ATOM INDONESIA JOURNAL
Author’s Responses toward Associate Editor's Report
Article No. : 491
Title of Paper : Dynamic Analysis on the Safety Criteria of the Conceptual Core Design in MTR Type Research Reactor
Comment on Descriptions
Criteria Evaluation
Associate editor's evaluation
Author’s Responses
Yes No Comments
1. Originality of the article
Free of plagiarism/similarity
(max 20 %) v
New article/not yet published (presented/in proceeding max 30 %)
v 2. Related to nuclear/atomic
science and technology v
3. Reference
The number of references 10- 20 for non-review articles, 25+ for review articles
v
The use of recent references
80 % (maximum 5 years ago) x
Only nine of the 17 references (53 %) are from 2011 or later.
Please add recent references or reduce older references.
Already changed the older to the recent references
Type of the references (primarily, secondary etc.) 85
% from journal
v 15 of the 17 references (88 %) are from journals
All the references from journals
DOI (digital object identifier)
reference (traceable) x
No DOIs are provided. Please provide DOIs whenever available. For instance, for Ref.
[6], its DOI is
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.pnuc ene.2007.11.089
Already provided the DOIs for refernces when they are available
Reference style standard:
Elsevier numeric without title x
The writing of the author's name (some of which are written in full, such as “ Anis Bousbia- Salah” instead of “A. Bousbia- Salah) should be
corrected/standardized. Only initials of first/middle names should be given.
Already corrected with the initials of first names
When reference has more than 3 authors, write only 3 name, et al.
x
For [2], [5], and [6], all authors' names are given, even though there are more than three of them. Please correct those references.
Already corrected all authors’ names
Article follows the Atom Indonesia template and guidelines
x
Please use last names in the list of the article's authors.
Please follow SI convention in writing quantities and units, including percentages. SI
Already used the last names in the list of the articles’s authors
Already used the SI unit
brochures are available from http://www.bipm.org/en/publica tions/si-brochure/ among others, at least
http://www.bipm.org/utils/com mon/pdf/si_brochure_8_en.pdf in particular.
Table (clear, without vertical
line) x
All tables in this article still use vertical lines. Please remove those lines, by redesigning the tables if necessary.
The tables are already removed the vertical lines
Figure (clear, min 300 dpi) v Not applicable: no photographs are used
Final recommendation:
1. Continue review process [ ] 2. Return to the author [ v ] 3. Reject [ ]
Comments:
The article should be returned to the authors to allow for the necessary improvements to be made.
