Associate editor's report form >> - Atom Indonesia

10/24/2019 Review Form Response

http://aij.batan.go.id/index.php/aij/sectionEditor/viewReviewFormResponse/947/1190 1/4

REVIEW FORM RESPONSE

Associate editor's report form >>

1. Originality of the article

Free of Plagiarism/Similarity (max 20%) * [2] Partly Correct

Comments

The author should confirm about the published  article in  Experimental Heat Transfer Volume 31,  2018 ­ Issue 5 with the title "Characterization of  the boiling width on metal quenching with spray  cooling".

 

New article/not yet Published (presented/ in proceeding max 30%) * [2] Partly Correct

Comments

The author should confirm about the published  article in  Experimental Heat Transfer Volume 31,  2018 ­ Issue 5 with the title "Characterization of  the boiling width on metal quenching with spray  cooling".

2. Related to nuclear/atomic science and technology * [2] Partly Correct

Comments

Authors should described the relation of the study  with nuclear/atomic science and technology. 

Otherwise the manuscript will be rejected.

3. Reference

The number of references at least 10 *

10/24/2019 Review Form Response

http://aij.batan.go.id/index.php/aij/sectionEditor/viewReviewFormResponse/947/1190 2/4

[1] Completely Correct Comments

 

The use of recent references 80% (maximum 5 years ago) * [2] Partly Correct

Comments

The numbers of your recent references (2015­

now) are less than 80%.

 

Type of the references (primarily, secondary etc.) 85% from journal * [1] Completely Correct

Comments

 

Cross link reference (traceable) * [1] Completely Correct Comments

 

Reference style standard: Elsevier numeric without title * [1] Completely Correct

Comments

10/24/2019 Review Form Response

http://aij.batan.go.id/index.php/aij/sectionEditor/viewReviewFormResponse/947/1190 3/4

 

When reference has more than 3  Authors, write only 3 name, et al. * [2] Partly Correct

Comments

Please follow the guidelines for writing the  references!

 

Article follows the Atom Indonesia template and guidelines * [1] Completely Correct

Comments

 

Table (clear, without vertical line) * [1] Completely Correct Comments

 

Figure (clear, min 300 dpi) * [1] Completely Correct Comments

10/24/2019 Review Form Response

http://aij.batan.go.id/index.php/aij/sectionEditor/viewReviewFormResponse/947/1190 4/4

Is the Level of English appropriate? * [1] Completely Correct

Comments

Final recommendation: * Continue review process Return to the Author Reject

Final Comments *

­ The author must see carefully and follow the  guidelines of Atom Indonesia journal! 

­ The author should confirm about the potential  self­plagiarism. Otherwise the manuscript will be  rejected.

­ The author should state the relation of the study  with nuclear/atomic science and technology. 

Otherwise the manuscript will be rejected.

Close

* Denotes required field