LAMPIRAN 1 DISPLACEMENT DAN DRIFT RATIO

(1)

LAMPIRAN 1

DISPLACEMENT DAN DRIFT RATIO

(2)

6 Lantai OF=1.2

Lantai Elevasi

Gempa 200 tahun Gempa 500 tahun Gempa 1000 tahun Pushover Time History Pushover Time History Pushover Time History

Disp. (m) Disp.

(m)

Time

(s) Disp. (m) Disp.

(m)

Time

(s) Disp. (m) Disp.

(m)

Time (s) 6 21.00 0.188068 0.2225 3.14 0.301314 - - 0.442926 - - 5 17.50 0.17696 0.2127 3.14 0.284011 - - 0.417888 - - 4 14.00 0.153603 0.1878 3.13 0.247785 - - 0.364648 - - 3 10.50 0.118542 0.1466 3.12 0.194987 - - 0.288805 - - 2 7.00 0.075115 0.09504 3.11 0.129487 - - 0.195763 - - 1 3.50 0.032182 0.04218 3.09 0.060938 - - 0.095889 - - 0 0.00 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 - - 0.000 - -

Lantai

Elevasi

Drift Drift Time

(s) Drift Drift Time

(s) Drift Drift Time (s) 6 21.00 0.003174 0.003677 4.83 0.004944 - - 0.007154 - - 5 17.50 0.006673 0.007631 4.79 0.01035 - - 0.015212 - - 4 14.00 0.010017 0.012109 3.19 0.015085 - - 0.021669 - - 3 10.50 0.012408 0.014923 3.15 0.018714 - - 0.026584 - - 2 7.00 0.012267 0.015149 3.12 0.019585 - - 0.028535 - - 1 3.50 0.009195 0.012051 3.09 0.017411 - - 0.027397 - - 0 0.00 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 - - 0.000 - -

6 Lantai OF=1.5

Lantai

Elevasi

Gempa 200 tahun Gempa 500 tahun Gempa 1000 tahun Pushover Time History Pushover Time History Pushover Time History Disp. (m) Disp.

(m)

Time

(s) Disp. (m) Disp.

(m)

Time

(s) Disp. (m) Disp.

(m)

Time (s) 6 21.00 0.19518 0.2233 3.13 0.299444 - - 0.440721 - - 5 17.50 0.183659 0.2122 3.14 0.282163 - - 0.414425 - - 4 14.00 0.159458 0.1863 3.14 0.24611 - - 0.362051 - - 3 10.50 0.123289 0.1463 3.12 0.193615 - - 0.287555 - - 2 7.00 0.078497 0.09576 3.1 0.128505 - - 0.195249 - - 1 3.50 0.033978 0.04291 3.09 0.060417 - - 0.095692 - -

0 0.00 0.000 0.000 0 0.000 - - 0.000 - -

(3)

Lant Drift Drift Time

(s) Drift Drift Time (s) 6 21.00 0.003292 0.004066 4.83 0.004938 - - 0.007513 - - 5 17.50 0.006915 0.007643 4.78 0.010301 - - 0.014964 - - 4 14.00 0.010334 0.011809 3.18 0.014999 - - 0.021285 - - 3 10.50 0.012798 0.01474 3.16 0.018603 - - 0.026373 - - 2 7.00 0.01272 0.015143 3.11 0.019454 - - 0.028445 - - 1 3.50 0.009708 0.01226 3.09 0.017262 - - 0.02734 - - 0 0.00 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 - - 0.000 - -

10 Lantai OF=1.2

Lantai

Elevasi

Disp. (m) Disp.

(m)

Time

(s) Disp. (m) Disp.

(m)

Time

(s) Disp. (m) Disp.

(m)

Time (s) 10 35.00 0.287408 0.2242 3.27 0.461571 - - 0.66939 - -

9 31.50 0.282527 0.2245 3.26 0.455195 - - 0.660615 - - 8 28.00 0.27215 0.2227 2.53 0.439659 - - 0.638192 - - 7 24.50 0.254995 0.2126 3.25 0.412719 - - 0.599299 - - 6 21.00 0.2277 0.1883 3.23 0.371723 - - 0.541921 - - 5 17.50 0.192429 0.1526 3.21 0.319388 - - 0.469338 - - 4 14.00 0.150404 0.1106 3.18 0.257093 - - 0.383062 - - 3 10.50 0.105936 0.07127 3.12 0.189586 - - 0.288334 - - 2 7.00 0.062018 0.03907 4.09 0.119984 - - 0.188405 - - 1 3.50 0.024368 0.01309 4.07 0.05438 - - 0.089802 - -

0 0.00 0.000 0.000 0 0.000 - - 0.000 - -

(4)

Lantai

Elevasi

Drift Drift Time

(s) Drift Drift Time (s) 10 35.00 0.001395 0.002576 2.61 0.001822 - - 0.002507 - -

9 31.50 0.002965 0.005069 2.59 0.004439 - - 0.006407 - - 8 28.00 0.004901 0.007617 2.56 0.007697 - - 0.011112 - - 7 24.50 0.007799 0.0085 2.62 0.011713 - - 0.016394 - - 6 21.00 0.010078 0.011114 3.29 0.014953 - - 0.020738 - - 5 17.50 0.012007 0.012514 3.25 0.017799 - - 0.02465 - - 4 14.00 0.012705 0.011966 3.22 0.019288 - - 0.027065 - - 3 10.50 0.012548 0.00994 3.2 0.019886 - - 0.028551 - - 2 7.00 0.010757 0.007437 3.08 0.018744 - - 0.028172 - - 1 3.50 0.006962 0.00374 3.06 0.015537 - - 0.025658 - -

0 0.00 0.000 0.000 0 0.000 - - 0.000 - -

10 Lantai OF=1.5

Lantai

Elevasi

Gempa 200 tahun Gempa 500 tahun Gempa 1000 tahun Pushover Time History Pushover Time History Pushover Time History Disp. (m) Disp.

(m)

Time

(s) Disp. (m) Disp.

(m)

Time

(s) Disp. (m) Disp.

