ATOM INDONESIA
Author's Responses
Article : # 859
Article Title : Investigation on Neutron Flux Effect onto Irradiated Fuel Burnup Stored in the Reactor TRIGA PUSPATI
Line # Referee’s Comments Author's Responses
Page 1 (2nd column, line # 222) Page 2 (1ft column, line # 250), (2nd column, line # 44, 48, 86, 88, 164, 172 ) Page 4 (1ft column, line # 198, 234) Page 5 (2nd column, line # 188) Page 7 (2nd column, line # 20- 166)
Reference style standard: Elsevier numeric without title: No
Comments:
Should be revised
All reference style standards have been updated according Elsevier standard.
Page 7 (2nd column, line # 30, 54, 84, 94, 112)
When reference has more than 3 Authors, write only 3 name, et al.: No Comments:
Should be revised
Updated have been done according comments given by referee’s.
2nd Round Referee’s Comments.
The references are adequate in complete / consist of 85% primary references and recent journals:
[2] Partly Correct
Comment:
primary references and recent journal should be added more
Based on referee’s comments and to comply the journal standard percentage for the journal requirement (the
references are adequate in complete / consist of 85%
primary references and recent journals):
Some of the reference highlighted has
been changes to journal form to meet the
requirement of the journal reference
standard at minimum 85%.
Page 1 (2nd column, line # 49 -52
[1]
Page 3 (1st column, line
# 210 – 215 [9]
Page 4 (1st column, line
# 220 – 222) [10]
Page 4 (1st column, line
# 230 – 231) [11]
Page 4 (1st column, line
# 238 – 239) [12}
Page 4 (2nd column, line
# 249 – 257) [13]
Page 5 (2nd column, line
# 337 – 339) [14]
Page 1
(2nd column, line # 49 -52 [1] change to line
# 52-54 [1]
Page 3 (1st column, from line # 210 – 215 change to 210-215) [9]
Page 4 (1st column, line # 230 – 231)) change reference number from [10] to [11].
Page 4 (1st column, line # 238 – 239) change reference number from [1] to [12].
Addition the information of argument in order to meet percentage of journal source reference and strengthening the result of the calculation.
Page 5 (2nd column, line # 337 – 339) [14]
change reference number from [11] to[14].
Page 6
Final Comments To the Author:
The Table 3 should be written in the journal standard, i.e 0.000002 -> 2 x 10-6
There are 2 tables involved in this
comments; first table 2 and second is table 3.
All the information given has been updated according journal standard.
Final Comments To the Author:
It would be much better if you use recent references and from journal rather than proceedings or books
All the comments of this matters was updated according reviewers’ suggestion but some of the information came from manual that was made by owner of the product such as MCNPX user manual and some more from the result of study that was one of the content in the thesis.
