$1$/,6,6.(%(5/$1-87$13(1*(/2/$$1+87$1/,1'81*
0$1*529(',%$78$03$5.$%83$7(1.8%85$<$
3529,16,.$/,0$17$1%$5$7
"OBMZTJTPG4VTUBJOBCJMJUZPG.BOHSPWF1SPUFDUJPO'PSFTU.BOBHFNFOU
JO#BUV"NQBS,VCV3BZB3FHFODZ8FTU,BMJNBOUBO1SPWJODF
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
.H\ZRUGV0XOWLGLPHQVLRQDOVFDOLQJDQDO\VLVSURWHFWHGPDQJURYHIRUHVWVVXVWDLQDELOLW\5$30SIRUHVW
$%675$.
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
,3(1'$+8/8$1
(NRVLVWHP PDQJURYH PHPEHULNDQ PDQIDDW VHFDUD HNRORJLV VHEDJDL SHQ\HGLD QXWULVL WHPSDW PHPLMDK VHUWD PHQFDUL PDNDQ EHEHUDSD ELRWD SHUDLUDQ PHOLQGXQJL JDULV SDQWDL GDUL HURVL PHQ\HGLDNDQDUHDSHPELELWDQEDJLEDQ\DNVSHVLHV LNDQGDQNUXVWDVHDPHQFHJDKLQWUXVLDLUODXWGDQ DQJLQNHQFDQJGDQSHQDKDQJHORPEDQJODXWVHUWD PDQIDDW HNRQRPLV DQWDUD ODLQ VHEDJDL SHQ\HGLD EHUEDJDLKDVLOKXWDQND\XGDQMDVDHNRVLVWHPGDQ PHQ\HGLDNDQ WHPSDW XQWXN DUHD SHPELELWDQ PDQJURYH .XHQ]HUHW DO 6DVLGKDUHW DO
*LULHWDOGDQ0DVRRGHWDO
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
/XDV KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH GL ZLOD\DK .HFDPDWDQ%DWX$PSDUVHOXDVKDDWDX VHNLWDUGDULOXDVKXWDQOLQGXQJPDQJURYHGL .DEXSDWHQ .XEX 5D\D 'LQDV 3HUNHEXQDQ .HKXWDQDQGDQ3HUWDPEDQJDQ.DEXSDWHQ.XEX 5D\D 3HUPDVDODKDQ XWDPD SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH GL .DEXSDWHQ .XEX 5D\DWHUPDVXNGLZLOD\DK.HFDPDWDQ%DWX$PSDU DGDODK ODMX NHUXVDNDQ WHJDNDQ PDQJURYH GDQ HNRVLVWHPQ\DVHEDJDLGDPSDNGDULEHUEDJDLMHQLV SHPDQIDDWDQ VHFDUD NRPHUVLDO ROHK PDV\DUDNDW ORNDOGDQVHNLWDUQ\D
3ULQVLS SHPEDQJXQDQ EHUNHODQMXWDQ PHP SXQ\DL HIHN VHFDUD XPXP WHUKDGDS NHVHOXUXKDQ
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
3DWDQJ
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²6HSWHPEHU
6XPEHU6RXUFH*RRJOHHDUWK
*DPEDU/RNDVLSHQHOLWLDQ
)LJXUH5HVHDUFKORFDWLRQ
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
/60 $GDSXQ GDWD VHNXQGHU EHUXSD GDWD GDQ LQIRUPDVL \DQJ EHUNDLWDQ GHQJDQ NHWLJD GLPHQVL NHEHUODQMXWDQ GLSHUROHK GDUL KDVLO VWXGL GRNXPHQWDVL GDQ VWXGL WHUKDGDS KDVLOKDVLO SHQHOLWLDQOLWHUDWXUWHUNDLWGDWDPRQRJUDILORNDVL SHQHOLWLDQ
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
0'6DQDOLVLV0RQWH&DUORGDQDQDOLVLV/HYHUDJH 5$3),6 + VHEDJDL WHNQLN VWDWLVWLN XQWXN PHQJJDPEDUNDQ VHFDUD FHSDW GDQ DNXUDW VWDWXV NHEHUODQMXWDQ SHQJHORODDQ EHUGDVDUNDQ DWULEXW
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
6HODQMXWQ\D QLODL LQGHNV NHEHUODQMXWDQ SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH GDODP DQDOLVLV GDWD GLNHORPSRNDQ NHGDODP HPSDW WLQJNDWDQ VWDWXV NHEHUODQMXWDQ \DLWX ² WLGDNEHUNHODQMXWDQ²NXUDQJNHEHU
