Kelola Vol. 2. No. 3 edisi September 2015 ISSN : 2337 - 5965 ! "#$ ! % & # & ' ' ! "#$ ! % & #
!
"
##
$%#
"
#&&'
#&$$"
(
!"
!
"
"
)
" *
(
"
(
!
!
+ , -
.
)
!
/
+/
-"
"
0
(
1
(
)*# &"
+
"# ) & ! #
& )" +
$
&")
! "&* *
$"#$ +
) , &(
#
-"! *# .
"
!& $"# -"! ! )"#
" & & "-
!
& "#'
'" "
"#
&
$
" &! #
+&
# ! &* -" ! ." + ! #
)*# &"
+ (
", & #"
'" " )"# ! ,
& $"# ! ,
&
"
) &
& "#'
&"
+
"#$ & / (
'" " )"# ! ,
0" ."# +
" & &
)
!
$
&
" ' && & "#'
&"
+ / + ! $
." +
)"#
$ (
" #
! * * 123345 6)"#
$ 1 0* " ! ** , +5
"# ) &
!
, !
"& & )"#"& / !
$
." +
'
"
) & 7 + #
# !
$
/ +
! $ 8( "$"# ) ) , & $"#)" . )
)# & & )"#
$ . ++ ) !"$ +
. & / +
"# + & & #"
. &
" ++
$ #& &* . ! &"
+ !"$" # / (
" #
. ! , 123345
& # )"# ! ,
. )
. ,
. #
*
&
-)"# ! ,
.
!"
& $"! # '
, & - ) . )"# ! ,
!"
& $ & & "#'
)"# ! ,
.
" +, ! & .
&
" $ / # ,
+ )"# ! ,
(
)"# ! ,
$"! # . )"#& # & "$ ,
" +, . # 7 &
!
$ / + .# ! !(
#" ' &
"#' . )" #
$
& $
. &
+! + . # )" #
& -
. )
" /"$ $&
.
) &
$ # &
$ +
)"# ! ,
(
", & #"
)"# ! ,
$"! # . . +
"$ ,
" & & )# & & )"#
$ (
" #
# ,
.
.* * 123335 )#*7
$
! / + . ,
+ ." +
1
5 . )
" )" + # , -"! *# .
$"# -"! ! ( "# ! ,
/ +
"
&
/ +
++ 0" ."# +
" & & )# & & )"#
$ . $ . +&
/ + "$ ,
#" . ,(
'" " . )
" +"!
! &"
)
/
&
" . ) &
$ ) .
Kelola Vol. 2. No. 3 edisi September 2015 ISSN : 2337 - 5965
2
" )"#0")
$ !"!
'
/ + . + &
'" " (
" #
# * * 1233 5 .
. ! , 123345
" ' &&
)#*)*#! )" ++
+ &
" $ /
-"! ! )"# ! ,
( "
& $"! #
+
)"# ! ,
& !"
& $"! # )
# ! &* / + . , . ) -"! *# !", ++
-"! *# &
"
+&
&" + / + !"
&
++ .
)"# ! ,
(
& $
&* . !
)"# ! ,
"#!"$
" & & )# & & )"#
$ (
)"#
" $ , !
" +"
)" + # ,
& # )"# ! ,
)#*7
$
! . 7 0
"-"# +"
"#, . ) )# & &
)"#
$ (
(
%
(
(
'" "
$ (
'" "
$
" $
)" / '
)*# &"
+ . 7*#
!
& !
/
. & !"!
." + &" /
/ + !"! ++ , / (
)*# &"
+ / +
.
)
!
" /
$ !
$"#.
) & ) .
&"$ ' & . - ."
/ +
&
. "# )& .
$"! # /
'
, . - ." / +
& . $ + & ) . ) # )" "+ +
! ,
(
. &
'" "
$
.
&! .&
&
"
!& &")" +
)"
& )"# ! ,
!")"#
" &
)"# ! ,
)"# ! ,
." +
$ / +
! $
"
& # ! &* / + #" . ,(
, !
)*
. #
'" "
$
.
,
1 "#
$ 5(
(
"#
$ (
* !") )"#
$ !"'
." + &* !")
'" "
$ / + !
9 !
" ++ & "*# &" +" (
" #
:&/ 123
5 "*# &" +" .
)# & &
)"#
$
. )" + # ,
. /
)"#$".
