Ibn-Qudaamah's Critique of Ibn-Hanbal's Narratives in Al-Mughny

(1)

! " #

$

%&' () *"+ ,-.

*

' ( )

* +, - 17

08 1439 * +, 01-2 ;"#

18 09 1439

"#

0&12 2 5 678 971 :# ;, :

− <= >?

− 5@ AB? CD5 ,E * AA)'D8 -2 F

G8DH C,I J? ?'' KD L:52

MA, N 5O PD 9Q2 GR5= ST > '#2 ,5U VW? X'-=2 5, 5Y2 ZD[ > %'\5,8 ] XDY2 A^R 0_Y `aT b? G'JO ;cd1H A^e a'^f * Z' 5\ gJh * 5C?'B' i#: j f^2 ,A^R 0_Y ? V,E= 5k7 Rl Ae G Am CD GA)'h2 <= 2

i#:J \Dfa n2 oSU A^R p

q7D > AJ[Q 0^,8 r (s2 tr

2= ^8 2 ^D8 2= Z17Da tr Z')' > 2= Q8 2= #[

H 0J78 u' b?

5kv tr X'w' * GD-\2 F5@ ?'B' Amr2 Hxh * 971 Ay ,#p p

'# GD[ L: 971 MA,2 :

MA,

z7D {C_^Da p

971 M_Df q#= >2 iYD, L:5 G i 5\5D ?2 ,Z' 5\ X'w'2 - >8 ?'B' 'Am :

FS 9Q ,Gr

971 :# * |,JB CD2 Gh2 }8 a Z'x8 G : g5Jh j ,Fl b? ~?a ,? 5CJ CA^R ^5,2 'v Z= 'Am =p

5s a2 N- j ) 5 n82 ,AD=2 X'-U O-,2 A^R xY ? * F5@ ^ P5 (:H2 p

05D2 G XaDa p

3 4 56&

,- >8 : 01,Q >8

, C,I 9v ^f ,9v 2 ,<= ,Y , p

_________________________________________________________________________

Ibn-Qudaamah’s Critique of Ibn-Hanbal’s Narratives in Al-Mughny:

A Comparative Study

Abdulmajeed Yousuf Al-Mutlaq*

King Saud University

(Received 03/05/2018; accepted for publication 02/06/2018.)

Abstract: This research is concerned with identifying Imam Ibn-Hanbal’s Hadith narratives criticized by Ibn-Qudaamah is his book Al- Mughny. It attempts to establish the objectivity and reliability of Ibn-Qudaamah approach in evaluating the selected narratives. The research applies an inductive analytical methodology. Among the most important findings of the research are the following: It is proven that objectivity is obvious in Ibn-Qudaaqmah’s investigative approach. Despite belonging to Ibn-Hanbal’s school of thought, Ibn-Qudaamah does not show any bias in evaluating Ibn-Hanbal’s narratives. Ibn-Qudaamah’s criticism displays a worthy etiquette of disagreeing in fiqhi debates and discussions, without ill feelings or offence. Ibn-Qudaamah’s approach reflects meticulousness in issue presentation, analysis of statements and related evidences, and comparing and weighing views and arguments rationally. Given how valuable Al-Mughny is in terms of content and approach, the research recommends that special attention be paid to studying it. It would be greatly useful to link contemporary issues to those in Al-Mughny wherever relevant, especially methodologically. This would benefit students of Shari’ah greatly.

Keywords: Ibn-Qudaamah, Ibn-Hanbal, Al-Mughny, Musnad Ahmad, Hadith narratives, criticism of Hadith.

_________________________________________________________________________

* ' ( ) ,8~ H , qY^8 ?Y sD=

p

% ,'Y 8 [J , p

Z 2458 P , 11451 p (*) Associate Professor, Department of Islamic Studies, College of

Education, King Saud University.

Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, p.o box: (2458), Postal Code:( 11451).

2~[ K :

[email protected] e-mail:

(2)

8!

Jv 5nr ,

RIDYf2 G,DYf ,

>" 8 s'f2

e 0 >2 ,G 50 e > ,,YRf= 2

1? J 5n= A=2 , 5ar Gr a n= A=2 ,G L#

G'""2

>""S2 ""52U 5"" , ,

""< '""1

,

G87w=2 GT b?2

, G" o"D# >2 ,

82 ,>5 ' tr GD, b? 2 :

" G)'h * 978 q[ ^ L 1e cd"[ "R5@ iQ"w z1,v i#: AD

^ - >8 5J >8 1?

>"8 <= [ 5

5, 5Y 0#= r 01,Q −

jJ qQ −

* C,I G8DH p

V"- V",E= "' c5 > GD 971 :#2 ""_'e >"" 5z""? 5""J "" G""e n52= |"",[e , Z""D[

0"5J L:"5 G")'5D :# A,8 > nH2 ,m'72

" >"? "'^, 2 5 77\h "Ay2 ,"<=

- >8 ?'B' 5kv tr X'w'2 971 *

Z' 5\2 p

9:- ;< = :

""2 5 6""Q

− ""<= "" >""?

− C""D5

F5@ AB?

, L:"5 Z"D[ ,E * AA)'D8 -2

j") 0_Y `aT |5JB cd1H J? ?'' KD j > VW Ar A^R i#:

p

>" G AODa2 G)'5D * F5@ MA, n8 oSU A^R i#: VW? X'-=

p

9:- &>

: G"R5= ST > - >8 C,I ZDH

"A^R G"1DH >

1

'"#2 ,

;cd"1H "A^e "J? ?'"'