(m)

Time (s) 10 35.00 0.286337 0.2249 3.27 0.459453 0.3237 3.3 0.679016 - -

9 31.50 0.281452 0.2253 3.27 0.453057 0.3208 3.29 0.66993 - - 8 28.00 0.271072 0.2233 2.53 0.437524 0.3127 3.28 0.646974 - - 7 24.50 0.253919 0.2125 3.25 0.410626 0.2927 3.27 0.60738 - - 6 21.00 0.226643 0.188 3.23 0.369713 0.2543 3.25 0.549135 - - 5 17.50 0.191415 0.1525 3.21 0.317512 0.2025 3.22 0.475549 - - 4 14.00 0.149465 0.1106 3.18 0.255406 0.1457 3.19 0.388134 - - 3 10.50 0.105118 0.07118 3.12 0.188158 0.09342 3.14 0.292174 - - 2 7.00 0.061383 0.03899 4.09 0.118908 0.05254 3.07 0.190956 - - 1 3.50 0.023999 0.01304 4.07 0.05377 0.01928 3.06 0.091056 - - 0 0.00 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 - -

(5)

Lant Drift Drift Time

(s) Drift Drift Time (s) 10 35.00 0.001396 0.002585 2.62 0.001827 0.003637 4.86 0.002596 - -

9 31.50 0.002966 0.00532 2.59 0.004438 0.006163 4.92 0.006559 - - 8 28.00 0.004901 0.007591 2.56 0.007685 0.008509 3.4 0.011313 - - 7 24.50 0.007793 0.008497 2.62 0.01169 0.012534 3.34 0.016641 - - 6 21.00 0.010065 0.011051 3.3 0.014915 0.015829 3.3 0.021025 - - 5 17.50 0.011986 0.0125 3.25 0.017745 0.017097 3.27 0.024976 - - 4 14.00 0.012671 0.011969 3.22 0.019214 0.015689 3.23 0.027417 - - 3 10.50 0.012496 0.00994 3.2 0.019786 0.0128 3.2 0.028919 - - 2 7.00 0.010681 0.007423 3.08 0.018611 0.009526 3.09 0.028543 - - 1 3.50 0.006857 0.003726 3.06 0.015363 0.005509 3.06 0.026016 - - 0 0.00 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 - -

(6)

LAMPIRAN 2

PERBANDINGAN DUCTILITY DEMAND DENGAN

POSSESSED DEMAND

(7)

200 tahun

Periode

Gempa Portal eksterior (Possessed Demand)

200 tahun

2.381 1.408 4.489 2.103 4.534 2.354 4.449 2.292 3.675 3.152

0.9331 26.75 19.14 20.05 23.54 0.9544

1.07 0.897 0.8785 0.8644 0.8663 0.8162

9.661 4.966 5.284 6.004 5.347 5.59 5.367 5.517 4.369 6.246

0.9055 22.66 23.06 21.64 23.03 13.06

0.9845 0.8451 0.8677 0.8545 0.8611 0.6281

18.63 8.48 14.89 9.582 15.16 9.627 15.31 9.551 14.52 9.933

8.299 21.98 21.13 20.34 21.55 19.71

0.8039 0.848 0.8401 0.8312 0.8169 0.6557

20.81 11.86 23.71 12.95 22.73 13.46 22.81 13.1 19.21 12.41

0.8643 4.234 3.176 3.233 5.001 0.9798

0.7466 0.8184 0.7821 0.7831 0.8047 0.6281

21.08 13.09 22.66 14.12 22.81 14.1 22.8 14.01 19.92 13.81

0.5521 0.8206 0.8108 0.8114 0.8414 0.6263

0.6811 0.8867 0.8803 0.8802 0.9075 0.7222

22.07 13.68 25.47 14.6 25.46 14.6 25.47 14.56 20.71 14.01

0.4723 0.5897 0.5915 0.5913 0.6038 0.5321

12.05 9.809 10.07 10.07 9.682 11.87

37.3194 37.3194 38.7193 38.7193 38.7193 38.7193 38.7193 38.7193 37.3194 37.3194

54.9884 45.3111 45.3111 45.3111 45.3111 54.9884

39.6085 61.3054 34.7380 34.7380 34.7380 34.7380 34.7380 34.7380 61.3054 61.3054

47.6674 39.9282 39.9282 39.9282 39.9282 47.6674

59.8550 32.2214 61.9254 29.4700 61.9254 29.4700 61.9254 29.4700 59.8550 59.8550

50.3123 35.6910 35.6910 35.6910 35.6910 50.3123

57.3021 28.8488 63.5492 28.7231 63.5492 28.7231 63.5492 28.7231 57.3021 28.8488

38.5196 29.6408 29.6408 29.6408 29.6408 38.5196

53.0603 30.5715 65.2500 28.3824 65.2500 28.3824 65.2500 28.3824 53.0603 30.5715

30.7936 27.0206 27.0206 27.0206 27.0206 30.7936

56.3991 32.2549 46.3766 28.9125 46.3766 28.9125 46.3766 28.9125 56.3991 32.2549

28.9065 24.7687 24.7687 24.7687 24.7687 28.9065

(8)

Periode Gempa

Time History 6 Lt (OF=1,2) Portal interior (Ductility Demand)

200 tahun

Periode

Gempa Portal interior (Possessed Demand)