&")" +
#
) , &
'" " ." + ) , & -"! *# / + !
9!
" + + & '
,
$ / +
$"! #(
, &
'" "
" $"#
7*#
!
." +
"
)
!
)" )*#
&"
+ !"$ +
! ,
&
" # &
-"! ! ( * 7 & & "#' .
) $
' &
! ,
'" "
&
"
&!
&
$
. & . &
* ",
! ,
"
&!
& &"& /
)" "+ + ! ,
(
. ! , 123345
" +
& $ ,
)"#
$
"# ) &
. & / +
.
& &
." +
!" + '
&
" + # +
- # $
!
$
/ + .
)*#& + # . )
" + # + # ! &* ) ! #
! ! ,
)"# ! ,
/ + ) .
&, # /
. )
" +& & , #+
! ,
)"# ! ,
!"
)"#
$ ' + . ."7 ! & !"$ +
) / / + !" + '
.
& & &
" )"#&"0 7 &
! ) .
+&
$ / + . ++ ) *#
$ +
)"# ! ,
!"#
!"$
, )# & & ." +
" ++ & "& &9 "& &
& !
&
" + # + 7 &
!
$ $"#! , !"
$"$"# ) )"# *."
& (
"#
$ .
& & * ",
'" " ." +
* - !
&
" +& &
.
" )"# , & , $ + / +
" ,
"#'
#
) , &
'" "
-"! *# . &#". *#
&
"
&!
& &")" +
"# " (
" )
." +
. /
)# & & )"#
$
!"# + &
$
!
, / +
. !"$
." +
.
# ) , & "#
. "&! "#
)"# ! ,
( " #
/
.
$# ,
1233;5 $" #
&")" +
0
& #"
) , & "#
$"#&" +
&
" +& &
&"!"' , "#
" + + &
)" "#* ",
&#".
!"$"! #
+& ." +
'
, $ + / + #" . , . &
" $ / # ) ' & !"&"0
+& (
". +&
) , & "&! "#
$"#&" +
&
" +& & &"& /
" $"# & &#".
!"!
." + &"
)
)"# ! ,
&
" +" $
& ) '
/
.
&
"
+
) ' & !" ++
+& (
* .
"#
/ 1233<5
" + +& )& $ ,
'
)"#
$
.
,
&
" )"#$ &
0 #
)"# ! ,
.
) , & "& "#
.
" ' && $ ,
)"# ! ,
"#!"$
"
&
#"! &* / + #" . ,(
!
) +
" $"# & 7*#
! / + #" "- .
" & & )#". &! "#, . )
Kelola Vol. 2. No. 3 edisi September 2015 ISSN : 2337 - 5965
=
# & & )"#
$
. !"$ $&
. /
* - !
'" "
&
" + # +
. /
7 &
!
$
/ + .
)*#& (
'" "
"
,
&
" ' +
$
/ +
! $
. $ . +
$
/ +
!"# +&
)" +&
/ &9 # !", ++ ) , &
'" " &
" &&
$ / +
.
)*#& ' &
'
,
$
/ + !"$" # /
" # . #
, !"$"
/ (
"$
& /
'" "
&
" # &
$
) $
$
/ + .
)*#&
" +&
. #
$
, !"$"
/ (
$ / + #
. #
, &"
, ! +
. ! &
* ",
'" " . -"! *# & #"
$ / + #
" + . & ! & $ ,
)"# ! , "#!"$
&
. ! $ (
# & & )"#
$
"# ) & #"& / !
'" " &
" "& '
,
$
) .
!"'
, )"# *." "# "
." +
'
&
" )"#* ",
+&
$
!"!
." + / + . , # )& (
" + # +
)"
$ ,
$ .
& & & #"
. /
)"#$".
#
$
/ + !", # ! /
.
)*#& ." +
$
/ + . , # )& (
" + &
)"#
$
.
, #"& / !
$ / + .
& &
'" " !", ++
)*#
" +"
$
"
& 7 &
! / + #"
-" #" . , . ! $ !"
) )"# *." / (
& & /
)"#
$
* ",
'" "
.
,
+ # ) #
-"! *#
)"
*.
" )
" + -"! ! & &"& /
"#"&
& )"# ! ,
" )
,
" ' . !
,
/ +
"# + & ) #
-"! *# & #"
-"! *#
. & &
" )"#* ", 7*#
! / +
& #
" +"
$
&
" +"-
!
