Pengaruh Jarak Katup Limbah dengan Katup Penghantar terhadap Efisiensi Hidram

"$'& 23' 3 2 ' : ;? / - @7, - , )3( 92$ @ = 7

+ !" ! !" 4 ! . , , 4! , *!"!. @ ! 5!*! ! ! #!"# ,

"$" &' 23' 3 2 ', *&3" (& 23' 3, ' >2$ (& &'6& & +& ? 5 9$&'$+ 7C5+& -6 +

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

%%'%' (+ ( . !- +! %"% !# % %#,& +! +) , !-% . !%# % %#,& ) !-% -&'# +" (+ ( # ; &'# <1

- ) #%)% # - . ) '+ !%' ! / . !-% %** % & * -&'# +" (+ ( # (%#* # % . !- $ # !

* ' )! % %!.%% !-% $ "$% * !-% . )!% . !- !-% '+ ! $% $ "$% ' !-% #%)% # - %!- ' !-#

+,-'%) , * -&'# (+ ( . !- )%#$ ! * !-% *"+% % * !-% $ "$% ' )! % * !-% . )!% . !- !-%

'%" $%#& $ "$% ;573 8 5 2 ' 5@3 <1 -% #%)+"!) )- .%' !- ! !-% - ,-%)! %** % & * -&'#

(+ () . ) 51FF9 #' , ! V + + )) %** % & ' 71739 #' , ! / % %** % & ! !-% ' )! % * !-% %**"+% ! $ "$% . !- !-% '%" $%#& $ "$% ! ' )! % * 5@3 1 ! # -% ' )! % %!.%% !-% %**"+% ! $ "$% ' !-% '%" $%#& $ "$% **% !) !-% ' ) - #,% * (+ ( ,8 ' ) - #,%8 ' -&'# (+ ( %** % &1 &'# (+ (8 "%! ( (%8 %:- +)! $ "$%8 ' %** % & $%

$ +2$"#&3&' "+92$ 32! "#&' 9&5 2( &# +&3! "3- !" " '%& & &+ !& ' & & &! +&'" & , +&'& & $ ' &'5&( 9"("!3&' 9& 3 #2$3 (&&' +&"#"' #2 2 &&'- & %&$&3&( %&'5 92 "+ (2$4&'53&" ($ 3 &3&' 32 " (&' & &+ +2+#2$ 2! & $ 92$ ! &' !&$" +2'2+#"! #2$4& &'&' %&'5 4&"! - "+92$ & $ ' 9 & 92$& & #& & &2$&! &(&$&' ( '55 +&"#"' $2' &! , 4 3& #2+"3 +&' #2' " "3 92$& & 9&<&! "+92$ & $ (2'("'%& 9"3&' +& & &!- &5& +&'& 4 3&, "+92$ & $ (2$ 29"( 92$& & 4&"! 9&<&! #2$+"3&&' #2' " "3 !& ' +2+2$ "3&' & &( %&'5 92$5"'& "'("3 +2'%& "$3&' & $ &5&$ 9 &

&#&(3&' 2'5&' +" &! 2! #2' " "3 - ) 2! 3&$2'& (" +&3& 9"("!3&' &! 29"&! # +#& & $ , '&+"' 3&$2'& "# & ($ 3 %&'5 92 "+ (2'(" (2$ 2 & +&3& 9"("!3&' &! # +#& (&'#& 2'2$5

($ 3 +2 & '3&' +2'55"'&3&' 2'2$5 & $ (2$ 29"( %& (" # +#& ! $&" 3 $&+ : $&+; L

M-+&'& # +#& ! $&+ & & &! & &! &(" & &( %&'5 5"'&3&' "'("3 +2'5&'53&( & $ &$ "&(" (2+#&( %&'5 29 ! $2' &! 32 (2+#&( %&'5 29 ! ( '55 2'5&' +2+&' &&(3&' 2'2$5% # (2' & "+92$ & $ %&'5 &3&' & $3&'- +#& ! $&+ +2'5& $3&' & $ 26&$& 3 '( '%" 2'5&' +2'55"'&3&' 2'2$5 # (2' & "+92$ & $ %&'5 &3&' & $3&' 29&5& &%& #2'552$&3 (&'#& +2'55"'&3&' "+92$ 2'2$5 "&$ L