200 tahun

0.7888 1.609 2.246 2.135 2.195 2.086 2.121 2.067 1.656 0.843

0.9223 0.9242 0.892 0.8677 0.8874 0.9738

0.9651 0.6848 0.6833 0.6754 0.6677 0.6652

5.814 4.977 5.145 5.631 5.143 6.001 5.14 5.372 4.559 7.086

0.7822 1.646 1.505 1.917 1.452 0.9595

0.9296 0.7769 0.78 0.803 0.7702 0.6992

14.69 8.695 11.84 10.02 13.21 9.478 11.99 9.913 11.93 10.15

0.8181 1.84 1.692 1.874 1.725 1.095

0.6137 0.7353 0.7115 0.7236 0.7391 0.4793

19.47 11.09 19.08 12.39 18.18 12.71 18.16 12.64 17.79 12

0.6474 0.8896 0.8646 0.8752 0.8803 0.7782

0.6154 0.6445 0.6459 0.6424 0.6498 0.5191

20.65 12.29 20.51 13.19 20.67 13.19 20.69 13.11 20.81 12.19

0.4345 0.6767 0.6585 0.6561 0.6739 0.5808

0.5934 0.6916 0.6782 0.6782 0.6872 0.622

20.87 13.03 20.62 13.83 20.64 13.83 20.65 13.82 20.13 12.97

0.348 0.4798 0.4843 0.4845 0.4774 0.4415

8.349 5.96 6.032 6.031 6.006 6.924

29.4589 29.4589 28.0149 28.0149 28.0149 28.0149 28.0149 28.0149 29.4589 29.4589

35.7144 35.7144 35.7144 35.7144 35.7144 35.7144

34.7380 34.7380 35.9729 35.9729 35.9729 35.9729 35.9729 35.9729 34.7380 34.7380

30.5086 30.5086 30.5086 30.5086 30.5086 30.5086

56.8623 31.5222 49.1394 32.9732 49.1394 32.9732 49.1394 32.9732 56.8623 31.5222

28.4152 28.4152 28.4152 28.4152 28.4152 28.4152

66.8938 28.1550 65.3680 29.6654 65.3680 29.6654 65.3680 29.6654 66.8938 28.1550

22.7892 22.7892 22.7892 22.7892 22.7892 22.7892

44.4923 29.6513 66.7423 27.9504 66.7423 27.9504 66.7423 27.9504 44.4923 29.6513

21.6520 21.6520 21.6520 21.6520 21.6520 21.6520

66.4948 30.7909 65.3440 29.7694 65.3440 29.7694 65.3440 29.7694 66.4948 30.7909

20.8591 20.8591 20.8591 20.8591 20.8591 20.8591

(9)

200 tahun

Periode

Gempa Portal eksterior (Possessed Demand)

200 tahun

5.325 2.921 4.424 5.338 4.494 5.585 4.395 5.219 3.631 4.851

0.9084 4.798 0.9937 0.9934 1.037 0.9444

3.592 0.863 0.8176 0.8915 0.8032 0.7888

10.05 6.519 7.213 7.776 6.679 7.737 7.018 7.469 7.289 7.73

0.7684 2.295 1.001 1.002 1.074 0.9494

0.8251 0.7843 0.8357 0.8334 0.8303 0.5881

18.93 9.78 17.74 11.05 17.96 10.99 18.02 10.95 17.11 10.16

0.8925 1.086 0.9921 0.9925 1.006 3.764

0.7505 0.6967 0.6862 0.6843 0.7053 0.5717

20.4 11.89 23.78 12.92 22.67 13.39 22.7 13.23 19.42 12.25

0.7357 0.842 0.8324 0.8338 0.8633 0.8154

0.6522 0.6802 0.654 0.6535 0.6626 0.5575

20.86 12.97 22.42 13.96 22.53 13.95 22.53 13.88 19.72 13.68

0.4674 0.6762 0.6689 0.6686 0.688 0.5503

0.5641 0.7167 0.704 0.7039 0.726 0.6196

22.33 13.84 25.79 14.77 25.79 14.77 25.79 14.72 20.97 14.13

0.4974 0.5968 0.6097 0.6098 0.6123 0.5292

11.93 11.23 9.982 9.954 9.795 12.44

44.4961 37.3194 38.7193 38.7193 38.7193 38.7193 38.7193 38.7193 37.3194 37.3194

53.4787 39.8458 39.8458 39.8458 39.8458 53.4787

39.6085 61.3054 64.2231 34.7380 64.2231 34.7380 64.2231 34.7380 39.6085 61.3054

38.6976 32.7062 32.7062 32.7062 32.7062 38.6976

59.8550 32.2214 61.9254 29.4700 61.9254 29.4700 61.9254 29.4700 59.8550 32.2214

42.3972 31.3151 31.3151 31.3151 31.3151 42.3972

57.3021 28.8488 63.5492 28.7231 63.5492 28.7231 63.5492 28.7231 57.3021 28.8488

33.2899 25.3865 25.3865 25.3865 25.3865 33.2899

53.0603 30.5715 65.2500 28.3824 65.2500 28.3824 65.2500 28.3824 53.0603 30.5715

30.2661 24.5400 24.5400 24.5400 24.5400 30.2661

56.3991 32.2549 46.3766 28.9125 46.3766 28.9125 46.3766 28.9125 56.3991 32.2549

33.6924 25.7896 25.7896 25.7896 25.7896 33.6924

(10)

Periode Gempa

Time History 6 Lt (OF=1,5) Portal interior (Ductility Demand)

200 tahun

Periode

Gempa Portal interior (Possessed Demand)

200 tahun

0.7949 2.093 2.281 2.743 2.239 2.737 2.165 2.595 1.694 0.927

0.7872 0.7726 0.7545 0.7501 0.7682 0.9068

0.7543 0.5413 0.5167 0.5179 0.5307 0.5568

5.813 6.068 5.151 6.946 5.146 6.933 5.143 6.773 4.627 7.903

0.6323 0.8732 0.8721 0.8719 0.8829 0.7745

0.6735 0.6795 0.6675 0.6709 0.6799 0.4918

14.08 9.152 12.84 10.43 14.03 10.01 13.03 10.26 12.55 10.05

0.6026 0.8682 0.853 0.8491 0.8583 0.7803

0.5504 0.6106 0.598 0.5977 0.6192 0.3929

18.99 10.91 18.71 12.17 17.76 12.52 17.79 12.45 17.44 11.75

0.5389 0.7109 0.7011 0.7027 0.7071 0.6547

0.5169 0.5277 0.5318 0.5312 0.5325 0.4237

20.43 12.17 20.25 13.07 20.42 13.06 20.43 12.98 20.57 12.08

0.3558 0.5485 0.5325 0.532 0.5443 0.4829

0.4857 0.5498 0.5383 0.5383 0.5457 0.5066

21.14 13.17 20.91 13.98 20.93 13.99 20.93 13.97 20.41 13.11

0.3557 0.4973 0.502 0.5019 0.4949 0.4506

8.571 6.139 6.214 6.212 6.189 7.114

29.4589 29.4589 28.0149 28.0149 28.0149 28.0149 28.0149 28.0149 29.4589 29.4589

30.5345 30.5345 30.5345 30.5345 30.5345 30.5345

34.7380 34.7380 35.9729 35.9729 35.9729 35.9729 35.9729 35.9729 34.7380 34.7380

26.2835 26.2835 26.2835 26.2835 26.2835 26.2835

56.8623 31.5222 49.1394 32.9732 49.1394 32.9732 49.1394 32.9732 56.8623 31.5222

26.0967 26.0967 26.0967 26.0967 26.0967 26.0967

66.8938 28.1550 65.3680 29.6654 65.3680 29.6654 65.3680 29.6654 66.8938 28.1550

21.3686 21.3686 21.3686 21.3686 21.3686 21.3686

44.4923 29.6513 66.7423 27.9504 66.7423 27.9504 66.7423 27.9504 44.4923 29.6513

19.6439 19.6439 19.6439 19.6439 19.6439 19.6439

66.4948 30.7909 65.3440 29.7694 65.3440 29.7694 65.3440 29.7694 66.4948 30.7909

21.8057 21.8057 21.8057 21.8057 21.8057 21.8057

(11)