ODQMXWDQ²FXNXSNHEHUODQMXWDQGDQ ² EHUNHODQMXWDQ *DPEDU 1LODL LQGHNV NHEHUODQMXWDQ PDVLQJPDVLQJ GLPHQVL GLJDPEDUNDQGDODPEHQWXNGLDJUDPOD\DQJOD\DQJ NLWH GLDJUDP $QDOLVLVOHYHUDJH GLJXQDNDQ XQWXN PHQJHWDKXL DQWULEXWDWULEXW \DQJ VHFDUD VHQVLWLI PHPHQJDUXKL WLQJNDW NHEHUODQMXWDQ SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH 3HUXEDKDQ QLODL5RRW
0HDQ 6TXDUH 506 PHUXSDNDQ QLODL \DQJ
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
6XPEHU6RXUFH'LPRGLILNDVLGDUL6XZDUQR0RGLILHGIURP6XZDUQR
*DPEDU7DKDSDQDQDOLVLVGDWD )LJXUH'DWDDQDO\VLVVWDJHV %XUXN%DG ñì9 %DLN*RRG íìì9 ì9 *DPEDU,OXVWUDVLVWDWXVNHEHUODQMXWDQSHQJHORODDQKXWDQVHEHVDU
)LJXUH,OOXVWUDWLRQRI VXVWDLQDELOLW\VWDWXVRI IRUHVWPDQDJHPHQWDW 6XPEHU6RXUFH'LPRGLILNDVLGDUL6XZDUQR0RGLILHGIURP6XZDUQR
$QDOLVLV0RQWH &DUOR PHUXSDNDQ UDQJNDLDQ
GDODP PHWRGH 5DS03IRUHVW XQWXN PHQGXJD WLQJNDWNHVDODKDQDFDNUDQGRPHUURUSDGDPRGHO \DQJ GLKDVLONDQ GDUL DQDOLVLV 0'6 XQWXN VHPXD GLPHQVLSDGDWLQJNDWNHSHUFD\DDQ>6HPDNLQ NHFLOQLODL@DQWDUDKDVLODQDOLVLV0'6GDQDQDOLVLV
0RQWH &DUOR PDND VHPDNLQ EDLN PRGHO \DQJ GLKDVLONDQ PHWRGH 5DS03IRUHVW6XZDUQRHW DO GDQ +DVUDW 1LODL DNKLU \DQJ GLKDVLONDQ GDUL DQDOLVLV 5DS03IRUHVW \DLWX QLODL LQGHNV NHEHUODQMXWDQ NRHILVLHQ GHWHUPLQDVL 5ñ GDQ QLODL >VVWUHVV 6@ 6XZDUQR HW DO
PHQ\DWDNDQ EDKZD PRGHO GLNDWHJRULNDQJRRGQHVV
RI ILWFXNXSEDLNDSDELODPHPLOLNLQLODL6
GDQ5ñ!DWDXPHQGHNDWL
,,,+$6,/'$13(0%$+$6$1 $+DVLO
%HUGDVDUNDQKDVLO)*'LQGLNDWRUNHEHUODQ MXWDQ SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH GL .HFDPDWDQ%DWX$PSDUGLWHQWXNDQVHEDQ\DN LQGLNDWRU WHUGLUL GDUL GHODSDQ LQGLNDWRU NULWHULD HNRORJL WXMXK LQGLNDWRU NULWHULD HNRQRPL GDQ HQDPLQGLNDWRUNULWHULDVRVLDO7DEHO
7DEHO.ULWHULDGDQLQGLNDWRUNHEHUODQMXWDQSHQJHORODDQKXWDQOLQGXQJPDQJURYHGL%DWX$PSDU
7DEOH&ULWHULDDQGLQGLFDWRURI WKHVXVWDLQDELOLW\RI PDQJURYHIRUHVWPDQDJHPHQWLQ%DWX$PSDU
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
+DVLO DQDOLVLV 0'6 GHQJDQ PHQJJXQDNDQ 5DS03IRUHVW PHQXQMXNDQ QLODL LQGHNV NHEHU ODQMXWDQ NULWHULD HNRORJL VHEHVDU FXNXS EHUNHODQMXWDQ*DPEDU,QGLNDWRUNXQFL\DQJ GLSHUNLUDNDQSDOLQJEHUSHQJDUXKWHUKDGDSNHEHU
ODQMXWDQ NULWHULD HNRORJL VHEDQ\DN LQGLNDWRU \DLWX SHQDWDDQ EDWDV NDZDVDQ NHVHVXDLDQ SHUXQWXNDQ NDZDVDQ NHWHUVHGLDDQ ELELW WDQDPDQ PDQJURYH GDQ SHUOLQGXQJDQ WHUKDGDS IORUD GDQ IDXQD *DPEDU
3RVLVLVWDWXVNHEHUODQMXWDQ 7LWLNUHIHUHQVLXWDPD 7LWLNUHIHUHQVLWDPEDKDQ
6XPEHU6RXUFH'DWD3ULPHUGLRODK3ULPDU\GDWDSURFHVVHG
*DPEDU6WDWXVNHEHUODQMXWDQSDGDNULWHULDHNRORJL
)LJXUH7KHVWDWXVRIVXVWDLQDELOLW\RQWKHHFRORJLFDOFULWHULD
6XPEHU6RXUFH'DWD3ULPHUGLRODK3ULPDU\GDWDSURFHVVHG
