
= '(
&
% X .
b+.
3
; 7 3
% 5(7 5
= H DH '
0t (
;37 - '( D7 0 3 5 =5 C %44+<5
L D 5]`
= ( . V ; 5 D Z^
5… M U,
%
5 W /5 ~ q 25(7
Q 51 X d 3 W /5 ~ D ( K X ($ W 7 ;3<'5 =5(7 '
2 /5
= 3 5 =5 C D7
K5 J - '( D7 0 % V 9 5' 8 d
3
% C
(Rostow,
2004:481)
.
» K < 7 ;3H «
'
»
%H q . ' « 7 D U&Z d
3 (h n z, W /5 ~
1. Chantal de Jonge Oudraat
5(
^[)
# ` = M
> ( /& 8 % H 3
5) 3 W' ...
375
<' . 5 C : D7
$ (AP
=
… T 5 5 = Z7 ) +3+
/ g ' 9 5' D7 5 % \ ( F
I 5
(Boulden & Weiss, 2006:7)
.
< ,
% D Z^V B 1368
… _ z, n ( 7 5 I ( F ) V '
: 25 5 9 5N 5 W /5 ~
<' .
= 5 C uJ 5 = / , N3
O &25 ; 5
D7 K5 J
H 3 2 M5(J D7 /' g EH % V D 2003
( .
, ( 5 ; 5 p
+.5 N 3 : 25
D 5(R
% K X 5 C .
N ( D7
= 5(7
= ( 5]
0 W /5 ~ z, @p C @
7 : 25 D S
= '/ D7 @2 D7 :KF e( ]L D
<' .
= 25 D&C5 =/ 3 uJ .
D Z^V ;3 ' :
Z^V B 1373 28 (0 &12 2001 D&_. D2 /5 (&+ D 7 L
/5
)*+, 11 / 9 D7 M _ 5
C 5 F
. )5 EZ D Z^V ; 5 [5N<5
'F
= 34 D7 0 B
= uJ5
@4 K / 2 ( ia'
. ) 5N<5 ; 5
<' .
` 4H D7 5 3
(
= /5 +, .
= D O Z /
†3 D O Z (
/5 '(
. ' ' (
% 5 5 K ]L [ J ' E F = . 0&J5 i7 e(
= '(
. [N4
( . D7 '*J
<' . L D7 [N4 D7 K 5
'(
. 5N 5 ' 9 @ZH D34J 0V5(
D ]`
D 2 C ' :
X (&
.
= /(
= U ' I+.
= .
=
;37 C - '( D34J %44+<5
(Rostow, 2004:482)
.
; 5 5 /5 D Z^V ;
7 (\
% DU7 2 5N<5 D 7
% +. D7 5 B
<' .
+S 3 5 k U7 2 D ( @ ) 5N<5 ~ ;
k (h g ` )5 . Z
% C . N32 7 D U
Z^V :- '( . Z B
1373 )5 EZ 7 ;3<'5 =5(7
&2 I
% 5(7 5
= % + 191
5 uJ <' g
(
(Boulden & Weiss, 2006:11)
.
D E Z^V B 1373 % V ) 5N<5 7
% DU7 2 5
= D7 5
<' .
= @3+S uJ (
DI47 :
'/ 2
= 5 D7
\ uJ5 (X3L ' ) \
=
&3+
B a - '(
) (CTC
5 g ( g F .
D
» yO 5' 5 «
% K X ($ W = 'F D Z^V ; 5
+J 5
= Z7 DA , K5 ' /5 11
/ 9
25
(Luck, 2004:99)
.
&3+
B a 5 „ . D2 - '(
: U (w 3 .
= a '(
&
%
<' .
=
@4 K / 2 uJ E :
3 U& 5 @ 8+
.
= D7 %
<' . )5 EZ [ g 5 EH
a
& '(
% 6 . +. '
% ) 5 V5 a
'(
&
% K / 2 .
=
;37 DU^ :%44+<5 ' =5
/ DU^ (
=5
(Cortright & Lopez , 2006:3)
.
4 5
67
$&2 )
' .5 C 5 /5 ) J*$5 ;
+, D&
% /5 Z7 - '( D7 @4 K / 2 2 L D 11
/ 9
5 X i^U ; C
25 . L kO'5 3 /5 9 11 / 9 ) 5 V5 a
< V @4 K / 2 %& '(
)5 . Z
;37 7 %44+<5 .
' /5 -E (
; )5 . Z ; 5 ) 0J
5 /5 : . Z Q
;37 %44+<5
7 / 0 +7 5]`
= .
= %& '(
) 1997 ( . Z ' Q
;37 +J5 %< i7 7 / 0 %44+<5
%& '(
) 1999 .(
ICF 9 5N 5
= 5 . Z ' ; 5 D % . X 5 Z L
/5 11 / 9
376
47
"#
2 % &'( ) 1396
5 H' ( :
K b F ;p'{ D 2001
: 59 . Z X Q
+J5 s (2
u 5 5 %& '(
(
Unausa.org/site) .
