-
4 56
"7 8 ( 89 :; "<
) :
9 / 3 / –88 :
27 / 7 / 88 (
= : -? .) @ # A B C 89 ( ) # DE) 7 89 F( % 59
( G6 5 HI) -? .) 89 5( = J &# % 95K L " = ME N J
C 89 ( % A B L 5(
5( 8"O P 6 9
89 # Q5R L DE)
# ) 5( ( "&' 6 9 M = = L " P SB 9T P
) -? .
N 5U( ME N F( % 59
V
% 6 L @ :
E ME
E L W"K
% 59
% 59 -? .)
"&' 6 9
* 02818371606 : Email: [email protected]
! "# $ % "&'! (')*
"
+, +! - %+, "# ./* 0 1 % %2
"& 3*0 4 5.6 "7 1 -38 $ /* 3*
3 7 $9 -38 9 0 (')* %.:&
.
<+=7 +).)>
.!9 "? * ! @ 1 (')* 1 3A7 $ % "! .! BC = %.:& D.E=
0 ('+)* "! 8
(')* " 0F2 -38 9 "? * %G H ! 1
! . + ! -3 I' J )& 4 K8& 4 7
% "! .! BC = , - ! 2 L ! 4 7 H +! 0 M! N (')* 1 3A7 $
O +! - 7 %.PQ BC = 4 %7 "E& ? N 0 $ %R
4+ +7 $ +! 2 H %+7
S=7 3 7 TL !
"
- 3 3)* 0 "! %7 7 H%K*
+
"
+7 U +7%&
"+! .! BC += %.:+&
$ % "? M R
%2 "& V
! 8& H%K* ( N N W.* 7 +V D+.E= H %7
& B %K* 4.7 7X
W 1 %Y7 BC = 4 D.E= 7 $9 Z ! %7 [Y! 0 .
. :
!" # $%%&# '()
- 7 "\ BC = J0
R0 W]& - 3 ! H 0 BC += 4 "V%7
^
H%.:& "V%7
$9 %G " 0% 0 "_V @
"& "J A H%.:&
38*
. 0 "+! %7 +7 &
- 3 4 3)*
%2 "& V .
. 1 . +
L = D.E= $ %`a & "V%7 J0
388, "& - a ! H 0 - 3 1 .
1 $03EV 47
* EMR 4. :\
"& , ! "* %`a &
$9 $ G/.2 1 %, ( :=& D.E= b * 4 $ &
. H0
"& $ .7 "\ BC = D.E= 7 38,
. , H T %+ @+ 3+8* & T +J0 @+
» H%+M? L +#
"A.d#
«
%M? ! J0
03> TD:* ! 1 fC MA&
120
"+M* 10 +g TL ! + & 0 3+8,
"+& J0 .d ? hAi 0 B 6 X.* L = 3+ 7
) T$03+EV 1375 : 25
.(
aG7 L0 D:+* H0 +
"& %7 "* :, - %, j WR ] 7 "8.&1%! , 3*%.
$ `+! %] , "& G8 0 3*
ka> V "8./* %=l " 3*1 .d ? 0 0%.* " 3& 38 "&
388, . m0 D:+* "+J0 T
"& 3 32 H%] " 3*1 P9 .
+? 86 0 - +! " 3*1 H R * 3 6 0 DMg 0 X+.&9
"& % 4.7 .d ?
%+.
. -%# +V
L 1 +8 + B +.a., H
3+.& 0 +! -3+*1 +
!
! %* 4.7 1 ]*9 7 3g& "7 .
.d ? Tm ! D:* $3.! % 7 &
7 7 f', H
"& - %Y! " & % H # %Y& , ! g8 0
»
- , 1 0 B %
« X+R " + *%!
0% 0 3* H 7 *
"
7 ]*9 H g7 3 3R .d ? 7 %G
"& B 36 38!
.
3J * 9 4
" 3+*1 " ' 0 , T3 T3J 1 H38 % T$03EV 47 38* & X.* "7
"& -3 /& "? M R 0 "! .!
38, . 7 0 E& 4 % %K* H R - 0
7 "* &1 H
$ +8?
AJ _& 3> 0
$3M D& , n& R T V "
"& %6 AJ _& &
! 3) A& n6 0 0 3
7 3 7 E& % , o X+7 38 % @ 1 "pXR $ 8?
%+
+ % %+K*
) T"+7 4 + 1387 : 67 (.
4 aG7
- =* 7 $3M 3 "7 B +i A& +7 +]R & %` d& 0 q'V .E6 @ DM? H
"G :7 0
3+* 03=& * 3 "*3M r. & H0 aG7 .
+_)* fC +MA&
%+ "d.+ %! H
"&
> - p 0 ! 8& DM? 7 6 %G q'V .E6 , ! "& G8 $9 0 3!
D 0 :.*
*3M , 38 "& %G q'V -0% 7 V H R -0% 4 ]*
"
HX+ + 2 %G
388, "&
. b Mg&
T
4 , H%
"+& W.+!% %/+7 + 1 "7 + M* 3+8,
H + 0 %G*
$3M L'=Mi 0 L T3 T3J 1 "&0 3&
!
)
$ M (.
%K*
»
$ 3 X %7 $ Gd\*
«
»
$ Gd\* I % «
"& X.*
H 0 B %K* J 6 $
B l
%, H387 .
- 2 %K* 1 "! .! B 7')* 8s, 0 -% R A& R
8 T" .J Z
7 R 6 .J 0 3A ! , ! - !% $ Gd\* 7 3 3R $ Gd\* 1 ! @ " R H
- h, 1 t V .M, > %M ! H %7
"7 $ . Y! ]8 * .& 4 m %& 0 3*
0 m *
- 7 B 36 > H %7 -1 d& %.73 7 $ Gd\* 4 $ /*
3*
) - 1 .)*
: 1379 : 124 (.
-v 0 X.* (')* 03.&%
7%g Z ! %7 $ 8 %7 4 %, , ! H
"V%7 (')*
`7
"&
%7 . (')* "& M , 7 3) A& H0
& `> D& E>%& ! 1 H%dR d? 7 m `=&
* .&
T 0 7 38 V (')* $ 2 03.&% m g* %! 0 0 38 & `>
) T $ 8 %7 1382 : 54 (.
