INDONESIAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS - Atom Indonesia

(1)

ATOM INDONESIA JOURNAL

Referee’s Report

Article No. : #979

Title of Paper : Characteristics of Stable Isotope Compositions (δ18O and δ2H) of Surface Water in Bengkulu city

Comment on Descriptions 1. The Title is Appropriate*

[X] Completely correct [ ] Partly correct [ ] not Correct at all

Comment :

2. Abstract

The Content and Length of the abstract are appropriate*

[X ] Completely correct [ ] Partly correct [ ] not Correct at all

Comment :

3. Main Text

The results are important to be reported*

Comment :

The paper is of high scientific quality (scientifically sound)*

[ X] Completely correct [ ] Partly correct [ ] not Correct at all

Comment :

The paper is well organized (experimental/theory/results/conclusion)*

[ X] Completely correct [ ] Partly correct [ ] not Correct at all

Comment :

(2)

The length of the paper is appropriate to the content*

Comment :

The references are adequate in complete / consist of 85% primary references and recent journals*

[ ] Completely correct [X] Partly correct [ ] not Correct at all

Comment :

The references consist only 69.56%. You can calculate by MS Excel and give the recent journals as 1 and other references (books, journal published below 2015, website) as 0 ). Then it will show you the percentage of

primary references and recent journals.

The English is alright*

[X] Completely correct [ ] Partly correct [ ] not Correct at all

Comment :

Final Comments To the Author*

Line Number Comment :

ABSTRACT

Rain water should be rainwater Add comma after consequently Add “the” after water level Put space before “Therefore”

15

Put “the” before latitude

45

Change to : because of

54

Put comma before therefore

114

change to : standards

73

change to : compositions

78

Add “the” before isotopic

85

change to : because of

87

change to : the previous study ….

123

change to : seawater

165

change to : the surface

(3)

174

change to : province

186

change to : cap

203

Please provide better/bigger picture the Picarro L21140-i analyser

247

change to : closes

253

change to : a longer river

267

change to : A previous

277

change to : the local

285

change to : maybe

286

change to : the tropical

323

change to : have a slope

328

change to : may be

340

change to : rainwater

353

change to : the water body

367

change to : changing pattern

382

change to : Geochemistry

Confidential Comments to the EIC:

Comment :

This paper is recommended to be [ ] Accepted without further revision [X] Accepted with minor revision [ ] Major Revision is required [ ] Rejected

(4)

31/3/2020 Review Form Response

aij.batan.go.id/index.php/aij/sectionEditor/viewReviewFormResponse/979/1378 1/3

REVIEW FORM RESPONSE

Referee's Report >>>

1. The Title is Appropriate * [1] Completely Correct Comment

2. Abstract

The Content and Length of the abstract are appropriate * [1] Completely Correct

Comment

3. Main Text

The results are important to be reported * [1] Completely Correct

Comment

The paper is of high scientific quality (scientifically sound) * [3] Not Correct at all

Comment

(5)

The paper is well organized (experimental/theory/results/conclusion) * [1] Completely Correct

Comment

The length of the paper is appropriate to the content * [1] Completely Correct

Comment

The references are adequate in complete / consist of 85% primary references and recent journals *

[2] Partly Correct Comment

The English is alright * [1] Excellent Comment

Final Comments

The references consist only 69.56%. You can calculate by MS Excel and give the recent journals as 1 and other references (books, journals published before 20145, website) as 0 ). Then it will show you the percentage of primary references and recent journals

(6)

To the Author *

Confidential Comments to the EIC

This Paper is recommended to be * Accepted without further revision Accepted with minor revision Major Revision is required Rejected

Close

* Denotes required field

Please revised the article as my attached suggestion