(http://www
. D7 '*J
< ,
% D /5 @0V 11 / 9 : 27
. Z ; 5 X 5
7 ( :
KF /5 Z7 118
5 D EJ ; 5 (6 <'
( (0 2 ' 2005
E F 5 Z 7
D 145 32 <' )
' H 1 .(
;p'{
2001 : 43
. Z <' Q
%< i7 7 / 0 '(
. 7 ( u 5 5 :
< ,
% D /5 @0V 11 / 9 :
E ER 5 . Z ; 5 X (
7 : ] )*+, /5 Z7 ' 147
5 KF <'
( 5 . b+.
3
; / /5
% 3w' ; 5 D EJ D7 D_
Q . X : C D&C5]` 3 5 =5 C
% C D Z^V 5 Z % ' _ D /5 Z7 ' @0V - '( 7 >0 ( = .
5 DA , ; H'
5 . L3 9 /5 11 / 9 @ 3 5 =5 C 13
Z^V B DU0$
7
= C - '( | W 5 :
D7
$ ' h : J 8 %< 2 ;36 3 (
) ' H 2 .(
5 Z =(36+XR 9 5N 5
D Z^V = . C
Q /5 3 5 =5 C 11
/ 9 -XR D7
% : W 7 D S
= 5'5 D @ 2013 :
5 5 C ; 31 5 D Z^V v (
D7
$ 2 (. >2 &
4 5 D Z^V ) ' H 2 (.
] C 1 .
E =
M ) 3
= B E S ( 7
"9 B"( ( H ^ R6
M E M 5) 3
&' ) 1997 (
i) ( H ^ 9 7
5) 3 W'
http://www.un.org :i0
0 H (6 B D Z^V < H = .
C Q /5 Z7 ' @0V - '( 7 >0 ( 11
/ 9 ,
s
‹
=
`3 (
= 25
) :K X / 28:1386
.(
8 D Z^V /5 13 Z^V /5 @0V D 11
/ 9 D7 M _ 5 5 F
7 C :
< ,
% D 5 Z^V B Z7
= K' 7
‹
=
`3 (
= 5 X DI
= (H K
5(
^[)
# ` = M
> ( /& 8 % H 3
5) 3 W' ...
377
‹
=
`3 (
=
† C 7 : D7 2
3 . D Z^V ; (&X37 D =5 ' U
(75(7 KF ) h
(`
) 5
‹
= „($ /5 i &+
3 Π: ' 7 0+ / ' 9 5( : . :;3R (
:
^V Z B 748 2
1992 (S - .
=
% +J5 5 %03< = &V5 (
. L /5 11 / 9 : 19 D Z^V /5 20
D Z^V D7 M _ 5 :5 F 32 D7 .
Z^V D 2 E B
1450
‹
% D 5
+7 )*+, ' O 0 I3 %& '( = 5]`
3 4+, ' B >W D7 %IC V • 2 % 5 .
2 0+
3 28 (0 5 2002
% [ IS 5 (
)
$ 30
% : ( 23:1384
.(
4 5
8
$&2 )
`5( [5N<5 3 3 5 =5 C ) 5 V5 (
% +, D (\ ; 5 /5 : 9 5' D
5 5 C ; D7
A , B 11 / 9 H 5 : 25 7 3+.5 Np , '
2 :) 34+J ; 5 3_3 ' 3+.5 = H >
-E N3 @4 K / 2 25
. D7
\ D Z^V 3_3 %7 / 5 : .
% K5 ~ ER D7 5 E F
DU0$
= 7 ( : 1 . 4
% / :%
2 .
%& '( ) 5 V5 D7 9 5' 3
. %& '( ) 34+J D7 9 5'
- (S +J5 ' ' := &V5 = .
4 . - '(
D7 K5 J D A ~ a 8 .
+J '5 '(`
% /
T
% D Z^V @ C D 3 / - '( 7 D 25 % .
T 5 (& ` = .
%
'(2 ' 5 k 5N<5 A , D7 B h W
%
%+ C5 .
2 D Z^V /5 13 Z^V B C
Q @0V
/5 11 / 9 +J 5 (&X37 - '( | W
% / T
% ) ' H 3 (
& . .
Z^V B 635 Z^V ' B
1269 2 1999
;37 = I+.
%44+<5 ) 417 ( 3 / B
25 - '( D34J G H .
Z^V B 1269 2 1999 3 5 =5 C :
D7 34 ,5(h B
e' : +J5 D ' ' .
/5 -J5 5 %& '( = . 3
(_
= H ' 3 D ]L (
N36 5 /5 (\ „(h Q
+. E F B
/ (. ' H (. IC5 [ IS C [ g 5 D K
% :
D7 ' '( +J5 Y
&
%
;37 n4h ' 3 5 D E 5 %44+<5
% + 34 ' v B
<' D7 5 .
5(H5
=
;37 )5 . Z % + @ a %44+<5
%& '(
' C(6 D7
% 0
% +.5 ' ) '(a (7 3
5
&, ) 5 V5 ;
% . X KF
% 5 uJ D
& 0 -. )5 . Z ;
% z X D7
K5 J
D EJ KF & 3 E F 5 ($ D % E F D7 0 ( (7 z 5 8 N3 ' (367 (\ 5 .
