• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

PDF ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ - jpq.ut.ac.ir

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2023

Membagikan "PDF ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ - jpq.ut.ac.ir"

Copied!
18
0
0

Teks penuh

(1)

!

2 345 6 7 "8 9 : ;: <3=> <

) :

24 / 4 / 88 :

31 / 5 / 88 (

? : : AB C 2D ,5 E: 7 "8 9 : ;: < C &3F E: 9&35 G4 H & > D H

9& I J 6& I K 3: 8 9& . L C I J

M + " " 5 : 2 < 3: H 9& 2 N 3 N G " 5 H 3 > 3? C &3F O

& :

A5 :

> P 7" &3F 2 Q&3R S 6& I M P G4 3: O =:

2 = 9& H <3F 2 = I J

& 36 " TN 5 %& 5

%

> U 3V=

. 8 9&

= + &3F =:

& 36EP "I H 7 "8 9 : ;:

8 3A 8

%

XY N &

Z =& 4 3A 2O> 3J < C

: ;: 6 H N &

2 : 7 "8 9

& I < &3F

[ J

I J

# 3:

. V:

= 9& % <3 N = K

2 :

#

\: C &3F 9& 2 >

<

&% 5 H " 5 GC KV: P 7 ,5

3 N G " 5 ]& > < = I I J

& : I J

"5 34: 2D H

3 6:

.

< > 2 N ^ :

5

& 36EP I J 7 ,5 &%

& 36EP _ B 3 ` % 8 3A 8

H

< 6

: 66409595 [email protected]

Email:

" " #

$% & '( ')

* + ,'& - .& / "#

:

"

#$ % # &'( # ) * + ) ,+ -

"

. ) / 38 . 01 / 2 2 3 * /

" 87 56 & ) 7 8 * 9%: ;<%&

)

= 5>

#) =&?

*)< @< *

"

. ) / 38 . 01 / 4 2 3 A / 87

"B 2 CD ,' &' 2<%E* ) F< G$H IJ' K+7

"

. ) / 40 . 051 /

1 L* / 89 .

(2)

! ! "#

!

$% ! ! & ' () * +

* , + (

- . / ! ! 0 % % . 1 ( +

. 3

'

0- $% ! ! * () ! ! 4 5 67 ! +8

0(9

# ! ! 0 % % . 1

. :;

< = > '

? @ A( . 9

##%

"8 0 +B (! <

* C ! (D= ! ! :/ + % ,8 5 (5>

. + '

E F

.G ! 7

G % ! ! "#

9/ HI7 < < 98 & % ,8 ! 0 !

. ( +

< 9+! / 0 7 J 6K 9

5 ;

? 6K '? "

(! < ! ! * L 9/ HI7 M 0

N 5 (! < 98 (

(8 9

4 % ?(! 6K

4< !

! ! ! % ,8 + / "# 5

(8 .

4 % ! 0

O(1

! ! (8 G9+ ) 9

=

! ! 4 % . 1

= , . 6K ? (; L

4

; ( ! !

< ? = = >

"+ G+

+ / < O (

/ P 5 0 < 4 = 4

.

5 ; QI & ' .G

N

! . + '

K! 98 E 0 < = 5+

R % :; 0 % +# ( ? S( '

"9 (8 .

E & 0 9! ! , & , R

! ! ! < F 9 .G/ 0- , +B

. :;

0(+= = ! 8I .G

E T9 ( ,C

+ ' ! ! 9/

* ; ! 9/ % * (E

) 4 < D 1384 : 73

.(

O(1 4 5 5 ; ,8 5 (5>

' ! ! %

9,

0 98 ] ! +8 D I = = . += (

( ! ! : + (8

^

G 98 9D

= !

' < _ (D= ! ! ( ( * C 0 + ( 0 < N

(3)

(8 ( 0- 9 9 ! = >

Schweller 1997:30)

.(

( ` K

' 0 < N .G < , 9+% ( = ! * C

/ ` 4 % ' ++= R K ? = ! ! a

. #7 3 ` ) ( ( :A bCc

+=

. dc " +B

5D :/ + ?(GC (

=

! ! 0-

= <

. 5 * "&

'

F

! ! :/ + 3#c

(8 e .

e * ; 3#c :/ +

* ; = ! 79 +=

+= ! ! ,8 :/ + 4 9#% = ! .

9!

'

+ ; 9#% :/ +

" ` ) G ! ! 4

-

Morgenthau 1985:145-148)

.(

; : I7& > _, 5D+= f / 0 %

< (

= +! ) 9 ' (! < 0 ( 4 + :;

I = ! !

