LAMPIRAN A DATA MENTAH
Tabel A. 1 Data Scada Pada Aliran Co-Current dan Counter Current
Tabel A. 2 Data Teoritis Pada Aliran Co-Current dan Counter Current
LAMPIRAN B PERHITUNGAN
A. Co-Current
1. Perhitungan Nilai ΔT1
Temperatur 40ᵒC ΔT1 = Th in - Tc in
= 37,1196 - 30,231
= 6,88859
Temperatur 44ᵒC ΔT1 = Th in - Tc in
= 40,3181 – 30,4352
= 9,88284
Temperatur 48ᵒC ΔT1 = Th in - Tc in
= 44,6544 – 30,8066
= 13,8478
Temperatur 52ᵒC ΔT1 = Th in - Tc in
= 48,1939 – 31,1484
= 17,0455 2. Perhitungan Nilai ΔT2
Temperatur 40ᵒC
ΔT2 = Th out - Tc out
= 33,9671 – 32,558
= 1,40919
Temperatur 44ᵒC
ΔT2 = Th out - Tc out
= 35,5887 – 33,8435
= 1,74512
Temperatur 48ᵒC
ΔT2 = Th out - Tc out
= 37,6119 – 35,3716
= 2,24031
Temperatur 52ᵒC
ΔT2 = Th out - Tc out
= 38,909 – 36,2829
= 2,62616 3. Perhitungan Nilai ΔT LMTD
Temperatur 40ᵒC ΔT LMTD =
ΔT2−ΔT1 ln
(
ΔTΔT21)
=
1,40919−6,88859 ln
(
1,409196,88859)
= 3,4529986
Temperatur 44ᵒC ΔT LMTD =
ΔT2−ΔT1 ln
(
ΔTΔT21)
=
1,74512−9,88284 ln
(
1,74512 29,88284)
= 4,6930996
Temperatur 48ᵒC ΔT LMTD =
ΔT2−ΔT1 ln
(
ΔTΔT21)
=
2,24031−13,8478 ln
(
2,2403113,8478)
= 6,3724378
Temperatur 52ᵒC
ΔT LMTD =
ΔT2−ΔT1 ln
(
ΔTΔT21)
=
2,62616−17,0455 ln
(
17,045 52,62616)
= 7,709372 4. Perhitungan Nilai ΔTh
Temperatur 40ᵒC
ΔTh = Th out – Th in = 33,9671 - 37,1196 = 3,152422
Temperatur 44ᵒC
ΔTh = Th out – Th in = 35,5887 – 40,3181 = 4,729397
Temperatur 48ᵒC
ΔTh = Th out – Th in = 37,6119 – 44,6544 = 7,04251
Temperatur 52ᵒC
ΔTh = Th out – Th in = 38,909 – 48,1939 = 9,284853
5. Perhitungan Nilai ΔTc
Temperatur 40ᵒC
ΔTc = Tc out – Tc in = 32,558 – 30,231 = 2,326975
Temperatur 44ᵒC
ΔTc = Tc out – Tc in
= 33,8435 – 30,4352 = 3,408316
Temperatur 48ᵒC
ΔTc = Tc out – Tc in = 35,3716 – 30,8066 = 4,564962
Temperatur 52ᵒC
ΔTc = Tc out – Tc in = 36,2829 – 31,1484 = 5,134488
6. Perhitungan Nilai mH
Temperatur 40ᵒC
mH = ρ ×
(
1000SC1)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,671381000)
×(
601)
= 0,027494138
Temperatur 44ᵒC
mH = ρ ×
(
1000SC1)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,62551000)
×(
601)
= 0,026739543
Temperatur 48ᵒC
mH = ρ ×
(
1000SC1)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,452521000)
×(
601)
= 0,02389397
Temperatur 52ᵒC
mH = ρ ×
(
1000SC1)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,226461000)
×(
601)
= 0,020175187 7. Perhitungan Nilai mC
Temperatur 40ᵒC
mC = ρ ×
(
1000SC2)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,8961000)
×(
601)
= 0,031189144
Temperatur 44ᵒC