!" # $
%& ' #( # # " ) &
* + , -
.&
+
/ .
& 12" 3 44! 5&+ # &6 + " + 72 4 "
89 : $
) & &*" : & 8!" 3 & 724 +;
724
+ ; < ==
&" 3 >
= &+ 724
? 4 =$ 3 @ 724 : A+ !" 4BA
: 3 &
1:
$
+ +24 2 .
)
#3 : + 1363 : 78
.(
+
K $ #L L M <N + O "
3 P
1:
$ QR
+ 724 . $
K .
&*" ; 3 & 724 !" . 9 4BA +;
+ $ 5 .
&
a 3 7 %K* 4 3)*
"7 1 ('+)* 1 3A7 $ % "! .! m K* BC = 3*0
! %7
& B %K* Z 7X
fC0 T
* &1 B3&
"
"*C #
% T
"& %7 D:* ! 03> D6 3>
%+.
^
f .* P T .A6 0
"* +\M B + %K* 4+ +7 X+.* + ! "# $ % "\ 3*0 0
w0 0 3*
I1
"+& W/+N 7 $ % A& R B 6 7 1 8 (')* H
+` _7 +V
%GJ l H A %7 3.,Q 7 *
I1 + 3 %# A& R %S, 4.7 1 8 (')* H
! - 7 A 4.M Z ! %7 W]* J0 H10%.2 $9 * M* , .
- 2 . ./
- 2 D& ` %K* 1 H% 2 %.PQ 7 $ %`a & 1 %G H
"* % %.:& T" %
"+! .! H +
1 "_V n& R "? M R +A& R +7 " 8! A& R
"+& $ 3+& H 0 "E& +` " +GJ 0 3+8*
"+& w%+_& H%/+7 n& R M H %7 "_V @ 0 $ :` & -3*0%/.2 +M 3+*3)A& 0 3*1 +!
n& R H%dR B l 7
$9 (%x , H%.:&
&
"+& $ 0 ! - %, "# %.:
0 38+ 7
3> 0 "? M R 0 "! .! L3& 7 n& R M X.* ]*
3+8 V +! "+7%x L3+& $ +M ,
3.!
98) (So, 1990:
. + %K* 4 7 $'p 6 EMR 1 W., 0 D.& 0 %:8Y! 0 8, 8!
"& %l A& $ 0 38 7
. m +g* "J 4.* 6 7 "7 . ! H %7 8, V , H0 ,038,
%, y\/& D& ` %.! 1 E>%& ! T )
, "E> %&
4+ z D+& ` 1 E>%& ! 7
38 : 5d_8& $ :*
.(
. % 4 7 T
8,
» H .87 $ * 6 «
%+, ni0 $ :* %A& D& ` H %7 .
7
%G B d?
T
%/7 %` 1%#
» 7
"2 #
"& B0 a & H%K* .Ai0 ! 1 "2 38,
:
"8
" dP "ME? 0 "? X * @ X. & T"E.\
«.
E>%& ! 4 - . ! %7 -0'?
"+2 H
"+2
: X.* D> %& $9 7 5d_8& "? M R WK* b * ! %A& TH%` .J A .
%P{+& D& ? 8,
"& 03=& .:7 %..| }8 9 %7
"& "* % $ 7 ]R @ ^ 382
~%+ 0 % 2
"&
- . 7 L > H%/7 n& R D, , %, A& R H
x H 20 " A8l H
"7%
38 : +,
"& 0 V 8 . -38 9 7 $ D` $ :* B 36 8, 4`M& D6 3> 7 V H
"+&
) %,
T 1 , 1386 : 99
.(
%:8Y! B%7% / 3* 4 $ 0%/.2 1 %G "`
) 1903 + 1830 (
! . 1 - a +! +7 H0
: 1 H GJ
"+& W:+.* @+ +A& R T"! 8
3+ H +, 3+
H +! m0 3+&
.
(Spenser, 1969,p33)
.
- 3 ]*
& , $ 2 - 3 EMR 1 $ %`a & 1 H .:7 H
$9 ,
"+& -3+ x $ 8? 7 "! %`& L %d.J +
T
"+&
%+`a 4+ +& "+ ' $ +
fukuyama, 2006;15) :*
( ,%> 3*3) A& , J0
n& R 0
"+# (%+x , H%.:&
( 8 R ! - %,
! H%/7 n& R M H %7 m =& H3*0 0 / %7 D7 6%.x 0 % 2 * .
- %, I' $ %`a & "V%7 T 7 - G* b * 4 H ! (')* ,%> 3*0 3*
388, D.E= $ % "&'!
0
$ 3& 7 " 8! A& R 1 ,%> H%K* ( N ]N Z ! %7
"\ 3*0 4 H %7 $ 0 $ % "&'! (')* 0 3*1 %Y7 n 60 D.E= 7
A& R $3 " %? ?%! , 38& 87 $ 0 .) "8.MV m & " > 0 - %, -3./\7 ?%! $ % C `! 0 $ 3& & `> @ H ! 7 3*0 0 - %, n %:
!
T$ g>) 1380 : 57
.(
.A6 0 &
- 3 4 7 X.* $ % "\ H 3* q d_*
0
%.:+& $ %+ A& R
3* %6 $3 "7%x H%.:& ,%> H 8A& 7 $ .! X.* 3&
.
%+, "+# (%+x , "
&%! TW:.* &0 TH X7 .*')? 7 T ]*
+! - +V 3* .2 C `! "! %`& 0 H
%.:+& 0 +! - +7 B0 +a & "+ + ! "# "&'! (')* ,%> , "J >
$ % A!
38N % 0 +.*')? + 0 "+! %`& 1 b + $ +•M €% /+& - R0 "V%7
=E &
& 3., w%+_& "+8 }+8 % @+ $0 <+> d& 4+ `8 7 R 7
"&
& " H% R B l 7 1 ! B0 a
38, "& L d* (%x 1 .
- 3
"1 # – +& V 7 • \& 0 "J A H3*0 $9 $ ))=& 1 "V%7 Tn& R BC = D.E=
W :.! %K* 1 K8& 4 7 0 :* "E& ` " ]R -%]7
- %7 3*
. 3+ 7 , %K* 4
m E? 0 "! 8 : 1 l%?
w%_& "7%g
"! .! m E? 0 "? M R m E? ‚ 3 7 3
3 % , 7 X.* J0 0 A& R D.E= X.*
.