! I7& > _, 5D+= 0 (+& 4 G&

. (! <

5 '

( # : + < 4 G ! ! 7/( G -

. 1 M I = 3

%

% 4 .

! 0 % % . 1 = ! c

!

( 0 0 % + .

^

5 @L! 4 9#% * T 3 ( @L! * T = > ' +8 98 <

(8 . 5 0 '

g( / 9, ! ! ) 0 5 ;

! ! 0 % % . 1 / = 4 =

; @L!

%

Lake 1989:469-471)

.(

! ! 9+! / ( = 5 ; ! 79 0(# -

f / I7& > _, c ' ! (8

+ 5 < &( :;

; I = = I7&

( 0 < (! "!

+9#

+ (

. 1 9G

+!

. . 9# ; < ! 4 ! &( /

Allison 1972:51)

.(

) ! 79 (, (=

! ! ( 9+% ( I7&

Rationality)

4 ++= ! ! 67 (

= > '

! f /

= .

I7& 0 9 .

& :/ + N 0 9 = ! I7& N

++=

Kubalkova 2001:73-75)

.(

+ '

! ! 1+& ! 5 ;

O(1

< ! * "& ! ! :

! 4 +

h

E C i

* ; ( ! ! "

(4)

! :/ + h

! ! 3 7

< : +

8 ,9 ? ! ! c 19;

Lake 1989:471-475)

.(

= (`

' 4 % 5 ;

1; ( ! ! ) "#

.

<

' ( ? & ! ! E +& F E , L

9 ! h ( 0 = f / M ! ! ( ? &

9 ( h ( ? &

.G! ! ! % . 1 0 = e 9K 0 5 < (

h

' 0 ( f / > _, f /

= ( ? &

0 & 9

8 M( 0 * % ,8 ( ( +` 0

Guzzini 2004:91-95)

.(

.# " 9+! < 5 ,

< 6 = !

7 3 ; 5 3 ; *

' ! 4 8 A & * C9

( j 9D %k *

:

,8 J( 0 ,

* A 6 = ,

) 4 < D 1384 : 54

.(

H

! ! 4 5 67

> ( = 9m ; < 7 .# "

' J " 0 < N < , 4

* 5 (5>

' 4 C9!

(8 .

( # J " > (

= ! & 9 n A 0

n A ' 0 5 < 9/

- ( :/ + J " 0- < 9" = -

;I . +=

, (!

6 N f .

& 9 J "

G G - * % ,8 5 (5> = ! < 0 0

4 ++= M G - ! !

.

( = ! + <

n(+ T (

+= " ? * .

' 5 0

) 9 '0 0 & 9 9# p J "

* ( T (5> & 9 T = !

)

Moravcsik 1997:523-528 )

.(

J " = += 0 > (

! < DK 4 +

.

+ G ' +

%

? (` = !

& 9 0 5 < FI9m !( 0 8 9 ! 9 ! F 1 < F 1 n(A(

! . + '

< % > 4 + = ! +8

4 G&

! ! * 'F > = ! +8

! .G # '

Moravcsik 1997:533-539)

.(

(5)

L * T J "; * J " = c ' 5 (! <

* T J "; ' += T " n A

*I +B & 9

5

T

.

n( ! ( ! J "; *

,8 :

; . q L +> * * (E = ,

% h * q L ? & * (E = f 5 ,

( h

*I < n( = , f

. q L * .

5 , f 9 * .

, - 0 ( 0- J r

9

4 D

=

Moravcsik 1997:541-545 )

.(

% 0 ( 'J " < > ( m ;

FI = C

5 ; 6 % :/ + ' & 9 (& 67 4 %

' +9# 0 =

! ! :" * % ,8

- ! 4 8 ( I = G .

8 E / 5 +B

' 0- <

! + E 0 D ;

; I = !

*

+= f / 4 8 4 6 N < M .

5 (! <

'

m (

+ "

3! + H

? + E (D= ! ! (9 n(+

< _

Matthew 1995:65)

.(

!"# $ %

9/ HI7 <

1950 1960 ' I

) 9 98

) ! ! 9 I = 6K 98 0 F ,8

! ! 8 . #7 9 (

.

; + . #7 = 9"

! ! ) = 8

%k 0 (+& 0-

"

"

"4 !

! ! = c ' @ A( ! 9/ (8 4 5

0-

(9 9 G 8 ( 0- < E c *I 5

@ A( .9# ! * CE .

! ! ) = c 5 * "&

S ! ! . G ( S N <

. = ! N

Kubalkova 2001:79-81 )

. (

+ '

< 98 0 (+& ! ! 98 = ( 9/ HI7 4 8 .= c 0- % . & % = ' % v/ / % ,8 .

e S +> 4 B N + / 0 (+& ! ! ) 98

(6)

= (8 ++= J " 5 ( = ! / 8 .

