3(1,1*.$7$1.(7$+$1$12.6,'$6,7(50$/.$5(7$/$0
0(/$/8,5($.6,75$16)(5+,'52*(1$6,.$7$/,7,.
)$6$/$7(.60(1**81$.$16(1<$:$',,0,'$
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
LQGLDWH WKH WKHUPDO R[LGDWLYH UHVLVWDQFH RI UDZQDWXUDOUXEEHU
.H\ZRUGV +\GURJHQDWHG QDWXUDO UXEEHU F D W D O L W \ F W U D Q V I H U K \ G U R J H Q D W L R Q G L L P L G H FRPSRXQGWKHUPDOR[LGDWLYH
$EVWUDN
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
R
GLNHULQJNDQ GDODP RYHQ SDGD VXKX & VHODPDPHQLW(YDOXDVLPXWXNDUHWDODP WHUKLGURJHQDVL \DQJ GLKDVLONDQ GLODNXNDQ V H F D U D N X D O L W D W L I P H Q J J X Q D N D Q -XUQDO3HQHOLWLDQ.DUHW
,QGRQHVLDQ-1DW5XEE5HV 'RLKWWSVGRLRUJSSNMSNYL
VSHNWURIRWRPHWHU )7,5 GDQ XML NXDQWLWDWLI P H O L S X W L X M L E L O D Q J D Q L R G G H U D M D W KLGURJHQDVL LQGHNV NHWDKDQDQ SODVWLVLWDV GDQ NDGDU ]DW PHQJXDS +DVLO DQDOLVLV
R
GLNHWDKXL EDKZD VXKX UHDNVL VHEHVDU & GDQ ZDNWX SHQJHULQJDQ VHODPD MDP GLDQJJDSVHEDJDLNRQGLVLWHURSWLPDONDUHQD PHQJKDVLONDQ NDUHW DODP WHUKLGURJHQDVL GHQJDQ QLODL LQGHNV NHWDKDQDQ SODVWLVLWDV WHUWLQJJL VHEHVDU 1LODL LQGHNV NHWDKDQDQSODVWLVLWDVXPXPQ\DGLJXQDNDQ XQWXNPHQJJDPEDUNDQNHWDKDQDQRNVLGDVL WHUPDONDUHWDODPPHQWDK
.DWD NXQFL .DUHW DODP WHUKLGURJHQDVL WUDQVIHUKLGURJHQDVLNDWDOLWLN VHQ\DZD GLLPLGD RNVLGDVL WHUPDO
3(1'$+8/8$1
5DQWDL SDQMDQJ ELRSROLPHUFLV
SROLLVRSUHQD PHUXSDNDQ EDKDQ XWDPD SHQ\XVXQ NDUHW DODP +HYHD EUDVLOLHQVLV 0XHOO $UJ VHODLQ SURWHLQ GDQ SKRVSKROLSLG 5DQWDL SDQMDQJ PROHNXO SROLLVRSUHQD \DQJ
PHPLOLNL ERERW PROHNXO VHNLWDU VDPSDL
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
.HEXWXKDQ NDUHW VLQWHWLN WDKDQ RNVLGDVL WHUPDO GL GDODP QHJHUL KDUXV GLSHQXKL VHFDUD LPSRU 2OHK NDUHQD LWX G L S H U O X N D Q X S D \ D O D L Q X Q W X N PHQLPLPDOLVDVLSHQJJXQDDQSURGXNLPSRU $OWHUQDWLIFDUD\DQJGDSDWGLODNXNDQDGDODK GHQJDQ PHODNXNDQ PRGLILNDVL NLPLDZL WHUKDGDS UDQWDL PROHNXO NDUHW DODP DJDU PHQMDGL OHELK WDKDQ WHUKDGDS SURVHV RNVLGDVL WHUPDO 0RGLILNDVL NLPLDZL \DQJ
SDOLQJVHVXDLDGDODKPHODOXLUHDNVLWUDQVIHU KLGURJHQDVLPHQJJXQDNDQVHQ\DZDGLLPLGD 7UDQVIHUKLGURJHQDVLDNDQPHPXWXVLNDWDQ UDQJNDS WDN MHQXK & & PHQMDGL LNDWDQ WXQJJDO MHQXK && WDQSD GLLNXWL GHQJDQ SHPXWXVDQSDQMDQJUDQWDLPROHNXOVHKLQJJD NDUHW DODP PHQMDGL OHELK WDKDQ WHUKDGDS RNVLGDVL WHUPDO WDQSD GLVHUWDL GHQJDQ SHQXUXQDQ VLIDW PHNDQLNQ\D 3L\D DUHHWKDPHWDO
