• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

An assessment of the capacity of waterfront developments to adapt to climate change : a case study of the Point Waterfront Area, Durban.

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2023

Membagikan "An assessment of the capacity of waterfront developments to adapt to climate change : a case study of the Point Waterfront Area, Durban."

Copied!
107
0
0

Teks penuh

Chapter One: Introduction

Background of the study

According to Girardet (2008), naturally occurring gases such as carbon dioxide (CO2) and water vapor (H2O) store heat in the atmosphere, which then causes the greenhouse effect. However, Ballito has one of the lowest coastal profiles in the province (between 0 and 15 m.a.s.l.) and was the worst affected” (Smith et al, 2007:2).

Research Problem

However, the plan, which has become successful in the effort to revive the area, was launched in 1998 but has since faced complications that have caused delays. According to the Durban Point Waterfront website (2009), plans to revitalize the area have been discussed for decades, but the current vision was only formulated in 2002.

Objectives and key questions

Main objective

To inform eThekwini Municipality and Point Waterfront area development in particular, based on international and local precedents on climate change adaptation and waterfront development. To propose climate change adaptation solutions in the Point Waterfront development.

Research question

To inform similar developments in South Africa, such as Cape Town Waterfront, on the adaptation of waterfront developments to climate change; And. What solutions can be implemented in response to the threat that climate change poses to Point Waterfront development?

Hypothesis

Structure of dissertation

Introduction

Conceptual framework

This chapter outlines the methodology used to assess the adaptability of the Point Waterfront development to climate change through a case study. All respondents were asked questions about the adaptability of the Point Waterfront development to climate change. Based on the findings, one could argue that the Point Waterfront is adapting to climate change.

In the case of Point Waterfront there are a number of climate change factors forcing society to adapt. It is not possible to speculate on the costs of climate change adaptation measures in the Point Waterfront area due to the fact that the project has not been completed. The analysis has shown that adaptation to climate change at Point Waterfront is in place.

One could argue that, to an extent, Point Waterfront is ready for climate change. Current adaptation and planning measures at Point Waterfront are in place according to climate change projections. In what ways would you say climate change will affect the development of Point Waterfront?.

How informed are people living in the Point Waterfront area about climate change? To what extent has the community been made aware of climate change adaptation measures in Point Area? What climate change knowledge would you consider critical regarding the Point Waterfront?

To what extent have you ever been involved in the planning of Point Waterfront's climate change adaptation measures?

Figure 1: Tourists having a good time in the flooded streets of Venice (November, 2012)Source :( Getty  Images)
Figure 1: Tourists having a good time in the flooded streets of Venice (November, 2012)Source :( Getty Images)

International and local precedents waterfront developments and adaption to

Research methodology

The advantages and disadvantages of the research methodology adopted by this research are clearly described in this chapter. Topics covered in this chapter include the research paradigm, contextual considerations, research limitations, selecting a research strategy, research design, and an overview of the methods used to process the data.

Findings and analysis

Conclusion and recommendations

Chapter Two: Conceptual Framework

  • Introduction
  • Sustainable development
  • Climate change
  • Global warming
    • Cyclones/hurricanes
    • El Nino
    • Droughts
    • Sea level rise
  • Waterfront developments
    • Commercial waterfronts
    • Residential waterfronts
    • Industrial waterfronts
    • Recreational waterfronts
  • Adaptation to climate change
    • Global governance on adapting to climate change
    • National governance on adapting to climate change
    • Grass root level adaptation to climate change
  • Conclusion

Climate change is a long-term shift in weather statistics (including averages)” (www.nws.noaa.gov). However, some governments, having lost hope in the global community, have come up with their own ways of adapting to climate change.

Chapter Three: International and Local Precedents Waterfront Developments and

  • Introduction
  • The precedent studies
    • Venice, Italy
    • Brooklyn Waterfront, USA
    • Shanghai, China
    • Where??? Japan
    • Cape Town VA Waterfront, South Africa
    • KwaZulu-Natal Coast, South Africa
  • Conclusion

It is located in the swampy lagoon of Venice that stretches along the coast between the mouths of the Po and Piave rivers (Venezia, 2006). It is the capital of the Veneto region and is located in the northeastern part of Italy. Most of these adaptation measures require a huge amount of money, much of which is in the hands of the private sector.

The Brooklyn waterfront has faced a number of climate change events, some of which have resulted in flooding of the area. The reason for this is the belief of the strict adaptation measures they have in place, which then raises doubts about the flooding of the city. The rejection of these claims is based on knowledge of the adaptation measures the city has put in place for climate change.

The newspaper interviewed Xin, a deputy director of the Shanghai Flood Control Headquarters, who emphasized that the city's flood resistance. People fled to higher ground and abandoned their properties in the wake of the devastation associated with the tsunami. One of the objectives of the above report is to provide a specific evaluation of the threats and expenses to the city and its people.

Chapter Four: Research Methodology

  • Introduction
  • Research design
    • Qualitative research
  • The case study of the Point Waterfront development
  • Research setting
  • Data sources
    • Primary data
    • Secondary data
  • Ethical Considerations
  • Analysis
  • Conclusion

One can also argue that this research study is exploratory in terms of the purpose of investigation. This research is based on a case study of the Point Waterfront development, which was chosen because it is a typical waterfront development not only in eThekwini, but in South Africa in general. This research study is intended to contribute to learning as its results will be one of the few published, particularly focusing on adaptation to climate change.

Although there are many sampling techniques that one could use, purposive sampling was chosen in this study. This study mainly used these types of data collection tools by using interview schedules. This study used a number of these publications when referring to the municipality's plans in the field of climate change adaptation.