M-292$&#& #2'2 ( &' %&'5 &3"3&' (2$!& &# ! $&+ 5"'& +2'2+"3&' 2 2' (2$92 &$ %& (" X &'6&'5 &'5"' &' 4 3 #2$ +2'(&

2'5&$"! /&$ & &'4&'5 # $% (% &'

&+2(2$ # - %# (2$!& &# 2' +#&

$&+a , X &'6&'5 &'5"' +#& $&+ &' 2'5"4 &' 2'5&$"! /&$ & '55 &9"'5 &$& &' &'4&'5 #& 2+& "3&' 2$!& &# '4"3

2$4& +#& $&+a, X 2'5&$"! /&$ & &'4&'5 #& & "3 : # $% (%; &' 29&' &("# "&'5

: )!% "$%; 2$!& &# 2' +#&

$&+a, X 2'5&$"! &+2(2$ &9"'5 &$& &' &$&3 "9&'5 #& 23&' 2'5&' &("# 2'5&'(&$ 2$!& &# 2' +#& $&+a &' X 2'5&$"! &+2(2$ 2+9$&' & & +#& $&+ 2$!& &# 23&'&' 0&'5 2$4& & & #& "&'5 2' >6 X +&'& +& ! 9&'%&3 9&5 &' &$ # +#& ! $&+ %&'5 #2$ " (2 ( 5"'& +2' &#&(3&' !& (2$9& 3- ) 2! 3&$2'& (", #2'" +2 &3"3&' #2'2 ( &' (2'(&'5 X 2'5&$"! &$&3 &("# +9&! 2'5&' &("# 2'5!&'(&$

2$!& &# 2' $&+a- & &+ #$ 2

+2'5&'& 2 2' &$ # +#& ! $&+ +&3& 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! &' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ %&'5 &3&' (2 ( +2+ 3 4&$&3 ++, .@ ++,

&'

++-&#"' ("4"&' &$ #2'2 ( &' ' & & &! "'("3 +2'52(&!" 2'5&$"! &$&3 &("# +9&! 2'5&' &("# 2'5!&'(&$ 2$!& &# 2'

$&+-&%

&%$ " , 0! * ! 4 !*

$ ' # 32$4& # +#& ! $&" 3 $&+ & & &! +2 #&( 5&' &3&' 323"&(&' #"3" &' & $ #& & $"+&! # +#&, 2! '55& (2$4& #2$"9&!&' 2'2$5 3 '2( 6 +2'4& (23&'&' '&+ 3 %&'5 +2'5&3 9&(3&' (2$4& '%& #& " & $ :<&(2$ !&++2$; &' (2$4& (23&'&' ( '55 & &+ # +#&- &(2$ !&++2$ & & &! !2'(&3&' (23&'&' &(&" 52 +9&'5 & $ %&'5 29&93&' 2! 2'2$5 3 '2( 3 & $ & &+ 52$&3&''%& 32( 3& (2'&5& & $ ' !2'( 3&' &(&" &$&!'%& $"9&! 26&$& ( 9& ( 9&- 23&'&' '&+ 3 (2$" 3&' 32 & &+ (&9"'5 " &$& %&'5 92$ "'5 29&5& #2'5"&( (23&'&' & $ &' +2+&3 & & $ '& 3 32 # #& #2'5!&'(&$

L.M-&%& , # "/!"

- 2'& 3&' !2& (23&'&' L M

© ) ª„j ª…

!

+&'&?

© R 32'& 3&' !2& (23&'&' :+;

ŠR R 262#&(&' & $&' & $ & &+ # #& 292 "+

>& >2 +2'"("# :+D ;

Š R 3262#&(&' & $&' & $ & &+ # #& 2 " &! >& >2 +2'"("# :+D ;

* R 262#&(&' 52 +9&'5 "&$& & &+ & $ :+D ;

5 R #2$62#&(&' 5$&> (& :+D ;

- 23&'&' 324"( #& & #& " & $ :(#%))+#% )- /;

L M

. ) 2 2 « +&'&?

