• Tidak ada hasil yang ditemukan

the complementary medicines reform and its impact to the complementary medicine industry and the consumer lina karlina 2014

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2017

Membagikan "the complementary medicines reform and its impact to the complementary medicine industry and the consumer lina karlina 2014"

Copied!
25
0
0

Teks penuh

(1)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 1 of 25

CHE8000 Major Research Project A

The Complementary Medicines Reforms and Its Impact to the

Complementary Medicine Industry and the Consumer

(2)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 2 of 25 TABLE OF CONTENTS

Abstract ... 6

1 Introduction ... 6

1.1 Background ... 6

1.2 Purpose ... 9

2 Literature Review ... 9

2.1 Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) ... 9

2.2 Complementary Medicines ... 10

3 Methodology ... 11

4 Discussion ... 12

4.1 Complementary Medicines Reforms ... 12

4.1.1 Update to the Australian Regulatory Guidelines for Complementary Medicines (ARGCM)... 14

4.1.2 Update to the key regulatory guidance document on the evidence a sponsor should hold in support of indications for listed medicines ... 14

4.1.3 Update to the listed medicines electronic application portal ... 15

4.1.4 Enhancing post-market monitoring ... 15

4.1.5 Publishing outcomes of listing compliance reviews ... 15

4.1.6 Permitted (coded) indications project ... 16

4.1.7 Investigation process for advertising breaches ... 16

4.2 Impact of Complementary Medicine Reforms to the Industry and the Consumer ... 18

5 Conclusion and Recommendation ... 23

5.1 Conclusion ... 23

5.2 Recommendation ... 24

List of Tables ... 3

(3)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 3 of 25 References ... 24

(4)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 4 of 25 List of Tables

(5)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 5 of 25 List of Pictures

(6)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 6 of 25 The Complementary Medicines Reforms and Its Impact to the Complementary Medicine

Industry and the Consumer

Abstract

It is identified that complementary medicine industry in Australia is continuously growing.

This is due to the increasing use of complementary medicines which may be cause by the

assumption that complementary medicines are risk-free, safer and only contains natural

ingredients as well as the search for alternative or a substitute of conventional medicines.

According to the result of post-market compliance review conducted by the Therapeutic

Goods Administration (TGA) in 2010 and the performance audit conducted by the Australian

National Audit Organisation (ANAO) in 2011 a high number of complementary medicine

non-compliance were identified. To address the recommendations given in the Auditor-General’s report and the results of informal working group review the Secretary of Department of Health and Ageing (DoHA) published ‘TGA Reforms: A Blueprint for TGA’s Future’ which one of its reforms is associated with complementary medicines. The complementary medicine reforms consist of seven aspects and are aimed to reduce the level

of non-compliance by sponsors. These changes to complementary medicines regulatory

framework are most likely to have impact on the industry and the consumer which include

better understand of the current Australian guidelines on complementary medicines, sponsors

are encouraged to continuously comply with the regulatory requirements, more informed

consumer in regards to complementary medicines and the increased protection of consumer

from misleading indications.

1. Introduction 1.1Background

There are 10000 complementary medicines supplied in Australian market and only

about 200 of them are registered on the Australian Register of Therapeutic Goods

(ARTG). The remaining numbers of complementary medicines are listed on the

ARTG. This proportion of registered and listed complementary medicines (98%:2%)

(7)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 7 of 25 which normally slow, high cost and demands more and strict requirements e.g.

clinical trial documents.

According to the National institute of Complementary Medicine (NICM), at least two

out of three Australians use Complementary Medicine (CM) and in the period of

2010-2011 Australians spent more expenses on CM ($2 billion) compare to

conventional medicine e.g. prescribed medicines, over the counter medicines ($1.6

billion) (NICM, 2014).

A survey conducted in November 2013 to January 2014 shows that the Australian

complementary industry is healthy and growing with significant growth estimation in

2017-2018 ($4.6 billion revenue, increase to 45,000 employees). The increasing use

of complementary medicines in Australia is probably due to several factors as follows

(NICM, 2014):

 The search for substitute of conventional medicines with less adverse effects.

