ATOM INDONESIA JOURNAL Author's Responses
Article : #419
Name of All Authors : I. Kambali, H. Suryanto, Parwanto
Article Title : Identification and Angular Distribution of Residual Radionuclides Detected on the Wall of BATAN’s Cyclotron Cave
E-mail : [email protected]
Line # Referee’s Comments Author's Responses
2 Title Should be changed The article “the” has been removed 2,3,11 .. the BATANs .. → .. BATAN’s .. line 21: ..
hadron particles are .. → .. proton beam is ..
The words have been corrected as suggested by the referee.
75, 78 .. due .. → .. due to .. line 78: .. authors .. → ..
authors’ ..
The words have been corrected as suggested by the referee.
101 .. neutronsare.. → .. neutrons are .. A space has been added between the words neutrons and are.
146
replace use of letter “x” by multiplication sign symbol “×” (also in lines 154, 329, 424, 434)
The letter “x” has been replaced by “×”
217 do not write arabic numerals in italics, The italic numbers have been replaced with the ordinary ones
241-2 .. which follows [14]: .. → .. following [14] .. The words “which follows [14]” have been replaced with “following [14]”
243 string of periods preceeding any equation number is not required
string of periods preceeding any equation number have been removed
308-9 How Fig. 3 is obtained? Provide reference (and permission) if it is obtained elsewhere.
Fig. 3 was plotted from TALYS
calculations; therefore the words “TALYS calculated nuclear cross sections….” Have been added in the Fig. 3 caption.
319 In Fig. 4: Energy → Neutron Energy In Fig. 4, Energy corresponds to Neutron Energy. The word “Neutron” has been added in the x-axis
386,
562 Cs-137 or Cs-134? It should’ve been Cs-134. The term has been
corrected.
Final comm ents
mention when the measurement was done and when the last
cyclotron beam exposure happened (also beam energy and current)
This sentence has been added in lines 248- 252:
Note that all measurements were carried out between December 2014 and January 2015, and the CS-30 cyclotron’s last operation was in July 2005 at a maximum beam energy and current of 26.5 MeV and 1 µA respectively.
Final comm ents
reference 17 should be
added as it is cited in line 542.
Reference 17 has been removed from the reference list since it is not necessary anymore, and it has been well-represented by reference 16.
Please return to Atom Indonesia Editorial Office via e-mail: [email protected] and Faximile: 021-7560895.
This original sheet should be returned to:
Tata Usaha Atom Indonesia, PPIKSN-BATAN, Gedung 71, Lantai 1, Kawasan Puspiptek Serpong, Tangerang, Indonesia 15310
Author Signature(s) Date: 29/09/2015
Imam Kambali Name(s) (print)
