'RVHQ7HWDS)DNXOWDV,OPX$JDPD,VODP8QLYHUVLWDV,VODP,QGRQHVLD8,,GDQ'LUHNWXU 3URJUDP0DJLVWHU6WXGL,VODP8,,<RJ\DNDUWD
'$1352%/(0$7,.$1<$
$PLU0X¶DOOLP$EVWUDFW
7KHWKHRU\DQGSUDFWLFHRIV\DULDKEDQNLQJZLOOEHDEOHWRH[LVWDQGEHD PRGHOZKHQLW¶VDEOHWRVROYHWKHVRFLHW\¶VSUREOHPEXWLWZLOOEHOHIWZKHQFRQVLGHUHG XQVXFFHVVIXOWRVROYHWKHVRFLHW\¶VSUREOHPHVSHFLDOO\SRYHUW\DQGXQHPSOR\PHQW SUREOHP%DVHGRQWKLVRSLQLRQDFDGHPLFLDQVDQGV\DULDKEDQNLQJSUDFWLWLRQHUV KDYHWRHYDOXDWHDQGUHIRUPUHJXODUO\XSRQWKHFRQFHSWDQGVRPHSUDFWLFHVZKLFK IDLOHGWRRYHUFRPHWKHVRFLHW\¶VSUREOHP
7KH¿UPHVWLGHDXSRQWKHUHVHDUFKSXUSRVHLVWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIV\DULDK EDQNLQJIXQGLQJSURGXFWVV\VWHP7KHGRPLQDWLRQRIPXUDKDEDKIXQGLQJRIV\DULDK EDQNLQJPRUHRYHULQ,QGRQHVLDVWUHQJWKHQHGWKHLQGLFDWLRQWKDWVXEVWDQWLRQDOO\ V\DULDKEDQNLQJV\VWHPKDYHQ¶WSHUIRUPLWVEDVHIXQFWLRQLW¶VLPSURYLQJSHRSOH¶V HFRQRP\DQGVRFLHW\¶VSURVSHULW\
WKLVPRGHOHPSOR\PHQWRSSRUWXQLW\ZLOOEHEURDGHUH[SDQGHGDOVRWKHVRFLHW\¶V SURVSHULW\LVJRLQJWRVSUHDGZLGHUO\
.H\ZRUGV6\DULDKEDQNLQJV\VWHP3UREOHPDWLF)XQGLQJ
$ 3HQGDKXOXDQ
*XV'XUGDODPZDZDQFDUDQ\DGHQJDQVDODKVDWX79PHQJHQDL)DWZD 08,WHQWDQJ3HQJKDUDPDQ%XQJD%DQNPHQJDWDNDQEDKZDEXQJDEDQN WLGDNKDUDPNDUHQDEXQJDEDQNWLGDNLGHQWLNGHQJDQULED.RPHQWDU*XV 'XUWHUVHEXWEHUVDPEXWJD\XQJGHQJDQNRPHQWDU\DQJODLQVDODKVDWXQ\D GLNHPXNDNDQROHK6\D¿¶L0DDULI\DQJPHQJDWDNDQEDKZDIDWZD08,WHUVHEXW WHUODOXWHUEXUXEXUX%HUEDJDLNRPHQWDULQLGLWDQJJDSLNHPEDOLROHK08,\DQJ PHQMHODVNDQEDKZD08,EHOXPPHQJHOXDUNDQIDWZDEDKZDEXQJDEDQN KDUDPSHQJKDUDPDQEXQJDEDQNEDUXVHEDWDVXVXODQNRPLVLIDWZD08,
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
6HFDUDVLVWHPDWLVWXOLVDQLQLGLDZDOLGHQJDQPHQGHVNULSVLNDQNRQVHS GDQ SUDNWHN SHPELD\DDQ EDQN V\DULDK NHPXGLDQ GLODQMXWNDQ GHQJDQ SUREOHPSUREOHP \DQJ PXQFXO GDODP NRQVHS GDQ SUDNWHN SHPELD\DDQ DOWHUQDWLISHQJHPEDQJDQSHPELD\DDQEDQNV\DULDKGDQWHUDNKLUNHVLPSXODQ VHEDJDLUDQJNXPDQGDQUHNRPHQGDVLGDULSHPEDKDVDQWXOLVDQLQL
% .RQVHS.RQVHS3HPELD\DDQ%DQN6\DULDK