*DPEDU)DNWRUIDNWRU\DQJEHUSHQJDUXKSDGDNULWHULDHNRORJL )LJXUH7KHIDFWRUVWKDWDIIHFWHGRQWKHHFRORJLFDOFULWHULD 5RRW0HDQ6TXDUH ,QGLNDWRU 3HUOLQGXQJDQWKGIORUDIDXQD .HWHUVHGLDDQELELW $NWLYLWDVSHQDQDPDQSHPHOLKDUDDQSHUOLQG 3HQJHORODDQNHDQHNDUDJDPDQKD\DWL .HDQHNDUDJDPDQMHQLVSRKRQ 3HQXWXSDQYHJHWDVLSDGDNDZDVDQOLQGXQJ .HVHVXDLDQSHUXQWXNDQNDZDVDQOLQGXQJ 3HQDWDDQEDWDVNDZDVDQKXWDQOLQGXQJPDQJURYH ,QGHNV.HEHUODQMXWDQ
%HUGDVDUNDQ KDVLO DQDOLVLV 0'6 PHQJJXQD
NDQ5DS03IRUHVWQLODLLQGHNVNHEHUODQMXWDQSDGD NULWHULD HNRQRPL DGDODK NXUDQJ EHU NHODQMXWDQ*DPEDU6WDWXVNHEHUODQMXWDQLQL GLWHQWXNDQROHKGXDLQGLNDWRUNXQFL\DQJSDOLQJ EHUSHQJDUXK \DLWX SHQGDSDWDQ SHPHULQWDK GDULSHQJHORODDQGDQ3HPDQIDDWDQKXWDQOLQGXQJ PDQJURYH WLQJNDW SHQGDSDWDQ PDV\DUDNDWVHNLWDUKXWDQ*DPEDU
6XPEHU6RXUFH'DWD3ULPHUGLRODK3ULPDU\GDWDSURFHVVHG
*DPEDU6WDWXVNHEHUODQMXWDQSDGDNULWHULDHNRQRPL
)LJXUH7KHVWDWXVRIVXVWDLQDELOLW\RQWKHHFRQRPLFFULWHULD
6XPEHU6RXUFH'DWD3ULPHUGLRODK3ULPDU\GDWDSURFHVVHG
*DPEDU)DNWRUIDNWRUEHUSHQJDUXKSDGDNULWHULDHNRQRPL )LJXUH7KHIDFWRUVWKDWDIIHFWHGRQWKHHFRQRPLFFULWHULD 3RVLVLVWDWXVNHEHUODQMXWDQ 7LWLNUHIHUHQVLXWDPD 7LWLNUHIHUHQVLWDPEDKDQ ,QGHNV.HEHUODQMXWDQ 5RRW0HDQ6TXDUH ,QGLNDWRU 7LQJNDWSHQGDSDWDQPDV\DUDNDWVHNLWDUKXWDQ -XPODKSURGXNVLMHQLVMHQLV\JGLEXGLGD\DNDQ 7HUXNXUQ\DQLODLPDQIDDWNDZDVDQOLQGXQJ 3DVDUSURGXN 7HUXNXUVHFDUDHNRQRPLQLODLNDZDVDQOLQGXQJ 3HOXDQJNHUMDGDQSHOXDQJXVDKD 3HQGDSDWDQ3HPHULQWDKGDUL3HQJHO 3HPDQI+/PDQJURYH
+DVLO DQDOLVLV 0'6 PHQJJXQDNDQ 5DS 03IRUHVW PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD QLODL LQGHNV NHEHUODQMXWDQSDGDNULWHULDVRVLDONXUDQJ EHUNHODQMXWDQ*DPEDU,QGLNDWRUNXQFLSDGD NULWHULD LQL VHEDQ\DN HPSDW LQGLNDWRU \DLWX PHNDQLVPH UHVROXVL NRQIOLN ODKDQ \DQJ HIHNWLI
VHEHVDUSUDNWHNEXGD\DORNDOGDODP SHOHVWDULDQKXWDQOLQGXQJPDQJURYH NHWHUVHGLDDQ RUJDQLVDVL PDV\DUDNDW GDODP SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH GDQ NHWHUOLEDWDQ PDV\DUDNDW GDODP SHQJH ORODDQNDZDVDQKXWDQOLQGXQJPDQJURYH *DPEDU
6XPEHU6RXUFH'DWD3ULPHUGLRODK3ULPDU\GDWDSURFHVVHG
*DPEDU6WDWXVNHEHUODQMXWDQNULWHULDVRVLDO
)LJXUH7KHVWDWXVRIVXVWDLQDELOLW\RQWKHVRFLDOFULWHULD
6XPEHU6RXUFH'DWD3ULPHUGLRODK3ULPDU\GDWDSURFHVVHG
*DPEDU)DNWRUIDNWRUEHUSHQJDUXKSDGDNULWHULDVRVLDO )LJXUH7KHIDFWRUVWKDWDIIHFWHGRQWKHVRFLDOFULWHULD 3RVLVLVWDWXVNHEHUODQMXWDQ 7LWLNUHIHUHQVLXWDPD 7LWLNUHIHUHQVLWDPEDKDQ ,QGHNV.HEHUODQMXWDQ 5RRW0HDQ6TXDUH ,QGLNDWRU 3UDNWHNEXGD\DORNDOGOPSHOHVWDULDQNDZ/LQGXQJ .HWHUOLEDWDQPDV\GOPSHQJHONDZ/LQGXQJ .HWHUVHGLDDQWDWDFDUDSHPDQIDDWDQNDZ/LQGXQJ .HVHLPEDQJDQKDN NHZDMLEDQVWDNHKROGHUV .HWHUVHGLDDQRUJDQLVDVLPDV\GOPSHQJHONDZ/LQGXQJ 0HNDQLVPHUHVROXVLNRQIOLNODKDQ\JHIHNWLI
+DVLO DQDOLVLV NHEHUODQMXWDQ SHQJHORODDQ