200 tahun

4.064 1.938 2.575 4.083 1.998 3.611 2.345 3.104 1.151 3.296

0.7759 33.18 35.86 23.84 28.09 0.7722

0.6631 0.8582 0.8983 0.9018 0.8586 0.633

7.779 5.652 6.84 5.909 6.928 5.779 7.357 5.649 4.79 6.635

0.9125 6.553 6.182 5.88 9.018 0.9355

0.8212 0.7698 0.8349 0.8351 0.7672 0.7126

10.66 12.17 12.38 14.29 11.22 13.98 10.87 13.5 12.84 14.2

1.002 9.206 5.204 4.926 8.413 8.308

0.9342 0.9777 0.9387 0.9395 0.9715 0.8258

11.88 15.19 10.79 14.99 10.8 14.89 10.53 14.64 12.46 15.84

8.338 20.38 18.5 18.78 19.86 16.65

0.8577 4.084 2.492 1.659 4.452 0.9042

16.47 13.05 17.59 13.74 18.59 14.11 18.57 13.87 16.67 13.47

0.9529 13.29 11.5 11.47 13.37 6.432

0.8987 0.9941 0.9787 0.9791 0.9984 0.9252

21.19 9.887 20.1 11.86 20.23 11.87 20.2 11.87 20.24 11.13

0.974 0.9777 0.9623 0.9621 0.9706 0.8743

0.8135 0.8787 0.8696 0.8695 0.8831 0.8133

19.16 9.85 20.87 11.13 20.75 11.14 20.84 11.09 19.47 10.42

0.8915 1.116 0.9897 0.9895 1.046 0.8298

0.7787 0.9593 0.9391 0.9395 0.9717 0.7966

13.87 7.908 16.48 9.191 16.37 9.03 16.89 8.87 13.4 8.603

0.8323 0.9588 0.9263 0.9259 0.9429 0.8324

0.8783 0.9441 0.9291 0.9293 0.9689 0.8193

9.712 6.82 11.63 8.346 11.71 8.355 11.78 8.389 9.293 7.635

0.5617 0.6643 0.6485 0.6485 0.6581 0.5332

0.9526 0.89 0.88 0.8799 0.904 0.79

8.031 7 8.064 7.114 8.099 7.158 8.095 6.975 7.503 7.045

0.5575 0.5014 0.5051 0.5052 0.5067 0.4685

2.032 1.412 1.408 1.408 1.469 1.994

(12)

Periode Gempa

Time History 10 Lt (OF=1,2) Portal eksterior (Possessed Demand)

200 tahun

36.0174 36.0174 35.9649 35.9649 35.9649 35.9649 35.9649 35.9649 36.0174 36.0174

59.0269 59.1356 59.1356 59.1356 59.1356 59.0269

37.2577 61.7020 38.6808 38.6808 38.6808 38.6808 38.6808 38.6808 37.2577 37.2577

46.1804 41.2337 41.2337 41.2337 41.2337 46.1804

34.4044 45.0900 32.8261 32.8261 32.8261 32.8261 32.8261 32.8261 45.0900 45.0900

53.3549 38.4245 38.4245 38.4245 38.4245 53.3549

57.3498 57.3498 40.7899 40.7899 40.7899 40.7899 40.7899 40.7899 57.3498 57.3498

42.0639 31.0310 31.0310 31.0310 31.0310 42.0639

56.8880 56.8880 53.7213 53.7213 53.7213 53.7213 53.7213 53.7213 56.8880 56.8880

39.0688 29.9182 29.9182 29.9182 29.9182 39.0688

57.9977 27.6241 54.8595 26.8563 54.8595 26.8563 54.8595 26.8563 57.9977 27.6241

35.2341 25.4648 25.4648 25.4648 25.4648 35.2341

58.4875 25.6517 57.9006 27.6445 57.9006 27.6445 57.9006 27.6445 58.4875 25.6517

32.3785 23.5585 23.5585 23.5585 23.5585 32.3785

53.8679 24.8416 67.0467 26.0303 67.0467 26.0303 67.0467 26.0303 53.8679 24.8416

29.6352 20.5567 20.5567 20.5567 20.5567 29.6352

57.7775 57.7775 58.0582 58.0582 58.0582 58.0582 58.0582 58.0582 57.7775 57.7775

29.6742 20.4815 20.4815 20.4815 20.4815 29.6742

53.1615 53.1615 56.9328 56.9328 56.9328 56.9328 56.9328 56.9328 53.1615 53.1615

26.2382 20.3604 20.3604 20.3604 20.3604 26.2382

(13)

200 tahun

1.737 1.18 2.038 2.005 2.041 1.756 2.251 1.491 1.426 1.087

0.987 0.8953 0.8709 0.8555 0.8567 0.9873

0.6212 0.5796 0.6119 0.6142 0.6229 0.6013

7.517 3.704 6.545 5.587 6.529 5.212 6.414 4.971 4.446 6.206

0.8172 0.9859 0.9622 0.9584 0.9778 0.8409

0.6088 0.6945 0.6762 0.6829 0.6797 0.6338

9.188 10.57 9.341 9.368 9.428 9.323 9.316 9.829 7.638 9.065

0.7698 0.9336 0.9083 0.9066 0.9301 0.7963

0.7707 0.71 0.6862 0.6859 0.7089 0.5608

9.668 11.97 9.323 11.69 9.434 11.63 9.438 11.82 8.495 10.48

0.8679 1.393 1.285 1.318 1.388 1.032

0.6514 0.8372 0.8141 0.815 0.8363 0.7281

14.45 10.86 15.75 11.05 16.6 11.15 16.52 11.15 15.44 10.11

0.7119 0.9942 0.9612 0.9609 0.9833 0.8681

0.722 0.8629 0.8429 0.844 0.8665 0.7506

16.79 9.8 18.8 11.33 18.47 11.36 18.49 11.43 17.05 11.06

0.7846 0.7429 0.7303 0.7309 0.7467 0.6859

0.654 0.6598 0.6468 0.6471 0.6638 0.6572

17.61 9.529 18.24 11.4 18.44 11.34 18.42 11.25 17.58 10.53

0.7581 0.758 0.7451 0.7452 0.7714 0.6443

0.5899 0.7303 0.7117 0.7118 0.721 0.6649

14.89 7.867 15.11 9.306 15.15 9.32 15.17 9.27 14.15 8.975

0.7159 0.6377 0.6291 0.6288 0.6398 0.6556

0.7001 0.6512 0.6397 0.6399 0.6498 0.7146

9.571 6.578 10.01 6.909 10.04 7.229 10.1 7.122 9.419 7.297

0.4735 0.4301 0.4335 0.4339 0.4328 0.3955

0.6892 0.5629 0.557 0.5572 0.5628 0.6427

7.216 6.293 7.201 6.596 7.268 6.619 7.21 6.582 6.952 6.773

0.4593 0.3428 0.3437 0.3437 0.3467 0.3825

1.551 0.9239 0.9183 0.9186 0.9262 1.504

(14)