3URGXNEDQNV\DULDK\DQJEHUNDLWDQGHQJDQSHQ\DOXUDQGDQDGDODP LVWLODKEDQNV\DULDKGLNHQDOGHQJDQSHPELD\DDQVDPDGHQJDQNUHGLWGDODP LVWLODK EDQN NRQYHQVLRQDO PHQHUDSNDQ EHEHUDSD VLVWHP 'DODP 6XUDW .HSXWXVDQ'LUHNVL%DQN,QGRQHVLD1R.(3',5WDQJJDO0HL %DE9,3DVDOWHQWDQJ.HJLDWDQ8VDKDGLVHEXWNDQEDKZDEDQNZDMLE
PHQHUDSNDQSULQVLSV\DULDKGDODPNHJLDWDQXVDKDQ\D\DQJPHOLSXWL
0HQJKLPSXQ GDQD GDUL PDV\DUDNDW GDODP EHQWXN VLPSDQDQ \DQJ PHOLSXWL
DJLUREHUGDVDUNDQSULQVLSZDGLDK
EWDEXQJDQEHUGDVDUNDQSULQVLSZDGLDKDWDXPXGKDUDEDK F GHSRVLWREHUMDQJNDEHUGDVDUNDQSULQVLSPXGKDUDEDKDWDX GEHQWXNODLQEHUGDVDUNDQSULQVLSZDGLDKDWDXPXGKDUDEDK 0HODNXNDQSHQ\DOXUDQGDQDPHODOXL
DPXUDEDKDK ELVWLVQD
F LMDUDK GVDODP
HMXDOEHOLODLQQ\D
3HPELD\DDQEDJLKDVLOEHUGDVDUNDQSULQVLS DPXGKDUDEDK
EPXV\DUDNDK F EDJLKDVLOODLQQ\D
3HPELD\DDQODLQQ\DEHUGDVDUNDQSULQVLS DKLZDODK
0XKDPPDG.RQVWUXNVL 0XGKDUDEDK GDODP %LVQLV 6\DULDK 0XGKDUDEDK GDODP
EUDKQ F TDUG
3DGDSUDNWHNQ\DVHSHUWL%DQN%1,6\DULDKSURGXNSHPELD\DDQ\DQJ GLDSOLNDVLNDQDGDODKMXDOEHOLPXUkEDKDKEDJLKDVLO0XGKkUDEDKVHZD EHOL,MkUDKEDL¶DW7D¶MLULGDQNRQJVLPXV\kUDNDK8ODVDQSURGXNSURGXN
SHPELD\DDQWHUVHEXWVHEDJDLEHULNXW 0XUDEDKDK
0XUDEDKDKDGDODK SHPELD\DDQ GL PDQD SLKDN EDQN V\DULDK PHQ\HGLDNDQGDQDXQWXNPHPEHOLEDUDQJ\DQJGLEXWXKNDQQDVDEDKXPDW 6HFDUDRSHUDVLRQDOSUDNWHNPXUDEDKDKLQLDGDODKMXDOEHOLEDUDQJVHEHVDU KDUJDSHUROHKDQDWDXKDUJDMXDOKDUJDEHOLGLWDPEDKELD\DWUDQVSRUWDVL331 GDQVHEDJDLQ\DGLWDPEDKGHQJDQNHXQWXQJDQPDUJLQ\DQJGLVHSDNDWL GLPDQDSHQMXDOKDUXVPHPEHULWDKXNDQNHSDGDSHPEHOLPHQJHQDLKDUJD EHOLSURGXNGDQPHQ\DWDNDQMXPODKNHXQWXQJDQ\DQJGLWDPEDKNDQSDGD KDUJDSHUROHKDQWHUVHEXW.HXQWXQJDQ%DQN6\DUL¶DKEHUGDVDUNDQSULQVLS NHSDWXWDQ3HPED\DUDQVHMXPODKKDUJDEHOLROHKQDVDEDKGLODNXNDQVHFDUD WDQJJXKGDQPHQXUXWEDWDVZDNWX\DQJGLWHQWXNDQEHUVDPD
0XGKDUDEDK
0XGKDUDEDKDGDODK SHPELD\DDQ XQWXN PDV\DUDNDW \DQJ PHPLOLNL NHDKOLDQ WHWDSL WLGDN SXQ\D PRGDO EDQN V\DULDK EHUVHGLD PHPELD\DL VHSHQXKQ\D VXDWX SUR\HN XVDKD %DQN 6\DUL¶DK VHEDJDLVKRKLEXO PDO
