• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

Community participation in the Integrated Development Plan preparation process: the case of Ndwedwe Local Municipality, KwaZulu-Natal.

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2023

Membagikan "Community participation in the Integrated Development Plan preparation process: the case of Ndwedwe Local Municipality, KwaZulu-Natal."

Copied!
125
0
0

Teks penuh

This study examines community participation and focuses on the preparation of the Integrated Development Plan in Ndwedwe Local Municipality. The new dispensation of democratically elected government focuses on integrated development and mandate of policies such as municipal systems, law no.

Table number  Title  Page
Table number Title Page

Introduction

To identify how community participation can be strengthened in the preparation of the integrated development plan. This trend arose in light of the fact that the United Kingdom (UK) was the only country with such a liberal market, low social welfare and a high level of 'self-responsibility' among its people (Hobsbawm, 1968).

Fig1 Research Process
Fig1 Research Process

Study site

Statement of the problem

Ndwedwe Local Municipality is characterized by large differences between the community and its local municipality in terms of location with the exception of section 15 (The Ndwedwe 2009-2010 IDP Review). This could contribute to the participation of the community and service providers to fully engage the community in matters of community development.

Significance of the study

It focused on local municipal structures, ward community development committees and non-governmental organizations (NGOs) operating in Ndwedwe. The assumption is that effective local community engagement is likely to give them some ownership of the plan and use it to address their realities.

The main objective

It is the local communities that can identify their problems, and their absence contributes to a lack of services because the municipality is unable to know the services that the community needs.

Research Questions

This therefore re-emphasizes the need for research into the content of community participation in the preparation process for integrated development planning in Ndwedwe. How can the community be encouraged to participate in the integrated development planning process in Ndwedwe Local Municipality?

Hypothesis

The research methodology

The role of planners who facilitate community participation in the IDP preparation and the community courage in the preparation of the Integrated Development Plan. Information from the archives of the municipality related to community planning process in the Integrated Development Planning Process;.

Limitations of the study

Analysis helps prepare for the future development of the municipality and the local community. They provide a framework through which the concerned community participates in the preparation process of the integrated development planning process.

Chapter Summary ...................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined

Introduction

The conceptual and theoretical framework used in this study situates community participation in the integrated development planning processes. The conceptual and theoretical framework provides an overall context in which issues of integration, participation, development, planning and community are conceptualised.

Participatory Rural Appraisal

This chapter explains some of the key concepts in the discourse of integrated development planning as the planning movement has evolved over time. It would also eventually lead to the most profound and practical discovery of all – the infinite creative potential of man (Wint, 2002).

Community Participation

Community participation in the South African context

Furthermore, Greighton (2005: 22) argues “that community participation has levels of participation depending on the topic being discussed”). This is confirmed by Thomas (1995:1) who argues that "community participation involves community members and affected groups as community representatives".

Strategic Planning

Communities draw conclusions and circumstances that differ from the perceptions of outsiders (Burkey, 1993:62). It is the perceptions of the communities that must be the reference point for any analysis.

Neo-Functionalism

Intergovernmentalism

The liberal economies of the United States and the United Kingdom contrasted with continental Europe. These efforts were more similar to the ideas of the United States (http// www.Scribd.Com/doc Everything-abc).

Definitions of key concepts

Community

People with a community or a sense of attachment to a place, group or idea have a deep 'spirit of community' when they meet with other people. This, and the above discussion, led Cohen to argue that 'community' involves two related propositions that the members of a group have something in common with each other and the thing held.

Participation

Each area has a team of officials dedicated to implementing the integrated development planning program (Department of Provincial and Local Government URP, 2010). The role of traditional leaders in improving community life in South Africa.

Characteristics of effective participation

Integration

Development

Integrated Development Planning

The IDP is reviewed annually, resulting in a change to the plan should it be necessary (Integrated Development Planning Information Package, 2001). Basic concept in social science methodology South Africa: Human Sciences Research Council.

Summary of the chapter

Introduction

The central government had the right to determine what responsibilities could be assigned to local government. This meant that the minister had to control and carry out the strategic function of the local government.

Development planning in Ghana

41 Ofory, on the other hand, argues that the PNDC government has declared that power should be devolved to local people through the agency of the District Assemblies. Mensah adds that the PNDC has perceived the county assemblies as a preparatory and facilitating platform in the development of a representative national system of government.