+&
)" +" $
. # )*# *7* * / (
$(
& *# / +
" )" + # ,
"#
$ (
5
& # "# ! ,
" #
! * * 123345 *
& -
"# ) & )#*&! / + )
+ ")
&
" + & #
& # )"# ! ,
(
*
& -
" 0"#
& , #
&"& /
)"# ! ,
(
" + ."
& . )
. !
! & $ ,
!"
& $"! #
*
& -
!"
& $"! # )
& # )"# ! ,
. & "#' )"# ! ,
. )
. &
&
$ &
& #"
)"# ! ,
$"# ! ,
&"# !
&
" )
" +& &
& - / ( " )
)"# ! ,
/ + $"! # . )"#& # & &
" +, . # 7 &
!
$
/ + .# ! !
& #"
!"$
& /
' &
&
-)"# ! ,
" #
&
$
)
&
" # . ,
&
" $"# &
.
) & $ # & $ + )"# ! ,
(
", & #"
)"# ! ,
" & & )# & & )"#
$
+ # &* . !
$
/ + . , ! & * ",
&
-)"# ! ,
"# ,
! $ (
2 5
#*7
$
!
6 #*7
$
!
.
, &"
)
" +, ! &
$ (
! ! # ! *
&"
)
&
" +, ! &
$
. )
. &
& ." + )" '
& -
*. 8 1 # , .
23
>
;?5(
#*7
$
!
" 0"#
&
+&
"7"& -
! / + . 0 )
* ", *)"# ! *
)"# ! ,
(
"
& $"! # # ! *
)#*7
$
!
)"# ! ,
&
&
!"
&
$ &
)"# ! ,
.
" +, ! &
$ (
$
" ' &&
&"$"#, !
)"# ! ,
.
" +, ! & &" + (
", ++
. )
. &
& $ ,
$
"# ) &
$"#
$ &(
+&
)#*7
$
! / + &* ! ! "
&
" ' .
* *&
& # $ +
)"# ! ,
"#!"$
)
$"# , .
$ ! ! /
." +
" )"#* ",
#" # / +
"
.
. $ . + ." + # ! &* / (
" #
:&/ 123
5
)"# ! ,
0" ."# +
"
! !
!
" )"#* ",
+&
)#*7
$
! / +
++ (
+&
)#*7
$
! / +
++
&
" $"# &
&"/ & $ + -"! *# $ ,
)"# ! ,
"
& & "#' / + $ & . ' +
. )
" )" + # ,
.
)" +
$
&")
!
-"! !
&".") /
)"# ! ,
." +
+&
)#*7
$
!
/ +
++
&
" .*#* +
Kelola Vol. 2. No. 3 edisi September 2015 ISSN : 2337 - 5965
?
)"# ! ,
"# ,
"$ ,
! $
$
/ +
! $
. , # )&
. )
" ' && $ ,
)"# ! ,
"
& & "#' / + $ &(
=5
0
"-"# +"(
@ ' /
.
, /
1233A5
" /
&
,
+ 1
5
.
,
!"
&"
' $ &"
+ )"# ! ,
) . ) , &
/ + $"
"#)" ,
.
,
+
"# ) & !
$"# .
*.
/ + $"# !
. #
&#". *#(
.
. & # ." +
" $ . +& # ! *
#
*
,
+ . *
& - (
" ' && )#*)*#! )" ++
+
&
" $ /
-"! ! / ( "
& $"! #
+ )"# ! ,
&
!"
& $"! # )
# ! &* / + . , . )
-"! *# !", ++
-"! *#
&
"
+&
&" + / + !"
&
++ . -"! *#
& !"
&
&
&
" + -"! ! &
*. / &" )"# ! ,
& #" # ! &* /
++ (
* !")
$"#
7
&
! !
)"#" 0
.
)" +" .
&"
+ (
'" "
&"
+
"-"# +"
.
,
)" ++
!!" .
!
$"# . * ", )"# ! ,
/ +
"
& $ /
" ) ." +
&! . &
" +& & )* " !
)" "+ + ! ,
(
. /
. & !
)"# ! ,
" ++ & )"#
$
&
" +, . # )" ++ # )"#' ' ,
+
." +
" ,
&"
)
)"# ! ,
&
" !
+ /
." +
& - / + .
& )"# ! ,
( "
& 0")
)" ! ,
+ !"