SHPLOLN PRGDO PHPEHULNDQ SLQMDPDQ PRGDO XVDKD SDGD PDV\DUDNDW PXGKRULEXQWXNGLNHORODVHFDUDEDLN5DVLRNHXQWXQJDQPLVTDOQ\D DWDX VHVXDL NHVHSDNDWDQ \DQJ GLEXDW DQWDUD %DQN6\DUL¶DKGHQJDQQDVDEDK$SDELODWHUMDGLNHUXJLDQGDULSUR\HN\DQJ GLMDODQNDQQDVDEDKPDVLQJPDVLQJSLKDNVHFDUDEHULPEDQJPHQDQJJXQJ NHUXJLDQWHUVHEXW
%DL¶DO,VWLVQD
%DL¶DO,VWLVQD\DLWXNRQWUDNRUGHU\DQJGLWDQGDWDQJDQLEHUVDPDDQWDUD SHPHVDQGHQJDQSURGXVHQXQWXNSHPEXDWDQVXDWXMHQLVEDUDQJWHUWHQWX
,MDUDK
,MDUDKDGDODKSHUMDQMLDQDQWDUDSHPLOLNEDUDQJGHQJDQSHQ\HZD\DQJ PHPSHUEROHKNDQSHQ\HZDXQWXNPHPDQIDDWNDQEDUDQJGHQJDQPHPED\DU VHZDVHVXLGHQJDQSHUMDQMLDQNHGXDSLKDN
0XV\DURNDK
0XV\DURNDK\DLWXSHPELD\DDQPRGDONHUMDDWDXLQYHVWDVLGLPDQD%DQN 6\DUL¶DKPHQ\HGLDNDQVHEDJLDQPRGDOXVDKDNHVHOXUXKDQGDQGDODPSURVHV PDQDMHPHQSLKDN%DQN6\DUL¶DKGDSDWGLOLEDWNDQVHFDUDODQJVXQJVHKLQJJD NHGXDQ\DEHUVHULNDWGDODPXVDKD3HPELD\DDQPXV\DURNDKLQLEHUGDVDUNDQ SULQVLSEDJLKDVLOVHVXDLGHQJDQSURSRUVLSHQ\HUWDDQ5DVLRNHXQWXQJDQ PLVDOQ\DDWDXVHVXDLGHQJDQNHVHSDNDWDQ\DQJGLEXDW
%DL¶%LWVDPDQ$MLO
%DL¶ %LWVDPDQ$MLO\DLWX MXDO EHOL GHQJDQ VXDWX DNDG VHEDJDLPDQD WHUMDGLGDODPSULQVLSPXUREDKDKWHWDSLSHPED\DUDQVHMXPODKKDUJDEHOL ROHKQDVDEDKGLODNXNDQVHFDUDEHUDQJVXU
%DL¶$V6DODP
%DL¶$V6DODP\DLWXSHPELD\DDQGLPDQDQDVDEDKPHPHVDQEDUDQJ OHZDW %DQN 6\DUL¶DK -HQLV EDUDQJ GDQ KDUJDQ\D WHODK GLWHQWXNDQ GDQ QDVDEDKPHOXQDVLKDUJDEDUDQJWHUVHEXWSDGDVDDWDNDGQDVDEDKWHODK PHQLWLSNDQXDQJWXQDLSDGD%DQN6\DUL¶DKNHPXGLDQSLKDN%DQN6\DUL¶DK PHQ\HGLDNDQ EDUDQJ \DQJ GLSHVDQ SDGD ZDNWX MDWXK WHPSR VHGDQJ NHXQWXQJDQEDQNKDQ\DEHUXSDMDVDGDULQDVDEDK
+LZDODK
3HPELD\DDQLQLWHUMDGLDSDELODVHVHRUDQJPHPLOLNLXWDQJNHSDGDRUDQJ ODLQNHPXGLDQ\DQJEHUVDQJNXWDQPHQJDMXNDQSHUPRKRQDQNHSDGD%DQN 6\DUL¶DK XQWXN PHPED\DU KXWDQJQ\D VHWHODK %DQN 6\DUL¶DK PHOXQDVL KXWDQJ RUDQJ \DQJ EHUVDQJNXWDQ PDND VWDWXV KXWDQJQ\D EHUGDVDUNDQ DNDGSHUMDQMLDQ\DQJGLEXDWEHUDOLKNHSDGD%DQN6\DUL¶DK
5DKQ
5DKQDGDODKJDGDL\DQJGLODNXNDQVHFDUDVXNDUHODDWDVGDVDUWRORQJ PHQRORQJWDQSDPHQFDULNHXQWXQJDQ5DKQEHUODNXXQWXNVHPXDKDUWDEDLN \DQJEHUJHUDNPDXSXQ\DQJWLGDNEHUJHUDN
4RUGXO+DVDQ