Periode Gempa

Time History 10 Lt (OF=1,2) Portal interior (Possessed Demand)

200 tahun

33.4097 33.4097 31.2338 31.2338 31.2338 31.2338 31.2338 31.2338 33.4097 33.4097

58.5340 58.5340 58.5340 58.5340 58.5340 58.5340

37.6954 37.6954 40.7955 40.7955 40.7955 40.7955 40.7955 40.7955 37.6954 37.6954

45.1886 45.1886 45.1886 45.1886 45.1886 45.1886

35.3408 49.4952 33.9730 36.2247 33.9730 36.2247 33.9730 36.2247 49.4952 35.3408

39.1922 39.1922 39.1922 39.1922 39.1922 39.1922

65.6215 65.6215 33.0243 54.1540 33.0243 54.1540 33.0243 54.1540 65.6215 65.6215

33.3080 33.3080 33.3080 33.3080 33.3080 33.3080

58.1321 58.1321 59.7911 59.7911 59.7911 59.7911 59.7911 59.7911 58.1321 58.1321

29.0550 29.0550 29.0550 29.0550 29.0550 29.0550

58.3459 28.8629 58.1078 28.3059 58.1078 28.3059 58.1078 28.3059 58.3459 28.8629

25.0397 25.0397 25.0397 25.0397 25.0397 25.0397

67.5679 27.7328 58.0137 29.3491 58.0137 29.3491 58.0137 29.3491 67.5679 27.7328

22.4003 22.4003 22.4003 22.4003 22.4003 22.4003

59.8746 27.4890 58.8348 28.1713 58.8348 28.1713 58.8348 28.1713 59.8746 27.4890

20.0800 20.0800 20.0800 20.0800 20.0800 20.0800

51.6479 51.6479 58.5554 28.4326 58.5554 58.5554 58.5554 58.5554 51.6479 51.6479

18.8490 18.8490 18.8490 18.8490 18.8490 18.8490

58.1714 58.1714 64.7778 64.7778 64.7778 64.7778 64.7778 64.7778 58.1714 58.1714

18.0565 18.0565 18.0565 18.0565 18.0565 18.0565

(15)

200 tahun

4.343 1.934 3.531 4.078 2.563 3.669 2.722 3.555 1.161 3.435

0.7768 13.12 8.272 11.27 7.697 0.7715

0.7016 0.8483 0.8747 0.8828 0.8432 0.6345

7.814 6.893 7.532 6.697 7.617 6.737 8.042 6.768 5.504 6.791

0.7576 0.8831 0.8772 0.8698 0.8829 0.7828

0.6563 0.672 0.6901 0.6885 0.6684 0.584

11.38 12.85 12.88 14.84 12.29 14.51 12.22 14.24 13.47 14.08

0.8903 0.8533 0.8442 0.8431 0.8541 0.933

0.8831 0.714 0.7398 0.7389 0.7242 0.6783

13.88 15.19 14.18 14.98 13.73 14.88 13.48 14.64 13.65 15.73

0.861 0.9615 0.9466 0.946 0.9554 0.9803

0.738 0.7825 0.763 0.7621 0.7823 0.7443

16.03 13.07 19.82 13.77 19.99 14.14 19.95 13.91 18.73 13.45

0.7896 0.9158 0.8993 0.8985 0.9183 0.9076

0.7834 0.8081 0.7971 0.7972 0.8209 0.7824

21.05 9.877 20.1 11.85 20.19 11.86 20.18 11.85 19.69 11.54

0.8031 0.7824 0.7778 0.7776 0.7912 0.7307

0.6916 0.7134 0.706 0.706 0.7174 0.6779

19.16 9.836 20.84 11.12 20.72 11.12 20.82 11.08 19.38 10.43

0.8066 0.8158 0.7978 0.7976 0.8088 0.726

0.6983 0.7867 0.7693 0.7697 0.7972 0.729

14.03 7.779 16.59 8.998 16.45 9.07 16.52 8.925 13.44 8.615

0.7198 0.7798 0.753 0.7458 0.7672 0.6973

0.7376 0.7821 0.7625 0.7627 0.7906 0.7268

9.712 7.056 11.63 8.195 11.71 8.204 11.78 8.221 9.291 7.005

0.5538 0.543 0.5314 0.5314 0.5358 0.5275

0.9197 0.7316 0.7232 0.7231 0.7352 0.7652

8.021 6.811 8.047 6.882 8.082 6.926 8.078 6.821 7.126 6.694

0.5581 0.5024 0.5061 0.5062 0.5083 0.452

2.021 1.372 1.373 1.373 1.39 1.86

(16)

Periode Gempa

200 tahun

36.0174 36.0174 35.9649 35.9649 35.9649 35.9649 35.9649 35.9649 36.0174 36.0174

59.0491 57.7525 57.7525 57.7525 57.7525 59.0491

37.2577 61.7020 38.6808 38.6808 38.6808 38.6808 38.6808 38.6808 37.2577 37.2577

40.2736 35.3180 35.3180 35.3180 35.3180 40.2736

45.0900 45.0900 32.8261 32.8261 32.8261 32.8261 32.8261 32.8261 45.0900 45.0900

48.8447 33.6522 33.6522 33.6522 33.6522 48.8447

57.3498 57.3498 40.7899 40.7899 40.7899 40.7899 40.7899 40.7899 57.3498 57.3498

37.0212 27.9062 27.9062 27.9062 27.9062 37.0212

56.8880 56.8880 53.7213 53.7213 53.7213 53.7213 53.7213 53.7213 56.8880 56.8880

37.1304 27.3700 27.3700 27.3700 27.3700 37.1304

57.9977 27.6241 54.8595 26.8563 54.8595 26.8563 54.8595 26.8563 57.9977 27.6241

31.2448 21.4975 21.4975 21.4975 21.4975 31.2448

58.4875 25.6517 57.9006 27.6445 57.9006 27.6445 57.9006 27.6445 58.4875 25.6517

32.0335 23.9400 23.9400 23.9400 23.9400 32.0335

53.8679 24.8416 67.0467 26.0303 67.0467 26.0303 67.0467 26.0303 53.8679 24.8416

28.2851 20.6281 20.6281 20.6281 20.6281 28.2851

57.7775 57.7775 58.0582 58.0582 58.0582 58.0582 58.0582 58.0582 57.7775 57.7775

29.0108 19.4867 19.4867 19.4867 19.4867 29.0108

53.1615 53.1615 56.9328 56.9328 56.9328 56.9328 56.9328 56.9328 53.1615 53.1615

26.2424 20.3601 20.3601 20.3601 20.3601 26.2424

(17)