<' ]L D7 5 . 7 DR(. e(
3 5 (&X
†( )5 . Z ; 3
% +
(http://daccessdds.un.org/
doc/UNDOC/GEN
.(
378
47
"#
2 % &'( ) 1396
] C 2 . 3 ' S[K E M k 5) 3
# 4 ) W' M
H S( 8^K 3
5^ &c WE H 2001
http://www.un.org/terrorism/sc.htm:i0
7 3 ; D Z^V /5 Z7 = . 11
/ 9 /5 937 3
+
% /5 E F ) 11 D Z^V /5 20 D Z^V ( 5
D7 D ` 5
=
% K5 DU0$
D ( = 7 (7
+J ) ,*^h5
% C 7 z0^ - '( /5 )
' H
4 .(
D Z^V ; 5 Z^V @ C .
B 1373 ) 2001 (
&3+ D B : E 7 5 %& '( +J5 a
Z^V B 1535 D + 3 2 5 D&
2004 / 2/ 7
= Z^V : ( B
1540 2
2004 7 Q
e(& ` [ J
•*2 .
= D& .
%I { < 37 ' % 3+3C :=5 '
D Z^V 2
2005 l 0 5
25 %& '( ) 5 V5 - (S 7 .
D Z^V @ C '(` ;3 2 ' ;3 ' h W %& '( )*+, D & . % .
% [ IS 5
% . '(` ;3 2 Z
% D Z^V .
= +J5 ' %& '( ) 34+J D7 9 5' D7 l 7(
)5/ g D Z^V @ C = &V5
% % . D C (S - .
% ' . X D7 5 {
- .
% +J5
% DI0C D7 D
% 8+ %& '( = . 2
)
<*H
% : 71:1384
.(
73
&X D Z^V ; 5 ( @0V D .
/5 11 / 9 ) 9 D Z^V /5 13 D Z^V ( D7 ' ; 5 ' 32
5(V '(`
%
`3 (
) ' H 3 (
;37 %& '( ) 5 V5 D7 9 5' | W +7 K b+. %44+<5
5]`
= /5'(L
K L ( F I +C Q 103 2 1988 3 5N ' 3 %& '( )*+, ' 1996
25 . 7
% , = . X
% '(
;37 X (A5 E F )*3IX ' .
=5 C :%44+<5 3 5
X 5 =(6 [ ` )5/ g
v C5 (7 9C
D Z^V D7 K5 J [ 2 '(`
DU0$
7
= C 5
) ' H 2 .(
Z7 /5 -. / } ' , (0 &12 D Z^V
. ) 11 D Z^V /5 20 D Z^V ( 2 L
4+J D7 3 '( )
&
% W h
% 7 5 ) ' H 4 (v +7 )*+, @ C = 5]`
3 ' :
K <
. @ C D Z^V 8 E )5/ g
.
% /5 D 7 11
/ 9 25 32 D7 v
Z^V B
1526 2 2004
D )5/ g .
% ) 420 ( 5 -3+Z J U<5 )*3IX ' K 0< $ D34J '
5 DZ2 ) ' H 4 .(
C [ ER '(`
D Z^V @ E - '( D7 D & . % .
D7 K5 J 8
% 6 %pNH ~ a .
Z^V ' B /5 Z7 ' @0V 11
/ 9 7 ~ ; 5 /5 :
Z^V B 687
5(
^[)
# ` = M
> ( /& 8 % H 3
5) 3 W' ...
379
2 1991 D
| W G H
'5 4W 3
‚ q Z^V ' 7 B
1214 2 1998
D7 D
% l 7( K & ? 5 % +J 3Za' C
. Z7 „5(`5 L
= 5 D7
& ; 3 Dg
% K5 2 3
D Z^V 3_3 D ( (33? -. .
25 . L3 9 /5 11 / 9 E ' D Z^V /5 2 3 N D Z^V ) 15
h ( ) ,*^h5 7 4
% '( /5 -
D&C5 '(2 5
. /5 11 / 9 Z7 D7 : /5 937 3
+
% /5
D Z^V . ) 11 D Z^V /5 20 D Z^V ( '( 7 ) ,*^h5 7 -
4
% D&C5 '(2 5
) ' H 2 .(
2 25 9U - '( D34J G H
% 4H &2 B
/5 3 5 =5 C 11
/ 9 D&C5
25 :
< ,
% D D7 )*+, /5 @0V - '(
( F I C D7 3 Q h W
% (7 2
% C . '*J 5 (7 ;
. 6
%
% D&_` %< +H5 D C
73
&X D Z^V ( /5 Z7 ' @0V .
11 / 9 0$
3 k &Z D7 2 L
7 %h W %& '( ) 5 V5 D
C D& (`
5 ) ' H 2 .(
L3 9 /5 11 / 9 %& '( )*+, /5 = ' S 5 Z E 5 C D7 k*+J
% 5 ~ H 5 C
.
, ; 5 7
‚ L :D&C]` 2 (V (t 5
M _ 5 D7 5 ~ H 5 5 C D7 %& '( )*+,
C [ IS ' C 5
.