& $ &
)"# ! ,
( "# ! ,
/ +
"
&
+&
"-"# +" / +
++
. . +
&
" & &
)"#
$
& #"
)"# ! ,
"# 0
."7
!", ++
'" "
" $
&"$ ' & / + . )
" +& &
)" . )
(
?5 " + & # "#
$
" + & # )"#
$ . )
. & # .
$" &
1 4A 5
.
# !" *
!
. @ #/
123325
&
" $". &
)"# ! ,
/ +
" & & )# & & )"#
$ ." + )"# ! ,
/ + . &
" & & )# & & )"#
$ (
!
. # )" + & #
&
" ' & . / )# & & )"#
$ ' & $"! # / & # + . # !
( . )
)"#,
+
!"$ +
$"# &
>
Indeks Eckel=
-B!
C
D )"# $ , )" '
.
!
)"# *."
C
D )"# $ , )" +, !
$"#! ,E $ .
!
)"# *."
D &*"7 ! " - # ! . # - # $ " /
! . # ."- ! ." +
/ +
. , # )&
2(
"#
!
)* "! !
" "
"#
!& , )* "! ! !"$ +
$"# & >
> & # "# ! ,
$"#)" + # , ! + 7 & "#, . ) )# & & )"#
$
2 > #*7
$
! $"#)" + # , ! + 7 & "#, . ) )# & & )"#
$
= >
.
)
$"#)" + # , ! + 7 & "#, . ) )# & & )"#
$ (
?>
& #
"# ! ,
#*7
$
! .
.
)
!"0 #
!
$"#)" + # , !"0 # ! + 7 & "#, . ) )# & & )"#
$ (
(
(
(
"! " "
" "
"# ) & )" "
&
7 / + $"# '
&
" +" ,
)" + # ,
& # )"# ! ,
)#*7
$
! .
"#, . ) )# & &
)"#
$ (
*)
! .
)" "
.
, )"# ! ,
7 & # / +
Kelola Vol. 2. No. 3 Edisi September 2015 ISSN : 2337 - 5965
<
$"
)"# ! * 9
# $"
# $" +& * !") # $" . & *# & # &
& # "# ! , " 0"# & , # &"& / )"# ! , ( " & ++
& - !" & $ & & "#' )"# ! , * & - * & - ! * #*7 $ ! )#*&! & ." + ( " ' && &" ) )"# ! , . " +, ! & $ ) . )"# *." "# " $ $"#! , !"$" ) ' & 1 5 * & -D * & -! * . ) )#*&! & ." + / +/ -" " ) )"# ! , & " ! , + ." + & - / + . & )"# ! , * + * & -D * + * & -! * "# $ )#*&! & ." + # ! "0&" & " " & ) & , )"# ! ,
" & & . &
)"# $ ( "# $ , )" ' 1C 5 "# $ , $ 1C 5 2 C -B ! *
2(
) " " "
)" +
$
!
)" / + & . + & .
)" "
.
,
3
." + &# "#
!
)" !"$ +
$"# &
>
(
"# ! ,
7 & # / + "#. 7 # .
!"
=
, $"# # 9 #
/
. #
, 2334923
(
2(
"# ! ,
7 & # / +
" "#$ &
)*# &"
+ )"# *." =
"!" $"# &
, 2334923
(
=(
"# ! ,
7 & # / +
" "#$ &
)*# &"
+ #
&
, 2334923
(
?(
"# ! ,
7 & #
/ +
. &
" +
&"# +
!"
=
,
$"# # 9 #
. #
, 2334923
(
<(
"# ! ,
7 & # / +
" ++ &
+
) ,(
"#. ! #&
)"#,
+
. )
" +" ,
)"# ! ,
7 & # / + "# ." 7 & !
" & & )"#
$ (
# $" )"#
$
.
,
- # $"
&
" $". & )"# ! ,
/ +
"# ." 7 & !
" & &
)"#
$ . $"#
1!
5 . )"# ! ,
/ + . & "# ." 7 & !
" & &
)"#
$ . $"#
3 1 * 5( "# &
.
,>
Kelola Vol. 2. No. 3 Edisi September 2015 ISSN : 2337 - 5965
;
Step
Chi-square
df
Sig.
1
5,602
7
0,431
$" )"#,
+
1
"#,
+ ."&! 0&"
, 2334
, 23 3
, 23 2
)
. !