5 H D N V L W U D Q V I H U K L G U R J H Q D V L PHQJJXQDNDQ VHQ\DZD GLLPLGD \DQJ GLSHUROHK VHFDUD LQVLWX KDVLO GDUL RNVLGDVL KLGUDVLQ KLGUDW ROHK KLGURJHQ SHURNVLGD KDQ\D GDSDW GLODNXNDQ SDGD IDVD ODWHNV GLPDQD SDUWLNHO NDUHW DODP PDVLK WHUVHEDU VHFDUDPHUDWDGDODPVHUXPODWHNV0HWRGH WUDQVIHU KLGURJHQDVL GHQJDQ VHQ\DZD GLLPLGD OHELK GLVXNDL GDULSDGD KLGURJHQDVL NRQYHQVLRQDO GHQJDQ JDV + NDUHQD KDQ\D
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
%$+$1'$10(72'(
3HQHOLWLDQ EHUODQJVXQJ GL 3DEULN 3HUFREDDQGDQ/DERUDWRULXP3HQJXML3XVDW 3HQHOLWLDQ.DUHWVHMDNEXODQ$SULOKLQJJD-XOL %DKDQXWDPD\DQJGLJXQDNDQGDODP SHUFREDDQPHOLSXWLODWHNVNDUHWDODPSHNDW NDGDU DPPRQLDN WLQJJL KLGUDVLQ KLGUDW 1 + KLGURJHQSHURNVLGD+ 2
ODUXWDQVXUIDNWDQDQLRQLN6/6ODUXWDQ VXUIDNWDQ 3RO\R[\HWK\OHQH SKHQ\O HWKHU 33( ODUXWDQ DVDP ERUDW VHEDJDL NDWDOLVODUXWDQQDWULXPWKLRVXOIDWGDQ ODUXWDQ DVDP IRUPDW \DQJ VHOXUXKQ\D SDGDVSHVLILNDVLWHNQLV6HODLQLWXGLJXQDNDQ
3HQLQJNDWDQ.HWDKDQDQ2NVLGDVL7HUPDO.DUHW$ODP0HODOXL5HDNVL7UDQVIHU+LGURJHQDVL.DWDOLWLN
)DVD/DWHNV0HQJJXQDNDQ6HQ\DZD'LLPLGD
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
0HWRGH SHQHOLWLDQ PHQFDQJNXS SHPEXDWDQ NDUHW DODP WHUKLGURJHQDVL GDUL ODWHNVNDUHWDODPSHNDWGDQVHQ\DZDGLLPLGD SDGD VNDOD VHPL SLORW GLODQMXWNDQ GHQJDQ SHQJXMLDQ NDUHW DODP WHUKLGURJHQDVL \DQJ PHOLSXWL SDUDPHWHU XML LQGHNV NHWDKDQDQ SODVWLVLWDV 35, 61, NDGDU ]DW PHQJXDS 61, ELODQJDQ LRG 0HWRGH:LMV61,GDQVSHNWUXP ) 7 , 5 5 D Q F D Q J D Q S H U F R E D D Q \ D Q J GLDSOLNDVLNDQGDODPULVHWDGDODK5DQFDQJDQ $FDN/HQJNDS5$/GHQJDQWLJDSHUODNXDQ VXKX & & & GHQJDQ NDOL SHQJXODQJDQSDGDVHWLDSSHUODNXDQ
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
PHQLW/DWHNVWHUKLGURJHQDVL\DQJGLSHUROHK GLDNKLU UHDNVL NHPXGLDQ GLJXPSDONDQ GHQJDQ ODUXWDQ DVDP IRUPDW VHKLQJJD W H U E H Q W X N J X P S D O D Q N D U H W D O D P WHUKLGURJHQDVL .DUHW DODP WHUKLGURJHQDVL WHUVHEXW GLFXFL GHQJDQ DLU PHQJDOLU GDQ UHQGDP GHQJDQ DLU VHODPD MDP *XPSDODQ NDUHW DODP WHUKLGURJHQDVL \DQJ VXGDKEHUVLKWHUVHEXWGLJLOLQJGHQJDQPHVLQ