W :.! $ •M n& R T- 3 4
@.* "`.* `& H T
? Mg&
! ƒ XR 1 H
"& W :.! L A R & ƒ XR 4.7 "G8 M 0 R0 D7 ) & „7 0 ]*9 4.7 ,
) TL0 2 03* MJ9 1377
: 54
.(
T"! .! m K* EMR 1 W :.! % …3 4 % M]& T %K* 4 Z ! %7
"& V %M ! 0 m0 3 ka>
"& L M? -F 0 , ]N K8& 4 7 , 3 7 38,
:\*
4.
, 4.&0 0 ! A& R " 1 m K* ka> n6 0 , "? M R "G :dM 0 m g:* ka> $9 F 0
"& ?1 8& D> - , 3 7
E.! 7
"& m g* "6 )> m K* "8A g8
%.
. , 4.& !
"& m g* "! .! m K* 0 ]* E.! 7 , ! … 3 7 D.* -F 0 -F 0 , 4.& ]N 0
t)* "> %# E.!0 7 , ! 3 3R 0 %.| & „ % 7 H 1 ! 0 q d_*
m g* 3 3R H
"&
%.
. , -F 0
"! ! $ * 6 0 Hv J p3 1 - a ! 7 J0 q * ]N H
$ * 6 J 6 " 1 m K* 0 m g* & `> 0 "! %`& %7 - G ! T"p †6 - G !
! .?0%/& -388, 4.&Q Hv J p3 0 "! !
"! . ( :=& "! .! BC = H 87 % 1 0
"&
"& %M ! R & ni0 7 0 K* , H # 7 3/\7
m 0 A& R "6 )> 0 H g8
& E.!0 H ]* ? Mg& 4.8•M 5)=
" 1 m K* 4 V ! 38 7 "&
) TB `.N 1378 : 53
.(
.! W :++.!
++!
++! "R ++V 0 "++EV „.++=& 0 H "
.
%++ 1 D& ++ "++EV „.++=&
W :.!
m 7 H H ) ? T"G8 % T" V 8 )
4 (
! "6 )> TH 6 T .
=&
X+.* "R +V „.
W :.! D&
"& "
4.7 "! .! m K* %.K* ^3* %6 1%& 1 ‡ V , m +K* T"EEMJ
4.7 H 6
4.7 "6 )> m K* T"EEMJ 4.+7 m +K* T"EEMJ
"+G8 % "+EEMJ W :+.!
"+! .! H +
H 0 0
"R0%V 0 "
.
&
_ TB dJ
! V w%_& „.=& , " / 0
"+&
1 +!
» H 0 0 «
! 2 0
"& $ 37 "! .! m K* , "
T3
»
"& -3.& * "R0%V .
0 0 H +V
t\7 0 H
» i ) « 0
» M>
«
‡ +V DV „.=& 1 ! 4`M& 0 % 0 38 :
3*%.G7 BQ/*
.
! 2 7 W :.! H
»
„V ( \ * 0 W.M Tm 36 D` 7 H 0 0
"& 10%7 "/&
3+8, . +,
$9
» V1 7 «
"& @73.
38& * .
! 2 B %.PQ 0 ‚ * 1 5 %# 4 1 "! .! W :.!
H +
"& nE_& V .A6 0 0 V $ .& … ` TW :.! 0
"& %2 A& R H q +d_* +7 0 38,
"& 4.M† V B .> m0 3 T ]*9 7 V 38,
)
$ M
.(
$9 "M :.! D.E= … A & Dl „.+=& 1 - 0 H /+ +•* 8N , !
) + "+EV
"R V (
"+R0%V 0 /+* W.+K8 "+R0%V 0 H 0 0 "+)_8& „+7 0 E.!0 7 +7 +6 +
"&%7 W :.! $0 7 "a8& V1 7 T38 d* " G\! 2 L +A m3? 0 h? †& / 0 %
"& W :.! " 20% R & T"R0%V 0 H 0 0 $ .&
.
4 %7 87 T W :.!
"& I' +& +, g*9 1 & 388, ka> R & L A & ni0 388,
B dP "7 D& ? %_V ~%A& - M .Ai0 4 0 D+V 1 L +A -3+8*1 W %+7 0 -3+88,
W :.! 4 T ! W :.! ‡ V
"& %6 "* % hE \& j_! ~%A&
"+V%7 , 3*%.
"* % 4 1
%..|
"
"M* R0 7 W :.! 4./.2 L A W]&
%+G "+V%7 & 09
"* % 4 1
"& I' W :.! , - %..| W :.! R & .Ai0 T +7 V 38,
"* % 4 J A 0 3 5.d_ 4 .87 H
"
09 R 7 3 3R
)
$ M (.
4 %7 87 T n& R L = 3*0 J0
8? 7
"+Ed6 "J A .Ai0 1 L = TW :.! @ $
"& 3 3R "J A .Ai0 7
"& 3R & "* % 4 •*9 3 7
"+ 1 m +K* L =
"& W :.! „.=& L = A& R 3 7
.
&
L A 4 9 `8 &
"& • V H ! 0 M! H %M :& H O%.V 38 7
X* ! 2 4 ! 3) A&
"& X.* -3*0 t.2 ,%> "? * H L A W :+.! %+ 1 38 7
H %7 t X+ 0 " 3* 1 ! . %ˆ t X 7 dg& 3 3R „ % 7 H 1 ! 0 q d_*
"& V H %, , % %P &
38 7 . 4 %7 87 T E>%& L A 3 3R E>%&
%/.2 H +7 d:+* %
n6 0 0 ! 4./.2 E>%& L A 3+ 3R L +A .*')? ) H ! 7 ,%> "? *
"& -3 /&
) T 1 , 4./.2 : 44
.(
# 2 % !" # 3
"+8..d B 36 7 R 7 +! 8&
"M :+.! - 3+ %+
T
"+& I'+ +&
+ W.+8,
7 $ %+ "+! .! BC += "! %7 7 - 3 4 ( N ]N W 1 %+Y7 ('+)* 1 3+A
.