200 tahun

1.758 1.178 2.047 2.028 2.038 1.755 2.201 1.615 1.431 1.164

0.9262 0.7271 0.7053 0.6962 0.7133 0.9262

0.5797 0.4667 0.5003 0.5007 0.504 0.5618

7.531 3.817 6.572 6.1 6.556 5.697 6.425 5.501 4.319 6.728

0.6666 0.907 0.8845 0.882 0.9005 0.6945

0.5118 0.6309 0.6163 0.616 0.6174 0.5082

9.162 10.52 9.322 9.322 9.407 9.275 9.293 9.784 8.826 9.239

0.634 0.743 0.7231 0.7229 0.7404 0.6644

0.5601 0.5668 0.5479 0.5476 0.566 0.4572

9.793 11.88 10.63 11.65 10.35 11.6 10.16 11.79 10.06 10.42

0.6443 0.8209 0.8041 0.8038 0.82 0.7745

0.5378 0.6737 0.651 0.6507 0.6673 0.5951

14.04 10.89 15.65 11.07 16.44 11.17 16.39 11.17 15.39 10.11

0.555 0.7549 0.7297 0.736 0.7466 0.6926

0.598 0.6697 0.6471 0.6443 0.667 0.5997

17.55 9.438 18.63 11.25 18.31 11.28 18.33 11.34 16.35 11.46

0.6249 0.5934 0.5829 0.5828 0.5966 0.5725

0.5427 0.5381 0.5276 0.5278 0.5415 0.5302

17.62 9.529 18.26 11.4 18.44 11.34 18.43 11.26 17.58 10.54

0.621 0.61 0.5993 0.5995 0.6209 0.5071

0.4654 0.5891 0.5793 0.5793 0.5869 0.5554

15.07 7.732 15.14 9.314 15.16 9.332 15.2 9.281 14.18 8.981

0.5875 0.5344 0.5264 0.5261 0.536 0.517

0.5585 0.5515 0.5411 0.5415 0.55 0.5976

9.568 6.457 10.09 7.118 10.1 7.095 10.1 6.978 9.418 7.147

0.3918 0.3565 0.3613 0.3612 0.3594 0.3154

0.5481 0.4707 0.4652 0.4655 0.4701 0.5352

7.2 6.103 7.178 6.374 7.234 6.393 7.193 6.364 6.934 6.537

0.4609 0.3428 0.3434 0.3436 0.3467 0.3833

1.542 0.9218 0.9134 0.9127 0.9127 1.48

(18)

Periode Gempa

Time History 10 Lt (OF=1,5) Portal interior (Posssessed Demand)

200 tahun

33.4097 33.4097 31.2338 31.2338 31.2338 31.2338 31.2338 31.2338 33.4097 33.4097

41.8966 41.8966 41.8966 41.8966 41.8966 41.8966

37.6954 37.6954 40.7955 40.7955 40.7955 40.7955 40.7955 40.7955 37.6954 37.6954

28.2715 28.2715 28.2715 28.2715 28.2715 28.2715

35.3408 49.4952 33.9730 36.2247 33.9730 36.2247 33.9730 36.2247 49.4952 35.3408

26.8420 26.8420 26.8420 26.8420 26.8420 26.8420

65.6215 65.6215 54.1540 54.1540 54.1540 54.1540 54.1540 54.1540 65.6215 65.6215

23.5810 23.5810 23.5810 23.5810 23.5810 23.5810

58.1321 58.1321 59.7911 59.7911 59.7911 59.7911 59.7911 59.7911 58.1321 58.1321

21.2919 21.2919 21.2919 21.2919 21.2919 21.2919

58.3459 28.8629 58.1078 28.3059 58.1078 28.3059 58.1078 28.3059 58.3459 28.8629

19.6025 19.6025 19.6025 19.6025 19.6025 19.6025

67.5679 27.7328 58.0137 29.3491 58.0137 29.3491 58.0137 29.3491 67.5679 27.7328

18.4863 18.4863 18.4863 18.4863 18.4863 18.4863

59.8746 27.4890 58.8348 28.1713 58.8348 28.1713 58.8348 28.1713 59.8746 27.4890

17.6455 17.6455 17.6455 17.6455 17.6455 17.6455

51.6479 51.6479 58.5554 58.5554 58.5554 58.5554 58.5554 58.5554 51.6479 51.6479

16.7065 16.7065 16.7065 16.7065 16.7065 16.7065

58.1714 58.1714 64.7778 64.7778 64.7778 64.7778 64.7778 64.7778 58.1714 58.1714

18.0986 18.0986 18.0986 18.0986 18.0986 18.0986

(19)

