11/2/2019 Review Form Response
http://aij.batan.go.id/index.php/aij/sectionEditor/viewReviewFormResponse/908/1090 1/3
REVIEW FORM RESPONSE
Referee's Report >>
1. The Title is Appropriate * [1] Completely Correct Comment
2. Abstract
The Content and Length of the abstract are appropriate * [1] Completely Correct
Comment
3. Main Text
The results are important to be reported * [2] Partly Correct
Comment
Please describe about the types of SIT objects that can be sterilized (egg, young and adult mosquitoes) including their number, how often the releasing the mosquitoes into the study area, and how wide the area under study. Please add the detailed information on the incident of DF found in local community members as output of the program after the SIT implementation study.
Is it possible to use irradiated egg to the study area outside Java Island???
The paper is of high scientific quality (scientifically sound) * [1] Completely Correct
Comment
11/2/2019 Review Form Response
http://aij.batan.go.id/index.php/aij/sectionEditor/viewReviewFormResponse/908/1090 2/3
The paper is well organized (experimental/theory/results/conclusion) * [1] Completely Correct
Comment
The length of the paper is appropriate to the content * [1] Completely Correct
Comment
The references are adequate in complete / consist of 85% primary references and recent journals *
[2] Partly Correct
Comment
Only 18 out of 35 (51%) are recent references (after 2014)
The English is alright * [1] Completely Correct Comment
Final Comments To the Author *
11/2/2019 Review Form Response
http://aij.batan.go.id/index.php/aij/sectionEditor/viewReviewFormResponse/908/1090 3/3
Line 122-123 : Please describe/completed with the results on evaluation of sterility and mating competitiveness, it may use a table.
Line 124 : What is the dose rate used???
Line 249 : Please add “the bar” on the figure that describe how wide the studied area
Confidential Comments to the EIC
It is appropriate to be published in AIJ after adding/completing the suggestion/comments
This Paper is recommended to be * Accepted without further revision Accepted with minor revision Major Revision is required Rejected
Close
* Denotes required field
ATOM INDONESIA JOURNAL
Referee’s Report
Article No. : #908
Title of Paper :
Current Status and Recent Achievements of The Sterile Insect Technique Program Against Dengue Vector, Aedes aegypti, in Indonesia
Comment on Descriptions 1. The Title is Appropriate*
[√ ] Completely correct [ ] Partly correct [ ] not Correct at all
Comment :
2. Abstract
The Content and Length of the abstract are appropriate*
[ √ ] Completely correct [ ] Partly correct [ ] not Correct at all
Comment :
3. Main Text
The results are important to be reported*
[ ] Completely correct [√ ] Partly correct [ ] not Correct at all
Comment :
Please describe about the types of SIT objects that can be sterilized (egg, young and adult
mosquitoes) including their number, how often the releasing the mosquitoes into the study area, and how wide the area under study. Please add the detailed information on the incident of DF found in local community members as output of the program after the SIT implementation study.
Is it possible to use irradiated egg to the study area outside Java Island???
The paper is of high scientific quality (scientifically sound)*
[√ ] Completely correct [ ] Partly correct [ ] not Correct at all
Comment :
The paper is well organized (experimental/theory/results/conclusion)*
[√ ] Completely correct [ ] Partly correct [ ] not Correct at all
Comment :
The length of the paper is appropriate to the content*
[√ ] Completely correct [ ] Partly correct [ ] not Correct at all
Comment :
The references are adequate in complete / consist of 85% primary references and recent journals*
[ ] Completely correct [ √ ] Partly correct [ ] not Correct at all
Comment :
Only 18 out of 35 (51%) are recent references (after 2014)
The English is alright*
[√ ] Completely correct [ ] Partly correct [ ] not Correct at all
Comment :
Final Comments To the Author*
Line Number Comment :
122-123
Please describe/completed with the results on evaluation of sterility and mating competitiveness, it may use a table
124
What is the dose rate used???
249
Please add “the bar” on the figure that describe how wide the studied area
Confidential Comments to the EIC:
Comment :
It is appropriate to be published in AIJ after adding/completing the suggestion/comments
This paper is recommended to be [ ] Accepted without further revision [√ ] Accepted with minor revision [ ] Major Revision is required [ ] Rejected
