02 PENILAIAN DAN PENELUSURAN KI

(1)

OPTIMALISASI DAN PENYAMAAN PERSEPSI

PELAKSANAAN PENILAIAN ANGKA KREDIT

KENAIKAN PANGKAT/JABATAN AKADEMIK DOSEN

(2)

PENILAIAN DAN PENELUSURAN KARYA ILMIAH

PEER REVIEW

KARYA ILMIAH UNTUK USULAN KENAIKAN JABATAN

FUNGSIONAL/PANGKAT DOSEN

Are You Stealing Intellectual Property?

(3)

MATERI :

1. PENILAIAN DAN PENELUSURAN KARYA ILMIAH

3. PRAKTIK PAK DAN PENILAIAN-PENELUSURAN KARYA ILMIAH

(4)

PENILAIAN DAN PENELUSURAN KARYA ILMIAH (SOP)

4 • BUKU (REFERENSI,

MONOGRAF, BOOK CHAPTER)

• JURNAL (NASIONAL, NASIONAL

TERAKREDITASI, INTERNASIONAL, INTERNASIONAL BEREPUTASI)

• PROSIDING (NASIONAL, INTERNASIONAL,

PROCEDIA/DISI SPESIAL)

• KUALITAS

PENERBIT/PUBLISHER

❶CEK KEBENARAN KLAIM KELOMPOK

KARYA ILMIAH

• TOLOK UKUR SESUAI FORMAT PEER REVIEW (POINT 1, 2, 3)

• POINT-1: KELENGKAPAN UNSUR ARTIKEL DAN

KESESUAIAN BIDANG ILMU PENGUSUL

• POINT-2: KEMUTAKHIRAN DAN METODOLOGI

• POINT-3: KEDALAMAN

❷CEK KUALITAS 2. MINTA PROSES

KORESPONDENSI

❸BILA DIRAGUKAN:

(5)

HARUS MEMILIKI STANDAR:

• MERUPAKAN ACUAN MINIMAL YANG HARUS

DIPENUHI

HARUS MEMILIKI KRITERIA:

• ASEMEN BERDIMENSI, KARENA ITU

KUALITATIF PERLU DISEPAKATI. BERBEDA

DENGAN SYARAT, TIDAK BOLEH

DILANGGAR

(6)

6

Tim PJA hanya memeriksa apa yang seharusnya dikerjakan oleh Editor dan apakah proses review artikel sudah baik dan

benar

Perlu diketahui bagaimana PROSES Tim PJA melakukan Penilaian Angka Kredit Kenaikan Jabatan

(7)

KETIKA TIM PJA MENILAI SUATU KARYA ILMIAH, MAKA YANG BERIKUT INI

DIPERHATIKAN:

Editorial boards  Apakah ada orang dikenal

atau tidak. Pengecekan melalui Scopus maupun Google Scholar

Daftar Isi  Apakah sesuai dengan ketentuan di

Pedoman Operasional: Penulis dari berbagai negara

Apakah ada Panduan Penulisan Karya Ilmiah (Guide for Authors/ Guide for Manuscript

Preparation)

(8)

8

JURNAL INTERNASIONAL

BEREPUTASI

JURNAL TERINDEKS DI WEB OF SCIENCE DAN

MEMPUNYAI JOURNAL IMPACT FACTOR

JURNAL TERINDEKS DI SCIMAGOJR, QUARTILE 4

(Q4)

MESKIPUN JURNAL SUDAH TERINDEKS BELUM MENJADI JAMINAN ARTIKEL DAPAT DISETUJUI MEMENUHI PERSYARATAN KE

(9)

Struktur Karya Ilmiah

Semua daftar isi dapat ditemukan dalam karya ilmiah dan tidak ada acuan yang tidak tercantum dalam daftar pustaka

SEBAIKNYA TIDAK MENGULANG APA YANG PERNAH DI TULIS OLEH DIRI SENDIRI pada KARYA ILMIAH SEBELUMNYA ATAU MENGULANG KALIMAT DARI KARYA