 Many consumers view complementary medicines as natural and considered as risk-free (no adverse effects) or at least safer compare to conventional medicines.

However, there is no risk-free therapeutic product including complementary

medicine even it is listed on the ARTG that considered low–risk complementary

medicines.

 There are potential risks pose by prolonged use of some conventional medicines

 Relatively lower cost than conventional medicines especially prescribed medicines

 The increased number of chronic disease, elderly

Complementary medicines supplied in Australian market are regulated by the TGA

and must be either listed or registered on the Australian Registration of Therapeutic

(8)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 8 of 25 risk medicines can be listed on the ARTG. The listing can be conducted by pre-market

self-assessment scheme through the Electronic Listing Facility (ELF). Therefore, the

products are not evaluated by the TGA for its safety, quality and efficacy before

entering the market. However, the ELF system ensures that the products only contain

permitted (safe) substances for low risk products and are manufactured in GMP

licensed facility (Harvey, 2008). The self-assessment method is highly depends on

trust on the complementary sponsor. Nevertheless, the scope of post-market

monitoring by the TGA covers all medicines regardless its registration scheme (listed

or registered).

Complementary medicines started to draw attention to its stakeholders including

regulatory authority, industry and consumers due to two major incidences. The first

incidence occurred in 2003 when the Pan Pharmaceuticals recalled more than 1600 of

its complementary medicine products. The second incidence occurred in 2010 when

the Department of Health and Ageing (DoHA) released a result of post-market

compliance review conducted by TGA on complementary medicines. It is reported

that 90% of the reviewed complementary medicines were non-compliant with

regulatory requirements which partially required removal from the ARTG and only 3

products were compliant (DoHA, 2011).

Given the two major incidences, an audit was conducted in August 2011 by the

Australian National Audit Organisation (ANAO) as part of periodic audit on TGA’s

performance was focused on listed complementary medicines. As a response, in December 2011 the DoHA published several reforms compiled in the ‘TGA Reforms: A Blueprint for TGA’s Future’ which one of its reforms is related to complementary medicines. The purpose of these reforms on complementary medicines is to reduce the

level of non-compliance by sponsors. In this reforms project the TGA holds a major

role in planning, implementing, monitoring and evaluating the results.

This research is intended to describe the changes in complementary medicines

(9)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 9 of 25 Additionally, it will also describe potential impact of the changes on complementary

medicines industry and consumers.

1.2Purpose

The purpose of this research is to describe the impact of the TGA reforms on

complementary medicines to the industry and consumers

2. Literature Review

2.1 Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA)

The Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) is an Australian government

institution under the Department of Health and Ageing that has the responsibility to

regulate therapeutic goods supplied in Australia including the evaluation of its

quality, safety and efficacy. These therapeutic goods comprise prescription

medicines, over-the-counter medicines, medical devices and complementary

medicines. The scope of its regulatory control would include the supply,

manufacturing and advertising of therapeutic goods (TGA, 2014).

During a product life cycle the TGA is responsible for the pre-market assessment,

post-market monitoring and licensing of its Australian manufacturers. In spite of

how the therapeutic goods are approved for sale, either as Aust L or Aust R, it is

subjected to post market monitoring once it has listed or registered on the Australian

Register of Therapeutic Goods (ARTG) (TGA, 2014).

TGA post market regulatory activity of complementary medicines consists of the

following elements (TGA, 2014; NICM, 2014):

 inspection of manufacturers for compliance with Good Manufacturing Practice

(GMP)

 compliance review for listed complementary medicines

(10)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 10 of 25  laboratory testing of complementary medicines in forms of products and

ingredients

 surveillance in the market place

 control and monitoring of complementary medicines advertising

2.2 Complementary Medicines

According to the Therapeutic Goods Regulations 1990, a complementary medicine

is defined as a therapeutic good consisting principally of one or more designated

active ingredients mentioned in Schedule 14 of the Regulations, each of which has a

clearly established identity and traditional use (TGA, 2014)

In Australia, complementary medicines would include vitamins, minerals, herbals,

nutritional supplements, certain aromatherapy preparations and homoeopathic

products. In relation to regulatory framework, complementary medicines are

classified into two types based on its potential risks to consumers, these are (TGA,

2014):

 Low-risk complementary medicines, can be listed on the ARTG

 High-risk complementary medicines, must be registered on the ARTG

Complementary medicines are regulated under the Australian Regulatory Guidelines

for Complementary Medicines (ARGCM). It contains regulatory requirements that

complementary medicines sponsors are bound to comply with.