< ,
% D
<' .
= 5 D7 0 uJ N` 5 ;
X
% W(7
% ( : D7 (\
% /5 5 C D 2 11
/ 9 S 5 (&X37
= 25 ( @+J
) + 3 2 0J ' K
% :
65:1391
.(
5 F ~ +H5 (6 / 7 )' _
= 25 C ICF .
/5 @0V 11 / 9 E 8 D Z^V /5 13
D Z^V ) 62 h ( D7 M _ 5 5 F C
:
<'
% /5 Z7 KF 19 D Z^V /5 20 D Z^V ) 95
h ( D7 M _ 5 32 D7 5 F .
e*
.
= /5 3 5 =5 C 11
/ 9 (&X37 Z7 D7
. / 2
% /5 -E ' N (+&
Db F 7 D&C]`
5 : 25 C )
W(. $
% : 65:1388 .(
% _` K5
< ,
% D e*
.
= W5 3 0 (7 (
= - '( /5 ' 7 c 5 , D7
K5 J ~ a
0Sh ;3 L n^2
% /5 : 11 / 9 Z7 D7 5
; D ` e*
.
`5(
3 ' ( 2 25
% ( 25 7 .
L /5 11 / 9 D Z^V -E . ( K ` 5 = &W 2 ' C | W 5 @4 K / 2 = .
% @IC - '(
' .
&W 2
=
% -.5( 5 5 V5 D 'F
% EH 5 73
&X
<' ( .
=
=(0. @4 K / 2 uJ
%
(Rostow,2004:487) .
i0 : http://www.un.org
380
47
"#
2 % &'( ) 1396
] C 3 . D Z^V .
= 5 C
= 5 3 4J 3 '( D /5 @0V - (0 &12 -. / )
2001 (
http://www.un.org :i0
5(
^[)
# ` = M
> ( /& 8 % H 3
5) 3 W' ...
381
] C 4 . S[K E M
# M 5)
3 H S( W' 3
5^ &c WE H )
2001 (
١ .
i0 : http://www.un.org
382
47
"#
2 % &'( ) 1396
2 . ) 0
/5 D&C]`
`(`
% g3& - '( D7 9 5' 3.
B 4+, B 11 / 9 : q(&2 = . 5N75
( (33? N3 - '( 7 / 0 5
. L3 9 /5 11 / 9 (S» - . « D7
$ % E 5N75 +Z
(&2 C q 7 3 5 =5 .
5 C (S - . . 7 D2 - '( D34J 5 B
1990 :%03< D34J
+J5 K & ? 5 ' K5 2 (
. - (S 5 C /5 - '( D7 9 5' 5 .
11 / 9 Z7 D7 D7 NH
H - { )5/ g
. D 25 D34J
;7 K O : uJ5
= ' 5( 5 ' :K 0< $ ' J U<5 )*3IX
'(`
.
= 5' +J5 KF D7 D& 7 (I
' ( F I +.
B D2 ]
. B 1990 D7 @2 &
'/ +J5 C
. L + W /5 B - '( [ E_ )5(33? 7 ' C J > 5(C (2 G H
:%4 5(
D /' 5 C =5 g 5
C - (S +J5 D 5 .
D7 K5 J
<' D34J = 5N75 = .
+, Q
I0C B ;I+ %& '(
W 2 .
» )5 '5
«
% K X ($ W D
{ - .
= - (S
. B 1990 U4 7
% - '(
D7 K5 J
< Z 3&
%
~'(X IS D7 3
;37 C , ~ +H5 -
%44+<5
8+
( D 3 / [5 V5 D&2 Z+H
%
;37 %44+<5 D7
\ 7 E F 7 D47 U .
; 5(7 7
)5/ g . (33? D7 +J e(6
%
<' . 8+ - '( D7 0 (
(Outrad, 2004:157)
.
25 ƒTX D
)5/ g .
? 33 2 25 (
%
<' &
.
= 5 „ . g +
% : 5
» yO « K5 J
% ; 5 D )5/ g
. 2 /5
= 5 C [ ` .
= 7
% DU7 2 5
= J'(X 3
5 /
%
< Z 3 . ' '(`
.
= '(
&
% '
&<
% 5 . '*J 5 (7 ; )5/ g .
` 5 / 7 5N75
% ' 7 3 (6
[NJ
= H 5 C - '( 7 D47 U 5
(Luck,2004:94)
. D2
= KF D )5/ g
.
C +J5 :
‚ &
L3 9 73
% ]L ( E ' 7
= D )5/ g . 7 3U 5(+.
7 ) K5 2 ' %03<
( :
% 5 K _`
D )5/ g . 5]`(A5 7 5 . '*J 5 (7 ; 3 C/ 5 K5N
%
(A5 <' 8 D (S
- . 2 /5
% : . +E N +
% 3U 5 (S
- . ƒTX
% . 3< /5 /5 D X D&25 W K5 2 ' %0 +J N3R
-XR K X V D7 0 =5 %C L
:
;7 D7 K 0< $ Ž J 5 7 K O
W ) V 7 D& 75' % \ ' %< :%2 32 +, =5(
/5(,5 5 K & ? 5 .
