ATOM INDONESIA
Author's Responses
Article : #846-3541-1-SP
Article Title : Associate Editor's Report
Line # Referee’s Comments Author's Responses
1. Type of reference (primary, secondary etc) 85%
from journal, only 35% new
References were added, currently has 85,2%
from new journal 2. When reference has more than 3 author, write
only 3 names, et al
References list were corrected to only 3 author for reference has more than 3 author 3. Article follows the atom indonesia tempale and
guidlines : Table and figures should be revised
Tabel and figures were corrected following template and guidlines of atom indonesia template
4.
Table (clear, without vertical line), figure (clear min 300 dpi) : Table 1 should follow template.
Figs 1,4,5,6 should be revised
Table 1 was corrected following template.
Figs 1,4,5,6 were revised
ATOM INDONESIA
Author's Responses
Article : #846-3673-1-SP
Article Title : Referee’s Report
Line # Referee’s Comments Author's Responses
1.
The abstract should be improved. The experiment results should be added in the abstract, some grammar error shsould be corrected
Experimental data for other methods was entered into the abstract and the grammar was improved
2. In abstract, imageries images Imageries was corrected to be images 3. Line 21 in the paper, “has had been installed” Line 21 was corrected to be “was installed”
4. Line 49 – 50, “has been” Line 49-50 was corrected to be “have been”
5. Line 369, ASAM or other method Misplaced the citation, the number of citation at line 369 was deleted.
6. Fig 4 & 5 should be closed figure Figure 4 & 5 was corrected 7. Table 1 should follow the atom indonesia
instruction Table 1 was corrected following the template
ATOM INDONESIA
Author's Responses
Article : #846-3675-1-SP
Article Title : Editor's Report
Line # Referee’s Comments Author's Responses
1. Fig 4 & 5 should be closed figure Figure 4 & 5 was corrected 2. Table 1 should follow the atom indonesia
instruction
Table 1 was corrected following the template of atom indonesia
Please return to Atom Indonesia Editorial Office via
supplementary file in OJS aplication.June 28, 2018