The risk profiles of complementary medicines are established based on the

following elements (TGA, 2014):

 The composition of substances in the product

 The potential in resulting adverse effects either from short-term or long-term use or due to inappropriate administration.

(11)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 11 of 25 Product risk is inherent in therapeutic goods including complementary medicines.

However, the risks are acceptable when the benefits outweigh the risks. Risks that

may be occurring in respect to the use of complementary medicines are as follows

(Harvey, 2008; NICM, 2014):  Adverse reaction

 Drug interaction when consumed together with some conventional medicines  Use a complementary medicine to replace clinically proven treatment

Sponsors are not allowed to make indications and claims for listed complementary

medicines other than for health maintenance, health improvement and treatment of

non-serious illness.

There are certain information that the labels of complementary medicines required to

have which include (NICM, 2014):

 Product name

 Name and quantities of ingredients

 Name of ingredients that are known to present a risk to some consumers

 Dosage form

 Quantity of the medicine  Required warning statements  Directions for use

 Name and address of the sponsor  Indications/claims

 Registration/listing number

3. Methodology

Method that will be used in this research is qualitative research method to analyse

(12)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 12 of 25 4. Discussion

4.1Complementary Medicines Reforms

Reforms in regards to complementary medicines are part of the “TGA reforms: A blueprint for TGA’s future” which was raised by The Secretary of Department of Health and Ageing (DoHA) in December 2011. The ‘TGA reforms: A blueprint for TGA’s future’ was published as a response to several major reviews in therapeutic goods regulations carried out by government institutions and informal working groups

in 2010 and 2011. Among those reviews there were two reviews that are directly

related to complementary medicines. The first review is the Auditor-General’s report

on Therapeutic Goods Regulation: Complementary Medicines that was released on 30

August 2011 as a result of performance audit conducted by the Australian National

Audit Office (ANAO) in the same year. The second review is when an informal

working group was examining the complementary medicines regulation and causes of

low percentage of regulatory compliance.

The diagram below shows a simple process map that describes how the

(13)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 13 of 25 Picture 1. Process map of complementary medicines reforms

8 December 2011: TGA Reforms: A Blueprint for TGA’s future

These reforms are grouped under the following themes:

 Communications and stakeholder engagement

 Advertising of therapeutic products

 Complementary medicines (Complementary Medicine Reforms)

 Medical devices

 Promotion of therapeutic products

Major reviews of therapeutic goods regulations in 2010 & 2011:

 The review to improve the transparency of the TGA

 Public consultations on the regulatory framework for advertising therapeutic goods

 The Auditor-General’s report on Therapeutic Goods Regulation: Complementary Medicines (August 2011)

 An informal working group examining the regulation of

complementary medicines and reasons for low compliance rates

 Public consultations on the medical devices regulatory framework

 The Working Group on Promotion of Therapeutic Products

 The Health Technology Assessment Review

 The Auditor-General’s report on Therapeutic Goods Regulation:

(Addresses the above 2 reviews in respect to complementary medicines: Auditor-General’s report and Informal Working Group)

 Update to the Australian Regulatory Guidelines for Complementary Medicines

 Update to the key regulatory guidance document on the evidence a sponsor should hold in support of indications for listed medicines

 Update to the listed medicines electronic application portal

 Enhancing post-market monitoring

 Publishing outcomes of listing compliance reviews

 Permitted (coded) indications project

(14)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 14 of 25 As mentioned in the above diagram the Complementary Medicines Reforms include

seven aspects that will be described in the following discussion (TGA, 2014).