mC = ρ ×
(
1000SC2)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,934531000)
×(
601)
= 0,03182301
Temperatur 48ᵒC
mC = ρ ×
(
1000SC2)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,933751000)
×(
601)
= 0,031810133
Temperatur 52ᵒC
mC = ρ ×
(
1000SC2)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,916481000)
×(
601)
= 0,031526123 8. Perhitungan Nilai Qh
Temperatur 40ᵒC
Qh = ΔTh × mH × Cp
= 3,152422 × 0,027494138 × 4178 = 362,1203041
Temperatur 44ᵒC
Qh = ΔTh × mH × Cp
= 4,729397 × 0,026739543 × 4178 = 528,3578745
Temperatur 48ᵒC
Qh = ΔTh × mH × Cp
= 7,04251 × 0,02389397 × 4178 = 703,0467357
Temperatur 52ᵒC
Qh = ΔTh × mH × Cp
= 9,284853 × 0,020175187 × 4178 = 782,6381612
9. Perhitungan Nilai Qc
Temperatur 40ᵒC
Qc = ΔTc × mC × Cp
= 2,326975 × 0,031189144 × 4178 = 303,2239984
Temperatur 44ᵒC
Qc = ΔTc × mC × Cp
= 3,408316 × 0,03182301 × 4178 = 453,1578682
Temperatur 48ᵒC
Qc = ΔTc × mC × Cp
= 4,564962 × 0,031810133 × 4178 = 606,6960115
Temperatur 52ᵒC
Qc = ΔTc × mC × Cp
= 5,134488 × 0,031526123 × 4178 = 676.2949414
10. Perhitungan Nilai U
Temperatur 40ᵒC
U = Qh
(A × ΔT LMTD) = 362,1203041
(0,432×3,4529986) = 242,7575
Temperatur 44ᵒC
U = Qh
(A × ΔT LMTD) = 528,3578745
(0,432×4,6930996) = 260,6062
Temperatur 48ᵒC
U = Qh
(A × ΔT LMTD) = 703,0467357
(0,432×6,3724378) = 255,3847
Temperatur 52ᵒC
U = Qh
(A × ΔT LMTD) = 782,6381612
(0,432×7,709372) = 234,9948
11. Perhitungan Nilai Cc
Temperatur 40ᵒC Cc = Cp × mC
= 4178 × 0,031189144 = 130,308242
Temperatur 44ᵒC Cc = Cp × mC
= 4178 × 0,03182301
= 132,956535
Temperatur 48ᵒC Cc = Cp × mC
= 4178 × 0,031810133 = 132,9027377
Temperatur 52ᵒC Cc = Cp × mC
= 4178 × 0,031526123 = 131,7161439
12. Perhitungan Nilai Ch
Temperatur 40ᵒC Ch = Cp × mH
= 4178 × 0,027494138 = 114,87051
Temperatur 44ᵒC Ch = Cp × mH
= 4178 × 0,026739543 = 111,71781
Temperatur 48ᵒC Ch = Cp × mH
= 4178 × 0,02389397 = 99,829006
Temperatur 52ᵒC Ch = Cp × mH
= 4178 × 0,020175187 = 84,291932
13. Perhitungan Nilai NTU
Temperatur 40ᵒC NTU = U × A
Ccold
= 242,7575×0,432 130,308242 = 0,80479
Temperatur 44ᵒC NTU = U × A
Ccold
= 260,6062×0,432 132,956535 = 0,84676
Temperatur 48ᵒC NTU = U × A
Ccold
= 255,3847×0,432 132,9027377 = 0,83013
Temperatur 52ᵒC NTU = U × A
Ccold
= 234,9948×0,432 131,7161439 = 0,77073
14. Perhitungan eff
Temperatur 40ᵒC
eff = Tcout−Tcin
Thin−Tcin ×100 % = 32,558−30,231
37,1196−30,231×100 % = 33,7802
Temperatur 44ᵒC
eff = Tcout−Tcin
Thin−Tcin ×100 % = 33,8435−30,4352
40,3181−30,4352×100 % = 34,4872