KXWDQOLQGXQJPDQJURYHEHUGDVDUNDQQLODLLQGHNV NHEHUODQMXWDQ SDGD NHWLJD NULWHULD NHEHUODQMXWDQ PHQXQMXNNDQ EDKZD QLODL LQGHNV NHEHUODQMXWDQ SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH GL .HFDPDWDQ %DWX $PSDU DGDODK DWDX NXUDQJEHUNHODQMXWDQ7DEHO
%3HPEDKDVDQ
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
7DEHO1LODLVWDWXVNHEHUODQMXWDQSHQJHORODDQKXWDQOLQGXQJPDQJURYHGL.HFDPDWDQ%DWX$PSDU
7DEOH7KHYDOXHRI VXVWDLQDELOLW\VWDWXVRQPDQJURYHSURWHFWLRQIRUHVWPDQDJHPHQWLQ%DWX$PSDU6XE'LVWULFW
.ULWHULD ,QGHNV %RERW -XPODK
(NRORJL
(NRQRPL
6RVLDO
-XPODK
NDZDVDQKXWDQOLQGXQJVDDWLQL,QGLNDWRULQLSHUOX GLSHUKDWLNDQ NDUHQD NHEHUDGDDQ IORUD GDQ IDXQD PHQMDGL EDJLDQ SHQWLQJ GDUL NHVHLPEDQJDQ HNRVLVWHP PDQJURYH GL NDZDVDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ OLKDW/DPSLUDQ
6WDWXV NHEHUODQMXWDQ SDGD NULWHULD HNRQRPL DGDODKNXUDQJEHUNHODQMXWDQ,QGLNDWRU EHUSHQJDUXK SDGD NULWHULD HNRQRPL \DLWX SHQGDSDWDQ SHPHULQWDK GDUL SHQJHORODDQ GDQ SHPDQIDDWDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH GDQ WLQJNDW SHQGDSDWDQ PDV\DUDNDW VHNLWDU KXWDQ 3HQGDSDWDQ SHPHULQWDK GDUL SHQJHORODDQ GDQ SHPDQIDDWDQKXWDQOLQGXQJPDQJURYHVHMDXKLQL GLQLODL EHOXP DGD OLKDW /DPSLUDQ 6HPHQWDUD KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH PHPSXQ\DL QLODL PDQIDDW HNRQRPL \DQJ EHVDU EDJL PDV\DUDNDW 8QWXN PHQGXNXQJ NHEHUODQMXWDQ SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH GL .HFDPDWDQ %DWX $PSDU SHPHULQWDK GDHUDK SHUOX PHQHUDSNDQ UHJXODVL WHUNDLW LQGLNDWRU LQL WHUXWDPD XQWXN PHQGXNXQJ NLQHUMD SHODNVDQD NHELMDNDQ SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH VHFDUD EHUNHODQMXWDQ 3RWHQVL KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH GDSDWPHQMDGLVXPEHUSHQGDSDWDQGDHUDKPHODOXL DNWLYLWDV ZLVDWD MDVD NDUERQ GDQ EHUEDJDL MDVD OLQJNXQJDQ ODLQQ\D ,QGLNDWRU EHUXSD WLQJNDW SHQGDSDWDQPDV\DUDNDWGLVHNLWDUNDZDVDQKXWDQ OLQGXQJPDQJURYHVDDWLQLGLQLODLEHOXPRSWLPDO 3HQJDWXUDQ WHQWDQJ NDZDVDQ \DQJ EROHK GLPDQIDDWNDQ SHUOX PHQGDSDW SHUKDWLDQ XQWXN PHQJRSWLPDONDQ QLODL PDQIDDW KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH EDJL SHQLQJNDWDQ SHQGDSDWDQ PDV\D UDNDW 0DV\DUDNDW %DWX $PSDU VHEDJLDQ EHVDU EHUSURIHVL VHEDJDL QHOD\DQ SHWDQL SHQJUDMLQ DUDQJGDQSHGDJDQJ$NWLYLWDVQHOD\DQGDQSHWDQL WHUPDVXN SHQJUDMLQ DUDQJ PHPLOLNL KXEXQJDQ ODQJVXQJGHQJDQSRWHQVLHNRVLVWHPPDQJURYHGL NDZDVDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ 'LQDV 3HUHNHEXQDQ .HKXWDQDQGDQ3HUWDPEDQJDQ.DEXSDWHQ.XEX 5D\D PHQJHPXNDNDQ EDKZD VHEDJLDQ EHVDU HNRVLVWHP PDQJURYH WHUXWDPD GL NDZDVDQ KXWDQOLQGXQJGLZLOD\DK.HFDPDWDQ%DWX$PSDU EHUDGD GDODP NRQGLVL UXVDN EHUDW DNLEDW SHQH EDQJDQROHKRNQXPPDV\DUDNDWXQWXNPHPHQXKL NHEXWXKDQEDKDQEDNXDUDQJ+DOLQLEHUGDPSDN SDGD SHQXUXQDQ SHQGDSDWDQ QHOD\DQ 0HQXUXW SDUDQHOD\DQVDDWLQLSHQGDSDWDQQHOD\DQEHUNLVDU KDQ\D²GDULSHQGDSDWDQPHUHNDVHEHOXP PDQJURYHGLWHEDQJ