2 ZD[ > %'\5, b? GWDa '"-=2 5, 5Y"

VW"? X

,""5U

""^e g""Jh * 5C?'""B' MA,"" N 5O"" P""D

G Am Rl <= 2 a'^f * Z' 5\

i#:" j f^2 ,A^R 0_Y ? V,E= 5kQ >

i#:J i 5\5D2 \Dfa n2 oSU A^R p

K" ,#2 0"J?

"Hxh * GD\"l2 9"Q1

5kv tr X'w' * F5@ ?'B' Amr2 p

! 2 5 " 8 :

o' 971 u'B'J8 5qD# 8DH 2= 78 )= 0_Y" A"= * "A^R "- >"8 DS ZDH

1

" '"8= [8 'DH X- :

"- >"8 ;"? "-2 *

"Ae ,i#:"J i2 C5^D ^1 ARxh

c"J

c""Q2 ""2 b""? _"D1J 5q""E p

j"",^

>""? j""Rh >""

G"^R n 5"JD ;0 > )2 ,2 Ge e ,qAD) 0 >? 9712 ,7\5D b?2 i#: * AD)a b?

p

5q""E

*""[

"",8 ,"" 5'DJ ""f2^ c""Q2 ""2 b""?

j"""B' * """Hs2 ,05"""8 i#:""" * """2 5 5"""h :

>JD p qE :

C- N * C,I

`" 2 ,0 Ge2

,` :S¡2 ,[QU 0?2 ,i#: * ` 2 ,¢

"A^R * "AD)a Z"8 G^RDJ DR ;GhJE2

p f

"y :

: 0\R 0S 01,Q >8 <= i#

2 719 p

(3)

e "1 ,L"I " >"8 z"? 'DH5 ,

£ - >8 DS H:8 5qD# G5f= 5ar ,"#1418

>

8

X"- 9Q 22 X'-U :

`" |") "-2

X'-U iYQ "Hs= 5q"E ,X'-U b? J_U |?22 ,

" " "8 k"5e' DS8 i^?= 5qE ,X'- 50H 5=

i#:" "^5e' n"H sr " 58=2 ,A^R G1DH * Gf52 G" R¤ 2= <=

,"DSa G"8 5MD"Q "2 , q"E

Rl X'-U 5= ¥-f=

2

p

A? ~? CD5 2 5 6Q 'Ae zJ? 5=

P I\8 - >8 ,

>" = c'AO" |"fH= V'"

i#:"" ""R ""2 5 b""? G""B~? n""8 j"" ,

b"? G"B~? * G"h Hs2 ,<= >? '^, 2 5 GA)'h2 ,25 n"8 Hs= 5qE ,A? ~

~? 05D ,

b? AO W8 X'^5, 2= 5U Hs=2

GB~? 57w ,

GD7w ? 2=

, Z"DH * (s )= 2

0_Y" j"J ¦ 5"D G"5f= W"H ,DSa W"5fr2 ,

A, c'AOJ p

9:- #?3 :

C""D5 ""<= "" >""? ""'^, ""2 5 −

? C,I ZDH * ) I\8 F5@ AB

3

p

2 yf : "e 0_Y" A"= * A^R - >8 DS

% 9 p

3

# lYf iYQ ,

k"^§

>"8 "1? 'DH" ¢"

=

9:- @A :

−

* ""- >""8 MA,"" n""8 ""2 5 G"")'h

,? ) 5 B p

L 5""75D * ""- >""8 ?'""B' ""Amr −

Z' 5\

i#:J i 5\5D ?2 , p

9:- &B"

: −

* ""- >""8 MA,"" ""

""2 5 G"")'h

5 B

,? )

?

−

* ""- >""8 ?'""B' o"" ""

L 5""75D

Z' 5\

i 5\5D ?2 ,

?

9:- CD :

"15D "{§ {_^D 971 * MA, n'[

¢5D (Y :

− xY" 'w }8 |fH sr ,uP5, 50 n8

¦R5h 50 A82 ,`S 50

p

− 2 ,xY * X'-U Hs >" " X- > n8

"# 5ªa iY"Q `" ? n'[2 ,q 0#=

5A^R p

− j" ,cK"D "A^R i#:" b? \D-a

F 5Y" X'"-= >" G? `'-' 5«D H:8 ,

= ,'"v "J >"8 NDR"1? 'DH"2 CH 5~ >Y71?

, ,iD[ ? |1

+, , 1417 "#

1997 p j

oS= Y, CDf^

; F7\D > e'S HxD p

(4)

5\

>"8 " " "DS "A? =2

{

Jh ,

' q- >8 :Jh2 ,

)2 sr p

Hs2 ,a5 G)2 n8 j X'-U 5= r −

>"[= nr "A,? G8 Z¬ 2 ,O-, > A?

c1 05 8 (s Hs2 ,(s p

F # CD5 2 5 - >8 G)'h Hs−

) 5 , Gh2 p

− C"D5 ("s "8 q 0#= X'^f2 5U Hs

57\8 AOh - >8 G)'h

, GR 2=

p

")2 nr 5wU \ A5= b? WD?a −

,k"E'5D2 ,"75D * ("s2 ,#d® >? C,I Ae jJ2 ,Ml5D2 p

− i"""5,ª2 ,9"""71 u'""B' b"""? P""H 5~

Da p

−

q-h ,

#' n82 p

−

""wU #\"" >"" 9""QU M""