4.1.1 Update to the Australian Regulatory Guidelines for Complementary Medicines (ARGCM)

This reform is a response to the Auditor-General’s report particularly on one of

its findings which is that the TGA has taken and continues to take a long time in

reviewing guidance documentation for complementary medicines (ANAO,

2011). This situation may cause precariousness on how to comply with the

regulatory requirements. Moreover, currency is an important nature of

regulatory guidance which will affect the regulator on how to respond on

findings.

Therefore, the Australian Regulatory Guidelines for Complementary Medicines

(ARGCM) as one of the primary guidelines that regulate complementary

medicines is updated by the TGA in a timely manner through the following

activities (DoHA, 2011):

 Publish completion date for the update of ARGCM

 Provide periodic reports of progress on the current updates include its publication on the TGA website.

4.1.2 Update to the key regulatory guidance document on the evidence a sponsor should hold in support of indications for listed medicines

One of the recommendations from Informal Working Group review is to update the ‘Guidelines for levels and kinds of evidence to support indications and claims’ which was published on April 2011. In order to address the

recommendation the TGA has replaced it with the ‘Evidence guidelines:

Guidelines on the evidence required to support indications for listed

complementary medicines’ which was published on March 2014 and refined on

July 2014. The revision of previous guidelines was conducted through public

(15)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 15 of 25 that the guidelines stay current and applicable with present situation (DoHA,

2011).

4.1.3 Update to the listed medicines electronic application portal

In the Auditor-General’s report it was recommended that the TGA enhance the

integrity of listing procedure of complementary medicines due to the increased

number of inappropriate use of free-text field on the electronic system by

sponsors. This reform on the electronic application portal is aimed to ensure that

only permitted claims or indications are made by the sponsors for their

complementary medicines. To achieve this purpose the TGA has planned to

remove the free-text field from the electronic application portal. By doing so the

TGA has directed the sponsors to use only the permitted list of indications

available on the portal (DoHA, 2011).

4.1.4 Enhancing post-market monitoring

Based on the performance audit conducted by the ANAO in 2011 apparently the

TGA did not utilise the results of compliance review on listed complementary

medicines for further use. Therefore, the TGA was recommended to use the

results of compliance review in generating risk profiles on sponsors and

complementary medicines which later will provide a tool in determining priority

of targeted post-market reviews (ANAO, 2011). This reform in post-market

monitoring program is carried out to improve the compliance rate with the

existing regulatory framework of complementary medicines. The TGA has

agreed to the recommendation made by the ANAO by implementing a

risk-based approach in the conduct of its post-market reviews (DoHA, 2011).

4.1.5 Publishing outcomes of listing compliance reviews

According to the ANAO findings the TGA has not publicise the results of its

(16)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 16 of 25 for a long time and that those results are considered important information for

consumers in selecting complementary medicines to be used. Nevertheless, the

TGA has always announced review outcomes which may result in adverse

reaction and/or product recall (ANAO, 2011).

In order to provide information associated with listing compliance review to

consumers the TGA will make the information available to public through the

provision of publicly-viewable elements on the ARTG. This information will

include the complementary medicines that have been reviewed as part of the

post-market monitoring program as well as the review outcomes (DoHA, 2011).

4.1.6 Permitted (coded) indications project

The trigger for this reform associated with permitted indications project is the

increased rate of inappropriate claims made about listed complementary

medicines by the sponsors. This reform is closely related to the previous reform which is ‘Update to the listed medicines electronic application portal’ (section 4.1.3) since it has the same reason and purpose for the reforms to be taken

(ANAO, 2011).

Accordingly, the TGA will improve the permitted indications for listed

complementary medicines through addition of new indications obtained from

the evaluation of claims frequently made by sponsors in the free-text field on

the ARTG (DoHA, 2011).

4.1.7 Investigation process for advertising breaches

Great number of breaches in complementary medicine advertising such as

prohibited terms use and unpermitted claims are currently exist in many media

including a widely used media, internet. The TGA holds a major responsibility

in managing advertising breaches compared to other national agencies

associated with advertising e.g., the Therapeutics Goods Advertising Code

Council (TGACC) and the Complaints Resolution Panel (CRP). It was

(17)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 17 of 25 of advertising violations which resulted in two recommendations (ANAO,

2011).