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
OLQGXQJPDQJURYHPHQJLQJDWSHUDQRUJDQLVDVLLQL
XPXPQ\DGHNDWGHQJDQSURJUDPSURJUDPSHP EHUGD\DDQ PDV\DUDNDW VHODPD LQL GL .HFDPDWDQ %DWX $PSDU 3DGD VLVL PDV\DUDNDW LQGLNDWRU NHWHUOLEDWDQ PDV\DUDNDW GL VHNLWDU KXWDQ GDODP SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH GLQLODL PDVLK NXUDQJ 3DGD UHQFDQD DNVL SURYLQVL SURJUDP5HGXFLQJ (PLVVLRQV IURP 'HIRUHVWDULRQ DQG
)RU HVW 'HJUDGDWLRQ 5('' PHOLEDWNDQ
PDV\DUDNDW GDODP SHQLQJNDWDQ NHVHMDKWHUDDQ PHODOXL SURJUDP 5('' .DOLPDQWDQ %DUDW +DUGLDQV\DK HW DO .HWHUOLEDWDQ PDV\DUDNDWPHODOXLEHUEDJDLSURJUDPVHSHUWLLQL UHOHYDQGHQJDQWXMXDQSHQJHORODDQKXWDQOLQGXQJ PDQJURYH EHUNHODQMXWDQ SHUOX GLWLQJNDWNDQ WHUXWDPDGDODPKDOSHUHQFDQDDQGDQSDGDVHWLDS WDKDSSHQJDPELODQNHSXWXVDQDJDUEHQDUEHQDU GDSDW PHPEHUL NRQWULEXVL GDODP PHQGXNXQJ NHEHUODQMXWDQ SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJ URYHGL.HFDPDWDQ%DWX$PSDU
6WDWXV NHEHUODQMXWDQ SDGD PDVLQJPDVLQJ NULWHULD\DLWXFXNXSEHUNHODQMXWDQSDGD NULWHULD HNRORJL GDQ NXUDQJ EHUNHODQMXWDQ SDGD NULWHULD HNRQRPL GDQ NULWHULD VRVLDO *DPEDU
6XPEHU6RXUFH'DWD3ULPHUGLRODK3ULPDU\GDWDSURFHVVHG
*DPEDU 6WDWXV NHEHUODQMXWDQ SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH GL %DWX $PSDU
)LJXUH 7KH VXVWDLQDELOLW\ VWDWXV RI PDQJURYH SURWHFWLRQ IRUHVW PDQDJHPHQW DW %DWX $PSDU
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
,QGLNDWRU\DQJEHUSHQJDUXKWHUKDGDSVWDWXV NHEHUODQMXWDQ SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH SDGD NULWHULD HNRORJL \DLWX SHQDWDDQ EDWDV NDZDVDQ NHVHVXDLDQ SHUXQWXNDQ NDZDVDQ VHEHVDU NHWHUVHGLDDQ ELELW WDQDPDQ PDQJURYH GDQ SHUOLQGXQJDQ WHUKDGDS IORUD GDQ IDXQD ,QGLNDWRU EHUSHQJDUXK SDGD NULWHULD HNRQRPL \DLWX SHQGDSDWDQ SHPHULQWDK GDUL SHQJHORODDQ GDQ SHPDQIDDWDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH GDQ WLQJNDW SHQGDSDWDQ PDV\DUDNDW VHNLWDU KXWDQ ,QGLNDWRUEHUSHQJDUXKSDGDNULWHULDVRVLDO\DLWX PHNDQLVPH UHVROXVL NRQIOLN ODKDQ \DQJ HIHNWLI SUDNWHN EXGD\D ORNDO GDODP SHOHVWDULDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH NHWHUVHGLDDQ RUJDQLVDVL PDV\DUDNDW GDODP SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH GDQ NHWHUOLEDWDQ PDV\DUDNDW GDODP SHQJHORODDQNDZDVDQKXWDQOLQGXQJPDQJURYH