,5

"Hs " n82 ,9v q-2 7R 5\2 VP 1Er2 2= 77 5\"" * >""[h nr ""AD) * nx 5O"" 0""#=

¯"Q= * 2= WAe |fH n°e ,¯Q=

, :"±,Q CRDHx"e

¯Q= > 2= WA, A¬lD8 p

5wU #\ > E M − p

5>"R iDH > 7\8 F5D − L:"5

cJD 7\ iDH > 2= ,\ G1D p

− ,c""JD ""I5 q)"" >"" "" k""E'h

7R 5\2 VP8 A? Q n'[h2 p

− "8r j" ,9"71 ²l >? c1?

w'5D2 M_D5, 5q#=

p

9:- 8' :

"5^ b"? 971 0JD

, i" "8=2 ,

S2 j)2 \J ³Ae2 , p

8!• : ,9"71 u'B' ¯= b? |JD2

2"Q2 ,^8 5Y" "52 ,GD[O2 ,

G"e#=2 ,

GD±=2 , GA,2 p X 52U i""• :

""2 ""- >""8 G"")'h

1 qY- * <=

0_Y 5| Ge2, p

5 i• :

2 - >8 G)'h

u'1 qY- * <=

, 0_Y E Ge2 p

9"5 i• :

"2 "- >"8 G")'h

N[5, qY- * <=

, 0_Y E Ge2 p

j""8 5 i"• :

""2 ""- >"8 G"")'h

2:,2 nWU qY- * <=

, cQ2 xY Ge2 p

E F• , CH 8 8IAG?

J

KL # M N-O• J

"^2 ("s 5¢2 '# G5fr ,G8 jR, n= X=2 G?

p

* * *

(5)

8?P Q&'

5 +?L 5# -R I2 S

´| Ge2 0_Y

p

T?P U2 :

9VW # " , :

G" g"Rf a " f * q 0#= FDS

®KH _

'- b? #'7f2 9 :

8?P XX!

* ²""S >""5µ2 ,#"" G""5f= :

9®K :

R,Q '8=

4

,

Ce 5O2

5

,

,"<= >"? 22

i#: C#

6

p

ID,3?

: " sr dY" V g, Yf nH ' G5f= −

Ge G", e ¶2S > qY a V * 9[ sr G5f°e ;

Ge

7

p

g G5fU2 − N'RY 8

5" "Q W"5fr2 ,

N'RY

8

p

4

£'Y""1 , 1O""

1 70 p 2

""yf : ""] N "",

1 328 p

5 P 6D¤

1 18 G1,D * X-2 :

2r bw n , G"8'E *2

9®K , V" _" >" dY" 2=

, X'"1 g" 2=

, 2=

Ghw ) B7Da

1 28 p

6 X- : N'RY '# g ,G8 ³x8 a p

<= 0_Y yf

G'# >8 ¦7r2

2 463 , 2

"yf : "e * `\"f

` > )

1 327 p

7 P 6D¤

1 18 p

8

<= 0_Y ,

G'# >8 ¦7r2

2 463 , C,I2

=

Y 8Z ! :

9®K * X- <= >? 2 :

""H sr G"", uP""eU 5r ,

9

p

5C""l5, X""-2 :

"" 0Y""®

|D

10

p

9®K * ( X-2 5°"e +Df2 H sr :

0YI n= o=

11

p

G"A)'h * - >8 X-2 :

X2U2

− L=

"?

5,

"<= X'"-2 ,"Am= – G", uP"eU 5r :

, g"

GDf * 68 e GR5-'h b? 0 '# W5fr2 ,

g"2 ,G

9®K tr Z'Y, X'82 ,#5y * ]'8 '# W5fr ,

g,8 g +v :#

p q?= 2

12

p

G)'D :# @ 5µ2 5D q 0#= X'^f

:

−

""

X""- £'Y""1 * ""Hs :

|""== |""-

X"- ?Z'"5 * n'"[ 5k"12 9®K 5k"1 "5= :

= 2 484 p

9

"" 0_Y""

DY""Y 2 ·= ""2 ""<=

% 61 ,

yf2 : C,I 2 485 d"1[ N+"2 , ,

>"8 ><"1

- 1 302 p

10 ¦" "1? F,\

1 374 q-"8 1463 , ¸"2U2

2 151 p

11 oK[ f2

1 21 p

"AU j) * X-2 :

>"?2

", ¥QRD d® 9®K ,

= >"?2

)"l "E ,

>"?2

G[ ]'8=2 Z2 2= > 0,2 F ,

G"8 z\"2

;

^OJ

% 37 p 0 i#' * X-2 :

0Y® i7DY

¥QRh sr 9®K

1 158 p

12 C,I 2 485 p

(6)

³x8 G8 ge 9®K2

13

p

− Z'"5 * n'"[ 9®K * f2 >2

X"- - 5RD :

GY"® ("s ¥Q"Rh sr ,

d"® n"H n°"e

x8 G8 o= e ¥QRD

14

p

|- : 8 = 5n= ¢ Ay2 ;GD", g 0YI

H - 0YIh 5, 5nU G", (s W5fr2 ,cdH 2= |f

,h y R Z17Da 01 b?

p

− Ce 5O"" X""- :

0"") 5b""w '""2 ,

G""8'E *2

2 9®K 0 - nH2 ,- 2= > f ³5, eD

15

p

Z85:" "8 o" a n"H G"5f= >Y"v >?2 − ¹x8 9®K2 '12

16

p

− X- c2? >8 O# >?2 :

|"w , ·'"E *2

Z8s ,

X^e ,·U |^e º 5» a :