500 tahun

7.028 2.113 2.256 3.954 2.084 3.979 3.02 4.762 0.9702 8.38

0.7843 38.57 32.41 19.61 42.55 0.8063

0.8627 0.9644 0.9413 0.9992 4.801 0.6767

8.765 6.77 7.503 9.553 9.52 8.389 6.449 9.823 8.116 10.71

0.7937 0.9291 0.8842 0.8973 0.9276 0.8345

0.8277 0.7884 0.8094 0.8211 0.7905 0.7103

14.7 13.22 14.94 13.64 15.32 13.86 15.83 13.78 12.9 12.36

2.532 4.194 2.706 2.524 2.955 16.78

0.9766 0.8653 0.8358 0.836 0.8521 0.9087

22.44 18.99 19.63 18.4 20.02 18.33 20.01 18.38 19.07 17.92

5.125 8.746 7.321 7.517 7.874 10.75

0.9198 0.9762 0.9495 0.9401 0.9815 0.9993

28.45 17.06 31.14 18.39 31.39 18.33 31.43 18.49 28.04 16.4

0.9141 2.308 1.046 1.047 1.709 1.624

0.885 0.898 0.8888 0.8879 0.903 0.8893

31.5 15.14 31.09 17.85 31.08 17.87 31.46 17.67 30.72 16.66

0.8725 0.8347 0.8394 0.8307 0.8519 0.7757

0.7156 0.7635 0.7509 0.756 0.7622 0.6963

28.91 13.36 29.24 15.61 29.41 15.6 29.41 15.53 26.34 15.44

0.9103 0.8948 0.8816 0.8796 0.8943 0.8466

0.8975 0.9185 0.8946 0.8945 0.923 0.878

19.91 11.08 23.26 12.71 23.4 12.7 23.39 12.65 19.28 11.91

0.8023 0.8435 0.8168 0.8168 0.838 0.7973

0.8884 0.8926 0.8822 0.8821 0.9047 0.8371

14.56 8.135 16.85 9.569 16.97 9.596 16.97 9.485 13.64 8.771

0.6605 0.6044 0.6024 0.5968 0.5947 0.6408

1.039 0.7853 0.7763 0.7766 0.7978 0.9093

11.84 7.558 13.14 8.265 13.19 8.243 13.49 8.161 12.14 7.447

0.6468 0.5566 0.561 0.5606 0.5682 0.603

3.996 2.8 2.783 2.783 2.872 3.16

(20)

Periode Gempa

500 tahun

56.6310 36.0174 35.9649 35.9649 35.9649 35.9649 35.9649 35.9649 36.0174 36.0174

59.0491 57.7525 57.7525 57.7525 57.7525 59.0491

61.7020 37.2577 63.5078 38.6808 63.5078 38.6808 38.6808 38.6808 61.7020 37.2577

40.2736 35.3180 35.3180 35.3180 35.3180 40.2736

45.0900 45.0900 32.8261 32.8261 32.8261 32.8261 32.8261 32.8261 45.0900 45.0900

48.8447 33.6522 33.6522 33.6522 33.6522 48.8447

57.3498 57.3498 40.7899 40.7899 40.7899 40.7899 40.7899 40.7899 57.3498 57.3498

37.0212 27.9062 27.9062 27.9062 27.9062 37.0212

56.8880 56.8880 53.7213 53.7213 53.7213 53.7213 53.7213 53.7213 56.8880 30.7571

37.1304 27.3700 27.3700 27.3700 27.3700 37.1304

57.9977 27.6241 54.8595 26.8563 54.8595 26.8563 54.8595 26.8563 57.9977 27.6241

31.2448 21.4975 21.4975 21.4975 21.4975 31.2448

58.4875 25.6517 57.9006 27.6445 57.9006 27.6445 57.9006 27.6445 58.4875 25.6517

32.0335 23.9400 23.9400 23.9400 23.9400 32.0335

53.8679 24.8416 67.0467 26.0303 67.0467 26.0303 67.0467 26.0303 53.8679 24.8416

28.2851 20.6281 20.6281 20.6281 20.6281 28.2851

57.7775 57.7775 58.0582 58.0582 58.0582 58.0582 58.0582 58.0582 57.7775 57.7775

29.0108 19.4867 19.4867 19.4867 19.4867 29.0108

53.1615 28.7652 56.9328 28.2463 56.9328 28.2463 56.9328 28.2463 53.1615 53.1615

26.2424 20.3601 20.3601 20.3601 20.3601 26.2424

(21)

500 tahun

0.995 2.282 1.173 3.643 1.071 3.576 1.353 3.276 0.9471 4.435

0.9095 0.889 0.9098 0.9239 0.9504 0.9591

0.7293 0.5384 0.5301 0.5354 0.5627 0.5934

5.665 5.793 6.121 7.031 5.742 7.201 5.022 7.251 5.157 8.583

0.6793 0.9356 0.9126 0.9085 0.929 0.7147

0.6817 0.7385 0.747 0.7466 0.7253 0.5957

10.6 10.63 9.649 9.571 9.419 9.545 9.913 9.527 10.97 9.965

0.7431 0.8763 0.8606 0.8623 0.874 0.8048

0.7042 0.6423 0.6456 0.645 0.6435 0.5325

16.66 14.4 16.47 15.11 17.19 14.42 16.61 15.12 15.47 13.63

0.8069 0.9666 0.9503 0.9501 0.9652 0.9205

0.6909 0.8494 0.8262 0.8262 0.8424 0.8018

24.64 14.33 26.79 16.22 26.76 16.26 26.72 16.28 24.27 15.14

0.6636 0.8424 0.8169 0.817 0.834 0.7746

0.6756 0.7411 0.718 0.718 0.7372 0.6703

25.89 14.85 29.12 16.89 29.07 16.91 29.05 16.9 26.8 15.81

0.6807 0.6375 0.6266 0.6265 0.6396 0.587

0.562 0.5801 0.5651 0.5652 0.5743 0.5443

26 13.17 26.34 15.85 26.6 15.81 26.62 15.66 25.06 14.84

0.7009 0.6757 0.6629 0.6631 0.68 0.5965

0.6106 0.6862 0.6786 0.678 0.6847 0.6704

21.58 11.05 21.57 12.86 21.86 12.8 21.56 12.87 20.11 12.44

0.6546 0.5851 0.5766 0.5767 0.5857 0.5941

0.676 0.6403 0.6306 0.6308 0.6404 0.6868

14.95 8.489 15.15 9.38 15.12 9.41 15.21 9.352 14.42 8.607

0.4689 0.4075 0.4102 0.4133 0.4082 0.4145

0.6122 0.4836 0.4785 0.4791 0.4842 0.5856

12.09 7.46 12.25 8.179 12.17 8.413 12.16 8.432 11.88 7.645

0.5587 0.3691 0.3705 0.3703 0.373 0.5202

3.211 1.801 1.782 1.782 1.783 2.359

(22)

Periode Gempa

Time History 10 Lt (OF=1,5) Portal interior (Possessed Demand)