& 2SHUDVLRQDO%DQN6\DUL¶DKGDODP3HPELD\DDQ
'DODPSHPELD\DDQDWDXSHQ\DOXUDQGDQD%DQN6\DUL¶DKPHQJJXQDNDQ VLVWHPEDJLKDVLOGDQSHQJDPELODQNHXQWXQJDQEHUGDVDUNDQV\DUL¶DW,VODP $GDSXQPHNDQLVPHQ\DDGDODK
3HUPRKRQDQ SHPELD\DDQ ROHK QDVDEDK GHQJDQ NHWHQWXDQ VHEDJDL EHULNXW
D0HPEHULNDQNHMHODVDQWHQWDQJSODWIRUPSHPELD\DDQ\DQJGLPRKRQ E0HPEHULNDQNHMHODVDQWHQWDQJUHQFDQDSHQJJXQDDQGDQD
F 0HPEHULNDQ NHMHODVDQ WHQWDQJ UHQFDQD MDQJND ZDNWX SHOXQDVDQ SHPELD\DDQ
G0HPEHULNDQNHMHODVDQWHQWDQJUHQFDQDMDPLQDQDWDVSHPELD\DDQ \DQJGLPRKRQ
H0HPEHULNDQ ODSRUDQ NHXDQJDQ SHUXVDKDDQ PLQLPDO WDKXQ WHUDNKLU
I0HPHQXKLNHWHQWXDQXPXPDGPLQLVWUDVL
J3HQHULPDDQEHUNDVSHUPRKRQDQROHKSHWXJDV%DQN6\DUL¶DK 3DGD SULQVLSQ\D SHUPRKRQDQ SHPEL\DDQ GLDMXNDQ VHFDUD WHUWXOLV
QDPXQ GDODP NHDGDDQ GL PDQD FDUD LQL VXOLW DWDX WLGDN PXQJNLQ GLODNXNDQSHUPRKRQDQGDSDWGLDMXNDQVHFDUDOHVDQODQJVXQJDQWDUD QDVDEDKGHQJDQSHWXJDV
K0HPSHODMDULEHUNDVSHUPRKRQDQ
%HUNDV SHUPRKRQDQ \DQJ GLWHULPD NHPXGLDQ GLSHODMDUL VDPSDL GLGDSDWNDQ VXDWX NHVLPSXODQ EDKZD SHUPRKRQDQ WHUVHEXW OD\DN XQWXNGLWLQGDNODQMXWL
L 6XUYH\/DSDQJDQ
6XUYH\ODSDQJDQGLODNXNDQVHWHODKGLGDSDWNDQVXDWXNHVLPSXODQ\DQJ MHODVEDKZDVXDWXSHUPRKRQDQSHPELD\DDQ\DQJGLDMXNDQSHPRKRQ GLSDQGDQJOD\DNXQWXNGLWLQGDNODQMXWL
M 0HODNXNDQDQDOLVDSHPELD\DDQ
$QDOLVD SHPELD\DDQ DGDODK VHUDQJNDLQ NHJLDWDQ GDODP UDQJND PHQLODL LQIRUPDVL GDWDGDWD VHUWD IDNWD GL ODSDQJDQ VHKXEXQJDQ GLDMXNDQQ\DSHUPRKRQDQSHPELD\DDQROHKVHVHRUDQJ
&RQWRK3HUKLWXQJDQ3UDNWLV3HPELD\DDQ
D0XUDEDKDKPLVDONDQ VHVHRUDQJ QDVDEDK LQJLQ PHPLOLNL VHSHGD PRWRU ,D GDSDW PHQJDMXNDQ SHUPRKRQDQ DJDU %DQN 6\DUL¶DK PHPEHOLNDQQ\D0HODOXLSURVHGXU\DQJWHOLWLNHPXGLDQGLQ\DWDNDQ %DQN 6\DUL¶DK VHWXMX PDND EDQN V\DULDK PHPEHOLNDQ PRWRU WHUVHEXWGDQGLEHULNDQNHSDGDQDVDEDKMLNDKDUJDPRWRUWHUVHEXW 5SGDQ%DQN6\DUL¶DKLQJLQPHQGDSDWNDQNHXQWXQJDQ5S VHODPDGXDWDKXQ+DUJD\DQJGLWHWDSNDQNHSDGDQDVDEDK VHKDUJD5SQDVDEDKGDSDWPHQFLFLOSHPED\DUDQWHUVHEXW 5SSHUEXODQ