17

p

8Z U2 X!G ,\X'RG ; 8L " KG ]^ :

:

KXG 8L&? \X'. X _`X a+ ,(b _? 8 J

cdXA

?; 8L KG 8L f(g . _] Hhi |""¹- :

o'"" xY"" :"" q""5[h >"" "")=

13

£'Y1 , 1O 1 70 p

14 oK[ f2

1 21 p

15 P"" 6""D¤

1 18 , 2

""yf : G""1,D 1 28 p N+""2

d1[

, Ce 2 24 p

16 1 ·= >8 F,\

1 175 p

17 k8Y \

1 175 p

8,v , q¼R > A52 p

j"e 5 G\½ G5fU ;G_P¬ a G5f= <= >? L2e u'H 5 >

18

p

G"A)'h * - >8 X-2 :"# 5n= 7 5\"2 :

,=P)xe G8 ;h= -2 ,, G KDh a Hs :# 5nU ;G_P¬

#s X- ' WH ,

d® G1-2

¾Q p

C"Rf b"? a Z17D"a b? 0J¿ <= X'-2

^^Q VP)

19

p

:] XDY 5µ2 z G)'D

:

− ?e o2 X-

<

: |¹Àw X' F¹S

5

|""^e | ¹Y""e

""1Á d""ÂH ""¹< Â5Â ""¹Jv :

,´8 ´iÂ¿ WH G? H1 Ge H1

Ã ¹2 5b"w 5W"e ,

5 X' X^e , ` 6¹f

?Âc 5\" * qÁ[D > :

Âf5 ]- ÀqE ,Ä Q= ¹qÀ[D qe ?Âc 5\" * qÁ[D > :

18

* w G,8 X- :

0"R ·= G",8 "2 "<= 0_Y

""w 1 388 :

z\"" n""H 0"") >""? GDx""2 ,

x""e

ge jH n=

, > G= je We X"- u'"H

: ("2 ",8

Jv , u'"H2 g"? " (:8 L',

? X"- : sr G"P¬ a

GY"Rf * "J¿ c\ * g?

, * `\"f * X"-2

`" >" )" e

2 63 :

>" G"= j"e '"

X^e ,ge u'H :

"Jv ("2 ",8 ,

>"? (:"8 L'",

je Hs2 Y

: 7\ b? ,G_P¬ ²"f i#:" >

,q" >"82 ,k_"R2 ,"? * G-2 01,Q 2 * G?

N+2

p

19 C,I 2 191 p

(7)

Â5 ]- ÀqE ,Ä Q= ¹qÀ[D qe ?Âc 5\" * qÁ[D > :

>8 Åje >8 ?e X^e VR?

Â5 X'" " "f= : p

X"-

|- X- ? |¹- FH "H 1 "15 dH < ÂÀ ¹Jv :

5C"15, X^e , Ã2 ,58 ´iÂ¿ WH G? H1 Ge :

[ n'E E 2 Ä ¹8 #D8 ^ 8 Æ¹Rf L:À2 ¹q 5= ,

\

(

20

p

X'" 5 GJ L:5 (s d® 0^ 2

− G"?

5Y""2 c 5\""

− G""? ""[, 2 ,

c""J§ :""#2

³""

>"" j""e 5 c""J§ >""? =P"")= (""s j""2 ,

u'H 5 p Z 8Z U2 :

5 ! fj? k

;h8 8d) L+Lg " a >"5µ ^J 2 :

(Y5, , X'S a '#2 W"e ")Q 08 ,v

' , G? VÇ a2 ,`S dI8 Q GP a :Ae

"Q :"] "8 ;D 5qE ,Q ºh * G" 5"ª2 ,

G? P ,

^ tr j) 0Ae ,

?Gf[ > ¿ 2=

¹'- b? (s * q 0#= FDS :

8?P X!

G"B' >" "¿ G"5f= : ,

Ç a2 V

20 L:~ >, G,, * L: 5~ 2

2 254 q-8 404 ,

qHv2 3 257 q-8 5023 p

y,2 : d1[ q

5 41 Èev X-2 , :

³x"8 a ,

G""8 ,

""w=2 L""l1 7""w * G

p

""y, : L""1 D""e

10 600 yf 1U G77w2 , :

>," FB2 7w

L: 5~

1 404 p

G?

p

"R,Q '"8= X"- G82

21

,

("2

22

,

L'"52

23

,

Ce 5O2

24

,

i#: C# <= >? 22

25

p

8"?

: 5C""15, 5n= − ¹h 5"" ""8 '""h= G87""w=2

,

"Rv L:"8 n2 5Je ,d®2 A n2eY 'fH2 ,

n'¿ e x8 (:8 n2 a2,

26

p

c""J ""Q= ""- −

""8 >"" F_""5 D""e

21 dI\ j

1 146 p 2 yf : j_,\ j_8

2 166 ,

>8? >8 Q2

2 581 p

22 oK[ f2

2 373 p 0H 2 ¶D * X-2

3 43 :

v =2 f

,

[Y, Q= \^ sr ;#2 ,

H D

"

,

FDSe :

"^ > Qa qA? i¬ 0#

, i7DY" 2=

?

'- b?

, X[ e 'Q= ne ,

U b? qA? a2 A

r '¿ n , 2 r 2P * FDSe (s 8 'Q= n ,

=2

r

"e [ n

° >"[ n É c2 ,

>"[ 2 "e DY"

G?