%+
W :.! %K* Z ! %7 4.+7 $1 + & " .Ai0 "J A .Ai0
H 0 0
"+R0%V 0 + H +
"& fC l W.8, 8A& ]*9 $3 - 09%7 $ X.& 0 i ) 0 W :.!
('+)* 1 3+A7 $ 0 $
L A $ 0 7 L A m3? 0
R " 1 m K* 4.7 tJ N 1 " * "+_.=& B %+..| 0 +A&
:*
.
"+& + %K* 4+ ( N ]N t 0F2 4 "El L ! 7 ! 2 ` # 7 4+ $ +
L A ka> H %7 I' (')* 1 3A7 $ % BC = H ! 0 M! , %, B dP .i%
4.7 I1 7 "&'! H I' -3M? 0 ! - 7 %.| & "_.=&
+ L +! "+! "#
%+7
+! -3 X,%M & tJ N 4 "#
. +g +7 "&'+! ('+)*
I1 + d& 3+ 3R H
%+7 "+8
I1 4 %, I' "&'! H I1
3+? 6 0 "6 )> m K* "8A g8 J 6
"? M R t)* 0 ]* E.!0 7 0 4+ +& 3/+\7 +Ed H m K* 0 " & `> m K* "8A
m 36 L A & * D& ? H / ~%A& - M -388,
0 +! - +7 W :.! $0%.7 0 $0 1
- %, I' L ! "! "# (')* $ %d fC0 + 3+*
T -3+88, L +A & +* D+& ? 4+
f .* P 0 388, ]&
T 4.7 q d_* L d6 D7 6 H ] 1 ! g 7 I1
- t X „.=& 0 H
A 0 L 38 $ & ! 3 3R H .
a 3 7 U d 4 :
L ! $ 0 1 3A7 H
('+)* +.J0 4.+J0 %) +! +7
J0 -0% ( E_&
" ) H %G&'! H L !
61
"+&
$ + :+\*
L +A - 0 4.
$9 , %, 7%g "&'! H ]MR
"&
"7')* m'! $ M a $ 0 $ 3.& * " )
.
L !
L0 H
60
"R0%V 0 0 0 T 7 0 W :.! H
0 B +K * %+G B +d?
E` B K * 4 7 W :.! ! 2
"
L A &
.
$ %+=7 1 7 % 1 L +! H +
+.J0 H +
g*9 1 T"G8 % 0 "? M R T"! .! l%? "d `& J0 q a 0 "&'! H ]MR %) ! 5)= "! .! W :.! 1 A& R %S, B K * , I1
7 "&'! H .
4+ +7 +! 2
I% : 0 $ %, "&'! H %7 I' X.* "! .! W :.! T i ) I1
+ m'+! m +`> 0
l%? "& M T"! .! H
T"? M R 4+ +, - %, L d* /, "p †6 0 "G8 % TH 6
M> ! .!
/\7 H
"
4.+7 "J +A n+6 0 0 + L d*3+7 X.* m %& /6 1 n.!0
- 09%7 0 i ) 7 "! .! W :.! ]*9 $3
"& W/N V .
„! 0 1 ‚ 3 7 T &
60 4 -38*1 W %7 "R V 0 "EV %l 8? 4 % B 6 3
"& L A L ! 4 0 W. 7 7 DV :` 1
R +G8 % "? +M R H 3+& .2 +7
"
T
"V%7 z \ T"J ? I1 &9 0 H1 &9 ! 3 T‡ V 7 B # d t X T"8./*%] I% :
! .!
H3+&9 , * "+V%7 0 "? M R 0 H 6 H +l%? " % 3+& B , `_+l 0 +
/, %7 "EEMJ 4.7 H / 0 "! .!
7
0 H 6 B %..| 3 ‚ 3
3+ 0 "? +M R
+A& R 3 3R "G8 % 5p'? "? M R BC = 4 , - 7 3 3R "? M R /6 "V%7
"& I% : 0
I1 tJ N 7 R & H
"&
I%+G* 0 3./, +
-1 +> 3+ 3R "
I1
"& w%_&
V ! 4.7 L A m3? I% : H %7 8.&1 0 I1
„ % 0 W, > H
"_.=&
"& W % 09 . 0
"& R & "! .! W :.! 1 3 3R H i ) 3 3+ %
) TH1 +
1385 T
‡ 2 : 87
.(
9 $3.! B 36 7 7 , " 3*1 ! $ M a n6 0 1 x9 /, "* g8: "M ‰
- +! 0 - 4.+7 L +A +g 0 $ 0 $9 H +i ) H %7 "! .! W :.! , 7 "\! 2 3 w%_&
%, . 0 H + 6 R & B'`/& n 0 /, H1 !1 7 B 0%i $ •M "E& ? % 1
i ) $ 8A7 T R & "? M R
"+! .! W :+.! 0 +7 w%+_& B3/+7 }8R $ 2 7 W]& "
TH1 +!1 7 +, +7 $9 3+8&1 .* "+! .! W :+.! L +A g 0 i ) 4 7 ! 2 H %7 H 6 A! 0 " 3*1 !
%.:+a +p +7 1 .* K8& 4 H %7 0 3 %6 J0 H
1 3 3R I1
7 "7')* H T
&%! 3* 7 , H%.:a 0 3+8, .R " 3*1 ! 0 H
"7')* 0 - 4.7 p %6 38&1 .* 4 0 1 ! %6%7 " 9 H%
"
1 3 3R I1
0 "&'+! H
V%7 g 0 :` 1 "7')*
H 19 "
/+6 H %+7 %+G H +! 1 "? +M R 0 "+G8 % H
38 †> /, 8=l , 7 H 6 3 3R
.
%G H ! 1 T
+7 "R +V H + 6 B 0 %+& I% : 0 "R V &%! ( R +K8&
‚8/ 38&1 .* /, H1 !1 7 4+ B %+..| "V%7 g 0 "R V ! .! l%? "p 1
l%?
7 . +7 0 -3+88, L +A & * D& ? 4 %7 $3&9 5p H %7 "! .! m K* n6 0 +K8&
W:.* `& 1 - a ! 7 V H )7 ka>
W :.! $0 H V +! T"! ! $ * 6
H -3+.•.2 0 %+
"& w%_& % , 38,
^
* M a
"
„p % 7 3* 7 D` 3 3R 1 +! +V 3+ 3R
3+8&1 .* %+& 4+ +, 3+8, H%+.G.2 3+ 3R "J +A D`+ V %K* & … 3 0 38, +, +7 3+ 3R H V +! BC = 7 ! 8 & 3 3R " 1 H GJ H %6%7 0 "GN Y`
" 3*1 +! $ M a w%# 7 m K* n6 0 0
%+7 $3+&9 5p + 4M+i %+, I'+ H + 6 A+!