R (#%))+#% )- / : D+._;

R 3262#&(&' & $&' +& "3 :+D ;

R 3262#&(&' & $&' 9& 3 :+D ; « R +& & 42' & $ :35D+._;

.- 262#&(&' & $&' 9& 3 L M Š ) ˜y_¬

+&'&?

Š R 3262#&(&' & $&' 9& 3 :+D ; \ R + " " 9" 3 & $ : D+ ; « R +& & 42' & $ :35D+._;

- 2' Q "9" ' L M - ) ®¯2™¯ ®¯°2®±™²2 T//³ 2(2$&'5&'? g R 2 2' ! $&+ Q "9" ' :8; g R 29 ( !& :+._{D ;} gcR 29 ( 9"&'5 :+.D ; R !2& 32 "&$ :+; ;R !2& +& "3 :+; - 2' +2'"$"( &'3 '2L M ->)®¯2 ™¯j ™²_{®¯°2®±™²}2 T//³ 2(2$&'5&'? ->R 2 2' ! $&+ +2'"$"( &'3 '2 :8; g R 29 ( !& :+._{D ;} gcR 29 ( 9"&'5 :+.D ; R !2& 32 "&$ :+; ;R !2& +& "3 :+; (% '

2'2 ( &' ' &3 &'&3&' &9 $&( $ "+ 23' 3 2 ' *&3" (& 23' 3 ' >2$ (& &'6& &-/&$ &92 & &+ #2'2 ( &' ' & & &!?

&- /&$ &92 29&

&+2(2$ 3&("# +9&! '6! &' - '6! /&$ & 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ %& ("? ++, .@ ++ &'

++ 9- /&$ &92 (2$ 3&(

29 ( #2+ +#&&' :W; 29 ( 9"&'5 :];

"+ &! 32("3&' 3&("# 9"&'5 : ; 2' # +#& ! $&+ :g;

(%$ 4,*! * ! !*

&+9&$ 32+& 2'2 ( &' +#& $&+ 2(2$&'5&' 5&+9&$?

- #+ #

- #& & "3 : # $% (%<

.- & &' $&+ - &9"'5 " &$&

- &("# "&'5 : )!% "$%;

"$'& 23' 3 2 ' : ;? / - @7, - , )3( 92$ @ = =@

&+9&$ .- 32+& +#& $&+ (%& !/ !* ,", # !"

&+9&$ .- &5$&+ & $ #2'2 ( &' -%

&$ !& #2'2 ( &' #2$ 2! &(& &' &#&( 9"&( 5$& 3 29&5& 92$ 3"(?

- 2'5&$"! 4&$&3 3&("# +9&! &' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ (2$!& &# 29 ( #2+ +#&&'

&92 - 29 ( 2+ +#&&' &("# +9&! &$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# :++; 29 ( #2+ +#&&' :+._{D ;} , '6! @,@@@ @= .@ @,@@@ . @,@@@ , '6! @,@@@@7@ .@ @,@@@@ . @,@@@@ 7.

&+9&$ - $& 3 29 ( 2+ +#&&' &$ 5$& 3 29 ( #2+ +#&&' &(& &#&(3&' 29 ( #( +"+ #& & "3"$&' 3&("# +9&! 92$ &+2(2$ , '6! &' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ ++ %& (" @,@@@ +._{D 2 &'53&' 29 ( + ' +"+}

(2$ &#&( #& & "3"$&' 3&("# +9&! &+2(2$ , '6! &' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ ++ %& (" @,@@@@ 7. +._D

-- 2'5&$"! 4&$&3 3&("# +9&! &' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ (2$!& &# 29 ( & $ (2$9"&'5

&92 - 29 ( &("# +9&!