E0XGKDUDEDKPLVDONDQVHRUDQJSHGDJDQJ\DQJPHPHUOXNDQPRGDO XQWXNEHUGDJDQJGDSDWPHQJDMXNDQSHUPRKRQDQXQWXNSHPEL\DDQ EDJLKDVLOVHSHUWLPXGKDUDEDKGLPDQD%DQN6\DUL¶DK\DQJEHUWLQGDN VHODNXVKRKLEXOPDOGDQQDVDEDKVHODNXPXGKRULE&DUDQ\DDGDODK GHQJDQPHQJKLWXQJGXOXSHUNLUDDQSHQGDSDWDQ\DQJDNDQGLSHUROHK QDVDEDKGDULSUR\HN\DQJEHUVDQJNXWDQ0LVDOQ\DGDULPRGDO5S GLSHUROHKSHQGDSDWDQ5SSHUEXODQ'DUL SHQGDSDWDQLQLKDUXVGLVLVLKNDQGDKXOXXQWXNWDEXQJDQSHQJHPEDOLDQ PRGDOPLVDOQ\D5SVHOHELKQ\DGLEDJLDQWDUDEDQNGHQJDQ QDVDEDKGHQJDQNHVHSDNDWDQGLPXNDPLVDOQ\DXQWXNQDVDEDK GDQXQWXNEDQN
F 0XV\DURNDKPLVDOQ\D3DN8VPDQDGDODKVHRUDQJSHQJXVDKD\DQJ DNDQ PHODNVDQDNDQ VXDWX SUR\HN XVDKD WHUVHEXW PHPEXWXKNDQ PRGDO VHMXPODK 5S WHUQ\DWD VHWHODK GLKLWXQJ 3DN 8VPDQKDQ\DPHPLOLNL5SGDULPRGDO\DQJGLSHUOXNDQ 3DN8VPDQNHPXGLDQGDWDQJNH%DQN6\DUL¶DKXQWXNPHQJDMXNDQ SHPELD\DDQGHQJDQPRGHOPXV\DURNDK'DODPKDOLQLNHEXWXKDQ WHUKDGDS PRGDO VHMXPODK 5S GLSHQXKL GDUL QDVDEDK GDQ GDUL %DQN 6\DUL¶DK 6HWHODK SUR\HN VHOHVDL QDVDEDK PHQJHPEDOLNDQ GDQD WHUVHEXW EHUVDPD EDJL KDVLO \DQJ WHODKGLVHSDNDWLXQWXN%DQN6\DUL¶DK6HDQGDLQ\DNHXQWXQJDQGDUL SUR\HN WHUVHEXW DGDODK 5S GDQ QLVDEDK DWDX SRUVL \DQJ GLVHSDNDWL SDGD DNKLU SUR\HN 3DN 8VPDQ KDUXV PHQJHPEDOLNDQ GDQD VHEHVDU 5S GLWDPEDK 5S GDULNHXQWXQJDQXQWXNEDQN
SHQJDGDDQEDUDQJ\DQJGLMXDONHSDGDQDVDEDKGLZDNLONDQNHSDGD QDVDEDKEHUVDQJNXWDQXQWXNPHPEHOLQ\D$UWLQ\DQDVDEDKPHPEHOLEDUDQJ VHQGLULVHWHODKGLEHULNDQIDVLOLWDVGDQDROHKEDQNV\DULDK%HEHUDSDWUDQVDNVL MXJDWHUMHEDNSDGDMXDOEHOLIXGKXO\DLWXEDUDQJGLMXDOEHOXPEHQDUEHQDU PHQMDGL PLOLN SHQMXDO DWDX PLOLN EDQN V\DULDK VXGDK GLMXDO ODJL NHSDGD QDVDEDK
6HFDUDIRUPDOEHQWXNDNDGDWDXSHUMDQMLDQSHPELD\DDQPXUDEDKDK PHUXSDNDQDNDGMXDOEHOLDQWDUDEDQNV\DULDKVHODNXSHQMXDOGDQQDVDEDK VHODNXSHPEHOLQDPXQKDNHNDWQ\DEDQNV\DULDKVHEDWDVPHQDZDUNDQSURGXN SHPELD\DDQDWDXSHQGDQDDQNHSDGDFDORQQDVDEDK\DQJPHPEXWXKNDQ SHQGDQDDQEDLNXQWXNNHEXWXKDQSURGXNWLIPDXSXQNRQVXPWLI3UDNWHNLQL PDVLKPLULSGHQJDQPHNDQLVPHSDGDEDQNNRQYHQVLRQDO
'
0XUDEDKDK
,GROD3HPELD\DDQ%DQN6\DULDK