, 2 r nH n É

`S CRe DY c2

p

23 C,I 5 70 p

24 U 2 140 p Z:A * X-2 :

tr "w- ^ 2) >2

[ 01- jB' ,

0"S sr W"H G"B' >" Q= (Y, = qE

)v [ , [ > Gh^ nH Q = qE

1 . 203 p

25 G"'# >"8 ¦7"r2 <= 0_Y

5 2107 p 2 "yf

* cd1[ ^D :

b? ` 0_Y <= i#:

2 207 ,

C"",I2 5 70 p >"" )"" ""e * `\""f * X""-2

` 3 429 :

G'-

(Y", G" "8 nr q"E :

>" "Q=

GB'

i#: :#

p

= GP G,?2 ,Z7wU G?2 j") n

,

G? a2 ,^ > 7e p

Q2 a'- ? * #Hs

p

26 C,I 5 70 , L^ cJ?2

9 141 p

(8)

f

,

^J j) 2 p

5K" "1? >8 X- − :

Ls * "5 "JD? 5q"E

f > F_5 > 01-= Q nWE , c^

27

p

Y 8Z ! :

= >? 2 ^ tr j) G5f= <

7e

^ n2 > Q= G5fU (s2 ; 5" G"Pe ,

L:5H v X'S

28

p

GA)'h * - >8 X-2 :

5w= X52U ,

H2

Q G? i¬ >5µ ^ 2¬ > b? 0J¿ <=

;

5C15, X'^

:

Â ¹d"® >" À>ÂA¹"? ;"h= ¹>"Â2 À>] À>#

¹>ÂJe (s n2 nH ¹>2 ,c¹J2 ÀMv = ¹>5 Âµ À>ÂA#=

¹f= 9¹Q À[ > À[ 0 ¹#= ;5DQ x O

29

p

8 GA)'h - >8 05?2 z W

:

N"1 G)2 b? ^ n2 0\Q G5f= − ,

n"[e

n[ (s 0#xH G, Q G

30

p

G"P, n"H >" 5n= tr ÊR X'^ :# 5nU2 −

"^ tr ¶"S sr ^ n2 G"P, tr "? 5q"E ,

,

Q =2

^ tr ¶2 GP ,

G8 0_- a2

31

p

27 AJ5D , K 1? >8a

22 290 p

28 G"'# >8 ¦7r2 <= 0_Y

5 2107 p "yf2

* cd""1[ ""^D :

""<= i#:"" z""? `"" 0_Y""

2 207 , C,I2 5 70 p

29 Ll1 7w

2 554 q-8 1452 p

30 C,I 5 70 p

31 k8Y \

5 70 p

Gf=− X'" X'^ F¤

:

n"H ¹>"Je

:H2 ÂG¹#= ¹>Je À>Ë2

n'"´ "À[ 0"¹#= ;DQ (:[e ,

A,

32

p

5D q 0#= X'^f G)'D :# @ 5µ2 :

− ( X- :

0"#= >" ") 5n= '" (:"H2

H 6 nRY8 )Q G |f ,

nRY? Ì1e ,

a '#2

nRY? > 5M¿ n= G 8 5qE , 5Mv nRY? > 5M7e ,

,

^ 2) - G5fU ;^ > ºh G? VÇ a2 ,

5M"¿ n= 2") " "8 G" "8 5qE , 5Mv a '#2 ,

5M7e , 2") "- n"H nr2 ,G" 8 9Q > JD2

^ , G? a2

33

p

− Ce 5O X- :

" {Q a 5>A? ;h= >Je

cJ? a2 5M¿ n= G 8 5qE ,^ 2e ,

,

"JD 2=

,

G"h^ ("s n"H2 ,G" 21 9Q > 5Mv8 50#=

W"H

O"f= >:5 G#= ^ n'[

@ 2 G", 2= 5M"v n2"

Of= Q cJ

@

= ;, :#2 ,G, 2 X'

G'^8 : = ¹>"5 Âµ À>Â#Â ¹d"® >" À>ÂA¹"? ;h= ¹>Â2 À>] À>#

c ¹J2 ÀMv

34

;

" {Q " a ^ 2) :# 5nU

cJ? a2

35

p

32 qY 7w

2 838 q-8 1454 p

33 oK[ f2

2 373 p

34 Ll1 7w

2 554 q-8 1452 p

35 U 2 140 yf2 , : Z:A 1 203 p

(9)

|De= G82

v 8 * J_5 ,5

36

p

R 8L U2 :

m:& L: \- :

7 g1 0" z"v > GA1= 2 Xl

¶'52 ' 5Y

37

p

36 q- o'DR

22414 V"De j-' :

,X@" 2 9"Q

G 5\f :#2 : >? 50^h a c~R c5) , ZD,f V' g CR5m' >7f "-2 ,c"J VU ,D5f GDh 5x8 ,'w2 82 ,A= EE 9"Q c5") >" "7f 0"Ae ,"Q X'Q c'S FDS ,Ae J^ ,71w=

?F_5 * ^ tr j)f 2=

¶ " 5 >" q[2- Q q[5f=2 ,Hs WH j-' nH sr : c"J 5f )22 ,cJ q[D5f * g 0J 0)U c5

c5) * , ;v :# * q[h^ C#2 ,c5) > n'§ q[5f°e

"^ n2 n"H >2 ,^ n2 c5) 5nU ,

"S '"#2 ¶

v 2Q 5w 5 ;Ge '# L:5 Gf[ > cJ ¿ G5f°e ,

5C15, >?