)5/ g . /5 11 / 9 +J5 - '( D7 9 5' X
5 : D7 NH =5(7 )5/ g .
= H
J U<5 ' K 0< $ D34J :
5 D D4 ; Z& @ O -.
= 5 v :kO'5 L D7 )*+, /5 ( F
I
4J (0 - '( D3 73
; 44+<5
% k*
- '( D34J D47 U D7 ' (` W D7 = H @IC
C @ 0 :
< ,
% D XW +J5 /5 % ' _& IC5 5
(7
% (`
. Z^V B 1368 z,
5…
% 5 W /5 ~ q 25(7
Q 51
@4 K / 2 X z
( ) 34+J D7 ' ( F
I
J'(X K & ? 5 3
XT7 3 (& ` +, KF /5 ' Q
;37 D7 %44+<5 'F @+J
) W(. $ ' _
% :
11:1391
.(
(I4+J D0 gI
% \ ' ( F
I M5(J ' K & ? 5 )5/ g
. Z75 5
= R
5(
^[)
# ` = M
> ( /& 8 % H 3
5) 3 W' ...
383
S
~ ZC 5 5(V . :[' )5/ g .
% / 7 <' 8 D34J D D
: ' @+J s W
% :
D 5(R D7 ( 2 KF H
<' . :% \ >75' / g KF 7 5 W 83 +41 ' = &V5
i^V .
)5/ g . DI0C D34J %4 5( %& '( = .
(&+ J U<5 (AP
25 K R :
„ . L3 D&2 25 K C %_T ' U& 5 , .
[ 2 : %4 5( •- '( H = 3
e*
. D7
\ U K5
<' .
&3+ - '( 7 / 0 B
a - '(
( (AP
/5 )5/ g .
% 5 C 7 . D7 (6 ) 0J :
/5 _&25 N`
B
\
% :M5(J ' K & ? 5
+J @IX
% ~ +H5 D7 ,
| W (7
)5/ g .
< Z ' 3
&3+
B
a :%& '(
5
% +J5 )5/ g
. /5 5 11 / 9 D7 25 5 9. Z7 .
)5 '5
% K X ($ W D
{ - .
= - (S N` =5(7 5 5
B 4J % \ 3
% 5 +. - '( D .
-3 67 D 25 5 C ; 5(7 7 )5/ g
. / 2 %4 5( - '( D34J F UR
7 .5 W .
Z H D 25 ƒTX B
;37 @4+<5 L /5 11 / 9 D7 - (S /5 (3†
. /5 = . 5N75
(6
= 25 ( _&25 -.
: %< ) 5N<5 N3 ' % \ = .'(3 /5 _&25 D4+H /5 '
+J
% a
&3+ >2 D %& '(
B a
% (& %& '(
C .
:.
;
$&2 )
U (6 @ J B
5 C (I4+J
= 5 3 '( 7 W(7 L :-
] K / 2 )5 EZ e(
<' >2 @4 25 uJ = .
. 5 2 D U ; 3
: D 5(R /5 @0V
= 11 / 9 ]L C(
% /5
2
=
<' . 25 W X
7 . D Z^V •3.
[5 V5 … T 5 K .5 W D =5
<' . D7
2 C
% : C 7 - '(
D7 NH D Z^V D7 l 7( = . )5/ g
. /5 @0V ' C5 H'
11 / 9 ]L )5 EZ e(
~ a - +.5 3&
% U4
%
% v C 5 L 5 /5 ; ( 5 ; 5 :
?3 3 ( ( .
Z^V H D7 B
1373 )5 EZ : [5N<5
'F
`5( ' 3 (
=
<' D7 0 b+. : uJ = .
3 ;
\ '/ 2
%
&3+
B - '( a
) (CTC
C 3 Q D V*W 5
= 5 5(7
= Dp5 5 - '( 7 D47 U
( . @ 5'5 2004 : 3 5 =5 C
| W U D7 / 3
&3+
B ($ /5 - '( a z
p5 5 B 7 ) V ' i7 3
~ +H5 :(&X (` ) h
. 5 C ( 5 ; 5 Z^V +2 D7 5
B
1535 q 2004
5 M 2 .
. :D Z^V 3
)d H %& '( a % 5(H5
= 5 5 @3IX
D D7
$ +J 3 +
% (, D 5 =5 H' D7 'F
5(H5 ) 5 V5 /5 '
%
<' +, uJ = .
( . 3.
d (0 &12 /5 %& '( a % 5(H5 ) 2005
D7
$ . / 2 @
% (0 2 ' C
2 K +.
D7 ) h 4+J 3
% d 3 C
) S
% : 23:1390
.(
+.
3 2 ; D&3+ ; 5 ) V*
.
=
Z&
=
<' 7 5 uJ = .
D7
\ I+.
= U&
3 ' %+2 ) U 7 -
< J
% D0 / †F (
' 8+
.
=
%
=(&E7
=5(H5 EH 5 Z^V
B 1373 ) 2001 ( ' 1624 ) 2005 ( -.5(
W 2 .