ILMIAH ORANG LAIN. SERING TERJADI PARAGRAPH DI PENDAHULUAN DI ULANG DAN BEBERAPA GAMBAR DI PAKAI KEMBALI DI METHODOLOGY

Gambar dan Tabel semua di mention dalam teks karya ilmiah

(10)

10

PENULISAN KARYA ILMIAH: STRUKTUR KARYA

ILMIAH

• Title: Describes clearly the content

• Authors: Ensures recognition for the writer/s

• Abstract: Describes succinctly what was done

• Keyword: Ensures the article is correctly

(11)

M

Introduction: explains the hypothesis

Methods: explains how the data were collected

Results: describes what was discovered

Discussion: discusses the implications of the findings

Conclusion: comment on important, validity, and generality of conclusion

Acknowledgments: ensures those who helped in the research are recognized

(12)

12 AUTHORSHIP

CONFLICT OF INTEREST

PLAGIARISM & SELF PLAGIARISM

RESEARCH FRAUD

SALAMI SLICING or SALAMI / SEGMENTED PUBLICATION

DUPLICATE SUBMISSION

(13)

Kriteria Authorship

1. Berkontribusi substansial thd konsepsi atau desain pekerjaan

tsb; atau akuisisi, analisis, atau interpretasi data untuk

pekerjaan tsb; DAN

2. Mendraf kerja tsb atau merevisinya secara seksama; DAN

3. Memberikan persetujuan final untuk publikasi; DAN

4. Bertanggung jawab thd akurasi atau integritas pekerjaan tsb.

Menurut

International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE)

(14)

SISTEM SKOR HAK KEPENGARANGAN

SEBUAH KARYA TULIS ILMIAH (NATURE)

Masukan Intelektual (skor 20)

Masukan Fisik Menangkap Data (skor 20)

Masukan Pengolahan Data (skor 20)

Masukan Kepakaran/Keahlian (skor 20)

Masukan Kesastraan (skor 20)

(15)

SISTEM SKOR HAK KEPENGARANGAN SEBUAH

KARYA TULIS ILMIAH

A. Masukan Intelektual (skor 20)

(identifikasi masalah, gagasan pendekatan, perencanaan, dan perancangan )

Tidak ada sumbangan berarti 00

Dua tiga kali diskusi 05

Beberapa kali diskusi terinci 10

Pertemuan dan pembicaraan tak terhitung 15

(16)

B. Masukan Fisik dalam MenANgkap Data (skor 20)

(penataan peranti, pengamatan, pengumpulan, perekaman dan penyarian data )

Tidak pernah terlibat secara berarti 00

Terlibat tidak langsung, hanya dua tiga kali 05

Keterlibatan langsung, beberapa kali 10

Keterlibatan berkali-kali, tak terhitung 15

Terlibat secara penuh dan mendalam 20

(17)

C. Masukan Pengolahan Data (skor 20)

(pengorganisasian, pemrosesan, analisis dan sintesis )

Tidak ada sumbangan secara berarti 00

Keterlibatan pendek, dua-tiga kali 05

Beberapa kali terlibat 10

Ikut cukup lama 15

Ikut terus menerus dari awal sampai akhir 20

(18)

D. Masukan Kepakaran/Keahlian (skor 20)

(konsultasi, nasehat, pandangan, pemikiran dan pendapat ; penyimpulan, pengihtisaran, perampatan, serta pencetusan teori )

Nasehat pendek, penyimpulan sebagian 05

Pandangan cukup bermakna, pengihtisaran sebagian besar

10

Bantuan pemikiran dan perampatan menyeluruh 15

Pendapat yang mendasari penyimpulan dan pencetusan teori umum 20

(19)

E. Masukan Kesastraan (skor 20)

(sumbangan terhadap buram naskah lengkap pertama )

Membaca+menyunting bagian tertentu naskah 05

Membaca+menulis beberapa bagian naskah 10

Ikut menulis sebagian besar naskah 15

Menulis buram hampir keseluruhan naskah 20

(20)