0DV\DUDNDW DZDP PHPSXQ\DL NHVDQ EDKZD EDQN V\DULDK DGDODK EDQN GHQJDQ VLVWHP EDJL KDVLO 6HPXD SURGXN GLDQJJDS PHQJJXQDNDQ EDJLKDVLO3DGDKDOEDQNV\DUL¶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
7DEHO3HQ\DOXUDQ'DQDGDODP3URGXN%DQN6\DULDKGL%HEHUDSD1HJDUD
-HQLV 0DOD\VLD %DKUDLQ %DQJODGHVK (PLUDW -RUGDQ 7XUNL
0XUDEDKDK
,MDUDK
0XGKDUDEDK
0XV\DUDNDK
/DLQQ\D
'L ,QGRQHVLD VHQGLUL GDUL NDVXV %1, 6\DULDK EDKZD SDGD DNDKLU WDKXQPHQXQMXNNDQSHQ\DOXUDQGDQDGDODPEHQWXNSHPELD\DDQ PXUDEDKDKGDQSDGDDNKLUWDKXQPHQXQMXNNDQDQJND'DWD
%DQN,QGRQHVLDSHU0DUHWMXPODKSHPELD\DDQPXUDEDKDKPHQFDSDL VHGDQJNDQ SHPELD\DDQ EDJL KDVLO VHSHUWL PXV\DUDNDK GDQ PXGKDUDEDKPDVLQJPDVLQJEDUXGDQ'DULWRWDOSHPELD\DDQ SHUEDQNDQV\DULDKVHEHVDU5SWULOLXQ5SWULOLXQGLDQWDUDQ\D EHUXSDPXUDEDKDK3DUDKQ\DODJLSHUVHQWDVHGDULWUDQVDNVLPXUDEDKDK LQL PD\RULWDV XQWXN NRQVXPVL EDKNDQ DGD FDEDQJ EDQN V\DULDK \DQJ PHQ\DOXUNDQ SHPELD\DDQQ\D XQWXN NUHGLW PRWRU 3HUVHQWDVH LQL
PHQXQMXNNDQOHELKWLQJJLGDULSDGDSUDNWHNPXUDEDKDKGLQHJDUDPDQDSXQ GLDWDV
(
%DQN6\DULDK3UREOHPDWLNDGDQ6ROXVLQ\D
'RPLQDVL SLOLKDQ \DQJ MDWXK SDGD PXUDEDKDK WHUVHEXW GLVHEDENDQ NDUHQDXQWXNMXDOEHOLLWXODKNHEXWXKDQULLOPDV\DUDNDW$SDELODGRPLQDVL WHUVHEXWGLKXEXQJNDQGHQJDQKDVLOSHQHOLWLDQGLVDODKVDWXEDQNV\DULDK GL6XUDNDUWDWHQWDQJ7DQJJDSDQ0DV\DUDNDW7HUKDGDS%DQN6\DUL¶DK\DQJ PHQJKDVLONDQWHPXDQGLDQWDUDQ\DEDKZDDODVDQ\DQJSDOLQJXWDPDGDUL EHEHUDSDQDVDEDK\DQJPHPSHUROHKSHPELD\DDQGL%DQN6\DUL¶DKXWDPD \DLWXLQJLQPHQJKLQGDULULED$ODVDQGDULEHEHUDSDSHQJXVDKD\DQJ WHUWDULNXQWXNPHQDEXQJGDQPHPSHUROHKSHPEL\DDQGDUL%DQN6\DUL¶DK LQLFXNXSEHUDJDP$ODVDQPHQJDSDPHUHNDWHUWDULNSDGD%DQN6\DUL¶DK VHWHODKGLSHUGDODPGHQJDQSHUWDQ\DDQSHUWDQ\DDQ\DQJEHUNDLWDQGHQJDQ NHXQWXQJDQ PDND IDNWRU NHVHVXDLDQ GHQJDQ V\DUL¶DW ,VODP LQL PHQMDGL PHOHPDK +DO LQL EHUDUWL EDKZD NHWHUWDULNDQ PDV\DUDNDW WHUKDGDS %DQN 6\DUL¶DKPDVLKVDQJDWWHUEDWDVSDGDIDNWRUIDNWRU\DQJEHUVLIDWHPRVLRQDO VHPHQWDUDIDNWRUIDNWRU\DQJEHUNDLWDQGHQJDQDNVHVGDQPXWXSHOD\DQDQ EHOXPPHQGDSDWSHUKDWLDQXWDPD
$ODVDQ LQL PHPSHUOLKDWNDQ EDKZD VHVHRUDQJ PHPLOLK EDQN V\DULDK DGDODK DODVDQ HPRVLRQDOLGHRORJLV EXNDQ DODVDQ \DQJ PHPEHUL VROXVL