To address the finding and recommendations the TGA have planned a number

of measures in order to improve the investigation process for advertising

violations which include (DoHA, 2011):

 Implementation of standard operating procedure for investigating

advertising breaches

 Development of timeframes to complete investigations of advertising breaches

 Periodic reporting of the investigation progress to the TGA Executive

It is planned to take four years for the Blueprint reforms to be completely

implemented. This four years implementation period is divided into 3 phases as

follows (TGA, 2012):

 Phase 1 (January – June 2012): better managing our communication  Phase 2 (July 2012 – June 2013): better managing our practice

 Phase 3 (July 2013 – December 2015): mature and sustainable performance Based on the Blueprint Implementation Schedule the implementation of

complementary medicine reforms is scheduled to finish in phase 2 with the following

details:

Table 1. Implementation schedule of complementary medicines reforms

(18)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 18 of 25 4.2Impact of Complementary Medicines Reforms to the Industry and the

Consumers

The impact of complementary medicine reforms on the industry and its consumers

will be discussed according to each reform as described below.

4.2.1 Update to the Australian Regulatory Guidelines for Complementary Medicines (ARGCM)

To the industry:

It is more likely to increase the compliance rate of complementary industry to

the regulatory requirements since the updated guidelines represent the current

regulatory framework. The probability of increase of compliance rate is also

supported by the consultation process held after the first updated version of this

guideline was published involving the TGA and the complementary medicine

stakeholders to maintain the pertinence and currency of information available in

the guidelines (DoHA, 2011).

To the consumer:

The higher the industry compliance rate to regulatory requirements the higher

assurance that their products are safe and of good quality. Provided with the

assurance that complementary medicines available in market place are safe and

of good quality, it will result in higher consumer confidence in using

complementary medicines which later may cause the increase of complementary

medicines usage.

4.2.2 Update to the key regulatory guidance document on the evidence a sponsor should hold in support of indications for listed medicines

To the industry:

The evidence guidelines describe the types and levels of evidence required to

(19)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 19 of 25 including complementary medicines. By revising the previous guidelines to

ensure the currency of information contained the sponsors will be more

well-informed on the requirements demanded by the regulator and eventually it will

likely increase the compliance rate to the regulatory requirements particularly

when the TGA conducts its listing compliance review.

In spite of the positive impact, this reform on the evidence guidelines renders

difficult some of the small industry of complementary medicines since it

normally lack of resources to perform pre-clinical or clinical trial (CMA, 2014).

To the consumer:

Claims or indications made about complementary medicines provided with

scientifically sound evidence will increase the trust of consumers on the safety,

quality and efficacy of complementary medicines because it is scientifically

proven rather than just traditionally known to be effective for certain symptoms.

4.2.3 Update to the listed medicines electronic application portal

To the industry:

This reform is performed by eliminating the free-text field on the application

portal which will direct the sponsors to use only the available indications

provided by the TGA. These indications have been assessed and permitted to be

used for low risk medicines such as listed complementary medicines. Therefore, it will limit the sponsors’ freedom in making claims and indications for their products which this can be considered as an advantage when the sponsor

deliberately misuses the free-text field to make misleading or unsubstantiated

claims or indications for promotion purposes. Moreover, it will be difficult for

the sponsors to make particular indications that are not available in the list but

considered as appropriate for low risk products. Given the situation, the sponsor

(20)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 20 of 25 procedure would not be simple since it has to pass through assessment and

regulation amendments (DoHA, 2011).

To the consumer:

Consumer will be more protected from misleading and unsubstantiated claims

and indications. This is crucial especially when the sponsors do not hold

evidence to support the safety of their products.

4.2.4 Enhancing post-market monitoring

To the industry:

Since a risk-based approach will be implemented on the TGA’s post-market

monitoring program through the utilisation of risk profiles of sponsors and

products characteristics which means products that pose high probability of

non-compliant and sponsors who frequently innon-compliant will be more often

subjected to post-market monitoring (Harvey, 2012). Therefore, this reform

encourages the industry to continuously comply with regulatory requirements.