G - 0 ! m ! 8 .

) 0 1382 : 49 - 51

.(

* < , 0 (+& 9 9 ! ! '4 (= 7 0 <

! ! 4<(c .G

! ! 0- 4 %

4 % x_! 9 N

. ; ! ( ! ! ) 4<(c

. H 9= 9

! ! )

1979 ( 9 ! 5 ; @ D

< N h

= +

! ! ! < 9 ! + "

<

. 4 8 y+ & =

QI = :; ' # ? @L! # < ( (

0- (&

+=

. '

0- 0 ; 0 5D+= $N q ` < 9 ! d&

G D (8 0 < J(` 0 D 9/

. 3

'

< 79# 9 !

* E(1

G - 9/ G - 0 *I c

+=

.

= ; 9 3

* C ( 9 !

+= " ! ! 7

0 G - ! ! "8 &(

Griffits 1999: 54-58)

.(

. 1 0 9 J & 4 ++= (& 0 (+& 9 ! T9

! ! 0 % %

+ / 0 % % . 1 ( ( = (9! # > 0-

* ; ( ? & = > ' ! "# * ; ( ' 8 ! ! * ( + < N N #,8 ? < F$c d&

(8 ! !

Lake 1989:466-467)

.(

. 9 ( 9"

E 9,

$%

g = . ( = > ' # ! ! =

++= 0 (+& 9D

0- p( ! ! ! 4

.

= >

4 C9! ; + % 4 D 4 8 0- B -

sUsable option)

9c = ! (

.= * ; >(=

* ; J "; O ( + % < + ( .

5 ) 9 0- < ++= 4 C9! z

(Valerie and Hudson 1995:210-211)

.

79 + 0 ! ! * ; ( +B 9

' ( 8 - ? = 9 + ( = !

+ H S = J "

+9#

. 3

'

! E F !

7 +

!

Griffiths 2007:13 )

.(

= (`

' 5 (5> ( ? &

5 (! < 0- 0 ( % " % (! < :/ + ( % ,8

% ,8 5 (5> ! ! m 0- ( d&

*

! 4 8

Kowert 1997:45-49)

.(

(7)

! ! 4<(c 0I= .G 0 (+& 9 9 ! ! <

= * ! ' ! ! "# 4 %

@L!

)

% ,8 = G ( `

! !

(.

. < N ' ! 9/ % * (E ! ! ) 4<(c .

= (`

'

4<(c ! / ( ! ! ) * L

. 9#

: e :

. 1 *

% h H :

! ! 9# : +

h

{ :

! 7 "L * L !

.

% ,8 (, ' % . 1 * 4<(c

! ! 4 % . 1 G % ' / @L! ! ! !

S ! 0 (

( * _! ;- . * ' ! ! 9# : + * 4<(c

,8 5 (5> 0- * M

! ! %

; ! ( '

%

Bilgin 2008:227-228)

.(

& ' ()* % + :

& ' ()* - # (*

< N 4<(c = +9# < N < N 8 x H

5 (5>

,8 (,

! ! %

QI =

! +D /

= 9 (8

.

. 1 4<(c G - :;

. 1 / = ! ! %

4 %

.G ,8 L @L!

.

E = x *

. 1 /

%k 4 %

! G - ! +D .

) E = = ! 79

! !

8 0- * M ! +D /

Jervis 2006:641-643)

.(

; 67 ( E =

= G < = ! 79

* C9 |( (m g 5 < ` < I = ! + G q & / !

.

= ! 79

= ! * S(`

6 N 0- < 0 (

. 1 9/ +

0 % %

= 4 C9! ! !

Jervis 2006:647)

.(

( = ! 79 x

8 = = & "+

.

( d& ( -

% . 1 (! < 9/ 0 (8 4

& :;

% 9/

- ) 9 .

. 9# ; E = !

. 4

= "+

0 ( =

= C%

. 9# ; E

n( :;

7/ <

* ; G ( "+ 7/

Jervis 2006:649)

.(

g( c Ir

x

% } & , - (G 4

S # ;

D }(7c

(8)

. 5 ; E '

c < F = . (5 . ( * (E

% ' ! 4 ( C ( 9! 7/ (D=

; E P

7/

'. = = "+

F = . 5 ) 9 . (

4 ( 5

S # < 7/

4 C9! %- * (E 6 ; ( G D }(7c

8 " %- 1+& ; E = ! (E ' ! 4 =

( (`

-

%

% 9/ 0 - ( d& 4 .