$ %=7 H 3 3R "J A .Ai0 R &
3+ $ & ! .
4M+i " 3*1 +! $ 0 $ +M a
t)* L = g 0 "M 36 H V ! w'l D`+ 3 + +& T +
H +GJ 5+.MA H%+.
"+& +A& R " 1
%.:+a "? +* 0 % /+.7 H 1 +! 3+ 3R .A+i0 +7 +, W.+ 7
* % .*
1 % I1 6 $ 0 "7')* H
"+& %.:+a 4 , Dd H %+7 +8.&1 :+*
38, .]& /, H 6 A!
)
$ M
.(
m0 3 %7 38N% $ 0 4 I1
"& 3.,Q "7')* H H1 +!1 7 %+7 3+.,Q +7 & 3
"7 %V
V !% 1 ) 0 L | 0 H 6 .Ai0 d]7 T}8R 0
/+, H + 6 H
7 H † g
+ "+! .! 0 @ v J p3+ H † 1 4 % El 0 "G8 % 0 "? M R % 1
t8 4.8•M 0 (')* L0 0 a "R V ! .! l%? "p 1
"
"Ed6 $ 0 7 W]&
L A .Ai0 0
D` 3 3R t\7 .
L +A 0 W+K* -3+8*1 W %7 D& ? ! 8& „ % 0 3 3R $ 0 , g*9 1 &
X+.*
"& D` ‚ 3 7 $ &XM 3*%.
. tJ +N 7 3 3R "J A .Ai0 4 hE \& D& ? ‚ 3 7
3*3./, . 3 -3./, tJ N 7 DV 0%.* b * ! H ! 1 L A 4 .
+, "p 0%.* :` 1
1 $3 0 x3x
I1
$ & 9 1 (')* , 3* 7 3) A& 0 (')* H
"7')* H
0 J 3? T4.&0%=& 1 b T" : 1 - ! $ •M V "&'!
8A& T" V -1 d& 0 "p %
%+G H +! 1 0 3+* 7 ('+)* L +l +7 /+ 1 7 +! V 0 +! -3 0 d` ! 7 i ) 3+* 7 -3+ ) " 3*1 ! $ 0 , 3 3R H 0%.* H ! 1 , 7 "
w%+_&
"&
3 0 4 % 1 ƒ +) 0 "J +? I1 &9 3 TH1 &9 ! 3 T$ R .AMR 3 $
l%? $ *1 t)*
1 - a +! +7 , H 6 3 3R B )d# 0 7 t X "? M R H
l%
* "V%7 0 }8R 1 3A7 0 }8R $ 0 H 3+* 7 + % D`+ "+ J0 H +
1
EMR -0%
, 3* 7 "
i ) 3 3R "
T"+! .! B 3+6 , /+& H +i ) $ +•M
H 19 0 "p % $ * 6 T"? M R .8& t X
"& w%_& H 6 0 "? M R H +, 3* %,
& "V%7 D.J37 "! .! W :.!
=
! .! 0 H V ! B 0 7 "p G\! 2 7 6 V $',
d* ]*9 . T 0%.* 4.& ! 0 -
.! 1 , 3* 7 "aE \& H
! H D 3+A 7%+i H + 6
3* 7 R & ni0 %..| ! V -38, %2 D` 7 0 - V .
- 4.+7 L A m3? f 3g& X.* „p % 4 - +! 0 +
W %+7 W :+.! H + 1
4+ +,
"+V%7 "+ > 0 3 3/+ "* g8:+ "M+ H +69 H +]MR +! m0 - 0 .Ai0
"& 9 * /, "! .! H
"& W :.! L A m3? "? * 1 $ /* , 3 R &
.
W]& B 7 \ * W:.* `& 0 m K* ]MR V ! L A m3? 4 7 E7 )& H %7 X7 4 %
4 , 7
7 X.* 7
"& G8 W a B 7 \ * 0 3&9 "! .! W :.! @M, B >'l $ M a ,
! 4 3 % 5 & n6 0 3 w%_&
J A f 3g& - 09 % %G 3` 8, 0%.*
"
3+ 3R
38, g "! .! W :.! H %7 .
n6 0 "! ! $ * 6 . %ˆ 1 - a ! 0 "! ! $ * 6 $ %, 8 ]* A 7 "M V H 69 L l "&%GJ & :` 1
%
"*
$ & 9 1 $3 0 x3x , 7 0 38 + (')* H
1 H 0%.* ( R <? 7 %G H ! "? M R 3 3R
$ * +6 +! V +, 7
% + +.8& 0 "
3* 7 "! .! , /& 0 "? M R .
%G H ! 1 T
3+ 3R $ M a 4 - +
1 - +V 0 H +
! .!
0 %, ( R % ]7 .Ai0 3.& 7 X.* $ 0 H 6 H I1
$ * +6 H
"! ! 0 * "dJ 6
$ * +6 1 0 w%+_& $ 3+& "* 71 7 T"+p %
0 4+ 4.+7 " + 9 TH 19
5.MA 7 %, I' 0 %7 m * B 6 7 "* :* & %, 0 &%> 0 q )> 1 b 0 "! %, &
4 I1 q +a X.* %& 4 , 09 R 7 "? M R q 0 0 "E& B3>0 "? * 3 3R H
J A 0
"
R 7 3 3R 09
)
$ M : 128 (.
DM? "M V
! .!
+! .! l%? 0 & J0 "R V H H +
%..| X.* H 6
"
%, L d* €3* .:7 .
0 "+G8 % +l%? %..| 4 % /.7 &
7 "? M R
^ l%? 4 H 19 0 "*3& H ]* 0 B ? d_&
% 0 "? +M R H + "+G8
I% : .