The Development Planning in South Africa

Ghana, South Africa and the rest of the third world countries had a top-down approach. The authors further argue that in many cases this body was part of the office of the executive, the reason why Malawi's development agency was located in the office of the president and cabinet.

Participation and planning

Participatory Process

Conventional means of Public Participation

However, this does not minimize the importance of the information flow process, because it is recognized that little intelligent input can be expected from the citizens if they are not kept informed of the database from which the ongoing work of the planners and the issues that exercise the elected. members are derived (Held, 1972). Despite a saturation of a community with programs of exhibitions and public meetings and wide coverage of the events by means of posters and local press releases, only one third of respondents in one survey had a real understanding of the planning situation (Held, 1972).

Public meetings and hearings

In any case, the spectacle of planners undergoing thorough scrutiny is often an adequate substitute for those who attend the meetings but have no intention of actively participating (Pretty and Scoones 1995: 159). It acts as a one-way flow of information, from the planning agency to the client public, with little feedback that can be translated into the planning process; "her criticism is that the one-way operation of the ordinary public meeting is manipulative, allowing for superficial or evasive treatment of lay attempts at involvement."

Information documentation

Cullingworth (1979:50) argues that the power to call a planning application for decision by the Secretary of State is entirely separate from that to decide an appeal against an adverse local planning authority decision. This procedure enabled the Secretary of State to decide whether the development was sufficiently important to warrant being called in for his own determination (Fehily and Grist, 1992).

Innovative means

  • Decision making
  • Means of participation
  • The participants
  • Lessons for South Africa
  • Inequality opportunities
  • Summary

The Council's decision was final and could be legally challenged by the Supreme Court (Fehily and Grist, 1992). Integration into public services and the local community would enable proposed solutions and reduce the resulting problems and mindset change of participants (Pycroft.

Introduction

There are a number of policies in line with the constitution, as it considers integrated development planning as a tool for the development of the municipalities. These include the White Paper on Local Government (1998); The Green Paper on Development Planning; Development Facilitation Act of 1995 (DFA); Municipal Structures Act of 1999 and Municipal Systems Act of 2000.

The roles and the responsibilities of the government spheres

The life span of an Integrated Development Plan

The duration to complete the integrated Development Planning process

The core components of the Integrated Development Planning

Through observing Ndwedwe IDP, it was determined that the strategies are in line with the IDP vision. The integrated development planning is a tool that the Ndwedwe Municipality uses to identify its priority issues.

The Integrated Development Plan and Community Participation

Therefore, it is very important for the municipality to link the planning with the municipal budget, as this will ensure the implementation of the project, therefore the development is guided by the IDP (Parnell et al. 2002). Participation in the IDP requires a large number of people or all members from the district of the local municipality to attend and raise a number of issues for discussion.

Problems in implementing service delivery and development in traditional areas

In traditional areas, the land is "owned" by the traditional leader, not by the member of the community or household. Land allocation has over the years been the duty of traditional leaders under the Ingonyama Trust.

Preparation of Integrated Development Plan in Ndwedwe Local Municipality

In South Africa, the issue of land allocation has been crucial and important for understanding the functioning of traditional leadership for many years (KZNPPDC, 2008:9). Theron and Barnard argue that local government officials and agents do not fully understand their roles and expectations in the integrated development planning process.

The Ndwedwe Local Municipal powers and functions

It is important that the IDP is reviewed annually; because as a Strategic Plan it must at all times remain relevant to the changing institutional environment of the municipality. Good financial planning and budgeting can only take place if the municipality's Strategic Plan remains relevant in recording both internal and external business activities (Planact, 1997). In order to facilitate intergovernmental processes, the IDP should guide the financial planning and budgeting of government departments and state-owned enterprises.

Ndwedwe Local Municipal functions

As a result, the Ndwedwe Local Municipality Review 2009-2010 IDP ensures that limited resources are channeled into critical projects that will boost Ndwedwe's economy and that programs and projects are in line with the municipality's strategic vision. It strives to address internal and external circumstances that affect priority issues, goals, strategies, projects and programs of the Integrated Development Plan, and to capture the impact of successes and corrective measures to address challenges.

The Challenges of Ndwedwe local Municipality

Inadequate road infrastructure has a negative impact on the economy as well as on general access to certain sections of the Municipality. The steep landscape and the fragmented pattern of settlements have a negative impact on the internal and external connections of the municipality, making the service of the area relatively expensive and conditional.

Community participation; a strategy or a tragedy?