To the consumer:

This will provide greater assurance to consumer that the listed complementary

medicines reviewed by the TGA are proven to be safe, manufactured in GMP

licensed facility, of good quality and effective. On the other hand, consumer

may become unsure in regards to the safety, quality and efficacy of listed

complementary medicines that have not been reviewed since post-market

monitoring is performed only on a small percentage of the medicines.

4.2.5 Publishing outcomes of listing compliance reviews

To the industry:

Providing the results of listing compliance reviews to public through the TGA

(21)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 21 of 25 may be considered as free promotion media by notifying the public that their

products have been reviewed and passed all the regulatory requirements.

Nevertheless, it results in different situation when the products did not pass the

review. Moreover, the company’s reputation may be damaged when the

companies were given sanctions or financial penalties by the TGA and the

medicine reviewed or other medicines produced by the company may be in

questioned by consumer in regards to its safety, quality and efficacy. Consumer

may question the safety, quality and efficacy of the product reviewed even if the

product was only incompliant with some aspects of the regulatory requirements.

To the consumer:

Publication of the outcomes of listing compliance reviews on the TGA website

provides easy access for consumer to obtain information on complementary

medicines that have been reviewed as well as the outcomes which will greatly

assist the consumer in making well-informed decision associated with

complementary medicines use.

4.2.6 Permitted (coded) indications project

This measure will be taken to support the previous action planned by the TGA

which is the update to the listed medicines electronic application portal.

Therefore, the impact are more likely to be similar.

To the industry:

The sponsors are only allowed to use indications permitted in the list which

have been assessed by the TGA. This project limits the sponsors that previously

used the free-text field to deliberately make misleading claims and indications

for commercial purposes (Harvey, 2012).

To the consumer:

The indications available on the label of complementary medicines packaging

(22)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 22 of 25 Accordingly, it will prevent the consumers from being exposed to misleading

and inappropriate indications.

4.2.7 Investigation process for advertising breaches

To the industry:

A risk-based approach will also be implemented in the investigation of

advertising violations where risk profiles will be developed and trends will be

made based on previous or historical data of advertising breaches (DoHA,

2011). Through trending of the breaches it will be easier to identify sponsors

that often conducted violation on advertising as well as the common type of

advertising breaches. In this regard, sponsors required to better understand and

will be more aware of regulations and requirements applied to advertising of

complementary medicines.

The development of investigation timeframes by the TGA will affect the

response time to address complaint associated with violation in advertising as

well as the time required to determine follow-up action (e.g. sanctions, financial

penalties) to the sponsor who conducted the breaches.

To the consumer:

The completion of investigation associated with advertising breaches within

specified timeframes ensures that follow up action in regard to the

advertisement (e.g. withdrawal from media or public spaces) will be promptly

carried out. It is necessary to have a fast response to prevent the more

widespread of misleading information contained in the advertisement to a larger

(23)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 23 of 25 5. Conclusion and Recommendation

5.1Conclusion

 The complementary medicine reforms consist of the following elements:

- Update to the Australian Regulatory Guidelines for Complementary

Medicines

- Update to the key regulatory guidance document on the evidence a sponsor

should hold in support of indications for listed medicines

- Update to the listed medicines electronic application portal

- Enhancing post-market monitoring

- Publishing outcomes of listing compliance reviews

- Permitted (coded) indications project

- Investigation processes for advertising breaches  The impact of the reforms to the industry would include:

- The sponsors became better understand the Australian guidelines for

complementary medicines (e.g. ARGCM, Evidence guideline) as well as the

approach to comply with current regulatory framework.

- The sponsors are more encouraged to continuously comply with the

regulatory requirements.

- The sponsors are limited to use only the permitted indications during listing

of complementary medicines through the Electronic Listing Facility (ELF).  The impact of the reforms to the consumer would include:

- The consumer became more informed on complementary medicines that

have been reviewed for compliance

- The increased consumer’s assurance that the complementary medicines

supplied in the market place are safe and of good quality.