4 %7 +87 0 7 "M V $ 3 %# …' p 1 "/\7 H i ) & 4 , T
t+\7 0 ‚ 3+ 7
%G
! .! 4 1 3g& 0 -3 - V 0
"+& w%+_& W :.! 1 V H i ) 3+* %,
.
h.A†+ 0 :+& $ %+G* 1 8 "d & 0 "7')* H 0%.*
+ I1 0 3+* 7 "+8 %p A+ 0
-
! .! 1 - V%! H 38 H 6 l%? H3R "J = H i ) TD 3A H
.
%G H ! 1 T
3+* 7 .J A 8.&1 3 3R 1 7 H † 4 , t 3* % H 0%.* "V%7
"/ 3* 1 7 "? * ! V I1
3+* 7 ('+)* H A+ 0 .
H +i ) 4+ +? Mg&
:.! f 3g& 3 3R G\! 2 m3? 7 W
W %+ L +A m3+? "? +* H %+7 8.&1 0 R & "
09 . H%. 7 %g8& ` _7 tJ N 0
$ %+=7 0 /+, "+! .! h+E \& H 0%.* 4.7
3 % /, "! .!
.
4 7 B 7 \ * W:.* `& X.* 7
@M, K*
J A 0 3&9 m
"
"/\7 4.7 …' p Z ! %7 3 3R
H 0%.* 1 L l
- 0 %
"&0%=& H 3
! .! 1 ,
$ M a H - V%! 4./.2 H
3* 7 -3 . H3M>
A+ +7 0 "+7')* H 0%.* t\7 T(')* L l 7 / 1 7 A 7 F*
J 3?
- " V J A T3 3R $ M a 7 3 5 & 0 %, ( R \7
"
j_! 3 3R
09 R 7 "! .! W :.!
.
4 - 56 7 % !" # " + 89 4.+7 L +A Z +! %7 W :+.! L +A k+a> $ %+ "+! .! BC += 3*0 % L >
I1 B +l 4+ W.* 37 "! .! m K* %M ! ka> K8& 7 "! .! „.=& 0 W, > H
(0 8 & L A D> %& 4 9 , ! 4 L ! - 7 X.* " ! 0 M! H
"& 9 O3*
$ +
E>%& H3A7 E>%&
%/.2 H +]R m 3+, %/+.2 4 H ! 0 M! O :* Dd6 1 %
O ! - 7 0
O ! - 7 N %K* & $ & 9
"& L ! 4 7 ! 2 H %7 H 0 0 : )& 7 $
"R0%V 0
%+ "+! .! W :.!
$ .7 7 0 - 0 i ) %G
& W :.! 1 7X
4.+8•M 0 +i ) $9 7 W :.! $9 ! 2 0
tJ N %l 8?
V %2 "* &1 n_)& % 1 .
4 - 1 - + + !" # " + 89 5(:%
"& y\/& i ) W :.! H 0 0
"+AMR + 0 H % H i ) D& i ) 4 38,
-1 >
"& 1 .* hE \& H 3* ]*9 D> K * J0 1 $ 3*0%] ,
.
i ) 4 L >%]7 1 %PQ &
I1 , ! W :.! „.=& %7 W, > H I1
W, +> H
"& X.* W :.! „.=& %7 38, %..| "R V 0 "EV D& ? %.PQ = 3*
.
! V 4 &
$ % "&'! (')* 1 3A7
"&
a $ : l%? %
"
! V "& M? "Eg %]K& B 7 \ * m03* % $ •M
"& W.* 37 "E& H
$
:\*
m %& "& M? H i ) 4.
"&'! H =& 7 " & `> g :*
m03* % 7 ,
1 t.7 "&'! H ]MR 98
3*3 $9 " 2%7 ! V m %& 1 3l )
B ?'# & *10 16
0%
4 58 ]R 0 "! ! $ * 6 3A7 E>%& 0 (.
H%.
$9 H W]& EMR 1
4 %
i )
"& "E& W]& H
, :* $
0 3* H $9 7 - % : " 7 \ * m %&
$ /*
, 7 $9 -38 I1
l%? $ * 6 $9 %7 W, > H 0 "? M R "! .! H
% M]& $ 8? 7 H 6
! w%_& (')* 1 3A7 "& M? H i ) 4
) T [email protected] 1380 : 18
.(
%
]R
"? * g , "8 H C ! m %& H ! 7 ,%> "! ! $ * 6 "! .! H%.
$ * 6 $9 H 6 H%. ]R% 0 W.* 37 m'! „7 i ( N N & @. %`& m K*
J 3? 0 "&'! 6 H ! 7 ,%>
A! 0 "? M R
% 0 W.* 37 =& J 3? H
]R I% : 0 "&'! 0 "* :* g H ! 7 ,%> $ * 6 $9 "G8 % H%.
"& B l $9 W.* 37 A& R H1 ! $ :* 0 8A&
H i ) 4 % M]& , a $
A! T"? M R J 3? T"8 H C :& %& g W :.! 1 .J0 I% : TH =& J 3?
0 8A&
I1
! - 7 A& R H%_ 0 "&'! H
)
$ % ‡ "! ! $ * 6 7 b R 1358
(
n6 0
"! ! $ * 6 7 m %& HC 7 HŠ 7 R 7 T
4 I1 m g:* , - 7 %. % H
R 7 t\7 L A "El D& ? 0 - D` (')* 1 x9 "? M R
! - 7 A&
. 7
"El 4, ! "&'! 8A& 0 H 19 0 L') ! T"? M R J 3? H%]_& ! -3.)?
! "&'! (')*
.
"&'! (')* , 3*3) A& $ / T
7')*
"
0 ! - 7 % 7 % =8&
* H 6 0 "! .! T- 7 "&'! 0 "d & , L > $ M Tm'! 3l (')* 38* M X.
"&
… ` 0 "? M R B †.Ad m3? T J 3? T" 19 0 %> "8A ^3 7 4 & " )d# H
%6 "&'! B M.EA
) TH%]_&
1362 : 43 (.
n6 0 T 4 I1 + ‚ 3+ +7 , 7 (')* Hv J p3 1 %PQ &
40 0 50
1 ]*9 0 7 % D` $ ME:& $ %`a & / 3*
$ 8A7 $9 W:+ D+7 )& H . +*% J9
H +
& K* 0 3* %, b R &
"
, H 6 H H%. ]R -1 >
+* 0 +7 W:.J .! ! *
&%!
