• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

Money Machine

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2023

Membagikan "Money Machine"

Copied!
320
0
0

Teks penuh

At the other end of the spectrum—from greed to fear—the stock market crashes of 2002 and 2009 left suitcases full of $100 bills on the sidewalks. Think of the money you will receive if you own the machine (and leave yourself a margin for error).

VALUE INVESTING

SEEING THROUGH THE HYPE

But again I heard nothing about whether share prices were too high, too low or just right. They didn't talk about whether stock prices were too high, too low or just right.

SPECULATION VERSUS INVESTING

IMAGINE turning $1,000 into $34,500 in less than a year!" The letter said that "no special background or training" was needed and that "it's an investment you can make with extra money you'd normally spend on lottery tickets or the racetrack." Second red flag: I don't buy lottery tickets or bet on horses. To demonstrate the "explosive profit potential," the letter listed twenty low-cost stocks and said $100 invested in each ($2,000 total) would have grown instantly to $26,611 .

SEMI-EFFICIENT MARKETS

Morgan was exactly right when he said that "the market will rise and fall, but not necessarily in that order." It's a heads up and we have our winner - the student who correctly predicted five in a row.

FIGURE 3-1.  Shareholder return in adjacent three-year periods
FIGURE 3-1. Shareholder return in adjacent three-year periods

TORTURING DATA

In the same way, stock market sentiment can be gauged by observing stock prices; additional news about the economy or specific companies would be disruptive. The accuracy of the Super Bowl indicator is nothing more than a fun coincidence fueled by the fact that the stock market usually goes up and the NFC usually wins the Super Bowl.

FIGURE 4-1.  A graph of closing prices reveals a channel
FIGURE 4-1. A graph of closing prices reveals a channel

In fact, some human brains behind the computers boast that they don't understand why their computers choose to trade. The computers bought many of the futures contracts that the fund was selling, then sold them seconds later.

BAUBLES AND BUBBLES

They saw how much prices had risen in the past and assumed that the same would be true in the future. Skeptics watched the ups and downs in the S&P and concluded that Madoff's performance claims were mathematically impossible. In the spring of 1720, Sir Isaac Newton said: "I can calculate the motions of the heavenly bodies, but not the follies of men".

When a banker invested £500 in the third offering of South Sea shares, he explained that "when the rest of the world is angry, we have to imitate them to some extent". In 1999, a small Internet company called NetJ.com filed an SEC statement that was relentlessly candid: "The company is not currently engaged in any substantial business activity and has no plans to engage in such activity in the foreseeable future. ." A modern nivender. However, the fact that stocks have beaten bonds in the past does not guarantee that stocks will beat bonds in the future.

FIGURE 5-1.  The risks of speculation
FIGURE 5-1. The risks of speculation

INTRINSIC VALUE

The net asset value of these most blue-chip companies certainly didn't go up or down by double digits every few months. This is the time value of money: a dollar today is worth more than a dollar tomorrow. Because you act as if you will hold a stock forever and receive dividends forever, the net asset value of the stock is the present value of these dividends.

To implement the intrinsic-value model, we need to specify the future dividends and a required return, which Williams called an investor's "personal interest rate." The required return for stocks certainly depends on the returns available on other investments, such as Treasury bonds. The JBW equation also demonstrates how important the growth rate is to the value of a share. When interest rates rise or fall, so do the required returns used to determine the intrinsic value of stocks.

FIGURE 6-1.  Dow Jones Industrial Average, August 26, 2015, to August 25, 2016
FIGURE 6-1. Dow Jones Industrial Average, August 26, 2015, to August 25, 2016

INVESTMENT BENCHMARKS

To apply Bogle's model, we need to predict the rate of earnings growth and the change, if any, in the price-earnings ratio. Shiller calculates a cyclically adjusted P/E ratio (CAPE) by dividing the inflation-adjusted value of the S&P 500 by cyclically adjusted earnings. A money manager passionate about growth stocks wrote: “The time to buy a growth stock is now.

Perhaps the Dogs of the Dow aren't as far out of favor as dogs not in the Dow. Another plausible identification of out-of-favor stocks is the ratio of stock price to book value. One study calculated the ratio of market value to book value for the S&P 500 on January 1 of each of forty-five years from .

FIGURE 7-1.  The S&P 500 earnings yield (E/P) and long-term Treasury rate (R),    1871–2015
FIGURE 7-1. The S&P 500 earnings yield (E/P) and long-term Treasury rate (R), 1871–2015

THE CONSERVATION OF VALUE

If the stock splits 2-for-1, with no change in the company's business, the total market value should remain at $60 million, implying a market value of $30 per share: doubling the stock halves the value of each . It is as if the company sends a message to its shareholders every three months: “The company is doing well; please send money to the IRS.”. A legendary fund manager wrote, "If a company buys back half of its stock and the total earnings stay the same, earnings per share have just doubled." The obvious shortcoming is that the company may have to liquidate half of its assets to buy back half of its stock.

Over the long term, dividends, earnings and stock prices have grown faster than consumer prices. In the short term, however, an increase in the inflation rate has not reliably increased stock prices. In the short run, there is no correlation between inflation and stock returns.