However, this compromises the counselor's ability to act intentionally for the benefit of the community. This explains the degree of representative participation commitment manifested by the counselor during the speech.

Governance

The budget is reviewed annually at IDP preparatory meetings to provide adequate services to the communities. The local municipality may face a community that participates in the form of riots and rebellions in IDP preparatory meetings.

Public participation Strategy

However, absenteeism among municipal councilors during the IDP preparation process was particularly high due to participation in other activities and the efforts of the Ndwedwe local municipality. This study first explained some of the key conceptual and theoretical frameworks used in the study.

Ndwedwe Representative Forum

Mayoral Izimbizo

The decision making structure of Ndwedwe Local Municipality

Local Community Participation and Municipal IDP

Needs orientation

Community ownership

Empowermen

Composition of Ward Committees

Status functions and powers of Ward Committees 62

Ward meetings for IDP 63

The Stakeholder Organization 63

Chapter Summary 64

Findings and Discussions

Introduction 66

The Department of Provincial and Local Government (DPLG) is the national coordinator for the implementation of the Integrated Development Plan. Program of Action for 2006: Asgisa – The Accelerated and Shared Growth Initiative for South Africa” in Vukuzenele, Volume 1, Number 4- March 2006.

The Ndwedwe Integrated Development planning process 67

Skills shortages 68

The Mayor reported that the IDP in Ndwedwe follows certain guiding principles and requirements in line with the IDP Guides prepared by the State Provincial Department. The issues mentioned above are in line with the IDP review and budget allocation to promote sustainability.

Levels of participation

Forms of engagement by councillors and mayors

This is due to insufficient financial resources, shortcomings in implementation and a lack of coordination capacity, which still prevent councilors from delivering on promises.

The role of the Amakhosi in the IDP process

Service delivery

The local municipality is not well equipped to carry out any ambitious development program embodied in the IDP. Finally, it is also difficult to make any comparative observations about public participation in Ndwedwe Local Municipality.

Attendance of meetings

89 This study also found that the most important factor negatively impacting the community's ability to influence decisions has been language. This has been most evident in this group's inability to meet the demands of businesses and business organizations, resulting in their dominance.

Testing the hypothesis of the study

If a top-down approach to planning ignores the importance of information obtained through a bottom-up approach, the result can be a number of theoretical planning documents that are irrelevant to local population”. Here are the findings, the study concluded by making a number of recommendations to address the challenges in order to improve community participation in the Integrated Development Plan preparation process in Ndwedwe Local Municipality.

Summary ......................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined

Reconstruction of Non-Metropolitan Local Government in South Africa', International Journal of Administrative Sciences, Principles of Integrated Development Planning and Process Evaluation 2001-2002. Rental Housing Policy and the Role of the Household Rental Sector: Evidence from South Africa.

Gambar

Table number  Title  Page
Figure number  Title  Page
Fig1 Research Process

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

LIST OF ABBREVIATION ACRONYMS EXPLANATION ASGISA Accelerated and Shared Growth Initiative of South Africa BRE Business Retention and Expansion CDE Centre for Development and

ACRONYMS ANC: African National Congress CASP: Community Action Support Programme CBP: Council Based Plan CBPA: Community Based Planning Approach CoGTA: Department of Co-operative

List of Acronyms ASGISA: Accelerated and Shared Growth Initiative-South Africa BESG: Built Environment Support Group BNG: Breaking New Ground CBO: Community Based Organization

ix LIST OF ACRONYMS: ACRONYM FULL DESCRIPTION ASGISA Accelerated & Shared Growth Initiative Of South Africa B-BBEE Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment BEE Black Economic

vii ABBREVIATIONS AND ACCRONYMS ASGISA Accelerated and Shared Growth Initiative for South Africa ANC African National Congress CAS Centre for African Studies CHE Council for Higher

viii LIST OF ABREVIATIONS Accelerated and Shared Growth Initiative for South Africa Asgisa African National Congress ANC African National Congress Youth League ANCYL Broad Based

ASGISA ACCELERATED AND SHARED GROWTH INITIATIVE OF SA CDF CAPITAL DEVELOPMENT FUND CDW COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT WORKER DORA DIVISION OF REVENUE ACT EMLM ELIAS MOTSOALEDI LOCAL

xv LIST OF ACRONYMS ASGISA : Accelerated and Shared Growth Initiative of South Africa B-BBEE : Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment CoGTA : Department of Cooperative