20

6 ( enam) karya ilmiah dari penulis yang sama dalam satu nomor edisi penerbitan vol 64 no 4 , 2013

CONFLICT OF INTEREST

(21)

(22)

PADA BULAN JUNI 2016 NAMA EDITORIAL BOARD DARI PTS DI

(23)

Artikel: Phenol Removal from water by pulsed power disharge, Penulis: MMM AAA BBB, S.T.,M.Eng.,Ph.D, Nama Jurnal: Jurnal TTTT (Sciences and Engineering),

Volume Jurnal: 64, Nomor Jurnal: 4, Halaman: 125-130, ISSN: XXXXXX, Penerbit:

Artikel: On-site partial discharge monitoring system in generator at Tanjung bin power, Penulis: MMM AAA BBB, S.T.,M.Eng.,Ph.D, Nama Jurnal: Jurnal TTTT

(Science and Engineering), Volume Jurnal: 64, Nomor Jurnal: 4, Halaman: 131-135, ISSN: 0948-7921, Penerbit: UUU

6 paper di

spesial edition

dari satu orang penulis di vol dan no

yang sama.

Disetarakan dengan jurnal edisi khusus, karya

(24)

(25)

(26)

26

Publisher

Virtus

enterprise

(27)

(28)

(29)

(30)

(31)

(32)

(33)

ENGLISH

(34)

34

(35)

(36)

36

DARI DISKUSI DAPAT DITUNJUKKAN BAHWA TERDAPAT

KONVERGENSI BILA SUATU JURNAL AKAN TERINDEKS DI

WEB

OF SCIENCE

• Jurnal Publishing standards

• Editorial contents

• International diversity

(37)

(38)

(39)

(40)

(41)

(42)

42

MEMILIH JURNAL UNTUK PUBLIKASI

(43)

(44)

Are you submitting your research to a trusted journal?

Is it the right journal for your work?



More research is being published worldwide.



New journals are launched each week.



Stories of publisher malpractice and deception are also on

the rise.



It can be challenging to find up-to-date guidance when

choosing where to publish.



How can you be sure the journal you are considering is the

right journal for your research?

(45)

Reference this list for your chosen journal to check if it is trusted.



Do you or your colleagues know the journal?

- Have you read any articles in the journal before?

-Is it easy to discover the latest papers in the journal?



Can you easily identify and contact the publisher?

–

Is the publisher name clearly displayed on the journal website?

–

Can you contact the publisher by telephone, email, and post?



Is the journal clear about the type of peer review it uses?



Are articles indexed in services that you use?



Is it clear what fees will be charged?

(46)

46

Do you recognize the editorial board?

– Have you heard of the editorial board members?

– Do the editorial board mention the journal on their own websites?

Is the publisher a member of a recognized industry initiative?

– Do they belong to the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) ?

– If the journal is open access, is it listed in the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ) ?

– If the journal is open access, does the publisher belong to the Open Access Scholarly Publishers’ Association (OASPA) ?

– Is the journal hosted on one of INASP’s Journals Online platforms (for

journals published in Bangladesh, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Central America and Mongolia) or on African Journals Online (AJOL, for African

journals)?

– Is the publisher a member of another trade association?

(47)

http://www.authoraid.info/en/news/details/1156/

Andy Nobes provides a checklist of questions to consider

before you register for your next conference

(48)



It’s very important to make sure that the conference you

attend is suitable for your purposes, whether it’s a small,

niche conference or a large, international conference

–

will

you be presenting your valuable research to the right

audience and making useful contacts? Will the conference

presentation look good on your CV?



To

help you decide, we’ve put together some questions you

should ask if you are in any doubt about registering for a

conference:

(49)

Conference subject and scope

 Have your peers and senior colleagues in your field heard of, or attended this conference? Would they recommend it?

 Is the content of the conference relevant to your field?