) & $ ,
)"# ! ,
/ + "# ." 7 & !
" & & )"#
$ =
,
$"# # 9 #
.
, )"# ! ,
# !, .
"&
+
1
5 .
"
" ) #
1
5(
=(
! !
(
" + ' , )* "! ! .
)" "
" ++ &
*." #"+#"! *+ ! 0 $ "#(
" + ' .
& & ) .
+&
! + 7 & ! 1F5 < )"#!" (
"
&" / &
*." #"+#"!
$" 4
)
(5 *
, .
$" =
'
*! "# . " "!,*
"!
$"# >
!
" +* , .
." +
;
.
$" =
" ' && , !
)" + '
4
)
(
"
! )" + '
" ' && $ ,
)#*$ $
!
! + 7 & !
.
,
3 ?= G 3 3<
" ' &&
*."
0 & )
)
" '" !& .
# /
*." #"+#"!
/ & & . + & .
! ! !" ' / (
2(<3A 3 2=H(< ; 3 2=H(< ; 3 2 (2=2 3 2(33 3 2(33 3 = (?44 3 2(? H 3 2(? H 3 ? 2(32A 3 =( A 3 =( A 3 < =(=H; 3 A(=3; 3 A(=3; 3 ; <( A3 3 ;2(<A? 3 ;2(<A? 3 H 2(? ? 3 (?H 3 (?H 3 A ;( ? 3 3(<AH 3(<AH
4 (A3A 3 4(4?A 3 4(4?A 3
3 2( ;4 3 (;<? 3 (;<? 3
2(?; 3 3( 22 3( 22
2 @ 2 ;(23< 3 A<(A23 3 A<(A23 3
= (4H4 3 ?(? ? 3 ?(? ? 3
? (AH4 3 (<A; 3 (<A; 3
< ? HA(?3 3 (=A? 3 (=A? 3
; (; 3 3 3(324 3(324 H =( <H 3 <(< 2 3 <(< 2 3 A =(24H 3 3(3 2 3(3 2 4 9<( ; 4(;;H 3 4(;;H 3 23 3(2 3 3(H2< 3(H2< 2 93(3 3 93(3< 93(3< 22 ;(2?? 3 92?A(<H? 92?A(<H?
Kelola Vol. 2. No. 3 Edisi September 2015 ISSN : 2337 - 5965
H
2(
'
"!" # ,
*."
$" ?
"#$ . +
92
1 *0& 35 ." + 92
&, # 1 *0&
$"# >
!
" +* , .
." +
;
"#. ! #&
$" ?
" ' && )"#$ . +
# 92
." +
92
&, #(
92
!"$"! # A< <A2
"# ) & , !
)" +* , .
!"$"
. )" + # , * ",
/
& # )"# ! ,
.
!" " , &" +
- # $"
.
! &&
92
" +
)" #
" ' .
;H 22= )" #
&" ,**. 192 5
" ' &&
*."
#"+#"!
/ +
"$ ,
$ &
*." / + . , )* "! !& 7 ." + .
=(
*."
#/
$" <
*"7 ! " " "#
!
$"# >
!
" +* , . #
;(
! 6
7
"# ) &
& # / +
" 0*$
" #
& #
I
#" ) .
) " #"+#"!! * / + . . ! #& ) .
"& & "!
!
&" ,**.
." +
&!
& # + . #
!", ++ !
& . "#)#" ! & (
",
& #"
8
7
/ +
"# ) &
*. 7 & ! . #
! 6
.
"#)#" ! /
!
I
#" ) .
) " #"+#"!! *
3
9
7
.
*
*+ ! 0 #"+#"!! * (
8
!I
#" ) .
$" <
" ' &&
!"$"! # 3 24
24 J(
$"# #
- # $
! - # $ " .")" ." . )
. '" !& * ",
- # $
! - # $ "9- # $" .")" ." !"$"! # 24 J( ". +& ! ! /
H3 4J
/
. )" + # ,
. '" !& * ", - # $" 9- # $" / +
. &
.
! && .
)" "
"
?(
" + ' "+#"!
*+ ! &
"#(
&
" + ' , )* "! ! )" "
" ++ &
! ! *+ ! & $ "# & #"
.
)" "
$"#! 7
(
"#. ! #& , !
)" +* , .
." + )#*+#
;
& . )"#* ", , ! !"$ +
$"# &
>
(
" + '
*"7 ! " #"+#"!