%DKDXGGLQ(YDOXDVL3UDNWHN3URGXN3HPELD\DDQ0XUDEDKDKSDGD%DQN6\DULDK
6WXGL.DVXV3DGD%DQN%1,6\DULDK<RJ\DNDUWD7HVLV0DJLVWHU6WXGL,VODP8QLYHUVLWDV ,VODP,QGRQHVLD7DKXQKDO
0DMDODK02'$/1R,-XOL³5XEULN*DJDV8ODV1\HOHQHK´KDO
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
0HUXMXNSDGDSULQVLSGDVDUSHUEDQNDQV\DULDKEDKZDSRODEDJLKDVLO VHVXDLGHQJDQV\DULDW,VODPVHPHVWLQ\DSURGXNSURGXNSHUEDQNDQ\DQJ EHUXSDEDJLKDVLOOHELKXQJJXOGDULSDGDSURGXNSURGXNODLQQ\D.HQ\DWDDQ LQLODK\DQJPHQLPEXONDQNHVDQEDKZDEDQNV\DULDK,QGRQHVLDVHEHQDUQ\D EXNDQEDQNEDJLKDVLOPHODLQNDQ³%DQN0XUDEDKDK´6HEDJLDQRUDQJEDKNDQ PHPHOHVHWNDQQDPD%DQN0XDPDODW,QGRQHVLDPHQMDGL³%DQN0XUDEDKDK ,QGRQHVLD´ %DQN 6\DULDK 0DQGLUL PHQMDGL ³%DQN 6\DULDK 0XUDEDKDK´ 6HPHVWLQ\D SHPELD\DDQ EDJL KDVLO OHELK WLQJJL GDULSDGD SHPELD\DDQ \DQJODLQNDUHQDSHPELD\DDQEDJLKDVLOLQLODK\DQJGDSDWPHPSHUFHSDW SHQJHPEDQJDQHNRQRPLPDV\DUDNDWGDQPHQLQJNDWNDQNHVHMDKWHUDDQXPDW /RJLNDQ\D XPXPQ\D SHPELD\DDQSUR¿W DQG ORVH VKDULQJDWDXUHYHQXH VKDULQJWHUVDOXUNHVHNWRUULLO
)HQRPHQD LQL WLGDN KDQ\D GLSDFX ROHK NRQGLVL XPDW \DQJ OHELK EHURULHQWDVLNRQVXPWLIQDPXQMXJDGLSHQJDUXKLROHKGLDQWDUDQ\DNHVXOLWDQ PHQHPEXVSHPELD\DDQEDJLKDVLOWHUVHEXW3URVHGXU\DQJPHPEHUDWNDQ VHSHUWLDGDQ\DODPDQQ\DELGDQJSHNHUMDDQEDJLQDVDEDK\DQJPHQJDMXNDQ SHUPRKRQDQSHUOXGLUXEDKGHQJDQPHQJDGDNDQSHQGDPSLQJDQDWDXGHQJDQ
SHUVRQDOJXDUDQWHHDWDXDGGODPDQ8QWXNPHQJDWDVLKDOLQLEDQNV\DULDK VHEHQDUQ\DELVDPHPEDQJXQMDULQJDQGHQJDQXODPDDWDXWRNRKPDV\DUDNDW VHWHPSDW-DGLEXNDQPHQRODNSHUPRKRQDQSHPELD\DDQSURGXNWLIWHWDSL PHQHULPDGHQJDQSHQGDPSLQJDQ
SHQHQWXDQ WDULI NHXQWXQJDQ PDUJLQODED MDQJND ZDNWX SHPELD\DDQ MDPLQDQSHPELD\DDQ
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
,GHDOLVPH SHUEDQNDQ 6\DULDK DGDODK SHUEDQNDQ \DQJ GLODQGDVL WHRULSULQVLSHNRQRPLGDQSHUDQJNDWXQGDQJXQGDQJ\DQJPDQWDS3HODNX SHODNXQ\DPHPSXQ\DLDNKODN\DQJLWTDQWHNXQGDQ,KVDQSURIHVLRQDO GDODPELGDQJHNRQRPLEDLN\DQJEHUSHUDQVHEDJDLSURGXVHQNRQVXPHQ SHQJXVDKD GDQ NDU\DZDQ 6HWLDS ODQJNDK ELVQLV KDUXV GLGDVDULDO DPDQDKDOLVWLTDPDKDWWDTZDDVVLGTDOKDTGDQDOTXOE$QWLVLSDVL SDGDNHFHQGHUXQJDQSHQ\LPSDQJDQGDSDWGLWHUDSNDQPHWRGHUHZDUGGDQ