This research study has made use of journals in an attempt to understand climate adaptation issues at a deep level. This research study has used books to review literature and to cross-reference what eThekwini Municipality and other stakeholders, both locally and globally, are doing regarding climate adaptation. This research study respected these ethics, therefore no one was harmed or exploited in the data collection process.

Chapter Five: Findings and Analysis

  • Introduction
  • Presentation of the case study
    • Objectives of the Point Waterfront development
    • Actors and their roles
    • Sources of information
    • Sources of funding
  • Findings
    • Adaptation to climate change
    • Funding
    • Participation
  • Analysis and discussion
  • Conclusion

After the invasion of the Point in 1940 by not-so-wealthy whites, the area began to decline. The rise of suburbs on the edge of the city also played a major role in the Point's decline. Laurusco Developments Laurusco Developments are the project directors or development managers of Point Waterfront Development.

The municipality alone could not revitalize the area due to the astronomical costs associated with the process. To date, sums of money amounting to approximately R2.5 billion have been invested in the development of the Point area's infrastructure, including uShaka Marine World. Currently, the water surface of the canal system at the Point Waterfront is four meters above sea level.

According to the councilor, 60% of the Point area's residents attend these meetings and awareness programs. The protection of the beach, for example, benefits the Punt Waterfront because it lies along the coastline. This proves that the ridge-shaped design of the drainage system at the Point worked.

The design of the Point Waterfront area shows that the small craft harbor and properties close to the shore are at greatest risk. These appeals were against the development of certain parts of the Point Waterfront, particularly those closest to the shore.

Figure 6: The Point Waterfront and UShaka Theme Park. Source (DPDC)
Figure 6: The Point Waterfront and UShaka Theme Park. Source (DPDC)

Chapter Six: Conclusion and Recommendations

  • Introduction
  • Reflections on the research
  • Recommendations
  • Final Conclusion

Nevertheless, this dissertation's research was able to find important information about climate change adaptation measures in the area. These joint efforts will help make the Point Waterfront area more environmentally resilient to climate change. If the same strategy can be used to raise funds for climate change adaptation, the Point Waterfront will not need much intervention from outsiders regarding climate change adaptation measures.

The stakeholders expressed concern that securing funding for climate change remains a vexing issue. This research study showed that stakeholder participation is a crucial component of climate change adaptation. Funds must be collected in the form of levies, taxes and financial penalties for adaptation to climate change;.

This research aims to assess whether the Point Waterfront Development in Durban has adaptive measures to take care of climate change. After a review of other waterfront developments around the world facing the same problem, it became clear that Point Waterfront is lucky to be where it is, given the climate change. Vulnerability and resilience to climate change: Current research and population information needs.

To what extent do you think there is a need for adaptation to climate change? .. k) What climate change adaptation measures have been taken by relevant stakeholders in the development of Point Waterfront so far? .. l) To what extent would climate change adaptation measures have the capacity to succeed when put to the test? To what extent do you think it is your responsibility as planners to devise measures against climate change?

What have you heard about local community consultation in the Point Waterfront development decision-making process?. How do you think local community consultation in the decision-making process would help advance sustainable development in the Point Waterfront area?. How would you recommend such consultation? . j) Does the community operating in the Point Waterfront area have a clear understanding of the environmental impacts that sustainable development is likely to cause?. k) Looking at other developments around the world that are built near the sea, how might the Point Waterfront development cope with the likely impacts of climate change? .. l) To what extent would you say that the principles of sustainable development were used in this development?.

What can other waterfront developments in South Africa and the rest of the world learn from this development in terms of environmental concerns linked to climate change?. Do you think these measures have the capacity to work when put to the test of climate change?

How will this community consultation help in the decision-making process towards sustainable development in the Point Waterfront area? To what extent would you say that the principles of sustainable development have been implemented in this development? In your opinion, is there a need for adaptation to climate change in the Point Waterfront area? . j) What climate change adaptation measures have been taken by relevant stakeholders in the development of the Point Waterfront area.

Gambar

Figure 1: Tourists having a good time in the flooded streets of Venice (November, 2012)Source :( Getty  Images)
Figure 3: The Aftermath of Hurricane Sandy (2012). The streets of Brooklyn closer to the waterfront
Figure 6: The Point Waterfront and UShaka Theme Park. Source (DPDC)
Figure 7: Land Use variety in Point Waterfront. Source (DPDC).
+4

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

To improve capacity and reduce vulnerability to climate change, the participants suggested a number of actions, including actions focused on infrastructure development,

o Serve as a focal point, bringing the social forestry dimensions into ongoing climate change mitigation and adaptation deliberations and actively engage with ASEAN Member

eds., Nature‐based Solutions to Climate Change Adaptation in Urban Areas, Theory and Practice of Urban Sustainability Transitions, Effects of Urban Green Space on Environmental

This paper sought to fill this knowledge gap by exploring the impact of climate change and variability on subsistence farming communities and the adaptation strategies devised by

Context Climate change impacts perspective Vulnerability perspective Root problem Climate change Social vulnerability Policy context Climate change mitigation, compensation,

3 | 2021 QUESTONLINE.ORG.ZA Animal home-building habits may provide clues to climate change adaptation NEWS | CLIMATE CHANGE Birds build nests to keep eggs and chicks safe and warm,

1.6 Objectives of the Study and Research Questions The main objective of this study was to investigate how information on adaptation to climate change and variability is packaged and

Author Title Year Program Muluneh, Wolde Mariam Impact of Climate change on Pastoral Livelihood, Vulnerability and Adaptive Strategy A Case Study in Moyale District, Borena Zone,