&("# +9&! &$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# :++; 29 ( 3&("# +9&! :+._{D ;} , '6! @,@@7 . .@ @,@@7 = @,@@7 7 , '6! @,@@7 . .@ @,@@7 77 @,@@7 .=

&+9&$ - 5$& 3 29 ( 3&("# +9&! &$ 5$& 3 29 ( 3&("# +9&! &(& &#&(3&' 29 ( 3&("# +9&! (2$9&'%&3 #& & "3"$&' 3&("# +9&! &+2(2$ , '6! &' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ ++ 2 &'53&' 29 ( 3&("# +9&! + ' +"+

,+ # ,* * !! " 8* (; : ! !4 "#! ! !# 8**: ,"/! ! !4 "#! ! !# *+! ,"/!" !# ,"/ !"#! , ! ! ,+ # ,* * !!" ,+ # !# * + ! 8* (; : ! !4 "#! ! !# 8**: ,"/! ! !4 "#! ! !# *+! ,"/!" !# ,"/ !"#! , ! ! ,+ # !# *+!

(2$ &#&( #& & "3"$&' 3&("# +9&! &+2(2$ , '6! &' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("#

#2'5!&'(&$

++-.- 2'5&$"! 4&$&3 3&("# +9&! &' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ (2$!& &# 4"+ &! 32("3&' 3&("# 9"&'5

&92 -. "+ &! 2("3&'

&("# +9&! &$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# :++; "+ &! 32("3&' :32("3&'; , '6! = .@ = , , '6! @, .@ , ,

&+9&$ -. $& 3 "+ &! 2("3&' & " $ &$ 5$& 3 4"+ &! 32("3&' #& " & $ &(& &#&(3&' 4"+ &! 32("3&' #( +"+ #& & "3"$&' 3&("# +9&! &+2(2$ , '6! &' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ ++ %& (" , 32("3&' 2 &'53&' 4"+ &! 32("3&' + ' +"+ (2$ &#&( #& & "3"$&' 3&("# +9&! &+2(2$ - '6! &' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ ++ %& (" ,

32("3&'-- "9"'5&' 4&$&3 3&("# +9&! &' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ (2$!& &# 2 2' Q "9" '

&92 - 2' Q&"9" ' &("# +9&! &$&3 '(&$& 3&("# :++; 2' Q&"9" ' :8; , '6! ,= .@ , , , '6! , .@ ,. , = &+9&$ - $& 3 2' Q "9" ' &$ 5$& 3 2 2' Q&"9" ' &(& &#&(3&' 2 2' # +#& Q&"9" ' (2$( '55 (2$ &#&( #& & "3"$&' 3&("# +9&! 92$ &+2(2$

, '6! &' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&'

3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ ++ %& (" , 8

2 &'53&' 2 2' # +#& Q&"9" ' + ' +"+ (2$ &#&( #& & "3"$&' 3&("# +9&! 92$ &+2(2$ , '6! &' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ ++ %& (" ,

=8-- "9"'5&' 4&$&3 3&("# +9&! &' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ (2$!& &# 2 2' $&'3 '2

&92 - 2' &'3 '2

&("# +9&! &$&3 &'(&$& 3&("#_{:++; $&'3 '2 :8;} 2'

, '6! ,@ .@ , , , '6! @,7 .@ @, @, = &+9&$ - 2' &'3 '2 * ! ,# 4!" ! !4 "#! ! !# 8**: ,"/! ! !4 "#! ! !# *+! ,"/!" !# ,"/ !"#! , ! ! * ! ,# 4!" ," D!+ " 8? : ! !4 "#! ! !# 8**: ,"/! ! !4 "#! ! !# *+! ,"/!" !# ,"/ !"#! , ! ! ," D! + " , " ! " 4", 8?: ! !4 "#! ! !# 8**: ,"/! ! !4 "#! ! !# *+! ,"/!" !# ,"/ !"#! , ! ! ," !"4 ",

"$'& 23' 3 2 ' : ;? / - @7, - , )3( 92$ @ = =

&$ 5$& 3 2 2' $&'3 '2 &(& &#&(3&' 2 2' ! $&+ #( +"+ (2$ &#&( #& & "3"$&' 3&("# +9&! 92$ &+2(2$ , '6! &' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ ++ %& (" , 8 2 &'53&' 2 2' ! $&+ + ' +"+ (2$ &#&( #& & "3"$&' 3&("# +9&! 92$ &+2(2$ , '6! &' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ ++ %& ("