 Is the topic of the conference focused enough for you to a) hear about relevant research and b) meet relevant researchers? For example, an

“International Conference of Social Sciences” or “International Conference on Business and Economics” may be too broad and

probably raises questions about the purpose of the conference.

 Does the conference prioritize the academic value of the conference more than the tourist destination? (You should judge the conference on its content rather than its location.)

 If the conference title includes the word ‘international’, are you

(50)

Conference website

Does the conference website seem knowledgeable about your subject field? Does it spell key technical terms correctly, and is it up-to-date on key themes in your field?

Does the conference programme list respected speakers who you or your colleagues have heard of? Consider checking their credentials on Google if you are unsure.

Does the conference website have full contact details (email, phone and postal address) so that you can contact them to ask questions?

Is there a report on the previous year’s conference? (Unless this is a

new conference.)

Does the website look reputable, with good spelling and grammar?

Is the conference listed on a source (e.g. a magazine, journal, blog, website, or sector-specific source) that you trust? This is especially important if you heard about the conference via an unsolicited email.

(51)

Conference organizers

 Who is organizing the conference, and for what reason? Is the goal or theme of the conference clear and specific? (Please note that generic phrases such as ‘to promote scientific innovation’ or ‘to facilitate

dissemination of research findings’ are not specific.)

 Do the organizers seem fully focused on making this a high-quality conference? Or are they involved in multiple events in the same

day/week/month?

 If the conference is being hosted by a university or research institution, do they seem like the most appropriate host? Are they also advertising the

conference on their website or at their campus?

 Is the conference organized by a scholarly or non-profit organisation who you have heard of? Does this organization list the conference on their

website?

 If the conference is organized by a commercial company:

(52)

By AuthorAID Team | Feb. 6, 2017

INFORMASI SELENGKAPNYA DI URL

http://www.authoraid.info/en/news/details/1156/

The

answer to most of these questions should be ‘Yes’

then you are in the right way to participate in the

conference ( this end text slightly modified from the

original in order to give more clear conclusion)

(53)

MATERI :

1. PENILAIAN DAN PENELUSURAN KARYA ILMIAH

3. PRAKTIK PAK DAN PENILAIAN-PENELUSURAN KARYA ILMIAH

(54)

PRAKTIK PAK & PENILAIAN KI

MOCKUP 2: PENILAIAN KARYA ILMIAH (KLAIM KRITERIA JURNAL dan TEST KEMIRIPAN)

COBA CEK KARYA ILMIAH BERIKUT, TERMASUK PADA PUBLISH KELOMPOK JURNAL YANG MANA (JURNAL NASIONAL, JURNAL NASIONAL TERAKREDITASI, JURNAL INTERNASIONAL, JURNAL INTERNASIONAL

BEREPUTASI): HARD DAN SOFTFILE SERTA AKSES ONLINE TERSEDIA.

•Karya Ilmiah-1.

Sripum, C., Kukreja, R.K., Charoenkiatkul, S., Kriengsinyos, W. and Suttisansanee, U. 2017. The effect of extraction conditions on antioxidant activities and total phenolic contents of different processed Thai Jasmine rice. International Food Research Journal 24(4): 1644-1650 (August 2017). Online Journal: http://www.ifrj.upm.edu.my/; Online Article: http://www.ifrj.upm.edu.my/24%20(04)%202017/(40).pdf.

•Karya Ilmiah-2.

Kylie Wong, , Qumrul Ahsan, Azma Putra, Sivarao, Subramonian, and Mohd jailani Mohd Nor. 2017. Preliminary study on the sound absorption behavior of spent tea leaves filled with natural rubber latex binder. Jurnal Teknologi vol. 79(5-2):59-64. Online Journal: http://www.jurnalteknologi.utm.my/index.php/jurnalteknologi/article/view/11284. Online Article: http://www.jurnalteknologi.utm.my/index.php/jurnalteknologi/article/view/11284/6172

(55)

(56)

Permendikbud no.88 Tahun 2013:

Pengangkatan Dosen Tidak Tetap dalam JAFA pada PTN (Membatalkan