A#U |-' |5-2 5 X- G5f=

: >2 5>] 5>#

n"H >"Je ,c"J2 5Mv = >5µ 5>A#= d® > 5>A? ;h=

G"#= > GAJe 5>Ë2 p

pp 9"v p G"? k"R5D p

"2 *2 :

n2 nH >2 xO"f= 9"Q >" GAJe (s

* n"H nr "5=

u') 5 q[? i)'e qH8 > 2^ Q cJ q[D5f :"# * c5") > qDQ= n°e ,G, Q 2 qH8 ^ tr

"5[ * 8:"h e q[, Q2 50H be v ,

b"? u5'"h2

q[ KD ^ > Q º~ ;A_^e p

82 ,k"e'5D

q52 G17w2 GT2 5J ,51f b? 5bw2 p

VDe 2 J '71 J_5 ,5 p

http://www.alifta.net/Fatawa/FatawaSubjects.aspx?languagena me=ar&View=Page&HajjEntryID=0&HajjEntryName=&Ram adanEntryID=0&RamadanEntryName=&NodeID

37 ¶'¹´

Ázv > ¹Â : ,

C, :

"8 ¸"¿ ' Gf=

,

=

"EE b"? ("s '") * q" 0"#= FDS X'-=

: 8?P ! :

GY1 ¿ ,

<= >? 2 '#2

38

p

8,3?

: 07[H , 5P > G5f= −

39

p

Y 8Z ! :

GY1 [

, V? X- G82 ,

L'52 ,

'E '8=2 , cD-2

40

p

! 9 8Z

"J? >"8 X"- G82 ,Ge \S 5 : ,

O""_?2

41

(""2 ,

42

Ce 5O""2 ,

43

o"" i#:""2 ,

R,v

44

<= i#: #m '#2 ,

45

p

= ,Z nY yf

2 276 N7\" "D¤2 ,

1 88

M c % ¸' q2 ,

297 p

38 u2""R 3 334 p 6""D¤ b""? Í""HP N * X""-2

C- :

>" j", n= ², :# * <=2 C- H #m

s q7D 01 b? (

3 143 p

39 C,I 3 334 p

40 1" ·= >"8 F,\"

3 283 q-"8 14217 , C"",I2

5 159 p

41 1 ·= >8 F,\

3 143 p yf2 : oK[ C^A1 >,

5 52 q-8 8860 p

42 oK[ f2

2 462 , cdS:2 3 304 p

43 Z:""A 1 208 , d""1[ L2""v2

11 277 ""Ë2 ,

¶D7 7 151 p

44

£'Y"""1 , Æ"""S«

4 128 , """^ D"""e N2

2 442 p

45 ,u",- >D" >? u,^ `OH

2 448 ,

¢2= i"2

=

(10)

ID8#?

:

1? 9Q − J? >8

: 5 X'" jJ GÀf=

"2 ÂZ^5,2 Â>¹ÀR^ >? À>ÂAÂ ¹Qr * V Y5, ;Ë

(s 8 ¹g1¹D2 , ÂZ5 > nR?ÀP2 ³¹' Àg 2= "{ÂQ 2= {P"S 2= , R ¹\" ÂZ"5 Ân'= > ¹|À1 Q=

{RS 2= \J- 2= 02 Î

46

p

− X- G5f= jef >? LÂ2 2 :

J? >8 VYf nH

R\2 zv >Y1 Gh,82

" 5>"#2 , ,

"[, a

1? (s

47

p

−

|- 5Ë= O_? >? LÂ2 2 :

"7 g1"h

g1h

#5P S > XQ C#2 ,

48

AQ2 #5P-2

49

p

= ;A, 2 353 , C,I2 5 159 p

46 2 ·= >,"""

2 166 q-"""8 1827 qH"""v 22 ,

1 661 -8 q 1788 p X-2 :

b"? 7"w 9Q :#

"")½ 2 qY"" £

p d"", ""1 * X""-2

6 327 :

MD ,r X)2

q

*

77\"

>"8 "J "S

iQw ¦7r

LI

;

G" ¶"S= W"fr2 ,G8 D¿ WË°e

8D qY

1a X-2 ، :

7"w >Y"Q ,"r p

"y, :

·= 7w 2

6 90 q-8 1603 p

47 1 ·= >8 F,\

3 143 C,I2 , 5 160 p

48 ´P : Y '8= X- >" MY",h Z"E a 52= `2 ´P :

G5H X'J n `2 5P 2 ,Q1 C#2 ,q8r2 `'w q8 >

p Z CJ?= ,Z5 > 5P^2 p

y, : nY"

Z 5 345 ³2 ¶h2 ,

15 136 b? j2 ,

,j,^ Z'8=

1 352 5PS c p

49 1"" ·= >""8 F,\""

3 282 p

""yf2 : C""^A1 >,""

=

− :"", >""8 X""- :

d""I8 G"", j"", '""¬ a

5Q

50

p

GA)'h * - >8 X-2 :

"<= "H 0J¿2

Ge ;#[ b? j, * C- 2

", 5P >

, GA1"2

07[ * e a WH Ge e a2 ,JE 8 07[8

51

p

5D q 0#= X'^f G)'D :# @ 5µ2 :

jef >? LÂ2 − :

G"h,82 "J? >8 VYf nH

R\2 zv >Y1 "1? (s [, a 5>#2 ,

52

p

£'Y1 * X-2

53

:

? >?2 V

G"5f= t"h

"Q * z"v g1 VY5, [

a G"5f= 7 5\"2 p

J? >8 >? LÂ2 -2 ,G8 ³x8 VYf g1 nH G5f=

<

""Q ""Q * z""v

54

¹h="" X'"" o=2 ,

|18 ne'h ,

9"v i"#s >" n'" WA?2 ,

(:8 ³x8 a G5f= 5Xe

55

p

= oK[

5 52 q-8 8860 , C,I2 5 160 p

50 VW i#: b? `

3 263 p

51 C,I 5 160 p

52 ¦"" ""1? F,\""

11 69 q-""8 19932 , C"",I2

5 160 p

53

£'Y1 , ÆS«

4 128 p

54 EU M k1 p

55 F@ Hs L: ÈR5 : 9v )= 2 ,

ÈR8 W5fr2 : 5nr

5 X' Dh= Â>J Â0#= > Â ¹h=

> Ân' Â WA¹?2

5 X' X^e , Åi#s :

Â>¹' Â WH5' n= ÂnÀ1 §=

=

(11)

[ ( >[ 2 zv g1 7J

56

p

L2v * X-2 :

", 5P2 z"v "] 8=2

57

p

X-2 = −

− : 9 5O 0P a G5fU

58

p

5²f2

<=

X"^e ,'" b"? 0"1,Q 2 * :

zv 7 g1h

59

p

Z7wU 'A :# b?2

60

p

"Jh >"8 " " X-2 :

n= ³x"8 a2

g1h R\2 zv 7

61

p

2 F U2 6DX n ]^ 3? _ o M8 Kp :

q G 2 J

U2 L+Lg n"8 * 0") 5 J_ |fH sr :

;D

c 5\" "Ae 6"^h a eY" WA,82 , ,

|"fH 2=

JD c"HPH "¼H |"fH2 ,}"8 tr A8 5qB ,

`S dI8 Dl

62

p

eY" n"1 "8 n"H nr2

6- ¹'- b? (s * q 0#= FDSe , :

= Åf >

D- ? X"- ,Â5 X' 2 ,a : :

Â5 Àk"Q "5xe

:# * W[¹?

p y, : 0"1,Q >"8 <= ,Y

2 204 q-"8

6901 p

56 oK[ f2

2 462 p

57 d1[ L2v

11 277 p

58 \ k8Y 11 281 p

59 ÍHP N

1 496 p

60 k8Y \

1 497 p

61 cJ N

3 94 p

62 C,I 4 63 p

8?P ! :

5n=

b"? KD GYRf q[Q X 0[

Q Gh cHP GRe 8 \Âf nH nr , tr 5q a2 ,e 5ar2 ,

S 1 * L:5 X

63

'"# "<= >? X'^ :#2 ,

i#: > 7\

64

,

G'- #y8 5MDQ2 :

a2

Å¦ Á""RD ""8 j""J ¬

O"" S Åj""ÂJD ""8 ¦ À""R a2 ,

Â- 5\

65

p

XH WË'H * ¹) ¹ uWD) 5E= 5 G5fU2 ;"5DQ "Q' 0") 5 X ¦~e 5E@ n= i¬ Q'

¹H G¬

66

p

:, >8 X- :

:"# q"?= a d"® >"? X'"^

<=

67

p

Y 8Z ! a - 5RD n8 * c _ G >Je :

X""- G""82 ;±¹"" ""A, ¦\"" :""Sx

""R,Q '""8=

68

,

63 G? V,82 : c n'8= 8 * ²lO nH ' ,

G"2

−

"=

−

nh Ge c n'8= ST 8 * p

64 ` > ) e * `\f

3 83 , X-2 : '#2

i#: > 7\

p yf2 : u",- >D" >"? u,^ `OH

2 264 p

65 Ll1 7w

6 2551 q-8 1801 p

66 C,I 4 63 p

67 VW i#: b? `

3 17 p

68

£'Y1 , 1O 2 74 p j_,\ j_8 * X-2 :

G'-2 :

jJD 8 ¦R a2 ,

L=

: ( * , q,"I > n'fWE G 0)H

"DRD¤ D? * , =

c"Q2 c" G"? i"¬ G"f ,

= '"2

jJD ¦R n= ¦\

,

) ËxH Ae ,

A, :Sxe =

(12)

(2

69

Ce 5O2 ,

70

<= >? 22 ,

71

p

¸1"B sr A1Q"w2 ,¦ 5RD 8 jJ¬ a G5fU −

Ge?2 (s V^R * A ,GYR,8 '# ¶S=

72

p

"#2 `D""S j"" i""ª "¼H 5n= b""? 5X"" :

8 \"Âf ¬ a Gf'[ ;#:Sx a C? 5Y 5n= 5ar ,n1

JD H (" "5xe ,"Ae Xv ^^Q q a2 ,

"DS :"#2 ,cH 5P V= G? H 8 \Âf G[J8 Z ·=

, VA^R _ i#:2

73

p

'# :#2 7 5\

− t"h V" nr

− G"'^

:

c c 8= *

74

G1= Q2 ( G5fU2 ,

J_ 5Y d® 2= 8^D n8 * nH ' p

GA)'h * - >8 X-2 :

* <= H 0J7f2

X" 5Z "5=2 ,#:Sx a ¦5\ 5n= b? t2U 25 1 Q= * R ¶le )Q jB' G5fU ;>¹

75

p

= (s G g h

; jJD ( nU ,

G"^Rh ("J "e

.