+* "+G8 % %+K* 1 0 H + ` +* 0 7 "7%x "! %`& * "! .! %K* 1 0 H X. ! 3g f'& , 0
" 8!
* 0 7 V ! w%_& % 3g
38
"& M> " GJ 1 0 3+* %,
$9 $9%6 , )
_!0 &
( +, L +A 4+ +7 $3.+! n6 0 7 -3.& * L A & H A& R
"&
"* :+* & %, 0 8A& 0 H 19 T"? M R J 3? T A! T"! %`& T4 :*
9 %+7 +, +GJ 4 0 7 $ *9 %K* & 38, nMR %G 3` 8, 3+8
+! V m %+& "\ +
"& ( :=& $ % $ ME:&
3 3+ % [`A8& $ * 6 4 7 m %& H 0 "! ! $ * 6 0
X.* hE \& n# )&
E.! 7 $ .7 m %&
! -3 ^ H _7 ,
"&
J0 , a $ W+]& H +
"& $ /* & 4 %7 .` hE \& n# )& A& R i ) 3
.
4 - 2 - 5(:% ;+ / !" # " + 89
"R0%V "! %7
"& %6 3.,Q & b i & 0 X.* W :.! H 3
: C0 fT
"& $ /*
3
W :.! "R0%V
! 3* i ) 7 D& , L A
^
%`EM? % ` _7
J0
$ 8? 7
"R0%V
"& W %.G7 %K* "\ n_)& % W :.! H a $
"R0%V n_)& % H
"& %7 i ) 1 "/\7 ]8
%
^
%7 3.,Q L0 ` # 7 I1
H 8A& H
%7 3.,Q m0 " \ J 3? 0 (')*
I1 T" 3*1 ! 0 H 6 A! $ •M "
0 "! .! A! %7 3.,Q m !
3.,Q ]* 0 H 6
%7 J 3? A!
=&
3 % .
"R0%V H%G* "/\7 4 DpC
"&
n* & 0 "_.=& „ % 3N% a $
"R0%V D.E) W]& D& ? 1 "` n# )& "V%7 }8R $ •M R &
& ! - 7
"&%7 /, $ % 3& B 36 0 "! .! V ! 7 X.* $9 1 "/\7 /
.
/ 0F2 4Mi $ ))=& 1 "`
"
7 "* 3.&
W]& H ] J0 "! %7 J0
(')* 1 3A7 H
$ M a -3 $ .7 4.& †& Z ! %7 J0
& H 7X
! V %2 T
.
"& $ /* "! %7 4
J0 4 3
• V DpC 7 @ %
T
"& L d* hE \& … 3
@ % ` # 7 3* %,
V %2 (')* $', … 3 1 "/\7 7 ]8 , 3*
"7 R & b i & 4 t\7 $3* & ! 2
m %& " i * 1 ! 8.&1 , - 7 … 3 $9 1 %G
! -3 .
! 3) A& 5)=& 4
- 7 J0 HX. ! d` ! 0 "? M R J 3? $ •M " ? i & H ! & Z38]& J0
! . H 69 J0 0 H 6 A! "* g8: H 69 J0 `.J >
V
"M A!
! - 7 V%7 J0 1 "! .!
.
"& g. * ]* H0
4 , %.
J0 I%G*
).aE 7 38 :* * 0 38 %G* ! @ 0 H3A7 @
"
388, 3.2 ! … 3 4 1 ! 8&
& *%7 $ 3) 0 $ %, DM? "M! & 0 " %&10 $9 E? , d* R M 0 n& R 0 $', HX
G*
$ & 9 0 … 3 Z ! %7 H%
A! & *%7 0 (')*
3 2 0 $1 & H
! - 7
) 4.:>
T- 1 1386
.(
, 3 "& $ /* "! %7 4 J0
3+8N %+ T('+)* 1 3+A7 H
H A+ +.E, %+7
(')*
& 38 3., DM? m )&
V %2 (')* … 3 1 "V%7 7 m 3,%
3+*
… 3+ 0
(')* %G +7 $ % "? M R B )d# "\ ! V ,
- +]* +! 2 "+7
4+ +,
/\7 " i * <? 7 b i &
"
A& R /6 1 W]&
3 % <? 7 0 3 - 0 % 9
+7 +]*
, 3 3R H 3 3* , 1 M>
+! V T + 3+., -3+ I +& % H A+ $ %7 H +
A& R V "\
388, w%_&
.
4 - 3 - 5(:% (/ !" # " + 89
W.M V ! "! %7
"& $ /* /, H1 ! , 3
‚ 3 7 V ! 4
" 3 7 D` 1
-3.•.2 "E` 7
" \ 0 %
! ƒ ) %
. L ! "! ! $ * 6 B %..|
68 g
:+7 47 D> H %7 m K* =E & y.\/ nMg&
+ T
"+! 8 , B %+K* %+7 % /+.7 3+., T
W.M " \ X, %& 0 I% :
%7 I% :+ TH%+.
0
"+! %,
$ /+* %+G +& 0
"&
! %..| V ! H% ˆ D` , 3
.
"& $ /* &9 4.8•M 3
"! 8 , *37 .a., 0 $ % 3& " \ j_!
/+, $ % 3&
(')* 1 3A7 H ]J ! X.*
) 0
%K* 1 N "a., B %..|
! -3 W]&
.
%& 4
4.7 L A 0 "G8 M 8.&1 3* "&
"R0%V 3*0 H 0 0 +7 W :+.!
$9 H + t X+
0 3
% C 7 j_! "! .! W :.! L A 3 M* K =&
.
%G H ! 1 T
V ! B'`/& 1 "V%7 H
@ ‹ B'`/& / .
+7 +R 7
$ +& 9 `8 3+8, "+& 4.+.A W :+.! H + H 0 0 0 +i ) +, "&'+! ('+)* H +
? Mg&
$ & 9 1 H
& "
"
0 $3+ -X +‹ +7 1 +.* +]*9 ":+.! +. & D.J 7 , 3 7
m ]a&
H1 !
^ U +d 0 $ ME:+& $ 38M/+ 3* %M :+& H1 0 /+ 3* 3+8&1 .* 4+ %+7 87
W.M }8 G8
"& $ 38M/ 3* 7 $ 1 ! T"&'+! + 6 $ +•M " C +)& 3+8* 7 + 3+ 7
0 T =& J 3? A! T "8 H C :& %&
....