3HUHQFDQDDQ SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH SHUOX PHPSHUWLPEDQJNDQ NHVHSXOXK LQGLNDWRU EHUSHQJDUXK WHUVHEXW 3HUHQFDQDDQ \DQJ WLGDN PHPSHUWLPEDQJNDQ IDNWRUIDNWRU WHUVHEXW VHFDUD VHLPEDQJ WLGDN DNDQ PHQMDPLQ NHEHUODQMXWDQ SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYHGL%DWX$PSDU (NRORJL (NRQRPL 6RVLDO 6WDWXV.HEHUODQMXWDQ
%6DUDQ
3HUHQFDQDDQ SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH EHUNHODQMXWDQ SHUOX PHODNXNDQ SHQJHPEDQJDQ GDQ SHUEDLNDQ NLQHUMD SDGD LQGLNDWRUNXQFLXQWXNPHQLQJNDWNDQVWDWXVNHEHU ODQMXWDQSHQJHORODDQKXWDQOLQGXQJPDQJURYHGL .HFDPDWDQ %DWX $PSDU 3HUEDLNDQ NLQHUMD WHU VHEXW GLDQWDUDQ\D PHODNXNDQ SHQDWDDQ EDWDV NDZDVDQKXWDQOLQGXQJPDQJURYHDGDQ\DXSD\D SHUOLQGXQJDQIORUDGDQIDXQDSHPDQIDDWDQKXWDQ OLQGXQJ PDQJURYH \DQJ EHUNRQWULEXVL EDJL SHQLQJNDWDQSHQGDSDWDQSHPHULQWDKGDQPDV\D UDNDW SHQLQJNDWDQ SHQHUDSDQ SUDNWHN EXGD\D ORNDOSHQJDGDDQNHUMDVDPDSHPHULQWDKGHQJDQ RUJDQLVDVLPDV\DUDNDWVHUWDSHQLQJNDWDQSDUWLVL SDVLPDV\DUDNDWGDODPSHUHQFDQDDQSHQJHORODDQ KXWDQOLQGXQJPDQJURYH 8&$3$17(5,0$.$6,+ "$,/08-&%(&.&/5 3HQXOLV PHQJXFDSNDQ WHULPD NDVLK NHSDGD 3HPHULQWDK.DEXSDWHQ.XEX5D\D.DOLPDQWDQ %DUDW DWDV IDVLOLWDVL VHODPD SHQHOLWLDQ GDQ SHQXOLVDQDUWLNHOLQL
'$)7$53867$.$
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
0DQDJHPHQW
+DUGLDQV\DK*<DQL$)DKUL]DO(ULDQWR« ,UYDQWR$)6WUDWHJLGDQUHQFDQDDNVL SURYLQVL 65$3 5('' .DOLPDQWDQ %DUDW 3RQWLDQDN3HPHULQWDK3URYLQVL.DOLPDQWDQ %DUDW +DVDQ 0 6DSHL $ 3XUZDQWR - 6XNDUGL .DMLDQNHELMDNDQSHQJHORODDQVXPEHU GD\DDLUSDGD'DHUDK$OLUDQ6XQJDL&LWDUXP -XUQDO6XPEHU'D\D$LU +DVUDW $6 6WDWXV NHEHUODQMXWDQ SHQJHORODDQ SHULNDQDQ EXGL GD\D GL SXODX SXODX NHFLO 0DNDVVDU -XUQDO 0DQDMHPHQ 3HULNDQDQGDQ.HODXWDQ
.DYDQDJK35$3),6+VRIZDUHGHVFULSWLRQ IRU0LFURVRIW([FHO5DSLGDSSUDLVDORI ILVKHULHV 5$3),6+ SURMHFW 9DQFRXYHU )LVKHULHV &HQWUH8QLYHUVLW\RI %ULWLVK&ROXPELD .XHQ]HU & %OXHPHO $ *HEKDUGW 6 4XRF
79 'HFK65HPRWHVHQVLQJRI PDQJURYH HFRV\VWHPV $ UHYLHZ 5HPRWH
6HQVLQJ
0DFLQWRVK'- $VKWRQ(&'UDIWFRGH RI FRQGXFW IRU WKH VXVWDLQDEOH PDQDJHPHQW RI PDQJURYH HFRV\VWHPV 'HQPDUN &HQ7(5 $DUKXV
0DULPLQ7HNQLN GDQ DSOLNDVL 3HQJDPELODQ NHSXWXVDQNULWHULDPDMHPXN-DNDUWD*UDVLQGR 0DVRRG+$IVDU6=DPLU8%LQ .D]PL
-+ $SSOLFDWLRQ RI FRPSDUDWLYH UHPRWH VHQVLQJ WHFKQLTXHV IRU PRQLWRULQJ PDQJURYHV LQ ,QGXV 'HOWD 6LQGK 3DNLVWDQ
%LRORJLFDO)RUXP$Q,QWHUQDWLRQDO-RXUQDO
3DWDQJ$QDOLVLVVWUDWHJLSHQJHORODDQKXWDQ PDQJURYH .DVXV GL 'HVD 7RQJNH7RQJNH .DEXSDWHQ 6LQMD\ -XUQDO $JULVLVWHP
3DWWLPDKX'9.HELMDNDQSHQJHORODDQKXWDQ PDQJURYH EHUNHODQMXWDQ GL .DEXSDWHQ 6HUDP %DJLDQ %DUDW 0DOXNX 'LVHUWDVL %RJRU 6HNRODK 3DVFDVDUMDQD ,QVWLWXW 3HUWDQLDQ %RJRU