9,

^

+ ' ! ; q "L # += 4 8 0- x = 5

# = (% 0 0- - ; G ( ! ! 4 % . 1 =

; 6)+! 6 +

6 ( += ! < N

~ & L • (c 0

8 98 ( L % 9c += ;

Jervis 2006:659)

.(

< 5 , N 8

! +D / = ! ! ! 0 < N

"# / j 5 (5>

j = M : ;

(

. 1

8 98 ! ! %

'

< N . 9 +8 + / ?(GC <

Cognitive Processes)

0 += % . 1 & & 0 (+& (

=

0 ( 9 +8 + / ! +8

6+= 9/ + 6 N

. 1 0 % %

N ? + E 0(% (% :; ( ! !

Shapiro 1973:154)

.(

9 +8 • (c J "; ( ! ! 4 % . 1 = 0

! +8 = (% ' 8 98 4 B N 4 ! . 1 4

% 0 !- 4 ! #

5 ( 0 % * (E

T9 ) ( ( 5

4 C! 4 ! > ' &I`

(8 . x,& I = 4 B N +8 = c

4 C9! # ! < xN 4 % . 1 ( v;

J <

! ;

% . 1 !

<

Shapiro 1973:165)

.(

! +8 +> . N 8

!( 7& # c 9/ + 6 N 0- < 4 C9! 9 +8 + / . 1 . 1 0 4 %

%

! ! 4 % . 1 = 0 < N

' ( 7& (7 # J c M c G (

# ? c

6 N ?(! c ' " (

# +

(

5

O ! ! H K9 ! - c ( (

<

Shapiro 1973:170)

.(

(9)

. :

# (*

& ' ()* &

% ,8 (, 5 (5> " = ! < N .G , x + 4 % ( ( ' ! ! ; 4 % . 1

. :;

H 4 % +! q L I7& 9K! A % ,C S(E 4 % . 1

H #c 0- p( * -

Snyder,Bruke and Spain 1963:85)

.(

x +

= 0 D 0(# (G ! 0 O(1 ? +9 y+ ( !

4 (" ( * 1 . r= 4 ( % * (E 0 % . 1 r=

! . &

< 8

' G < 8 D/ ' - 9 ;( H(> G>

G - |( (m 0 ( 4 % . 1 / & 9 + < 5+

Janis 1972:154-156)

.(

3 !- . ( ' ( ' 9# ,C 0(> (& < x +

$N

F$c ? )# ! D/

D < v& (! < 9C K (%

Janis 1972:144)

.(

5 (! <

' D <

4 "98 % . 1

(

* &I` ) '3! + 5 ( # 0 7/ 0(> C (

79 * F$c 6 % ' 0- - :

0- P n 0 !

Janis 1972:160)

.(

< += 0 L 8 7/( x + :

D7 (

+ 9 +8

4 % v& 0 |( (m 5+ < ' ! ! 1

(# ! ( )+ = c 4 % ? )#

79 * F$c

(D . 0 N

) 9

= %

. 1 #

. 1 + / 9c ! ! 0 % %

%

N ++= ; % ,C C+ "r

< _ . 1 9G R K + (9

Janis 1972:151)

.(

/ :

0 1 2 3

:; J

%k / @L! <

! +D

@L! < +B g

4 % . 1

4 %

S # ( 67 ' ! !

. 1 + /

%

. ! ! !

. 0 0 (+& 7 _ 0(# - =

. 1 € ! J 4 ' ! !

0 9#

0 < ! 0 / ! !

-. 1

% ! S # (

.

> 9! 0- * 1 ! ! J

! 0- 0 / 0 < ! e 9K *S " <

.

FI :;

5 ; = I7& + 5 < J 0

= 0 0-

5 <

9= 1

(10)

! ! + E I7& > _, 5 < ' = f / _, I7&

. = !

0 9# 4 M I7& J = > .

< >

! ! !

.

< ! < 6 % :/ + ! +8 = ! ) 0

.G # ! ! * 1

!

Allison and Halprein 1972:60-62)

.(

! ) 0(# -

(D= !

/ n( !

8 = (

: / 98 R K )+ =

0 5 < (! < * 1

8 (8

Decision Games)

/ '(

98 R K )+ = ! !

O

(8

Policy Games)

0 = J " 8 * 7 * 1 J " = & '(

0 7/ 9c G -

- ( * 1

Action Games)

.(

3 '

. 1 < 0(# -

9! G> ( % . 1 ! ! 0 % %

:/ + <

! :

< ! :/ + :/ + ' 1K8 :/ + ' + :/ +

(Allison and Halprein 1972:65-68)

.