Temperatur 48ᵒC
eff = Tcout−Tcin
Thin−Tcin ×100 % = 35,3716−30,8066
44,6544−30,8066×100 % = 32,9653
Temperatur 52ᵒC
eff = Tcout−Tcin
Thin−Tcin ×100 % = 36,2829−31,1484
48,1939−31,1484×100 % = 30,1223
15. Perhitungan NRedh
Temperatur 40ᵒC
Nre Hot = ρ× Sc−1× Dh mu, h × Ah×60000 = 987,1×1,67138×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 643,62111
Temperatur 44ᵒC
Nre Hot = ρ× Sc−1× Dh mu, h × Ah×60000 = 987,1×1,6255×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 625,95648
Temperatur 48ᵒC
Nre Hot = ρ× Sc−1× Dh mu, h × Ah×60000 = 987,1×1,45252×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 559,34335
Temperatur 52ᵒC
Nre Hot = ρ× Sc−1× Dh mu, h × Ah×60000
= 987,1×1,22646×0,00387 0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 472,2889
16. Perhitungan NRedc
Temperatur 40ᵒC
Nre Cold = ρ × Sc−2× Dc mu, c × Ac ×60000 = 987,1×1,896×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 7301,1894
Temperatur 44ᵒC
Nre Cold = ρ × Sc−2× Dc mu, c × Ac ×60000 = 987,1×1,93453×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 7449,5736
Temperatur 48ᵒC
Nre Cold = ρ × Sc−2× Dc mu, c × Ac ×60000 = 987,1×1,93375×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 7446,5594
Temperatur 52ᵒC
Nre Cold = ρ× Sc−2× D c mu, c × A c ×60000 = 987,1×1,91648×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 7380,0743
B. Counter Current
1. Perhitungan Nilai ΔT1
Temperatur 40ᵒC ΔT1 = Th in - Tc in
= 39,2377 - 36,1913
= 3,04645
Temperatur 44ᵒC ΔT1 = Th in - Tc in
= 40,1438 – 37,2386
= 2,9052
Temperatur 48ᵒC ΔT1 = Th in - Tc in
= 43,354 – 39,3962
= 3,95778
Temperatur 52ᵒC ΔT1 = Th in - Tc in
= 47,4242 – 40,9596
= 6,46461 2. Perhitungan Nilai ΔT2
Temperatur 40ᵒC
ΔT2 = Th out - Tc out
= 33,9463 – 31,3204
= 2,62589
Temperatur 44ᵒC
ΔT2 = Th out - Tc out
= 34,4383 – 31,3584
= 3,07987
Temperatur 48ᵒC
ΔT2 = Th out - Tc out
= 35,4366 – 31,4456
= 3,99101
Temperatur 52ᵒC
ΔT2 = Th out - Tc out
= 35,2486 – 30,9262
= 4,32241
3. Perhitungan Nilai ΔT LMTD
Temperatur 40ᵒC ΔT LMTD =
ΔT2−ΔT1 ln
(
ΔTΔT21)
=
2,62589−3,04645 ln
(
2, 625893,04645)
= 2,8309656
Temperatur 44ᵒC ΔT LMTD =
ΔT2−ΔT1 ln
(
ΔTΔT21)
=
3,07987−2,9052 ln
(
3,079872,9052)
= 2,991685
Temperatur 48ᵒC ΔT LMTD =
ΔT2−ΔT1 ln
(
ΔTΔT21)
=
3,99101−3,95778 ln
(
3,991013,95778)
= 3,974374
Temperatur 52ᵒC ΔT LMTD =
ΔT2−ΔT1 ln
(
ΔTΔT21)
=
4,32241−6,46461 ln
(
4,322416,46461)
= 5,3218449 4. Perhitungan Nilai ΔTh
Temperatur 40ᵒC
ΔTh = Th out – Th in = 33,9463 – 39,2377 = 5,291423