2 29 , yf2 : ^ De N

2 174 p

69 K[ f2 o

2 333 cdS:2 ,

3 132 p

70 u'J 5 402 yf2 , : L1 De

3 314 p

71 C,I 4 63

<= X-2 , :

(s ¸1B sr A1Qw ,

Ge?2 ,

V^R * A GYR,8 '# ¶S=

p yf2 : >"? u,^ `OH

u,- >D

2 201 , u2R2 2 264 p

72 C,I 4 63 , u2R2 2 264

73 C,I 4 63 p

74 Ll1 7w

2 527 q-8 1386 p

75 C,I 4 63 p

5D q 0#= X'^f G)'D :# @ 5µ2 :

−

^ De N * X- :

Z\5, 5n= oh a=

G"e i"ª ( cQ2 j ,[= * ¦R ,

(" >"2

c fWE * A-R nx8 8 \Âf WA¬ n= C? 5Y g

;",Je , ¹f[

"8 ¦"R a j"JD

¦"R a G"5f= :

"A >+"2 "_ 2= , fW5 8 C? 5Y EE2 ¹8 \Âf

76

p

f2 * X- :

G" 2 ,c" n'"8= G" >

tr AJ""B c""R, n'""8= ""ST ""8 * G""2 ,n'"8=

jJ > C? 5Y :S=2 ,

77

p

C, : cQ2 c 5ar :Sx a p

u'J * X-2 :

q[Q |1 G5f= ,2

5ËxH d\h2 ,fW5 *

D¤ A5H

; "Q' X" 5nU

}8 tr G8 5q

¦ 5Rh nr2 , Gf8 5h2 ,

78

p

L=

¹h G, :Sx a : c" W5fr2 ,

, k"e= :"#2

C5HP8 p

"# 82 U2 f 8h r . :

:

L+Lg :U2 `\" > `6 n= 5\ 0#

1 > G8 o~O cH 5P

;

?kD n= 0)U

X'-= EE b? (s * q 0#= FDS :

76 ^ De N

2 174 p

77 oK[ f2

2 333 cdS:2 ,

3 132 p

78 u'J 5 402 p

(13)

8?P ! ,Z-5 ¦D? cH 5P `É '¬ :

( X'- :#2

79

<= >? 22 ,

, i#: C#

80

p

8"?

:

G'- 'J8

− th

− :

†Îûuρ 

É>$s%Ìh9$#

〈

8'D :

60

,

Ge #m '# 08 ,>^ X2,D '#2 sr 1- 5 5n°e ;

G'^H ,Gr |e6f |^=

− th

− :

ãƒÌóstGsù

7πt7s%u‘

〈

VY, : 92

^h2

Z- 5 ¦D?r *2 ,

81

p

G"e c"H 5P `É "e ,1- 5 ¦D?r G5fU2 −

8D[ * GeH

82

p

! :Y Z

' ? ,

Ce 5O" X"- G82

83

,

<= >? 22

84

:

79 ( X-2 :

"#Ïa2 n'"[2 ,c"H 5P >" 1- 5 kD? P¬

Y ?W

J

p y, : L"l1 7w N

, X"8 >"8a

3 495 H:Da2 ,

3 212 K1? >8 X-2 , :

:#2

( i#:

p

80

`" >" ) e * `\f * X- :

3 231 :

WA^=2 ,D2 b? ?A^D 1- A, L~O n= '¬ 0#2

"72 ,²lD2 ,C,I2 ,] * 6"D¤2 ,N+"2 ,

k_R2 ,u2R2 ,q >8 p

¯Qr : i#:" '"#2 ,'"¬

p

yf2 : G'# >8 ¦7r2 <= 0_Y

3 1117 p

81 C,I 9 320 p

82 k8Y \

9 320 p

83 y, : U 2 69 , Z:A2 1 172 , `D"S 6"D¤2

VW 1 482 p

84 a X-

<=

:

G"e 2 cHP > kD a2 ,

|",H "-2

kD n= tr c i#s=

, G",? |",1) r qE

"yf . : 0_Y"

=

8"?

:

− X'- ;, 5n=

− th

− :

†Îûuρ

É>$s%Ìh9$#

〈

n'1h[ q#

q#?= F,w 50H 5nx8 5MDQ2 p

n= i¬ Z- 5 (:[e ,(J5D 01 b? - 5\

- 5\ (5 > G8 n'[

p 12 (J a

8 j2 ,fW5 `,wU Hs 5n°e , =2 - 5\

V^R 8 jJe ,;, * ¹8Â^D ¹R,w 50H

2 ,HY2 q'- R5@2 8 j

W 5ËU ;

f2 * 5r2 ,- 5\ 1) * 5r ,W nDY 01 5Y >8 8 j2 ,JY * W^D ; 012

;, ,I2 Z- 5 8 j2 ,eY j- '#2 ,

n'5 I :SxH GD8DH I ih[ :Sxe

85

p

9 8Z ! :

H 1- kD a2 n p

X- G82

R,Q '8=

86

,

i"h[ n" G"f= (" >"? 22

87

,

<= >? 22

88

p

= "w 0R ·= G,8 2 <=

3 243

"y,2 :

<= i#: b? ]

% 561 p

85 Ll1 7w N

, X8 >8a

3 496 p

86 j_,\""" j_"""8

2 45 p L"""D1 """8 N """]2

1 113 p

87 H:Da 3 212 p

88

`" >" ) e * `\f * X- :

3 231 :

1- GhH > kD a G,?2 p

A,JE * >[

p [8 '8= X- :

H 1- kD a p

? * X- :

"1- "A, k"D a G",?2

a2 G,?2 ,h A8

p A,JE * 08

p