" + ' , )* "! !
.
&! .&
&
" +" ,
) & ,
& #
)"# ! ,
)#*7
$
! .
$"#)" + # , "#, . ) )# & &
)"#
$ (
$" ;
!
'
- #
"
#/ *+ ! 0 "+#"!! *
# $ " $"$ !
)9-
"
1! +5
@ .
.7
" "# +
*
& # "# ! ,
3 3=4
? 2?4
K3 3<
* &
#*7
$
! 1
5
3 32=
< ;H
K3 3<
* &
0
"-"# +"
1
5
3 334
; A 2
K3 3<
* &
$"# >
! )" +* , .
." +
;
"#. ! #&
$"
;
& #
)"# ! ,
/ +
. )#*&! &
." +
*+ #
#
. #
*
& -
)"# ! ,
" ' &&
@ . ,
+
92 *+ &" ,**.
*0& 3 A< <A2
*0& ;H 22=
*L M "
I
#"
+" &"#&"
I
#"
3 2
3H
Kelola Vol. 2. No. 3 Edisi September 2015 ISSN : 2337 - 5965 A
!"$"! # ? 2?4 "$ , $"! # . #
7
$" ." + .7
!"$"! # = A? .
)#*$ $
! /
3 3=4 K 3 3<(
# , !
$"# #
*
. * & - # $ "
.")" ." $"# )
& # )"# ! ,
$"#)" + # , !"0 # ! + 7 & "#, . )
)# & & )"#
$ (
# $" )#*7
$
! ) .
$" ; / + . )#*&! & ." +
" ' &&
. ,
+ !"$"! # < ;H
) $
. $ . +& ." +
7
$"
." + .7
/
!"$"! # = A?
(
,
+ G . #
7
$"
1< ;H G = A? 5 .
" ' &
)#*$ $
! !"$"! # 3 32= K 3 3<
&
* 2 . * & )#*7
$
! $"#)" + # , ! + 7 & "#, . ) )# & & )"#
$ (
.
/ + . )#*&! & ." +
$"#. ! #&
$" ; $ ,
:
,
+ !"$"! # ; A 2 "$ , $"! # . #
7
$"
." + .7
/ + !"$"! # = A?
.
"
&
+&
! + 7 & !
!"$"! #
3 334
K
3 3<
,
" ' &&
* =
. * &
$"#)" + # , ! + 7 & "#, . ) )# & & )"#
$ (
" ,
(
$ " H
$ ! "! *7
*." 0*"77 0 "
, 9!I
#"
.7
+(
")
")
< =?2
=
3 332
*0&
< =?2
=
3 332
*."
< =?2
=
3 332
$"# >
! )" +* , .
." +
;
' !
1
,
5 $"# '
&
" +" ,
) & , & #
)"# ! ,
#*7
$
!
.
!"0 #
$"#!
9!
" )" + # , )"#
$ (
! )" + '
1)" + ' !
5
. )
. ,
. # 2 0 #
/
." +
9 7
,
+ ." + .7 =
9 7
!"$"! #
< =?2 "$ , $"! # . # 0, 9!I
#"
$" !"$"! # H A < .
." +
" ,
+&
! + 7 & ! !"$"! # 3 332 "$ , &"0 . # 3 3<
&
. # &".
' "#!"$
. )
. &
&
* ? . * &( # /
- # $ "
& #
)"# ! ,
)#*7
$
! .
!"0 # !
$"#)" + # ,
! + 7 & "#, . ) )"#
$ 1
5(
0(
! ! "+#"! (
"# &
.
, , ! )" + ' ." +
" ++ & #"+#"! *+ ! 0 $ "#(
.
! ! $"# &
/ + )"#
. &" ,
.
,
. # &*"7 ! " #"+#"! 1 5 .
!
" +"
&*"7 ! " #"+#"! / + $"#
)*! 7 . "+
7( "# &
.
,
$" , ! . # )" + ' #"+#"! *+ ! &
$" A
!
! ! "+#"!
# $"
.")" ."
+
93 ?;?
3 3=4
2 <<;
3 32=
; A A
3 334
* !
342
3 H 3
$"# >
! )" +* , .
." +
;
"#. ! #&
, !
. #
$"
?( 3
&
. $" &
)"#!
