Associate editor's report form >>>

(1)

10/23/2019 Review Form Response

http://aij.batan.go.id/index.php/aij/sectionEditor/viewReviewFormResponse/983/1306 1/4

1. Originality of the article

Free of Plagiarism/Similarity (max 20%) * [1] Completely Correct

Comments

By iThenticate, the similarity level of the manuscript is 16%.

New article/not yet Published (presented/ in proceeding max 30%) * [1] Completely Correct

Comments

Based on the result generated by iThenticate, I conclude that this manuscript is new.

2. Related to nuclear/atomic science and technology * [1] Completely Correct

Comments

The manuscript discusses the effects on TRIGA safety at its different states of core burnt during reactivity induced transient.

3. Reference

The number of references at least 10 * [3] Not Correct at all

Comments

(2)

The number of references is only 6

The use of recent references 80% (maximum 5 years ago) * [3] Not Correct at all

Comments

Only 1 out of 6 is younger than 5 years.

Type of the references (primarily, secondary etc.) 85% from journal * [3] Not Correct at all

Comments

Only 2 out of 6 references are from journal

Cross link reference (traceable) * [2] Partly Correct

Comments

Only references from journal can be traceable

Reference style standard: Elsevier numeric without title * [3] Not Correct at all

Comments

All references still include title

(3)

When reference has more than 3 Authors, write only 3 name, et al. * [3] Not Correct at all

Comments

Article follows the Atom Indonesia template and guidelines * [1] Completely Correct

Comments

Table (clear, without vertical line) * [1] Completely Correct Comments

Figure (clear, min 300 dpi) * [1] Completely Correct Comments

Is the Level of English appropriate? * [2] Adequate

Comments

(4)

Final recommendation: * Continue review process Return to the Author Reject

Final Comments *

The manuscript needs to be returned to the author for revising before it goes through to reviewers

Close

* Denotes required field