3LWFKHU7- 3UHLNVKRW'5$3),6+$ UDSLG DSSUDLVDO WHFKQLTXH WR HYDOXDWH WKH VXVWDLQDELOLW\ VWDWXV RI ILVKHULHV )LVKHULHV
5HVHDUFK
3UDPXGML+XWDQPDQJURYHGL,QGRQHVLD 3HUDQDQ SHUPDVDODKDQ GDQ SHQJHORODDQQ\D
-XUQDO2VHDQD
6DVLGKDU . 7LUXSDWKL &+ .ULVKQD 5+ 9LVKQXYDUGKDQ=6ZDP\ %UDKPDMLUDR3 6DOLQLW\VWXGLHVRI %D\RI %HQJDODQG LGHQWLILFDWLRQRI YDULRXVVDOWWROHUDQWVSHFLHV RI PDQJURYHV-,QWHUQDWLRQDORI (QJLQHHULQJ
6FLHQFH5HVHDUFK 6FKDGXZ-1.HEHUODQMXWDQSHQJHORODDQ HNRVLVWHP PDQJURYH 3XODX 0DQWHKDJH .HFDPDWDQ :RUL .DEXSDWHQ 0LQDKDVD 8WDUD3URYLQVL6XODZHVL8WDUD-XUQDO/330 %LGDQJ6DLQVGDQ7HNQRORJL
6XZDUQR - .DUWRGLKDUGMR + 3UDPXG\D % 3HQJHPEDQJDQ NHELMDNDQ SHQJH ORODDQ EHUNHODQMXWDQ '$6 &LOLZXQJ +XOX .DEXSDWHQ %RJRU-XUQDO $QDOLVLV .HELMDNDQ
.HKXWDQDQ
7KHUHVLD %RHU 0 3UDWLZL 170 6WDWXV NHEHUODQMXWDQ SHQJHORODDQ HNRVLVWHP PDQJURYH GL 7DPDQ 1DVLRQDO 6HPELODQJ .DEXSDWHQ %DQ\XDVLQ 3URYLQVL 6XPDWHUD 6HODWDQ -XUQDO ,OPX GDQ 7HNQRORJL .HODXWDQ
7URSLV :LKDU\DQWR ' /DJD $ .DMLDQ SHQJHORODDQ KXWDQ PDQJURYH GL NDZDVDQ NRQVHUYDVL 'HVD 0DPEXUXQJDQ .RWD 7DUDNDQ.DOLPDQWDQ7LPXU0HGLD6DLQV
/DPSLUDQ ,QGLNDWRUGDQ6NRU.HEHUODQMXWDQ3HUHQFDQDDQ3HQJHORODDQ.DZDVDQ+XWDQ/LQGXQJ 0DQJURYH.HFDPDWDQ%DWX$PSDU.DEXSDWHQ.XEX5D\D.DOLPDWDQ%DUDW
$SSHQGL[
'LPHQVLGDQ,QGLNDWRU 6NRU %DLN %XUXN .HWHUDQJDQ
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
/DPSLUDQ/DQMXWDQ
$SSHQGL[&RQWLQXHG
'LPHQVLGDQ,QGLNDWRU 6NRU %DLN %XUXN .HWHUDQJDQ
%XUXN 7HUGDSDWSHUHQFDQDDQSHQJHORODDQNHDQHNDUDJDPDQ KD\DWLWHWDSLWLGDNGLLPSOHPHQWDVLNDQGLODSDQJDQ $NWLILWDVSHQDQDPDQ SHPHOLKDUDDQSHUOLQGXQJDQ GDQSHQJDPDQDQSDGD NDZDVDQOLQGXQJ %DLN 0HPLOLNLSHUHQFDQDDQGDQWHUGDSDWLPSOHPHQWDVL SHQDQDPDQSHPHOLKDUDDQSHUOLQGXQJDQSHQJDPDQDQ VHVXDLWDUJHW 6HGDQJ 0HPLOLNLSHUHQFDQDDQGDQLPSOHPHQWDVLSHQDQDPDQ SHPHOLKDUDDQSHUOLQGXQJDQSHQJDPDQDQWLGDNVHVXDL WDUJHW %XUXN 7LGDNPHPLOLNLSHUHQFDQDDQGDQWLGDNDGDLPSOHPHQWDVL SHQDQDPDQSHPHOLKDUDDQSHUOLQGXQJDQSHQJDPDQDQ .HWHUVHGLDDQELELWXQWXN PHQGXNXQJXSD\D SHQDQDPDQGLNDZDVDQ OLQGXQJ %DLN .HEXWXKDQELELWGDSDWGLSHQXKLGDULSHUVHPDLDQ SHUPDQHQDWDXQRQSHUPDQHQ\DQJEHUDGDGLZLOD\DKQ\D VHQGLULGHQJDQMXPODKPHQFXNXSLGDQNXDOLWDV\DQJ EDLN 6HGDQJ .HEXWXKDQELELWGDSDWGLSHQXKLVHEDJLDQGDUL SHUVHPDLDQSHUPDQHQDWDXQRQSHUPDQHQ\DQJEHUDGD GLZLOD\DKQ\DVHQGLULGHQJDQMXPODKPHQFXNXSL NHEXWXKDQGHQJDQNXDOLWDVVHGDQJ %XUXN .HEXWXKDQELELWVHEDJLDQEHVDUGLSHQXKLGDUL SHUVHPDLDQSHUPDQHQDWDXQRQSHUPDQHQGLOXDU ZLOD\DKQ\DGDQDWDXMXPODKELELWWLGDNPHPHQXKLVHUWD NXDOLWDVQ\DMHOHN 3HUOLQGXQJDQWHUKDGDS VSHVLHVIORUDGDQIDXQDMDUDQJ ODQJNDGDQWHUDQFDPSXQDK VHUWDIORUDGDQDWDXIDXQD \DQJPHUXSDNDQNHNKDVDQ ZLOD\DKVHWHPSDWGLNDZDVDQ OLQGXQJ %DLN ,QYHQWDULVDVLGDQPRQLWRULQJGLODNXNDQVHFDUDNRQWLQ\X