#"+#"! !"$ +
$"# & >
Kelola Vol. 2. No. 3 Edisi September 2015 ISSN : 2337 - 5965
4
(
" $ , !
!
" "
& # )"# ! ,
"
&
&*"7 ! " #"+#"! "+
7 )#*$ $
! )"# ! ,
7 & # / +
"
&
+&
*
& - / + #" . , 0" ."# +
&
" & &
)# & & )"#
$ (
!"!
." + )" "
/ + " , .
& & % * .
+
+ 123
5 / +
" +
& $ ,
)"# ! ,
." + *
& - &"0 0" ."# +
" & & )"#
$
. $ . + ." + )"# ! ,
/ +
"
&
*
&
-/ + $"! # & #" )"# ! ,
/ + $"! # "$ , . )"#,
& * ",
!/ # &
!", ++
)"# ! ,
"#!"$
& "$ , $"#,
9,
.
" & & )" )*# &"
+ / (
* . ! . )"#'" ! ." + )"# ! ,
.
!"
=
, $"# #
." +
*
& - / + ! $ . & ! # 2 333 1%
*+
) ,5 .
= 333 1%
*+
) ,5
$ ,
)"# ! ,
"#!"$
"# . & !
" & & )# & & )"#
$ (
$ /
*
& - ) .
)"# ! ,
" )"# , & &" .
)"# ! ,
/ +
" & & )"# & & )"#
$
& #"
+ . ++ ) &* . ! )"# ! ,
!", (
". +& )"# ! ,
." + &* . !
*
& -
! $
. & ! #
A 333 1%
*+
) ,5 .
"
&
& - / + "$ , ++ . $ . + )"# ! ,
/ !"
=
, $"# # 9 #
. & "# . & !
" & & )# & & )"#
$ (
" "
!"!
." +
. ! , 123345 ." +
" ++ & )" + '
#"+#"!
"# $"#+ . . '
, - # $" / + "$ , $ / & . # )" "
& #
)"# ! ,
"
& )" + # , / + ! + 7 & "#, . ) )"#
$ ( " ) )" "
$"# " + ." + )" "
/ + .
& & * ", @ ' /
.
, /
1233A5 / +
" & & )" + ' #"+#"!
*+ ! &
" /
& $ ,
& # )"# ! ,
. &
$"#)" + # , ! + 7 & "#, . ) )"#
$ (
"#"&
" /
& $ ,
*
&
-$ & !
, !
0 #
&
" +,
+ & # )"# ! ,
(
# $" )#*7
$
! / + . )#*&! & ." +
' +
"
& )" + # , / +
! + 7 &
"#, . ) )# & & )"#
$
.
"
& &*"7 ! " / + )*! 7(
" /
& $ ,
)"# ! ,
/ +
"
&
)#*7
$
! / +
++
0" ."# +
&
" & & )"#
$
& #"
!"
&
++
)#*7
$
! / + .
&
)"# ! ,
&
'" " ." +
. ,
" +
#
$ /
" & &
)"#
$ .
'" " "# ,
"
& & "#' $ & ) $
.
. #
+&
$
/ +
) . , ! & ( * . ! !")"#
. )"#&
." +
)#*7
$
! ) .
' /
.
)*"#
/ +
"
&
+&
)#*7
$
! "# ++ ) .
,
23
)#*7
$
! /
!"$"! #
3 <;=
.
)"# ! ,
"#!"$
"# ." 7 & !
" & & )"#
$ (
" "
!"!
." + )" "
. ! , 123345
" /
& $ ,
)#*7
$
! )"# ! ,
$"#)" + # , !"0 #
! + 7 &
"#, . ) )# & & )"#
$ ( " ) )" "
$"# " + ." + )" "
' .
123 35 $ ,
)#*7
$
!
. &
"
&
)" + # ,
/ + ! + 7 & "#, . ) )"#
$ (
"#!"$
. !"$ $& $ ,
)" "
. #
' .
/ +
" ++ &
*."
;
!"$ +
)" "
&
" +" ,
)"# ! ,
/ + "# ." 7 & !
" & &
)"#
$ !". +& )" "
" ++ &
*."
"
/ +
"# &, #
.
, - # $ "
/ + . )#*&! & ." +
"
& )" + # , / + ! + 7 & .
"
&
&*"7 ! " / +
)*! 7 ,
" ' && $ ,
!"
&
++
+&
,
+
&
!"