500 tahun

33.4097 33.4097 31.2338 31.2338 31.2338 31.2338 31.2338 31.2338 33.4097 33.4097

41.8966 41.8966 41.8966 41.8966 41.8966 41.8966

37.6954 37.6954 57.4269 57.4269 57.4269 40.7955 57.4269 40.7955 62.3970 37.6954

28.2715 28.2715 28.2715 28.2715 28.2715 28.2715

49.4952 49.4952 36.2247 33.9730 36.2247 33.9730 36.2247 36.2247 49.4952 35.3408

26.8420 26.8420 26.8420 26.8420 26.8420 26.8420

65.6215 65.6215 54.1540 54.1540 54.1540 54.1540 54.1540 54.1540 65.6215 65.6215

23.5810 23.5810 23.5810 23.5810 23.5810 23.5810

58.1321 58.1321 59.7911 30.7084 59.7911 30.7084 59.7911 30.7084 58.1321 58.1321

21.2919 21.2919 21.2919 21.2919 21.2919 21.2919

58.3459 28.8629 58.1078 28.3059 58.1078 28.3059 58.1078 28.3059 58.3459 28.8629

19.6025 19.6025 19.6025 19.6025 19.6025 19.6025

67.5679 27.7328 58.0137 29.3491 58.0137 29.3491 58.0137 29.3491 67.5679 27.7328

18.4863 18.4863 18.4863 18.4863 18.4863 18.4863

59.8746 27.4890 58.8348 28.1713 58.8348 28.1713 58.8348 28.1713 59.8746 27.4890

17.6455 17.6455 17.6455 17.6455 17.6455 17.6455

51.6479 51.6479 58.5554 28.4326 58.5554 28.4326 58.5554 28.4326 51.6479 27.5629

16.7065 16.7065 16.7065 16.7065 16.7065 16.7065

58.1714 28.4699 64.7778 29.1939 64.7778 29.1939 64.7778 29.1939 58.1714 28.4699

18.0986 18.0986 18.0986 18.0986 18.0986 18.0986

(23)

LAMPIRAN 3

Prosedur Perhitungan Yield Curvature Pada

Program RUAUMOKO 3D

(24)

As atas

As 400 700

Lampiran ini didasarkan pada hasil analisis nonlinear time history portal beton bertulang 6 lantai dengan daktilitas penuh untuk keperluan skripsi penulis. Contoh perhitungan berikut menampilkan perbandingan nilai yield curvature elemen balok yang dihitung oleh RUAUMOKO 3D dengan yang dilaporkan oleh ESDAP, serta nilai damage index yang dihitung oleh RUAUMOKO 3D dibandingkan dengan hasil perhitungan jika menggunakan nilai yield curvature dari ESDAP.

Data penampang balok :

f

_c

’ = 30 MPa ; E

_c

= 4700√ f

_c

’ = 25742960,2 kNm

²

E

s

= 2E+08 kNm

²

I gross = 1/12 x 0,4 x 0,7

³

= 0,01143 m

⁴

Selimut beton = 40 mm

Tulangan lentur (f

y

= 400 MPa) As atas = 1169,6152 mm

²

As bawah =584,8076 mm

²

Tulangan geser (f

y

= 240 MPa)

digunakan rectangular hoops Ø 12 – 109.15(2 kaki) Hasil analisis moment-curvature dari ESDAP :

Positif:

Ø

y+

= 0.004111298 rad/m;

Ø

u+

= 0.18293652 rad/m

M

_y⁺

= 139.18 kNm; M

_u⁺

= 212.26 kNm r (bi-linear factor) = 0.012072

μ

u+

= Ø

u+

/ Ø

y+

= 44.49605

Negatif:

Ø

_y^-

= 0.004313951

rad/m; Ø

_u^-

= 0.16099408

rad/m

M

_y^-

= 279.102

kNm; M

_u^-

= 407.54

kNm

r (bi-linear factor) = 0.01267

μ

u-

= Ø

u-

/ Ø

y-

= 37.3194

Hasil analisis nonlinear time history RUAUMOKO 3D :

Pada program RUAUMOKO 3D, untuk merepresentasikan respon nonlinear elemen

struktur terdapat beberapa macam hysteresis rule (Appendix B, manual

RUAUMOKO 3D). Untuk keperluan penelitian ini digunakan bi-linear hysteresis

seperti terlihat pada gambar berikut.

(25)

F = member force atau moment.

d = member deformation atau curvature.

k

0

= initial elastic stiffness (dalam hal kekakuan lentur adalah EI).

F

_y

= yield force atau moment.

r = bi-linear factor.

d

y

= yield deformation atau curvature (d

y

= F

y

/k

0

).

Nilai M

_y

, r, μ

_u

(positif dan negatif) dari hasil ESDAP dipakai sebagai input untuk nonlinear properties elemen pada RUAUMOKO 3D, sedangkan nilai Ø

y

dihitung sendiri oleh RUAUMOKO 3D sesuai keterangan yang tertera pada Appendix B, dimana Ø

_y

= M

_y

/EI (dengan I adalah I gross sesuai yang di-input untuk elastic properties).

Hasil output analisis nonlinear time history dari RUAUMOKO 3D melaporkan maximum curvature (Ø

m

), maximum ductility (μ

_m

), serta damage index (DI) sebagai berikut :

End1z Æ Ø

m

= -0,002265 rad/m (negative envelope)

Ø

_y

= M

_y^-

/E

_c

Igross = -279.102/(25742960,2 x 0,01143) = -0,0009485 rad/m μ

_m

= Ø

_m

/ Ø

_y

= -0,002265 /-0,0009485 = 2,388

DI = (μ

m

-1)/(μ

u-

-1) = (2,388- 1)/( 37.3194 - 1) = 0.038 End2z Æ Ø

m

= -0,001339 rad/m (negative envelope)

Ø

_y

= M

_y^-

/E

_c

Igross = -279.102/(25742960,2 x 0,01143) = -0,0009485 rad/m μ

m

= Ø

m

/ Ø

y

= -0,001339 /-0,0009485 = 1.411

DI = (μ

m

-1)/(μ

u+

-1) = (1.411- 1)/(37.3194 - 1) = 0.011

Jika nilai-nilai di atas dihitung kembali dengan menggunakan yield curvature (Ø

_y

)

dari ESDAP, maka :

(26)

End1z Æ Ø

m

= -0,002265 rad/m (negative envelope)

Ø

_y

= -0.004313951 rad/m (negative yield curvature dari ESDAP) μ

_m

= Ø

_m

/ Ø

_y

= -0,002265 /-0.004313951 = 0.525

DI = (μ

m

-1)/(μ

u-

-1) = (0.525- 1)/( 37.3194- 1) = -0.013 Hal ini berarti balok belum mengalami pelelehan End2z Æ Ø

_m

= -0,001339 rad/m (negative envelope)

Ø

y

= -0.004313951

rad/m (negative yield curvature dari ESDAP) μ

m

= Ø

m

/ Ø

y

= -0,001339 /-0.004313951

= 0.31

DI = (μ

_m

-1)/(μ

_u-⁺