% . 1 + / 0 < ! 0 N 0(# -

! +8 + (9 '* &I` J 9+= < > + / # 4 I& = q/(

< _ m # q ; ++= e ( 0-

QI = 0- 0- 4 I&

+8 98 J 9+=

. +> . ( (9 = ! #= q/( 4 % . 1

5

0 5 <

$5 M G - += n +;

.

= (`

'

J

&

S # ( 0 < ! ( ( 0 D g 9#% 0 DD % +> .

: ( ' ( ( :A bCc . 1

H #c %

(Christensen 2004:70- -

73

.(

41 5 6 7

( 0- 9# ! ! ) 4<(c = < 5 ,

(& = D7 L (& = = ! * _! ;- . ' = (

8 98 ! ! % . 1

(, 9# &( :; '

,8

4 = = ! ! %

.

9 +D . #7 * _!

< P- ( = &

( & = ++= 0

6K (

)

L A

( )

A L

( (8 . #7 .

0(> (& &

! ! G ' 19; ' / T '] 'y+ / (& <

! .G #

. 1 =

G - . 1 5 (5> 0 % % M

$%

Valerie and Hudson 1995:209-211)

:; (.

'

* _!

L &( 0 = N J "

(11)

~ &

7 < ` 98 L n A 0

O . 1 G

%

O

? = ! ! 0 % % . 1 = 0- 0

! .G # ' +8 ,9 L <

Sprout 1965:54)

.(

L

< * "&

: 1 - QI = = ' L % 67

(& > 0(> 4 ++=

! ! 0 % % . 1 = ! 79 = ! ! * 1 L

7/( M I =

! ! #,8 (D=

A = $ * 7 59# I = ? + E

; (D= 0- 0 9 9 h

2 -

. 1 H K9 4 m ; = %

-

L (& 7 ! ! 0 % % .

J v I =

( ! 79 !

. 1 ' ! .G 0- ( ( A =

-

" P 4 ++= * M + ( ( H K9 ! ! 0 % % ++=

h 3 - 67 ?(! L

4 ++=

= ! ! * 1

. 4 S 7& -

S(E = ! 4

* 1 M •

! !

( 0 ! ! 0 % % . 1 H K9

R K 0- 4 ++= 7 4 ++= * M

) (8

Sprout 1965:60

.(

.G * , < ,

8 q L # * _!

9 +D & 98 9

! ! ! 0 % % . 1

.

0- G - =

# = (%

' ++ " 0- + = (% 0- % +

. - 9, '

% M

j = ! . 1 ( , .G # 0 % % . 1 !( <

!

( = # = ! . 1 M 5

.G # '0 5 % . 1 j # > ;

) 8

Christensen 2005:933-935

.(

8* % 8

! <

1960 ' 0 ' ! 6 > )+ ,/ K

8 7 "L ! ! .

! ! 0 . 8 ,/ + < = c

< 8 0 5 < r, K + < ' 8 . / ! !

< 9!

'

&

! ! * L /(,8 M(

% 7 "L .

:;

4<(c 7 "L ! ! = C% 0 (

= ! g , ' # 6 <

. 8 9D 0- 4 8 € ; ( >

( ( "9 0- p(

Valerie and Hudson 1995:235 )

.(

5 (! <

'

/ .G F < ,

0 !

(12)

e 9K 0 < 0 , 0 ) 0( <- q ` < 0( ; "8 . q ` <

! * &I` + 9!

q L * A 5 (5> ( p( 5 F

8 ( F ` %< !

Carlsnaes 1980:15)

.(

"L * L 98 79

9C% S( ' ! ! 7

= (8

0I= @L! m 0 ( (! < = > ' ! ‚; +

! . 5 (! <

'

@L! ( (

'

0- 6+= +

(N

? '

= 9 +=

.

! p( 5 #

< = 4k (

ƒ = (!

0 D ( < 59#" 0(+/ ( € ! 0 = & < !

( y+ / € #c ' / c 'j r . C < 5 (! <

+= 4 C9! ( * L 0- < (

Rosenau 1968:320)

.(

.G * < , 0 (+& 5 4< ! d < "; 6K 0 N

< ! ! 6 N J ! ! ?<S '

. < _ .

>

! 8I ' ! ! ) G+D N J =

q C G

= (& 9/ % 4 I& = 4<(c 0I= @L!

(, + ( @L!

8 98 67 (D= ! !

(& 67 '

! 4 = ( .

< # = ! ! ! 0 < N

< !( 4 8 m J

+ 4<(c " J (

.

6 > A ! ! ) ( G+D N J <

%< ! (N . = ! J " + < 9+% ( * 0 D=

8 98 ) q 1 ; . 8

. +> = + <

! ! ! ) 4<(c 9 & +> L!

