ATOM INDONESIA
Author's Responses
Article : #947
Article Title : Characterization of the heat transfer on spray quenching for different material properties
Line # Referee’s Comments Author's Responses
You still have not improved the ABSTRACT. It has to consist of re- search gap, research objective, research methodology, and results
As suggested, section ABSTRACT has been revised to explicitly highlight research gap, research objective, research methodology, and results
Please avoid any figure from section INTRODUCTION The mentioned figure is already removed from section INTRODUCTION Your response to reviewer's comment of "Please provide scientific
reason for choosing Nickel and Aluminum alloy AA6082 for this study" is "Scientifically, Nickel and Aluminum Alloy AA6082 are the two non-ferrous metals representing two different casting process from which they are produced. Nickel is produced through continu- ous casting process while AA6082 is through direct chill casting. Be- sides, they have different thermophysical properties which are sus- pected for the reason of having different quenching characteristics.
You have to include this description into the revised version of your manuscript
It is already revised accordingly as suggested (in the experimental setup)
Your response to reviewer comment of "How do you decide the heat- ing up temperature of 560o C?" is "Temperature of 560o C is the op- timum point for comparing AA6082 and Nickel. Nickel physically can undergo a higher temperature but not for AA6082. Under this designated temperature both AA6082 and Nickel are still good physi- cally and providing feasibility to see some phenomena of interest e.g., film boiling, Leidenfrost transition for the sake of analysis."
You have to include those explanation above into the revised version of your manuscript
It is already revised accordingly as suggested (in the experimental setup)
Please describe all variables in the NOMENCLATURE closed to the corresponding equations. Please read and refer to the author guide lines.
Section NOMENCLATURE is already removed. Instead, necessary information is already put close to the corresponding equations.
You still have not improved the CONCLUSION. You only need to describe your main findings regarding your research objectives and their physical meaning. In this version, the conclusion is still too long.
It is already revised accordingly shorter and only highlight main finding pertaining research objectives
Please follow the reference style of atom indonesia. You can read the author guidelines or confirm to the previous atom Indonesia publica- tions.
It is already revised accordingly as stated in author guideline.
Between section ACKNOWLEDGMENT and section REFER- ENCES, you have to provide section AUTHOR CONTRIBUTION.
Please refer to the newest version of atom indonesia template.
This part is already added as suggested.
Please return to Atom Indonesia Editorial Office via
supplementary file in OJS application.February 25th, 2021