Temperatur 44ᵒC
ΔTh = Th out – Th in = 34,4383 – 40,1438 = 5,705524
Temperatur 48ᵒC
ΔTh = Th out – Th in = 35,4366 – 43,354 = 7,917398
Temperatur 52ᵒC
ΔTh = Th out – Th in = 35,2486 – 47,4242 = 12,17555
5. Perhitungan Nilai ΔTc
Temperatur 40ᵒC
ΔTc = Tc out – Tc in = 31,3204 – 36,1913 = 4,870866
Temperatur 44ᵒC
ΔTc = Tc out – Tc in = 31,3584 – 37,2386 = 5,8802
Temperatur 48ᵒC
ΔTc = Tc out – Tc in = 31,4456 – 39,3962 = 7,950622
Temperatur 52ᵒC
ΔTc = Tc out – Tc in
= 30,9262 – 40,9596 = 10,03334
6. Perhitungan Nilai mH
Temperatur 40ᵒC
mH = ρ ×
(
1000SC1)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,707881000)
×(
601)
= 0,028094565
Temperatur 44ᵒC
mH = ρ ×
(
1000SC1)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,709341000)
×(
601)
= 0,028118614
Temperatur 48ᵒC
mH = ρ ×
(
1000SC1)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,707391000)
×(
601)
= 0,028086548
Temperatur 52ᵒC
mH = ρ ×
(
1000SC1)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,601391000)
×(
601)
= 0,026342924 7. Perhitungan Nilai mC
Temperatur 40ᵒC
mC = ρ ×
(
1000SC2)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,697141000)
×(
601)
= 0,027917877
Temperatur 44ᵒC
mC = ρ ×
(
1000SC2)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,655041000)
×(
601)
= 0,027225459
Temperatur 48ᵒC
mC = ρ ×
(
1000SC2)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,698781000)
×(
601)
= 0,02794488
Temperatur 52ᵒC
mC = ρ ×
(
1000SC2)
×(
601)
= 987,1 ×
(
1,76551000)
×(
601)
= 0,029042399 8. Perhitungan Nilai Qh
Temperatur 40ᵒC
Qh = ΔTh × mH × Cp
= 5,291423 × 0,028094565 × 4178 = 621,1024319
Temperatur 44ᵒC
Qh = ΔTh × mH × Cp
= 5,705524 × 0,028118614 × 4178 = 670,2824936
Temperatur 48ᵒC
Qh = ΔTh × mH × Cp
= 7,917398 × 0,028086548 × 4178 = 929,0717547
Temperatur 52ᵒC
Qh = ΔTh × mH × Cp
= 12,17555 × 0,026342924 × 4178 = 1340,049553
9. Perhitungan Nilai Qc
Temperatur 40ᵒC
Qc = ΔTc × mC × Cp
= 4,870866 × 0,027917877 × 4178 = 568,1421496
Temperatur 44ᵒC
Qc = ΔTc × mC × Cp
= 5,8802 × 0,027225459 × 4178 = 668,8608455
Temperatur 48ᵒC
Qc = ΔTc × mC × Cp
= 7,950622 × 0,02794488 × 4178 = 928,2646378
Temperatur 52ᵒC
Qc = ΔTc × mC × Cp
= 10,03334 × 0,029042399 × 4178 = 1217,436893
10. Perhitungan Nilai U
Temperatur 40ᵒC
U = Qh
(A × ΔT LMTD) = 621,1024319
(0,432×2,8309656) = 507,861
Temperatur 44ᵒC
U = Qh
(A × ΔT LMTD) = 670,2824936
(0,432×2,991685) = 518,6308
Temperatur 48ᵒC
U = Qh
(A × ΔT LMTD) = 929,0717547
(0,432×3,974374) = 541,124
Temperatur 52ᵒC
U = Qh