. 9/ 79&

@L! 9 (,c T9 '67 ' / & „+N M (D=

! 0I= @L! ? &

1971:98) (Rosenau

. (C 0 < R

(D= = 5 < * ; 0(> (& M ! ! (, T9 + ' & 9 9 ! 0 ( 9# < ' += . #7 >(= z 9!

e 9K &(A( 4<(c 5+ / 9 ! $N

1972:146) (Rosenau

.

+ '

! ! 0 % % . 1 < ! ! 6 N J (

++, & (! % . 1 4<(c # = += -

( 5 . += (& T9 < 9!

( ( * $ * 7

= > ' + 3! + % . 1 ! @L!

(13)

( ' 5 @L! ( ( (& < CP @L! ( ( (& F E (

(D= ! ! #,8 * " ( ( '0 % + .

" 5 ? + E

8 98 J .

9

:5( ; <

0 * ! +8 g ! +8 / a = 5 4< !

5 - dc " (9 a 5 "M #N 0 E 5 ;

! ,8 5 (5> ( 0 5D+= & 9 8 ! = '

( %

G! G -

!

! ! )

8 98 (

Kowert 1997:113)

.(

% 5 ;

! 9 ! = 9 9 !

* ; : <( (5> = + (

0- ! ! (, 5 (5> 9/

( % ,8 5 (5> + 9 ! E 5 4< ! ' $% M

D7 ( = !

"# G - ! ! .G 5

.

%

5 ; (

5 ;

:/ + (

f / 4 8 6 N < M (

! (8

7 bCc !

0 - ! + 3#=

5 4< ! ' (8 EI * ; 9D >

= ( 0 8 9 !

! ! n(+ 0 5D+= 5 0 !

Price and Smith 1998:241-244) .(

4< !

( 4 I = & 9 ( n( 9 ! … L 0 5

++= E 0 * <

. 9!

+" (

(8 0- P ' / T ' + < ! * E(1 8

.

( = c

& 9 4 - ( = ! 5 ,

+ D N "+

d&

? 5 , <

(8 .

* 3 P = ! c

E 0 7/

( (

G <

= ! (

* C " + ! !

< _

Wendt 1999:111-)

(115

. 4< ! )+ & (; 0 5

( ( (,

G :/ + j

! ! %

G # 67 .

= ! / % 4 8 6 N < :/ + 0 (

. 0 ( "# = >

+= :/ + 0 ( + D N A / G+ 0 5 4< ! ( 0 ( L

! ! T n(+ + A (` ,

? + E

(14)

0 +=

. 3

'0 8 ( < 0 5D+= 8 ' )+ & (; T

T ! ! 0 D / +

Jepperson and Wendt 1996:96-99)

.(

0 5 4< ! = e 9K 4 % ! ?<S H

& (; M

(, )+

. < _ ' :/ + ( .

e : 4< !

? + 9 ! 67 = % + 9# ! 0 5

++= = ( (, )+ & (;

. 0 5 4< !

8 - . , . ? 8 - = 79 9# !

@ A( 0 ( .

? + E 5D+= +

( * ;

( = 0- ( ( )+ & (; ? + 9 ! (

n ( }(7c 3 ;

0 D . |

C K ? ) '

( ? v& 5 (D

Wendt 1999:178-179)

.(

J r 0 (+&

' v& C K &

*I c < xN , - , * ; ? 11

(D= *I c " 9_!

9 ! (D= * ; * T ` 0 ( % 6 N n / 3 ; } &

? RS

' # 0- )+ & (;

(D= * ; = >

< {

! RS 9 !

9 & D •

) 4 < D 1387 :

213 - 214

.(

H : )+ & (; M = 9D 9= r c @L! 0 5 4< !

,8 ! ! :/ + ' ( % 9 N

5 * "&

' D

+ ; ! ( ! ! (,

. + '

! +8

y+ / ' ! ! 0( ; = )+ & (;

0 D ( ! ! ( &

# '

! A

.

( @L! =

! ! * C "

+= = #

) 4 < D 1385 : 17

.(

{ :

= 0 5 4< !

@L! + ( :; = % (>( = r %

++= ( .

G . 4 G> )+ & (; 0-

c

Ruggie 1998:111)

.(

! 4

& 9 5 4< ! ! 79 ! ! 5 4< ! p "

= ` 7 ; ' 8 3! + ! ! O (`

( 0 G 0 5D+= = (8 n 8 A C < & 9 59 !

< !

#C = +9# 0 5D+=

++= ?I& ' % . 1 ' ++=

+ .