FUHSHU PHQMDGL OHPEDUDQ NDUHW DODP WHUKLGURJHQDVL NHPXGLDQ NDUHW DODP WHUKLGURJHQDVL\DQJVXGDKGLJLOLQJWHUVHEXW GLNHULQJDQJLQNDQVHODPDKDULVHEHOXP GLNHULQJNDQ GDODP RYHQ SDGD VXKX & VHODPD PHQLW /HPEDUDQ NDUHW DODP WHUKLGURJHQDVLNHPXGLDQGLNDUDNWHULVDVL
+$6,/'$13(0%$+$6$1
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
PHQJDNLEDWNDQPXQFXOQ\DEXLK7LPEXOQ\D JDV1 VHULQJNDOLWLPEXOSDGDUHDNVLUHGRNV
\DQJ PHQJJXQDNDQ KLGURJHQ SHURNVLGD <XOLDQWR .DUHW DODP WHUKLGURJHQDVL \DQJGLSHUROHKEHUWHNVWXUNRNRKNHUDVGDQ WLGDNOHQJNHW3DGDNRQGLVLEDVDKEHUZDUQD SXWLK GDQ EHUXEDK PHQMDGL NXQLQJ VDDW NHULQJ*DPEDU
7 H U E H Q W X N Q \ D N D U H W D O D P WHUKLGURJHQDVL GLNRQILUPDVL GDUL KDVLO D Q D O L V L V N X D O L W D W L I P H Q J J X Q D N D Q VSHNWURVNRSL )7,5 6HWLDS LNDWDQ DNDQ PHQ\HUDSUDGLDVLLQIUDPHUDKSDGDELODQJDQ JHORPEDQJ \DQJ EHUEHGDEHGD VHKLQJJD VHWLDS PROHNXO DNDQ PHPLOLNL VSHNWUXP
*DPEDU0HNDQLVPHWUDQVIHUKLGURJHQDVLNDWDOLWLNSROLLVRSUHQDROHKGLLPLGD )LJXUH3RO\LVRSUHQHFDWDO\WLFWUDQVIHUK\GURJHQDWLRQE\GLLPLGDPHFKDQLVP :DNWXSHQDPEDKDQUHDNWDQ PHQLWNH 5HDFWDQWDGGLWLRQWLPH 0LQXWHDW 5HDNVL& 5HDNVL& 5HDNVL& 5HDNVL& 5HDNVL& 5HDNVL& 5HDNVL& 5HDNVL& 5HDNVL& 6XKX 7KHPSHUDWXUH & *DPEDU3RODNHQDLNDQVXKXUHDNVLWUDQVIHUKLGURJHQDVLODWHNVNDUHWDODP )LJXUH7KHPSHUDWXUHLQFUHDVLQJSDWWHUQDW15ODWH[WUDQVIHUK\GURJHQDWLRQ *DPEDU9LVXDOLVDVLNDUHWDODPWHUKLGURJHQDVL )LJXUH9L]XDOLWDWLRQRI+15
LQIUDPHUDK\DQJNKDV+DVLOVSHNWUXP)7,5
NDUHW DODP PXUQL GDQ NDUHW DODP WHUKLGURJHQDVLGDSDWGLOLKDWSDGD*DPEDU VHEDJDL EHULNXW %HUGDVDUNDQ *DPEDU WHUOLKDW EDKZD VSHNWUXP )7,5 NDUHW DODP GLFLULNDQ ROHK DGDQ\D VHUDSDQ WDMDP SDGD
SXQFDN ELODQJDQ JHORPEDQJ FP LNDWDQ UDQJNDS WDN MHQXK & & GDQ
FP LNDWDQ &+ ,EUDKLP HW DO
3XQFDN VHUDSDQ ODLQ \DQJ WHUGDSDW SDGD UDQWDLPROHNXONDUHWDODPDQWDUDODLQ FP LNDWDQ &+ FP LNDWDQ &+ FP LNDWDQ&+ FP LNDWDQ&+
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
6HFDUD NXDQWLWDWLI VLIDW NDUHW DODP WHUKLGURJHQDVL \DQJ GLSHUROHK GLNRQILUPDVL PHODOXL SHQJXMLDQ ELODQJDQ LRG GHUDMDW KLGURJHQDVL LQGHNV NHWDKDQDQ SODVWLVLWDV GDQNDGDU]DWPHQJXDS+DVLOSHQJXMLDQVLIDW