384
47
"#
2 % &'( ) 1396
&3+
B 3. ' %& '( a d
e* ;3<'5 %& '( a % 5(H5 ) . / 2
% C Q K / 2
@4 {'(L 8 Q
G . +.
%& '( a % EH ' 5
(www.un.org/sc/ctc/mandate)
. 2 3 N
. Z Q 4+S %& '( a
% 5(7 % V
= 6 . +.
%
%4 s g : 5
•3. 5 '/ 2
+ V
=
&W5 3 5 . 7 5
&3+ DI B
%+ %& '( a
<' 5 5 uJ = .
_C : )5/ g 3
( ; 5 5 ]L M X Z^V e(
B 1373 25 . q 25(7
` e 5N
"
&2
[5 V5
"
5(7
= U (7 B @4 K / 2
| W
&3+ :- '( a B
z - '( a
( @+J :
D 5(R EH 3J'(X ' %2 32 ) V D&3+ ; 5 e*
.
= %& '( a
( -.5( 5 % EH 25
: 6&2 .
= 6 . +. =5(7 % T
% e*
.
= % EH D7
\
= . E 7 / 0
& '(
% e(& ` 5
;37 = . g . U ' DZ2 D7 ' 5 %44+<5
['5 ' g 5 ' ( 8+
h(
.
=
;37 %44+<5 D7
\ U e*
.
=
+E 9U %& '( a
% 5 5 25 ( _
(Cortright etc,2004:8)
.
[ + 191 uJ <' e 5N`
.
=
&3+ D7 5 % U ' B
'( a Dp5 5 %&
( 5 D
5 5N75 ;
= 5(7
= Z^V
B 1373 C E F >2 .
e 5N`
<' . /5 %I >2 5 &75
+ D2 3&
B ' %J(
. Z7
&3+ @ >2 B
D\,* %& '( a
% C . 3.
d % 5(H5 )
%& '( a
% 5 3 / B D0 H e 5N` % = .
<' . D4+H /5 D '
3 5 V ' .
;
(g 5 (&25 ' % (H E :% (+` %< % 5NH U D7 l 7( ) J a K
% 34L ' % V
M R V '
†3 V(
% . 7 ) X D&3+ D7 DS425
)
&T
= : 54:1387
.(
L @34S /5 e 5N`
. D&3+ :
% 5
$
% D D7 =5
<' . (&X37 ) J*$5
= 5
25 W .
<' . 12 90 ' /' . 2 L H e 5N` < V 5 V .
5{
B 2005
&3+
B /5 937 %& '( a 550
/5 e 5N`
<' . (
D7 5 KF D
% 6 7
% D ( @ 0 =5 kO +&,5 5 KF K5
r N7 (
; 7 B '( % J*$5
3 % EH
(Cortright,2005:2)
.
< ,
% D . 3 7 • 3 K D& C D& ' 5
=
| W U
B
e 5N`
. /5 @0V %& '( a 11
/ 9 5 H' :
/5 Z7 KF 0A ; 5 e 5N`
. 8 D2
C 25 . q 25(7 (\
5(
E + 5 Z
% /5
<' . Z^V 7 5 W B
1373
5 (&X37 ' 5 U7 ^ ;
<' . %&Z h -.
L3 D& (X 5 D (w ' i7 3 2 Dg L' [(
+, D7 l 7( 5 7 K (
<
% ( '
% d 3
; K / 2 .
= 5 5 %& '(
. ' ,
60
& . 5]` K5 ' <' .
; 5
<' . E+ 5(
3 5 5 :% V )5(33?
= '
J V
= 5(7
=
;37 - '( 7 D47 U
%44+<5 5 . ' , 70
<'
&3+ 7 B - '( a
z 5 5 : % *IX 7 5 K5(S7
.
= (U :% \ C
' 5
%
<'5 XT7
% D7
%& '( a @p DH5
5 . '(` ; (WF )
' , 20
<' ( 5
% ]L 5 )5 EZ e(
5(
^[)
# ` = M
> ( /& 8 % H 3
5) 3 W' ...
385
5 : 5 5 (I 5 ; .
; 5 /5 %W(7
<' . 7 / 0 [ U >W ' & . - '(
% + E F %& 2 e*
.
=
% }3Zu 5 @4 K / 2 .
'*J 5 (7 :;
/5 L ]L U 5 ' e(
<' . 7 D Z^V .
= '( a
&
%
&3+ : B (6
&3+ [ D7 3 5 =5 C %& '( a B
1540 e(& ` [ J
•*2 .
= Z+H &X
%
D 5 e 5N`
30
% 2006 : 129 ;3<'5 K / 2 8 ' <' e 5N`
.
= D7 5 W %4
5 Dp5 5 D&3+
' 5 62 uJ <' D7
`/
% Dp5 5 5 W e 5N` ;3<'5 (
5 . 9 5'
2 (7 D7
% e 5N`
.
=
<'5 3 B :D&3+ >2 %4 83
7 ) J*$5 <' 3
(&X
= 5 Dp5 5 5 .
e 5N` @3E .
% 5 . '
< Z 3 . D7
\ L 3 (0X e 5N`
.
% K 3
<'5 .
