ATOM INDONESIA JOURNAL
Author’s Response toward Associate Editor's Report
Article No. : #497
Title of Paper : An Experimental Analysis on Nusselt Number of Natural Circulation Flow in Transient Condition Based on the Height Differences between Heater and Cooler
Comment on Descriptions
Criteria Evaluation
Associate editor's evaluation
Author’s Responses
Yes No Comments
1. Originality of the article
Free of Plagiarism/Similarity
(max 20%) √ Yes Ok
New article/not yet Published (presented/ in proceeding max 30%)
√ √
Yes Ok
2. Related to nuclear/atomic science
and technology √ Yes Ok
3. Reference
The number of references at least
10 √ Yes Ok
The use of recent references 80%
(maximum 5 years ago) √
13 out of 23 references are
older than 2011 The state of the art must relate with the flow of story of natural circulation, related to the equation which was developed.
Type of the references
(primarily, secondary etc.) 85%
from journal
√ √
Ok Ok
Cross link reference (traceable) √ Not yet checked
Reference style standard:
Elsevier numeric without title √ Yes Ok
When reference has more than 3
Authors, write only 3 name, et al. √ No It has corrected base on the advice
Article follows the Atom Indonesia template and guidelines
√ √
Yes Ok
Table (clear, without vertical
line) √ No tables Ok
Figure (clear, min 300 dpi) √ √ Yes Ok Final recommendation:
1. Continue review process [ ] 2. Return to the Author [ √ ] 3. Reject [ ]
Comments:
Small revision is needed.
It colud be continued review process