388, " .EM?
+]& 38N % - 4 ,
"
" ! , 1 8 & ! -3 %7 0 H1 ! W.M m K* " ! , 4 , R0 1 H
! H3R B'`/& 7 V
! - %, R & %G* n& R 0 B3& 38E7 B M.M
3
<%(
nMR
"& "E, H387 L +A tJ +N 1 %PQ & (')* BC = a $
+7 "+A_)& H +
L A & * %l 8?
"+! .! m +K* 0 "EV 0 "R V D& ? / , ! - 7 -388,
%7 $3&9 5p H %7 L A m3? 4
+! - m +g* h+E \& B & 36 V H )7 ka> 0 .
W.M + ) ]R V ! L = 7 :` 1 B & 36 4
" % 3+& w _+! H1 +!
/, 0
"R0%V q d_* H %7 I' ) %G H ! 1 0 „p % 7 ]*9 $ %, ! 8 &
H +
H 0 0 0 i ) 7 W :.!
$9 H + - +7 +!
.
"+&
+a $ + :
4+ +M €% /+& +R0
$ M a 7 "! .! m K* ka> hE \& H I1
"&'!
"? M R L A ka> H %7 I' 0
W :.!
%.| & "_.=&
! - 7 .
b Mg&
T H 0 0 L A a $ "& Z ! 4 %7
"R0%V 0 V ! T L >
"& ƒ ) 7 W :.! 0 3 7
l%? L A ]R @ H !
- +7 +,%> L +> % C 7 H
! . 3*0 4
"E?
./* 0 1 % Wx
"& "7 \7 3 $
.
"E? ` # 7 H%G* 3A7 @ "V%7 Wx
‚ 3 7 $ 0 H
J0 M+! +7
? * H%G* n& R "
- %, ,%>
C :+& %& 0 H 19 T J 3+? T A+! H i ) 0 3*
0 "+8 H
i ) $ &XM 8A&
, ! "
+J0 +
"+& I'+
0 3+*1 %Y7 +]*9 1 b + +7 3+88,
& *%7 ,%> H M8 $ 8? 7 X.* /, A! H J0
3.,Q ]*9 %7 .
3*0 4 "! %7 T
- % : 3 -3.•.2 0 %
0 :+` 1 "+! .! H V +! $3+ %
%G* n& R )
"R0%V % /.7 H H 0 0 7 q d_* K8& 7 W :.! H
"
- 7 W+
+,
.A& R 1 H% 2 %.PQ 7 I1
+i ) T A& R %7 W, > H
"+! .! W :+.! 1 n& +R "
! .
$ /* D& ? 4
"E& +` 0 -3*0%/.2 "J A 0 "! .! m K* "J A A! -38
"&
3 7 .
7
"& %K*
! 3*0 4 3
m0 3 B l
$1 & 0 n& R " GJ
%d /+, $',
R & H D.:* 2 1 - a ! 0 0 "A.+ "+*')? 0 H +] R m'!
0 +K =&
5+.MA
m %&
"8 H C ! 7
L * , 0 B 7 \ * W:.* `& 1 ! %>
"& m %& , /& H
"7 +\7 3*
m K*
m K* @ M! 7 D& ` & "! .!
"*')? 0 H V ! %K* 1 %
" 1 %K* 1 % m0 3+
0 3/\7
* & B 36
$9 L A m3? 1 d? H %7 L A 7 $3.! 0
m 0 +7 "+_.=&
%.| &
09 W % .
= >
?/@ + :
. A :
1 . 3* MJ9 D %7 -
* & B%7 0 L0 2 m ]G8.7 )
1377 ( T ( = W=
[R) 5( L 5( L5\
+i%.E? MR% T
$ %] T .#
-
" J0 % 3& I1 &9 X,%&
.
2 . T$ 1 7 H3]&
) 1363 ( T
@5 % 59 ME T
T $ %]
% K& %/*
.
3 . 7 4 %, $ 8 % )
1382 ( T
ME W= # [7 @
T"P'P 4:=& T ( 1 %/* $ %]
.
4 . i 3M=& @.R )
1380 ( T E ME % "&/6 56:
« - M+ t.+2 TL0 L +! T"&'+! (')* "/ 0F2 & 8E
]7 .
5 .
…1 R 3J * 9 "7 4 )
1387 ( T ( 89 ) HT 9:6
"* !%J 9 4.:> 3M=& MR% T -
%.d, %.&
.
6 . B `.N 3J *0 ) 1378 (:
95\
'9 L P
L
# i%.E? 0 " X7 3.>0 MR%
! "G8 % :!{& T$ %] T . .
7 . 3M=& T- 1 4.:>
) 1386
% "&/6( 5( ]@ L P P 7
% 5^9 E^ L W"K ME N F( L
%/+* T$ %+] T
8! X,%&
.
8 . 3.A! $ g>
) 1380 ( L N ( P # ) ; P # N T :
5WU 89 % # 5 $ %] T
:
* w%#
.
9 . J 3d? $03EV 4M>%
) 1375 ( T
% < 8(
- H 7 8 4 0%2 3M=& MR%
-
$ %]
"G8 % 0 "ME? B / * ,% T
10 .
& *10 16- E_
4 0%
58 .
11 .
".= H1 ) 1385 ( T ME N F( % 59 "&K -? .) ‡0%? %/* T$ %] T
.
12 .
$ % ‡ "! ! $ * 6 1359
.
13 . [.p J 1 ,
%aJ9 ) 1386 (.
F K % 6 :( 9 6 N
# R% T
"ME? %/* T$ %] T"P'P 4:=& M .
14 .
"† %& H%]_&
) 1362 (
E ME % 5 B
$ %] T : 3l .
15 . 3M> T- 1 .)*
) 1379 (
# F K 5( L T M! T$ %] T
.
.
; / :
1. Fukuyama Francis,(2006)The end of history and the last man, published byFree press.
2. So. Alvin.y (1990)Social change and Development. SAGE Publication.Inc.
3. SomervellD. (1986): Astudy of History, vol.I-V (New york: Oxford press).
4. Spenser, Herbert, (1969) Principles of sociology, ed.Stanislav Andreski (London:
Macmiian.