. 1 0 5D+= = ! > ' ! 9 ! & c ! ! ' +

(15)

+ D 19; 0 # ?(GC 5 4< ! = ! ` 8 = %

= ! ( :/ + J " = (

; J " ( 0 % :;

H K9 & 9 0 # (

%

Smith 2001:83-85)

.(

) 0 F ,8 0 = N 5 4< ! .G! .G !

! ! ! ! !

. :;

' (,

79

"

9 ! -

" % = ' % = ' 9 ! < ( 9# < 9/ / @L! '

':/ + ' (

, G

@L! 9/ % ; "` ) 9 =

! ! ! += ! !

Kubalkova 2001:85-86)

.(

4< ! 5

! = G ( 9

0- 0 *I 0 ( 0 8

+= 0 ' 0 D ( <

J " ( + bCc 4 I& =

+9# 0 8 9 ( + .

9 ( + ?(GC … ` / ' +

' (

0 * &< + "

< _ ' ( / + v G - 0 = ( 9c 9 .

= ! 79 0 9 + <

( 9 ( + bCc

4 <

0 =

0 5 0 DL 4 < n( 9" = < N

3 19 eL + ( 0 =

8 . 4 <

0 =

+ ! A c 9c ( 9 ( + bCc 3 19

p " ! ! & ( 0 = ! ' < L . g

( ,

Mitzen 2006:234-236)

.(

4 < J &† 'eL + 0 = 4 <

9# 5 F 0 (+& G - bCc (8

9/ % ! 0 (+& , ' -

(8 . 4 < % + ! ! 3 19 0 =

I7& ; / 6+=

0- 4 < ' ! K! # * G

G eL + 0 =

I7& %

(8 4 D ! !

Mitzen 2006:239)

.(

4< ! 0 5 4

6 N

* ; ! ! +

? + E

)+ & (; )+ & (; 0 %< ! 0 ; = 79 9/ + 6 N (! < 0- * ; " 0 ( 9G 8 9D

! !

%< ! 0 = ! c N ' 5 (! < 0-

6+= ? 0- * ; + 6 N I,D C (

- ( 5

) 0 1382 : 69

.(

(16)

= 4 4< ' 8 0 = (% 0

% ++=

0

9G R K ! !

. 1 ! ! + E

* ! ! (7 4 5

! ! * () * 0 ( < + (9 +8 +8- I =

-

" 4 G 9G G - $%

. 7 ( +

! ! 4 5 67 8 !

% ; ! ( *

.

+ '

+ 9+! / ! 9

5 ;

? "

= . = 0 . 9 N ! ! ) 9/ HI7 * M x_!

HI7 < % & * (E ! ! 98 % ,8 d& (! <

5 (!

' - . / ! ! < 0- * " ( .

#,8 =

0 5 "M #N 0 < + < ' < N E

/ 98 % 9 ! #N

% . .

= ( G % < , 5 4< !

/ ! +8 9# " m :;

E 0 0 0 < N 0 ( ( ! +8

8 0- e K * .

9 ! 0 79 ? (; 0 = … L

! +8 9# % =

! ! ) 0 % + <

3 ' - . / ! !

'

) ! ! 5

* L 0-

/ % ; .

$% ! ! * () < ! ! 0 % % . 1 = # ]! N

=

4 8 … L < ?

98(

' " 4 G 9D 9G + (

; . += q C < = ' G+D N 7 C J < 4 C9! 7

9, 5 (8 E c 4 8 0 * ( ( + * , 0

= !

( % . 1 ! ! 0 % % . 1

( #

6K ? (; L

0- $% ! ! * () * ,

+8 98 ( I = + <

.

+ * , m 7 N #; ( +

<

. 9 N 4 8 … L .

(17)

> ? 6 7 :

+ . - :

1 -

#c '4 < e ! )

1381 ( 3 4 0 G '

:

0 D

.

2 - c '4 < D )

1385

" (

5 4< ! + < 0 I! (G ! !

"

'

*5 - /

" &6 7 8 8 9 - % '

4 :

0 G ' C1 1

:

‡E ' ! ! * L 9/

11 - 35 .

3 - c '4 < D )

1387

" ( ˆ ˆ ? + 9 ! } & & , - y+

"

' 5 -& ' :5;

5/ <=

* 4 ' 38 g ' 1

‡E ' 213 - 239 .

4 - c '4 < D )

1384 ( ' 7 / -" >

0 G ' : ! .

5 - E '0 ) 1382

" (

ˆ ˆ! ! ˆ ˆ < 5 4< !

"

' 8 59 *5 -& ' :5;

g ' 4 '

‡E 45 - 70 .

. . :

1- Allison, Graham and Morton Halperien (1972) “Bureaucratic Politics: A paradigm and some Policy Implications “, World Politics, Vol 24, pp 40-79.