Table 8-1 shows the consequences for this company. Either way,  the $20 million payout reduces the firm’s total value from $400  mil-lion to $380 milmil-lion
Table 8-1 shows the consequences for this company. Either way, the $20 million payout reduces the firm’s total value from $400 mil-lion to $380 milmil-lion

WE’RE ONLY HUMAN

Objects shown for longer periods of time or with greater background contrast are rated more favorably

Statements like “Osorno is in Chile” are more likely to be judged true if written in colors that are easier to read

Aphorisms that rhyme are more likely to be judged true; for example, “Woes unite foes” versus “Woes unite enemies.”

For each trading day from the beginning of 1984 (when smart ticker symbols began to become popular) to the end of 2005, we have the daily return for a portfolio of the smart ticker stocks that received the most votes in our survey, calculate. Overall, compounded annual returns were 24 percent for the smart ticker portfolio and 12 percent for the market portfolio. The market-beating performance was not because the smart-tick stocks were concentrated in one industry.

Our eighty-two smart ticker companies span thirty-one of the eighty-one industry categories used by the United States. Nor was it due to the extraordinary performance of a small number of smart ticker stocks: 65 per cent. the smart ticker stocks beat the market. Perhaps a smart ticker is a useful barometer of managerial ability, which reveals itself over time as the company repeatedly outperforms investors' expectations.

FIGURE 9-6.  Clever-ticker portfolio relative to market
FIGURE 9-6. Clever-ticker portfolio relative to market

VALUE INVESTING APPLIED

THE RIGHT ATTITUDE

The average annual return on the stocks in the S&P 500 was 12 percent, which is not only positive, but much higher than the average return on Treasury bills or bonds. Even if two-thirds of the funds underperform the market, invest only in the one-third that beats the market. Instead of trying to pick stocks that can beat a market index, an index fund buys the stocks in the index.

John Bogle wrote his senior thesis at Princeton on the failure of mutual funds to beat the S&P 500 and concluded that the way to beat most mutual funds was to buy the shares in the S&P 500. One of the most popular is the Vanguard 500 Index Fund, which contains the 500 stocks in the S&P 500. In the stock market, some investors do better and others do worse, but their total return is equal to the market return minus investment costs.

FIGURE 10-1.  Annual returns from S&P 500 stocks since 1926
FIGURE 10-1. Annual returns from S&P 500 stocks since 1926

KISS

Another wrinkle is that the capital gains tax rate is lower for long-term holdings (more than a year). Even after one year, there are continued tax-deferral benefits to continue earning tax-deferred dividends and capital gains. If you don't sell, you can continue to earn dividends and capital gains on the full $20,000.

Essentially, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has loaned you your $2,800 tax liability, and the only "interest" you pay on this loan is taxes on the extra dividends and capital gains. The "annual trader" strategy is to rotate the portfolio each year and hold each year's portfolio just long enough to qualify for a 15 percent long-term capital gains tax. Tax is paid on realized capital gains and saved on realized capital losses.

TABLE 11-1.  Wealth for buy-and-hold vs. portfolio turnover
TABLE 11-1. Wealth for buy-and-hold vs. portfolio turnover

TIMING THE MARKET

That was lower than the 6.26 percent return on ten-year Treasuries, indicating that stocks were not an attractive long-term investment. In December 2008 and (to a lesser extent) in August 2016, the earnings yield was well above the Treasury rate, indicating that stocks were an attractive investment. The price-earnings ratio was 28.3 in March 2000, and I considered four different scenarios for the price-earnings ratio ten years earlier, in 2010.

Unless investors expected a significant increase in the price-earnings ratio of the S&P 500, stocks were not an attractive investment. The S&P 500 price-to-earnings ratio was 24, and I considered four different scenarios for the price-to-earnings ratio in 2026. Stocks were cheap in August 2016, so it was a good time to be in the market (and I'm saying this at This time).

TABLE 12-1.  Three different valuations using the JBW equation Dividend
TABLE 12-1. Three different valuations using the JBW equation Dividend

PICKING STOCKS

At the time, Apple's dividend yield of 2.28 percent was slightly higher than the S&P 500, making it slightly more attractive. stocks if we use the same 5 percent dividend growth rate for Apple and the S&P 500. I've also done a more complicated calculation of the present value of Apple's dividends, assuming Apple's dividends grow at 10 percent per year for 20 years, then fall to a growth rate of 5 percent, roughly the expected long-term growth rate of the economy. Due to Apple's rapid growth, the $3.73 average over this ten-year period is an underestimation of Apple's current and projected future revenues.

Conversely, for Apple, long-term growth is more important than year-to-year fluctuations, and the ten-year average is a misleading representation of Apple's earnings. Apple was slightly less attractive than the overall S&P 500, but there was still a 4.42 percentage point difference between Apple's cyclically adjusted earnings yield and the real 10-year Treasury yield. If Apple's earnings and dividends grow by more than 5 percent per year over the next ten years and/or its P/E is higher than 12 in 2026, the rate of return on Apple stock will be higher than 7.28 percent—perhaps much higher.

TABLE 13-1.  Using the JBW equation to value Apple stock, August 2016 Dividend
TABLE 13-1. Using the JBW equation to value Apple stock, August 2016 Dividend

Gambar

FIGURE 3-3.  ESPH daily volume of trading
FIGURE 4-2.  The GSR 1970–1985
FIGURE 5-1.  The risks of speculation
FIGURE 6-2.  Nike, August 26, 2015, to August 25, 2016
+7

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

If the result from each test is similar or higher than critical value of α= 0.05, therefore the null hypothesis (H0) is rejected because there is a significant