= -E
< Z 3 25 %V 7 D&3+ % F .
&3+ ;3 2 B
3 5 =5 C %& '( a )
&3+
B 1267 : J U<5 D7 l 7(
: 5( 5 ' K 0< $
' '(`
.
= D& 75' ( 2 1999 2d 3 D&3+ E ' C D 25 =5
% K5 7 5 KF ' @0V
Z7 A , /5 B 11 / 9 U D ( .
&3+
B 1267 (w '(`
= D 5 e 5N`
.
= Z&
= 5
(X&
( 5
<' 5 : = .
[N4 uJ p5 5 D7
B e 5N`
.
= 2 %4 2002
0 . 5 7 ;
q , 2006
: 45 . / . <' 3
7 (I Dp5 5 %C 5N` •
) :(E12 12:1384
. (
( )
, 0 • L3 9 D&_`
5' D 25 KF (7 3 5 =5 C 9
- '( D7 L
/5 11 / 9 V
= (
25 C .
@4 K / 2 (I4+J , ; 5 7 3 5 =5 C ' @
D7
$ ' Y D7
^25' B
J a
% O IC5 7
% 25 7 5(+.
. @ C i 5 ; 5 0
:- '( /5 % EH } (Z
0 . '/ 2
= 5(H5
% : 5(6
% .
= C
% (X7 M U, ) J a : I ( F … _ /5
= 3+.5 '
DX @4J =5
25 .
- '( D7 @4 K / 2 9 5' D7 l 7( ) J a ; (&X37 /5 %I :kO'5 :
5 %
<' uJ = . D7
\ - '( [ E_ (2 (7 z 5 25
. D7
% (\
<' 2 /5 uJ = .
D7 [ E75 DI 5
% (2 (7 k*
%a5 5 : D 5(R KF (7 5 E F
% 5 D7 5 - '(
7 D } (Z %V($
„ . .
= C 7 2 & E F %2 32 .
U, 3 +J U 9I+X ; (
7 - '( F D 25 7 ; 5 D7
K5 J C } (Z %2 32 90 H 8 W
3 (.
J 5
= z 5 5
; 5 4 D 3 B
< Z 3 .
= [ g 5 D& (`
H W ?C5 (75(7 ' U D7 0
%
'
< Z 3 .
= 9I+X F
3 5(7 N
= .
% XT7
% (Z /5 5 %4 '( }
- t&
(Rostow, 2004:480)
v R(.
D7
%+ (\
2 0 (Z ,5' }
= '( /5
< Z i - 3
4+J
%
&3+ 3 5 =5 C B
C 7 7 %& '( a .
+J i+g e*
% . Z EH Q
386
47
"#
2 % &'( ) 1396
i H ,5' '(
- D7 H
=
@I '(L H )5 . Z ' . 3
/
<' ~ +H5 .
=
uJ 25
) Z2 L 3 : 7:1388
.(
5(6
%
| W _ (Z K5 U
% EH
% - '( /5 :
D† † 5
= := g . ' %V*W5
(X7 M U,
= 25 . ' (6C 5N`
/ Y 3 B L 3 ' (0X +, /5 5/F
= .
= 7 3
= M U, '
W e 5N` (X7 2006
% Z H /5 ) J D B
;37 44+<5
% :- '( 7 / 0
(Z K' 7 5 }
•*^h5 ; H
% C
&<' (. D
% (Z 5 /5 5 W } {5' ;
KF D ` D
5 KF
% : +E 7 3 K .5 ( 5 ; D7 ) h 5 • 2 D7 U< 7 _&2
Q
†3 5 5(
= ' (X7 M U, /5
&,
% _&25 Q 5 /5 2 {5' ;
(7
% (`
. N 8 (
; (Z } 5 C R KF 3 N
= 25 D
Z^V B 1269 2 1999 7 3 K C 25 . 3 5 =5 C D7
,5(h +J5 % + e' :
.
D ' '
= . 5 %& '(
D7 K5 J ' D (S 5 H
3 D ]L (
„(h N36 5 /5 (\
.
= E F :
4H ' IC5 [ + K X .
g (.
% I ( D % (. >2 ' [ IS C
% : D7
| W 5 V5
%
;37 n4h ' 3 5 D
% E 5 %44+<5 5 ' :
( 5 ;
% 5
(` 5 N
=
%4 (37 Z =5(7 -.5(
. D ' D7 D =5
% ' _&25 )5 . Z /5
a %& '(
D7 K5 J N36 5 ;33Z =5(7 =5 Db F
5(7 @+J
= - '( 7 / 0 D7
% : ' 25 . Z H B
@4 U 5 / 3
%
| W _ (Z
% - '( /5 % EH D7
\
+, L ' (X7 M U, /5 3
%& '( a i H (0.5 (0X D 5(R : 25
D7 0 z 5 [ J
(Z _
% D&W C C V*W5 IC5 ;C' '
% Zu 5 - '( 7 / 0 = g . ' 3
} ( '
(ER Q 5 @4 K / 2 DC W
5
% / 2 .
U ~ a :[' =N ( 9U - '( D7 0 3 5 =5 C 9 5' 3U
5 . Z^V =5(H5 B
1373 = ' , D7
<3 0 @
% 5 ' i7 = .