GDQWHUGDWDVHUWDXQWXNIORUDGDQIDXQDMDUDQJODQJND GDQWHUDQFDPSXQDKVHUWDIORUDGDQDWDXIDXQD\DQJ PHUXSDNDQNHNKDVDQZLOD\DKVHWHPSDWGLNDZDVDQ OLQGXQJ 6HGDQJ ,QYHQWDULVDVLGDQPRQLWRULQJGLODNXNDQVHFDUDNRQWLQ\X GDQWHUGDWDWHWDSLXQWXNIORUDGDQIDXQDMDUDQJODQJND GDQWHUDQFDPSXQDKVHUWDIORUDGDQDWDXIDXQD\DQJ PHUXSDNDQNHNKDVDQZLOD\DKVHWHPSDWGLNDZDVDQ OLQGXQJ %XUXN ,QYHQWDULVDVLGDQPRQLWRULQJGLODNXNDQVHFDUDLQVLGHQWDO ',0(16,(.2120, 3HQGDSDWDQ\DQJGLSHUROHK SHPHULQWDKGDULSHQJHORODDQ GDQSHPDQIDDWDQKXWDQ OLQGXQJPDQJURYH %DLN 3URSRUVLDQWDUDSHQGDSDWDQGDQELD\DSHPHOLKDUDDQ PHQJJDPEDUNDQGLSHUROHKQ\DNHXQWXQJDQMXJDGDSDW WHUSHQXKLQ\DVHPXDNHEXWXKDQELD\DXQWXNPHQMDJD NHOHVWDULDQQ\D
/DPSLUDQ/DQMXWDQ
$SSHQGL[&RQWLQXHG
'LPHQVLGDQ,QGLNDWRU 6NRU %DLN %XUXN .HWHUDQJDQ
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
/DPSLUDQ/DQMXWDQ
$SSHQGL[&RQWLQXHG
'LPHQVLGDQ,QGLNDWRU 6NRU %DLN %XUXN .HWHUDQJDQ
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
/DPSLUDQ/DQMXWDQ
$SSHQGL[&RQWLQXHG
'LPHQVLGDQ,QGLNDWRU 6NRU %DLN %XUXN .HWHUDQJDQ
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
%DLN
7HUGDSDWXUDLDQNHVHSDNDWDQWHQWDQJKDNGDQNHZDMLEDQ DWXUDQPHNDQLVPHLQVHQWLI GDQGLVLQVHQWLI SHQJHORODDQ NDZDVDQOLQGXQJGLGDODPNDZDVDQKXWDQGDQGLOXDU NDZDVDQKXWDQGDQGLLPSOHPHQWDVLNDQGHQJDQEDLNROHK SDUDSLKDNGDODPSHPDQIDDWDQNDZDVDQOLQGXQJ 6HGDQJ
7HUGDSDWXUDLDQNHVHSDNDWDQWHQWDQJKDNGDQNHZDMLEDQ DWXUDQPHNDQLVPHLQVHQWLI GDQGLVLQVHQWLI SHQJHORODDQ NDZDVDQOLQGXQJGLGDODPNDZDVDQKXWDQDWDXGLOXDU NDZDVQKXWDQQDPXQEHOXPGLLPSOHPHQWDVLNDQGHQJDQ EDLNROHKSDUDSLKDNGDODPSHPDQIDDWDQNDZDVDQ OLQGXQJ %XUXN 7LGDNWHUGDSDWXUDLDQNHVHSDNDWDQWHQWDQJKDNGDQ NHZDMLEDQDWXUDQPHNDQLVPHLQVHQWLI GDQGLVLQVHQWLI SHQJHORODDQNDZDVDQOLQGXQJGLGDODPNDZDVDQKXWDQ PDXSXQGLOXDUNDZDVDQKXWDQ .HWHUVHGLDDQWDWDFDUD SHPDQIDDWDQNDZDVDQOLQGXQJ %DLN 7HUGDSDWNHMHODVDQDNVHVGDQGLVWULEXVLGDODP SHPDQIDDWDQROHKVWDNHKROGHUEDLNNDZDVDQOLQGXQJGL GDODPNDZDVDQKXWDQGDQGLOXDUNDZDVDQKXWDQ GLSDKDPLGHQJDQEDLNROHKVWDNHKROGHUSDGDWLQJNDWORNDO VHUWDWHUGDSDWNRPSHQVDVLDWDVKLODQJQJQ\DSHOXDQJ NHVHPSDWDQPDV\DUDNDWGDODPSHPDQIDDWDQNDZDVDQ OLQGXQJ
/DPSLUDQ/DQMXWDQ
$SSHQGL[&RQWLQXHG
'LPHQVLGDQ,QGLNDWRU 6NRU %DLN %XUXN .HWHUDQJDQ
6HGDQJ
7HUGDSDWNHMHODVDQDNVHVGDODPSHPDQIDDWDQNDZDVDQ OLQGXQJGLGDODPNDZDVDQKXWDQDWDXGLOXDUNDZDVDQ KXWDQGDQNXUDQJGLSDKDPLQDPXQGLVWULEXVLQ\DEHOXP DGLOGLUDVDNDQROHKVWDNHKROGHUSDGDWLQJNDWORNDO %XUXN
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x ,../ ,QGHNV.HVHVXDLDQ.DZDVDQ/LQGXQJ x ,63$ ,QIHNVL6DOXUDQ3HUQDIDVDQ$NXW x '%' 'HPDP%HUGDUDK'HQJXH x 333 3XUFKDVLQJ3RZHU3DULW\3DULWDV'D\D%HOL
6XPEHU6RXUFH'DWD3ULPHUGLRODK3ULPDU\GDWDSURFHVVHG