& $"! #
&"
+&
&
" & & )"#
$ (
. & #" & $ ,
Kelola Vol. 2. No. 3 Edisi September 2015 ISSN : 2337 - 5965
3
" $ /
*)"# ! )"# ! ,
." +
" ++ & ,
+(
* . !
. )"#&
* ", )"# ! ,
# !, .
"&
+ 1
5 . "
" ) #
1
5 !"
=
, $"# # 9 #
+&
,
+ )"# ! ,
"#!"$
0" ."# + ++
&
." + +&
,
+ . & ! # <3 )"#!" !". +&
." + +&
,
+ . & ! # ?3 )"#!" . "# ." 7 & !
" & & )# & & )"#
$ (
!"!
." + )" "
/ + .
& & * ",
' .
123 35 / +
" /
& $ ,
$"#)" + # , ! + 7 & "#, . ) )# & & )"#
$
" )
. & !")" . )
." + )" "
. ! , 123345 . @ ' / .
, /
1233A5 / +
" /
) & .
)" "
/
. & $"#)" + # ,
! + 7 &
"#, . ) )"#
$ (
"#!"$
$"# #
$ ,
) .
)" "
/ +
.
& &
. ! , !"#
@ ' /
.
, /
#
9#
)"# ! ,
!
)"
"
&
+&
,
+ / + #" . ,
." + &
)"# ! ,
. & $"#+ + ) .
,
+ .
" $ /
& - )"# ! ,
/ (
(
(
& # "# ! ,
/ + . )#*&! & ." + *
& - !"0 # ) #!
$"#)" + # ,
! + 7 &
"#, . ) )# & & )"#
$
." + &*"7 ! " "+
7(
$"# #
!"
& #" . ,
& # )"# ! ,
!"
&
++ )"# ! ,
&
" & &
)"#
$ (
2(
#*7
$
! / + . )#*&! & ." +
!"0 #
) #!
$"#)" + # , ! + 7 &
"#, . )
)# & &
)"#
$ (
"
&
++
)#*7
$
! ) .
)"# ! ,
!"
& $"! # )"
+ $ ,
)"# ! ,
"#!"$
" & & )# & &
)"#
$ (
=(
.
/ + . )#*&! &
." +
$"#)" + # ,
!"0 #
! + 7 &
"#, . ) )# & & )"#
$ (
"
&
++ # ! * 7 0
"-"# +"
&
!"
& $"! # )
# ! &* / + . , . ) ) #
-"! *#(
&
)"# ! ,
/ +
"
& # ! * 7 0
"-"# +"
++ 0" ."# +
&
" & &
)# & & )"#
$ (
?(
" +
" & & '
)" + ' !
. )
. !
) & $ ,
& #
)"# ! ,
)#*7
$
!
.
!"0 # $"#!
9!
$"#)" + # , !"0 # ! + 7 & "#, . ) )# & & )"#
$ (
<(
. + 7*#
! . # !&" # * )"#
$
$"#)* " !
" / # & )#
&
*#
& # + " ! )" & $ ! ! "# "$ , . &
& ." + !"
+
"+#
!
.
) . "#
!"& # + (
'
,
#
.,* .
# ,
# , 23 3( " + # , #*7
$
!
! &* "
+
"# ! ,
.
# & # ")"
& "#, . ) # & & "#
$
>
.
) # !
"# ! ,
7 & # / +
"#. 7 # .
(
8
<
= "$"
" & *
, ".
, ( 233H
"
(
&
(
" $
) > % & # (
. ! ,
( 2334(
& *#9
& *# / +
" )" + # ,
# & & "#
$ (
>/ ?
@ +$-" ?
#&&'"
*". * *
(
( 233<(
#". & $
$ >
.
" + # ,
"& ! "
*#)*# "
*-"# 0" .
) &
'" "
$
." +
" ++ &
!
%
#(
&
,(
8
<"
"
.
# ( 233A(
& *#9
& *# / +
" )" + # ,
# & &
"#
$
.
"# ! ,
7 & # . " $ +
"
+
/ / + "#. 7 # .
#!
7"&
% & # (
?
A
< 8 "#"
,*:
( 23
(
B
3
B 3
$'"
. ! <(
. " "#$
-"#!
!
)* "+*#*> "
# +(
Kelola Vol. 2. No. 3 Edisi September 2015 ISSN : 2337 - 5965