- The increased protection of consumer from misleading, inappropriate or

(24)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 24 of 25 5.2Recommendation

It is recommended that the government:

 Provides more incentives to encourage the industry to comply with the regulatory framework of complementary medicines.

 Accommodates the industry to conduct clinical research in complementary medicines to encourage evidence-based complementary medicines

 Provides basic information especially associated with listed complementary medicines in an interesting way to educate consumer as well as to assist in

informed decision making.

 Applies more enhanced sanctions and financial penalties to advertising breaches.

References

ANAO, 2011, The Auditor – General audit Report No. 3 2011 – 12 Performance Audit Therapeutic Goods Regulation: Complementary Medicine, Australia.

CMA, 2014, 2014 Complementary Medicines Industry Survey, Australia

DoHA, 2011, TGA Reforms: A Blueprint for TGA’s Future, Australia.

Harvey, K, 2008, Does CM regulation need reform?, Australia.

Harvey, K, 2012, TGA Complementary Medicines Reforms, Australia.

NICM, 2014, The Safety of Complementary Medicines, Australia.

NICM, 2014, Information for Consumers: Reports, Surveys and Audits, Australia. <http://www.nicm.edu.au/health_information/information_for_consumers/reports,_

surveys,_audits>

TGA, 2012, Delivering Reforms – Implementation Plan for TGA Reforms: A Blueprint for TGA’s Future, Australia.

(25)

Lina Karlina (2067226) Page 25 of 25 <http://www.tga.gov.au/complementary-medicine-regulation-basics>

TGA, 2014, Complementary Medicines Reforms, Australia.

< http://www.tga.gov.au/complementary-medicines-reforms>

TGA, 2014, TGA Basics, Australia. <http://www.tga.gov.au/tga-basics>

Bibliography

Bollen, D & Whicker, S, 2009, Complementary Medicines Regulatory Reform, Australian ‘Health Review’, Vol. 33, No. 2, Australia.

Harvey, K, 2008, Australian Complementary Medicine Regulation: Time for Reform!, ‘Health Issues’, Winter 2008, Issue 95, Australia.

Harvey, K, 2009, A Review of Proposals to Reform the Regulation of Complementary Medicines, ‘Australian Health Review’, Vol. 33, No. 2, Australia.

Harvey, K, 2012, The Evidence for Complementary Medicines, ‘Consumers Health Forum of Australia’, Issue 11, Australia.

Pollard et.al., 2008, Commercialism, Choice and Consumer Protection: Regulation of Complementary Medicines in Australia, ‘MJA’, Vol. 1889, No. 1, Australia.

Gambar

Table 1. Implementation schedule of complementary medicines reforms  Work Streams  Phase 1  – January 2012

Referensi

Dokumen terkait

f) Sertifikat keahlian (SKA) dan Ijazah tenaga ahli tetap yang dipersyaratkan, dan.. g) Surat pengangkatan tenaga ahli tetap bersangkutan oleh pimpinan perusahaan dan

[r]

PERPRES 70 Tahun 2012, terhitung sejak tanggal 13 September 2015 sampai dengan tanggal 15 September 2015 Demikian disampaikan, untuk

Pada hari ini, Jum’at tanggal Dua belas bulan Agustus tahun Dua ribu sebelas, berdasarkan Keputusan Kelompok Kerja Biro Kerumahtanggaan Unit Layanan Pengadaan Sekretariat Jenderal

[r]

Jeda waktu antara penembakan getaran ultra sonic dan penerimaan getaran pantul adalah sebanding dengan jarak antara transduser dengan dinding Jarak antara transmitter dan receiver

Akibat timbulnya resistensi dari antibiotik, maka saat ini telah banyak dilakukan pengujian efek tanaman obat sebagai antibakteri, salah satunya jeruk nipis.. Hasil

dengan kekerasan verbal paling banyak didapat oleh anak dari orang tua mereka.. Bahkan tanpa disadari setiap harinya orang tua melakukan pada