(A × ΔT LMTD) = 1340,049553
(0,432×5,3218449) = 582,8743
11. Perhitungan Nilai Cc
Temperatur 40ᵒC Cc = Cp × mC
= 4178 × 0,027917877 = 116,6408919
Temperatur 44ᵒC Cc = Cp × mC
= 4178 × 0,027225459 = 113,749691
Temperatur 48ᵒC Cc = Cp × mC
= 4178 × 0,02794488 = 116,7537102
Temperatur 52ᵒC
Cc = Cp × mC
= 4178 × 0,029042399 = 121,339145
12. Perhitungan Nilai Ch
Temperatur 40ᵒC Ch = Cp × mH
= 4178 × 0,028094565 = 117,37909
Temperatur 44ᵒC Ch = Cp × mH
= 4178 × 0,028118614 = 117,47957
Temperatur 48ᵒC Ch = Cp × mH
= 4178 × 0,028086548 = 117,3456
Temperatur 52ᵒC Ch = Cp × mH
= 4178 × 0,026342924 = 110,06074
13. Perhitungan Nilai NTU
Temperatur 40ᵒC NTU = U × A
Ccold
= 507,861×0,432 116,6408919 = 1,88095
Temperatur 44ᵒC NTU = U × A
Ccold
= 518,6308×0,432 113,7479691 = 1,96969
Temperatur 48ᵒC NTU = U × A
Ccold
= 541,124×0,432 116,7537102 = 2,00221
Temperatur 52ᵒC NTU = U × A
Ccold
= 582,8743×0,432 121,339145 = 2,07519
14. Perhitungan eff
Temperatur 40ᵒC
eff = Tcout−Tcin
Thin−Tcin ×100 % = 31,3204−36,1913
39,2377−36,1913×100 % = -159,887
Temperatur 44ᵒC
eff = Tcout−Tcin
Thin−Tcin ×100 % = 31,3584−37,2386
40,1438−37,2386×100 % = -202,403
Temperatur 48ᵒC
eff = Tcout−Tcin
Thin−Tcin ×100 % = 31,4456−39,3962
43,354−39,3962 ×100 % = -200,886
Temperatur 52ᵒC
eff = Tcout−Tcin
Thin−Tcin ×100 % = 30,9262−40,9596
47,4242−40,9596×100 % = -155,204
15. Perhitungan NRedh
Temperatur 40ᵒC
Nre Hot = ρ× Sc−1× Dh mu, h × Ah×60000 = 987,1×1,70788×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 657,67673
Temperatur 44ᵒC
Nre Hot = ρ× Sc−1× Dh mu, h × Ah×60000 = 987,1×1,70934×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 658,23969
Temperatur 48ᵒC
Nre Hot = ρ× Sc−1× Dh mu, h × Ah×60000 = 987,1×1,70739×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 657,48907
Temperatur 52ᵒC
Nre Hot = ρ× Sc−1× Dh mu, h × Ah×60000 = 987,1×1,60139×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 616,67188
16. Perhitungan NRedc
Temperatur 40ᵒC
Nre Cold = ρ × Sc−2× Dc mu, c × Ac ×60000 = 987,1×1,69714×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 6535,4058
Temperatur 44ᵒC
Nre Cold = ρ × Sc−2× Dc mu, c × Ac ×60000 = 987,1×1,65504×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 6373,3149
Temperatur 48ᵒC
Nre Cold = ρ × Sc−2× Dc mu, c × Ac ×60000 = 987,1×1,69878×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 6541,7271
Temperatur 52ᵒC
Nre Cold = ρ × Sc−2× Dc mu, c × Ac ×60000 = 987,1×1,7655×0,00387
0,000769×0,00021×60000 = 6798,6496