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
*DPEDU6SHNWUXP)7,5NDUHWDODPPXUQLGLEDQGLQJNDQNDUHWDODPWHUKLGURJHQDVL )LJXUH)7,56SHFWUXPRISXUH15FRPSDUHGWR+15
3HQLQJNDWDQ.HWDKDQDQ2NVLGDVL7HUPDO.DUHW$ODP0HODOXL5HDNVL7UDQVIHU+LGURJHQDVL.DWDOLWLN )DVD/DWHNV0HQJJXQDNDQ6HQ\DZD'LLPLGD
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
KLGURNVLO \DQJ WHUEHQWXN GDUL SHUXUDLDQ KLGURJHQSHURNVLGDSDGDVXKXWLQJJL
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
6XKXUHDNVL 7KHPSHUDWXUH R& .RGH &RGH %LODQJDQ ,RG ,RG QXPEHU 'HUDMDW KLGURJHQDVL 'HJUHHRI K\GURJHQDWLRQ ,QGHNV NHWDKDQDQ SODVWLVLWDV 3ODVWLFLW\ UHWHQWLRQ LQGH[ 35, .DGDU]DW PHQJXDS 9ROODWLOH PDWWHU FRQWHQW 150XUQL $ $ $ 5DWDUDWD % % % 5DWDUDWD & & & 5DWDUDWD 7DEHO6LIDWNLPLDNDUHWDODPWHUKLGURJHQDVL 7DEOH&KHPLFDOSURSHUWLHVRIK\GURJHQDWHGQDWXUDOUXEEHU
PHPLFX WHUMDGLQ\D UHDNVL GHSROLPHULVDVL
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²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²'RL MDSFDWD .RYXWWLNXOUDQJVLH6 6DNGDSLSDQLFK-7 7KHPROHFXODUZHLJKW0:DQG PROHFXODU ZHLJKW GLVWULEXWLRQ 0:' RI 15 IURP GLIIHUHQW DJH DQG FORQH +HYHD WUHVV6RQJNODQDNDULQ - 6FL
7HFQRO 0DKLWWLNXO$3UDVDVVDUDNLFK3 5HPSHO */'LLPLGHK\GURJHQDWLRQRI QDWXUDOUXEEHUODWH[-RXUQDORI$SSOLHG 3RO\PHU6FLHQFH² 'RLDSS 0DKLWWLNXO$3UDVDVVDUDNLFK3 5HPSHO */+\GURJHQDWLRQRIQDWXUDO UXEEHU ODWH[ LQ WKH SUHVHQFH RI >,UFRG3F\ S\@3) -RXUQDO RI 0ROHFXODU &DWDO\VLV $ &KHPLFDO 'RL MPROFDWD
3HQLQJNDWDQ.HWDKDQDQ2NVLGDVL7HUPDO.DUHW$ODP0HODOXL5HDNVL7UDQVIHU+LGURJHQDVL.DWDOLWLN )DVD/DWHNV0HQJJXQDNDQ6HQ\DZD'LLPLGD
3L\DDUHHWKDP 3 3UDVDVVDUDNLFK 3 5HPSHO*/2UJDQLFVROYHQW IUHH K\GURJHQDWLRQ RI QDWXUDO UXEEHU ODWH[ DQG V\QWKHWLF SRO\LVRSUHQH HPXOVLRQ FDWDO\]HG E\ ZDWHUVROXEOH UKRGLXP FRPSOH[HV -RXUQDO RI 0ROHFXODU &DWDO\VLV $ &KHPLFDO ² 'RL MPROFDWD 3XYLDUDVDQ 1 $UMXQDQ 9 0RKDQ 6 )7,5 DQG )75DPDQ 6SHFWUDO LQYHVWLJDWLRQ RQ $PLQRTXLQDOGLQH DQG $PLQRTXLQROLQH 7XUNLVK -RXUQDORI&KHPLVWU\ :DQJ' $VWUXF'7KHJROGHQDJH RI WUDQVIHU K\GURJHQDWLRQ &KHPLFDO
5HYLHZV
<XOLDQWR ( 0RGLILNDVL .DUHW $ODP 3DGD )DVH /DWHNV 3HNDW +HYHD %UDVLOLHQVLV GHQJDQ FDUD +LGURJHQDVL 7DQSD .DWDOLV >7HVLV@ ,QVWLWXW 3HUWDQLDQ%RJRU%RJRU