@,

8-+#& ! $&" 3 $&+ 9232$4& 92$ & &$3&' #$ ' # #& " & $- 2'"("#&' 3&("# +9&! +2'%29&93&' & $&' & $ 2#2$( !2'( 3&' 26&$& ( 9& ( 9& 2! '55& (2$4& #2$"9&!&' 92'("3 2'2$5 3 '2( 3 +2'4& 2'2$5% (23&'&'- (2'("3&' 2! 3262#&(&' +2'"("#'%& 3&("#- &(2$ !&++2$ & & &! !2'(&3&' (23&'&' &(&" 52 +9&'5 & $ %&'5 29&93&' 2! 2'2$5 3 '2( 3 & $ & &+ 52$&3&''%& 32( 3& (2'&5& & $ ' !2'( 3&' &(&" &$&!'%& $"9&! 26&$& ( 9& ( 9&- '("3 >&$ & 4&$& &'&(&$& 3&("# +9&! &' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$

: ++, .@ ++ &' ++; %&'5 5"'&3&'

#& & #2'2 ( &' ' (2$'%&(& &'5&( 92$#2'5&$"! (2$!& &# 29 ( #2+ +#&&', 29 ( 9"&'5 &'

2 2' # +#& ! $&+- & ' 29&93&'

#2'5&$"! 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! &' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$, 29 ( #2+ +#&&' &' 2 2' (2$( '55 (2$ &#&( #& & 3&("# +9&! , '6! &' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! & & &! ++ 3&$2'&3&' 2+&3 ' 23&( 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +&3& <&3(" "'("3 #2'5 &' & $ &' (2$4& '%& #& " & $ 2+&3 ' '53&( #& & (&9"'5 " &$& %&'5 +2'5&3 9&(3&' 32$4& ! $&+ 92 "+ #( +"+-1%

'2$4& # +#& ! $&+ (2$!& &# #2$92 &&' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ +2+ 3 #2'5&$"! (2$!& &# 29 ( !& #2+ +#&&' 2! '55& +2+#2'5&$"! 2 2'

&$ # +#& ! $&+ (2$

29"(-- 29 ( #2+ +#&&' #( +"+ #& & "3"$&' 3&("# +9&! 92$ &+2(2$ , '6! &' 4&$&3

&'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ ++ %& (" @,@@@ +._D

-- 29 ( 3&("# +9&! + ' +"+ (2$ &#&( #& & "3"$&' 3&("# +9&! &+2(2$ , '6! &' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$ ++ %& (" @,@@7 7 +._D

-.- 2' ! $&+ +2'"$"( (2 $ Q&"9" ' #2$ 2! !& (2$( '55 (2$ &#&( #& & "3"$&' 3&("# +9&! 92$ &+2(2$ , '6! &' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$

++ %& (" ,

8-- 2' ! $&+ +2'"$"( (2 $ $&'3 '2

#2$ 2! !& #( +"+ (2$ &#&( #& & "3"$&' 3&("# +9&! 92$ &+2(2$ , '6! &' 4&$&3 &'(&$& 3&("# +9&! 2'5&' 3&("# #2'5!&'(&$

++ %& (" , 8

-L M & 2 "&$ & &' $&<&', ? 0

/)(%# % ! " % , #+- + , ' # ' % ' %/ ( '# , "$'& + &! 23' 3 2 ' 1 / - , "' @@ : @ ; L M "'55"3 "(&$9"(&$, % , #+- %!%# % # % ' ( '# %#- ' ( %/ , %#0 ' ' ( + , >% )

$ , "5& 3! $ @ 7, *&3" (& 23' 3 2 ', ' >2$ (& &'6& &

L.M 2($& &'55&$&, & "!& ' < )"($&,

% , #+- # ) 0 , ( )+/

; < % ? !+( + ,

; < %#- ' ( * ) % ) (

, @ ., ) ) , / , D & .

.

-L M &' 2 )$(25& &'4& (&', 23& (2#",

, ,+ ( ( - '# ' (% ,+0 (% , #+- $ # ) ! ,, ! + , +' # ' ( 0 , ( ( (% )+/ !%#- ' ( + 0+/ /%#0 ( ( - '# , 4"$'& '&+ , / , 2#(2+92$ @ , .. @.