2- Bar, Josef ( 2003) “Intelligence Failures and Need for Cognitive Closure”, Political Psychology , Vol 26, pp 75-99.

3- Bilgin, Pinar ( 2008)” Foreign Policy Analysis: Classic Book Review: Valerie M. Hudson

,Millennium - Journal of International Studies, pp 227-228.

3- Carlsnaes, Walter (1980)The Concept of Foreign Policy Actions in Comparative Analysis” Cooperation and Conflict, Vol. 15, No. 1, 3-20.

4- Christensen, Eben J. (2004)” Bureaucrats Versus the Ballot Box in Foreign Policy Decision Making: An Experimental Analysis of the Bureaucratic Politics Model and the Poliheuristic Theory”, Journal of Conflict Resolution, 48; 69, pp69-90.

5- Chritensen, Eben J. (2005) “Book Review: Alex Mintz (ed.), Integrating Cognitive and Rational Theories of Foreign Policy Decision Making”, Millennium - Journal of International Studies,pp 932-935.

6- Dunn , Joe P(1978) “Book Review: Remaking Foreign Policy: The Organizational Connection. By Graham Allison and Peter.” Political Research Quarterly, vol. 31, pp.

137 – 138.

7- Griffiths, Martin (1999), Fifty Key Thinkers In International Relation, London: Routledge.

8- Guzzini,Stafano(2004),“ The Enduring of Realism in IR”, European Journal of International Relation, No 10,pp87-113.

9- Janis, Irving L (1972) Group Think, Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company.

10- Jepperson R.L and A. Went (1996) Norms, Identity and Culture in National Security, New York: Columbia University Press.

11- Jervis , Robert (2006) “ Understanding Belief”, Political psychology , Vol 27 , No 5 ,pp 641-659.

12- Kowert , Paul (1997) “ Toward a Constructivist Theory of Foreign Policy”, Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of American Politics. Science Association, DC.

13- Kubalkova, Vendulka (2001), Foreign Policy in a Constructed International Politics in a constructed world, Armonk: M.E Sharpe.

14- Lake, David ( 1989) “Toward a Realist Theory of State Action” , International Studies , Vol 33,pp 457- 474.

15- Matthew, Richard A., and Mark. Zachery. (1995) “ Liberal International Theory:

Common Threads, Divergent Strands”, In Controversies in International Relations Theory: Realism and the Neo-Liberal Challenge, edited by Charles Kelley, New York: St. Martin’s Press,pp 107–50.

16- Mitzen , Jennifer ( 2006) “ Ontological Security on World Politics”, European Journal of International Relations, Vol. 12(3): pp341–370.

17- Moravscik, Andrew (1997) “Taking Preferences Seriously: A Liberal Theory of International Politics”, International Organization , No 51,pp 513-553.

18- Morgenthau, H.J. (1985) Politics Among Nation, New York: Alfred Knoph.

(18)

19- Rosenau , James ( 1968) “ Comparative Foreign Policy: Fad, Fantasy or Field?” , International Studies , Vol 12 , No 3 , pp 296 – 329.

20- Rosenau , James ( 1971) The Scientific Study of Foreign Policy. New York: The Free Press.

21- Rosenau, James (1972) The Analyses of International Politics. New York: The Free Press.

22- Schweller, Randall and David Priess (1997) “A Tale of Two Realism Expanding the Institutions Debate”, International Studies Review, Vol 41, No 1, pp 1-32.

23- Shapiro, Michael (1973) “Cognitive Process and Foreign Policy Decision Making”, International Studies, Vol 17, No 2, pp 147-170.

24- Smith, Steve (2001), “Foreign Policy is What States Make of It”, in Foreign Policy in constructed world. Armonk: M.E Sharpe.

25- Snyder, Richard C, H .W. Bruke and Burton Spain (1963) Foreign Policy Decision Making: an Approach to the Study of International Politics. Glencoe, IL: the Free Press.

26- Sprout , H and Sprout M ( 1965) Environmental Factors in the Study of International Politics. Prinston: Prinston University.

27- Sprout , H and Sprout M ( 1965) Man. Milieu Hypotheses in the Context of International Politics . Prinston: Prinston University.

28- Wendt , Alexander ( 1999) Social Theory of International Politics, Cambridge:

Cambridge university press.

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

Based on Table 3, pretest and post-test data scores have significance values of 0,060 and 0,038. The above prerequisite test results concluded that the score of

International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences Review and Research, [online] 501, pp.83–89.. Available at: http://globalresearchonline.net/journalcontents/v50-1/13.pdf [Accessed