SXQLVKPHQWLQVHQWLIGDQVDQNVLVHWLDSNDOLWHUMDGLGDODPWUDQVDNVL+DOLQL XQWXNPHQJHOLPLQLUNHFXUDQJDQGDQPHQMDJDDJDUQDVDEDK\DQJDPDQDK WHWDSWHJDU
3HUMDODQDQSHUEDQNDQV\DULDK\DQJPDVLKVDQJDWPXGDPHPEHULNDQ NHVHPSDWDQXQWXNEHUNHPEDQJVHFDUDOHELKSHVDWGDQGHQJDQGLQDPLND \DQJ DJUHVLI GDQ VHFDUD EHUWDKDS JUDGXDO 'DVDU SLMDNDQ \DQJ ELVD GLJXQDNDQ DGDODK SHQHOLWLDQSHQHOLWLDQ WHQWDQJ SHUEDQNDQ V\DULDK \DQJ GLODNXNDQROHKSLKDNSHUEDQNDQV\DULDKGHZDQV\DULDKGDQDNDGHPLVL $JUHVLYLWDVGDQGLQDPLND\DQJGLODNXNDQROHKSHUEDQNDQV\DULDKGLODNXNDQ GDODPELQJNDLVHPDQJDWSHUEDLNDQWHUXVPHQHUXV
)
.HVLPSXODQ
GDQ NHVHMDKWHUDDQ HNRQRPL XPDW .HNXDWDQ EDQN V\DULDK VHODPD LQL KDQ\DEHUWXPSXSDGDSLMDNDQHPRVLRQDOLGHRORJLV\DQJPHPDQJPHQMDGL NHNXDWDQ\DQJWHUEHVDU1DPXQDNDQVDQJDWUHQWDQDSDELODSHUNHPEDQJDQ EDQN V\DULDK WLGDN PHQXQMXNNDQ SHUDQQ\D \DQJ OHELK VLJQL¿NDQ SDGD SHQJHPEDQJDQHNRQRPLGDQNHVHMDKWHUDDQXPDW
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
SHUVRQDOJXDUDQWHHDWDXDGGODPDQ'HQJDQPRGHOLQLODSDQJDQNHUMDDNDQ OHELKWHUEXNDGDQSDGDJLOLUDQQ\DNHVHMDKWHUDDQDNDQPHQMDGLOHELKOXDV VHEDUDQQ\D
'DIWDU%DFDDQ
$KPDG'DKODQ³,PSOHPHQWDVL3HPELD\DDQ0XGDUDEDKGL%070HQWDUL $UWKD.RWD7HJDO6WXGL.DVXV7DKXQ´7HVLV0DJLVWHU6WXGL ,VODP8QLYHUVLWDV,VODP,QGRQHVLD
%DKDXGGLQ³(YDOXDVL3UDNWHN3URGXN3HPELD\DDQ0XUDEDKDKSDGD %DQN6\DULDK6WXGL.DVXV3DGD%DQN%1,6\DULDK<RJ\DNDUWD´7HVLV
0DJLVWHU6WXGL,VODP8QLYHUVLWDV,VODP,QGRQHVLD
%XNX 3HGRPDQ 3HUXVDKDDQ %1, 6\DULDK 3HWXQMXN 3HODNVDQDDQ 3HPELD\DDQ-DNDUWD%1,6\DULDK
0DMDODK02'$/³5XEULN*DJDV8ODV1\HOHQHK´1R,-XOL
0XKDPPDG .RQVWUXNVL 0XGKDUDEDK GDODP %LVQLV 6\DULDK 0XGKDUDEDK GDODP ZDFDQD )LTK GDQ 3UDNWLN (NRQRPL 0RGHUQ <RJ\DNDUWD3XVDW6WXGL(NRQRPL,VODP67,6<RJ\DNDUWD
0XKDPPDG GDQ 6KROLKXO +DGL 3HJDGDLDQ 6\DULDK<RJ\DNDUWD 6DOHPED'LQL\DK
6XGLQ+DURQ3ULQVLSGDQ2SHUDVLRQDO3ULQVLS3HUEDQNDQ,VODP.XDOD /XPSXU%HULWD3XEOLVKLQJ