&3+
B - '( a
25 C @&T i H ) \ [ g 5 .
D7 '*J •3. D&3+ ; 5 : '/ 2
% 5(H5
Z^V ) 5N<5 D % . X /5 D&2 KF )5/ g B
1373
%+ [ g 5 5 5 : .
. /5 %W(7
%+ . X ; 5 +2 D7 5 i7 0+ 5
e*
.
= „ ^Z %& '( a :
< ,
% D 5 5 . X ( 2 Q
<' v 5 5 ; 5
&2 = . B [' D7 +&,5 / D&2 5
=
D & . +
5 @ DI0C D7 L %& '( = . .
+, E F /5
) VF
% : C L DH5 W
34:1392
.(
5 [ 2 :DI ( F I ='(3 (AP
= 5 C ;&C5 5' 5 D7
_
= XU
% D O Z ( / 0 7
25 7 % EH - '(
.
<' ( 2 =5(7 D7 I ( F ) V =( (7 : 3 5 =5 C uJ = .
D N`
= .
@IX (
=
%E&
% ) C 5 - '( D34J G H D C
% XT7 D7 D /5
5(
^[)
# ` = M
> ( /& 8 % H 3
5) 3 W' ...
387
' I ( F ) V D34J
… _
% ) 0 KF / '
. S 5 D7 @IX ; 5
= }4&T uV
3 B _&25
4J '/ /5 3 M5(J D 2003
5 C 25 7 DXV
.
3 5 =5 C D U&Z K 2 C /5 = 3 7 :[ ER e*
.
= 7 / 0 W
DR - '(
D7 K5 J
<' DR ' @ 8 + V = .
= 5 Z %XU S& )O 5
) J/
L(
= DU^
=5 D7 (` .5 W EJ .
Z H D 25 KF (7 „ Z& (W B
;37 @4+<5 / , Q 7 .5 T z - '(
: DI F (6 9I+X
. K EH }4&T z$
2(7 K L D7 (3+X ' D 3 ' W K b+.
.
9U @4 K / 2 DI 5 K I 5 :-g L ( (AP
(&X37 '
= EJ (7 - '( D34J G H 5
(367 : H 5(6
% J +&H5
% K b+.
'(`
.
= (X7 M U,
= : K / 2 .
= D &2' (X7 '
25 C •*2 i4W K5 5 ($
. 5 D 5 H' q( ; e*
.
= >2 %& '( a
<' . s (2 EH _< T
K D7
% ' .
= I+.
=5(7 25 ;I+ %& '( a = .
{ - .
= %XC L = 5 0&25 5
.5(
' (X7 M U, D7 0 E F ' S )5 EZ 'F -
' S 5 K V =5(H5 / 2
. L /5 11 / 9 : /5 +, | W D Z^V D2 % +J i+g
M U,
= 5/F ' (X7 - '( D34J ; 3 7 = .
2 .
= 2002 : 2003 : 2004 (
.
Z^V B 191 / 59
% +J i+g
% z D
<' . 5 V5 (. D ;3+u 7
%
5(7
= - '( 7 / 0 7
;37 ;3 5 V S E F )5 EZ 7 %44+<5
D7 ' Y (X7 M U,
=
;37 :%44+<5 M U, ' K ` . L M U, D &2' (X7
C 7 z0^
. 2 @ (37 .
= 2003 :
2004 ' 2005 e 5N` D2
= 5/F ' (X7 M U, /5 +, = .
7 / 0 = 3 7
( Dp5 5 - '(
. 73 (WF @ ( C5 W e 5N` ;
% + 3 3 (X7 M U, K
=O H 2005
` F
% 5(7 5 W
= L 3 +, ' (0X
= 5/F ' (X7 M U, /5 4J = 3 7 = .
3 D
25 ( [*J5 - '(
. S& @4 K / 2 (X7 M U, %< J ( 3+ (&
) OHCHR (
IR 3 5
= +2
% /5
< Z 3 .
= DU^ )*3IX ' @4 K / 2 M U, /5 +, =5
( (X& 5 - '( 7 D47 U (X7 :
0
% (7 5
^75 (& ; 5 DI B
+ ' 7 W 3&
B ' CTC
D 5 5 5 CTED
5 .5 W z3+J '
.5 W ( (
. 9T7
&3 Dg
`3 (
= 7 : 3 K5 J @ (
%
ƒTC D '
= : 3+
3 (6 / K 2 C ' (X7 M U, %< J (
= 3 / B (X7 M U,
( K 37 5 = 5
= 5/F ' (X7 M U, %& '( a ) 5 V5 ‘V D 5 = 3 7 = .
7 5 . :-XC 5 2 (7 D< U ; 5 „ . DR(`
% 7 3 5 =5 C %I3& 9 5' Q
- '( E
: 25 C /5 = 3 7 b+. ' K 2
3 EH K5(0. ;
%
% / 2 L ; 5 D U&Z D
DX = . 02 / 2 X E %& '( +J5 :
7 .5 T z .
7 K N+.
d 3 (7
